20170628 BM96UU4WW46RKGQQ.4RjKkq"QWQR.f.46RWKVKcpf"SWY
94.BKLfOOIK96UU4WW46RK9NfUEQ"WIKT"SK:O66"IK5-88K96R2QR.46RK9QR.Q"Ku"42Q
JDRQKv0IKv85-K7K1F88KqG
–
”“XQ'–ZUWVW’–"HDW&H
NQOOWBBWQ&H'–:QU&–jVWI“FH7U–YVHO“&
NQOOWBBWQ&H'–;W19X–Y''WQV“
NQOOWBBWQ&H'–”W1U“HV–8'WH1Q
NQOOWBBWQ&H'–:QX–”“V“9Q22
NQOOWBBWQ&H'–4'WB7H&–;QBH&–8Q&I“VHI
NQOOWBBWQ&H'–”W19X–67HW&FH'5
NW7X–”“&“5H'–:WOOX–"0–”Q'“VHB
NW7X–Y77Q'&HX–;“3V–:0–Y53WV“
NW7X–NVH'9–;“2“HV–j0–8'“&“/Q
.MyMCmvymdCmvvvoglfglhcfebaiom.wmnegmdrofadymdfamuMaoemyCgod MfrmenmtMCsmte MyyMefmiooCMfryV
c33bh3,lhKcHHKHlyy),d3d
9Nfw.Q"KvIKc".4AOQK&,,IKu424W46RKTK6aK.NQK94.BK96SQK6aKG4fU4KyQfANIKQR.4.OQSKrH6EEB4W.WIrK"QPD4"QWK.NQ
"Qj4W."f.46RK6aKfOOKO6EEB4W.WKp4.NK.NQKlaa4AQK6aK.NQK94.BK9OQ"(Kw"46"K.6KQRjfj4RjK4RKfRBKO6EEB4Rj
fA.424.BKp4.NK.NQK94.BK96UU4WW46RIKfRBK94.BKy6f"SK6"K96UU4..QQIK6"KfRBKwQ"W6RRQOKfWKSQa4RQSK4RK.NQ
WDEgQA.K96SQKWQA.46RWtK96w4QWK6aK.NQK94.BK96SQKWQA.46RWK6RKO6EEB4W.WKOfpWKf"QKf2f4OfEOQK4RK.NQ
laa4AQK6aK.NQK94.BK9OQ"(tKeDQW.46RWK"Qjf"S4RjK.NQKw"624W46RWK6aK.NQKl"S4RfRAQKWN6DOSKEQKS4"QA.QSK.6
.NQKlaa4AQK6aK.NQK94.BKc..6"RQBt
wQ–'H)3HB7–7UWB–O“7H'W“V–W&–“V7H'&“7H–2Q'O“7-–BW5&–V“&53“5H–W&7H'’'H7H'–(2WDH,/“X–&Q7W1H–'H)3W'H/q-–W&2Q'O“7WQ&–Q&
“11HBB–2Q'–’H'BQ&B–TW7U–/WB“FWVW7WHB-–“&/dQ'–“&X–“11QOOQ/“7WQ&–7Q–'HDWHT–“&X–/Q13OH&7–Q'–’“'7W1W’“7H–W&–“&X
1W7X,B’Q&BQ'H/–’'Q1HH/W&5B-–1“VV–u.g0S.K0fKGk–“&/–BHVH17–c–2Q'–j&5VWBU–Q'–f–2Q'–6’“&WBU-–7UH&–Q’7WQ&–SR–wwA
3BH'B–O“X–1“VV–DW“–tcc–(bVQ'W/“–;HV“X–6H'DW1Hq0
z&–Q'/H'–7Q–H&B3'H–“/H)3“7H–’3FVW1–1Q&BW/H'“7WQ&-–W2–&H1HBB“'X-–7UH–”“XQ'–“&/–NW7X–NQOOWBBWQ&–O“X–OQDH–“&X
“5H&/“–W7HO–7Q–“&–“V7H'&“7H–OHH7W&50––z&–“//W7WQ&-–7UH–”“XQ'–“&/–NW7X–NQOOWBBWQ&–O“X-–“7–7UHW'–/WB1'H7WQ&-
“/EQ3'&–7UH–NQOOWBBWQ&–”HH7W&5–TW7UQ37–'H“1UW&5–“VV–“5H&/“–W7HOB0
cMbhucK b)
Z'HBH&7“7WQ&B–“&/–YT“'/BJ;H53V“'–Y5H&/“J
ZY–,–Z'HBH&7“7WQ&B–“&/–YT“'/B;f–,–NQO’H7W7WDH–sW/–;H’Q'7B
;g–,–m'/W&“&1HB
NQ&BH&7–Y5H&/“J;t–,–;HBQV37WQ&B
Nf–,–NQO’H7W7WDH–sW/–;H’Q'7B;k–,–CHT–s3BW&HBBHB–n–NQOOWBBWQ&–;H)3HB7B
NK–,–NQOOWBBWQ&–NQOOW77HH–YBBW5&OH&7B;c.–,–NW7X–Y77Q'&HX–;H’Q'7B––––––––
NS–,–NQOOWBBWQ&–NQOOW77HH–;H’Q'7B
Nt–,–;HBQV37WQ&B;H’Q'7B–“&/–z&2Q'O“7WQ&“V–z7HOB
Page 1 of 230
cMbhuc
c0NY""–wm–m;vj;
qnbdbh3c3,lhdKchuKcscnud
ZYcNj;wzbzNYwj–mb–YZZ;jNzYwzmC–Z;j6jCwjv–wm–wej–Lzwp6–Cjlj;–m4Lm ZYCj"
6ZjY4j;6–iem–vz6Nh66jv–wjjC–vYwzC8–lzm"jCNjmYw–wej–”Y;Ne–cS-–f.ct
”zY”z–sjYNe–6jCzm;–ez8e–6Nemm"–Zw6Y–8jCj;Y"–”jjwzC80
NQOOWBBWQ&H'–”W19X–67HW&FH'5
vH2H''H/–2'QO–”“X–ct-–f.ct–,–ZY–G
ZYfZ;mN"Y”YwzmC–vjN"Y;zC8–:hCj–f.ct-–Y6–Y"Pejz”j;p6–YCv–s;YzC–YiY;jCj66
”mCwe0–
lW1H,”“XQ'–4'WB7H&–;QBH&–8Q&I“VHI
ZYuNj;wzbzNYwj–mb–YZZ;jNzYwzmC–Z;j6jCwjv–wm–4Ywzj–Nm”j;-–Y–6w;mC8–lmzNj
bm;–ez6wm;zN–Z;j6j;lYwzmC–YCv–YZZ;mZ;zYwj–vj6z8C–8hzvj"zCj6–zC–Cm;we
sjYNe0–
NQOOWBBWQ&H'–:QX–”“V“9Q22
ZYKNj;wzbzNYwj–mb–;jNm8CzwzmC–Z;j6jCwjv–wm–wej–NzwA–mb–”zY”z–sjYNe–bz;j
vjZY;w”jCw–bm;–;jNjzlzC8–wej–Y”j;zNYC–ejY;w–Y66mNzYwzmCr6–f.ct
”z66zmCJ–"zbj"zCj–j”6–8m"v–Z"h6–"jlj"–;jNm8CzwzmC–YiY;v0
NQOOWBBWQ&H'–:QX–”“V“9Q22
ZYgNj;wzbzNYwj6–mb–YZZ;jNzYwzmC–wm–sj–Z;j6jCwjv–wm–NzwA–6wYbb–bm;–im;"v
mhw8Y”j60
wQ3'WBO-–N3V73'H–“&/–j1Q&QOW1–vHDHVQ’OH&7
ZYSNj;wzbzNYwj6–mb–;jNm8CzwzmC–wm–sj–Z;j6jCwjv–wm–wej–”zY”z–sjYNe
;mizC8–N"hs0
lW1H,”“XQ'–4'WB7H&–;QBH&–8Q&I“VHI
9lhdbh3KcMbhuc
9iK7K96UU4WW46RK96UU4..QQKcWW4jRUQR.W
NKY;jbj;;Y"–wm–Z"YCCzC8–smY;v–,–Z;mZm6jv–m;vzCYCNj–Zj;wYzCzC8–wm–YN"b
YCv–”jvzNY"–h6j60
ZV“&&W&5
NQOOWBBWQ&H'–:QU&–jVWI“FH7U–YVHO“&
NKs;jbj;;Y"–wm–wej–"YCv–h6j–YCv–vjlj"mZ”jCw–Nm””zwwjj–YCv–vz;jNwzmC–wm
Z"YCCzC8–6wYbb–mC–YCY"A6z6–;j"YwzC8–wm–ZeY;”YNzj6–YCv–”jvzNY"
NYCCYsz6–vz6ZjC6Y;zj60
m22W1H–Q2–7UH–NW7X–Y77Q'&HX
NQOOWBBWQ&H'–:QU&–jVWI“FH7U–YVHO“&
NKN;jbj;;Y"–wm–wej–"YCv–h6j–YCv–vjlj"mZ”jCw–Nm””zwwjj–YCv–wej
Z"YCCzC8–smY;v–;j"YwzC8–wm–ZeY;”YNzj6–YCv–”jvzNY"–NYCCYsz6
Page 2 of 230
vz6ZjC6Y;zj60
m22W1H–Q2–7UH–NW7X–Y77Q'&HX
NQOOWBBWQ&H'–:QX–”“V“9Q22
NKv;jbj;;Y"–wm–wej–Cjz8esm;emmvdNm””hCzwA–YbbYz;6–Nm””zwwjj–YCv–wej
bzCYCNj–YCv–NzwAizvj–Z;m:jNw6–Nm””zwwjj–,–;johj6w–bm;–NzwA–wm
6ZmC6m;–wej–6wzC8–6iz”–N"hs0
lW1H,”“XQ'–4'WB7H&–;QBH&–8Q&I“VHI
9-K7KnQW6OD.46RW
NtYY–;j6m"hwzmC–mb–wej–”YAm;–YCv–NzwA–Nm””z66zmC–mb–wej–NzwA–mb–”zY”z
sjYNe-–b"m;zvY-–;jZjY"zC8–;j6m"hwzmC–Cm0–f.ct,fkk.t–YCv–NY""zC8–bm;–Y
6ZjNzY"–j"jNwzmC–mC–Cmlj”sj;–t-–f.ct-–bm;–wej–Zh;Zm6j–mb–6hs”zwwzC8–wm
wej–j"jNwm;Ywj–mb–wej–NzwA–mb–”zY”z–sjYNe-–b"m;zvY–Y–sY""mw–ohj6wzmC
Y64zC8–iejwej;–wej–NzwA–Nm””z66zmC–6eY""–YvmZw–YC–m;vzCYCNj
NeYC8zC8–wej–Nh;;jCw–gJ..–Y0”0–wj;”zCYwzmC–wz”j–wm–fJ..–Y0”0–bm;–wej–6Y"j
YCv–NmC6h”ZwzmC–mb–Y"Nmem"zN–sjlj;Y8j6–mC–Z;zlYwj–Z;mZj;wA–Yw
Y"Nmem"zN–sjlj;Y8j–j6wYs"z6e”jCw6–"mNYwjv–mC–mNjYC–v;zlj–b;m”–gwe
wm–cgwe–6w;jjw6-–jyj”ZwzC8–b;m”–wez6–wz”j–NeYC8j–wem6j–zCvmm;
Zm;wzmC6–mb–Y"Nmem"zN–sjlj;Y8j–j6wYs"z6e”jCw6–weYw–Y;j–Nm”Z"jwj"A
jCN"m6jv–YCv–"mNYwjv–jCwz;j"A–izwezC–emwj"60
m22W1H–Q2–7UH–NW7X–Y77Q'&HX
”“XQ'–ZUWVW’–"HDW&H
nbMmHcnKcMbhuc
n1K7Kl"S4RfRAQW
;gYCm;we–sjYNe–wYwh”–iYwj;iYA–NmC6j;lYwzmC–vz6w;zNw–vj”m"zwzmC
”m;Ywm;zh”J
YC–m;vzCYCNj–mb–wej–”YAm;–YCv–NzwA–Nm””z66zmC–mb–wej–NzwA–mb–”zY”z
sjYNe-–b"m;zvY-–jywjCvzC8–wej–”m;Ywm;zh”–we;mh8e–mNwmsj;–uc-–f.ct-
bm;–Z;mZj;wzj6–b;mCwzC8–mC–wYwh”–iYwj;iYA–YCv–"mNYwjv–mC–wej–ij6w
6zvj–mb–wYwh”–iYwj;iYA–v;zlj–YCv–sA;mC–YljChj–b;m”–ttwe–6w;jjw–wm
Gtwe–6w;jjw-–Z;mZj;wzj6–"mNYwjv–mC–wej–jY6w–6zvj–mb–eYiwem;Cj–YljChj
b;m”–ttwe–6w;jjw–wm–N;j6Zz–smh"jlY;v-–Z;mZj;wzj6–"mNYwjv–mC–wej–jY6w
6zvj–mb–N;j6Zz–smh"jlY;v–b;m”–eYiwem;Cj–YljChj–wm–Ggwe–6w;jjw-–YCv
Z;mZj;wzj6–"mNYwjv–mC–wej–Cm;we–6zvj–mb–Ggwe–6w;jjw–sjwijjC–N;j6Zz
smh"jlY;v–YCv–sA;mC–YljChjR–z”Zm6zC8–Y–wj”Zm;Y;A–”m;Ywm;zh”–hZmC
wej–;jNjzZw–mb–m;–Z;mNj66zC8–mb–YZZ"zNYwzmC6-–Zj;”zw6–m;–ZjCvzC8
YZZ;mlY"6–Zj;wYzCzC8–wm–vj”m"zwzmC–mb–6w;hNwh;j6–mC–wYwh”–iYwj;iYAR
bm;–PmCzC8–zC–Z;m8;j66–Zh;Zm6j6-–wez6–m;vzCYCNj–6eY""–sj–jbbjNwzlj
hZmC–bz;6w–;jYvzC8–mb–wez6–m;vzCYCNj-–YCv–Cm–YZZ"zNYwzmC6–bm;
vj”m"zwzmC–izwezC–wej–vj6z8CYwjv–Y;jY–6eY""–sj–YNNjZwjv–sA–wej–NzwAR
Z;mlzvzC8–bm;–jyNjZwzmC6R–Z;mlzvzC8–bm;–6jlj;Ysz"zwAR–;jZjY"–mb
NmCb"zNwzC8–m;vzCYCNj–Z;mlz6zmC6R–YCv–Z;mlzvzC8–bm;–YC–jyZz;YwzmC
vYwj0
1F85KwtUtKdQA6RSKnQfS4RjKqDEO4AKLQf"4Rj ZV“&&W&5–vH’“'7OH&7
bW'B7–;H“/W&5–Ze–Q&–:3&H–t-–f.ct–,–;g–YNQOOWBBWQ&H'–;W19X–Y''WQV“
;gsCm;we–sjYNe–CYwzmCY"–;j8z6wj;–NmC6j;lYwzmC–vz6w;zNw6–vj”m"zwzmC
”m;Ywm;zh”J
YC–m;vzCYCNj–mb–wej–”YAm;–YCv–NzwA–Nm””z66zmC–mb–wej–NzwA–mb–”zY”z
sjYNe-–b"m;zvY-–Zj;wYzCzC8–wm–jywjCvzC8–wej–”m;Ywm;zh”–we;mh8e
Page 3 of 230
mNwmsj;–uc-–f.ct–bm;–wej–bm""mizC8–Y;jY6dZ;mZj;wzj6J–Z;mZj;wzj6
"mNYwjv–sjwijjC–wYwh”–iYwj;iYA–v;zljdsA;mC–YljChj–mC–wej–ij6w–YCv
wej–jY6wj;C–"mw–"zCj6–mb–"mw6–b;mCwzC8–Yssmww–YljChj–mC–wej–jY6w
sjwijjC–ttwe–6w;jjw–mC–wej–6mhwe–YCv–GSwe–6w;jjw–mC–wej–Cm;weR–wej
Z;mZj;wzj6–"mNYwjv–sjwijjC–wej–wYwh”–iYwj;iYA–mC–wej–ij6w–YCv–wej
jY6wj;C–"mw–"zCj6–mb–"mw6–b;mCwzC8–Yssmww–YljChj–mC–wej–jY6w–sjwijjC
tgwe–6w;jjw–mC–wej–6mhwe–YCv–ttwe–6w;jjw–mC–wej–Cm;weR–wej–Z;mZj;wzj6
"mNYwjv–Yw–Ggck-–Ggfg-–YCv–Ggft–N;j6Zz–smh"jlY;vR–wej–Z;mZj;wzj6
b;mCwzC8–Cm;”YCvA–v;zlj–b;m”–;hj–Cmw;j–vY”j–mC–wej–ij6w–wm–sYA
v;zlj–mC–wej–jY6wR–wej–Z;mZj;wzj6–b;mCwzC8–tc6w–6w;jjw–b;m”–;hj–Cmw;j
vY”j–mC–wej–ij6w–wm–sYA–v;zlj–mC–wej–jY6wR–wej–Z;mZj;wzj6–b;mCwzC8
wej–jY6w–6zvj–mb–;hj–lj;6Yz""j6–b;m”–tc6w–6w;jjw–wm–szY;;zwP–v;zljR–wej
Z;mZj;wzj6–b;mCwzC8–szY;;zwP–v;zlj–b;m”–;hj–lj;6Yz""j6–mC–wej–ij6w
wm–;hj–ljCvm”j–mC–wej–jY6wR–wej–Z;mZj;wzj6–b;mCwzC8–;hj–ljCvm”j
b;m”–tc6w–6w;jjw–mC–wej–Cm;we–wm–s;j6w–j6Z"YCYvj–mC–wej–6mhweR–wej
Z;mZj;wzj6–b;mCwzC8–s;j6w–j6Z"YCYvjR–wej–Z;mZj;wzj6–b;mCwzC8–wej
ij6w–6zvj–mb–sYA–v;zlj–b;m”–s;j6w–j6Z"YCYvj–mC–wej–6mhwe–wm–tc6w
6w;jjw–mC–wej–Cm;weR–wej–Z;mZj;wzj6–b;mCwzC8–wej–jY6w–6zvj–mb–sYA
v;zlj–b;m”–tc6w–6w;jjw–mC–wej–6mhwe–wm–wej–Cm;”YCvA–iYwj;iYA–mC–wej
Cm;weR–z”Zm6zC8–Y–wj”Zm;Y;A–”m;Ywm;zh”–hZmC–wej–;jNjzZw–mb–m;
Z;mNj66zC8–mb–YZZ"zNYwzmC6-–Zj;”zw6–m;–ZjCvzC8–YZZ;mlY"6–Zj;wYzCzC8
wm–vj”m"zwzmC–mb–6w;hNwh;j6–mC–wYwh”–iYwj;iYAR–Z;mlzvzC8–bm;–YC
jbbjNwzlj–vYwj–;jw;mYNwzlj–wm–bz;6w–;jYvzC8-–bjs;hY;A–G-–f.ctR–bm;
PmCzC8–zC–Z;m8;j66–Zh;Zm6j6-–wez6–m;vzCYCNj–6eY""–sj–jbbjNwzlj–hZmC
bz;6w–;jYvzC8–mb–wez6–m;vzCYCNj-–YCv–Cm–YZZ"zNYwzmC6–bm;–vj”m"zwzmC
izwezC–wej–vj6z8CYwjv–Y;jY–6eY""–sj–YNNjZwjv–sA–wej–NzwAR–Z;mlzvzC8
bm;–jyNjZwzmC6R–Z;mlzvzC8–bm;–6jlj;Ysz"zwAR–;jZjY"–mb–NmCb"zNwzC8
m;vzCYCNj–Z;mlz6zmC6R–YCv–Z;mlzvzC8–bm;–YC–jyZz;YwzmC–vYwj0
–
1F8vKwtUtKdQA6RSKnQfS4RjKqDEO4AKLQf"4RjZV“&&W&5
bW'B7–;H“/W&5–Ze–Q&–:3&H–t-–f.ct–,–;g–sNQOOWBBWQ&H'–;W19X–Y''WQV“
;gNY;w–vjNmd”z”m–Nm””j;NzY"–NeY;YNwj;–YCv–bm;”h"Y–Nm””j;NzY"
mlj;"YA–vz6w;zNwJ
YC–m;vzCYCNj–mb–wej–”YAm;–YCv–NzwA–Nm””z66zmC–mb–wej–NzwA–mb–”zY”z
sjYNe-–b"m;zvY-–Y”jCvzC8–NeYZwj;–ccK–mb–wej–NzwA–Nmvj-–jCwzw"jv
a8jCj;Y"–Z;mlz6zmC6-M–wm–Z;mlzvj–bm;–vjbzCzwzmC6–bm;–aNejN4–NY6ezC8
6wm;j-M–aNmCljCzjCNj–6wm;j-M–abm;”h"Y–;j6wYh;YCw-M–abm;”h"Y
Nm””j;NzY"–j6wYs"z6e”jCw6-M–a”Y;z:hYCY–vz6ZjC6Y;A-M–aNYCCYsz6
vz6ZjC6Y;A-M–amNNh"w–6NzjCNj–j6wYs"z6e”jCw-M–aZeY;”YNA-M–a6mhljCz;–YCv
w,6ez;w–6emZ-M–awYwwmm–6whvzm-M–a”Y66Y8j–wej;YZA–NjCwj;-M–YCv–;j"Ywjv
vjbzCzwzmC6R–Y”jCvzC8–NeYZwj;–cKf–mb–wej–NzwA–Nmvj-–jCwzw"jv–aPmCzC8
vz6w;zNw6–YCv–;j8h"YwzmC6-M–Yw–Y;wzN"j–zzz-–jCwzw"jv–Lmlj;"YA–vz6w;zNw6-L
wm–j6wYs"z6e–vzlz6zmC–cf-–jCwzw"jv–aY;w–vjNm–d–”z”m–Nm””j;NzY"
NeY;YNwj;–mlj;"YA–vz6w;zNw-M–wm–Z;mlzvj–YvvzwzmCY"–;j8h"YwzmC6–bm;
wej–Ybm;j”jCwzmCjv–h6j6-–zCN"hvzC8–vz6wYCNj–6jZY;YwzmC
;johz;j”jCw6-–"z”zwYwzmC6–mC–Ch”sj;–mb–j6wYs"z6e”jCw6-–YCv
Z;mezszwzmC6–hCvj;–Nj;wYzC–Nz;Nh”6wYCNj6R–Z;mlzvzC8–bm;–;jZjY"j;R
6jlj;Ysz"zwAR–NmvzbzNYwzmCR–YCv–YC–jbbjNwzlj–vYwj0
1F8TKwtUtKdQA6RSKnQfS4RjKqDEO4AKLQf"4Rj ZV“&&W&5
bW'B7–;H“/W&5–Ze–Q&–:3&H–t-–f.ct–,–;g–:NQOOWBBWQ&H'–;W19X–Y''WQV“
;gvim;4bm;Nj–YCv–Ybbm;vYs"j–emh6zC8–,–Nm”Z;jejC6zlj–Z"YC–Y”jCv”jCw6J
YC–m;vzCYCNj–Y”jCvzC8–wej–NzwA–mb–”zY”z–sjYNe–AjY;–f.fg
Nm”Z;jejC6zlj–Z"YC-–sA–Y”jCvzC8–NeYZwj;–c-–jCwzw"jv–Lbhwh;j–"YCv–h6j
Page 4 of 230
j"j”jCwRL–Lms:jNwzlj–cJ–"YCv–vjlj"mZ”jCw–;j8h"YwzmC6-L–wm–Y""mi–bm;
zCN;jY6jv–vjC6zwA–izwezC–Nj;wYzC–bhwh;j–"YCv–h6j–NYwj8m;zj6–bm;–wej
"z”zwjv–Zh;Zm6j6–mb–Z;mlzvzC8–Ybbm;vYs"j–emh6zC8–YCv–im;4bm;Nj
emh6zC8–Zh;Zm6j6–YCv–wm–Y""mi–bm;–;j6zvjCwzY"–h6j6–zC–wej–LZY;4zC8–(ZqL
bhwh;j–"YCv–h6j–NYwj8m;AR–Y”jCvzC8–NeYZwj;–u-–jCwzw"jv–Lemh6zC8
j"j”jCw-L–wm–Z;mlzvj–zCNjCwzlj6–bm;–vjlj"mZzC8–im;4bm;Nj–YCv
Ybbm;vYs"j–emh6zC8R–N"Y;zbA–Zm"zNzj6–;j"Ywjv–wm–im;4bm;Nj–YCv
Ybbm;vYs"j–emh6zC8R–Y”jCvzC8–NeYZwj;–S-–jCwzw"jv–LNmC6j;lYwzmCd
NmY6wY"–PmCj–”YCY8j”jCw–j"j”jCw-L–wm–Y""mi–bm;–vjC6zwA–zCN;jY6j6–zC
m;vj;–wm–zCNjCwzlzPj–im;4bm;Nj–YCv–Ybbm;vYs"j–emh6zC8
Z;m:jNw6dNmC6w;hNwzmCR–Z;mlzvzC8–bm;–zCN"h6zmC–zC–wej–Nm”Z;jejC6zlj
Z"YCR–w;YC6”zwwY"R–;jZjY"j;R–6jlj;Ysz"zwAR–YCv–YC–jbbjNwzlj–vYwj0
–1F8iKwtUtK:4"W.KnQfS4RjKqDEO4AKLQf"4Rj ZV“&&W&5
NQ&7W&3H/–2'QO–:3&H–t-–f.ct–,–;g–”NQOOWBBWQ&H'–:QU&–jVWI“FH7U–YVHO“&
;gjYbbm;vYs"j–emh6zC8–hCzw–6zPj–YCv–ZY;4zC8–;johz;j”jCw6J
YC–m;vzCYCNj–mb–wej–”YAm;–YCv–NzwA–Nm””z66zmC–mb–wej–NzwA–mb–”zY”z
sjYNe-–b"m;zvY-–Y”jCvzC8–wej–NzwAp6–"YCv–vjlj"mZ”jCw–;j8h"YwzmC6R–sA
Y”jCvzC8–NeYZwj;–gG-–aemh6zC8-M–sA–j6wYs"z6ezC8–Y;wzN"j–l-–aemh6zC8–bm;
"mi–YCvdm;–”mvj;Ywj–zCNm”j–j"vj;"A–Zj;6mC6MR–Z;mlzvzC8–NmvzbzNYwzmCR
sA–Y”jCvzC8–NeYZwj;–ccK-–a8jCj;Y"–Z;mlz6zmC6-M–Yw–6jNwzmC–ccK,c-
avjbzCzwzmC6-M–wm–j6wYs"z6e–sA–;jbj;jCNj–wm–NeYZwj;–gG-–aemh6zC8M
vjbzCzwzmC6–bm;–CmC,j"vj;"A–YCv–j"vj;"A–"mi–YCv–”mvj;Ywj–zCNm”j
emh6zC8R–sA–Y”jCvzC8–NeYZwj;–cu.-–ambb,6w;jjw–ZY;4zC8-M–Yw–6jNwzmC–cu.,
uf-–ambb,6w;jjw–ZY;4zC8–;johz;j”jCw6–bm;–ZY;4zC8–vz6w;zNw–Cm0–c-M–YCv
6jNwzmC–cu.,uu-–ambb,6w;jjw–ZY;4zC8–;johz;j”jCw6–bm;–ZY;4zC8–vz6w;zNw6
Cm60–f-–u-–K-–g-–S-–YCv–t0M–sA–Y”jCvzC8–wej–ZY;4zC8–;johz;j”jCw6–bm;–"mi
YCvdm;–”mvj;Ywj–zCNm”j–CmC,j"vj;"A–YCv–j"vj;"A–Zj;6mC6R–sA–Y”jCvzC8
NeYZwj;–cKf-–aPmCzC8–vz6w;zNw6–YCv–;j8h"YwzmC6-M–Y;wzN"j–zz-–avz6w;zNw
;j8h"YwzmC6-M–vzlz6zmC–u-–a;j6zvjCwzY"–”h"wzbY”z"A–vz6w;zNw6-M–6hsvzlz6zmC
zz-–a;”,c–;j6zvjCwzY"–”h"wzbY”z"A–"mi–zCwjC6zwA-M–6hsvzlz6zmC–zl-–a;”,f
;j6zvjCwzY"–”h"wzbY”z"A-–”jvzh”–zCwjC6zwA-M–6hsvzlz6zmC–l0–a;”,u
;j6zvjCwzY"–”h"wzbY”z"A-–ez8e–zCwjC6zwA-M–vzlz6zmC–K0–aNv,c–Nm””j;NzY"-
"mi–zCwjC6zwA–vz6w;zNw-M–vzlz6zmC–g0–aNv,f–Nm””j;NzY"-–”jvzh”–zCwjC6zwA
vz6w;zNw-M–vzlz6zmC–S0–aNv,u–Nm””j;NzY"-–ez8e–zCwjC6zwA–vz6w;zNw-M–vzlz6zmC
cu-–a”yj–”zyjv–h6j–jCwj;wYzC”jCw–vz6w;zNw-M–vzlz6zmC–cG-–aZ6–Zj;bm;”YCNj
6wYCvY;v–vz6w;zNw-M–vzlz6zmC–f.-–awN–Cm;we–sjYNe–wmiC–NjCwj;–vz6w;zNw6-M
sA–6w;z4zC8–Y""–;jbj;jCNj–wm–6jNwzmC–cKf,ccGu–jCwzw"jv–LhCzw–6zPjL–YCv
N;jYwzC8–Cji–”zCz”h”–YCv–Ylj;Y8j–YZY;w”jCw–hCzw–6zPj6–bm;–CmC,
j"vj;"A–YCv–j"vj;"A–"mi–YCv–”mvj;Ywj–zCNm”j–emh6zC8R–sA–Y”jCvzC8
Y;wzN"j–zl-–a6hZZ"j”jCwY;A–vz6w;zNw–;j8h"YwzmC6-M–sA–Y”jCvzC8–vzlz6zmC–S-
aemh6zC8–bm;–"mi–YCvdm;–”mvj;Ywj–zCNm”j–j"vj;"A–Zj;6mC6-M–sA
6w;z4zC8–wez6–vzlz6zmCR–Z;mlzvzC8–NmvzbzNYwzmCR–;jZjY"j;R–6jlj;Ysz"zwAR
YCv–YC–jbbjNwzlj–vYwj0
1F81KwtUtK:4"W.KnQfS4RjKqDEO4AKLQf"4Rj ZV“&&W&5
NQ&7W&3H/–2'QO–:3&H–t-–f.ct–,–;g–CNQOOWBBWQ&H'–:QU&–jVWI“FH7U–YVHO“&
;gbim;4bm;Nj–emh6zC8–ZY;4zC8–YCv–hCzw–6zPj–;johz;j”jCw6J–
YC–m;vzCYCNj–mb–wej–”YAm;–YCv–NzwA–Nm””z66zmC–mb–wej–NzwA–mb–”zY”z
sjYNe-–b"m;zvY-–Y”jCvzC8–6hsZY;w–Y– –8jCj;Y"–m;vzCYCNj6-–mb–wej–NzwA
Nmvj-–sA–Y”jCvzC8–NeYZwj;–gG–aemh6zC8M-–sA–N;jYwzC8–Y;wzN"j–lz-–jCwzw"jv
aim;4bm;Nj–emh6zC8RM–6jNwzmC6–gG,g..–we;mh8e–gG,gc.R–Z;mlzvzC8–bm;
vjbzCzwzmC6–YCv–zCNjCwzlj6–wm–Z;mlzvj–im;4bm;Nj–emh6zC8R–j"z8zsz"zwA
bm;–wjCYCNA-–jCbm;Nj”jCw-–YCv–ZjCY"wzj6R–sA–Y”jCvzC8–NeYZwj;–cu.-
ambb,6w;jjw–ZY;4zC8-M–Yw–6jNwzmC–cu.,uf-–ambb,6w;jjw–ZY;4zC8
Page 5 of 230
;johz;j”jCw6–bm;–ZY;4zC8–vz6w;zNw–Cm0–c-M–YCv–6jNwzmC–cu.,uu-–ambb,
6w;jjw–ZY;4zC8–;johz;j”jCw6–bm;–ZY;4zC8–vz6w;zNw6–Cm60–f-–u-–K-–g-–S-–YCv
t0M–sA–j6wYs"z6ezC8–ZY;4zC8–;johz;j”jCw6–bm;–im;4bm;Nj–emh6zC8
hCzw6R–sA–Y”jCvzC8–NeYZwj;–cKf-–aPmCzC8–vz6w;zNw6–YCv–;j8h"YwzmC6-M
Y;wzN"j–zz-–avz6w;zNw–;j8h"YwzmC6-M–vzlz6zmC–u-–a;j6zvjCwzY"–”h"wzbY”z"A
vz6w;zNw6-M–6hsvzlz6zmC–zz-–a;”,c–;j6zvjCwzY"–”h"wzbY”z"A–"mi–zCwjC6zwA-M
6hsvzlz6zmC–zl-–a;”,f–;j6zvjCwzY"–”h"wzbY”z"A-–”jvzh”–zCwjC6zwA-M
6hsvzlz6zmC–l0–a;”,u–;j6zvjCwzY"–”h"wzbY”z"A-–ez8e–zCwjC6zwA-M–vzlz6zmC–K0
aNv,c–Nm””j;NzY"-–"mi–zCwjC6zwA–vz6w;zNw-M–vzlz6zmC–g0–aNv,f–Nm””j;NzY"-
”jvzh”–zCwjC6zwA–vz6w;zNw-M–vzlz6zmC–S0–aNv,u–Nm””j;NzY"-–ez8e–zCwjC6zwA
vz6w;zNw-M–vzlz6zmC–cu-–a”yj–”zyjv–h6j–jCwj;wYzC”jCw–vz6w;zNw-M–vzlz6zmC–cG-
aZ6–Zj;bm;”YCNj–6wYCvY;v–vz6w;zNw-M–vzlz6zmC–f.-–awN–Cm;we–sjYNe–wmiC
NjCwj;–vz6w;zNw6-M–sA–N;jYwzC8–Cji–”zCz”h”–YCv–Ylj;Y8j–YZY;w”jCw–hCzw
6zPj6–bm;–im;4bm;Nj–emh6zC8–hCzw6R–Z;mlzvzC8–NmvzbzNYwzmCR–;jZjY"j;R
6jlj;Ysz"zwAR–YCv–YC–jbbjNwzlj–vYwj0
1F8oKwtUtK:4"W.KnQfS4RjKqDEO4AKLQf"4Rj ZV“&&W&5
NQ&7W&3H/–2'QO–Sdtdf.ct–,–;g–mNQOOWBBWQ&H'–:QU&–jVWI“FH7U–YVHO“&
;g8YC–m;vzCYCNj–mb–wej–”YAm;–YCv–NzwA–Nm””z66zmC–mb–wej–NzwA–mb–”zY”z
sjYNe-–b"m;zvY-–jywjCvzC8–wej–wj”Zm;Y;A–”m;Ywm;zh”–hCvj;–m;vzCYCNj
f.ct,K.tu-–we;mh8e–vjNj”sj;–uc-–f.ct-–mC–wej–YNNjZwYCNj-–;jlzji-
YZZ;mlY"-–m;–z66hYCNj–mb–YCA–"YCv–vjlj"mZ”jCw–Zj;”zw6–(Y6–wej–wj;”–z6
vjbzCjv–zC–6jNwzmC–cSu0ucSK(cSq-–b"m;zvY–6wYwhwj6q-–sh6zCj66–wYy–;jNjzZw6-
m;–YCA–mwej;–"zNjC6j–m;–Zj;”zw–bm;–wej–j6wYs"z6e”jCw–m;–mZj;YwzmC–mb
Yvh"w–NmC8;j8Ywj–"zlzC8–bYNz"zwzj6-–Y66z6wjv–"zlzC8–bYNz"zwzj6-–N;z6z6
6wYsz"zPYwzmC–hCzw6-–;j6zvjCwzY"–vjwmyzbzNYwzmC–NjCwj;6-–Nm””hCzwA
;j6zvjCwzY"–em”j6-–YCv–;j6zvjCwzY"–”jvzNY"–;jeYsz"zwYwzmC–NjCwj;6-–YCv
YCA–6z”z"Y;–m;–vj;zlYwzlj–h6j6–Y66mNzYwjv–izwe–6hNe–h6j6-–izwezC–wej
NzwA-–zC–m;vj;–wm–Z;mlzvj–wej–NzwA–izwe–YC–mZZm;whCzwA–wm–;jlzji–YCv
jCYNw–vjbzCzwzmC6–YCv–;j8h"YwzmC6–8mlj;CzC8–6Yzv–h6j6R–Z;mlzvzC8
ZjCY"wzj6–bm;–YCA–lzm"YwzmC–ej;jmbR–Z;mlzvzC8–bm;–6jlj;Ysz"zwAR
;jZjY"j;–mb–NmCb"zNwzC8–m;vzCYCNj–Z;mlz6zmC6R–YCv–Z;mlzvzC8–bm;–Y
NmCwzChjv–jbbjNwzlj–vYwj–mb–bjs;hY;A–G-–f.ct–YCv–jywjCvzC8–wej
”m;Ywm;zh”–we;mh8e–vjNj”sj;–uc-–f.ctR–bm;–PmCzC8–zC–Z;m8;j66
Zh;Zm6j6-–wez6–m;vzCYCNj–6eY""–sj–jbbjNwzlj–hZmC–bz;6w–;jYvzC8–mb–wez6
m;vzCYCNj0
1F8-KwtUtK:4"W.KnQfS4RjKqDEO4AKLQf"4RjZV“&&W&5dm22W1H–Q2–7UH–NW7X–Y77Q'&HX
NQOOWBBWQ&H'–:QU&–jVWI“FH7U–YVHO“&
;geYC–m;vzCYCNj–mb–wej–”YAm;–YCv–NzwA–Nm””z66zmC–mb–wej–NzwA–mb–”zY”z
sjYNe-–b"m;zvY-–Y”jCvzC8–NeYZwj;–cKf–mb–wej–Nmvj–mb–wej–NzwA–mb–”zY”z
sjYNe-–jCwzw"jv–aPmCzC8–vz6w;zNw6–YCv–;j8h"YwzmC6-M–Y;wzN"j–zz-–avz6w;zNw
;j8h"YwzmC6-M–vzlz6zmC–cG-–aZ6–Zj;bm;”YCNj–6wYCvY;v–vz6w;zNw-M–6jNwzmC
cKf,Sku-–aZj;”zwwjv–h6j6-M–wm–N"Y;zbA–weYw–jCwj;wYzC”jCw–z6–Cmw–Zj;”zwwjv
zC–wej–NzwAp6–Zj;bm;”YCNj–6wYCvY;v–vz6w;zNw6R–YCv–Z;mlzvzC8–bm;
;jZjY"j;-–6jlj;Ysz"zwA-–NmvzbzNYwzmC-–YCv–YC–jbbjNwzlj–vYwj0
k,3bGK3lKybKdmyG,33buK,hKdmqqHbGbh3cHY
1F80KwtUtK:4"W.KnQfS4RjKqDEO4AKLQf"4RjZV“&&W&5dm22W1H–Q2–7UH–NW7X–Y77Q'&HX
NQOOWBBWQ&H'–”W1U“HV–8'WH1Q
;gzYC–m;vzCYCNj–mb–wej–”YAm;–YCv–NzwA–Nm””z66zmC–mb–wej–NzwA–mb–”zY”z
