Memo 012-2012 Follow-up Information re DROP MIAMI BEAC
OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER 2012 JUL 17 AM g: 20
C, I Rt.lyr ...F n;`
MEMORANDUM
012 -2012
To: Mayor Matti Herrera Bower and Members of the City Commission
FROM: Kathie G. Brooks, Interim City Manager
DATE: July 16, 2012
SUBJECT: Follow -up Information. Regarding of Miami Beach Employees Currently
Participating in the Deferred Retirement Option Plan (DROP)
This Memorandum is in response to a request made by Commissioner Libbin for a list of all
employees participating in the Deferred Retirement Option Plan (DROP) including the DROP
participants' annual earnings, DROP payment, and. the City's monthly cost of medical and
dental benefit plans. This is a follow -up to a Memorandum sent on June 20, 2012 (Attached).
As, requested, this additional information includes:
•.,, The employee's current annual earnings, including their base salary, overtime and any
premiums they may be eligible for based on their position and /or union agreement.
The payroll periods used were July 1, 2011 through June 30, 2012.
• The monthly medical and dental premium cost to the City based on the each
employee's current enrollment, the plan's current premium and the City's premium
subsidy.
• The monthly DROP payment received by each employee. This DROP payment
represents the employee's full pension payment which is based on their Final Average
Monthly Earnings (FAME), years of creditable service and their classification and tier.
This detailed information is found in the following attachments:
• Attachment A — DROP Participants.in the Miami Beach Employees' Retirement Plan
(MBERP).
• Attachment B - DROP Participants in the Fraternal Order of Police (FOP).
• Attachment C — DROP Participants in the International Association of Fire Fighters
(IAFF).
Should you have any questions or need additional information, please feel free to contact me.
KGB /ri
Attachment A
General Employees
Drop Participants as of 07/01/2012
d� nnwal s nl
�M Earnings 6�� p �
Name D End Date 07/ ,�f;
�� p� 01 Monthl�y�Gty Monthly" City.
( Dental, � "Month I D
ro
p
u ����2µt a �F�a�. °06/302012' Premium , aPremiu.i??� Payment
�..,.
1 SALAZAR, LUISA 08/30/2012 $52,194.74 $679.60 $10.80 $3,164.43
2 ORTIZ, LUIS 08/31/2012 $60,473.14 $381.74 $0.00 - $3,001.50
3 BONDE, KENT 09/30/2012 $134,730.96 $783.90 $18.78 $8,452.35 .
4 BUCACCI, ANTONIA 09/30/2012 $86,478.55 $329.84 $18.78 $6,661.26
5 DE LAS SALAS, ANGEL 09/30/2012 $75,874.57 $329.84 $18.78 $4,847.36
6 FARIAS, PEDRO 09/30/2012 $70,430.93 $0.00 $0.00 $3,659:79.
7 GARCIA, MERCEDES 09/30/2012 $56,602.74 $679.60 $55.48 $4,121.13
8 GOMEZ, JORGE 09/30/2012 $212,356.56 _ $1,306.64 $55.48 $11,245.70
9 HOBBS JR, NELSON 09/30/2012 $73,183.42 $329.84 $6.18. $5,562.86
10 MENDEZ, ALFREDO 09/30/2012 $59,060.02 $946.40 $0.00 $2,007.33
11 ROVIROSA, MERCEDES 09/30/2012 $57,987.14 $329.84 $18.78 $2,967.51
12 SABALLOS, SHARON 09/30/2012 $61,895.18 $679.60 $55.48 $3,926.04
13 SCHWAB, LINDA 10/31/2012 $51,025.34 $640.72 $18.78 $2,362.44
14 LAMAZARES, MERCEDES 12/31/2012 $110,913.68 $640.72 $18.78 $5,717.50
15 LABOY, JOSE 01/31/2013 $66,173.11 $381.74 $6.18 $2,113.90
16 MAYORGA, CESAR 01/31/2012 $57,285.24 $0.00 $0.00 $4,104.14
17 SUAREZ, ROBERTO 02/01/2013 $59,221.14 $0.00 $0.00 $4,092.28
18 AZZINARO, WILLIAM 02/28/2013 $115,926.08 $946.40 "$10.80 $7,256:83 '
19 REGOJO, JORGE 04/30/2013 $58,965.24 $329.84 $55.48 $1,059.53 °
20 RIVERO, MARIA 04/30/2013 $67,836.80 $329.84 $618.00 $4,955.58
21 FRANCISCO, LUIS 05/31/2013 $49,369.21 $0.00 $0.00 $1,940.86
22 LAMONS, LEE 05/31/2013 $74,963.91 $329.84 $18.78 $4,442.34
23 STEVENS, VICTORIA 05/31/2013 $62,718.70 $381.74 $18.78 $4,743.64
24 LIBURD, DENIS 06/30/2013 $71,759.44 $946.40 $16.98 $4,146.96
25 GIBSON, ELIZABETH 07/31/2013 $51,325.34 $329.84 $36.18 $3,805.02
26 MCKINNON, RICHARD 08/31/2013 $87,785.88 $946.40 ' $55.48 $6,243.34
27 MOORE, S L 09/30/2013 $114,587.98 $679.60 $16.98 $4;036.29
28 SMITH, KEVIN 09/30/2013 $185,547.06 $679.60 $55.48 $7,040.25
29 LAMPROU, ATANACIOS 12/31/2013 $40,709.93 $381.74 $10.80 $1,336.98
30 ALVAREZ, MICHAEL 03/31/2014 $144,377.46 $679.60 $36.18. $6,222.73
31 GARRETT, MERCEDES 03/31/2014 $48,032.78 $946.40 $10.80 $1,917.13
32 ANTONA, GIANCARLO 04/30/2014 $114,107.22 $0.00 $0.00 $4,306.591
33 LEWIS, DARLENE 04/30/2014 $39,495.18 $329.84 $0.00 $2,527.87
34 JORGE, RAUL 05/31/2014 $69,568.14 $670.72 $18.78 $4,257.87
35 PETERS, HARRY 05/31/2014 $53,214.65 $0.00 $36.18 $1,162.23
36 HERNANDEZ, CANDIDA 07/31/2014 $66,544.58 $329.84 $6.18 $2,498.23
37 TELLEZ, ELENA 07/31/2014 $60,606.44 $640.72 $18.78 $4,487.34
38 MARTINEZ, VICTOR 07/31/2014 $44,456.88 $329.84 $55.48 $1,325.43
39 RUSH, HARRY 08/31/2014 $48,477.22 $381.74 $18.78' $1,944.79
Attachment A
General Employees
Drop Participants as of 07/01/2012
OF E Annual ��
nfk
'' r Narne Drop Ends Date 07 /01 /2011,�Monthly City'Mon
thly City'"
through�� "' =Medical �� Dental�W Nlonthl` Dio
3 �p y p
"�r 0 2012 mium,.Premiun Payment`
. .� 063 Pre ».
