Agreement between CMB & State of Florida Department of Transportation uut..0 JIyII CIIvelupe IL/.L1,4/IJIJCV-r Uou-4/M4-D l'J(-:7UL//Jr CU IOlJ4
20 2Z-322,1 )
FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
PATTERN PAVEMENT CROSSWALKS, LANDSCAPING AND
MISCELLANEOUS PEDESTRIAN FEATURES
MAINTENANCE MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT
WITH THE
CITY OF MIAMI BEACH
This AGREEMENT, entered into on February 2 , 20 2024, by
and between the STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF
TRANSPORTATION, an agency of the State of Florida,
hereinafter called the DEPARTMENT, and the CITY OF MIAMI
BEACH, a municipal corporation of the State of Florida,
hereinafter called the CITY, and collectively referred to as
the PARTIES.
RECITALS:
A. The DEPARTMENT has jurisdiction over State Road (SR) 907
(Alton Road) at Lincoln Road, which is located within the
limits of the CITY; and
B. The CITY, pursuant to Permit Numbers 2020-A-691-00021 and
2021-L-691-00007, has drafted design plans for
improvements along SR-907 (Alton Road) at Lincoln Road,
the limits of which are further described Exhibit 'A'
attached hereto and made part hereof (PROJECT LIMITS) , have
been approved in accordance with the design plans
referenced in said Permit (PLANS) ; and
C. The CITY will install pattern pavement crosswalks,
landscaping and pedestrian features along SR-907, inside
the DEPARTMENT Right-of-Way, within the PROJECT LIMITS, in
accordance with Permit Numbers 2020-A-691-00021 and 2021-
L-691-00007 (the "Project") ; and
D. It is the intent of the PARTIES for this AGREEMENT to
supplement all existing Maintenance Memorandum of
Agreement and existing Permits previously executed between
the DEPARTMENT and the CITY; and
E. The PARTIES to this AGREEMENT mutually recognize the need
for entering into an agreement designating and setting
forth the CITY' s responsibilities with regards to the
Maintenance Memorandum of Agreement between Flonda Department of Transportation and City of Miami Beach(SR-907)
Page 1 of 13
uocu igri trivelope tu:Gk.4/1Al.t l.-rot3u-4/H4-Dl.J/-you/Jrtu Ibl.4
maintenance of the pattern pavement crosswalks,
landscaping and pedestrian features (the "IMPROVEMENTS")
within the PROJECT LIMITS; and
2022-32291 September 14, 2022
F. The CITY, by Resolution No. , dated
attached hereto as Exhibit `B' , which by reference shall
become a part of this AGREEMENT, desires to enter into this
AGREEMENT and authorizes its officers to do so.
NOW, THEREFORE, for and in consideration of the mutual
benefits contained herein and other good and valuable
consideration, the PARTIES covenant and agree as follows:
1. RECITALS
The recitals in this AGREEMENT are true and correct, and are
incorporated herein by reference and made a part hereof.
2. DEPARTMENT RESPONSIBILITIES
The PARTIES agree that the execution of this AGREEMENT shall
constitute an assignment of all maintenance responsibilities
pertaining to the IMPROVEMENTS within the PROJECT LIMITS to
the CITY upon the DEPARTMENT' s acceptance of the CITY' s work.