sjYNe-–b"m;zvY-–Y”jCvzC8–”zY”z–sjYNe–NzwA–Nmvj–NeYZwj;–f-–Y;wzN"j–lzz-
vzlz6zmC–g–jCwzw"jv–LNY”ZYz8C–bzCYCNj–;jbm;”-L–sA–YvvzC8–wej;jwm
6jNwzmC–f,Kkc–jCwzw"jv–LZ;mezszwjv–"mssAzC8–sA–NY”ZYz8C–NmC6h"wYCw6-L
Z;mezszwzC8–NY”ZYz8C–NmC6h"wYCw6–YCv–Nj;wYzC–Ybbz"zYwjv–Zj;6mC6–m;
Page 6 of 230
jCwzwzj6–b;m”–"mssAzC8–NzwA–Nm””z66zmC–bm;–cf–”mCwe6–6hs6johjCw–wm
6ijY;zC8–zC–mb–6hs:jNw–j"jNwjv–mbbzNzY"(6q-–j6wYs"z6ezC8–vjbzCzwzmC6-
YCv–"z”zwjv–jyj”ZwzmCR–Z;mlzvzC8–bm;–;jZjY"j;-–6jlj;Ysz"zwA-
NmvzbzNYwzmC-–YCv–YC–jbbjNwzlj–vYwj0
1F8CKwtUtKdQA6RSKnQfS4RjKqDEO4AKLQf"4Rjm22W1H–Q2–7UH–NW7X–Y77Q'&HX
bW'B7–;H“/W&5–Q&–Sdtdf.ct–,–;g–Y:NQOOWBBWQ&H'–:QX–”“V“9Q22–n–NQ,B’Q&BQ'H/–FX
lW1H,”“XQ'–;QBH&–8Q&I“VHI
;g:YC–m;vzCYCNj–mb–wej–”YAm;–YCv–NzwA–Nm””z66zmC–mb–wej–NzwA–mb–”zY”z
sjYNe-–b"m;zvY-–Y”jCvzC8–”zY”z–sjYNe–NzwA–Nmvj–NeYZwj;–f-–Y;wzN"j–lzz-
vzlz6zmC–u–jCwzw"jv–a"mssAz6w6-M–6jNwzmC–f,KGf–wej;jmb–jCwzw"jv
a;j8z6w;YwzmCR–vz6N"m6h;j6M-–sA–NmCbm;”zC8–wez6–Nmvj–6jNwzmCp6
"mssAz6w–;j8z6w;YwzmC–;johz;j”jCw–wm–wej–Z;m6N;zZwzmC–6jw–bm;we–zC
Nmvj–6jNwzmC–f,Kkc–Z;mezszwzC8–NY”ZYz8C–NmC6h"wYCw6–YCv–Nj;wYzC
Ybbz"zYwjv–Zj;6mC6–m;–jCwzwzj6–b;m”–"mssAzC8–NzwA–Nm””z66zmC–bm;–cf
”mCwe6–6hs6johjCw–wm–6ijY;zC8–zC–mb–6hs:jNw–j"jNwjv–mbbzNzY"(6qR
Z;mlzvzC8–bm;–;jZjY"j;-–6jlj;Ysz"zwA-–NmvzbzNYwzmC-–YCv–YC–jbbjNwzlj
vYwj0
:4"W.KnQfS4Rjm22W1H–Q2–7UH–NW7X–Y77Q'&HX
NQOOWBBWQ&H'–:QX–”“V“9Q22
;g4YC–m;vzCYCNj–mb–wej–”YAm;–YCv–NzwA–Nm””z66zmC–mb–wej–NzwA–mb–”zY”z
sjYNe-–b"m;zvY-–Zj;wYzCzC8–wm–j6wYs"z6ezC8–Y–wj”Zm;Y;A–”m;Ywm;zh”
bm;–6zy–”mCwe6–b;m”–wej–jbbjNwzlj–vYwj–mb–wez6–m;vzCYCNj–mC–wej
YNNjZwYCNj-–;jlzji-–YZZ;mlY"–m;–z66hYCNj–mb–YCA–"YCv–vjlj"mZ”jCw
Zj;”zw6–Y6–wej–wj;”–z6–vjbzCjv–zC–b"m;zvY–6wYwhwj6–6jNwzmC–cSu0ucSK(cSq-
sh6zCj66–wYy–;jNjzZw6–m;–YCA–mwej;–"zNjC6j–m;–Zj;”zw–bm;–wej
j6wYs"z6e”jCw–m;–mZj;YwzmC–mb–vz6ZjC6zC8–bYNz"zwzj6–izwezC–wej–NzwA
jC8Y8jv–zC–wej–mC,6zwj–vz6w;zshwzmC-–6Y"j-–vj"zlj;A–m;–;jwYz"–mb–"mi,
weN–NYCCYsz6-–”jvzNY"–NYCCYsz6–m;–NYCCYsz6–vj"zlj;A–vjlzNj6–Zh;6hYCw
wm–6jNwzmC6–uGc0kGS–YCv–Kkk0.fkg–mb–wej–b"m;zvY–6wYwhwj6-–zC–m;vj;–wm
Z;mlzvj–wej–NzwA–izwe–YC–mZZm;whCzwA–wm–;jlzji–YCv–jCYNw–;j8h"YwzmC6
8mlj;CzC8–wej–j6wYs"z6e”jCw–YCv–mZj;YwzmC–mb–vz6ZjC6zC8–bYNz"zwzj6R
Z;mlzvzC8–ZjCY"wzj6–bm;–lzm"YwzmC–ej;jmbR–Z;mlzvzC8–bm;–6jlj;Ysz"zwAR
;jZjY"–mb–NmCb"zNwzC8–m;vzCYCNj–Z;mlz6zmC6R–YCv–Z;mlzvzC8–bm;–YC
jbbjNwzlj–vYwj–;jw;mYNwzlj–wm–:hCj–fG-–f.ctR–bm;–PmCzC8–zC–Z;m8;j66
Zh;Zm6j6-–wez6–m;vzCYCNj–6eY""–sj–jbbjNwzlj–hZmC–bz;6w–;jYvzC8–mb–wez6
m;vzCYCNj0
1F58KwtUtK:4"W.KnQfS4RjKqDEO4AKLQf"4Rjm22W1H–Q2–7UH–NW7X–Y77Q'&HX
NQOOWBBWQ&H'B–:QU&–jVWI“FH7U–YVHO“&–n–:QX
”“V“9Q22
n-K7KnQW6OD.46RW
;tYY–;j6m"hwzmC–mb–wej–”YAm;–YCv–NzwA–Nm””z66zmC–mb–wej–NzwA–mb–”zY”z
sjYNe-–b"m;zvY-–zC–YNNm;vYCNj–izwe–6jNwzmC–cG,u0c–mb–wej–”zY”z,vYvj
NmhCwA–Nmvj-–;johj6wzC8–wej–”zY”z,vYvj–NmhCwA–smY;v–mb–NmhCwA
Nm””z66zmCj;6–wm–w;YC6bj;–NmCw;m"–mb–wej–sz6NYACj–ZmzCw–6jNh;zwA
8hY;v–6ZjNzY"–wYyzC8–vz6w;zNw–b;m”–wej–NmhCwA–wm–wej–NzwA-–YCv–wm
vj6z8CYwj–wej–”YAm;–YCv–NzwA–Nm””z66zmC–Y6–wej–8mlj;CzC8–smvA–mb
wej–6ZjNzY"–wYyzC8–vz6w;zNw-–6hs:jNw–wm–Y–”Y:m;zwA–lmwj–mb–wej–ohY"zbzjv
j"jNwm;6–;j6zvzC8–zC–wej–6ZjNzY"–wYyzC8–vz6w;zNw0
m22W1H–Q2–7UH–NW7X–Y77Q'&HX
NQOOWBBWQ&H'–”W1U“HV–8'WH1Q
Page 7 of 230
nCK7KhQpKyDW4RQWWKfRSK96UU4WW46RKnQPDQW.W
;kYvz6Nh66zmC–;j8Y;vzC8–iejwej;–wm–NmCwzChj–wej–Yz;–n–6jY–6emi–bm;–wej
f.cG–”j”m;zY"–vYA–ijj4jCv–(”YA–fS-–f.cG–we;mh8e–”YA–ft-–f.cGq-–YCv–zb–6m-
iejwej;–wej–NzwA–Nm””z66zmC–6emh"v–Yhwem;zPj–wej–Yv”zCz6w;YwzmC–wm
;jCj8mwzYwj–YCv–N"Y;zbA–wj;”6–(6hNe–Y6–wem6j–;j"YwzC8–wm–NzwAp6
bzCYCNzY"–NmCw;zshwzmC–bm;–Nj;wYzC–jljCw,;j"Ywjv–jyZjC6j6q0
wQ3'WBO-–N3V73'H–“&/–j1Q&QOW1–vHDHVQ’OH&7
;ksvz6Nh66–YZZ;mlY"–mb–Y”zNh6–s;zjb–mC–sjeY"b–mb–Nzwzj6–YvlmNYwzC8–bm;
w;YC68jCvj;–zCN"h6zlj–ejY"weNY;j–bm;–ljwj;YC6–mb–wej–h060–Y;”jv
bm;Nj60
m22W1H–Q2–7UH–NW7X–Y77Q'&HX
NQOOWBBWQ&H'–”W19X–67HW&FH'5
h6.4AQW
c0Yvlj;wz6j”jCw6–bm;–wej–:hCj–fG-–f.ct–Nm””z66zmC–”jjwzC80
Page 8 of 230
:pkkvrrvpZy:pkkvbbccydrrv0ZkcZbry9y:8yyd
:766533572y6167ad2lP6
3W–
”“‘“’xkw695x)“’9x‘K9564k6’(9“v9zq69cpz)9c“44p((p“‘
-GW5–Ip44)9NP95“’xw6(B9cpz)95x‘xU6’
S731–I0‘69982B98uEA
Dg,I1c3–
G1-1GG7N93W9.N7LLJLR9,W7GS9F9.GW.WD1S9WGSJL7Lc19.1G37JLJLR93W
7cN-97LS951SJc7N9gD1DP
a1:76612ldG572
G6v6’9zq69i’“i“(6K9W’Kp‘x‘C69746‘K46‘z9z“9zq69.wx‘‘p‘U9,“x’K9v“’9C“‘(pK6’xzp“‘9x‘K9’6C“446‘Kxzp“‘P
d2dKB353
H53G7aB
W‘9-6k’0x’)92B98uEAB9xz9zq69’6h06(z9“v9c“44p((p“‘6’9I“q‘91wptxk6zq97w64x‘B9zq69cpz)9c“44p((p“‘9’6v6’’6K9zq6
pz649z“9zq69Nx‘K9g(69x‘K9S6f6w“i46‘z9c“44pzz669sJz649cmdyP99W‘9-6k’0x’)9EMB98uEAB9zq69Nx‘K9g(69x‘K
S6f6w“i46‘z9c“44pzz669Kp(C0((6K9zq69pz649x‘K9C“‘zp‘06K9pz9z“95x’Cq92B98uEAP99W‘95x’Cq92B98uEAB9zq69Nx‘K9g(6
x‘K9S6f6w“i46‘z9c“44pzz669Kp(C0((6K9zq69pz649x‘K9C“‘zp‘06K9pz9z“9zq697i’pw9E B98uEA9466zp‘UP99
9
W‘97i’pw98eB98uEAB9zq69cpz)9c“44p((p“‘9’6v6’’6K9zq69pz649z“9zq69”6xwzq97Kfp(“’)9c“44pzz669v“’9Kp(C0((p“‘9x‘K
’6C“446‘Kxzp“‘9sJz649cm1yP9W‘95x)9EMB98uEAB9zq69”6xwzq97Kfp(“’)9c“44pzz669Kp(C0((6K9zq69pz649x‘K
’6C“446‘K6K9zqxz9pz9qxf69x9l“’b(q“i9z“9’6fp6l9zq69i’“i“(xw9p‘9v0’zq6’9K6zxpw9i’p“’9z“94xbp‘U9x9’6C“446‘Kxzp“‘P993q6
”7c9qx(9(Cq6K0w6K9x9v“ww“l90i9l“’b(q“i9466zp‘U9v“’9I0‘69E B98uEAP
9
W‘97i’pw9E B98uEA9zq69Nx‘K9g(69c“44pzz669Kp(C0((6K9zq69pz649x‘K9C“‘zp‘06K9pz9z“95x)9EAB98uEAP9W‘95x)9EAB98uEA
x‘K90iKxz69lx(9i’“fpK6K9z“9zq69Nx‘K9g(69c“44pzz669x‘K9zq69pz649lx(9C“‘zp‘06K9z“9zq69I0‘69EmB98uEA9466zp‘UP
9
W‘9I0‘69EmB98uEAB9zq69Nx‘K9g(69c“44pzz669’6C“446‘K6K9zqxz9zq69cpz)9c“44p((p“‘9’6v6’9zq69K’xvz9W’Kp‘x‘C69z“
zq69.wx‘‘p‘U9,“x’KP993q69c“44pzz669xw(“9C“‘zp‘06K9Kp(C0((p“‘9“‘9zq69pz649z“9zq69I0w)9MB98uEA9Nx‘K9g(69c“44pzz66
466zp‘UP
9
Yd:LTa7P2l
3q69cpz)9c“44p((p“‘9qx(9xii’“f6K9x9z64i“’x’)94“’xz“’p049“‘9zq69p((0x‘C69“v9x‘)9wx‘K9K6f6w“i46‘z9i6’4pz(B
k0(p‘6((9zxa9’6C6piz(9“’9x‘)9“zq6’9wpC6‘(69“’9i6’4pz9v“’9zq696(zxkwp(q46‘z9“’9“i6’xzp“‘9“v9xK0wz9C“‘U’6Uxz69wpfp‘U
vxCpwpzp6(9s7cN-yP99J‘9xKKpzp“‘9z“97cN-r(B9zq69i’“i“(6K94“’xz“’p049l“0wK9xiiw)9z“9x((p(z6K9wpfp‘U9vxCpwpzp6(B9C’p(p(
(zxkpwptxzp“‘90‘pz(B9’6(pK6‘zpxw9K6z“apvpCxzp“‘9C6‘z6’(B9C“440‘pz)9’6(pK6‘zpxw9q“46(B9x‘K9’6(pK6‘zpxw946KpCxw
’6qxkpwpzxzp“‘9C6‘z6’(B9x‘K9x‘)9(p4pwx’9“’9K6’pfxzpf690(6(9x((“Cpxz6K9lpzq9(0Cq90(6(P9
9
c0’’6‘zw)B9zq69cpz)9c“K69p(9p‘9‘66K9“v90iKxzp‘U9K6vp‘pzp“‘(9x‘K9’6U0wxzp“‘(9v“’9C’p(p(9(zxkpwptxzp“‘90‘pz(B9’6(pK6‘zpxw
K6z“apvpCxzp“‘9C6‘z6’(B9C“440‘pz)9’6(pK6‘zpxw9q“46(B9x‘K9’6(pK6‘zpxw946KpCxw9’6qxkpwpzxzp“‘9C6‘z6’(P997KKpzp“‘xww)B9zq6
z6’49xK0wz9C“‘U’6Uxz69wpfp‘U9vxCpwpz)9s7cN-y9qx(9k6C“469“k(“w6z69x‘KB9x(9C0’’6‘zw)9K6vp‘6K9p‘9zq69cpz)9c“K6B9‘66K(
z“9k690iKxz6K9z“9C“‘v“’49z“9(zxz69wxlP99J‘9xKKpzp“‘9z“9’6iwxCp‘U9zq69“k(“w6z69z6’49n7cN-r9lpzq9ox((p(z6K9wpfp‘U9vxCpwpz)BH
zq69cpz)9c“K69‘66K(9z“9k69’6fp(6K9z“9p‘Cw0K69i’“i6’9wpC6‘(0’69’6h0p’646‘z(9x‘K9z“9C“4iw)9lpzq9(zxz69wxl
Page 9 of 230
’6h0p’646‘z(P
9
UKd2252Tyd2dKB353
J‘pzpxw9’6(6x’Cq9“‘9(zxz69(zxz0z6(9x‘K9fx’p“0(940‘pCpixw9C“K6(9’6wxz6K9z“946KpCxw90(6(9qx(9k66‘9K“‘6P993q69cpz)9“v
.“4ix‘“9,6xCq9qx(9k66‘9v“0‘K9z“9qxf69f6’)9K6zxpw6K9’6h0p’646‘z(9v“’9(0Cq90(6(9p‘9zq6p’9wx‘K9K6f6w“i46‘z
’6U0wxzp“‘(P9
9
Dzxvv9qx(90‘K6’zxb6‘9x9’6fp6l9“v946KpCxw90(6(9lpzqp‘9zq69cpz)P993q69’6fp6l9p(90zpwptp‘U9k0(p‘6((9zxa9’6C6piz9s,3Gy
p‘v“’4xzp“‘B9xw“‘U9lpzq9p‘v“’4xzp“‘9v’“49fx’p“0(9Dzxz69xU6‘Cp6(9zqxz9x’69’6(i“‘(pkw69v“’9zq69’6U0wxzp“‘9“v946KpCxw
0(6(P993q69cpz)9C0’’6‘zw)9qx(98M9,3G9Cwx((pvpCxzp“‘(9v“’946KpCxw90(6(P99D“46946KpCxw90(6(9qxf69k66‘9pK6‘zpvp6K
lq6’69pz94x)9k69k6‘6vpCpxw9z“96(zxkwp(q9‘6l9Cwx((pvpCxzp“‘(9p‘9“’K6’9z“9k6zz6’9xCC“0‘z9v“’9zq69fx’p6z)9“v946KpCxw90(6(
x‘K9p4ixCz(P
9
Jz9p(9zq69p‘z6‘z9“v9zq69“’Kp‘x‘C69z“90zpwpt69z6’4(9zqxz9x’69C“‘(p(z6‘z9lpzq9zq69wpC6‘(6(9p((06K9k)9Dzxz69xU6‘Cp6(B9p‘Cw0Kp‘U
zq69-w“’pKx97U6‘C)9v“’9”6xwzqCx’697K4p‘p(z’xzp“‘9s7”c7yB9-w“’pKx9S6ix’z46‘z9“v9”6xwzqB9x‘K9zq69-w“’pKx
S6ix’z46‘z9“v9cqpwK’6‘9x‘K9-x4pwp6(P993qp(9lpww96‘(0’69z’x‘(ix’6‘C)9v“’9zq69t“‘p‘U9’6h0p’646‘z(9v“’946KpCxw90(6(P
9
79(0pzxkpwpz)9x‘xw)(p(9p(9xw(“9C0’’6‘zw)9k6p‘U90‘K6’zxb6‘9v“’9fx’p“0(946KpCxw90(6(P99-“’9zq69i0’i“(6(9“v9zqp(9x‘xw)(p(B
46KpCxw90(6(9qxf69k66‘9Cxz6U“’pt6K9k)9zq69p‘z6‘(pz)9“v9zq6p’9p4ixCz9x‘K9lq6zq6’9“’9‘“z9zq6)9xww“l9v“’9“f6’‘pUqz9(zx)(
“’9i6’4x‘6‘z9’6(pK6‘C6P9cwx((6(9“‘69sEy9z“9v“0’9smy9l“0wK9‘“z9xww“l9v“’9“f6’‘pUqz9(zx)(B9lqpw69Cwx((6(9vpf69sMy9z“9z6‘
sEuy9l“0wK9xww“l9v“’9“f6’‘pUqz9(zx)(9“’9i6’4x‘6‘z9’6(pK6‘C6P99R6‘6’xww)B9xww9“v9zq690(6(9lpzqp‘9x9ix’zpC0wx’9Cwx((9l“0wK
qxf69x9(p4pwx’9p4ixCz9“‘9zq69(0’’“0‘Kp‘U9x’6x(P993q69Cwx((6(9x’69U6‘6’xww)9x(9v“ww“l(–
9
cwx((6(9“‘69sEy9z“9v“0’9smy9l“0wK9LW39xww“l9v“’9“f6’‘pUqz9(zx)(–
9
:DRrryEy:956KpCxw90(6(9zqxz9qxf69x‘9p4ixCz9(p4pwx’9z“B9x‘K9“vz6‘9p‘C“’i“’xz69’6zxpw90(6(P993q6(694x)9p‘Cw0K6
WizpCpx‘B9.qx’4xC)B95x((xU69cwp‘pCB9x‘K95x((xU693q6’xip(zP993q6(690(6(9x’69“vz6‘9(66‘9x(9x9(4xww
xCC6((“’)90(69z“9wx’U6F(Cxw69’6(pK6‘zpxw9x‘K9q“z6w90(6(9x(9l6wwP99,x(6K9“‘9x‘9p‘pzpxw9(0pzxkpwpz)9x‘xw)(p(9zq6)
C“0wK9k69xii’“i’pxz69p‘90i9z“98u9“v9zq69cpz)r(9t“‘p‘U9Kp(z’pCz(P
9
:DRrryN9:956KpCxw90(6(9zqxz9qxf69x‘9p4ixCz9(p4pwx’9z“9“vvpC6(P993q6(690(6(9x’69z)ipCxww)9w“Cxz6K9lpzqp‘9“vvpC69“’
’6zxpw9k0pwKp‘U(B9x‘K9z)ipCxww)9(Cq6K0w69xii“p‘z46‘z(9lpzq9ixzp6‘z(9K0’p‘U9(zx‘Kx’K9l“’bp‘U9q“0’(P93q6(694x)
p‘Cw0K6956KpCxw9WvvpC6B9S6‘zp(z9WvvpC6B9Sp6zpCpx‘B9S“Cz“’r(9“vvpC6B9”“46“ixzqpC9.q)(pCpx‘r(9WvvpC6B
Wiz“46z’p(zB9.xzq“w“Up(zB9.qw6k“z“4p(zB9.q)(p“zq6’xip(zB9.“Kpxz’p(zB9.()Cqpxz’p(zB9D“Cp“w“Up(zB9D“Cpxw9O“’b6’B
3q6’xip(zB97K0wz9Sx)9cx’6B9cqp’“i’xCz“’r(9“vvpC6P993q6(690(6(9z)ipCxww)9K“9‘“z9U6‘6’xz69qpUq9x4“0‘z(9“v
46KpCxw9lx(z6P99,x(6K9“‘9x‘9p‘pzpxw9(0pzxkpwpz)9x‘xw)(p(9zq6)9C“0wK9k69xii’“i’pxz69p‘90i9z“9Em9“v9zq69cpz)r(9t“‘p‘U
Kp(z’pCz(P
9
:DRrryS9:956KpCxw90(6(9lqpCq9i’“fpK6946KpCxw9Cx’69zq’“0Uq“0z96az6‘K6K9l“’bp‘U9q“0’(B9xw“‘U9lpzq9KpxU‘“(zpC
x‘K9wxk“’xz“’)9(6’fpC6(P993q6(694x)9p‘f“wf69zq69U6‘6’xzp“‘9“v9qpUq9w6f6w(9“v946KpCxw9lx(z6B9x‘K9U6‘6’xz6
qpUq6’9w6f6w(9“v9z’xvvpCP993q6(694x)9p‘Cw0K69x956KpCxw9NxkB9S6‘zxw9NxkB9SpxU‘“(zpC(9c6‘z6’B9x‘K9g’U6‘z9cx’6
c6‘z6’(P99,x(6K9“‘9x‘9p‘pzpxw9(0pzxkpwpz)9x‘xw)(p(9zq6)9C“0wK9k69xii’“i’pxz69p‘90i9z“9z6‘9sEuy9“v9zq69cpz)r(9t“‘p‘U
Kp(z’pCz(P
9
:DRrry89:956KpCxw90(6(9lqpCq9z)ipCxww)9Kp(i6‘(69iqx’4xC60zpCxw(9x(9ix’z9“v9zq6p’9z’6xz46‘z9iwx‘P993q6(694x)
p‘f“wf69v’6h06‘z9fp(pz(9v’“49ixzp6‘z(9lq“94x)9’6h0p’69(6’fpC6(9v’“49zq69vxCpwpz)9“‘9x9Kxpw)9kx(p(P993q6(694x)
p‘Cw0K69Np4pz6K956‘zxw9”6xwzq93’6xz46‘z9-xCpwpz)B9Np4pz6K9D0k(zx‘C697k0(693’6xz46‘z9-xCpwpz)B9x‘K9.xp‘
5x‘xU646‘z9cwp‘pC(P99,x(6K9“‘9x‘9p‘pzpxw9(0pzxkpwpz)9x‘xw)(p(9zq6)9C“0wK9k69xii’“i’pxz69p‘90i9z“9(6f6‘9sAy9“v9zq6
cpz)r(9t“‘p‘U9Kp(z’pCz(P
9
cwx((6(9vpf69sMy9z“9z6‘9sEuy9l“0wK9xww“l9v“’9“f6’‘pUqz9(zx)(9“’9i6’4x‘6‘z9’6(pK6‘C6–
9
Page 10 of 230
:DRrryI9:979Cxz6U“’)9p‘9lqpCq9x((p(zx‘C69p(9Upf6‘9z“9i6’4x‘6‘z9’6(pK6‘z(9lpzq9x((p(zx‘C69p‘9Kxpw)9i6’(“‘xw
xCzpfpzp6(9p‘Cw0Kp‘U9k0z9‘“z9wp4pz6K9z“B9kxzqp‘UB9K’6((p‘UB96xzp‘UB9U’““4p‘UB9x‘K9Kp(i6‘(p‘U9“v946KpCp‘6P99D0Cq9x
vxCpwpz)9lpww9z)ipCxww)9qxf69(pa9sey9“’9v6l6’9’6(pK6‘z(P993qp(9p‘Cw0K6(9c“440‘pz)9G6(pK6‘zpxw9”“46(P99,x(6K9“‘
x‘9p‘pzpxw9(0pzxkpwpz)9x‘xw)(p(9zq6)9C“0wK9k69xii’“i’pxz69p‘90i9z“98M9“v9zq69cpz)r(9t“‘p‘U9Kp(z’pCz(P
9
:DRrryM9:979Cxz6U“’)9p‘9lqpCq9x((p(zx‘C69p(9Upf6‘9z“9i6’4x‘6‘z9’6(pK6‘z(9lpzq9x((p(zx‘C69p‘9Kxpw)9i6’(“‘xw
xCzpfpzp6(9p‘Cw0Kp‘U9k0z9‘“z9wp4pz6K9z“B9kxzqp‘UB9K’6((p‘UB96xzp‘UB9U’““4p‘UB9x‘K9Kp(i6‘(p‘U9“v946KpCp‘6P99D0Cq9x
vxCpwpz)9lpww9z)ipCxww)9qxf69Ee9“’9v6l6’9’6(pK6‘z(P993qp(9p‘Cw0K6(9(4xww6’97((p(z6K9Npfp‘U9-xCpwpzp6(9s7N-r(yP
,x(6K9“‘9x‘9p‘pzpxw9(0pzxkpwpz)9x‘xw)(p(9zq6)9C“0wK9k69xii’“i’pxz69p‘90i9z“98T9“v9zq69cpz)r(9t“‘p‘U9Kp(z’pCz(P
9
:DRrryO9:979Cxz6U“’)9p‘9lqpCq9x((p(zx‘C69p(9Upf6‘9z“9i6’4x‘6‘z9’6(pK6‘z(9lpzq9x((p(zx‘C69p‘9Kxpw)9i6’(“‘xw
xCzpfpzp6(9p‘Cw0Kp‘U9k0z9‘“z9wp4pz6K9z“B9kxzqp‘UB9K’6((p‘UB96xzp‘UB9U’““4p‘UB9x‘K9Kp(i6‘(p‘U9“v946KpCp‘6P99D0Cq9x
vxCpwpz)9lpww9z)ipCxww)9qxf694“’69zqx‘9Ee9’6(pK6‘z(P993qp(9p‘Cw0K6(9wx’U6’97N-r(9x‘K9‘0’(p‘U9q“469vxCpwpz)P99,x(6K
“‘9x‘9p‘pzpxw9(0pzxkpwpz)9x‘xw)(p(9zq6)9C“0wK9k69xii’“i’pxz69p‘90i9z“9E29“v9zq69cpz)r(9t“‘p‘U9Kp(z’pCz(P
9
:DRrry49:97946KpCxw90(6(9zqxz9i’“fpK698mFq“0’946KpCxw9(0i6’fp(p“‘9x‘K94x)9p4iw646‘z946KpCxzp“‘
4x‘xU646‘z9x‘K9“zq6’946KpCxw9Cx’69v“’9pz(9ixzp6‘z(P99”“l6f6’B9zq69ixzp6‘z(9lq“9K“9‘“z9‘6C6((x’pw)9i“(69x
iq)(pCxw9Kx‘U6’9z“9zq64(6wf6(9“’9“zq6’(P993q6)9x’69z)ipCxww)9“v9x‘9p‘(zpz0zp“‘xw9‘xz0’6B9zq“0Uq9zq6)94x)9C“‘zxp‘
x46‘pzp6(9z“9p4i’“f69zq69h0xwpz)9“v9wpv69“v9ixzp6‘z(P993qp(94x)9p‘Cw0K69G6(pK6‘zpxw93’6xz46‘z9-xCpwpz)P9,x(6K9“‘
x‘9p‘pzpxw9(0pzxkpwpz)9x‘xw)(p(9zq6)9C“0wK9k69xii’“i’pxz69p‘90i9z“9v“0’9smy9t“‘p‘U9Kp(z’pCz(P
9
:DRrry-9:97946KpCxw90(6(9zqxz9i’“fpK698mFq“0’946KpCxw9(0i6’fp(p“‘9x‘K94x)9p4iw646‘z946KpCxzp“‘
4x‘xU646‘z9v“’9pz(9’6(pK6‘z(P99”“l6f6’B9zq6)9z’6xz9ixzp6‘z(9lq“94x)9i“(69x9iq)(pCxw9Kx‘U6’9z“9zq64(6wf6(9“’
“zq6’(9x‘K9(6C0’pz)9p(9’6h0p’6KP993q6)9x’69z)ipCxww)9“v9x‘9p‘(zpz0zp“‘xw9‘xz0’6B9zq“0Uq9zq6)94x)9C“‘zxp‘9x46‘pzp6(
z“9p4i’“f69zq69h0xwpz)9“v9wpv69“v9ixzp6‘z(P993qp(94x)9p‘Cw0K69x9Di6Cpxwz)9”“(ipzxwB9.()Cqpxz’pC93’6xz46‘z9-xCpwpz)B
x‘K9D0k(zx‘C697k0(693’6xz46‘z9-xCpwpzp6(P99,x(6K9“‘9x‘9p‘pzpxw9(0pzxkpwpz)9x‘xw)(p(9zq6)9C“0wK9k69xii’“i’pxz69p‘
0i9z“9zq’669sTy9t“‘p‘U9Kp(z’pCz(P
9
:DRrryEgy:97946KpCxw90(69zqxz9z’6xz(9x9v0ww9’x‘U69“v946KpCxw9’6wxz6K9p((06(P993qp(9p(9zq694“(z9p‘z6‘(6946KpCxw
0(6P99D0Cq9x9vxCpwpz)9p‘Cw0K6(9x9”“(ipzxwP999,x(6K9“‘9x‘9p‘pzpxw9(0pzxkpwpz)9x‘xw)(p(9zq6)9C“0wK9k69xii’“i’pxz69p‘
“‘69sEy9t“‘p‘U9Kp(z’pCzP
9
79’6fp6l9“v9zq69xCzpf69x‘K9xiiwp6K9v“’946KpCxw90(69,3Gr(9p‘KpCxz6(9zqxz9zq69cpz)9“‘w)9qx(9cwx((9EB98B9TB9eB9AB
x‘K9Eu9vxCpwpzp6(P993q69v“ww“lp‘U9zxkw69p‘KpCxz6(9zq69‘04k6’9“v9vxCpwpzp6(9lpzqp‘96xCq9Cwx((B9x‘K9zq69t“‘p‘U
Kp(z’pCz(9p‘9lqpCq9zq6)9x’69w“Cxz6KP99794xi9pK6‘zpv)p‘U9zq69w“Cxzp“‘(9p(9p‘Cw0K6K9xz9zq696‘K9“v9zqp(9464“’x‘K04P
9
6cAveRDyPrcy:DRrryKpeRbvpZyt ynpZvZ0ylvrbsveb
y
Page 11 of 230
9
93q69K’xvz9“’Kp‘x‘C69C“‘zxp‘(9p‘pzpxw9i’“i“(xw(9v“’9zq69v“ww“lp‘U–
9
EP93q69t“‘p‘U9Kp(z’pCz(9v“’9lqpCq9zq69Kpvv6’6‘z9Cwx((6(9“v90(6(9(q“0wK9k69i6’4pzz6KP
9
999998P9OqpCq90(6(9(q“0wK9k69z’6xz6K9x(9x94xp‘9i6’4pzz6K90(69“’9’6h0p’69c“‘Kpzp“‘xw9g(69xii’“fxw999999999999999v’“49zq6
.wx‘‘p‘U9,“x’K9lpzqp‘9zq69fx’p“0(9t“‘p‘U9Kp(z’pCz(P9
9
9999TP9Sp(zx‘C69(6ix’xzp“‘9’6h0p’646‘z(9k6zl66‘9x‘K9lpzqp‘9C6’zxp‘9Cwx((6(9“v9vxCpwpzp6(9(“9x(9z“9‘“z9999999999C’6xz6
6aC6((pf69p4ixCz(9“‘9x‘)9ix’zpC0wx’9‘6pUqk“’q““KP9
9
3q697K4p‘p(z’xzp“‘9qx(9’6zxp‘6K9x946KpCxw90(69C“‘(0wzx‘zB9J‘‘“fx9R’“0iB9z“9’6fp6l9zq69K’xvz9“’Kp‘x‘C69z“96‘(0’69zqxz
zq69K6vp‘pzp“‘(9x‘K9p4ixCz(9“v9zq690(6(9x’69xCC0’xz6w)9’6vw6Cz6KP
9
:72:KP3572
.0’(0x‘z9z“9zq69’6C“446‘Kxzp“‘9“v9zq69Nx‘K9g(69x‘K9S6f6w“i46‘z9c“44pzz66B9zq697K4p‘p(z’xzp“‘
’6C“446‘K(9zqxz9zq695x)“’9x‘K9zq69cpz)9c“44p((p“‘9’6v6’9zq69xzzxCq6K9K’xvz9“’Kp‘x‘C69z“9zq6
.wx‘‘p‘U9,“x’KP9
Kc0vrDRbvicyGsRemvZ0
.wx‘‘p‘U
3opZrps
c“44p((p“‘6’9I“q‘91wptxk6zq97w64x‘
dGGd:H612G3C
lcresvobvpZ
S’xvz9G6v6’’xw9W’Kpx‘C6
Page 12 of 230
DRAFT - ASSISTED LIVING AND MEDICAL USES MAY 4, 2017
Page 1 of 17
DRAFT ORDINANCE
CHAPTER 142
ZONING DISTRICTS AND REGULATIONS
ARTICLE V
SPECIALIZED USE REGULATIONS
DIVISION 2
ASSISTED LIVING AND MEDICAL USES
Sec. 142-1252. – Definitions.
Addictions Receiving Facility means a secure, acute-care, residential facility operated 24 hours-
per-day, 7 days-per-week, designated by the department of children and families to serve
persons found to be substance abuse impaired as described in Section 397.675, F.S.
Adult Day Care Center means a facility that provides programs and services for adults who
need a protective setting during the day. An adult day care center can be a freestanding
program or services can be offered through a nursing home, assisted living facility, or hospital.
The basic services include, but are not limited to: social activities, self-care training, nutritional
meals, a place to rest, and respite care. Adult day care centers are licensed and surveyed by
the State of Florida.
Adult Family Care Home means a dwelling unit that provides full-time, family-type living in a
private home for up to five elderly persons or adults with a disability, who are not related to the
owner. The owner lives in the same house as the residents. The basic services include, but are
not limited to: housing and nutritional meals; help with the activities of daily living, like bathing,
dressing, eating, walking, physical transfer, giving medications or helping residents give
themselves medications; supervision of residents; arrange for health care services; provide or
arrange for transportation to health care services; health monitoring; and social activities. Adult