a, .nw
40 GRAHAM, EDWARD 08 /31/2014 $66,449.57 $329.94 $0.00 $2,414.24
41 BLACKSHEAR, ROBERT 08/31/2014 $69,965.64 $0.00 $0.00 $4,846.14
42 LOCKE, CELIA 09/30/2014 $128,950.79 $763.90 $18.78 $6,482.97
43. BERNSTEIN, LYNN 09/30%2014 $133,326.98 $640.72 $36.18 $4,818.21
44 LEGGETT, JAMES 10/31/2014 $96,696.60 $329.84 $6.18 $3,378.32
45 GREEN, WAREN 10/31/2014 $77,167.11 $679.60 $55.48 $5,338.60
46 STANIONS, MARC 11/30/2014 $81,191.52 $329.84 $0.00 $6,168.73
.47 FRANCIS, LEONARDO 11/30/2014 $88,701.27 $329.84 $6.18 $6,969.97
48 HIRSH, KATIA 12/31/2014 $83,462.88 $1,306.64 $55.48 $3,189.16
49 OLDENBURG, JOHN 12/31/2014 $171,727.50 $679.60 $55.48 $9,551.25
50 MARTINEZ, ROBERT 12/31/2014 $99,778.56 $329.84 $18.78 $6,458.16
51 CARY, WILLAIM 02/28/2015 $134,730.93 $783.90 $18.78 $6,272.30
52 EMERSON SMITH, LEE 03/31/2015 $84,644.80 $679.60 $16.98 $6,546.89
53 ADAMS, CHARLES 04/30/215 $141,770.24 $783.90 $18.78 $4,984.66
54 BECKMANN, FRED 04/30/215 $274,277.99 $0.00 $36.18 $4,983.06
55 ELLIS, CHARLES 05/31/2015 $77,617.95 $329.84 $6.18 $4,984.66
56 PITTMAN, ALPHONSO 05/31/2015 $82,559.87 $0.00 $16.98 $6,475.07
Attachment B
FOP
Drop Participants as of 07/01/2012
, :I &g Annuat
"� �,� � 'i � , � � �ah P aa^
Earnings u k'