3. CITY' S MAINTENANCE RESPONSIBILITIES
So long as the IMPROVEMENTS remain in place, the CITY shall
be responsible for the maintenance of the same. The CITY
shall maintain the IMPROVEMENTS in accordance with all
applicable DEPARTMENT guidelines, standards, and procedures,
which shall include but shall not be limited to the
Maintenance Rating Program Handbook, as may be amended from
time to time. Additionally, with respect to the landscape,
the CITY shall maintain same in accordance with the
International Society of Arboriculture standards, guidelines
and procedures, the latest edition of the "Maintenance Rating
Program", and Index 546 of the latest DEPARTMENT Design
Standards, as may be amended from time to time. The CITY
shall further maintain the IMPROVEMENTS in accordance with
the standards set forth in the Project Plans, and in the
Project Specifications and Special Provisions . The CITY' s
maintenance obligations shall include but not be limited to:
Maintenance Memorandum of Agreement between Florida Department of Transportation and City of Miami Beach(SR-907)
Page 2 of 13
UUI:UJIIyII CI I11tl1Upe IU.L1,,4/VI,CI.r-r"V DV-+,#%$D\JO!-UVU I or"CU 1 OL'41
So long as the IMPROVEMENTS remain in place, the CITY shall
be responsible for the maintenance of the same, at CITY' s
sole cost and expense. The CITY shall maintain the pattern
pavement crosswalks, landscaping and pedestrian features in
accordance with all applicable DEPARTMENT guidelines,
standards, and procedures, which shall include but shall not
be limited to the Maintenance Rating Program Handbook, as
may be amended from time to time . Additionally, the CITY
shall maintain the landscape in accordance with the
International Society of Arboriculture standards, guidelines
and procedures, the latest edition of the "Maintenance Rating
Program", and Index 546 of the latest DEPARTMENT Design
Standards as may be amended from time to time. The CITY
shall further maintain the landscape, turf and hardscape in
accordance with the standards set forth in the Project Plans,
and in the Project Specifications and Special Provisions .
The CITY/ s maintenance obligations for all proposed
landscape, turf, pedestrian features, and pattern pavement
crosswalks shall include but not be limited to:
3 . 1 General Requirements :
a. Removing and disposing of litter from PROJECT LIMITS in
accordance with all applicable government rules,
regulations, policies, procedures, guidelines, and
manuals, as amended from time to time.
b. Maintain all gravity walls, pedestrian steps, risers,
handrails, bus shelters, and all elements associated
with the aforementioned features.
c. Removing and disposing of all trimmings, roots,
branches, litter, and any other debris resulting from
the activities described by 3 . 1 through 3.2 .
d. Maintaining a service log of all maintenance operations
that sets forth the date of the maintenance activity,
the location that was maintained, and the work that was
performed.
e. Submitting Lane Closure Requests to the DEPARTMENT when
maintenance activities will require the closure of a
traffic lane in the DEPARTMENT' s right-of-way. Lane
closure requests shall be submitted through the District
Six Lane Closure Information System, to the DEPARTMENT's
Maintenance Memorandum of Agreement between Flonda Department of Transportation and City of Miami Beach(SR-907)
Page 3 of 13
uouuJlgn envelope -`,ouI 3rCu IOU4
area Permit Manager and in accordance with the District
Six Lane Closure Policy, as may be amended from time to
time .
3.2 Pattern Pavement:
a. Within sixty (60) days of project acceptance by the
DEPARTMENT, all lanes of each patterned crosswalk shall
be evaluated for surface friction. The friction test
shall be conducted using either a locked wheel tester
in accordance with FM 5-592 (Florida Test Method for
Friction Measuring Protocol for Patterned Pavements) or
a Dynamic Friction Tester in accordance with ASTM E1911 .
FM5-592 can be accessed at the following link:
http:, materials.dot.state.fl.us;smoadministration'resources,library;publications:f
stm;Methodsi'fm5-592.pdf
b. The initial friction resistance shall be at least 35
obtained at 40 mph with a ribbed tire test (FN4OR) or
equivalent. Failure to achieve this minimum resistance
shall require all deficient crosswalk areas to be
removed to their full extent (lane-by-lane) and replaced
with the same product installed initially. If the
DEPARTMENT determines that more than 50% of the lanes
in the intersection require replacement, the entire
intersection installation may be reconstructed with a
different product on the Qualified Products List (QPL)
or replaced with conventional pavement.
c. Approximately one (1) year after project acceptance and
every two (2) years thereafter and for the life of the
adjacent pavement, only the outside traffic lane areas
of each patterned crosswalk shall be tested for friction
resistance in accordance with ASTM E274 or ASTM E1911 .