family care homes are licensed and surveyed by the State of Florida.
Ambulatory Surgical Center (ASC) means a facility that is not part of a hospital and provides
elective surgical care where the patient is admitted to and discharged from the facility within the
same working day. The patient does not stay overnight. Hospitals can have outpatient surgical
units, but these units would be a part of the hospital license and would not require a separate
ASC license. Ambulatory surgical centers are licensed and surveyed by the State of Florida.
Assisted Living Facility (Up to 16 Beds) means a facility that provides full-time living
arrangements in the least restrictive and most home-like setting for up to 16 residents. The
basic services include, but are not limited to: housing and nutritional meals; help with the
activities of daily living, like bathing, dressing, eating, walking, physical transfer, giving
medications or helping residents give themselves medications; arrange for health care services;
provide or arrange for transportation to health care services; health monitoring; respite care; and
social activities. Assisted living facilities are licensed and surveyed by the State of Florida.
These facilities are intended for residency of six (6) months and a day or more.
Page 13 of 230
DRAFT - ASSISTED LIVING AND MEDICAL USES MAY 4, 2017
Page 2 of 17
Assisted Living Facility (Over 16 Beds) means a facility that provides full-time living
arrangements in the least restrictive and most home-like setting for over 16 residents. The basic
services include, but are not limited to: housing and nutritional meals; help with the activities of
daily living, like bathing, dressing, eating, walking, physical transfer, giving medications or
helping residents give themselves medications; arrange for health care services; provide or
arrange for transportation to health care services; health monitoring; respite care; and social
activities. Assisted living facilities are licensed and surveyed by the State of Florida. These
facilities are intended for residency of six (6) months and a day or more.
Beds means one resident or patient, as applicable.
Birth Center means a facility in which births are planned to occur away from the mother's place
of residence following a normal, uncomplicated, low-risk pregnancy. It is not an ambulatory
surgery center, a hospital, or located within a hospital. Birth centers are licensed and surveyed
by the State of Florida.
Brain and Spinal Cord Injury. (See Transitional Living Facility.)
Chiropractor's Office. (See Medical Office.)
Clinical Laboratory means a laboratory that performs one or more of the following services to
provide information or materials for use in the diagnosis, prevention, or treatment of a disease
or the identification or assessment of a medical or physical condition. Services include
examination of fluids, tissue, cells, or other materials taken from the human body.
Community mental health partial hospital program means a Medicare certification program for
community mental health providers that provide services for mental illness and substance abuse
disorders. Unless the program meets the requirement to be a licensed health care clinic, a
licensed substance abuse program, or a licensed outpatient mental health program, there is no
state license requirement for partial hospitalization programs for community mental health
providers. For further information see the health care clinic definition (in this document) or
contact the Department of Children and Families concerning substance abuse services and
outpatient mental health services.
Community Residential Home (6 or fewer residents) means a dwelling unit licensed to serve
residents who are clients of the Department of Elderly Affairs, the Agency for Persons with
Disabilities, the Department of Juvenile Justice, or the Department of Children and Families or
licensed by the Agency for Health Care Administration which provides a living environment for
six (6) or fewer unrelated residents who operate as the functional equivalent of a family,
including such supervision and care by supportive staff as may be necessary to meet the
physical, emotional, and social needs of the residents, as defined by Section 419.001 Florida
Statutes. These facilities are intended for residency of six (6) months and a day or more.
Community Residential Home (7 to 14 residents) means a dwelling unit licensed to serve
residents who are clients of the Department of Elderly Affairs, the Agency for Persons with
Disabilities, the Department of Juvenile Justice, or the Department of Children and Families or
licensed by the Agency for Health Care Administration which provides a living environment for 7
to 14 unrelated residents who operate as the functional equivalent of a family, including such
supervision and care by supportive staff as may be necessary to meet the physical, emotional,
and social needs of the residents, as defined by Section 419.001 Florida Statutes. These
facilities are intended for residency of six (6) months and a day or more.
Page 14 of 230
DRAFT - ASSISTED LIVING AND MEDICAL USES MAY 4, 2017
Page 3 of 17
Comprehensive Outpatient Rehabilitation Facility means a non-residential facility that provides
diagnostic, therapeutic, and restorative services for the rehabilitation of injured, disabled, or sick
persons, by or under the supervision of a physician.
Crisis Stabilization Unit means a facility where the purpose is to examine, stabilize, and redirect
people to the most appropriate and least restrictive treatment settings for their psychiatric
needs. Crisis stabilization units include:
Crisis stabilization units (adult and children) provide brief psychiatric intervention, primarily
for low-income individuals with acute psychiatric conditions. Inpatient stays average 3 to 14
days, resulting in return to the patient's own home or placement in a long-term mental health
facility or other living arrangements. Intervention means activities and strategies that are
used to prevent or impede the development or progression of substance abuse problems.
Short-term residential treatment facilities provide a step-down service for adult residents
(ages 18 and over) of crisis stabilization units needing a more extended, but less intensive
level of active treatment for psychiatric conditions, usually with a stay of 90 days or less.
Both of these facility types are licensed by the State of Florida.
Day/Night Treatment means treatment provided on a nonresidential basis at least three (3)
hours per day and at least 12 hours each week and is intended for clients who meet the
placement criteria for this component.
Day/Night Treatment with Community Housing means treatment that is provided on a
nonresidential basis at least five (5) hours each day and at least 25 hours each week and is
intended for clients who can benefit from living independently in peer community housing while
undergoing treatment.
Day/Night Treatment with Host Home means treatment that is provided on a nonresidential
basis at least three hours per day and at least 12 hours each week and is intended for clients
who meet the placement criteria for this level of care. This component also requires that each
client reside with a host family as part of the treatment protocol.
Dental Laboratories means
Dentist’s Office (See Medical Office.)
Detoxification means is a process involving sub-acute care that is provided on a residential or
an outpatient basis to assist clients who meet the placement criteria for this component to
withdraw from the physiological and psychological effects of substance abuse.
Dietician. (See Medical Office.)
Doctor's Office. means (See Medical Office.)
Electrology Facility means a facility where electrologists are allowed to perform laser and light-
based hair removal.
Page 15 of 230
DRAFT - ASSISTED LIVING AND MEDICAL USES MAY 4, 2017
Page 4 of 17
End-Stage Renal Disease Center means is a facility programs that that offer dialysis services.
When patients are diagnosed with End-Stage Renal Disease, they may receive dialysis which
replaces kidney function by filtering blood to remove waste and extra fluids. The program can
either be a freestanding facility or offered as an outpatient service through a hospital.
Forensic Toxicology Laboratory means a laboratory that examines specimens taken from the
human body to look for the presence or absence of alcohol and certain drugs or their
metabolites. The results of forensic toxicology testing are not used for clinical treatment, medical
diagnosis, health assessment or disease prevention.
Health Care Clinic means a facility that provides health care services to individuals for a fee.
Such facilities do not allow for overnight stays. Health care clinics are licensed and surveyed by
the State of Florida.
Health Care Clinic Exemption means businesses that have gotten an exemption to the health
care clinic license requirement. However, businesses that meet the exemption criteria are not
required to have an official exemption, so there may be clinics that are exempt that are not listed
here. The exemption criteria are listed in section 400.9905(4), Florida Statutes.
Health Care Services Pool means a health care services pool provides temporary employment
of licensed, certified, or trained health care personnel to health care facilities, residential
facilities, and agencies. Health care services pools are registered by the State of Florida.
Home Health Agency means an agency that provides services to patients in private homes,
assisted living facilities, and adult family care homes. Some of the services include nursing care;
physical, occupational, respiratory, and speech therapy; home health aides; homemaker and
companions; and medical equipment and supplies. Along with services in the home, an agency
can also provide staffing services in nursing homes and hospitals. Home health agencies are
licensed and surveyed by the State of Florida.
Home Medical Equipment Provider means a service that sells or rents medical equipment and
services for use in the home. Home medical equipment includes any product as defined by the
Federal Drug Administration's Drugs, Devices and Cosmetics Act; any products reimbursed
under the Medicare Part B Durable Medical Equipment benefits; or any products reimbursed
under the Florida Medicaid durable medical equipment program. Service includes managing the
equipment and teaching consumers in its use. Home medical equipment providers are licensed
and surveyed by the State of Florida.
Homemaker and Companion Services means a company that provides housekeeping, prepare
and serve meals, help with shopping, routine household chores, companionship in the client's
home, and can take the client to appointments and other outings. By law, homemakers and
companions may not provide hands-on personal care, such as help with bathing, and cannot
give medications. Homemaker and companion agencies are registered by the State of Florida.
However, individuals who work on their own, with no other workers helping them are not
required to be registered.
Homeopathic Physician's Office. (See Medical Office.)
Homes for Special Services means a residential facility where specialized health care services
are provided, including personal and custodial care, but not full-time nursing services. Home for
special services are licensed by the State of Florida.
Page 16 of 230
DRAFT - ASSISTED LIVING AND MEDICAL USES MAY 4, 2017
Page 5 of 17
Home Hospice Service means services provided in a patient's residence for patients with a
diagnosis of a terminal illness. They provide a coordinated program of professional services,
including pain management and counseling for patients; nursing, physician, therapy, and social
work services; counseling and support for family members and friends of the patient; and other
support services. Hospices are licensed and surveyed by the State of Florida.
Hospice Facility means a facility that provides services in a facility for patients with a diagnosis
of a terminal illness. They provide a coordinated program of professional services, including
pain management and counseling for patients; nursing, physician, therapy, and social work
services; counseling and support for family members and friends of the patient; and other
support services. Hospices are licensed and surveyed by the State of Florida.
Hospital means a facility that provides range of health care services more extensive than those
required for room, board, personal services, and general nursing care, and offers facilities and
beds for use beyond 24 hours by individuals requiring medical, surgical, psychiatric, testing, and
diagnostic services; and treatment for illness, injury, disease, pregnancy, etc. Also available are
laboratory and X-ray services, and treatment facilities for surgery or obstetrical care, or special
services like burn treatment centers. Hospitals are licensed and surveyed by the State of
Florida. Hospitals include any medical sub-use identified within this Division.
Intensive Inpatient Treatment means includes a planned regimen of evaluation, observation,
medical monitoring, and clinical protocols delivered through an interdisciplinary team approach
provided 24 hours-per-day, 7 days per week in a highly structured, live-in environment.
Intensive Outpatient Treatment means a facility that provides services on a nonresidential basis
and is intended for clients who meet the placement criteria for this component. This component
provides structured services each day that may include ancillary psychiatric and medical
services.
Intermediate Care facility for the Developmentally Disabled means a residential facility that
provides services by an interdisciplinary team to increase a client's independence and prevent
loss of abilities. They are licensed and surveyed by the State of Florida.
Medical Cannabis Dispensary (See Chapter 142, Division 10 and Chapter 6, Division 3)
Medical Lab means a laboratory where tests are usually done on clinical specimens in
order to obtain information about the health of a patient as pertaining to the diagnosis,
treatment, and prevention of disease.
Medical Office means a small-scale office providing medical or dental treatment. This includes
chiropractor’s office, dentist’s office, dietician, doctor’s office, homeopathic physician’s office,
pathologist, physiotherapist’s office, phlebotomist’s office, podiatrist’s office, optometrist’s office,
ophthalmologist’s office, psychiatrist’s office. A small-scale office shall mean a maximum floor
area of 5,000 square feet. This shall not include Class III to X medical sub-uses.
Medication and Methadone Maintenance Treatment Facility means a facility that provides
outpatient treatment on a nonresidential basis which utilizes methadone or other approved
medication in combination with clinical services to treat persons who are dependent upon opioid
drugs.
Page 17 of 230
DRAFT - ASSISTED LIVING AND MEDICAL USES MAY 4, 2017
Page 6 of 17
Multiphasic Health Test Center means a facility that collect specimens from the human body for
testing at a licensed clinical laboratory and provide certain health testing services such as
height, weight and blood pressure measurements, limited audio and visual testing, X-rays or
electrocardiograms. A multiphasic health testing center may serve the general public or
contracted employers at either a fixed location or a mobile facility. Multiphasic health test
centers are licensed and surveyed by the State of Florida.
Nursing Home means a facility that provides nursing, personal, custodial, and rehabilitative
care. Nursing homes, sometimes called skilled nursing facilities, are freestanding, which means
they are not part of a hospital. They provide long-term care of the chronically ill, the physically
disabled, and the aged who are unable to move about without the aid of another person or
device. Nursing homes are licensed and surveyed by the State of Florida.
Optical Establishment means the retail sale of glasses and contact lenses.
Optician means a professional that provides eye exams for the purposes of the retail sale of
glasses or contact lenses.
Optometrist’s office. (See Medical Office.)