Name; .. Drop;,EndDate 07/01J2011 Month"Iy�City Monthly City
�Mz
throu h� Medical "� °Dental Monthl Dro
30/2012:. Premium' , ^Premium ti 40yment
1 CARDELLE, THAMYRIS 08/31/2012 $95,602.58 $1,210.14 $55.48 $3,689.07
2 METZGAR, JESS 08/31/2012 $123,242.43 $1,210.14 $55.48 $6
3 RUDER, BERNIE 08/31/2012 $187,437.20 $1,210.14 $55.48 $7,019.52
4 ZACARIAS, ELISEO 08/31/2012 $114,034.95 $1,210.14 $10.80 $7,626.23
5 NAVARRO, GEORGE 12/31/2012 $174,295.67 $1,210.14 $36.18 $11,093.03
6 YERO, EDUARDO 02/28/2013 $175,429.55 $1,210.14 $10.80 $11,370.44
7 DOYLE, PAUL 04/30/2013 $141,492.49 $0.00 $0.00 $7,226.98 -
8 MAURO, JAMES 04/30/2012 $87,499.76 $1,210.14 $16.98 $7,103.40
9 BUTCH, JAMES 06/30/2013 $114,046.31 $456.95 $18.78 $6,186.03
10 QUINLAN, PATRICK 06/30/2013 $97,295.42 $456.95 $18.78 $7,248.23
11 RODRIGUEZ, PEDRO 08/31/2013 $145,128.78 $1,210.14 $10.80 $7,764.66
12 MARTINEZ, DOLORES 09/30/2013 $88,938.11 $456.95 $18.78 $6,671.60
13 ORTEGA, FLEIX 10/31/2013 $171,005.47 $1,210.14 $0.00 $10,329.87
14 RIVERA, JUAN 10/31/2013 $92,235.94 $456.95 $10.80 $6,633.21"
15 SHIMKO, RONALD 11/30/2013 $111,174.76 $456.95 $18.78 $6,332.27
16 SMITH, RANDOLPH 11/30/2013 $97,832.44 $0.00 $0.00 $6,051.57
17 SILVAGNI, ROBERT 05/31/2014 $133,897.77 $1,210.14 $55.48 $7,484.19
18 BENNETT, HOWARD 08/31/2014 $127,792.72 $1,210.14 $55.48 $7,380.57
19 MATfHEWS, KENNY 09/30/2014 $128,320.53 - $1,210.14 $16.98 $6,943.28
20 JOHNSON, BRUCE 09/30/2014 $136,914.14 $1,210.14 $55.48 $10,453.33
21 SAN ROMAN, VICENTE 09/30/2014 $156,535.21 $1,210.14 $36.18 $7,871.73
22 HAN, LORENZO 09/30/2014 $113,922.37 $1,210.14 $55.48 $8,028.82
23 YERO 1R, JULIO 11/30/2014 $134,709.35 $1,210.14 $55.48 $10,881.82.
24 KLUGER, GARY 12/31/2014 $129,578.85 $1,210.14 $55.48 $8,419.02
25' BAMBIS, JOHN 01/31/2015 $181,858.13 $1,210.14 $55.48 $10,760.08
26 ELMORE, ROBERT 01/31/2015 $133,373.48 $456.95 $18.78 $9,174.87
27 CHAPMAN, RONALD 02/28/2015 $161,257.33 $1,210.14 $55.78 $10,266.21
28 ROJO, MARIO 05/31/2015 $156,471.09 $1,210.14 $55.78 $8,585.98
Attachment C
IAFF
Drop Participants as of 07/01/2012
Ann_ uaI zli w r r
a NIB Y b
, Earnings
��� Drop EndDate ~ 07/01/201y1�� Montbly�City�
- 1 PRATTJR, ALBERT 06/30/2012 $119,818:30 $1,139.95 $48.46 $9,053.74
2 STEWARD, KEVIN 06/30/2012 $121,341.70 $0.00 $0:00 $9,261.00
- 3 GORDON, LONNIE 07/31/2012 $166,117.03 $1,139.95 °$48.46 $12,856.11
4 BOUCHARD, DONALD 08/31/2012 $150,908.47. $1,139.95 $48.46 $11,220.17
5 CARTER, PAUL 08/31/2012 $102,089:60 $1,139.95 $48.46 $7,334:09
6 HOFMANN, STEPHAN 08/31/2012 $136,809.06 $1,139.95 $48.46 $10,893.59
7 LUBINSKY, DANIEL 08/31/2012 $109,055.74 $1,139.95 $48.46 $8,025.64
8 MORRISON, ROBERT 08/31/2012 $132,983.41
$464.48 $16.39 $8,733:25
9 MULLINS, MICHAEL 08/31/2012 $93,264.41 $1,139.95 $48.46 $6,634.36
10 NOEL, DAVID 08/31/2012 $169,683.61 $1,139.95 $48.46 $12,230.40
11 PHILLIPS, STEVEN 08/31/2012 $155,671.05 $464.48 $16.39 $10,846.12
12 BARBERA, MARK 01/31/2013 $139,456.78 $464.48 $16.39 $11,763.42 .
13 GOLTZENE, TIMOTHY 01/31/2013 $137,999.72 $464.48 $16.39 $11,542.26
14 HOWARD, WILLIAM 01/13/2013 $166,071.27 $1,139.95 $48.46 $12,326.68
..15 WHITE, BRADFORD 01/31/2013 $127,893.89 $464.48 $16.39 $9,380.76
16 FREAR, CHARLES 03/31/2013 $98,804.79 $1,139.95 $48.46 $7,258.32
17 AMATO, LEE 04/01/2013 $169,578.35 $1,139.95 $48.46 $9,959.22
18 BERKSTRESSER, KEITH 06/30/2013 $128,493.25 $1,139:95 $48.46 $8;113.99
19 COURTRIGHT, WAYNE 06/30/2013 $117,263.16 $1,139.95 $48.46 $8,473.82
20 COURTRIGHT, RONALD 09/30/2013 $132,641.32 $1,139.95 $48.46 $8,126.14
21 CREEL, JOHNATHAN 09/30/2013 $104,918.05 $1,139.95 $48.46 $7,958.46
22 DAVISON, CARLETON 01/31/2014 $158,622.79 $1,139.95 $48.46. $11,316.37
23 'DOUGHERTY, TIMOTHY 01/31/2014 $136,452.43 $1,139.95 $48.46 $9,685.26
24 GONZALEZ, EDWARD 01/31/2014 $165,148.46 $1,139.95 $48.46 $10,863.23
25 REARDON, KENNETH 01/31/2014 $105,631.77 $1,139.95. $48.46 $8,640.09
26 TROUT, TIMOTHY 01/31/2014 $132,802.18 $1,139.95 $48.46 $9,530.31
27 CAR'ROLL, WALTER 02/28/2014 $135,852.58 $1 $48.46 $10,022.88
28 MORRIS, RAYMOND 01/31/2015 $171,479:60 $1,139.95 $48.46 $12,389.86
29 CASTEEL, JAMES C 01/31/2015 $142,367.88 $0.00 $0.00 $11,678.09
30 HUDDLESTON, PATRICK 01/31/2015 $136,146.95 $1,139.95 $48.46 $10,000.75 _
31 POLITZ, BRIAN R 01/31/2015 $125,096.21 $1,139.95 $48.46 $9,015.71
.32 ROBINETTE, WILLIAM 01/31/2015 $131,463.88 $1,139.95 $48.46 $9,127.91
.33 BROWN JR, CHARLES 01/31/2015 $149,892.97 $1,139.95 $48.46 $11,162.70
34 VOSS, ROBERT 01/31/2015 $96,670.55 $1,139.95 $48.46. $6,732.83
35 CALPINI, SEAN 01/31/2015 $105,324.83 $464.48 $16.39 $7,690.81
36 COX, THOMAS 01/31/2015 $114,558.55 $1,139.95 $48.46 $8,972.05
37 LEDON, GEORGE 02/28/2015 $118,318.57 $1,139.95 $48.46 .$8,057.91
38 JOHNSON, CARY 02/28/2015 $125,456.94 $464.48 $16.39 $7,975.61
39 MULSHINE, DOUGLAS .02/28/2015 $144,791.67 $464.48 $16.39 $9,412.01. `
MIAMI BEACH
City of Miami Beath, 1700 Convention Center Drive, Miami Beach, Florida 33139, www.miamibeachf.gov
MEMORANDUM
011 -2012
TO: Mayor Matti Herrera Bower and Members of the City Commission
FROM: Jorge M. Gonzalez, City Manager
DATE: June 20, 2012
SUBJECT: City of Miami Beach Employees Currently . Participating in the Deferred
Retirement Option Plan (DROP) and City of Miami Beach Employees Currently
Eligible to enter the DROP or Retire from the City of Miami Beach.
In response to the City Commission's request, attached is a list of all City employees currently
participating in the Deferred Retirement Option Plan (DROP) as well as a list of all full -time City
employees who are fully vested and meet the minimum age provision to be able to enter the
DROP or retire from the City of Miami Beach. This information is provided as follows:
1. Attachment A - DROP participants in the Miami Beach Employees' Retirement Plan
2. Attachment B - DROP participants in the Fraternal Order of Police (FOP)
3. Attachment C - DROP participants in the International Association of Fire Fighters (IAFF)
4. Attachment D - Full -time employees eligible to enter DROP or retire (sorted by hire date)
Should you have any questions or require any additional information, please feel free to contact
me.
