Resolution 2021-31552 RESOLUTION NO. 2021-31552
A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, APPROVING THE INTERIM CITY MANAGER'S
RECOMMENDATION AND AUTHORIZING A MODIFICATION AND REDESIGN
OF THE LINCOLN ROAD REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT, REVISING THE
SCOPE OF THE PROJECT SO THAT IT CAN BE COMPLETED WITHIN THE
ALLOCATED TOTAL BUDGET OF $52.4 MILLION; AND FURTHER
AUTHORIZING THE ADMINISTRATION TO NEGOTIATE AN AMENDMENT TO
THE AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY'S CONSULTANT, JAMES CORNER FIELD
OPERATIONS, WITH SAID AMENDMENT SUBJECT TO PRIOR APPROVAL
BY THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION.
WHEREAS, on March 9, 2016, pursuant to the development and approval of the Lincoln
Road Master Plan, the City Commission adopted Resolution No. 2016-29319, awarding the
contract for Architectural and Engineering Design Services for the Lincoln Road Redevelopment
Project to James Corner Field Operations (JCFO) and on June 8, 2016, pursuant to RFQ 2016-
073-KB, the City Commission adopted Resolution No. 2016-29447, awarding a Construction
Manager At Risk (CMAR) contract for pre-construction services, to Burkhardt Construction, Inc.;
and
WHEREAS, on October 28, 2016, following the completion of the Schematic Design
Phase and Value Engineering efforts, the project team presented the design and estimated costs
to the Finance and Citywide Projects Committee,which gave direction to the project team to forgo
the value engineering options and design to the Master Plan recommendations; and
WHEREAS, the overall project construction cost for the proposed improvements, as
prepared by Burkhardt Construction at 50% Construction Document submittal, included, without
limitation, costs of construction, labor, materials and contractor fee, and contingency; and
WHEREAS, City staff included in the total project cost, the cost of plans, specifications
and surveys, architecture and engineering, legal expenses, permit fees, and owner's contingency
and the total project cost for the Lincoln Road Redevelopment Project was projected to be
approximately$77.4 million; and
WHEREAS, the proposed project included Lincoln Road, from Lenox Avenue to
Washington Avenue; Lincoln Road, from Washington Avenue to Collins Avenue; Meridian
Avenue, from Lincoln Road to 17th Street; Pennsylvania Avenue, from Lincoln Road to Lincoln
Lane North; and Drexel Avenue, from 16th Street to Lincoln Lane North; and
WHEREAS, the types of improvements proposed included enhancement of pedestrian
walkways and cafe zones; modifications to the existing planters and water features; new
landscape and irrigation; cosmetic repairs to the historic Lapidus structures; drainage
improvements; lighting; signalization/wayfinding; performance/multipurpose areas in the 500 and
600 Blocks; outdoor furnishings at selected locations; a gateway trellis feature at the 400 Block;
replacement of underground infrastructure; crosswalk enhancements; and milling and resurfacing
of asphalt paving; and
WHEREAS, on July 3, 2019, the Board of Directors of the Lincoln Road Business
Improvement District (LRBID) adopted Resolution No. 18-19-11, in support of the full
implementation of Phase I of the Lincoln Road District Master Plan and the LRBID further
expressed its desire to (i) expand the term of the LRBID for an additional five years; (ii) increase
the area covered by the LRBID to include, at a minimum, Lincoln Road, from Collins Avenue to
West Avenue, and to also include the side streets; and (iii) increase the special assessments to
current LRBID members by approximately twenty-five percent(25%); and
WHEREAS, on July 31, 2019, the Administration presented the project and budget to the
City Commission and the full scope of the project, estimated at approximately $77.4 million, was
approximately$27 million over budget and during that meeting, the Administration recommended
proceeding with the project by reducing the project scope, and augmenting the funding; and
WHEREAS, the reduced scope included the omission of the gateway trellis located at the
Washington Avenue entrance to Lincoln Road and the recommendation omitted the Washington
Avenue to Collins Avenue (Lincoln Road 200-300 Blocks) scope; and
WHEREAS, the Administration's recommendation was expressly conditioned on an
expanded project budget being made available, upon the successful extension and expansion of
the LRBID (as represented by the LRBID in its Resolution), which would generate additional
revenue to be used for arts, culture and performance programming, as well as the necessary