Friction resistance shall, at a minimum, have a FN4OR
value of 35 (or equivalent) .
d. The results of all friction tests shall be sent to the
District' s Warranty Coordinator with a cover letter
either certifying that the crosswalks comply with the
minimum friction criteria, or stating what remedial
action will be taken to restore the friction.
e. Failure to achieve the minimum resistance shall require
Maintenance Memorandum of Agreement between Florida Department of Transportation and City of Miami Beach(SR-907)
Page 4 of 13
LJUI.UJIy.I I CI IVe1Uale U .4,-01./ ,,.l..Cl.-r I.)DU f/HY-O 6.J/-JUV/Jr CLJ IOI.Y
all lanes of the crosswalk to be friction tested to
determine the extent of the deficiency. All deficient
areas shall be removed to their full extent (lane-by-
lane) and replaced with the same product installed
initially. If the DEPARTMENT determines that more than
50% of the lanes in the intersection require
replacement, the entire intersection installation may
be reconstructed with a different product on the QPL or
replaced with conventional pavement .
f. When remedial action is required in accordance with the
above requirements, the CITY shall complete all
necessary repairs at its own expense within ninety (90)
days of the date when the deficiency was identified. No
more than two (2) full depth patterned pavement repairs
shall be made to an area without first resurfacing the
underlying pavement to 1" minimum depth.
g. The DEPARTMENT will not be responsible for replacing
the treatment following any construction activities in
the vicinity of the treatment .
h. Should the CITY fail to satisfactorily perform any
required remedial work in accordance with this
AGREEMENT, the DEPARTMENT reserves the right to replace
the patterned pavement with conventional pavement
(matching the adjacent pavement) and bill the CITY for
this cost .
Maintaining a service log of all maintenance operations that
sets forth the date of the maintenance activity, the location
that was maintained, and the work that was performed.
The DEPARTMENT may, at its sole discretion, perform periodic
inspection of the IMPROVEMENTS to ensure that the CITY is
performing its duties pursuant to this AGREEMENT. The
Department shall share with the CITY its inspection findings,
and may use those findings as the basis of its decisions
regarding maintenance deficiencies, as set forth in Section
4 of this AGREEMENT. The CITY is responsible for obtaining
copies of all applicable rules, regulations, policies,
procedures, guidelines, and manuals, and the Project
Specification and Special Provisions, as may be amended from
time to time.
Maintenance Memorandum of Agreement between Florida Department of Transportation and City of Miami Beach(SR-907)
Page 5 of 13
L/UL.u. IyII LiIVeiUpe ILJ. UOU-Y /-.7UIJ/Jr CI-,IOI+Y
4 . MAINTENANCE DEFICIENCIES
If at any time it shall come to the attention of the
DEPARTMENT that the CITY' s responsibilities as established
herein are not being properly accomplished pursuant to the
terms of this AGREEMENT, the DEPARTMENT may, at its option,
issue a written notice, in care of the CITY MANAGER, to notify
the CITY of the maintenance deficiencies . From the date of
receipt of the notice, the CITY shall have a period of thirty
(30) calendar days, within which to correct the cited
deficiency or deficiencies . Receipt is determined in
accordance with Section 5 of this AGREEMENT .
If said deficiencies are not corrected within this time
period, the DEPARTMENT may, at its option, proceed as follows :
a. Maintain the IMPROVEMENTS, or a part thereof, and
invoice the CITY for expenses incurred; or
b. Terminate this AGREEMENT in accordance with Section 7,
remove any or all IMPROVEMENTS located within the
PROJECT LIMITS, and charge the CITY the reasonable cost
of such removal .
5. NOTICES
All notices, requests, demands, consents, approvals, and
other communication which are required to be served or given
hereunder, shall be in writing and shall be sent by certified
U.S. mail, return receipt requested, postage prepaid,
addressed to the party to receive such notices as follows :
To the DEPARTMENT: Florida Department of Transportation
1000 Northwest 111 Avenue, Room 6205
Miami, Florida 33172-5800
Attn: District Maintenance Engineer
To the CITY: City of Miami Beach
1700 Convention Drive
Miami Beach, Florida 33139
Attention: City Manager
Notices shall be deemed to have been received by the end of
five (5) business days from the proper sending thereof unless
proof of prior actual receipt is provided.