JMG /ri
O
n C M
rQ
Cn
d .,
w
r�. W
i
i Attachment A
i
General Employees
Drop Participants as of 06/01/2012
Name JOB DESCRIPTION Drop End Date
1 HARRINGTON, CINDY FINANCIAL ANALYST 1 06/30/2012
2 PAREDES, GUSTAVO MECHANIC III 07/31/2012
3 SALAZAR, LUISA ADMINASTRIVE AIDE 1 08/30/2012
4 ORTIZ, LUIS HEAVY EQUIPMENT OPERATOR I 08/31/2012
5 SONDE, KENT REDEVELOPMENT COORDINATOR 09/30/2012
6 BUCACCI, ANTONIA LIFEGUARD LT 09/30/2012
7 DE LAS SALAS, ANGEL PROPERTY & EVIDENCE TECHNICIAN 09/30/2012
8 FARIAS, PEDRO PAINTER 09/30/2012
9 GARCIA, MERCEDES ADMINASTRATIVE AIDE II 09/30/2012
10 GOMEZ, JORGE ASSISTANT CITY MANAGER 09/30/2012
11 HOBBS JR, NELSON LIFEGUARD II 09/30/2012
12 MENDEZ, ALFREDO PARKING OPERATION SUPVERVISOR 09/30/2012
13 ROVIROSA, MERCEDES HUMAN RESOURCES TECHNICIAN II 09/30/2012
14 SABALLOS, SHARON PROPERTY & EVIDENCE TECHNICIAN 09/30/2012
15 SCHAWB, LINDA ADMINSTRATIVE AIDE 1 10/31/2012
16 LAMAZARES, MERCEDES PRINCIPAL PLANNER 12/31/2012
17 LABOY, JOSE PARKING OPERATION SUPVERVISOR 01/31/2013
18 MAYORGA, CESAR PARKING ENFORCEMENT SPECIAST 1 01/31/2012
19 SUAREZ, ROBERTO PARKING ENFORCEMENT SPECIALIST 1 02/01/2013
20 AZZINARO, WILLIAM COMMUNITY RESOURCES COORDINATOR 02/28/2013
21 REGOJO, JORGE IPAINTER 04/30/2013
22 RIVERO, MARIA FINANCIAL SPECIALIST 111 04/30/2013
23 FRANCISCO, LUIS MUNICIPAL SERVICE WORKER 11 05/31/2013
24 LAMONS, LEE HEAVY EQUIPMENT OPERATOR 1 05/31/2013
25 STEVENS, VICTORIA FINANCIAL SPECIALIST II 05/31/2013
26 LIBURD, DENIS PUBLIC SAFETY SPECIALIST 06/30/2013
27 GIBSON, ELIZABETH ADMINASTRIVE AIDE 1 07/31/2013
28 MCKINNON, RICHARD LIFEGUARD LT 08/31/2013
29'MOORE, S L CHIEF FIRE PROTECTION ANALYST 09/30/2013
30 SMITH, KEVIN PARKS & RECREATION DIRECTOR 09/30/2013
31 LAMPROU, ATANACIOS MUNICIPAL SERVICE WORKER II 12/31/2013
32 ALVAREZ, MICHAEL INFRASTRUCTURE DIVISION DIRECTOR 03/31/2014
33 GARRETT, MERCEDES ADMINASTRATIVE AIDE 1 03/31/2014
34 ANTONA, GIANCARLO CHIEF ELEVATOR INSPECTOR 04/30/2014
35 LEWIS, DARLENE CONCESSION ATTENDANT 04/30/2014
36 JORGE, RAUL COMMUNICATION OPERERATOR 05/31/2014
37 PETERS, HARRY CARPENTER 05/31/2014
38 HERNANDEZ, CANDIDA DATA ENTRY CLERK 07/31/2014
39 SUAREZ, MAURICIO PARKING ENFORCEMENT SPECIALIST 1 02/13/2013
40 TELLEZ, ELENA ADMINASTRATIVE ASSISTANT 1 07/31/2014
411 RUSH, HARRY MUNICIPAL SERVICE WORKER III 08/31/2014
42 GRAHAM, EDWARD SEWER PIPEFITTER 08/31/2014
Attachment A
General Employees
Drop Participants as of 06/01/2012
Name JOB DESCRIPTION Drop End Date
l
43 BLACKSHEAR, ROBERT PARK SUPERVISOR 08/31/2014
44 LOCKE, CELIA POLICE AND FIRE PENSION ADMINISTRATOR 09/30/2014
45 BERNSTEIN, LYNN COMMUNITY RESOURCE COORDINATOR 09/30/2014
46 LEGGETT, JAMES SENIOR BUILDING INSPECTOR 10/31/2014
47 GREEN, WARREN POOL GUARD II 10/31/2014
48 STANIONS, MARC LIFEGUARD II 11/30/2014
49 FRANCISCO, LEONARDO ENGINEERING ASSISTANT III 11/30/2014
50 OLDENBURG, JOHN ASSISTANT DIRECTOR PARKS 12/31/2014
51 MARTINEZ, ROBERT ASSISTANT DIRECTOR - MBERP 12/31/2014
52 CARY, WILLAIM ASSISTANT DIRECTOR PLANNING 02/28/2015
53 EMERSON SMITH, LEE LIFEGUARD LT 03/31/2015
54 ADAMS, CHARLES ASSISTANT DIRECTOR PARKING 04/30/215
55 BECKMANN, FRED PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR 04/30/215
56 ELLIS, CHARLES LIFEGUARD II 05/31/2015
57 PITTMAN, ALPHONSO PUMPING MECHANIC 05/31/2015
58 ALVAREZ, MARIA ENGINEERING ASSISTANT 111 05/31/2015
Attachment B
FOP
Drop Participants as of 06/01/2012
Name Job Description Drop End Date
1 CARDELLE, THAMYRIS POLICE OFFICER 08/31/2012
2 METZGAR, JESS POLICE OFFICER 08/31/2012
3 RUDER, BERNIE SERGEANT 08/31/2012
4 ZACARIAS, ELISEO POLICE OFFICER 08/31/2012
5 NAVARRO, GEROGE EMERGENCY MANAGER 12/31/2012
6 YERO, EDUARDO LIEUTENANT 02/28/2013
7 DOYLE, PAUL POLICE OFFICER 04/30/2013
8 MAURO, JAMES POLICE OFFICER 04/30/2012
9 BUTCH, JAMES POLICE OFFICER 06/30/2013
10 QUINLAN, PATRICK POLICE OFFICER 06/30/2013 s
11 RODRIGUEZ, PEDRO POLICE OFFICER 08/31/2013
12 MARTINEZ, DOLORES POLICE OFFICER 09/30/2013
13 ORTEGA, FLEIZ LIEUTENANT 10/31/2013
14 RIVERA, JUAN POLICE OFFICER 10/31/2013
15 SHIMKO, RONALD POLICE OFFICER 11/30/2013
16 SMITH, RANDOLPH POLICE.OFFICER 11/30/2013
17 SILVAGNI, ROBERT POLICE OFFICER 05/31/2014
18 BENNETT, HOWARD SERGEANT 08/31/2014
19 MATTHEWS, KENNY POLICE OFFICER 09/30/2014
20 JOHNSON, BRUCH LIEUTENANT 09/30/2014
21 SAN ROMAN, VICENTE SERGEANT 09/30/2014
22 HAN, LORENZO SERGEANT 09/30/2014
23 YERO JR, JULIO LIEUTENANT 11/30/2014
24 KLUGER, GARY SERGEANT 12/31/2014
25 BAMBIS, JOHN MAJOR 01/31/2015
26 ELMORE, ROBERT LIEUTENANT 01/31/2015
27 CHAPMAN, RONALD LIEUTENANT 02/28/2015
28 ROJO, MARIO SERGEANT 05/31/2015
'1 of 1
Attachment C
IAFF