Organ and Tissue Procurement Facility means one of three types of organ and tissue
procurement organizations: Organ Procurement Organizations (OPOs), Eye Banks and Tissue
Banks. OPOs must also be federally designated by the Secretary of the United States
Department of Health and Human Services and are responsible for using the national United
Network of Organ Sharing’s (UNOS) registry to medically and physically match organs, such as
the heart, lungs, kidneys, or liver, from a patient who has died with an individual awaiting a life-
saving transplant. An Eye Bank is an entity involved in the recovery, processing, storage or
distribution of eye tissue that will be used for transplantation. A Tissue Bank is an entity that is
involved in the recovery, processing, storage, or distribution of human tissue, such as bone,
skin, or cartilage, which will be used for transplantation. Organ and tissue procurement
organizations, including those located outside of Florida that provide eye and other tissue types
to Florida’s transplanting physicians, are certified by the State of Florida.
Outpatient Treatment means a facility that provides services on a nonresidential basis and is
intended for clients who meet the placement criteria for this component.
Pain Management Clinics means an establishment where allopathic or osteopathic physicians
practice pain-management by prescribing controlled substances to patients with chronic-non-
malignant pain. Such establishment is required to register and be inspected by the Department
of Health.
Pathologist’s office means a medical lab concerned with the diagnosis of disease based
on the laboratory analysis of bodily fluids such as blood and urine, as well as tissues,
using the tools of chemistry, clinical microbiology, hematology and molecular pathology.
Pharmacy means a store where solely medicinal drugs are dispensed and sold. Medical
cannabis cannot be sold from such stores.
Physiotherapist’s office. (See Medical Office.)
Page 18 of 230
DRAFT - ASSISTED LIVING AND MEDICAL USES MAY 4, 2017
Page 7 of 17
Phlebotomist’s office means an office where technicians or medical professionals draw blood
from a patient for clinical or medical testing, transfusions, donations, or research (See
Medical Office).
Podiatrist’s office. (See Medical Office.)
Portable X-Ray Provider means a provider that gives diagnostic x-ray tests in a patient’s own
home, a nursing home, or a hospital that does not provide x-ray services for its patients directly
but arranges for services with a portable x-ray provider. Some portable x-ray providers may
need a health care clinic license.
Prescribed Pediatric Extended Care Center means a facility that provides a basic nonresidential
services to three or more medically dependent or technologically dependent children with
complex medical conditions that require continual care. The comprehensive care includes
medical, nursing, psychosocial, and developmental therapies. These centers are licensed and
surveyed by the State of Florida.
Psychiatrist’s office. (See Medical Office.)
Rehabilitation Agency means a facility that provides a multidisciplinary program to help improve
the physical function of disabled individuals by creating a team of specialized rehabilitation staff.
The rehabilitation agency provides at least physical therapy or speech-language pathology
services and social or vocational adjustment services. Rehabilitation agencies are not required
to be licensed by the state if they are Medicare certified. Rehab agencies that are not certified
under the Medicare program may require licensure as a health care clinic.
Residential Treatment Center for Children and Adolescents means a facility with 24-hour
residential programs, including therapeutic group homes that provide mental health treatment
and services to children under the age of 18 who have been diagnosed as having mental,
emotional, or behavioral disorders. Residential treatment centers are licensed by the State of
Florida.
Residential Treatment Facility (Level I) means a facility that provides long-term residential care
with coordinated mental health services for adults (18 years or older) diagnosed with a serious
and persistent major mental illness. A state license covers five levels of care that range from
having full-time nurses on staff to independent apartments that receive only weekly staff
contact. Residential treatment facilities are licensed and surveyed by the State of Florida. Level
I facilities provide the highest level of care with a structured group treatment setting with 24
hours per day, 7 days per week supervision for residents who have major skill deficits in
activities of daily living and independent living, and need intensive staff supervision, support and
assistance. Nursing supervision is provided 24 hours per day, 7 days per week, however,
nursing services are limited to medication administration, monitoring vital signs, first aid and
individual assistance with ambulation, bathing, dressing, eating and grooming. The minimum
staffing is 1:10 staff to resident ratio with never less than 2 staff on site at all times.
Residential Treatment Facility (Level II) means a facility that provides long-term residential care
with coordinated mental health services for adults (18 years or older) diagnosed with a serious
and persistent major mental illness. A state license covers five levels of care that range from
having full-time nurses on staff to independent apartments that receive only weekly staff
contact. Residential treatment facilities are licensed and surveyed by the State of Florida. Level
II facilities provide a structured group treatment setting with 24 hour per day, 7 days per week
Page 19 of 230
DRAFT - ASSISTED LIVING AND MEDICAL USES MAY 4, 2017
Page 8 of 17
supervision for five or more residents who range from those who have significant deficits in
independent living skills and need extensive supervision, support, and assistance, to those who
have achieved a limited capacity for independent living, but who require frequent supervision,
support and assistance. Level II facilities maintain a minimum of 1:15 staff to resident ratio with
never less than one staff on site when residents are present during normal waking hours. During
sleeping hours, a minimum of 1:22 staff to resident ratio is required.
Residential Treatment Facility (Level III) means a facility that provides long-term residential care
with coordinated mental health services for adults (18 years or older) diagnosed with a serious
and persistent major mental illness. A state license covers five levels of care that range from
having full-time nurses on staff to independent apartments that receive only weekly staff
contact. Residential treatment facilities are licensed and surveyed by the State of Florida. Level
III facilities consist of collocated apartment units with an apartment or office for staff who
provided on-site assistance 24 hours per day, 7 days per week. The residents have a moderate
capacity for independent living. Level III facilities maintain a minimum 1:20 staff to resident ratio
with never less than one staff on site when residents are present during normal waking hours.
During normal sleeping hours, a minimum of 1:40 staff to resident ratio is required.
Residential Treatment Facility (Level IV) means a facility that provides long-term residential care
with coordinated mental health services for adults (18 years or older) diagnosed with a serious
and persistent major mental illness. A state license covers five levels of care that range from
having full-time nurses on staff to independent apartments that receive only weekly staff
contact. Residential treatment facilities are licensed and surveyed by the State of Florida. Level
IV facilities provide a semi-independent, minimally structured group setting for 4 or more
residents who have most of the skills required for independent living and require minimal staff
support. Level IV facilities may have less than 24 hours per day, 7 days per week on site
supervision; however, on-call staff must be available at all times. Staff is required to have a
minimum of weekly on site contact with residents.
Residential Treatment Facility (Level V) means a facility that provides long-term residential care
with coordinated mental health services for adults (18 years or older) diagnosed with a serious
and persistent major mental illness. A state license covers five levels of care that range from
having full-time nurses on staff to independent apartments that receive only weekly staff
contact. Residential treatment facilities are licensed and surveyed by the State of Florida. Level
V facilities provide the least amount of care and supervision. Level V facilities provide a semi-
independent, minimally structured apartment setting for 1 to 4 residents who have adequate
independent living skills and require minimal staff support. Level V facilities may have less than
24 hours per day, 7 days per week on site supervision; however, on-call staff must be available
at all times. Staff is required to have a minimum of weekly on site contact with residents.
Skilled Nursing Unit means Skilled nursing units are based in hospitals, either housed inside the
hospital or in a separate building. They typically provide only short term care and rehabilitation
services. The skilled nursing unit does not have a separate license because it is part of the
hospital license. See the hospital definition for further information.
Social Worker (See Medical Office.)
Sociologist (See Medical Office.)
Therapist (See Medical Office.)
Page 20 of 230
DRAFT - ASSISTED LIVING AND MEDICAL USES MAY 4, 2017
Page 9 of 17
Transitional Living Facility means a facility that provides services to persons with a spinal-cord-
injury or head-injury. Specialized health care services include rehabilitative services,
community reentry training, aids for independent living, counseling, and other services. This
term does not include a hospital licensed under chapter 395 or any federally operated hospital
or facility. A transitional living facility is licensed by the State of Florida.
Urgent Care Center means a facility which holds itself out to the general public as a walk-in
facility, where immediate, but not emergent, care is provided. Patients shall be served solely on
an outpatient basis and such services shall not include overnight stays.
Women’s Health Clinic means a facility that primarily provides obstetrics and gynecology
service or other services related to women’s healthcare. This definition includes Abortion
Clinics, which are licensed and surveyed by the State of Florida, but does not include a hospital
or a doctor's office where abortions might be performed, but where this is not the primary
purpose.
Sec. 142-1253. – Medical use classifications.
Medical uses shall be organized into classes for the purpose of determining allowable locations,
process of approval, and other zoning regulations. Generally, as the potential for impacts to
surrounding areas increase as the class increases. The classes and medical sub-uses within
each class are as follows:
(a) Class I Medical Uses.
Class I Medical Uses generally have an impact similar to, and often incorporate retail uses.
These uses are often seen as a small accessory use to large-scale residential and hotel
uses as well. Class I medical sub-uses include the following:
(1) Optician
(2) Pharmacy
(3) Retail Clinic
(b) Class II Medical Uses.
Class II Medical Uses generally have an impact similar to offices uses. These uses are
typically located within office or retail buildings, and typically schedule appointments with
patients during standard working hours. These uses typically do not generate high amounts
of medical waste. Class II medical sub-uses include the following:
(1) Adult Day Care Center
(2) Electrology Facility
(3) Medical Office
(c) Class III Medical Uses.
Class III Medical Uses generally provide medical care throughout extended working hours,
along with diagnostic and laboratory services. These may involve the generation of high
levels of medical waste, and generate higher levels of traffic. These uses typically do not
generate high amounts of medical waste. Class III medical sub-uses include the following:
Page 21 of 230
DRAFT - ASSISTED LIVING AND MEDICAL USES MAY 4, 2017
Page 10 of 17
(1) Ambulatory Surgical Center (ASC)
(2) Clinical Laboratory
(3) Comprehensive Outpatient Rehabilitation Facility
(4) Dental Laboratory
(5) End-Stage Renal Disease Center
(6) Forensic Toxicology laboratory
(7) Health Care Clinic
(8) Intensive Outpatient Treatment Facility
(9) Medical Lab
(10) Multiphasic Health Test Center
(11) Prescribed Pediatric Extended Care Center
(12) Urgent Care Center
(13) Women’s Health Clinic
(14) Pathologist
(15) Rehabilitation Agency
(d) Class IV Medical Uses.
Class IV Medical Uses generally dispense pharmaceuticals as part of their treatment plan.
These may involve frequent visits from patients who may require services from the facility on
a daily basis. Class IV medical sub-uses include the following:
(1) Pain Management Clinic
(e) Class V Medical Uses.
Class V Medical Uses generally are those in which assistance is given to permanent
residents with assistance in daily personal activities including but not limited to, bathing,
dressing, eating, grooming, and dispensing of medicine in a residential setting. Such a
facility generally may have no more than six (6) residents. Class V medical sub-uses
include the following:
(1) Adult Family Care Home
(2) Community Residential Home (6 or fewer residents)
(3) Hospice Facility (Up to 6 beds)
(f) Class VI Medical Uses.
Class VI Medical Uses generally are those in which assistance is given to permanent
residents with assistance in daily personal activities including but not limited to, bathing,
dressing, eating, grooming, and dispensing of medicine in a residential setting. Such a
facility may have up to 16 residents. Class VI medical sub-uses include the following:
(1) Assisted Living Facility (Up to 16 beds)
(2) Community Residential Home (7 to 14 residents)
(3) Hospice Facility (Up to 14 Beds)
(4) Homes for Special Services (Up to
(g) Class VII Medical Uses.
Page 22 of 230
DRAFT - ASSISTED LIVING AND MEDICAL USES MAY 4, 2017
Page 11 of 17
Class VII Medical Uses generally provide 24-hour medical supervision and may implement
medication management and other medical care for its residents. However, the patients do
not pose a physical danger to themselves or others. They are typically in a residential
setting; however, they may have some institutional components. Such a facility may contain
amenities to improve the quality of life of patients. The facility may have more than 16
residents. Such facilities are generally intended to assist permanent residents. Class VII
medical sub-uses include the following:
(1) Assisted Living Facility (Over 16 beds)
(2) Homes for Special Services
(3) Hospice Facility (Over 14 beds)
(4) Nursing Home
(5) Intermediate Care facility for the Developmentally Disabled
(h) Class VIII Medical Uses.
Class VIII Medical Uses generally provide 24-hour medical supervision and may implement
medication management for its residents or patients; however, the patients or residents do
not pose a physical danger to themselves or others. They are typically of an institutional
nature, though they may take place in a more residential setting. Such a facility may contain
amenities to improve the quality of life of patients. Class VIII medical sub-uses include the
following:
(1) Birth Center
(2) Intensive Inpatient Treatment Facility
(3) Residential Treatment Facility (Level III)
(4) Residential Treatment Facility (Level IV)
(5) Residential Treatment Facility (Level V)
(6) Nursing Home
(7) Transitional Living Facility
(i) Class IX Medical Uses.
Class IX Medical Uses generally provide 24-hour medical supervision and may implement
medication management for its residents or patients; however, they treat residents or
patients who may pose a physical danger to themselves or others and security is required.
They are typically of an institutional nature, though they may take place in a more residential
setting. Such a facility may contain amenities to improve the quality of life of patients. Class
IX medical sub-uses include the following:
(1) Addictions Receiving Facility
(2) Crisis Stabilization Unit
(3) Detoxification
(4) Residential Treatment Center for Children and Adolescents
(5) Residential Treatment Facility (Level I)
(6) Residential Treatment Facility (Level II)
(7) Community mental health partial hospital program
(j) Class X Medical Uses.
Page 23 of 230
DRAFT - ASSISTED LIVING AND MEDICAL USES MAY 4, 2017
Page 12 of 17
A medical use that treats a full range of medical related issues. This is the most intense
medical use. Class X medical sub-uses include the following:
(1) Hospital
(2) Trauma Systems
(3) Medication and Methadone Maintenance Treatment Facility
(4) Organ and Tissue Procurement Facility
(k) Medical sub-uses not identified in subsections (a) through (j) above or in section 142-1254
shall be considered Class X Medical Uses. If an applicant feels that the proposed medical
sub-use is of a similar nature or impact as the uses in a differing class, the applicant may
provide a description of the proposed medical sub-use and expected impacts from the use
to the Planning Department for a determination of equivalent impact. The Planning
Department may request additional information, as necessary, in order to make a
determination. The Planning Department may require a study to support the descriptions
and impacts in the study to support the descriptions and impacts and that the study be peer
reviewed at the expense of the applicant. The study must consider the supplemental
conditional use criteria in section 142-1267, as applicable, in addition to any other
information deemed necessary.
Sec. 142-1254. – Exempt uses.
The following medical sub-uses, which service individuals in their place of residence, shall be
exempt from the regulations of this division:
(a) Health Care Services Pool
(b) Home Health Agency
(c) Home Medical Equipment Provider
(d) Homemaker and Companion Services
(e) Home Hospice Service
(f) Massage Therapist
(g) Portable X-Ray Provider
Page 24 of 230
DRAFT - ASSISTED LIVING AND MEDICAL USES MAY 4, 2017
Page 13 of 17
Sec. 142-1255. – Zoning District Regulations.
The following table identifies the zoning districts in which each medical use class is allowed and
if conditional use approval is required.
Medical Use Zoning Regulations
Zoning
District
Class
I
Class
II
Class
III
Class
IV
Class
V
Class
VI
Class
VII
Class
VIII
Class
IX
Class
X
RS-1,2,3,4 P
TH P
RM-1 P C
RM-PRD P
RM-2 A P C C C
RM-PRD-2 A P
RM-3 A P C C C C
CD-1 P P P C C
CD-2 P P P P C C C
CD-3 P P P C P C C C C
I-1 P P P C
MXE P
P
GU P P P P P P
HD P P P P P P P P P P
RO P P P C C
RMPS-1 P C
RPS-1 P
RPS-2 P
RPS-3 A P
RPS-4 A P
C-PS1* P P P C C
C-PS2 P P P P C C
C-PS3 P P P C P C C C
C-PS4 P P P C P C C C
TC-1 P P P C P C C C
TC-2 P P P
P C C C
TC-3* P C
P C
P—Main permitted use A—Permitted as an accessory use
C—Conditional use Boxes with no designation signify that the use is NOT permitted
Page 25 of 230
DRAFT - ASSISTED LIVING AND MEDICAL USES MAY 4, 2017
Page 14 of 17
Sec. 142-1256. – Minimum zoning standards.
In addition to the regulations in the underlying zoning district and overlays (as applicable) and
other regulations in this division, medical uses shall comply with the following minimum
standards:
(a) Standards for all medical use classes:
(1) Medical uses that allow for overnight stays shall not exceed the maximum density limits,
when such limits are established by the underlying future land use designation in the
Miami Beach Comprehensive Plan. For the purposes of determining residential density,
a medical use in single family districts containing up to six (6) residents shall be deemed
one dwelling unit. In other districts, every two (2) beds shall count as one (1) dwelling
unit.
(2) For the determination of minimum distance separation requirements when established in
subsection (b) below:
A. The minimum distance separation, the requirement shall be determined by
measuring a straight line between the property lines of each use.
B. When a distance separation is required, a scaled survey drawn by a registered land
surveyor shall be submitted attesting to the separation of the uses in question.
(b) Standards for specific medical use classes:
(1) Class I Medical Uses:
A. Access to class I medical uses where permitted as an accessory use shall be limited
to guest of a hotel or residents and their guests of a residential use.
B. Overnight stays are prohibited.
(2) Class II Medical Uses:
A. Class II medical uses shall not operate between the hours of 10:00 p.m. and 7:00
a.m. Such hours may be modified with conditional use approval.
B. Overnight stays are prohibited.
(3) Class III Medical Uses:
A. Class III medical uses shall not operate between the hours of 10:00 p.m. and 7:00
a.m. Such hours may be modified with conditional use approval.
B. Overnight stays are prohibited.
(4) Class IV Medical Uses:
A. Class IV medical uses shall have a minimum distance separation of 1,500 feet from
other Class IV, VIII, or IX medical use.
Page 26 of 230
DRAFT - ASSISTED LIVING AND MEDICAL USES MAY 4, 2017
Page 15 of 17
B. Class IV medical shall have a minimum distance separation of 375 feet from schools
or parks.
C. Hotel or residential uses shall be prohibited on lots with Class IV medical uses.
D. Class IV medical uses shall not operate between the hours of 9:00 p.m. and 7:00
a.m.; notwithstanding the foregoing, if such facility is located within 375 feet of a
residential district, such facility shall not operate between the hours of 7:00 pm and
7:00 am. Such hours may be modified with conditional use approval.
E. Overnight stays are prohibited.
(5) Class V Medical Uses:
A. Class V medical uses shall have a minimum distance separation of 1,500 feet from
other class V medical uses.
B. Class V medical uses shall be the primary place of residence for patients or
residents.
C. The entire building shall conform with the Florida Building Code, fire prevention and
safety code, and with the city property maintenance standards. If it is a historic
structure, it shall also conform with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for
Rehabilitation and Guidelines for Rehabilitating Historic Structures, U.S. Department
of the Interior, as amended.
(6) Class VI Medical Uses:
A. Class VI medical uses shall have a minimum distance separation of 1,500 feet from
other Class VI medical uses.
B. Class VI medical uses shall be the primary place of residence for patients or
residents.
C. The entire building shall conform with the Florida Building Code, fire prevention and
safety code, and with the city property maintenance standards. If it is a historic
structure, it shall also conform with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for
Rehabilitation and Guidelines for Rehabilitating Historic Structures, U.S. Department
of the Interior, as amended.
(7) Class VII Medical Uses:
A. Class VII medical uses shall have a minimum distance separation of 1,500 feet from
other Class VII medical uses.
B. The entire building shall conform with the Florida Building Code, fire prevention and
safety code, and with the city property maintenance standards. If it is a historic
structure, it shall also conform with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for
Rehabilitation and Guidelines for Rehabilitating Historic Structures, U.S. Department
of the Interior, as amended.
Page 27 of 230
DRAFT - ASSISTED LIVING AND MEDICAL USES MAY 4, 2017
Page 16 of 17
(8) Class VIII Medical Uses:
A. Class VIII medical uses shall have a minimum distance separation of 1,500 feet from
other Class VII or VIII medical use.
B. Other hotel or residential uses shall be prohibited on lots with Class IX medical uses.
C. The entire building shall conform with the Florida Building Code, fire prevention and
safety code, and with the city property maintenance standards. If it is a historic
structure, it shall also conform with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for
Rehabilitation and Guidelines for Rehabilitating Historic Structures, U.S. Department
of the Interior, as amended.
(9) Class IX Medical Uses:
A. Class IX medical uses shall have a minimum distance separation of 1,500 feet from
other Class IV, VII, VIII, or IX medical uses. Notwithstanding the foregoing, a class
IX Medical Use may incorporate Class VIII medical sub-uses on the same site;
however, the stricter zoning standards shall apply to the combined uses.
B. Class IX medical uses shall have a minimum distance separation of 375 feet from
parks or schools.
C. Other hotel or residential uses shall be prohibited on sites with Class IX medical
uses.
D. The entire building shall conform with the Florida Building Code, fire prevention and
safety code, and with the city property maintenance standards. If it is a historic
structure, it shall also conform with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for
Rehabilitation and Guidelines for Rehabilitating Historic Structures, U.S. Department
of the Interior, as amended.
(10) Class X Medical Uses:
A. Class IX medical uses shall comply with the requirements of the HD district.
(11) Notwithstanding the foregoing, medical uses located in an HD or GU district shall be
exempt from distance separation requirements identified in this section. However, said
facilities shall be utilized for determining distance separation requirements for facilities in
other zoning districts.
(12) Notwithstanding the foregoing, medical uses located in an HD district shall be exempt
from limitations on hours of operation.
Sec. 142-1257. – Supplemental Conditional Use Review Criteria.
In reviewing an application for conditional use for medical uses, the planning board shall apply
the following supplemental review guidelines criteria in addition to the review guidelines listed in
section 118-192, as applicable:
Page 28 of 230
DRAFT - ASSISTED LIVING AND MEDICAL USES MAY 4, 2017
Page 17 of 17
(a) For medical uses not allowing overnight stays or residence, whether hours of operation are
identified in order to limit potential impacts to surrounding properties.
(b) Whether patients and residents served will pose a danger to themselves or others, and what
measures are being taken to ensure their safety and the safety of others in surrounding
areas.
(c) Whether a security plan for the establishment and supporting parking facility has been
provided that addresses the safety of the medical use, its users, and surrounding areas, and
minimizes impacts on the neighborhood.
(d) Whether a noise attenuation plan has been provided that addresses how noise will be
controlled from emergency vehicles, in the drop off areas, loading zone, parking structures,
and delivery and sanitation areas, to minimize adverse impacts to adjoining and nearby
properties.
(e) Whether a sanitation plan has been provided that addresses on-site facilities as well as off-
premises issues resulting from the operation of the medical use.
(f) Smaller scale facilities are encouraged in order to provide a non-institutional environment.
(g) Where overnight stays or permanent residency is allowed, if the facility is design to minimize
its institutional nature.
(h) Whether the facility will serve various income groups.
(i) Facilities located in newly constructed buildings are encouraged.
(j) Whether a plan for the delivery of goods for the medical use has been provided, including
the hours of operation for delivery trucks to come into and exit from the neighborhood and
how such plan will mitigate any adverse impacts to adjoining and nearby properties, and
neighborhood.
(k) Whether the proximity of the proposed medical uses to residential uses creates adverse
impacts and how such impacts are mitigated.
(l) Whether the scale of the proposed medical use is compatible with the urban character of the
surrounding area and create adverse impacts on the surrounding area, and how the adverse
impacts are proposed to be addressed.
Page 29 of 230
:HppkcckHrT:HppkvvaaTlcckYrparvcTLT:UTTD
:REENSSNRITEMEROlIB4E
pg-
c.Y.GIPVNLBIU.GLIYSLBN7PNG1L.0L,8NL2u,UL2.77u11u.Y
DAgB-2.77u11u.YNGLz.8YLEVuJIPN,8LRVN7IY
FRpE-ziYNLLChtLCfsm
dyMzE2p-
AEDEAAR LpgLpcEL ReFLydELReFLFElE gbBEepL2gBBappEELReF
FaAE2pageLpgLb ReeaerLdpRDDLgeLReR ndadLAE RpaerLpgLbcRABR2aEd
ReFLBEFa2R L2ReeRMadLFadbEedRAaEdo
lIl-gSNS
dNNLI,,IH8NSoL
-aYkcAevktaT nesikrY
g00uHNL.0L,8NL2u,ULR,,.GYNU
SmHrcHn
2.77u11u.YNGLz.8YLEVuJIPN,8LRVN7IY
l l:oEMI SC
BacsnkmvkHr
BN7.L:LAN0NGGIVL,.L yF2LIYSLSuGNH,u.YL,.LbVIYYuYOL1,I00L.YLIYIVU1u1LGNVI,uYOL,.LT8IG7IHuN1LIYSL7NSuHIV
HIYYIPu1LSu1TNY1IGuN1
Page 30 of 230
City of Miami Beach, 1700 Convention Center Drive, Miami Beach, Florida 33139, www.miamibeachfl.gov
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor Philip Levine and
Members of the City Commission
Jimmy L. Morales, City Manager
FROM:
Commissioner John Elizabeth Aleman
DATE:
June 28, 2017
SUBJECT: Referral to LUDC and direction to Planning staff on analysis relating to
pharmacies and medical cannabis dispensaries
I would like to refer a discussion to the Land Use and Development Committee relating
to medical cannabis dispensaries or “medical marijuana treatment centers.”
On June 9, 2017, the Florida Legislature, during a special session, in less than 48 hours
time – introduced, modified, and passed, in both houses, a new cannabis bill (SB 8-A,
3rd Engrossed). It provides in relevant part: that the regulation of medical marijuana is
preempted to the state, except as to the following: (1) the “medical marijuana treatment
center (medical cannabis dispensary) cannot be within 500 feet of a public or private
school; (2) that a city [or county] may ban medical marijuana treatment centers entirely;
or (3), if a city does not ban medical marijuana treatment centers, the city “may not place
specific limits, by ordinance, on the number of dispensing facilities that may locate within
[that city].” “The city may determine by ordinance the criteria for the location of, and
other permitting requirements that do not conflict with state law or department rule for,
medical marijuana treatment center dispensing facilities located within the boundaries of
[the city].” Additionally, a city “may not enact ordinances for permitting or for determining
the location of dispensing facilities which are more restrictive than its ordinances
permitting or determining the locations for pharmacies licensed under chapter 465. A
municipality or county may not charge a medical marijuana treatment center a license or
permit fee in an amount greater than the fee charged by such [city] to pharmacies.”
I would like planning staff to analyze the relevant sections of the state legislation,
particularly as it relates to pharmacies and the proposed new use. Specifically, I would
ask that planning staff identify all city rules regulating pharmacies, the zoning districts in
which the use is allowed, prohibited, any distance regulations, etc. This information
would assist the Commission in deciding how to implement SB 8-A, within the City of
Miami Beach.
If you have any questions please contact my assistant Cilia Maria Ruiz-Paz at 305-673-
7000 x 6437
Page 31 of 230
:HppkcckHrT:HppkvvaaTlcckYrparvcTLT:UTT:
:DRRENNEDSTRIRDMlSO4R
pc.
GIPIVNLBUS7N1IVSNP0S7U,LUV8SI2SuEUSADu1SAI,,D88DIP
kJc7.AI,,D88DIPUVSRI1S7NBNFI22
iCph.RtPUSSfsmSfdyM
elRhAp.
JhkhJJCbSpcSpGhSbCaiSe hSCaiSihrhbcn7hapSAc77opphhSCaiSpGh
nbCaaoaHSlcCJiSJhbCpoaHSpcSnGCJ7CAoh SCaiS7hioACbSACaaClo
io nha CJoh :
lSl-gNEN
UUSNuuNOEU0:
-aYkcAevktaT nesikrY
c22DOUSI2SuEUSADu1SCuuIVPU1
NmHrcHn
AI,,D88DIPUVSRI1S7NBNFI22
l l:oRIS NC
OacsnkmvkHr
lNPSONPPNLD8S0D8TUP8NVDU8SJU2UVVNBS7U,I
Page 32 of 230
City of Miami Beach, 1700 Convention Center Drive, Miami Beach, Florida 33139, www.miamibeachfl.gov
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor Philip Levine and
Members of the City Commission
Jimmy L. Morales, City Manager
FROM:
Commissioner Joy Malakoff
DATE:
June 28, 2017
SUBJECT: Referral to LUDC and Planning Board
I would like to jointly refer an ordinance to the Land Use and Development Committee
and the Planning Board that would prohibit medical cannabis dispensaries or “medical
marijuana treatment centers.”
On June 9, 2017, the Florida Legislature, during a special session, in less than 48 hours
time – introduced, modified, and passed, in both houses, a new cannabis bill (SB 8-A,
3rd Engrossed) which is highly unusual. It provides in relevant part: that the regulation
of medical marijuana is preempted to the state, except as to the following: (1) the
“medical marijuana treatment center (medical cannabis dispensary) cannot be within 500
feet of a public or private school; (2) that a city [or county] may ban medical marijuana
treatment centers entirely; or (3), if a city does not ban medical marijuana treatment
centers, the city “may not place specific limits, by ordinance, on the number of
dispensing facilities that may locate within [that city].” “The city may determine by
ordinance the criteria for the location of, and other permitting requirements that do not
conflict with state law or department rule for, medical marijuana treatment center
dispensing facilities located within the boundaries of [the city].” Additionally, a city “may
not enact ordinances for permitting or for determining the location of dispensing facilities
which are more restrictive than its ordinances permitting or determining the locations for
pharmacies licensed under chapter 465. A municipality or county may not charge a
medical marijuana treatment center a license or permit fee in an amount greater than the
fee charged by such [city] to pharmacies.”
Based upon the foregoing, I would like to refer an ordinance banning such use from the
City of Miami Beach.