promotional, marketing and advertising campaigns; and
WHEREAS, the City Commission accepted the recommendation of the Administration,
subject to the conditions provided, and directed staff to proceed with a version of the Lincoln Road
Plan which included a reduced scope and an augmented project budget, for a total project cost
of approximately $67 million; and
WHEREAS, to date, the LRBID has not expanded or extended the district (or generated
any additional revenue) in accordance with its initial 7/13/2020 Resolution; and
WHEREAS, on March 12, 2020, the City of Miami Beach declared a State of Emergency
in response to the Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) and announced various emergency
measures to mitigate the spread of COVID-19, including the immediate closure of non-essential
retail businesses which impacted the commercial businesses along the Lincoln Road corridor;
and
WHEREAS, simultaneously, market conditions and uncertainty within the construction
industry resulted in the CMAR advising the City to delay the BID/GMP process, in order to ensure
greater participation by potential bidders and the project team agreed that postponing the bid
process was in the best interest of the project; and
WHEREAS, additionally, in recognition of the impact of the pandemic on Lincoln Road
businesses, the Administration felt that continued business interruption generated by a
construction project of this magnitude would be excessive and on April 16, 2020, City staff met
with representatives of the LRBID to discuss options that would reduce the scope of work, with
the intent of minimizing impacts to those businesses; and
WHEREAS,the LRBID was supportive of the effort, and made recommendations on which
elements could be removed from the scope and the LRBID also informed City staff that as a result
of the pandemic, they would not be able to meet the commitment to expand and extend the
LRBID, as contemplated under the LRBID's 07/13/2020 Resolution; and
WHEREAS, during the Summer, City staff and representatives of the LRBID met
numerous times to explore and discuss options; and
WHEREAS, in light of the economic impact of the pandemic on the City,the Administration
advised the project team and the LRBID that the project budget would be limited to the funding
already available to the project; and
WHEREAS, this amounted to $40 million for Lincoln Road, from Lenox Avenue to
Washington Avenue; $10 million for Meridian Avenue, from Lincoln Road to 17th Street;
Pennsylvania Avenue, from Lincoln Road to Lincoln Lane North; Drexel Avenue, from 16th Street
to Lincoln Lane North; related underground infrastructure; and $2.4 million for security bollards
(GOB); all for a total of$52.4 million; and
WHEREAS, City staff and the LRBID further discussed potential scope reductions. In
order to reduce the scope and cost of the project to the available $52.4 Million budget. City staff
proposes elimination or reduction of the following:
• Omit the gateway trellis at Washington Avenue
• Eliminate, to the extent possible, all removal and replacement of concrete paving
within the pedestrian areas of Lincoln Road
• Reduced landscaping & irrigation improvements
• Reduced site furnishings
• Eliminate proposed light pole and fixture upgrades
• Eliminate electrical upgrades, specifically at electrical rooms
• Eliminate traffic signalization and crosswalk improvements
• Omit security camera infrastructure
• Omit, to the extent possible, any under-pavement work so as to preserve the
existing pavement
City staff proposes maintaining the following within the project scope:
• Infrastructure upgrades and improvements at Meridian and Drexel Avenues
(water, sanitary sewer& storm drainage)
• Meridian Avenue improvements
• Pedestrianization of Drexel Avenue
• Restoration/repair of fountains and repair of associated equipment
• Restoration of the Lapidus follies
• Upgrade existing light fixtures at existing locations
• Implementation of the concept for the Euclid Avenue oval
• Refurbishing the seating areas along the Lincoln Road corridor
• Refinish the existing piano keys using a more durable traffic coating
• Restoration of aluminum grates of at existing trench drains
• Lincoln Road directional and informational signage package
• A more significant Lincoln Road gateway sign at Washington Avenue, which also
serves as a component of the security barrier system
• A matching Lincoln Road gateway sign at Alton Road, which also serves as a
component of the security barrier system (this location and scope falls outside the original limits
of the project)
• Design and installation of a playground