Drop Participants as of 06/01/2012
Name Job Description Drop End Date
1 PRATTJR, ALBERT FIREFIGHTER 06/30/2012 l
2 STEWARD, KEVIN FIREFIGHTER 06/30/2012
3 GORDON, LONNIE CAPTAIN 07/31/2012
4 BOUCHARD, DONALD LIEUTENANT 08/31/2012
5 CARTER, PAUL FIREFIGHTER 08/31/2012
6 HOFMANN, STEPHAN LIEUTENANT 08/31/2012
7 LUBINSKY, DANIEL FIREFIGHTER 08/31/2012
8 MORRISON, ROBERT LIEUTENANT 08/31/2012
9 MULLINS, MICHAEL FIREFIGHTER 08/31/2012
10 NOEL, DAVID DIVISION CHIEF 08/31/2012
11 PHILLIPS, STEVEN LIEUTENANT 08/31/2012
12 BARBERA, MARK LIEUTENANT 01/31/2013
13 GOLTZENE, TIMOTHY LIEUTENANT 01/31/2013
14 HOWARD, WILLIAM DIVISION CHIEF 01/13/2013
15 WHITE, BRADFORD FIREFIGHTER 01/31/2013
16 FREAR, CHARLES FIREFIGHTER 03/31/2013
17 AMATO, LEE CAPTAIN 04/01/2013
18 BERKSTRESSER, KEITH FIREFIGHTER 06/30/2013
19 COURTRIGHT, WAYNE FIREFIGHTER 06/30/2013
20 COURTRIGHT, RONALD LIEUTENANT 09/30/2013
21 CREEL, JOHNATHAN FIREFIGHTER 09/30/2013
22 DAVISON, CARLETON CAPTAIN 01/31/2014
23 DOUGHERTY, TIMOTHY LIEUTENANT 01/31/2014
24 GONZALEZ, EDWARD CAPTAIN 01/31/2014
25 REARDON, KENNETH FIREFIGHTER 01/31/2014
26 TROUT, TIMOTHY LIEUTENANT 01/31/2014
27 CARROLL, WALTER LIEUTENANT 02/28/2014
28 MORRIS, RAYMOND DIVISION CHIEF 01/31/2015
29 CASTELL, JAMES C CAPTAIN 01/31/2015
30 HUDDLESTON, PRTICK FIREFIGHTER 01/31/2015
31 POLITZ, BRIAN R FIREFIGHTER 01/31/2015
32 ROBINETTE, WILLIAM FIREFIGHTER 01/31/2015
33 BROWN JR, CHARLES LIEUTENANT 01/31/2015
34 VOSS, ROBERT FIREFIGHTER 01/31/2015
35 CALPINI, SEAN FIREFIGHTER 01/31/2015
36 COX, THOMAS FIREFIGHTER 01/31/2015
37 LEDON, GEORGE FIREFIGHTER 02/28/2015
38 JOHNSON, CARY FIREFIGHTER 02/28/2015
39 MULSHINE, DOUGLAS LIEUTENANT 02/28/2015
1 Of 1
tiJ W W W W W W W N N NJ N N N N Ij N N Y N Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y
V M to A W . .N Y O tD 00 J 0) to A W N O tD 00 V Q) to A W N Y O lD 03 V O) to .A W N Y
Ln S
D D m l7 o m D m Z D< D D D Gl C D Gl S D Z O < m D
m D 2 < D m O d Z r D m Z C d D. v< D O n 0 v ' D
m Z m Z 2 0 O Z m to m m 0 -i Z Z -i 11 D z Z C D t ; A 2 d v m z O
n r C p Z m m m < O m m M A r m D O 2 Z< m m -� r p- ;Q to m m to Gl O Z
70 2 O z cAn p 7J C O D r to A d rn N O m D r D)
O D W Z Z D D- O m O D_ D D --4 - 2 ? m
m D
C) p y , f 1 to Z A �_ Z C W D r Z ,- D r� r p Z m 0 7° S r 2 ttnn d m r to
2 d O z n C n D M< d r C d O S p p w C O d m< m m O D
z D r Z '- D. d Z n < D rn D Z Z Z Z r Z r m Z D rr- Z< D Z
r D
m i '< —j rn m m m m Z Z D m O
Z
D
D
C'1
. m
n
0 3
D = x () D m m W D
Z „ N ,�, z n z O� O Z n Z > 2 Z
n z D q„ G) D Z, T Z m N m 0 G to n 2 o n ` CD
m 0 Z D d A n p A N m -" m Z to T v v -{ m D m �D
m r D m D p Z m m-0 m f D C -n m r O m -q N m !� m D 0 D A D
A 0 r Z d r n m to O m d m m T r D� j -� � n z m 2 r r m0 T
m N to m n D D O? O m r O m Z �' m 2 D 90 m T� O�� n m Q m
m C mm O z m .r - p Z z Z G1 O .� m to o NO m m Z m N Gzi O -0 Mn m O H
G) v F to Gl C m < < D D C
2 m C m D m m C D n D D G m C 0 D n K�. --1 d n o O 2 D C) t< m{ D H m
-i F) -n m Z D N r A m z D m m m ('1 m to C n m rn a
�_ v+ m a m D D d H A v D m m S n D n D= in ;u O m z D -_Di O �D
0- v� D _ D ?� O z m < Z m m m_ D d D O D D O O 7 -
to -i -f O Z n D C Q„ p m< z d G) p Z z O
m — O z z 5 O n D r) z t') m m m
m n z m m Z S Z 2 z >, C X
_ _ { U — < _ C
N
O
In N N tD C) W Y J J to to to J J to Ui W to Y Y N N N Y 00 Y Y Y =
\ \ \ O \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \
N W Y \ \ \ N Y \ N \ Y Y N \ N N Y \ \ Y N \ N N N Y \ \ N \ \ N N Y \ \ "m O 11 O Y O Y F ' A A O) N. Y. A 01 W W N Y Y A O N V N W O) Y Y A N lJ'1 V lD N m �"�' .
\. \\ to N \ \\ \ \\\\ \\\\ \ \\\ \\\ \\ \ \\
Y Y Y \\ Y Y Y\ Y Y Y !-� Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 1--` Y L O to Y Y Y Y Y Q O
D tO Y ~' tD tD '.0 Y tD tD
to tD tD lD . tD to to tD tD to tD t0 to tD tD tD Y Y iD lD LD to 1D Lo tD lD to tD t
lD tD �Q to LO tD tD to tD tD tD tD LO tD tD Oo W 00 00 00 00 W %.D 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 1 - tD A A A
U:) W W W W N N N N N O 0 0 0 CD 0 tD tD tD tD tD tD 00 li V J Y A W N f '' �' m $
00 N W W 01 N V N t71 W N N 00 A ✓ lD 00 Y W fD IT1 �•
\ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ h
N Y F - � Y W W N N Y' Y Y DQ
Q1 Y N N W W V Y N N In N Y Q1 N tD Y 00 a1
\ N O \ tD M N a) V to O \ \ \ \ �"' lfl V In \ V N A V O W V \ \ tD \ M Q) 0 l!) .�
N \ \ N \ \ \ \ \ \ \ N Y Y N \ \ \ \ Y \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ N N \ N \ \ \ \ Y fD a
O N Y O N N Y Y N Y N O to LD O N N N !- W N N N N N N N N O O N O N N N N tO tD � •1•
tD O O tD O tD O O O 0 0 0 (!1
0 0 tD O Y O� tD �-+ tD 0 0 LO t0 Y 0 0 0 W 0 0 O. O O Y O Y �"' F '' Y Y Y 0 0 0 00 fD .