If you have any questions please contact my assistant Bonnie Stewart at 305-673-7000
x 6722.
Page 33 of 230
kcrrTvvTcalkcrrTYYLLlUvvTRarLaYvlElkNllS
kIMMODDOI4lM-MIgU4SAM
6Z’
4$"$35')(xk5v$3x5"pxk(q'(3jx$wxg.(xQPgvxQ$qqPjjP$"
WYZk’/PI(Nk5v$3xL3Pjg("xY$j("xB$"U5)(U
S761’0,"(xx82ux8JEA
DzG01Q6’
Y1W1YY7Kx6Zx641x-1cB4GZY4ZZSVQZkkz-c6Rx7WW7cYDxQZkkc6611
7-Sx641xWc-7-Q1x7-SxQc6RFcS1xiYZ01Q6DxQZkkc6611xNxY1Cz1D6xWZY
Qc6Rx6ZxDiZ-DZYx641xD6c-BxDFckxQKzGh
U4UetDOD
i)(5j(x5ppx5x3(w(335)xg$xg.(x-(Pt.'$3.$$pVQ$qq,"Pgvx7ww5P3jxQ$qqPgg((x5"pxg.(xWP"5"I(x5"p
QPgvfPp(xi3$s(IgjxQ$qqPgg((x5x3(m,(jgxw$3xIPgvxjd$"j$3j.Pdx$wxg.(xDgP"txDfPqxQ),'h
x
6.(xDgP"txDfPqxQ),'xPjx5xI$qq,"Pgvx'5j(pxjfPqxg(5qxP"xkP5qPxG(5I.hx6.(P3xd,3d$j(xPjxg$x("3PI.
g.(x)Py(jx$wx5p,)gjx5"pxv$,g.xg.3$,t.xg.(xjd$3gx$wxjfPqqP"thx6.(xDgP"txDfPqxQ),'xPjx$"xg.(xI,ggP"t
(pt(x$wxjg3$M(xp(y()$dq("gxg(I."Pm,(hx6.(vxq5P"g5P"x5xI$qqPgq("gxg$x( I())("I(uxj5w(gvx5"p
wPg"(jjhx6.(P3xd35IgPI(xjg3,Ig,3(xPjxP"g(3y5)x'5j(phx6.(x5p,)gjx.5y(xgf$x$"(x.$,3x5"px5x.5)wxj(jjP$"j
'$g.xP"xg.(xq$3"P"tx5"px(y("P"txk$"p5vxg.3$,t.xW3Pp5vhx6.(xv$,g.x.5y(xwPy(x(y("P"txj(jjP$"j
k$"p5vxg.3$,t.xW3Pp5vux)5jgP"txgf$x.$,3jxP"x)("tg.hx6.(xg(5qxPjx5wwP)P5g(pxfPg.xW)$3Pp5xB,)wxQ$5jg
efffhwtIjfPqh$3tlx5"pxPjx3(I$t"PU(px'vx'$g.xzD7xDfPqqP"tx5"pxz"Pg(pxDg5g(jxk5jg(3jxDfPqqP"t
efffh,jqjh$3tlhx
6.(xDgP"txDfPqx6(5qbjx',jP"(jjxjg3,Ig,3(xPjx"$"xd3$wPgx'5j(pxfPg.xaJEIrxp(jPt"5gP$"x$wwPIP5))v
3(I$t"PU(px'vx'$g.xg.(xDg5g(x$wxW)$3Pp5x5"pxg.(xcYDhx6.(xg(5qx3(I$t"PU(jxg.5gxPgjxI$5I.P"txd$jPgP$"j
53(x5"x( g("jP$"x$wxkP5qPxG(5I.bjxj(3yPI(xq$gg$’xnhhhhI$qqPgg(pxg$xd3$yPpP"tx( I())("gxd,')PIxj(3yPI(
5"pxj5w(gvxg$x5))xf.$x)Py(uxf$3Mx5"pxd)5vxP"x$,3xyP'35"guxg3$dPI5)x.Pjg$3PIxI$qq,"Pgvhnx7jxfPg.x$g.(3xQPgv
jd$"j$3(pxg(5qjxeP"I),pP"txWghxK5,p(3p5)(luxg.(xj5)53P(jx$wx4(5pxQ$5I.xkPM(xB3(("xPjxoHauJJJux5"p
7jjPjg5"gxQ$5I.xD5"p3P"(xQ)P"g$"xPjxoHJuJJJux5"pxg.(xd$$)x3("g5)xw((jx53(x,"p(3f3Pgg("h
x
4(3(x53(xj$q(x( 5qd)(jx$wx3(g,3"x$"xP"y(jgq("g’
x
EhxxG3P"txkPI.5()xi.()djxDfPqxDI.$$)xI,33PI,),qxg$xkP5qPxG(5I.h
8hxY5Pj(xg.(xI$qd(gPgPy(xd3$wP)(x$wxg.PjxIPgv:jx5g.)(g(jx'vxI$qd(gP"txP"’xzD7xDfPqqP"tuxzDkDu
FZFO7x5"pxWc-7xj5"IgP$"(pxI$qd(gPgP$"jh
rhxxF$3MxfPg.xg.(xIPgvxg$x'(I$q(x5xIP3I,PgxIPgvxw$3xWc-7bjx$d("xf5g(3xjfPqxj(3P(jh
Hhxx4$jgx-5gP$"5)x5"pxc"g(3"5gP$"5)xDfPqxk((gjx5gxg.(xkP5qPxG(5I.xQ$"y("gP$"xQ("g(3h
ahxxGPpxw$3x5"pxfP"x5jx.$jgxIPgvxw$3xZ)vqdPIx63P5)jxP"x8J8JhxThxZd("P"tx$wx5xi3$xDfPqxD.$dx5g
W)5qP"t$xi$$)h
Page 34 of 230
eLRTv nYTsLlimnoCTaR
/PI(Nk5v$3xL3Pjg("xY$j("xB$"U5)(U
Page 35 of 230
:HpkcrTvkapgYgLUggD
LENNSIISEMgNONE:DMA7N
vpc
X5W5KQV9-GPQY5KGQWNGP-IV-KLG5BGUS-G71UYG75II1LL15W
08pPc8Q29GEDG,g219QAG71UYG,UU5KW-Y
.,vJcE2W-GGuRAGuFiC
htfEJ7vc
,G8JhpstvmpdGp0GvXJGP,yp8G,d.G7mvyG7pPPmhhmpdGp0GvXJG7mvyGp0
Pm,PmGfJ,7XAG0sp8m.,AG8JMJ,smd G8JhpstvmpdGdpDGuFiCeullFCG,d.
7,ssmd G0p8G,GhMJ7m,sGJsJ7vmpdGpdGdpbJPfJ8GCAGuFiCAG0p8GvXJ
Mt8MphJGp0GhtfPmvvmd GvpGvXJGJsJ7vp8,vJGp0GvXJG7mvyGp0GPm,Pm
fJ,7XAG0sp8m.,G,Gf,sspvGatJhvmpdG,hrmd GnXJvXJ8GvXJG7mvy
7pPPmhhmpdGhX,ssG,.pMvG,dGp8.md,d7JG7X,d md GvXJG7t88JdvGocFF
,DPDGvJ8Pmd,vmpdGvmPJGvpGucFFG,DPDG0p8GvXJGh,sJG,d.G7pdhtPMvmpdGp0
,s7pXpsm7GfJbJ8, JhGpdGM8mb,vJGM8pMJ8vyG,vG,s7pXpsm7GfJbJ8, J
Jhv,fsmhXPJdvhGsp7,vJ.GpdGp7J,dG.8mbJG08pPGovXGvpGiovX
hv8JJvhAGJHJPMvmd G08pPGvXmhGvmPJG7X,d JGvXphJGmd.pp8
Mp8vmpdhGp0G,s7pXpsm7GfJbJ8, JGJhv,fsmhXPJdvhGvX,vG,8J
7pPMsJvJsyGJd7sphJ.G,d.Gsp7,vJ.GJdvm8JsyGnmvXmdGXpvJshD
DMDC-ISI
h--GP-I5KQWN2IGQUUQ:S-ND
CH vpcnTviHgtunlova
pBB1:-G5BGUS-G71UYG,UU5KW-Y
Iskapku
PQY5KGMS191OGs-T1W-
DttDLeNOMtIR
AHpluvsTvka
Page 36 of 230
kvtGKBKYLTHlHbuHHP
gkoom..mkpHo1okbPp0:o
jxk
”“•“w’‘v)9(’q“w9’•69()p‘)wc9“Z9;5)9P3;q9P“pp3cc3“•
GXx(kI3ppq9VY9(“w’v)cW9P3;q9(’•’N)w
BUjSkI7•)9910W9182u
uUDEHNSISH.LYMKtHbLBtGKCHA5R-GYH LBvGKC
EADISPjk
gxXj”9DSUP”9jUjA(9,UjSX,U.9PxgESXLUjJxg9BJEjXJPj9BS(xVJjJxg
(xXUjxXJA(k
Ug9xXBJgUgPS9xG9j”S9(U.xX9UgB9PJj.9Px((JEEJxg9xG9j”S9PJj.9xG
(JU(J9DSUP”W9GVxXJBUW9SRjSgBJgF9j”S9(xXUjxXJA(9j”XxAF”
xPjxDSX9i2W9182uW9GxX9CXxCSXjJSE9GXxgjJgF9xg9jUjA(9,UjSX,U.9UgB
VxPUjSB9xg9j”S9,SEj9EJBS9xG9jUjA(9,UjSX,U.9BXJLS9UgB9D.Xxg
ULSgAS9GXx(9uuj”9EjXSSj9jx90uj”9EjXSSjW9CXxCSXjJSE9VxPUjSB9xg
j”S9SUEj9EJBS9xG9”U,j”xXgS9ULSgAS9GXx(9uuj”9EjXSSj9jx9PXSECJ
DxAVSLUXBW9CXxCSXjJSE9VxPUjSB9xg9j”S9SUEj9EJBS9xG9PXSECJ
DxAVSLUXB9GXx(9”U,j”xXgS9ULSgAS9jx90hj”9EjXSSjW9UgB
CXxCSXjJSE9VxPUjSB9xg9j”S9gxXj”9EJBS9xG90hj”9EjXSSj9DSj,SSg
PXSECJ9DxAVSLUXB9UgB9D.Xxg9ULSgASt9J(CxEJgF9U9jS(CxXUX.
(xXUjxXJA(9ACxg9j”S9XSPSJCj9xG9xX9CXxPSEEJgF9xG9UCCVJPUjJxgEW
CSX(JjE9xX9CSgBJgF9UCCXxLUVE9CSXjUJgJgF9jx9BS(xVJjJxg9xG
EjXAPjAXSE9xg9jUjA(9,UjSX,U.t9GxX9fxgJgF9Jg9CXxFXSEE
CAXCxESEW9j”JE9xXBJgUgPS9E”UVV9DS9SGGSPjJLS9ACxg9GJXEj9XSUBJgF
xG9j”JE9xXBJgUgPSW9UgB9gx9UCCVJPUjJxgE9GxX9BS(xVJjJxg9,Jj”Jg9j”S
BSEJFgUjSB9UXSU9E”UVV9DS9UPPSCjSB9D.9j”S9PJj.t9CXxLJBJgF9GxX
SRPSCjJxgEt9CXxLJBJgF9GxX9ESLSXUDJVJj.t9XSCSUV9xG9PxgGVJPjJgF
xXBJgUgPS9CXxLJEJxgEt9UgB9CXxLJBJgF9GxX9Ug9SRCJXUjJxg9BUjSY
b1gkoo1p0Psmkp
j5)9U6p3•3c;w’;3“•9w)s“pp)•6c9;5’;9;5)9P3;q9P“pp3cc3“•9’6“m;9;5)9xw63•’•s)Y
PpPec.m.
aPgnibk:p0
x•9(’q922W9182dW9’;9;5)9w)y7)c;9“Z9P“pp3cc3“•)w9Uww3“v’W9;5)9P3;q9P“pp3cc3“•963w)s;)69;5)9P3;q
U;;“w•)q9;“96w’Z;9’•9“w63•’•s)9)c;’‘v3c53•N9’9;)pm“w’wq9p“w’;“w37p9“•9;5)93cc7’•s)9“Z96)p“v3;3“•
m)wp3;c93•9;5)9g“w;59D)’s59’w)’9MJ;)p9X xeY9x•9I7vq92iW9182dW9;5)9P3;q9P“pp3cc3“•9’mmw“l)69;5)
“w63•’•s)9)c;’‘v3c53•N9’9;)pm“w’wq9p“w’;“w37p9Z“w9;5)96)p“v3;3“•9“Z9’•q9bP“•;w3‘7;3•Na9c;w7s;7w)9r3;53•
;5)9Z“vv“r3•N9’w)’c9“Z9;5)9g“w;59D)’s59(’c;)w9Cv’•9c;76q9’w)’k
n9j5)9og“w;59E5“w)9g’;3“•’v9X)N3c;)w9B3c;w3s;kH9F)•)w’vvq9‘“7•6)69‘q9uiw69E;w));9;“9;5)9c“7;5W
B3s:)•c9Ul)•7)W9”’r;5“w•)9Ul)•7)9’•69Pw)cm39D“7v)l’w69;“9;5)9r)c;W90u;59E;w));9;“9;5)9•“w;5W9’•6
P“vv3•c9P“7w;9;“9;5)9)’c;Y
n9j5)9og“wp’•6q9Jcv)c9g’;3“•’v9X)N3c;)w9B3c;w3s;kH9F)•)w’vvq9‘“7•6)69‘q9D3cs’q•)9D’q9;“9;5)9c“7;5W
Page 37 of 230
X’q9E;w));W9X7)9g“;w)9B’p)9’•69X7)9L)wc’3vv)c9;“9;5)9r)c;W9g“wp’•6q9E5“w)c9F“vZ9P“7wc)9;“9;5)
•“w;5W9’•69;5)9r)c;)w•9‘7v:5)’69“Z9J•63’•9Pw)):9;“9;5)9)’c;Y
Uc9“w3N3•’vvq9’mmw“l)6W9;5)9p“w’;“w37p9w)p’3•)693•9)ZZ)s;9Z“w9“•)957•6w)69’•69)3N5;q9M208e96’qc9Zw“p
;5)9)ZZ)s;3l)96’;)9“Z9I7vq92iW9182dW9r53s59r’c9I’•7’wq92iW9182uY
U;9’9cm)s3’v9p));3•N9“•9B)s)p‘)w9 W9182dW9;5)9P3;q9P“pp3cc3“•963w)s;)69;5)9P3;q9U;;“w•)q9;“96w’Z;
’•9“w63•’•s)9)O;)•63•N9;5)9)O3c;3•N96)p“v3;3“•9p“w’;“w37p9;“9;5)9’w)’9“Z9j’;7p9,’;)wr’q9’•
’663;3“•’v9d9p“•;5c9M20896’qceY9x•9G)‘w7’wq90W9182uW9;53c920896’q9)O;)•c3“•9r’c9’6“m;)6W
w);w“’s;3l)9;“9I’•7’wq922W9182uY9j5)9s7ww)•;9p“w’;“w37p93c9c);9;“9)Om3w)9“•9“w9’‘“7;9I7vq922W9182uW
7•v)cc9)O;)•6)6Y
PpPec.m.
j5)9mw“m“c)69p“w’;“w37p93c9’9v3p3;)69)O;)•c3“•9“Z9;5)9)O3c;3•N9p“w’;“w37pW9’•69r“7v69’mmvq9;“9;5)
6)p“v3;3“•9“Z9’•q9oP“•;w3‘7;3•NH9c;w7s;7w)9r3;53•9;5)9j’;7p9,’;)wr’q9’w)’9“Z9;5)9g“w;59E5“w)
g’;3“•’v9X)N3c;)w9B3c;w3s;Y9F)•)w’vvqW9;5)9mw“m“c)69p“w’;“w37p9r3vv9’mmvq9;“9mw“m)w;3)c9Zw“•;3•N9“•
j’;7p9,’;)wr’q9Bw3l)W9Dqw“•9Ul)•7)9’•69Pw)cm39Dvl69Zw“p9uu;59c;w));9;“90u;59c;w));Y
j5)9p“w’;“w37p9r“7v69•“;9’mmvq9;“9’mmv3s’;3“•c9;5’;95’l)9w)s)3l)69’9V’•69Ac)9D“’w69xw6)w9“w9’
‘73v63•N9m)wp3;9Z“w96)p“v3;3“•9mw3“w9;“9I7vq92iW9182dW9r53s593c9;5)9’mmv3s’‘v)96’;)9“Z9;5)9)O3c;3•N
p“w’;“w37pY9J;9r“7v69’vc“9•“;9’mmvq9;“9’•97•c’Z)9c;w7s;7w)9‘“’w69“w6)w9“w9’9v’rZ7v9“w6)w9“Z9;5)
D73v63•N9xZZ3s3’vY
Uc9mw“m“c)6W9;5)9p“w’;“w37p9r“7v69w)p’3•93•9)ZZ)s;97•;3v9xs;“‘)w9i2W9182uW97•v)cc9)’wv3)w9w)cs3•6)6W
w)m)’v)69“w9)O;)•6)69‘q9’•9xw63•’•s)9“w9X)c“v7;3“•9“Z9;5)9P3;q9P“pp3cc3“•Y9j5)9“w63•’•s)93c
mw“m“c)69;“9‘)9)ZZ)s;3l)W9XSjXxUPjJLSW9;“9I7•)9uW9182uY
j5)9mw“m“c)69g“w;59D)’s59g’;3“•’v9X)N3c;)w9g)3N5‘“w5““69P“•c)wl’;3“•9B3c;w3s;9xl)wv’q
xw63•’•s)93c9cs5)67v)69;“9‘)9w)Z)ww)69;“9;5)9Cv’••3•N9D“’w69“•9I7•)9uW9182uY9Ucc7p3•N9c7s5
“w63•’•s)93c9w)Z)ww)6W9G3wc;9X)’63•N9‘)Z“w)9;5)9P3;q9P“pp3cc3“•9r“7v69•“;9‘)97•;3v9I7vq9“w
E)m;)p‘)wY9j5)9mw“m“c)69p“w’;“w37p9)O;)•c3“•9r“7v69s“3•s36)9r3;59Cv’••3•N9D“’w69’•6
P“pp3cc3“•9w)l3)r9“Z9;5)9s“•c)wl’;3“•963c;w3s;9v)N3cv’;3“•Y
9
:A0Ps1
j5)9c7‘T)s;9p“w’;“w37p9r’c9’mmw“l)69’;9G3wc;9X)’63•N9“•9I7•)9uW9182uY
gkpge:.mkp
j5)9U6p3•3c;w’;3“•9w)s“pp)•6c9;5’;9;5)9P3;q9P“pp3cc3“•9’6“m;9;5)9xw63•’•s)Y
eLCGT-BdGrLHsvBYOGKC
Cv’••3•N9B)m’w;p)•;
.NMKTMv
P“pp3cc3“•)w9X3s:q9Uww3“v’
PssPg o1ps.U
Page 38 of 230
0LTYvGNdGMK
xw63•’•s)
U6
Page 39 of 230
North Beach Tatum Waterway Conservation District Demolition Moratorium
ORDINANCE NO. -----
AN ORDINANCE OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, EXTENDING THE MORATORIUM THROUGH
OCTOBER 31, 2017, FOR PROPERTIES FRONTING ON TATUM WATERWAY
AND LOCATED ON THE WEST SIDE OF TATUM WATERWAY DRIVE AND
BYRON AVENUE FROM 77TH STREET TO 87TH STREET, PROPERTIES
LOCATED ON THE EAST SIDE OF HAWTHORNE AVENUE FROM 77TH
STREET TO CRESPI BOULEVARD, PROPERTIES LOCATED ON THE EAST
SIDE OF CRESPI BOULEVARD FROM HAWTHORNE AVENUE TO 85TH
STREET, AND PROPERTIES LOCATED ON THE NORTH SIDE OF ssTH
STREET BETWEEN CRESPI BOULEVARD AND BYRON AVENUE;
IMPOSING A TEMPORARY MORATORIUM UPON THE RECEIPT OF OR
PROCESSING OF APPLICATIONS, PERMITS OR PENDING APPROVALS
PERTAINING TO DEMOLITION OF STRUCTURES ON TATUM WATERWAY;
FOR ZONING IN PROGRESS PURPOSES, THIS ORDINANCE SHALL BE
EFFECTIVE UPON FIRST READING OF THIS ORDINANCE, AND NO
APPLICATIONS FOR DEMOLITION WITHIN THE DESIGNATED AREA
SHALL BE ACCEPTED BY THE CITY; PROVIDING FOR EXCEPTIONS;
PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; REPEAL OF CONFLICTING ORDINANCE
PROVISIONS; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EXPIRATION DATE.
WHEREAS, the Mayor and City Commission have recognized the need for a temporary
moratorium on the receipt of and processing of demolition permits to ensure the completion of
the regulations relating to the creation of conseNation district regulations for Tatum Waterway,
from Byron Avenue to the North, and 77 Street to the South; and
WHEREAS, as seen in WC/ Communities, Inc. v. City of Coral Springs, 885 So.2d
912(Fla. 4th DCA 2004), a court will not interfere with the legislative act of establishing a
temporary moratorium in processing plan where there is a rational relationship to the City's
legitimate general welfare concern; and
WHEREAS, moreover, a court should not set aside the determination of public officers in
land use matters unless it is clear that their action has no foundation in reason, and is a mere
arbitrary or irrational exercise of power having no substantial relation to the public health, the
public morals, the public safety of the public welfare in its proper sense. Id.; and Smithfield
Concerned Citizens for Fair Zoning v. Town of Smithfield, 907 F.2d 239, 243 (1st Cir. 1990); and
WHEREAS, the first step in ensuring a proper moratorium, is to ensure that the City's
legislative has a rational basis and legitimate governmental purpose for the imposition of a
moratorium; and
WHEREAS, the second step is for the Mayor and City Commission to establish a record
that the moratorium would further the governmental purpose of creating, finalizing, and adopting
the North Beach vision through the Master Plan process; and
WHEREAS, while the planning process is being solidified, some key areas of emphasis
have emerged as the essential foundations to ensure the creation of the conseNation district
guidelines while garnering widespread support throughout the community, including but not
Page 40 of 230
limited to a balanced strategy to promote historic preservation while supporting incentives for
greater development, density and activation; and
WHEREAS, the Mayor and City Commission desire to encourage innovative and
compatible redevelopment that provides improved communities, enhances public benefits in the
form of compatible architecture and uses;
WHEREAS, the creation of a master plan and analysis of the impacts due to such plan
on parks, recreation, open space, infrastructure, accessibility of emergency and public service
vehicular traffic and public safety and public facilities needs is important to the City to ensure the
health, safety and welfare of the City's residents and visitors; and
WHEREAS, the City Commission has noted the rapid demolition of a multitude of
structures within the study area, and is concerned that the character of the community, and
possible increase of incompatible uses or structures is of concern; and
WHEREAS, the City in order to protect and preserve Tatum Waterway, while the City
develops the conservation district regulations, the moratorium is necessary; and
WHEREAS, the City Commission realizes that all these changes may have a
consequence of increasing demand for City services and on how these structures are handling
for land development reasons; and
WHEREAS, the City requires time to review, consider, modify, process for adoption, and
implementation regulations pertaining
to the referenced zoning districts, and to evaluate the
extent that the existing zoning/land development regulation are effectively implementing the
plan; and
WHEREAS, the Courts have recognized that a temporary moratorium is an important
land-use planning tool as a means of preserving the status quo during the planning process to
ensure the Community's problems are not exacerbated during the time it takes to formulate a
regulatory scheme; and
WHEREAS, it is well-settled that permissible bases for land use restrictions include
concern about the effect of the proposed development on traffic, on congestion, on surrounding
property values, on demand for City services, and on other aspects of the general welfare. WCI
Communities, Inc., 885 So.2d at 915 and Corn v. City of Lauderdale Lakes, 997 F.2d 1369,
1375 (11th Cir. 1993); and
WHEREAS, in applying an ordinance retroactively (1) there is clear evidence of
legislative intent to apply the Jaw retroactively, and (2) when allowed, the retroactive application
is constitutionally permissible, in that the new Jaw does not create new obligations, impose new
penalties, or impair vested rights. Jasinski v. City of Miami, 269 F.Supp.2d 1341 (SD Fla. 2003);
and
WHEREAS, for purposes of determining whether the retroactive application of a
municipal ordinance impairs a vested right under Florida law, a vested right is defined as an
immediate, fixed right of present enjoyment, Id.; and
2
Page 41 of 230
WHEREAS, the City is not interfering with a vested right obtained as a result of a final
order from a City Land Use Board, or permit already obtained under the Florida Building Code;
and
WHEREAS, the City requires a limited amount of additional time, as the original
moratorium is scheduled to expire on July 7, 2017, and although great progress has been
made, including by the North Beach Steering Committee, but additional time is needed to obtain
a consensus, and finalize the new draft regulations; and
WHEREAS, the Mayor and City Commission desire to ex1end the moratorium on
demolition permits through October 31, 2017, or adoption of the Conservation District
regulations, whichever is first.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF
THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA:
SECTION 1. RECITALS. The foregoing recitals are incorporated by this reference as if fully
set forth in the tex1 of this Ordinance. The recitals evidence the concern, motivations and
reasons for imposition of this Ordinance.
SECTION 2. MORATORIUM AREA. On February 8, 2017, the City Commission enacted
Ordinance, 2017-0471, which provided a six month moratorium through July 8, 2017, and which
moratorium is being ex1ended through this Ordinance. The imposed Moratorium shall apply to
the acceptance of applications for or the processing of applications for the demolition of any
structure for properties fronting on Tatum Waterway and located on the west side of Tatum
Waterway Drive and Byron Avenue from 7?1h Street to 8?1h Street, properties located on the east
side of Hawthorne Avenue from 7?1h Street to Crespi Boulevard, properties located on the east
side of Crespi Boulevard from Hawthorne Avenue to 851h
Street, and properties located on the
north side of 85th Street between Crespi Boulevard and Byron Avenue.
The moratorium will not prevent or affect: (i) applications that have received a Land Use Board
Order issued prior to February 8, 2017; (ii) a building permit for demolition issued prior to
February 8, 2017; (iii) a lawful order of the building official; or (iv) an unsafe structures board
order.
SECTION 3. CONSTRUCTION. This Ordinance is to be liberally construed to accomplish its
objectives.
SECTION 4. DURATION OF MORATORIUM. This Ordinance shall remain in effect through
October 31, 2017, unless earlier rescinded, repealed or ex1ended by an Ordinance or
Resolution of the City Commission of the City of Miami Beach. Within ninety (90) days from the
effective date hereof, the City staff shall provide an interim report to the City Commission as to
the progress being made in the preparation of the conservation district ordinances.
SECTION 5. SEVERABILITY. That if any clause, section or other part of this Ordinance shall
be held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, the remainder of this
Ordinance shall not be affected thereby, but shall remain in full force and effect.
SECTION 6. REPEALER. All ordinances or parts of ordinances and all section and parts of
sections in conflict herewith be and the same are hereby repealed.
PASSED and ADOPTED this __ day of ________ , 2017.
3
Page 42 of 230
ATTEST:
Rafael E. Granado
City Clerk
First Reading: June 7, 2017
Second Reading:
Verified by: ___________ _
Thomas Mooney, AICP
Planning Director
(Sponsored by: Commissioner Ricky Arriola)
Underscore denotes new language
ii>trikethrt1 Elenetes stricken langt1age
4
Philip Levine
Mayor
Approved as to
form and language
& for executioo
5-30-1·1
Date
Page 43 of 230
20NE NEIGHBORS THURSDAYJUNE152017
MIAMIHEEWED.COM
1Y %IA 1IBEAC A
CITYOFMIAMIBEACH
NOTICEOFPUBLICHEARING
ORDINANCEEXTENDING
THENORTHBEACHTATUMWATERWAY
CONSERVATIONDISTRICTDEMOLITION
MORATORIUM
June28, 2017
NOTICEISHEREBYgiventhataPublloHearingwillbeheardbytheMayorandCityCommission
oftheCityofMiamiBeach, Florida. intheCommissionChamber, 3rdFloor, CityHall, 1700
ConventionCenterDrive, MiamiBeach, Florida, anJune28, 2017at5:01p.m., orassoon
thereafterasthemattercanbeheard, toconsider:
ANORDINANCEOFTHEMAYORANDCITYCOMMISSIONOFTHECITYOFMIAMIBEACH,
FLORIDA, EXTENDINGTHEMORATORIUMTHROUGHOCTOBER31, 2017FORPROPERTIES
FRONTINGONTATUMWATERWAYANDLOCATEDONTHEWESTSIDEOFTATUMWATERWAY
DRIVEANDBYRONAVENUEFROM77THSTREETTO87THSTREET, PROPERTIESLOCATED
ONTHEEASTSIDEOFHAWTHORNEAVENUEFROM77THSTREETTOCRESPIBOULEVARD,
PROPERTIESLOCATEDONTHEEASTSIDEOFCRESPIBOULEVARDFROMHAWTHORNE
AVENUETO85THSTREET, ANDPROPERTIESLOCATEDONTHENORTHSIDEOF85TH
STREETBETWEENCRESPIBOULEVARDANDBYRONAVENUE; IMPOSINGATEMPORARY
MORATORIUMUPONTHERECEIPTOFORPROCESSINGOFAPPLICATIONS, PERMITSOR
PENDINGAPPROVALSPERTAININGTODEMOLITIONOFSTRUCTURESONTATUMWATERWAY;
FORZONINGINPROGRESSPURPOSES, THISORDINANCESHALLBEEFFECTIVEUPON
FIRSTREADINGOFTHISORDINANCE, ANDNOAPPLICATIONSFORDEMOLITIONWITHIN
THEDESIGNATEDAREASHALLBEACCEPTEDBYTHECITY; PROVIDINGFOREXCEPTIONS;
PROVIDINGFORSEVERABILITY; REPEALOFCONFLICTINGORDINANCEPROVISIONS;
ANDPROVIDINGFORANEXPIRATIONDATE.