Maintenance Memorandum of Agreement between Florida Department of Transportation and City of Miami Beach(SR-907)
Page 6 of 13
UULUJIIyII CI IVCIUpe ILJ.LL.'fI li C.l.-r000-4,M4-Ol.J/-UOLJIorcu 101+4
6. REMOVAL, RELOCATION OR ADJUSTMENT OF THE IMPROVEMENTS
a . The PARTIES agree that the IMPROVEMENTS addressed by
this AGREEMENT may be removed, relocated or adjusted at
any time in the future, at the DEPARTMENT' s sole
discretion. The DEPARTMENT shall notify the CITY as soon
as practicable of any such removal, relocation or
adjustment of the IMPROVEMENTS. This notification is not
subject to the notice provisions of Paragraph 5 of this
AGREEMENT. In the event that the DEPARTMENT relocates or
adjusts the IMPROVEMENTS, the CITY' s maintenance
responsibilities will survive the relocation or
adjustment, as long as the materials remain within the
Project Limits.
7 . TERMINATION
This AGREEMENT is subject to termination under any one of the
following conditions:
a. By the DEPARTMENT, if the CITY fails to perform its
duties under Section 3 of this AGREEMENT, following the
thirty (30) days written notice, as specified in Section
4 of this AGREEMENT.
b. In accordance with Section 287 . 058 (1) (c) , Florida
Statutes, the DEPARTMENT shall reserve the right to
unilaterally cancel this AGREEMENT if the CITY refuses
to allow public access to any or all documents, papers,
letters, or other materials made or received by the CITY
pertinent to this AGREEMENT which are subject to
provisions of Chapter 119, of the Florida Statutes .
c. If mutually agreed to by both parties, upon thirty (30)
days advance notice. An agreement to terminate shall be
valid only if made in writing and executed with the same
formalities as this AGREEMENT.
8. TERMS
a. The effective date of this AGREEMENT shall commence upon
execution by the PARTIES and shall continue so long as
the IMPROVEMENTS remain in place until termination as
set forth in Section 7 .
Maintenance Memorandum of Agreement between Florida Department of Transportation and City of Miami Beach(SR-907)
Page 7 of 13
uocuign tnveiope lu:Ll.4r t -rut u-wr/- -t3l,J!-jOU r or Cu IoI,K
b. This writing embodies the entire AGREEMENT and
understanding between the PARTIES hereto and there are
no other agreements and understanding, oral or written,
with reference to the subject matter hereof that are not
merged herein and superseded hereby.
c. This AGREEMENT shall not be transferred or assigned, in
whole or in part, without the prior written consent of
the DEPARTMENT.
d. This AGREEMENT shall be governed by and constructed in
accordance with the laws of the State of Florida. Any
provisions of this AGREEMENT found to be unlawful or
unenforceable shall be severable and shall not affect
the validity of the remaining portions of the AGREEMENT.
e. Venue for any and all actions arising out of or in
connection to the interpretation, validity, performance
or breach of this AGREEMENT shall lie exclusively in a
state court of proper jurisdiction in Leon County,
Florida.
f. A modification or waiver of any of the provisions of
this AGREEMENT shall be effective only if made in writing
and executed with the same formality as this AGREEMENT.
i . The section headings contained in this AGREEMENT are for
reference purposes only and shall not affect the meaning
or interpretation hereof.
j . No term or provision of this AGREEMENT shall be
interpreted for or against either Party because the
Party or its legal representative drafted the provision.
k. The DEPARTMENT is a state agency, self-insured and
subject to the provisions of Section 768 .28, Florida
Statutes, as may be amended from time to time . Nothing
in this AGREEMENT shall be deemed or otherwise
interpreted as waiving the DEPARTMENT' s sovereign
immunity protections, or as increasing the limits of
liability as set forth in Section 768 . 28, Florida
Statutes .
1 . The CITY is a municipal corporation, self-insured and
subject to the provisions of Section 768 .28, Florida
Statutes, as may be amended from time to time . Nothing
Maintenance Memorandum of Agreement between Flonda Department of Transportation and City of Miami Beach(SR-907)
Page 8 oft 3
LJUL:U0ILy1 I CI IVCIUpe IV. L.LJCL.-1-UDU-4/ -UULJ/JI'GLJ I
in this AGREEMENT shall be deemed or otherwise
interpreted as waiving the CITY' s sovereign immunity
protections, or as increasing the limits of liability as
set forth in Section 768 .28, Florida Statutes .