ID 0 1D tD Y 00 00 Y tD A W V DO Y . Y lD cn A lD tD pOo 00 A O to N O �'' Y �'' N O W 3 O
v
V V V V V Qi Qi 01 Qi O 01 O O m to U1 to In to u+ to to to to A A A A A A A A A A W W
1 W N N 0 tD m V m In A W N 1 O lD DO V (71 In A W "N F-+ O tD W V M to A W N N O lO 00 -
W
D W
m
D p -4 p� m O m O m
n Z > m 2 2 0 -d m C) D S O � m n m m C p
C m to ;10 r W r _ D rn m < W .N p G1 C m m D O m r D 7o n = Z r �O Z D
O D n O Z O -A, N T O D r n D= N A Z G) Z Gl m m O N m 2 m
-i Z N < O C T D O Gl to m A< D D A O N O r D .D < O Z
03 x m O - N �{ D D m -o m r z ; -I _1 N p Z m< O p Z Z
m to Z 2 D yr m r m m :'i D rrl O , m n m `� rrn m v
G O m oz rn r O D m 2? D m �_ Z G) m D D '� z D m D v N _ n, m A<
m D C m O D O Z r m x� C G1 r < D S , O (D
Z <_ • Z m r_ 7' S O ' S O N x O C N n m r_ I C, D r
G) --�� C z D O m D m— 2 r -4 m z a D O D O
m -i D G1 Z to S D �^ �o to = r r m w D O r W to -� = r m D� r
p0 p rZ < C D N D O v z D Z r m W� Z D W z D D D' Z N -< O
r r - G m - i r p
O m O O c
_ O ,
O n
tD
m
2 v m n m (1 m -0
n D z m m C C C m O m O C D C O D A Z C
O< 7C T 0 n Z Z Z Z 0 T T Z < Z m m Z
Z < O m D m C O n n O n O n "n z C1 m m n Z n m m Z n CD
70 m o Z C c1 m y m v v y„ T Z �, Z t'� Q D D O Q m G) v O. CD
O Q W Z O n n r m A D D -� D m -i O r m n m m D D C D O D D +S N
(7 n r r- r n Z r m r C f1
n O 7, m D m O-V m D m p A D r
AO ' ii D z C O c^ D m rn Z m D Z m Z to N m to E m W C D p m m m
O m O r m m„ -0 m < N m D On r' < c rn a r D m to z W Z
Z Z D z Z Z n m D m Z D D Z n m D Z Z v y < 3
cn Z to n -i m w O n C1 < O m m "i
-i -� r n m m n n to n to D Z n m -t n 2 Z n o m m m n a'
O N D m m to D< (� m �n m m to m D m O m m G D m n O n m r
m< n 70 m N^ m D v' O �' m to r c C N z vi { O D m__ O CD
Pz z ,, p _ n O m O O PD O m D= T D 0 0 0 z O z" W vi z O 3 -n
D = n < z �o < Z Z A_ z y z — C� D r? m 7o O
--1 ' < D D m m m -1 m i n m - I m m D n A
O . Q . m om z 7J = N = >, N Z = z
W
O
O'
f+ -
F+ F+ F•+ D1 A N N O to W N N N 1--� F+ I--� F+ tD Dl = ie
N N N N N 1-� /•� O O \ \ W W \ \ �''O lD � V \ \ 'p \ W \ \ \ \ \ \ N O O O \ \
\ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ O
N N A A N N N N to to In �"'' N W N N N N N N F-+ N W W\ t•+ h+ �„}
W N F+ A N O N lD N W V W In 01 W V W LO W m
W O \ \ 00 Ul 'p \ \ \ \ \ \ \ l/1 DD \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \. \ \ \ \ O ' F'' \ \ \
N Fa f-+ to Lo Lo to 0
h+ r N lD tD t-' N l0 tD lD lD tD t-+ �-+ r�
. tD tD tD tD lD lD tD tD lD lD lD lD tD O t0 tD tD W lD tD lD to tD tD tD tD tD tD tD W t0 t0 to y
to to W to lfl lD w lD lD lD W Gl Ol t0 W lD lD to to lJt tD 1 .0 to tD to lD tD tD 'lD lD lD to lD tD lD 1p to .,• O
01 Ot 01 01 01 6t Cl D1 G1 Cl 01 Ln to In In In to In In In ,p A A A A A (D . Ln
N N W i--• 'N V lD V 00 D1 F V lD 01 w F ~ ~ N F+ N 01 m_ A•
\ \ \ N N ~ \ \ \ \ N N \ \. N .� lD W tD N V \ 00 W \ \ \ \ \ N i"' \ O N \ �•
\ \ \ W N N \ N \ \ N N \ N \ \ \ \ N \ \ W \ N \ \ N \ \ F =�
01 01 �! W W !-+ N tD N W ~ N 01 to W O In W W N Ln w tD O �' �! N O In V N ~' O W A W -�
\\\\ \�` \\\ \\ a) ^� \\\ \\\ \\ \\\\ \\\\ \\ tD \\\\tD
N N N' N N N N N N N N \ \ N N N N N N N N N N N N N
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N. N O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 t0
O N N O W O tD
N O O O O O r O O O N O
00 00 N N A A VO A O O t0 ID 00 O 00 V O O W In �... p C Qt OV A (n ~ O 0 w YO t C
n
3
CD
0 N F�
O O O O O O O tO W t0 tD t0 t0 w t0 lD 0 lD 00 w V 00 m In 00 W w 00 DO 0 V V V V V
Vm In A W N �-+ O lO 00 V 6� In A W N 1--' O W Q1 A W N O lD 00 V Q1 In
m m to 2 n N T-
n r) m S c A n p" N m D p D m r m Z> S D D
D r 0 n 2 ro in K D O D C D O
O p D n 07 ro 2 m n m 2 to C D C Z co r < to
m N< p m m N C D m D rn 2 A D A r 2 m < r' D m 7c D m
N O Z z Z `n m D in D m CO = N c N D 7U M Z m D D Z Z Z p _ m= Z
Z m m _ 2 cn D O " m m U, Z Gl = A N N N D O N a < n v
r D 2 D p r m C 7c D O V) S D O m D A r 9 �' D >, 2 m
C f 1 >' D S C m D _{ m C= t Z Lr K D C D D m m D 0 A m Gl D -
Z Z S n 7 ' m �' to Z Z 2 to r� m m C D 7� Z D O� Z� � z A D
D � m D= -<m p G D G1 D Z D D : I rn to M Z O C z Z z G) m n= rn<
to < z O D m m Z M D M m M D O to m
m D
n
rh
C .