ThisOrdinanceisbeingheardpursuanttoSection2.05oftheCityCharterand §166.041F.S.
inquiriesmaybedirectedtothePlanningDepartmentat305.673.7550.
INTERESTEDPARTIESareInvitedtoappearatthismeeting, orberepresentedbyanagent, or
toexpresstheirviewsinwritingaddressedtotheCityCommission, c/otheCityClerk, 1700
ConventionCanterDrive, 1Floor, CityHall, MiamiBeach, Florida33139. ThisItemIsavailable
forpublicinspectionduringnormalbusinesshoursintheCityClerk'sOffice. 1700Convention
CenterDrive, 1°' Floor, CityHall, MiamiBeach, Florida33139. This [temmaybecontinued, and
undersuchcircumstances, additionallegalnoticeneednotbeprovided.
PursuanttoSection286.0105, Fla. Stat., theCityherebyadvisesthepublicthatifaperson
decidestoappealanydecisionmadebytheCityCommissionwithrespecttoanymatter
consideredatitsmeetingoritshearing, suchpersonmustensurethataverbatimrecordof
theproceedingsismade, whichrecordincludesthetestimonyandevidenceuponwhichthe
appealistobebased. ThisnoticedoesnotconstituteconsentbytheCityfortheIntroduction
oradmissionofotherwiseInadmissibleorIrrelevantevidence, nordoesItauthorizechallenges
orappealsnototherwiseallowedbylaw.
TorequestthismaterialInalternateformat, signlanguageInterpreter (five -daynoticerequired),
informationonaccessforpersonswithdisabilities, and/oranyaccommodationtoreviewany
documentorparticipateinanyCity- sponsoredproceedings, call305.604.2489andselect1
forEnglishor2forSpanish, thenoption6; TTYusersmaycallvia711 (FloridaRelayService).
Ad1346
RafaelE. Granado, CityClerk
CityofMiamiBeach
Page 44 of 230
kvtGKYKLTHlbluPllg
okmm.pp.k2lm0mku:2UDm
jxk
”“•“w’‘v)(q’p“w(’•c(q)Z‘)w9(“5(;6)(/W;p(/“ZZW99W“•
3XxqkPWZZp(YV(q“w’v)9G(/W;p(q’•’I)w
NBjUkPS•)((71G(7082
PAENlSIMIlpTLCKtluTYtGKBl5R- GLlsTYvGKB
uEAPU/jk
DxXj”(AUB/”(DBjgxDBY(XU,gujUX(/xDuUX.BjgxD(NgujXg/ju
NUqxYgjgxD(qxXBjxXgEqk
BD(xXNgDBD/U(x3(j”U(qBLxX(BDN(/gjL(/xqqguugxD(x3(j”U(/gjL(x3
qgBqg(AUB/”G(3YxXgNBG(JUXjBgDgD,(jx(URjUDNgD,(j”U(qxXBjxXgEq
j”XxE,”(x/jxAUX(F8G(7082(3xX(j”U(3xYYxigD,(BXUBuCJXxJUXjgUuk
JXxJUXjgUu(Yx/BjUN(AUjiUUD(jBjEq(iBjUXiBL(NXg.UCALXxD
B.UDEU(xD(j”U(iUuj(BDN(j”U(UBujUXD(Yxj(YgDUu(x3(Yxju(3XxDjgD,
BAAxjj(B.UDEU(xD(j”U(UBuj(AUjiUUD(22j”(ujXUUj(xD(j”U(uxEj”
BDN(1hj”(ujXUUj(xD(j”U(DxXj”t(j”U(JXxJUXjgUu(Yx/BjUN(AUjiUUD
j”U(jBjEq(iBjUXiBL(xD(j”U(iUuj(BDN(j”U(UBujUXD(Yxj(YgDUu(x3
Yxju(3XxDjgD,(BAAxjj(B.UDEU(xD(j”U(UBuj(AUjiUUD(2fj”(ujXUUj
xD(j”U(uxEj”(BDN(22j”(ujXUUj(xD(j”U(DxXj”t(j”U(JXxJUXjgUu
Yx/BjUN(Bj(1f8sG(1f7fG(BDN(1f72(/XUuJg(AxEYU.BXNt(j”U(JXxJUXjgUu
3XxDjgD,(DxXqBDNL(NXg.U(3Xxq(XEU(DxjXU(NBqU(xD(j”U(iUuj(jx
ABL(NXg.U(xD(j”U(UBujt(j”U(JXxJUXjgUu(3XxDjgD,(28uj(ujXUUj(3Xxq
XEU(DxjXU(NBqU(xD(j”U(iUuj(jx(ABL(NXg.U(xD(j”U(UBujt(j”U
JXxJUXjgUu(3XxDjgD,(j”U(UBuj(ugNU(x3(XEU(.UXuBgYYUu(3Xxq(28uj
ujXUUj(jx(AgBXXgjm(NXg.Ut(j”U(JXxJUXjgUu(3XxDjgD,(AgBXXgjm(NXg.U
3Xxq(XEU(.UXuBgYYUu(xD(j”U(iUuj(jx(XEU(.UDNxqU(xD(j”U(UBujt
j”U(JXxJUXjgUu(3XxDjgD,(XEU(.UDNxqU(3Xxq(28uj(ujXUUj(xD(j”U
DxXj”(jx(AXUuj(UuJYBDBNU(xD(j”U(uxEj”t(j”U(JXxJUXjgUu
3XxDjgD,(AXUuj(UuJYBDBNUt(j”U(JXxJUXjgUu(3XxDjgD,(j”U(iUuj
ugNU(x3(ABL(NXg.U(3Xxq(AXUuj(UuJYBDBNU(xD(j”U(uxEj”(jx(28uj
ujXUUj(xD(j”U(DxXj”t(j”U(JXxJUXjgUu(3XxDjgD,(j”U(UBuj(ugNU(x3
ABL(NXg.U(3Xxq(28uj(ujXUUj(xD(j”U(uxEj”(jx(j”U(DxXqBDNL
iBjUXiBL(xD(j”U(DxXj”t(gqJxugD,(B(jUqJxXBXL(qxXBjxXgEq(EJxD
j”U(XU/UgJj(x3(xX(JXx/UuugD,(x3(BJJYg/BjgxDuG(JUXqgju(xX
JUDNgD,(BJJXx.BYu(JUXjBgDgD,(jx(NUqxYgjgxD(x3(ujXE/jEXUu(xD
jBjEq(iBjUXiBLt(JXx.gNgD,(3xX(BD(U33U/jg.U(NBjU(XUjXxB/jg.U(jx
3gXuj(XUBNgD,G(3UAXEBXL(1G(7082t(3xX(mxDgD,(gD(JXx,XUuu(JEXJxuUuG
j”gu(xXNgDBD/U(u”BYY(AU(U33U/jg.U(EJxD(3gXuj(XUBNgD,(x3(j”gu
xXNgDBD/UG(BDN(Dx(BJJYg/BjgxDu(3xX(NUqxYgjgxD(igj”gD(j”U
NUug,DBjUN(BXUB(u”BYY(AU(B//UJjUN(AL(j”U(/gjLt(JXx.gNgD,(3xX
UR/UJjgxDut(JXx.gNgD,(3xX(uU.UXBAgYgjLt(XUJUBY(x3(/xD3Yg/jgD,
xXNgDBD/U(JXx.gugxDut(BDN(JXx.gNgD,(3xX(BD(URJgXBjgxD(NBjUV
(
Page 45 of 230
u0okmm02U:e.k2
j6)(BcZW•W9;w’;W“•(w)d“ZZ)•c9(;6’;(;6)(/W;p(/“ZZW99W“•(’c“y;(;6)(xwcW•’•d)V
:2:cap.p
g:oniukD2U
x•(q’p(88G(708hG(’;(;6)(w)MS)9;(“5(/“ZZW99W“•)w(BwwW“v’G(;6)(/W;p(/“ZZW99W“•(cWw)d;)c(;6)(/W;p
B;;“w•)p(;“(cw’5;(’•(“wcW•’•d)()9;’‘vW96W•I(’(;)Zy“w’wp(Z“w’;“wWSZ(“•(;6)(W99S’•d)(“5(c)Z“vW;W“•
y)wZW;9(W•(;6)(D“w;6(A)’d6(’w)’( g;)Z(XsxeV(x•(PSvp(8FG(708hG(;6)(/W;p(/“ZZW99W“•(’yyw“l)c(;6)
“wcW•’•d)()9;’‘vW96W•I(’(;)Zy“w’wp(Z“w’;“wWSZ(5“w(;6)(c)Z“vW;W“•(“5(’•p(b/“•;wW‘S;W•Ia(9;wSd;Sw)(rW;6W•
;6)(5“vv“rW•I(’w)’9(“5(;6)(D“w;6(A)’d6(q’9;)w(Jv’•(9;Scp(’w)’k
n(j6)(oD“w;6(u6“w)(D’;W“•’v(X)IW9;)w(NW9;wWd;kH(,)•)w’vvp(‘“S•c)c(‘p(2Fwc(u;w));(;“(;6)(9“S;6G
NWd:)•9(Bl)•S)G(”’r;6“w•)(Bl)•S)(’•c(/w)9yW(A“Sv)l’wc(;“(;6)(r)9;G(12;6(u;w));(;“(;6)(•“w;6G(’•c
/“vvW•9(/“Sw;(;“(;6)()’9;V
n(j6)(oD“wZ’•cp(g9v)9(D’;W“•’v(X)IW9;)w(NW9;wWd;kH(,)•)w’vvp(‘“S•c)c(‘p(AW9d’p•)(A’p(;“(;6)(9“S;6G
X’p(u;w));G(XS)(D“;w)(N’Z)(’•c(XS)(.)w9’Wvv)9(;“(;6)(r)9;G(D“wZ’•cp(u6“w)9(,“v5(/“Sw9)(;“(;6)
•“w;6G(’•c(;6)(r)9;)w•(‘Sv:6)’c(“5(g•cW’•(/w)):(;“(;6)()’9;V
B9(’yyw“l)cG(;6)(Z“w’;“wWSZ(w)Z’W•)c(W•()55)d;(5“w(“•)(6S•cw)c(’•c()WI6;p( 810e(c’p9(5w“Z(;6)
)55)d;Wl)(c’;)(“5(PSvp(8FG(708hG(’•c()OyWw)c(“•(P’•S’wp(8FG(7082V(
x•(q’wd6(8G(7082G(;6)(Z“w’;“wWSZ(r’9()O;)•c)c(’•(’ccW;W“•’v(810(c’p9G(w);w“’d;Wl)(;“(3)‘wS’wp(1G
7082V(j6)(dSww)•;(Z“w’;“wWSZ(W9(9);(;“()OyWw)(“•(“w(’‘“S;(BSIS9;(1G(7082G(S•v)99()O;)•c)cV
5c:22.2il:2:cap.p
j6)(yw“y“9)c(Z“w’;“wWSZ(W9(’•()O;)•9W“•(“5(;6)(yw)lW“S9(Z“w’;“wWSZG(’•c(r“Svc(’yyvp(;“(;6)
c)Z“vW;W“•(“5(’•p(o/“•;wW‘S;W•IH(9;wSd;Sw)(rW;6W•(;6)(’w)’9(Wc)•;W5W)c(5“w(W•dvS9W“•(W•(;6)(yw“y“9)c
D“w;6(A)’d6(D’;W“•’v(X)IW9;)w(/“•9)wl’;W“•(NW9;wWd;9V(,)•)w’vvpG(;6W9(W•dvSc)9(;6)(’w)’9(“5(;6)(D“w;6
u6“w)(’•c(D“wZ’•cp(g9v)9(D’;W“•’v(X)IW9;)w(NW9;wWd;9(;6’;(r)w)(•“;(W•dvSc)c(rW;6W•(;6)(yw“y“9)c
‘“S•c’wW)9(“5(;6)(v“d’v(6W9;“wWd(cW9;wWd;9V
j6)(Z“w’;“wWSZ()O;)•9W“•(r“Svc(•“;(’yyvp(;“(’yyvWd’;W“•9(;6’;(6’l)(w)d)Wl)c(’(Y’•c(E9)(A“’wc
xwc)w(“w(’(‘SWvcW•I(y)wZW;(5“w(c)Z“vW;W“•(ywW“w(;“(3)‘wS’wp(1G(7082G(r6Wd6(W9(;6)(’yyvWd’‘v)(c’;)(“5(;6)
)OW9;W•I(Z“w’;“wWSZV(g;(r“Svc(’v9“(•“;(’yyvp(;“(’•(S•9’5)(9;wSd;Sw)(‘“’wc(“wc)w(“w(’(v’r5Sv(“wc)w(“5(;6)
ASWvcW•I(x55WdW’vV
B9(yw“y“9)cG(;6)(Z“w’;“wWSZ(r“Svc(w)Z’W•(W•()55)d;(S•;Wv(xd;“‘)w(F8G(7082G(S•v)99()’wvW)w(w)9dW•c)cG
w)y)’v)c(“w()O;)•c)c(‘p(’•(xwcW•’•d)(“w(X)9“vS;W“•(“5(;6)(/W;p(/“ZZW99W“•V(j6)(“wcW•’•d)(W9
yw“y“9)c(;“(‘)()55)d;Wl)G(XUjXxB/jg.UG(;“(PS•)(2G(7082V
j6)(yw“y“9)c(D“w;6(A)’d6(D’;W“•’v(X)IW9;)w(D)WI6‘“w6““c(/“•9)wl’;W“•(NW9;wWd;(xl)wv’p
xwcW•’•d)(W9(9d6)cSv)c(;“(‘)(w)5)ww)c(;“(;6)(Jv’••W•I(A“’wc(“•(PS•)(2G(7082V(B99SZW•I(9Sd6
“wcW•’•d)(W9(w)5)ww)cG(3Ww9;(X)’cW•I(‘)5“w)(;6)(/W;p(/“ZZW99W“•(r“Svc(•“;(‘)(S•;Wv(PSvp(“w
u)y;)Z‘)wV(j6)(yw“y“9)c(Z“w’;“wWSZ()O;)•9W“•(r“Svc(d“W•dWc)(rW;6(Jv’••W•I(A“’wc(’•c
/“ZZW99W“•(w)lW)r(“5(;6)(d“•9)wl’;W“•(cW9;wWd;(v)IW9v’;W“•V
(
D5U:e0
j6)(9S‘T)d;(Z“w’;“wWSZ(r’9(’yyw“l)c(’;(3Ww9;(X)’cW•I(“•(PS•)(2G(7082V
ok2ocDp.k2
j6)(BcZW•W9;w’;W“•(w)d“ZZ)•c9(;6’;(;6)(/W;p(/“ZZW99W“•(’c“y;(;6)(xwcW•’•d)V
Page 46 of 230
cTBGH YdGrTlevYLOGKB
Jv’••W•I
pSCKHCv
/“ZZW99W“•)w(XWd:p(BwwW“v’
:ee:osm02epA
UTHLvGSdGCK
xwcW•’•d)
Bc
Page 47 of 230
North Beach National Register Conservation Districts Demolition Moratorium
ORDINANCE NO. ____ _
AN ORDINANCE OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, PERTAINING TO EXTENDING THE MORATORIUM
THROUGH OCTOBER 31, 2017 FOR THE FOLLOWING AREAS/PROPERTIES:
PROPERTIES LOCATED BETWEEN TATUM WATERWAY DRIVE/BYRON AVENUE
ON THE WEST AND THE EASTERN LOT LINES OF LOTS FRONTING ABBOTT
AVENUE ON THE EAST BETWEEN 77TH STREET ON THE SOUTH AND 86TH
STREET ON THE NORTH; THE PROPERTIES LOCATED BETWEEN THE TATUM
WATERWAY ON THE WEST AND THE EASTERN LOT LINES OF LOTS FRONTING
ABBOTT AVENUE ON THE EAST BETWEEN 75TH STREET ON THE SOUTH AND
77TH STREET ON THE NORTH; THE PROPERTIES LOCATED AT 8519, 8525, AND
8527 CRESPI BOULEVARD; THE PROPERTIES FRONTING NORMANDY DRIVE
FROM RUE NOTRE DAME ON THE WEST TO BAY DRIVE ON THE EAST; THE
PROPERTIES FRONTING 71 8T
STREET FROM RUE NOTRE DAME ON THE WEST
TO BAY DRIVE ON THE EAST; THE PROPERTIES FRONTING THE EAST SIDE OF
RUE VERSAILLES FROM 715
T
STREET TO BIARRITZ DRIVE; THE PROPERTIES
FRONTING BIARRITZ DRIVE FROM RUE VERSAILLES ON THE WEST TO RUE
VENDOME ON THE EAST; THE PROPERTIES FRONTING RUE VENDOME FROM
71 5T
STREET ON THE NORTH TO BREST ESPLANADE ON THE SOUTH; THE
PROPERTIES FRONTING BREST ESPLANADE; THE PROPERTIES FRONTING
THE WEST SIDE OF BAY DRIVE FROM BREST ESPLANADE ON THE SOUTH TO
71 5T STREET ON THE NORTH; THE PROPERTIES FRONTING THE EAST SIDE OF
BAY DRIVE FROM 715 T
STREET ON THE SOUTH TO THE NORMANDY
WATERWAY ON THE NORTH; IMPOSING A TEMPORARY MORATORIUM UPON
THE RECEIPT OF OR PROCESSING OF APPLICATIONS, PERMITS OR PENDING
APPROVALS PERTAINING TO DEMOLITION OF STRUCTURES ON TATUM
WATERWAY; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE RETROACTIVE TO FIRST
READING, FEBRUARY 8, 2017; FOR ZONING IN PROGRESS PURPOSES, THIS
ORDINANCE SHALL BE EFFECTIVE UPON FIRST READING. OF THIS
ORDINANCE, AND NO APPLICATIONS FOR DEMOLITION WITHIN THE
DESIGNATED AREA SHALL BE ACCEPTED BY THE CITY; PROVIDING FOR
EXCEPTIONS; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; REPEAL OF CONFLICTING
ORDINANCE PROVISIONS; AND PROVIDING FORAN EXPIRATION DATE.
WHEREAS, the Mayor and City Commission desire to create a conservation district overlay
for the entirety of the North Beach National Historic District and the Normandy Isles National Historic
District; and
WHEREAS, within the two National Historic Districts, the City has triggered zoning in progress
to create two new local historic districts, which two districts are smaller than the larger National
Historic Districts; and
WHEREAS, the Mayor and City Commission have implemented a temporary moratorium on
the receipt of and processing of demolition permits to ensure the completion of the regulations relating
to the creation of conservation district regulations for Tatum Waterway, from Byron Avenue to the
North, and 77 Street to the South and has imposed a moratorium for that area; and
Page 48 of 230
WHEREAS, as the conservation district regulations have not been drafted or implemented, the
City desires to implement a moratorium for the portions of the proposed conservation district that is
not currently subject to the Tatum Waterway Moratorium, or zoning in progress under the local historic
district designation process: and
WHEREAS, as seen in WCI Communities, Inc. v. City of Coral Springs, 885 So.2d 912(Fla. 4th
DCA 2004), a court will not interfere with the legislative act of establishing a temporary moratorium in
processing plan where there is a rational relationship to the City's legitimate general welfare concern;
and
WHEREAS, moreover, a court should not set aside the determination of public officers in land
use matters unless it is clear that their action has no foundation in reason, and is a mere arbitrary or
irrational exercise of power having no substantial relation to the public health, the public morals, the
public safety of the public welfare in its proper sense. Id.; and Smithfield Concerned Citizens for Fair
Zoning v. Town of Smithfield, 907 F.2d 239, 243 (1st Cir. 1990); and
WHEREAS, the first step in ensuring a proper moratorium, is to ensure that the City's
legislative has a rational basis and legitimate governmental purpose for the imposition of a
moratorium; and
WHEREAS, the second step is for the Mayor and City Commission to establish a record that
the moratorium would further the governmental purpose of creating, finalizing, and adopting the
conservation district regulations; and
WHEREAS, while the planning process is being solidified, some key areas of emphasis have
emerged as the essential foundations to ensure the creation of the conservation district guidelines
while garnering widespread support throughout the community, including but not limited to a balanced
strategy to promote historic preservation while supporting incentives for greater development, density
and activation; and
WHEREAS, the Mayor and City Commission desire to encourage innovative and compatible
redevelopment that provides improved communities, enhances public benefits in the form of
compatible architecture and uses;
WHEREAS, the creation of a master plan and analysis of the impacts due to such plan on
parks, recreation, open space, infrastructure, accessibility of emergency and public service vehicular
traffic and public safety and public facilities needs is important to the City to ensure the health, safety
and welfare of the City's residents and visitors; and
WHEREAS, the City Commission has noted the rapid demolition of a multitude of structures
within the study area, and is concerned that the character of the community, and possible increase of
incompatible uses or structures is of concern; and
WHEREAS, the City in order to protect and preserve the character of the remaining areas not
covered by the (a) Tatum Waterway moratorium or (b) zoning in progress for the local designation
areas, while the City develops the conservation district regulations, the moratorium is necessary; and
WHEREAS, the City Commission realizes that all these changes may have a consequence of
increasing demand for City services and on how these structures are handling for land development
reasons; and
2
Page 49 of 230
WHEREAS, the City requires time to review, consider, modify, process for adoption, and
implementation regulations pertaining to the referenced zoning districts, and to evaluate the extent
that the existing zoning/land development regulation are effectively implementing the plan; and
WHEREAS, the Courts have recognized that a temporary moratorium is an important land-use
planning tool as a means of preserving the status quo during the planning process to ensure the
Community's problems are not exacerbated during the time it takes to formulate a regulatory scheme;
and
WHEREAS, it is we/I-settled that permissible bases for land use restrictions include concern
about the effect of the proposed development on traffic, on congestion, on surrounding property
values, on demand for City services, and on other aspects of the general welfare. WCI Communities,
Inc., 885 So.2d at 915 and Corn v. City of Lauderdale Lakes, 997 F.2d 1369, 1375 (11th Cir. 1993);
and
WHEREAS, for purposes of determining whether the retroactive application of a municipal
ordinance impairs a vested right under Florida Jaw, a vested right is defined as an immediate, fixed
right of present enjoyment, Id.; and
WHEREAS, the City is not interfering with a vested right obtained as a result of a final order
from a City Land Use Board, or permit already obtained under the Florida Building Code; and
WHEREAS, the City requires a limited amount of additional time, as the original moratorium is
scheduled to expire on July 7, 2017, and although great progress has been made, including by the
North Beach Steering Committee, but additional time is needed to obtain a consensus, and finalize
the new draft regulations; and
WHEREAS, the Mayor and City Commission desire to extend the moratorium on demolition
permits through October 31, 2017, or adoption of the Conservation District regulations, whichever is
first.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA:
SECTION 1. RECITALS. The foregoing recitals are incorporated by this reference as if fully set
forth in the text of this Ordinance. The recitals evidence the concern, motivations and reasons for
imposition of this Ordinance.
SECTION 2. MORATORIUM AREA. On February 8, 2017, the City Commission enacted
Ordinance, 2017-0475, provided a six month moratorium through July 8, 2017, and which is being
extended through this Ordinance. The imposed Moratorium shall be on the acceptance of applications
for or the processing of applications for the demolition of any structure for the following
areas/properties: properties located between Tatum Waterway Drive/Byron Avenue on the west and
the eastern Jot lines of lots fronting Abbott Avenue on the east between 77tri Street on the south and
86tri Street on the north; the properties located between the Tatum Waterway on the west and the
eastern lot lines of lots fronting Abbot Avenue on the east between 75th Street on the south and 7yth
Street on the north; the properties located at 8519, 8525, and 8527 Crespi Boulevard; the properties
fronting Normandy Drive from Rue Notre Dame on the west to Bay Drive on the east; the properties
fronting 71st Street from Rue Notre Dame on the west to Bay drive on the east; the properties fronting
the east side of Rue Versailles from 71 st Street to Biarritz Drive; the properties fronting Biarritz Drive
from Rue Versailles on the west to Rue Vendome on the
3
Page 50 of 230
east; the properties fronting Rue Vendome from 71 31 Street on the north to Brest Esplanade on the
south; the properties fronting Brest Esplanade; the properties fronting the west side of Bay drive from
Brest Esplanade on the south to 71 st Street on the north; the properties fronting the east side of Bay
Drive from 71st Street on the south to the Normandy Waterway on the north.
The moratorium will not prevent or affect: (i) applications that have received a Land Use Board Order
issued prior to February 8, 2017; (ii) a building permit for demolition issued prior to February 8, 2017;
(iii) a lawful order of the building official; or (iv) an unsafe structures board order.
SECTION 3. CONSTRUCTION. This Ordinance is to be liberally construed to accomplish its
objectives.
SECTION 4. DURATION OF MORATORIUM. This Ordinance shall remain in effect through October
31, 2017, unless earlier rescinded, repealed or extended by an Ordinance or Resolution of the City
Commission of the City of Miami Beach. Within ninety (90) days from the effective date hereof, the
City staff shall provide an interim report to the City Commission as to the progress being made in the
preparation of the conservation district ordinances.
SECTION 5. SEVERABILITY. That if any clause, section or other part of this Ordinance shall be
held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, the remainder of this Ordinance
shall not be affected thereby, but shall remain in full force and effect.
SECTION 6. REPEALER. All ordinances or parts of ordinances and all section and parts of sections
in conflict herewith be and the same are hereby repealed.
PASSED and ADOPTED this __ day of ________ , 2017.
ATTEST:
Rafael E. Granado
City Clerk
Philip Levine
Mayor
Approved as to
First Reading: June 7, 2017
Second Reading: \
form and language
~ & for execution n
l__..-d~=-..l....L....L4~·--~ -.3 V -( I
Verified by: ___________ _
Thomas Mooney, AICP
Planning Director
(Sponsored by: Commissioner Ricky Arriola)
Underscore denotes new language
Strikethni 9enetes striGl<en language
e
4
Page 51 of 230
THURSDAYJUNE152017
MIAMIHERALD.COM NEIGHBORS 9NE
MIAMIBEACH
CITYOFMIAMIBEACH
NOTICEOFPUBLICHEARING
ORDINANCEEXTENDINGTHENORTHBEACH
NATIONALREGISTERCONSERVATIONDISTRICTS
DEMOLITIONMORATORIUM
June28, 2017
NOTICEISHEREBYgiventhataPublicHearingwillbeheardbytheMayorandCityCommissionoftheCityofMiamiBeach, Florida, intheCommission
Chamber, 3rdFloor, CityHall, 1700ConventionCenterDrive, MiamiBeach, Florida, onJune28, 2017at5:02p.m., orassoonthereafterasthematter
canbeheard, toconsider:
ANORDINANCEOFTHEMAYORANDCITYCOMMISSIONOFTHECITYOFMIAMIBEACH, FLORIDA, PERTAININGTOEXTENDINGTHEMORATORIUM
THROUGHOCTOBER31, 2017FORTHEFOLLOWINGAREAS /PROPERTIES: PROPERTIESLOCATEDBETWEENTATUMWATERWAYDRIVE /BYRON
AVENUEONTHEWESTANDTHEEASTERNLOTLINESOFLOTSFRONTINGABBOTTAVENUEONTHEEASTBETWEEN77THSTREETONTHE
SOUTHAND86THSTREETONTHENORTH; THEPROPERTIESLOCATEDBETWEENTHETATUMWATERWAYONTHEWESTANDTHEEASTERNLOT
LINESOFLOTSFRONTINGABBOTTAVENUEONTHEEASTBETWEEN75THSTREETONTHESOUTHAND77THSTREETONTHENORTH; THE
PROPERTIESLOCATEDAT8519, 8525, AND8527CRESPIBOULEVARD; THEPROPERTIESFRONTINGNORMANDYDRIVEFROMRUENOTREDAME
ONTHEWESTTOBAYDRIVEONTHEEAST; THEPROPERTIESFRONTING71STSTREETFROMRUENOTREDAMEONTHEWESTTOBAYDRIVE
ONTHEEAST; THEPROPERTIESFRONTINGTHEEASTSIDEOFRUEVERSAILLESFROM71STSTREETTOBIARRITZDRIVE; THEPROPERTIES
FRONTINGBIARRITZDRIVEFROMRUEVERSAILLESONTHEWESTTORUEVENDOMEONTHEEAST; THEPROPERTIESFRONTINGRUEVENDOME
FROM71STSTREETONTHENORTHTOBRESTESPLANADEONTHESOUTH; THEPROPERTIESFRONTINGBRESTESPLANADE; THEPROPERTIES
FRONTINGTHEWESTSIDEOFBAYDRIVEFROMBRESTESPLANADEONTHESOUTHTO71STSTREETONTHENORTH; THEPROPERTIES
FRONTINGTHEEASTSIDEOFBAYDRIVEFROM71STSTREETONTHESOUTHTOTHENORMANDYWATERWAYONTHENORTH; IMPOSINGA
TEMPORARYMORATORIUMUPONTHERECEIPTOFORPROCESSINGOFAPPLICATIONS, PERMITSORPENDINGAPPROVALSPERTAININGTO
DEMOLITIONOFSTRUCTURESONTATUMWATERWAY; PROVIDINGFORANEFFECTIVEDATERETROACTIVETOFIRSTREADING, FEBRUARY8,
2017; FORZONINGINPROGRESSPURPOSES, THISORDINANCESHALLBEEFFECTIVEUPONFIRSTREADINGOFTHISORDINANCE, ANDNO
APPLICATIONSFORDEMOLITIONWITHINTHEDESIGNATEDAREASHALLBEACCEPTEDBYTHECITY; PROVIDINGFOREXCEPTIONS; PROVIDING
FORSEVERABILITY; REPEALOFCONFLICTINGORDINANCEPROVISIONS; ANDPROVIDINGFORANEXPIRATIONDATE.