9. INDEMNIFICATION
Subject to Section 768 .28, Florida Statutes, as may be
amended from time to time, the CITY shall :
(a) promptly indemnify, defend, save and hold harmless the
DEPARTMENT, its officers, agents, representatives and
employees from any and all losses, expenses, fines, fees,
taxes, assessments, penalties, reasonable costs, damages,
judgments, claims, demands, liabilities, reasonable
attorneys fees, (including regulatory and appellate fees) ,
and suits of any nature or kind whatsoever caused
by, arising out of, or related to the CITY' s negligent
exercise or of its responsibilities as set out in this
AGREEMENT, including but not limited to, any negligent act,
negligent action, negligence or omission by the CITY, its
officers, agents, employees or representatives in the
performance of this AGREEMENT, whether direct or indirect,
except that neither the CITY nor any of its officers, agents,
employees or representatives will be liable under this
provision for damages arising out of injury or damages caused
or resulting from the negligence of the DEPARTMENT; and
(b) pay all reasonable costs and fees related to this
obligation and its enforcement by the DEPARTMENT.
The CITY' s obligation to indemnify, defend and pay for the
defense of the DEPARTMENT, or at the DEPARTMENT' s option, to
participate and associate with the DEPARTMENT in the defense
and trial of any claim and any related settlement
negotiations, shall be triggered immediately upon the CITY' s
receipt of the DEPARTMENT' s notice of claim for
indemnification. The notice of claim for indemnification
shall be deemed received if the DEPARTMENT sends the notice
in accordance with the formal notice mailing requirements
set forth in Section 5 of this AGREEMENT. The DEPARTMENT' s
failure to notify the CITY of a claim shall not release the
CITY of the above duty to defend and indemnify the
DEPARTMENT.
Maintenance Memorandum of Agreement beoveen Florida Department of Transportation and City of Miami Beach(SR-907)
Page 9 of 13
uoeii igri Ctiveiope tu.L1.4/t..l.tl.-rubu-4/H4-[S1.3/-y0u/3rCu I
The CITY' s evaluation of liability or its inability to
evaluate liability shall not excuse the CITY' s duty to defend
and indemnify the DEPARTMENT under the provisions of this
section. Only an adjudication or judgment, after the highest
appeal is exhausted, specifically finding the DEPARTMENT was
negligent shall excuse performance of this provision by the
CITY.
The indemnification provisions of this section shall survive
termination or expiration of this AGREEMENT, but only with
respect to those claims that arose from acts or circumstances
which occurred prior to termination or expiration of this
AGREEMENT.
Maintenance Memorandum of Agreement between Florida Department of Transportation and City of Miami Beach(SR-907)
Page 10 of 13
VUI:UJny1 I CI IV CIUt1C IU.G1.J4/I,rVGV-rUDU-4/MY-DI,J/-iUU/Jrcu 10%.4
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the PARTIES hereto have caused these
presents to be executed the day and year first above written.
CITY OF MIAMI BEACH: STATE OF FLORIDA
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION:
BY: BY:
Manager or Mayor District Director of
Transportation Operations
DocuSigned by:
t. � 2r22024 1 10:57 AM EST
ATTEST: ErtlftAtt
FABBBAOBFB5E4CF... (SEAL) ATTEST:
City Clerk Executive Secretary
LEGAL REVIEW:
BY BY:
For City Attorney 03/12/2023 District Chief Counsel
Maintenance Memorandum of Agreement between Florida Department of Transportation and City of Miami Beach(SR-907)
Page 11 of 13
uocuign I riveuope IU:LL4/1.1..cu-rUDU-4/H4-C3.3/- OU/3t'CU IOl..4
EXHIBIT 'A'
PROJECT LIMITS
Below are the limits of the pattern pavement crosswalks,
landscaping and pedestrian features to be maintained under this
AGREEMENT.
State Road Number: 907 (Alton Road)
Agreement Limits: At Lincoln Road
County: Miami-Dade
Maintenance Memorandum of Agreement between Florida Department of Transportation and City of Miami Beach(SR-907)
Page 12 of 13
VUI,,uol ll I I IVCIUpe -OUV I Jr CV I0V4
EXHIBIT 'B'
CITY OF MIAMI BEACH RESOLUTION
To be herein incorporated once adopted by the CITY Board of
Commissioners .