• Security barrier system, including planters, bollards, furnishings, etc.; and
WHEREAS, the infrastructure upgrades and improvements listed above include water
mains, sanitary sewer and storm drainage scope of work and as the Lincoln Road plan includes
replacement of paving on Drexel and Meridian Avenues, it is cost effective to undertake these
revisions at this time, and will avoid future impacts to newly installed roads; and
WHEREAS, the Public Works Department also deems these improvements critical and
the approximate total cost of the infrastructure improvements is $5.2 million ($3.4M water/sewer
and $1.8M storm drainage); and
WHEREAS, the Administration and City Attorney's Office have reviewed the project scope
for the Lincoln Road project, as approved in the Interlocal Agreement between the City and Miami-
Dade County governing the use of RDA funds(ILA)and based on the project scope for the.Lincoln
Road project(as approved in the ILA), the concurrence of Miami-Dade County would be required
to use RDA funds for the proposed water/sewer and storm drainage improvements, approval
which the Administration does not recommend obtaining at this time; and
WHEREAS, City staff believes that the current total project budget of $50 million could
absorb the cost of the infrastructure improvements and if these improvements are to be funded
by the $10 million dedicated to the improvements of the connector streets, it would, in all
likelihood, prohibit the full implementation of the proposed plan, providing only basic upgrades
and repairs to both Meridian and Drexel Avenues; and
WHEREAS, alternatively, the City could allocate additional funding to the project through
a budget amendment or through the next budget cycle; and
WHEREAS, if this is considered as an alternative by the City Commission, the City would
propose to fund the $3.4M water/sewer improvements from the recently approved $122M
Water/Sewer Bond Program, and $1.8M storm drainage from the Resiliency Fund; and
WHEREAS, on August 20, 2020, the LRBID adopted Resolution No. 19-20-10 and this
Resolution urged the City of Miami Beach to promptly enter into an agreement with James Comer
Field Operations to modify the Lincoln Road Master Plan in a manner that: (1)eliminates the most
disruptive element of the plan, the replacement of the sidewalks; (2) retains as many of the other
design elements of the Master Plan as possible, including the Gateway Trellis; (3) minimizes the
number of modifications to existing plans in order to expedite the permitting and construction
process; ( 4) makes the installation of the designed bollards a paramount priority; and (5) stays
within a budget approved by the City Commission; and
WHEREAS, additionally, the Resolution urged the City of Miami Beach to authorize
construction of a Modified Lincoln Road Master Plan with Burkhardt Construction in the manner
described above so that final permitting and construction can commence at the earliest possible
date; and
WHEREAS, having met with City staff and counsel for the LRBID since the December 9,
2020, City Commission meeting, I concur with the Administration's analysis, as set forth herein;
and
WHEREAS, it is anticipated that the revised scope of work, as proposed herein by City
staff, can be completed within the allocated total budget of approximately$52.4 million, equating
to a construction budget of$34 million to $36 million and of this total $52.4 million project budget,
the City has already expended $5.6 million; and
WHEREAS, in order to implement the changes detailed above, and maintain the design
character of the project, the City has requested a proposal from James Corner Field Operations
to revise the drawings; and
WHEREAS, an amendment to JCFO's contract will be brought to the City Commission for
approval at a future date; and
WHEREAS, the Administration recommends that the City Commission adopts the
Resolution.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT DULY RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY
COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA that the Mayor and City Commission
approve the Interim City Manager's recommendation and authorize a modification and redesign
of the Lincoln Road Redevelopment Project, revising the scope of the project so that it can be
completed within the allocated total budget of $52.4 million; and further authorize the
Administration to negotiate an amendment to the agreement with the City's consultant, James
Corner Field Operations, with said amendment subject to prior approval by the Mayor and City
Commission. �T
PASSED and ADOPTED this l3 day of 7°)4141 , 2021.