ThisOrdinanceisbeingheardpursuanttoSection2.05oftheCityCharterand § 166.041F.S. InquiriesmaybedirectedtothePlanningDepartmentat
305.673.7550.
INTERESTEDPARTIESareinvitedtoappearatthismeeting, orberepresentedbyanagent, ortoexpresstheirviewsinwritingaddressedtotheCity
Commission, c/otheCityClerk, 1700ConventionCenterDrive, 1stFloor, CityHall, MiamiBeach, Florida33139. Thisitemisavailableforpublicinspection
duringnormalbusinesshoursintheCityClerk'sOffice, 1700ConventionCenterDrive, 1stFloor, CityHall, MiamiBeach, Florida33139. Thisitemmay
becontinued, andundersuchcircumstances, additionallegalnoticeneednotbeprovided.
PursuanttoSection286.0105, Fla. Stat., theCityherebyadvisesthepublicthatifapersondecidestoappealanydecisionmadebytheCityCommission
withrespecttoanymatterconsideredatitsmeetingoritshearing, suchpersonmustensurethataverbatimrecordoftheproceedingsismade, which
recordincludesthetestimonyandevidenceuponwhichtheappealistobebased. ThisnoticedoesnotconstituteconsentbytheCityfortheintroduction
oradmissionofotherwiseinadmissibleorirrelevantevidence, nordoesitauthorizechallengesorappealsnototherwiseallowedbylaw.
Torequestthismaterialinalternateformat, signlanguageinterpreter (five -daynoticerequired), informationonaccessforpersonswithdisabilities, and/
oranyaccommodationtoreviewanydocumentorparticipateinanyCity- sponsoredproceedings, call305.604.2489andselect1forEnglishor2for
Spanish, thenoption6; TTYusersmaycallvia711 (FloridaRelayService).
Ad1347
RafaelE. Granado, CityClerk
CityofMiamiBeach
Page 52 of 230
kvt/WVWGKBYLYTHYYl
lkbbuPPukgYbobkTmg.pb
X•–
éz&zx’35Wjw’9zxj’&)jwW(3Wxvjzkjq6Wjpcq9jpz((cvvcz&
Q"•w–Zc((9j;-jwzx’5WvKjpcq9jw’&’”Wx
“4XP–ZG&WjjYVKjYNI/
H30:YUDADYPKGEWtYTKVt/WNYSIMC/GY5KVv/WN
BUSZPpX–
4"Xj“Pp•7w1w•jp•wwP"p14;jpé4"4pXP"j40“jQ•"wU;4jp•wwP"p14;
•8P";42j“1BX"1pX–
40j•"“1040pPj•QjXéPjw42•"j40“jp1X2jp•ww1BB1•0j•QjXéPjp1X2j•Q
w14w1jSP4péKjQ;•"1“4Kj4wP0“10ujpé4EXP"jIIAj•QjXéPjp1X2jp•“PK
P0X1X;P“jDuP0P"4;jE"•81B1•0BKgjX•jE"•81“PjQ•"j“PQ101X1•0BjQ•"
DpéPp,jp4Bé10ujBX•"PKgjDp•08P01P0pPjBX•"PKgjDQ•"wU;4
"PBX4U"40XKgjDQ•"wU;4jp•wwP"p14;jPBX4S;1BéwP0XBKgjDw4"1ZU404
“1BEP0B4"2KgjDp4004S1Bj“1BEP0B4"2KgjD•ppU;XjBp1P0pP
PBX4S;1BéwP0XKgjDEé4"w4p2KgjDB•U8P01"j40“jX.Bé1"XjBé•EKgjDX4XX••
BXU“1•KgjDw4BB4uPjXéP"4E2jpP0XP"Kgj40“j"P;4XP“j“PQ101X1•0BL
4wP0“10ujpé4EXP"jIAYj•QjXéPjp1X2jp•“PKjP0X1X;P“jDJ•010u
“1BX"1pXBj40“j"PuU;4X1•0BKgj4Xj4"X1p;Pj111KjP0X1X;P“jR•8P";42
“1BX"1pXBKRjX•jPBX4S;1Béj“181B1•0jIYKjP0X1X;P“jD4"Xj“Pp•j7jw1w•
p•wwP"p14;jpé4"4pXP"j•8P";42j“1BX"1pXKgjX•jE"•81“Pj4““1X1•04;
"PuU;4X1•0BjQ•"jXéPj4Q•"PwP0X1•0P“jUBPBKj10p;U“10uj“1BX40pP
BPE4"4X1•0j"PFU1"PwP0XBKj;1w1X4X1•0Bj•0j0UwSP"j•Q
PBX4S;1BéwP0XBKj40“jE"•é1S1X1•0BjU0“P"jpP"X410jp1"pUwBX40pPBL
E"•81“10ujQ•"j"PEP4;P"LjBP8P"4S1;1X2Ljp•“1Q1p4X1•0Lj40“j40
PQQPpX18Pj“4XP-
Tolkbbog.mRukg
X6Wj4)(c&cvqx’qcz&jxWiz((W&)vjq6’qjq6Wjpcq9jpz((cvvcz&j’)zCqjq6Wj•x)c&’&iW-
mgm- PuP
smlecTkpg.Y
•&jBWCqW(3WxjIAKjYNIhKj’qjq6WjxWtGWvqjzkjpz((cvvcz&Wxj"cif9j4xxcz5’Kjq6Wjpcq9jpz((cvvcz&jxWkWxxW)
q6cvjcqW(jqzjq6Wj;’&)jUvWj’&)j“WsW5zC(W&qjpz((cqqWWjm1qW(jpAjwd-j•&jBWCqW(3WxjY/KjYNIhKj’qjq6W
xWtGWvqjzkjpz((cvvcz&Wxj"cif9j4xxcz5’Kjq6Wjpcq9jpz((cvvcz&j’)zCqW)j’jIN.Czc&qjC5’&jq6’q
xWiz((W&)vj’jCxz6c3cqcz&jz&jkzx(G5’jxWvq’Gx’&qvj’&)j5c(cqvjz&jiWxq’c&jq9CWvjzkjxWq’c5jm1qW(j"ySd-j
•&jBWCqW(3WxjYIKjYNIhKjq6Wj;’&)jUvWj’&)j“WsW5zC(W&qjpz((cqqWWjiz&qc&GW)jq6WjcqW(jqzjq6W
•iqz3WxjYhKjYNIhj(WWqc&”-j•&j•iqz3WxjYhKjYNIhKjq6WjcqW(jM’vjiz&qc&GW)jqzj’j)’qWjiWxq’c&jzk
0zsW(3WxjIhKjYNIhKj’qjq6WjxWtGWvqjzkjq6WjvCz&vzx-j•&j0zsW(3WxjIhKjYNIhjq6Wj;’&)jUvWjpz((cqqWW
)cviGvvW)jq6WjcqW(j’&)jxWiz((W&)W)jq6’qjq6Wjpcq9jpz((cvvcz&jxWkWxjq6Wj’qq’i6W)jzx)c&’&iWjqzjq6W
E5’&&c&”jSz’x)jkzxjiz&vc)Wx’qcz&jMcq6jq6Wjkz55zMc&”j(z)ckci’qcz&vKjM6ci6j’xWjc&i5G)W)jc&jq6Wj’qq’i6W)
zx)c&’&iW–j
Page 53 of 230
I-jX6Wj’xW’j’) ’iW&qjqzje’v6c&”qz&j4sW&GWjM’vjxW(zsW)jkxz(jq6WjBzGq6jSW’i6jzsWx5’9j’xW’Lj
Y-jX6Wj)Wkc&cqcz&jzkjQzx(G5’j"Wvq’Gx’&qjM’vj(z)ckcW)jv5c”6q59j’&)j&zMjiz&vcvqvjzkj&zj(zxWjq6’&jkcsW
mldjWvq’35cv6(W&qvjc&jzCWx’qcz&jzxjMcq6j’CCxzsW)j)WsW5zC(W&qjzx)Wxvjc&jwc’(cjSW’i6Kj’vjzCCzvW)jqz
q6WjCxWsczGvj3W&i6(’xfjzkjqMzjmYdjWvq’35cv6(W&qvLj
b-jX6Wjkz55zMc&”jvG3vWiqcz&jM’vj)W5WqW)jkxz(jq6Wj)Wkc&cqcz&jzkjQzx(G5’j"Wvq’Gx’&q–j
Dzxjmccdj’jxWvq’Gx’&qjM6WxWj’qj5W’vqjvz(Wjkzz)jzxj3WsWx’”Wjzx)Wxvj’xWjiz((G&ci’qW)j39j’jiGvqz(Wxjqz
’&jW(C5z9WWjzsWxj’jizG&qWxjzxjvc(c5’xjCxz Wiqcz&j’&)jq6Wjkzz)jzxj3WsWx’”Wjq6’qjcvjzx)WxW)jcvjCxzsc)W)
qzjq6WjiGvqz(Wxj’qjzxjzsWxjq6WjizG&qWxjzxjvc(c5’xjCxz Wiqcz&-gj
•&j“WiW(3WxjIAKjYNIhKjq6Wjpcq9jpz((cvvcz&jxWkWxxW)jq6Wj’qq’i6W)jzx)c&’&iWjqzjq6WjE5’&&c&”jSz’x)
kzxjiz&vc)Wx’qcz&jm1qW(jpAj1d-j
S-mggugcYmgm- PuPY
X6Wjiz((Wxic’5j’xW’vjzkjwc’(cjSW’i6avj6cvqzxcij)cvqxciqvj’xWjMzx5)jxW&zM&jkzxjCxzsc)c&”jG&ctGW
WrCWxcW&iWvjqzjxWvc)W&qvj’&)jscvcqzxv-jX6WvWjc&i5G)WjzsWxj’jiW&qGx9jzkjWsz5sc&”Kj6c”659jvc”&ckci’&q
vq95Wvjzkj’xi6cqWiqGxWjmc&i5G)c&”j4xqj“Wizj’&)jEzvq.e’xjwz)Wx&7wcwzdjq6’qj’xWjG&ctGWjqzjq6Wj’xW’K
)c&c&”jWrCWxcW&iWvj’&)jvq95Wvjzkjkzz)jq6’qj’xWj)ckkciG5qjqzjWrCWxcW&iWjzGqvc)WjzkjBzGq6jQ5zxc)’-
4))cqcz&’559Kjq6WjxWq’c5jc&)Gvqx9jCxzsc)Wvj”zz)vj’&)jvWxsciWvjG&ctGWjqzjq6WjxW”cz&-jpz55WiqcsW59Kjq6cv
6c”659jG&ctGWj(crqGxWjzkj’xi6cqWiqGxWKjkzz)jnj)c&c&”j’&)jvCWic’5coW)jxWq’c5j6’sWjkzvqWxW)j’&)
(’c&q’c&W)j’j3x’&)jG&ctGWjqzjwc’(cjSW’i6-j1&jqGx&Kjq6cvjG&ctGWj3x’&)jxWc&qxz)GiW)j’jvqxz&”jqzGxcv(
c&)Gvqx9jc&jwc’(cjSW’i6KjM6ci6jcvjq6Wjpcq9avjCxc(’x9jWiz&z(cijW&”c&W-j
ézMWsWxKjc&jxWiW&qj9W’xvKjq6Wji6’x’iqWxjzkjq6WvWj’xW’vj6’vj3WW&ji6’&”c&”jMcq6j’&jc&k5Grjzk
3Gvc&WvvWvjq6’qj’xWjiz((z&jqzj(’&9jvG3Gx3’&j’xW’vjzkjq6WjizG&qx9-jX6WvWj3Gvc&WvvWvjc&i5G)W
i6’c&jmkzx(G5’djxWvq’Gx’&qvKji6’c&jmkzx(G5’djxWq’c5Kji6Wifji’v6c&”jvqzxWvKjiz&sW&cW&iWjvqzxWvKj’&)
C6’x(’i9jvqzxWv-jX6WvWjq9CWvjzkjWvq’35cv6(W&qvj6’sWj(G5qcC5Wj5zi’qcz&vjq6xzG”6zGqjq6WjizG&qx9Kj’v
MW55j’vjvq’&)’x)coW)jc)W&qcqcWvKj5z”zvKjiz5zxjvi6W(WvKjG&ckzx(vKj’&)j(Wxi6’&)cvW-j
X6WjCxz5ckWx’qcz&jzkjvGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&qvj5c(cqKj’&)jc&jvz(Wji’vWvjW5c(c&’qWKjzCCzxqG&cqcWvjkzxjq6W
G&ctGWj3Gvc&Wvvjq6’qj6’sWjqx’)cqcz&’559j3WW&jC’xqjzkjq6Wjk’3xcijzkjq6Wj6cvqzxcijiz((Wxic’5j)cvqxciqv-jX6cv
6’vj6’)j’j6z(z”W&coc&”jWkkWiqjzkjz&jq6Wjiz((Wxic’5j’xW’vKj’&)j6’vjxWvG5qW)jc&j’j)WixW’vWjc&jq6W
)csWxvcq9jzkjiG5qGx’5KjxWq’c5Kj’&)j)c&c&”jvWxsciWvjG&ctGWjqzjq6Wjwc’(cjSW’i6j3x’&)-j
•sWxjq6Wj5’vqjkzGxj)Wi’)WvKjq6Wjpcq9avj6cvqzxcij)cvqxciqvj6’sWjq6xcsW)jz&j’ji’xWkG5j3’5’&iWjzkjiG5qGx’5K
xWq’c5Kj’&)j)c&c&”jWrCWxcW&iWvjq6’qj’xWj&zqjkzG&)jW5vWM6WxWjc&jq6WjizG&qx9-jX6Wjc&ixW’vW)j5WsW5jzk
6z(z”W&Wcq9j6’vj)Wqx’iqW)jkxz(jq6WjG&ctGW&Wvvjzkjq6Wjpcq9avj3x’&)-j•sWxjq6Wj5z&”WxjqWx(Kjq6cvjizG5)
6’sWj’j&W”’qcsWjWkkWiqjz&jq6Wjpcq9avjWiz&z(9Kjvc&iWjscvcqzxvjMc55jW&izG&qWxjvc(c5’xj3Gvc&WvvWvjqzjq6zvW
q6’qjq6W9jvWWjc&jq6Wcxj6z(WjicqcWvKj’&)j5Wvvjzkjq6Wjpcq9avj3x’&)-j
4))cqcz&’559KjiWxq’c&j&Gcv’&iWjGvWvjvGi6j’vjC’M&v6zCvKjvzGsW&cxj’&)jq.v6cxqjv6zCvKjq’qqzzjvqG)czvK
kzxqG&WjqW55WxvjmziiG5qjvicW&iWjWvq’35cv6(W&qvdKj’&)jC’if’”Wj5ctGzxjvqzxWvj6’sWj’5vzj’kkWiqW)jq6W
i6’x’iqWxjzkjq6Wjpcq9avj6cvqzxcij)cvqxciqvjc&j’j&W”’qcsWjM’9Kj’vjq6W9j)Wqx’iqjkxz(jq6WjWrCWxcW&iWjq6’q
qzGxcvqvj’&)jxWvc)W&qvj’xWjvWWfc&”-jwW)ci’5j(’xc G’&’j)cvCW&v’xcWvj6’sWjxWiW&q59j3WW&jCWx(cqqW)jc&
q6WjBq’qWjzkjQ5zxc)’Kj’&)jq6WvWj(’9j6’sWj’jvc(c5’xjc(C’iqj’vjq6Wj’kzxW(W&qcz&W)jGvWv-j
•iW’&j“xcsWjcvjzkjC’xqciG5’xjiz&iWx&Kj)GWjqzjcqvjc(Czxq’&iWjqzjq6Wjpcq9avjqzGxcv(jc&)Gvqx9Kj’vjMW55j’v
cqvjG&ctGWj’xi6cqWiqGxWKjvc)WM’5fji’kHvKj’&)j3W’i6kxz&qj5zi’qcz&-j“GWjqzjq6Wj5zi’qcz&KjWrCzvGxWj’&)
vGiiWvvkG5j3x’&)c&”Kjq6Wj6z(z”W&coc&”jGvWvj6’sWj3Wiz(Wj6c”659j’qqx’iqcsWjkzxjCxzCWxq9jzM&WxvLj’
&G(3WxjzkjvGi6jGvWvj6’sWj’5xW’)9jzCW&W)jz&j•iW’&j“xcsWKjMcq6j(zxWjvWWfc&”jqzjzCW&-j1&jzx)Wxjqz
’))xWvvjq6cvjiz&iWx&Kjq6WjCxzCzvW)j•sWx5’9j“cvqxciqjCxz6c3cqvjq6WjCxWsczGv59j)Wvixc3W)jGvWvjkxz(
Page 54 of 230
zCW&c&”jz&jCxzCWxqcWvjq6’qjkxz&qj•iW’&j“xcsWjMcq6c&jq6Wj)cvqxciqj3zG&)’xcWv-j
R5oYSTkSkPm-Y
X6WjCxzCzvW)j•x)c&’&iWjMzG5)jWvq’35cv6jq6WjD4xqj“Wizj:jwcwzjpz((Wxic’5jp6’x’iqWxj•sWx5’9
“cvqxciq-gjX6Wj•sWx5’9jMzG5)j”W&Wx’559jizsWxj’xW’vjzkjBzGq6jSW’i6jkxz&qc&”j•iW’&j“xcsWj’&)jpz55c&v
4sW&GWj3WqMWW&jlq6jBqxWWqj’&)jIhq6jBqxWWq-j4))cqcz&’559Kjq6Wj’xW’vjzkj0zxq6jSW’i6jkxz&qc&”j•iW’&
XWxx’iWKjpz55c&vj4sW&GWKj’&)jé’x)c&”j4sW&GWj3WqMWW&j/bx)jBqxWWqj’&)j/lq6jBqxWWqj’xWj’5vz
c&i5G)W)-j
X6Wjkz55zMc&”jcvj’jvG((’x9jzkjq6WjxWscvW)jCxzscvcz&vjc&i5G)W)jc&jq6Wjzx)c&’&iW–j
Ojp6Wifjp’v6c&”jBqzxWv–jBGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&qvjv6’55j3WjCxz6c3cqW)jz&j5zqvjkxz&qc&”j•iW’&j“xcsWj’&)jc&
q6Wj•iW’&jXWxx’iW7é’x)c&”jXzM&vcqWj4xW’-j1&jq6WjxW(’c&c&”j’xW’vjzkjq6Wj•sWx5’9j“cvqxciqKjq6WxWjv6’55
3Wj&zj(zxWjq6’&jqMzjvGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&qv-jBGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&qvjv6’55j3Wj5zi’qW)j&zji5zvWxjq6’&jYKlNN
kWWqjkxz(j’&9jzq6WxjvGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&q-j
Ojpz&sW&cW&iWjBqzxWv–jBGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&qvjv6’55j3WjCxz6c3cqW)jz&j5zqvjkxz&qc&”j•iW’&j“xcsWKj’&)jc&
q6Wj•iW’&jXWxx’iW7é’x)c&”jXzM&vcqWj4xW’Kjq6WxWjv6’55j3Wj’j5c(cqjzkjz&WjmIdjvGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&q-j1&jq6W
xW(’c&c&”j’xW’vjzkjq6Wj•sWx5’9j“cvqxciqjq6WxWjv6’55j3Wj&zj(zxWjq6’&jkcsWvGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&qv-jBGi6
Wvq’35cv6(W&qvjv6’55j3Wj5zi’qW)j&zji5zvWxjq6’&jYKlNNjkWWqjkxz(j’&9jzq6WxjvGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&q-j
OjQzx(G5’jpz((Wxic’5–jBGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&qvjv6’55j3WjCxz6c3cqW)jz&j5zqvjkxz&qc&”j•iW’&j“xcsWj’&)
•iW’&jXWxx’iW-j
OjQzx(G5’j"Wvq’Gx’&qv–jBGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&qvjv6’55j3WjCxz6c3cqW)jz&j5zqvjkxz&qc&”j•iW’&j“xcsWjzx
•iW’&jXWxx’iW-j
Ojw’xc G’&’j)cvCW&v’xcWv–jExz6c3cqW)jc&j’55j’xW’v-j
Oj•iiG5qjBicW&iWjPvq’35cv6(W&qv–jExz6c3cqW)jc&jq6WjzsWx5’9j)cvqxciq-j
OjE’if’”Wj5ctGzxjvqzxWv–jBGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&qvjv6’55j3WjCxz6c3cqW)jz&j5zqvjc&jq6WjBzGq6jSW’i6j4xqj“Wiz
4xW’jMcq6j’&jG&)Wx59c&”jwTPjoz&c&”j)Wvc”&’qcz&j’&)jc&jq6Wj•iW’&jXWxx’iW7é’x)c&”jXzM&vcqWj4xW’-
1&jq6WjxW(’c&c&”j’xW’vjzkjq6Wj•sWx5’9j“cvqxciqjq6WxWjv6’55j3Wj&zj(zxWjq6’&jq6xWWjvGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&qv-
BGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&qvjv6’55j3Wj5zi’qW)j&zji5zvWxjq6’&jYKlNNjkWWqjkxz(j’&9jzq6WxjvGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&q-j
OjE’M&v6zCv–jExz6c3cqW)jc&j’55j’xW’v-j
OjE6’x(’i9jvqzxWv–jBGi6jGvWvjv6’55j3WjCxz6c3cqW)jz&j5zqvjkxz&qc&”j•iW’&j“xcsW-j1&jq6Wj•iW’&
XWxx’iW7é’x)c&”jXzM&vcqWj4xW’Kjq6WxWjv6’55j3Wj’j5c(cqjzkjz&WjmIdjvGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&q-j1&jq6WjxW(’c&c&”
’xW’vjzkjq6Wj•sWx5’9j“cvqxciqKjq6WxWjv6’55j3Wj&zj(zxWjq6’&jkcsWjmldjvGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&qv-jBGi6
Wvq’35cv6(W&qvjv6’55j3Wj5zi’qW)j&zji5zvWxjq6’&jYKlNNjkWWqjkxz(j’&9jzq6WxjvGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&q-j
OjBzGsW&cxj’&)jq.v6cxqjv6zCv–jBGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&qvjv6’55j3WjCxz6c3cqW)jz&j5zqvjkxz&qc&”j•iW’&j“xcsW
’&)jc&jq6Wj•iW’&jXWxx’iW7é’x)c&”jXzM&vcqWj4xW’-j1&jq6WjxW(’c&c&”j’xW’vjzkjq6Wj•sWx5’9j“cvqxciq
q6WxWjv6’55j3Wj&zj(zxWjq6’&jkcsWjmldjvGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&qv-jBGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&qvjv6’55j3Wj5zi’qW)j&z
i5zvWxjq6’&jYKlNNjkWWqjkxz(j’&9jzq6WxjvGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&q-j
OjX’qqzzjvqG)czv–jBGi6jGvWvjv6’55j3WjCxz6c3cqW)jz&j5zqvjkxz&qc&”j•iW’&j“xcsWj’&)jc&jq6Wj•iW’&
XWxx’iW7é’x)c&”jXzM&vcqWj4xW’-j1&jq6WjxW(’c&c&”j’xW’vjzkjq6Wj•sWx5’9j“cvqxciqjq6WxWjv6’55j3Wj&zj(zxW
q6’&jq6xWWjmbdjvGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&qv-j
Page 55 of 230
4))cqcz&’559Kjq6Wj•sWx5’9jMzG5)jCxz6c3cqjs’xc’&iWvjzkjq6WvWjxW”G5’qcz&v-j1qj’5vzjWvq’35cv6Wvj(c&c(G(
vG3(cqq’5jxWtGcxW(W&qvjqzj’55zMjpcq9jvq’kkjqzjW&vGxWjiz(C5c’&iWjMcq6jq6WvWjxW”G5’qcz&v-j
S-mggugcYskmT.YToauonY
•&jZ’&G’x9jYAKjYNI/Kjq6WjE5’&&c&”jSz’x)jqx’&v(cqqW)jq6WjCxzCzvW)j•x)c&’&iWj4(W&)(W&qjqzjq6W
pcq9jpz((cvvcz&KjMcq6j’jk’szx’35WjxWiz((W&)’qcz&-jX6WjE5’&&c&”jSz’x)j’5vzjxWiz((W&)W)jq6’qjq6W
pcq9jpz((cvvcz&jiz&vc)Wxjq6Wjkz55zMc&”j(z)ckci’qcz&vjqzjq6Wjzx)c&’&iW–j
IdjExz6c3cqjw’vv’”WjE’x5zxvjq6’qjzCWx’qWj’qj&c”6qjMcq6c&jq6WjzsWx5’9-j
Ydjwz)ck9jq6Wj)Wkc&cqcz&jzkjpz&sW&cW&iWjvqzxWjqzjxW(zsWj6zGxvjzkjzCWx’qcz&j’&)jq6WjqWx(jDCxWC’xW)
kzz)vg-j
bdj1&ixW’vWjq6Wj&G(3WxjzkjWvq’35cv6(W&qvjxWtGcxW)jkzxjkzx(G5’jxWvq’Gx’&qvjkxz(jINNjqzjANN
Wvq’35cv6(W&qv-j
Adjwz)ck9jq6WjixcqWxc’jkzxjkzx(G5’jxWq’c5jWvq’35cv6(W&qvjqzjz&59jCxz6c3cqjWvq’35cv6(W&qvjMcq6jkcsWjzxj(zxW
5zi’qcz&vjMcq6c&jwc’(cjSW’i6-j
Qzxj&zqciWjCGxCzvWvKjq6Wj’qq’i6W)j)x’kqjzkjq6Wjzx)c&’&iWjkzxjkcxvqjxW’)c&”jc&i5G)Wvjq6W
xWiz((W&)’qcz&jCWxq’c&c&”jqzj(’vv’”WjC’x5zxvjm(’vv’”Wjq6Wx’C9jiW&qWxvdKj’vjq6cvjxWtGcxW)j’ji6’&”W
qzjq6Wjqcq5WKj’vjMW55j’vjq6Wj(c&zxjqWrqji6’&”Wvj’kkWiqc&”jq6Wj)Wkc&cqcz&jzkjiz&sW&cW&iWjvqzxWv-j1kjq6Wjpcq9
pz((cvvcz&j)Wic)Wvj&zqjqzj(zsWjkzxM’x)jMcq6jq6WvWjC’xqciG5’xjxWiz((W&)’qcz&vKjq6Wjzx)c&’&iWji’&
3Wj(z)ckcW)jkzxjvWiz&)jxW’)c&”j39jxW(zsc&”jq6W(-
j
PpbbmT YiYpS.mRo
•&jw’xi6jIKjYNI/Kjq6WjcqW(jM’vjzCW&W)j’&)jiz&qc&GW)jqzj’j)’qWjiWxq’c&jzkjw’xi6jYYKjYNI/-j•&jw’xi6jYYKjYNI/Kjq6W
•x)c&’&iWjM’vjzCW&W)j’&)jiz&qc&GW)jqzj’j)’qWjiWxq’c&jzkj4Cxc5jYhKjYNI/-jX6Wjpz((cvvcz&j’5vzjxWtGWvqW)jq6W
kz55zMc&”j3WjCxzsc)W)–j
I-j4j)cvq’&iWjvWC’x’qcz&jkzxjX’qqzzjBqG)czvjvzjq6’qjvGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&qvjv6’55j3Wj5zi’qW)j&zji5zvWxjq6’&jYKlNNjkWWq
kxz(j’&9jzq6WxjvGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&q-
j
Y-jX6WjCxWC’x’qcz&jzkj’j(’xfWqj7jWiz&z(cij’&’59vcvjvqG)9jCWxq’c&c&”jqzjq6Wjkzx(G5’jxWq’c5j’&)jxWvq’Gx’&qjCzxqcz&jzk
q6Wj5W”cv5’qcz&-jBGi6jvqG)9jMc55jq’fWjc&qzj’iizG&qjM6Wq6Wxjq6WxWj’xWj’&9jq6xWv6z5)j)ckkWxW&iWvj3WqMWW&j•iW’&
“xcsWj’&)j•iW’&jXWxx’iW-jS’vW)jGCz&jq6WjxWvG5qvjzkjq6Wj(’xfWqj7jWiz&z(cijvqG)9Kj’))cqcz&’5j)cviGvvcz&j’&)
xWkc&W(W&qjzkjq6Wj&G(3Wxjzkjkzx(G5’jxWq’c5jWvq’35cv6(W&qvjv6zG5)j3Wjiz&vc)WxW)-
j
X6Wj)cvq’&iWjvWC’x’qcz&jxWtGcxW(W&qjkzxjX’qqzzjBqG)czvj6’vj3WW&jc&izxCzx’qW)jc&qzjq6WjxWscvW)j)x’kqjzkjq6W
zx)c&’&iW-jj•&j4Cxc5jYhKjYNI/Kjq6WjvG3 Wiqjzx)c&’&iWjM’vjiz&qc&GW)jqzj’j)’qWjiWxq’c&jzkjw’9jI/KjYNI/-j•&jw’9jI/K
YNI/Kjq6WjcqW(jM’vjzCW&W)j’&)jiz&qc&GW)jqzj’j)’qWjiWxq’c&jzkjZG&Wj/KjYNI/-jj
j
•&jZG&Wj/KjYNI/Kjq6WjvG3 Wiqj•x)c&’&iWjM’vj’CCxzsW)j’qjQcxvqj"W’)c&”-jX6Wjpcq9j6cxW)jwx-j4&)9j“z5f’xqjqzjCxWC’xW
’&jWiz&z(cij7j(’xfWqj’&’59vcvLj’qq’i6W)jcvjq6Wjkc&’5jxWCzxq-jj1&jvG((’x9Kjq6Wjiz&vG5q’&qjiz&i5G)W)jq6Wjkz55zMc&”–
j
4jxWscWMjzkj(’&9jzq6Wxjkzx(G5’jxWvq’Gx’&qjzx)c&’&iWvjc&)ci’qWvjq6’qjq6WjCxzCzvW)jzx)c&’&iWjMzG5)j3Wjq6Wj5W’vq
3Gx)W&vz(WKj’vj(zvqj5c(cqjkzx(G5’jxWvq’Gx’&qvjqzjIljzxjkWMWxjWvq’35cv6(W&qv-
X6WxWj’xWjANjW’qc&”j’&)j)xc&fc&”jWvq’35cv6(W&qvjc&jq6WjvG3 Wiqj’xW’-
•&59jq6xWWjMzG5)jtG’5ck9j’vj’jkzx(G5’jxWvq’Gx’&qjCGxvG’&qjqzjq6WjCxzCzvW)jzx)c&’&iWj)GWjqzjq6Wj&G(3Wx
zkjWvq’35cv6(W&qvjq6W9j6’sWjq6xzG”6zGqjq6WjizG&qx9-jBcrjWvq’35cv6(W&qvj’xWji6’c&vj3GqjMzG5)j&zqjtG’5ck9
’vj’jkzx(G5’jWvq’35cv6(W&qjCGxvG’&qjqzjq6WjCxzCzvW)jzx)c&’&iW-
QWMjxWvq’Gx’&qvjiGxxW&q59jzCWx’qc&”jz&j•iW’&j“xcsWj’xWji6’c&.’kkc5c’qW)j)GWjqzjWrcvqc&”j)Wvc”&j’&)j6cvqzxci
CxWvWxs’qcz&jxWtGcxW(W&qvj’&)j”Gc)W5c&WvKj’vjMW55j’vjzq6Wxj’Wvq6Wqcij5c(cq’qcz&vKjc&i5G)c&”jq6WjBWixWq’x9jzk
1&qWxczxjBq’&)’x)v-j
Page 56 of 230
p6’c&jxWvq’Gx’&qvj”W&Wx’559ji6zzvWjqzj5zi’qWjc&jvc&”5W.GvWxj3Gc5)c&”vjzxjv6zCCc&”jiW&qWxvjq6’qjCxzsc)WjW’v9
’Gqz(z3c5Wj’iiWvvj’&)jvW5k.vWxsWjC’xfc&”-
4&j’&’59vcvjzkjbbyji6’c&jxWvq’Gx’&qvjzCWx’qc&”jc&jq6WjU&cqW)jBq’qWvjc&)ci’qWvjq6Wjkz55zMc&”–
IVlj3x’&)vjzCWx’qWjk’vqjkzz)jxWvq’Gx’&qvj’&)7zxjCcoo’jv6zCvj’&)jMzG5)j5cfW59j&zqjM’&qj5zi’qWjz&j•iW’&
“xcsWj)GWjqzjq6WcxjCxWkWxW&iWjkzxj3Wc&”j5zi’qW)jc&j3Gc5)c&”vjMcq6jW’v9j’Gqz(z3c5Wj’iiWvvKjvW5k.vWxsW
C’xfc&”Kjzxj)xcsW.q6xGv-j
IhAj3x’&)vjk’55jc&qzj’js’xcWq9jzkji’qW”zxcWvjc&jqWx(vjzkjiGcvc&Wj’&)j’(3c’&iW-
VAj6’sWj5Wvvjq6’&jINNjWvq’35cv6(W&qvj’&)jizG5)j3Wj5zi’qW)jz&j•iW’&j“xcsW-
hNjzkjq6WvWj6’sWj(zxWjq6’&jINNjWvq’35cv6(W&qvj’&)jMzG5)j6’sWjqzj(’fWj(z)ckci’qcz&vjCGxvG’&q
qzjq6Wjzx)c&’&iWjqzjzCWx’qWjz&j•iW’&j“xcsW-
X6Wjzx)c&’&iWjCxzsc)WvjixcqWxc’jkzxjvGi6jWvq’35cv6(W&qvjqzj(’fWj(z)ckci’qcz&vjq6’qjMzG5)j’55zMjq6W(jqzj5zi’qW
c&jq6Wj’kkWiqW)j’xW’-
X6WjCxzCzvW)jzx)c&’&iWjMc55j&zqj(’fWjcqjc(Czvvc35Wjqzjkc55js’i’&qjvC’iWvj’&)jcqvj’)zCqcz&jMc55j&zqj’)sWxvW59
c(C’iqjq6Wjpcq9jzkjwc’(cjSW’i6jqzj’&9jvc”&ckci’&qj)W”xWWjc&jqWx(vjzkj5zvvjzkj z3vjzxjkcvi’559jc&jqWx(vjzkj5zvvjzk
’)js’5zxW(jq’rjxWsW&GW-jjjjjjjj
j
S’vW)jGCz&jq6Wjkc&)c&”vjzkjq6Wj’qq’i6W)jWiz&z(cij7j(’xfWqj’&’59vcvKjq6Wj4)(c&cvqx’qcz&jxWiz((W&)vjq6’qjq6W
•x)c&’&iWj3Wj’)zCqW)-
lkgl-pPukg
X6Wj4)(c&cvqx’qcz&jxWiz((W&)vjq6’qjq6Wjpcq9jpz((cvvcz&j’)zCqjq6Wj•x)c&’&iW-j
-KN/BCVd/rKYRvVGO/WN
E5’&&c&”
PUEWBEv
pz((cvvcz&Wxj"cif9j4xxcz5’
mRRml5bogRP3
.KBGv/Ud/EW
•x)c&’&iW
“z5f’xqjQc&’5j"WCzxq
“z5f’xqj.j4CCW&)ciWv
4)
Page 57 of 230
ART DECO I MIMO COMMERCIAL CHARACTER AND FORMULA COMMERCIAL
OVERLAY DISTRICT
ORDINANCE NO. _____ _
AN ORDINANCE OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, AMENDING CHAPTER 114 OF
THE CITY CODE, ENTITLED "GENERAL PROVISIONS," TO PROVIDE
FOR DEFINITIONS FOR "CHECK CASHING STORE," "CONVENIENCE
STORE," "FORMULA RESTAURANT," "FORMULA COMMERCIAL
ESTABLISHMENTS," "MARIJUANA DISPENSARY," "CANNABIS
DISPENSARY," "OCCULT SCIENCE ESTABLISHMENT,"
"PHARMACY," "SOUVENIR AND T-SHIRT SHOP," "TATTOO
STUDIO," "MASSAGE THERAPY CENTER," AND RELATED
DEFINITIONS; AMENDING CHAPTER 142 OF THE CITY CODE,
ENTITLED "ZONING DISTRICTS AND REGULATIONS," AT ARTICLE
111, ENTITLED "OVERLAY DISTRICTS," TO ESTABLISH DIVISION 12,
ENTITLED "ART DECO I MIMO COMMERCIAL CHARACTER
OVERLAY DISTRICT," TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL REGULATIONS
FOR THE AFOREMENTIONED USES, INCLUDING DISTANCE
SEPARATION REQUIREMENTS, LIMITATIONS ON NUMBER OF
ESTABLISHMENTS, AND PROHIBITIONS UNDER CERTAIN
CIRCUMSTANCES; PROVIDING FOR REPEALER; SEVERABILITY;
CODIFICATION; AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, properties fronting Ocean Drive and Collins Avenue that have a zoning
designation of MXE Mixed Use Entertainment are located in the Ocean Drive/Collins Avenue
Historic District, as well as the Miami Beach Architectural National Register Historic District; and
WHEREAS, properties fronting Washington Avenue that have a zoning designation of
CD-2 Com.mercial Medium Intensity District, are located in the Flamingo Park Historic District
and the Miami Beach Architectural National Register Historic District; and
WHEREAS, Ocean Drive, Collins Avenue, and Washington Avenue are some of the
premier streets in Miami Beach and provide residents and visitors with a unique cultural, retail,
and dining experience and are vital to Miami Beach's economy, especially the tourism industry;
and
WHEREAS, properties fronting Ocean Terrace and Collins Avenue between 73rd and
75th Streets are within the Harding Townsite Historic District and the North Shore National
Register Historic District; and
WHEREAS, properties fronting Harding Avenue between 73rd and 75th Streets are within
North Shore National Register Historic District; and
WHEREAS, the City of Miami Beach has undertaken a master planning process for the
North Beach area that includes the Harding Townsite Historic District and North Shore National
Register District, in order to encourage the revitalization of the area by improving cultural, retail,
and dining experiences for residents and visitors to the area; and
Page 58 of 230
WHEREAS, formula commercial establishments and formula restaurants are
establishments with multiple locations and standardized features or a recognizable appearance,
where recognition is dependent upon the repetition of the same characteristics of one store in
multiple locations; and
WHEREAS, formula commercial establishments and formula restaurants are increasing
in number along Ocean Drive and within other historic districts; and
WHEREAS, the sameness of formula commercial establishments, while providing clear
branding for retailers, counters the City's Vision Statement which includes creating "A Unique
Urban and Historic Environment"; and
WHEREAS, notwithstanding the marketability of a retailer's goods or services or the
visual attractiveness of the storefront, the standardized architecture, color schemes, decor and
signage of many formula commercial establishments detract from the distinctive character and
aesthetics of the historic districts; and
WHEREAS, the increase of formula commercial establishments hampers the unique
cultural, retail, and dining experience in commercial and mixed-use areas of the City's historic
districts; and
WHEREAS, specifically, the proliferation of formula commercial establishments may
unduly limit or eliminate business establishment opportunities for non-traditional or unique
businesses, thereby decreasing the diversity of cultural, retail, and dining services available to
residents and visitors; and
WHEREAS, the homogenizing effect of formula commercial establishments based on its
reliance on standardized branding, is greater if the size of the establishment, in number of
locations or size of use or branded elements is larger; and
WHEREAS, the increased level of homogeneity detracts from the uniqueness of the
historic districts, which thrive on a high level of interest maintained by a mix of cultural, retail,
and dining experiences that are not found elsewhere in the country; and
WHEREAS, sidewalk cafes are central to the economy of Ocean Drive and enhance the
pedestrian experience and historic and cosmopolitan character of the street; and
WHEREAS, it is not the intent of the City to limit interstate commerce, but rather to
maintain the historic character of neighborhoods and promote their unique cultural, retail, and
dining experiences that are vital to the City's economy; and
WHEREAS, it is the intent of the City that if an establishment that has multiple locations
and standardized features or a recognizable appearance seeks to locate within certain areas
affected by this ordinance that such establishment provide a distinct array of merchandise,
fa<;:ade, decor, color scheme, uniform apparel, signs, logos, trademarks, and service marks; and
WHEREAS, convenience stores, pharmacy stores and eating establishments have
similar impacts as formula stores; and
Page 59 of 230
WHEREAS, check cashing stores, pawnshops, souvenir and !-shirt shops, tattoo
studios, fortune tellers (occult science establishments), massage therapy center, and package
liquor stores are uses which negatively affect surrounding areas; and
WHEREAS, it is the intent of the City to limit the number of establishments which may