Maintenance Memorandum of Agreement between Florida Department of Transportation and City of Miami Beach(SR-907)
Paee 13 of 13
LAJUuoIyi CI IVCIIJ t IL).LI,Y/L,L ,-r UDV-VIHY-DL,JI LJ/JrI LJ IOI,N
RESOLUTION NO. 2022-32291
A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, APPROVING AND AUTHORIZING THE CITY
MANAGER AND CITY CLERK TO EXECUTE A MAINTENANCE MEMORANDUM
OF AGREEMENT (MMOA), BETWEEN THE CITY AND THE FLORIDA
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION(FDOT),ASSIGNING TO THE CITY THE
FULL MAINTENANCE RESPONSIBILITIES FOR CERTAIN LANDSCAPING AND
ARCHITECTURAL FEATURES AND IMPROVEMENTS ALONG A PORTION OF
STATE ROAD(SR)907(ALTON ROAD)AT LINCOLN ROAD, IN CONNECTION
WITH THE REDEVELOPMENT OF THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1628-1634
ALTON ROAD.
WHEREAS, OSIB MIAMI BEACH PROPERTIES, LLC, (the "Owner") owns the property
located at 1628-1634 Alton Road, as identified by Miami-Dade County Folio Nos. 02-3234-018-
0170 and 02-3234-018-0180 (the "Property"); and
WHEREAS,the Owner has obtained certain approvals from the City in connection with the
redevelopment of the Property; and
WHEREAS, SR 907, also known as"Alton Road," is a roadway maintained by the state of
Florida, pursuant to the Florida Statutes and through the authority of the FDOT; and
WHEREAS, the City, under permit 2020-L-691-00010, requested that the Owner install
certain landscaping and architectural features and improvements (the "Improvements") on the
Property and along a portion of Alton Road at Lincoln Road in accordance with the Hardscape Plan,
Planting Plan, Plant List and Specifications, Irrigation Plan, Irrigation Specifications, and Lighting
Plan (collectively, the "Site Plans"); and
WHEREAS, in addition to adherence to the installation of the Improvements in accordance
with the approved Site Plans,the City will require the Owner to execute a Declaration of Restrictive
Covenants(the"Declaration")concerning the Improvements which Restrictive Covenants include
provisions delineating Owner's responsibility to adequately maintain the Improvements as required
by the development approvals and as required by the FDOT, at no cost to the City; and
WHEREAS, the Owner has applied to the City for permission to install the Improvements
within the ROW,which extend into the FDOT's jurisdiction along a portion of Alton Road at Lincoln
Road; and
WHEREAS,as a condition to approving the issuance of the required permits for the project,
the FDOT is requiring that the City execute a Maintenance Memorandum of Agreement(MMOA),
pursuant to which the City assumes responsibility for the maintenance of such portions of the
Improvements as are located on Alton Road (the MMOA is attached to the Memorandum
accompanying this Resolution); and
WHEREAS, pursuant to the Declaration, the City will transfer to Owner all maintenance
obligations imposed upon the City under the MMOA; and
uocu ign tnveiope lu:Lug/l.t.tu-rubu-4/H4-Cl.J,-yOu/Jrtu Ibl..4
WHEREAS, the Improvements will enhance the aesthetic appeal of the intersection of Alton
Road and Lincoln Road.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT DULY RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY
COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA that the Mayor and City
Commission hereby approve and authorize The City Manager and City Clerk to execute a
Maintenance Memorandum of Agreement (MMOA), between the City and the Florida
Department of Transportation (FDOT), assigning to the City the full maintenance
responsibilities for the landscaping and architectural feature and improvements within a
portion of State Road (SR) 907 (Alton Road) at Lincoln Road, in connection with the
redevelopment of the property located at 1628 -1634 Alton Road, provided that the City
transfers all responsibilities to the owner of such property pursuant to a Declaration of
Restrictive Covenants.
PASSED and ADOPTED THIS iy day of CPp '4°0022
SEP 2 1, A
ATTES 7
IVOR? HATED! 11
ITY C ERK c ."~`�' MAYOR
SEP 2 1 2022
APPROVED AS TO
FORM& LANGUAGE
&FOR EXECUTION
lid 4/e 2oz2
% - City Attorney Dote