Dan Gelber, Mayor
ATTEST:
4
Rafael E. Granad , Ci y Clerk APPROVED AS TO
FORM &LANGUAGE
NM� 6 'c , &FOR EXECUTION
s M,«' ''s
s tINCORPORASED;
....;\q City Attorney Date
Resolutions -R7 B
MIAMI BEACH
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM
TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Commission
• FROM: Raul J.Aguila, Interim City Manager
DATE: January 13, 2021
9:30 a.m.
SUBJECT:A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY
OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, APPROVING THE INTERIM CITY
MANAGER'S RECOMMENDATION AND AUTHORIZING A MODIFICATION
AND REDESIGN OF THE LINCOLN ROAD REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT,
REVISING THE SCOPE OF THE PROJECT SO THAT IT CAN BE
COMPLETED WITHIN THE ALLOCATED TOTAL BUDGET OF $52.4
MILLION; AND FURTHER AUTHORIZING THE ADMINISTRATION TO
NEGOTIATE AN AMENDMENT TO THE AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY'S
CONSULTANT, JAMES CORNER FIELD OPERATIONS, WITH SAID
AMENDMENT SUBJECT TO FUTURE CITY COMMISSION REVIEW AND
APPROVAL.
BACKGROUND/HISTORY
On March 9, 2016, pursuant to the development and approval of the Lincoln Road Master Plan,
the City Commission adopted Resolution No. 2016-29319, awarding the contract for
Architectural and Engineering Design Services for the Lincoln Road Redevelopment Project to
James Corner Field Operations (JCFO).
On June 8, 2016, pursuant to RFQ 2016-073-KB, the City Commission adopted Resolution
No. 2016-29447, awarding a Construction Manager At Risk (CMAR) contract for pre-
construction services,to Burkhardt Construction, Inc.
On October 28, 2016, following the completion of the Schematic Design Phase and Value
Engineering efforts, the project team presented the design and estimated costs to the Finance
and Citywide Projects Committee, which gave direction to the project team to forgo the value
engineering options and design to the Master Plan recommendations.
The overall project construction cost for the proposed improvements, as prepared by Burkhardt
Construction at 50% Construction Document submittal, included, without limitation, costs of
construction, labor, materials and contractor fee, and contingency. City staff included in the total
project cost, the cost of plans, specifications and surveys, architecture and engineering, legal
expenses, permit fees, and owners contingency. The total project cost for the Lincoln Road
Redevelopment Project was projected to be approximately$77.4 million. This included Lincoln
Page 1030 of 1954
Road, from Lenox Avenue to Washington Avenue; Lincoln Road, from Washington Avenue to
Collins Avenue; Meridian Avenue,from Lincoln Road to 17th Street; Pennsylvania Avenue,from
Lincoln Road to Lincoln Lane North; and Drexel Avenue, from 16th Street to Lincoln Lane
North.
The types of improvements proposed included enhancement of pedestrian walkways and cafe
zones; modifications to the existing planters and water features; new landscape and irrigation;
cosmetic repairs to the historic Lapidus structures; drainage improvements; lighting;
signalization/wayfinding; performance/multipurpose areas in the 500 and 600 Blocks; outdoor
furnishings at selected locations; a gateway trellis feature at the 400 Block; replacement of
underground infrastructure; crosswalk enhancements; and milling and resurfacing of asphalt
paving.
On July 3, 2019, the Board of Directors of the Lincoln Road Business Improvement District
(LRBID) adopted Resolution No. 18-19-11, in support of the full implementation of Phase I of
the Lincoln Road District Master Plan. The LRBID further expressed its desire to (i)expand the
term of the LRBID for an additional five years; (ii) increase the area covered by the LRBID to
include, at a minimum, Lincoln Road, from Collins Avenue to West Avenue, and to also include
the side streets; and (iii) increase the special assessments to current LRBID members by
approximately twenty-five percent(25%).