m
m C n N D m C NZm O m n D CSC -
ro D p a - p = p
C< Z Z --I = 7c D Z Z to n n ' Ti q z T < m m Z Z Z 0
m n G x Z D v m Z D n n T n Z n Z n (M-) ro n' ,,, ^ - 0 ro O v p` m n p A Un rn n < m O m p
Z D O to m m m n n D Z- v m n r m m< rn C O C r -n p D -o D r N
N r r m O D rn z S' r D r m r
D ro N z D T C m O H O s O C n ' Z ro � r D r v Z to M cn O
m D m O Z -i O� p ro Z C m w w< m Z to D D r Z m D m to D m m D m m
M r< O -- O C R M m - < - 0 n n T -1 D r D N Gl GZl O Z O m 0 n O< < n t'
Z o n Z m n D ' - , m n n Z O D Z p D Z G) T Z m m O
to n ={ r m Z v+ o n n D ^� r D D A C (� Z to Z r m - D - m Z n Cr
m : m - I to r m Z p� D m - 1 r m �n m m < cn m '�
D m z m D O Z Z m A N m -�i { p --q z 0 v m m N O m C O O
m O m� m D D - O z ?� O= O m D- m m m O v O
r D M D z N m Z Z m L) - C 7o n Z � D n � m z O
--1 p O x - m m Z - n O O m
- m n z n m m N m - N=
m D - - = O - �D
Z N_
' O
O
tD V V at A In w w 00 v .P A w W 1- ~O 00 V V a) m Qt m A w w ' F. F N' _ z
\ p \\ \ \\\\\\\\ �. \\\ \\\ O ..
\ N N \ \ \ \ \ O
W N N 00 M N N N tD lD W m a1 N
O \ O lD A ' \ \ N tO N N 00 to to 'A W A W a� \ O A W lD N 00 \ \ \ Ol F+ A \ 'P \ \ \
N N N I--' N ! F N N N N N F N Fl F-` N v
O !-� N tD tD N lD F� N iD t0 lD lD lD tD lD
O t0 tD t0 tD to tD t0 tD t0 tD tD tD t0 lD t0 w tD lD tD t0 Cl 1
O tD %0 W to t0 lD t0 tD w tD tD LO tD
O lD lD t0 l0 lD W t0 W l0 lD lD lD t0 lD tD U:) t0 t0 tD LO 't
O O �c tDD to tD t0 tD tD w W t0 00 00 00 00 00 00 lVD V V V V V V V v V V V V V O
V
a1
a� N ai O V N 00 O r 'A to W V 00 A N to A W F+ A F+ W V al ~O a1 Ln N tO F-` N N 00 fD m �•
\ \ \ \ N \ \ \ \ \ \ \ N \ N \ \ \
N N 1-+ N N N N \ N N F-+ W\ N\
W N 00 W !-� W F+ A 00 N 00 AI
lJ9 \ tD �. tp \ \ 00 tD N N 06 00 O A 00 N V V1 t0 O N A A \ 00 to N V \ I- tD V A \ 00 \
\ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \. \ \ '� \ \ �. \ \ \ \. \ \ \ \ \ \ \ fD a
N \ N N \ N \ N N\ N
N O N N N O O N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N O N N N Ni O N N N N O N O tD
O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O cc O O O O O O Cl O
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 t-• 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 F-+ 0 0 �--� O t-• O �-+ 0 0 F+ 0 0 0 0 0 0 N 0 0 0� C
V U ' O V V O A w A A A to W to O V w O W F+ p r O N F-� m 00 O cn V A O N A A
n
m
Q
r r r r N 4 � F+ 41 r r r r Y r Y r r r Y r r r r r r r r r r Y r r r r r r r
A A A A A A A A A W W W W W W W W W W N N N N N N N N N N Y r Y r r r r r
W V D1 !n A W N r O O N V0� In A W N r 0 ID 00 V D1 In A W N Y O lD co V Dl In A W N
r
_ p In r D
m n G) -I G) m D p 0 A n D _ Z 0 O O C 1 D r
z n D p r m D m� to p D m S 'v z C O z
Z 7c W S D O, I " m* m D m cn C m 0 m m D D O D m 0 D D D D C m
D m D Z C Z S n !`� v O r In D m r z D O z m 70 V' C? m z A 0
Z z cn Gl D D y A „= m� Z S D Z Z p D Z D O to p Z m r n
v cn D = -i m Z N m D n �n v O m m C v p
O 3
n Z� Z r N 2 Ln n v' Z 2 m D D m Z D D m Z N N n rn D O r
C r Z m D ^ O O r r W r O 9 S CO p C O f0
`p p - N I Z ` - - ? D D< O D m z A D 2 D Ln 2 r D m m cn C C
Gl f�i < D> D Z C �O A> Z N Z Z m z z D = C O R D O m D n m rn »,
m D
Fri m O N D << O Z �. m D D m m O to
D
0
CD
m
r
O S r v V
D A m m
m m O= C C m n z T C m C C m m C Q
Z r- D Z Z O Z
r m (A m m � o N v: Z O D CD1 n v -n v z D-0 G C
m n O m m m D D D n t D D m K Gl -I r) n D co p D D m• 0 -I z D m
_ m Z S C N Z D T N v m m NI y r (� D n D 0 0 C r m r D O go m D to m G cr
N
D m O n H m m m m m D D O z z C m m D m to m - { r m D r m n M m
Z In Q O m 0 0 O C A Z° '� z z O z O v -+ -� Z O G1 < cn in z v+
!n p n < Z < O !n m -i Z < N< n
O n m n z D D m In D cn -� � z n m 0 Z C C O m
m m m D m r n D C cn m -i n G r (� n Gl n n n to D n n
n n K D (l m K m O m Om T N z C m m m m� n p m Z
m m m Z n n m m cn � z C1 n m
m m
� C v n
S -D m I m - { r- n _ m z In m A
Z „� z v = Z m O m < p< In - O m m O p m m m cn O
< z to A v, O v O X_ z n < z z m<
n cn C to — 7 C 7z O m m --4 7 c < = 7t •1
D n v m 7o n ( 7 m z 0 m m In _ - m
Z n v n = O - m = w° -
co
O
N N" I " r r ID M In A r r Y 00 J D, Ql In W N r r r r r 00 V 0) A W W N = z
\ \ N r \ \ \ \ \ N O \ \ \ \ ` \ \ \ N \ \ N \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ O ,
N r N \\ N W N f+ A V N N N\ �, Y \ N Y Y W r N N r N "t 1" P
A r
LO A W W M W N W 00 O O W 00 \\ r Y O A i„� r A \ A V ID A O W
\ \ O \ \ \. \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \
N N N N N N N N N N rj N N N N N N " O N N N N N N N N O N N rj N N N N N D v
O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O. O O O O O O O O O O O O O 1
O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O
W W O O N N N N N N N N r r r r r r ~'' �' r r r O 0 p O p 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 fD
PQ ri r ~ ~ ' r r Y V Vt V r r r V W V M r N W N r r A A r r In Im r 00 P- A m 2