negatively affect surrounding areas; and
WHEREAS, the amendments set forth below are necessary to accomplish the objectives
identified herein.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF
THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA.
SECTION 1. Chapter 114 of the City Code, entitled "General Provisions," is hereby amended
as follows:
Sec. 114-1. Definitions.
CHAPTER 114
GENERAL PROVISIONS
The following words, terms and phrases when used in this subpart B, shall have the meanings
ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning:
* * *
Check cashing store means a business which cashes checks or exchanges currency on
a regular basis for a fee. This definition does not include banks, which may cash checks in
addition to providing other financial services such as, but not limited to, money savings accounts,
loan services, and checking accounts.
* *
*
Convenience store means a retail store with direct access from the street or sidewalk
containing less than 6,000 square feet of floor area that is designed and stocked to sell primarily
food (packaged), beverages, newspapers, magazines, and other household supplies to
customers who generally purchase a relatively few number of items (in contrast to a "grocery
store" or "super market"). It is designed to attract and depends upon a large turnover of
customers.
Establishment, as used in the definitions of Formula restaurant and Formula commercial
establishment, means a place of business with a specific store name or specific brand.
Establishment refers to the named store or brand and not to the owner or manager of the store
or brand. As an example, if a clothing store company owns four (4) brands under its ownership
umbrella and each branded store has 10 locations, the term "Establishment" would refer only to
those stores that have the same name or brand.
*
* *
Page 60 of 230
Formula restaurant means (i) a restaurant with 100 or more establishments in operation
or with approved development orders in the United States or a restaurant with more than five (5)
establishments in operation or with approved development orders in Miami Beach. With respect
to the preceding sentence. in addition to the numerical thresholds the establishments maintain
two (2) or more of the following features: a standardized (formula) array of merchandise: a
standardized facade; a standardized decor or color scheme; uniform apparel for service
providers, food. beverages or uniforms: standardized signs. logos. trademarks or service marks.
For the purpose of this definition, the following shall apply:
(1) Standardized (formula) array of merchandise or food means that 50 percent or more of
in-stock merchandise or food is from a single distributor and bears uniform markings.
(2) Trademark means any word. name. symbol, or device, or any combination thereof. used
by a person to identify and distinguish the goods of such person, including a unique
product, from those manufactured or sold by others, and to indicate the source of the
goods, even if the source is unknown. A trademark may be registered with the U.S.
Patent and Trademark Office and/or the Florida Department of State. However. an
unregistered trademark may also be protected under common law.
(3) Service mark means any word, name. symbol, or device. or any combination thereof,
used by a person to identify and distinguish the services of such person, including a
unique service, from the services of others. and to indicate the source of the services,
even if that source is unknown. Titles, character names. and other distinctive features of
radio or television programs may be registered as service marks notwithstanding that the
person or the programs may advertise the goods of the sponsor. A service mark may be
registered with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office and/or the Florida Department of
State. However, an unregistered service mark may also be protected under common
law.
(4) Decor means the style of interior or exterior furnishings, which may include but is not
limited to, style of furniture. wall coverings or permanent fixtures.
(5) Color scheme means the selection of colors used throughout, such as on the
furnishings. permanent fixtures, and wall coverings. or as used on the facade.
(6) Facade means a face (usually the front) of a building, including awnings, that looks onto
a street or an open space.
(7) Uniform food, beverages or apparel/uniforms means standardized items of clothing
including but not limited to standardized aprons. pants, shirts, smocks or dresses, hats,
and pins (other than name tags) as well as standardized colors of clothing, food or
beverages. listed on the menus of such establishments or standardized uniforms worn by
employees.
*
* *
Formula commercial establishment means a commercial use. excluding office.
restaurant and hotel use, that has ten (10) or more retail sales establishments in operation or
with approved development orders in the United States of America; provided, however. for
those businesses located in a building that is two (2) stories or less with frontage on Ocean
Drive, formula commercial establishment means a commercial use. excluding office. restaurant
Page 61 of 230
and hotel, which has five (5) or more other establishments in operation or with approved
development orders in Miami Beach. In addition to meeting or exceeding the numerical
thresholds in the preceding sentence. the definition of formula commercial establishment also
means an establishment that maintains two or more of the following features: a standardized
(formula) array of merchandise; a standardized facade; a standardized decor or color scheme:
uniform apparel; standardized signs. logos. trademarks or service marks. For the purpose of
this definition, the following shall apply:
(1) Standardized (formula) array of merchandise means that 50 percent or more of in-stock
merchandise is from a single distributor and bears uniform markings.
(2) Trademark means any word, name, symbol. or device, or any combination thereof. used
by a person to identify and distinguish the goods of such person, including a unique
product, from those manufactured or sold by others, and to indicate the source of the
goods, even if the source is unknown. A trademark may be registered with the U.S.
Patent and Trademark Office and/or the Florida Department of State. However, an
unregistered trademark may also be protected under common law.
(3) Service mark means any word, name. symbol, or device. or any combination thereof.
used by a person to identify and distinguish the services of such person. including a
unique service, from the services of others, and to indicate the source of the services,
even if that source is unknown. Titles. character names, and other distinctive features of
radio or television programs may be registered as service marks notwithstanding that the
person or the programs may advertise the goods of the sponsor. A service mark may be
registered with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office and/or the Florida Department of
State. However. an unregistered service mark may also be protected under common
law.
(4) Decor means the style of interior or exterior furnishings, which may include but is not
limited to. style of furniture. wall coverings or permanent fixtures.
(5) Color scheme means the selection of colors used throughout, such as on the
furnishings, permanent fixtures, and wall coverings, or as used on the facade.
(6) Facade means a face (usually the front) of a building, including awnings, that looks onto
a street or an open space.
(7) Uniform apparel means standardized items of clothing including but not limited to
standardized aprons. pants, shirts. smocks or dresses. hats. and pins (other than name
tags) as well as standardized colors of clothing.
* *
*
Grocery store means a retail store with direct access from the street or sidewalk
containing 6,000 or more square feet of floor area that primarily sells food, including canned and
frozen foods, fresh fruits and vegetables, and fresh (raw) and prepared meats. fish, and poultry.
* * *
Page 62 of 230
Marijuana dispensary or Cannabis dispensary means a building, structure, or other
facility where marijuana or cannabis, inclusive of medical cannabis, and cannabis delivery
devices, are dispensed at retail.
* * *
Massaae therapv center means an establishment that offers, sells or provides
manipulations of the tissues or other tactile stimulation of the human body with the hand. foot
arm leg elbow or part of the torso. whether or not aided by any electrical or mechanical
device: and may include bathing hydrotherapy. thermal therapy. or application of chemicals
oils lotions or similar preparations to the human body
* * *
Occult science establishment shall mean an establishment engaged in the occupation of
a fortune teller. palmist, astrologist, numerologist, clairvoyant. craniologist, phrenologist, card
reader, spiritual reader, tea leaf reader, prophet, psychic or advisor or who in any other manner
claims or pretends to tell fortunes. or claims or pretends to disclose mental faculties of
individuals for any form of compensation. Nothing contained herein shall be construed to apply
to a person pretending to act as a fortune teller in a properly licensed theater as part of any
show or exhibition presented therein or as part of any play, exhibition, fair or show presented or
offered in aide of any benevolent, charitable or educational purpose.
* * *
Pharmacv store means a store with direct access from the street or sidewalk, containing
a minimum of 3,500 sguare feet. where medicinal drugs reguiring a prescription from a gualified
medical professional are dispensed and sold and that operates at a minimum between the
hours of 9:00 AM and 10:00 PM and is also designed and stocked to sell health and wellness
products. food (packaged and/or prepared), beverages, newspapers, magazines, and other
household supplies to customers who generally purchase relatively few number of items (in
contrast to a "grocery store" or "super market").
* * *
Souvenirs are items. exclusive of books, magazines or maps, which serve as a token of
remembrance of Miami Beach or any geographic areas in Florida and which bear the name of
the City or geographic areas or streets thereof or of events associated with Miami Beach or
South Florida.
*
* *
Souvenir and I-shirt shop means any business with direct access from the street or
sidewalk in which the retail sale of T-shirts or souvenirs or both is conducted as a principal use
of the business, or together with some other business activity, but which constitutes the primary,
or is the major attraction to the business.
* *
*
Supermarket. (See "Grocery store.")
* * *
Page 63 of 230
Tattoo studio means any establishment. place of business, or location. other than a
licensed medical facility, an office or clinic of a licensed medical professional. or a duly licensed
beauty shop or barber shop, wherein adornment of any part of the human body or head.
whether artistic. cosmetic or otherwise. is practiced through the use of needles, scalpels. or any
other instruments designed to touch, penetrate or puncture the skin for purposes of: (1) inserting,
attaching or suspending jewelry, decorations or other foreign objects; (2) producing an indelible
mark or figure on the human body or face by scarring skin or flesh; (3) producing an indelible
mark or figure on the human body or face by inserting a pigment under or upon the skin; or (4)
permanently changing the color or other appearance of the skin. This term shall not. however,
include piercing an ear with a disposable, single-use stud or solid needle that is applied using a
mechanical device to force the needle or stud through the ear.
*
* *
T-shirt is any garment or article of clothing which has no collar, including, but not limited
to, T-shirts, sweat shirts, tank tops, shirts or scrub shirts, which are designed or intended
generally to be worn on or over the chest and containing any communicative verbiage, graphics,
or images imprinted or to be imprinted on the garment or article of clothing, exclusive of a
garment manufacturer's mark or logo, exclusive of decorative words and information woven or
dyed in the fabric by the manufacturer of the fabric. exclusive of hand stitched, needle work or
embroidery, exclusive of tie-dye garments, and exclusive of hand painted or air-brushed
garments that contain no communicative verbiage, graphics or images.
* * *
Section 2. Chapter 142 of the City Code, entitled "Zoning Districts and Regulations," at Article
Ill, entitled "Overlay Districts," is hereby amended as follows:
DIVISION 12 -ART DECO I MIMO COMMERCIAL CHARACTER OVERLAY DISTRICT
Sec. 142-870.10. -Location and purpose.
@l. There is hereby created the Art Deco I Mimo Commercial Character Overlay District (the
"Overlay District"). The Overlay District consists of the properties in the South Beach Art
Deco Area identified in the map below in this subsection (a) and the properties identified
in the Ocean Terrace I Harding Townsite Area described in subsection (bl below. The
South Beach Art Deco Area is generally located east of the western lot lines of properties
fronting the west side of Collins Avenue between 5th Street to the south and 16th street to
the north and west of the ocean:
Page 64 of 230
Ail antic
.Ocean
_(Q). The Ocean Terrace I Harding Townsite Area is identified in the map below and is
generally located between Harding Avenue to the west and Ocean Terrace to the east,
between
73rd and 75"' Streets:
Page 65 of 230
EEJEEJ
a· <m ••
~·-
{fl The purpose of this Overlay District is to limit the proliferation of uses which may diminish
the character of historic commercial areas within the City. This Overlay District is
designed based on and intended to achieve the following facts and intents:
~ Properties fronting Ocean Drive and Collins Avenue that have a zoning designation
of MXE Mixed Use Entertainment are located in the Ocean Drive/Collins Avenue
Historic District, as well as the Miami Beach Architectural National Register Historic
District;
Q,_ Properties fronting Washington Avenue that have a zoning designation of CD-2
Commercial Medium Intensity District, are located in the Flamingo Park Historic
District and the Miami Beach Architectural National Register Historic District;
c. Ocean Drive, Collins Avenue, and Washington Avenue are some of the premier
streets in Miami Beach and provide residents and visitors with a unigue cultural.
retail. and dining experience and are vital to Miami Beach's economy, especially the
tourism industry;
Q,_ Properties fronting Ocean Terrace and Collins Avenue between 73rd and 75th Streets
are within the Harding Townsite Historic District and the North Shore National
Register Historic District:
e. Properties fronting Harding Avenue between 73rd and 75th Streets are within North
Shore National Register Historic District; and
t. The City of Miami Beach has undertaken a master planning process for the North
Beach area that includes the Harding Townsite Historic District and North Shore
National Register District, in order to encourage the revitalization of the area by
improving cultural, retail, and dining experiences for residents and visitors to the
area:
Page 66 of 230
~ Formula commercial establishments and formula restaurants are establishments with
multiple locations and standardized features or a recognizable appearance. where
recognition is dependent upon the repetition of the same characteristics of one store
in multiple locations;
h.. Formula commercial establishments and formula restaurants are increasing in
number along Ocean Drive and within other historic districts:
l.. The sameness of formula commercial establishments, while providing clear branding
for retailers. counters the City's Vision Statement which includes creating "A Unique
Urban and Historic Environment":
1 Notwithstanding the marketability of a retailer's goods or services or the visual
attractiveness of the storefront, the standardized architecture, color schemes, decor
and signage of many formula commercial establishments detract from the distinctive
character and aesthetics of the historic districts: and
k. The increase of formula commercial establishments hampers the unique cultural,
retail, and dining experience in commercial and mixed-use areas of the City's historic
districts; and
h Specifically, the proliferation of formula commercial establishments may unduly limit
or eliminate business establishment opportunities for non-traditional or unique
businesses, thereby decreasing the diversity of cultural, retail, and dining services
available to residents and visitors: and
m. The homogenizing effect of formula commercial establishments based on its reliance
on standardized branding, is greater if the size of the establishment, in number of
locations or size of use or branded elements is larger;
11. The increased level of homogeneity detracts from the uniqueness of the historic
districts, which thrive on a high level of interest maintained by a mix of cultural, retail,
and dining experiences that are not found elsewhere in the country;
Q,, Sidewalk cafes are central to the economy of Ocean Drive and enhance the
pedestrian experience and historic and cosmopolitan character of the street;
_p_,_ It is not the intent of the City to limit interstate commerce, but rather to maintain the
historic character of neighborhoods and promote their unique cultural, retail, and
dining experiences that are vital to the City's economy;
g_,_ It is the intent of the City that if an establishment that has multiple locations and
standardized features or a recognizable appearance seeks to locate within certain
areas affected by this ordinance that such establishment provide a distinct array of
merchandise, facade, decor, color scheme, uniform apparel, signs, logos,
trademarks, and service marks;
L. Convenience stores, pharmacy stores and eating establishments have similar
impacts as formula stores:
Page 67 of 230
s. Check cashing stores, pawnshops, souvenir and \-shirt shops, tattoo studios, fortune
tellers (occult science establishments), massage therapy center, and package liquor
stores are uses which negatively affect surrounding areas; and
t. It is the intent of the City to limit the number of establishments which may negatively
affect surrounding areas.
Sec. 142-870.11. -Compliance with regulations.
The following regulations shall apply to the Overlay District. There shall be no variances
allowed from these regulations. All development regulations in the underlying zoning district
and any other applicable overlay regulations shall apply. except as follows:
@l The following limitations shall apply to the commercial uses listed below:
ill Check cashing stores shall comply with the following regulations:
£,. Such establishments shall be prohibited on lots fronting Ocean Drive and in the
Ocean Terrace/Harding Townsite Area.
b. In areas of the Overlay District not inciuded in subsection a. above, there shall be no
more than two (2) such establishments. Such establishments shall be located no
closer than 2,500 feet from any other such establishment.
ill Convenience stores shall comply with the following regulations:
£,. Such establishments shall be prohibited on lots fronting Ocean Drive.
b. In the Ocean Terrace/Harding Townsite Area, there shall be a limit of one (1) such
establishment.
s;,_ In areas of the Overlay District not included in subsection a. and b. above, there shall
be no more than five (5) such establishments. Such establishments shall be located
no closer than 2,500 feet from any other such establishment.
Ql Formula commercial establishments shall comply with the following regulations:
a. Such establishments shall be prohibited on lots fronting Ocean Drive and Ocean
Terrace.
Q,_ This subsection shall not apply to any establishments in the South Beach Art Deco
Area other than establishments fronting Ocean Drive nor to any establishment in the
Ocean Terrace/Harding Townsite Area, other than Ocean Terrace.
Bl. Formula restaurants shall comply with the following regulations:
a. Such establishments shall be prohibited on lots fronting Ocean Drive and Ocean
Terrace.
Page 68 of 230
Q.,_ This subsection shall not apply to any establishments in the South Beach Art Deco
Area other than establishments fronting Ocean Drive nor to any establishment in the
Ocean Terrace/Harding Townsite Area, other than Ocean Terrace.
ffil Massage therapy centers shall not operate between 9:00 pm and 7:00 am in the Overlay
District
{fil Marijuana dispensaries shall be prohibited in the Overlay District.
ill Occult science establishments shall be prohibited in the Overlay District.
{fil Package stores shall comply with the following regulations:
.<!,, Such establishments shall be prohibited on lots in the South Beach Art Deco Area
with an underlying MXE zoning designation and in the Ocean Terrace/Harding
Townsite Area.
Q.,_ In areas of the Overlay District not included in subsection a. above, there shall be no
more than three (3) such establishments. Such establishments shall be located no
closer than 2,500 feet from any other such establishment.
{fil Pawnshops shall be prohibited in the Overlay District.
{1Ql Pharmacy stores shall comply with the following regulations:
a. Such uses shall be prohibited on lots fronting Ocean Drive.
Q.,_ In the Ocean Terrace/Harding Townsite Area, there shall be a limit of one (1) such
establishment.
c. In areas of the overlay district not included in subsection a. and b. above. there shall
be no more than five (5) such establishments. Such establishments shall be located
no closer than 2,500 feet from any other such establishment.
{11l Souvenir and !-shirt shops shall comply with the following regulations:
.<!,, Such establishments shall be prohibited on lots fronting Ocean Drive and in the
Ocean Terrace/Harding Townsite Area.
Q.,_ In areas of the overlay district not included in subsection a. above, there shall be
no more than five (5) such establishments. Such establishments shall be located
no closer than 2,500 feet from any other such establishment.
l.:1ll. Tattoo studios shall comply with the following regulations:
a. Such uses shall be prohibited on lots fronting Ocean Drive and in the Ocean
Terrace/Harding Townsite Area.
Page 69 of 230