A N r Y A A r Ol In N M
\ N \ \ \ \ \ \ \ N O r \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ N \ O \ \ \ r \ \ \ \ \ \ \
p1 \ r N \ r N N r A Y r � \ \ W N W r N r N N \ r \ r W N \ W W r N N A N
00 IO U'i In D� \\ O) W w r O m O V ID r Y O A w m O r A O ID a1 O\ A
N \ \ n \ \ \ \ N N \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ N \ \ \ \ N \ fD m
O N N N N N N N N O O N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N O N N N N O N
O O O O O O O O O O O O O 00 O O O O O O O O O O O O m V7
r F"' O O O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o r Y 0 0 0 0 0 0 a r r r 0 Y 00 Y O r Y �r,,, 00 m O
O V V V Oo 00 co V co O1 lD 01 O O V ID tD 01, O to O r r ID r O In �-+ r V� ,t
C)
ro
v
In un F+
W W- W W W W V V V V J V V V V V tT tT QJ M Ol Q1 W tT 01 0 l to to to to In V+ to In W In A
ll'. A W N V Q1 In A W N v 0 l0 W V Q1 U'i A W N F+ O D W V Q1 A W N f-+ O lD
W
_ N C = G) p D m co D z co r 03 O D C C3 m r"- D n T m m C 7�o Z p r D n Z p rn ;)a D p p Gl
C r1 rn Q N W p r D D A D m m m m r Z Z m 2 n m to O m D C m m z O p
C7 7c r n m Z p D m W O Z to W m r N D< 2 m O m - I m A 2
r to p < D O z O Z m C N i D cn O D Z C Z to 2 Z to in N Z
p 0 Z D -a r r 0 0 O m 7o _ m r O to m m p Z rn m D Z Ol
�n Z ,cn p m O O z O 70 „ r w x N m oO r N , n Z D r po M m
C r) r m O D r) D� G) l"1 p D D rn C m m r N Z Z C r- Z w C r) D D N N C M
D D D C 2 Z L, m D D Z z Z `O 70 m m C D m n N r 0 rl S r m 3` p
2 7ro r r r D Z m D 2 �' rn �' m r) to m z - 1 to r A m O to � D r O O r
O to m m Z r m D r0 < Z N mm Z S m D C - i r r Z Z m<
_ A O D Ln n S O Z -� o
O
a
c
C
m
M � (A "V to
D D = ("7 m
�. x 2 -� m to m ri m m O O C� •G
Z z Z p n C p� z z m n m v z z N m m Z Z �G
Z - 0 r? ;0 n C C '-' Z D D G) n = -i „ D D D m C C Z m n n ._
m to m to 'D F F m Gl Z Z r Z m m C m O m C *+ D C ° to m
D C7 D< D m x po T m > T r G1 D O D r C n (7 to Z? y= r r D- n a to
m O S_ Z Z C_ -� rn fl rl
N 1 to m to Z Z N m 0 cn co D to r �_ m Gl Z r C Z y D z p m N z m m
M O m m C7 Gl -1 m p C Z m p Z Z D z D r A O m m tD _s
r ;o ;o O m T to A � to Z �^ to D G1 m to GT r A D to
< to < r7 z C to < D m G1 m D I m Z D to O Q << m to n (a
C) - D- Z Z r) Z G1 m m m to Z Z Z r p Z m G1 Z O =.
to to D 1 m m m n -� rl Z m r1 to Gl �_ m Z Z r) n
F5 C rn Z m m m -i m D m to x N m m r> m -a -{ D m m r r? m D to O C m rn m z 'p
D m m m r7 to to N O m Z� r) to m Z D D m r r D •►
g S to D o C1 m L� -' O S° Z n O n L'I cn z m n t r� `L. 'o
W O 70 z z C n O v �' D M A - D D S r1 O m n rn < O to O v 3 O
m m m n D �' m 7 m D D t�ii m A -1 -1 X S=
�o z Z m Z Z Gl "� O D O G) �
m '� �° �_ ;Q
z
O
t�A
7
V� V to to to _ W N l0 W W to to A A W W W W N W W V V V In A N N N tD V
\ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ N \ \ \ 1 \ \
\ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ O
W W N N N N N lD (D A A N N N F- W\ tp to N Q1 N W to N LD to N N N N W ' P►
N \ O O O \ Vt \ V tD 01 \ \ \ \ \ �-+ t� h+ A. \ W \ \ tT \ .� t0 a) \ tD \ 00 \ \ fD
\ N \ \ N \ N \ \ \ N N N N N �` \ \ \ N \ N N \ N \ N \ \ N N \ N \. N N
N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N Q D
O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O 0 C 0 0 Cl 0 0 0 0 0 0
O O O O O O O O O O O O O 0 0 O O O
O O O O� O W O O O Un LM L � O O O O L O A A O A O A O O A A O W O W W h O
Q1 m Q) m tT W V7 to In to to to -r-
A A A A W W fD .
91
V V to to to N 1-+ W !--� to W to In W �--� V V A N N lD N m �•
\ W \ \ \ to W to to O \ \ \ \ \ F F , W W \ V \ to \ \ F N l0
W \ N W W \ N \ N \ N \ \ \ \ N N \ \ \ N \ N \ N N \ \ N \ N \ \ CO
/-+ V O O O to W V F- 0) F"'' t0 lD W V O) W A W W (
lD lD T CN tD M (T W N In N O N W m
\\\\\\\\\\\ \\\ \\ \\ \\ N \ \ \ \ \\ ty a
N N N N N N N N N N N \ N N N N
N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
O O O O O O O O O o O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O N O O O O O O
F.+ r+ N 0 0 0 N O O O O 0 0 O 0 0 �
O O O N N O O N O O� l0 lD ko lD l00 tD L S O l0 0 W W W W O
r►
a
n
CD
v
to LO tz kD N LO� tD w w w m
-4
�! m Ln� w fn io 0o m o0 m
Ql lf7 A W N tD �-+ O OD --j Q�
z m Z D N n 0 0 Gl
C Z m cmii D N 7
M r= D N —1 n ;a V ' m p 0
N N Z� r Q O D un Z Z Z
Z m Oa
m o N . z
D -� Z p N r O K m�=
A O p Z C CO O m n
0 -< K D n D n m Z�= O
O D <> m m C 1 to
to Z z to
D
CD
m
< __ C Z p
Z Z Z D z
_
D r r Ci Ln O m Dr � Z � N
cn yr m D N m H N = D N O ( n
m m D m < m m n Z m tD _
m < < Ln�� m < < Z m < n (Q
Z O „ =
O m m Q N 3 m m O C C cn m n
� a
{ c 4 n D M m O
D =� m D � O N-{ < CA 0 3 G
< r
- - - CD
N
O
PJ �D���� H 0) r-j Un J cD rt
r
- - O 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 p d 0
a) m m rn rn m
-. 'D m
N N A\ O N O N
\ \ \\ \fD
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 O
D
n
S
CD
rt