On July 31, 2019, the Administration presented the project and budget to the City Commission.
The full scope of the project, estimated at approximately $77.4 million, was approximately$27
million over budget. During that meeting, the Administration recommended proceeding with the
project by reducing the project scope, and augmenting the funding. The reduced scope
included the omission of the gateway trellis located at the Washington Avenue entrance to
Lincoln Road. Additionally, the recommendation omitted the Washington Avenue to Collins
Avenue (Lincoln Road 200-300 Blocks)scope.
The Administration's recommendation was expressly conditioned on an expanded project
budget being made available, upon the successful extension and expansion of the LRBID (as
represented by the LRBID in its Resolution). This would generate additional revenue to be
used for arts, culture and performance programming, as well as the necessary promotional,
marketing and advertising campaigns.
The City Commission accepted the recommendation of the Administration, subject to the
conditions provided, and directed staff to proceed with a version of the Lincoln Road Plan which
included a reduced scope and an augmented project budget, for a total project cost of
approximately $67 million. To date, the LRBID has not expanded or extended the district (or
generated any additional revenue)in accordance with its initial 7/13/2020 Resolution.
ANALYSIS
On March 12, 2020, the City of Miami Beach declared a State of Emergency in response to the
Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) and announced various emergency measures to
mitigate the spread of COVI D-19, including the immediate closure of non-essential retail
businesses which impacted the commercial businesses along the Lincoln Road corridor.
Page 1031 of 1954
Simultaneously, market conditions and uncertainty within the construction industry resulted in the
CMAR advising the City to delay the BID/GMP process, in order to ensure greater participation
by potential bidders. The project team agreed that postponing the bid process was in the best
interest of the project.
Additionally, in recognition of the impact of the pandemic on Lincoln Road businesses, the
Administration felt that continued business interruption generated by a construction project of
this magnitude would be excessive. On April 16,2020, City staff met with representatives of the
LRBID to discuss options that would reduce the scope of work, with the intent of minimizing
impacts to those businesses. The LRBID was supportive of the effort, and made
recommendations on which elements could be removed from the scope. The LRBID also
informed City staff that, as a result of the pandemic, they would not be able to meet the
commitment to expand and extend the LRBID, as contemplated under the LRBID's
07/13/2020 Resolution.
During the Summer, City staff and representatives of the LRBID met numerous times to
explore and discuss options. In light of the economic impact of the pandemic on the City, the
Administration advised the project team and the LRBID that the project budget would be limited
to the funding already available to the project. This amounted to $40 million for Lincoln Road,
from Lenox Avenue to Washington Avenue; $10 million for Meridian Avenue,from Lincoln Road
to 17th Street; Pennsylvania Avenue, from Lincoln Road to Lincoln Lane North; Drexel Avenue,
from 16th Street to Lincoln Lane North; related underground infrastructure; and $2.4 million for
security bollards (GOB); all for a total of$52.4 million.
City staff and the LRBID further discussed potential scope reductions. In order to reduce the
scope and cost of the project to the available $52.4 Million budget. City staff proposes
elimination or reduction of the following:
• Omit the gateway trellis at Washington Avenue
• Eliminate, to the extent possible, all removal and replacement of concrete paving within the
pedestrian areas of Lincoln Road
• Reduced landscaping &irrigation improvements
• Reduced site furnishings
• Eliminate proposed light pole and fixture upgrades
• Eliminate electrical upgrades, specifically at electrical rooms
• Eliminate traffic signalization and crosswalk improvements
• Omit security camera infrastructure
• Omit, to the extent possible, any under-pavement work so as to preserve the existing
pavement
City staff proposes maintaining the following within the project scope:
• Infrastructure upgrades and improvements at Meridian and Drexel Avenues (water, sanitary
sewer&storm drainage)
• Meridian Avenue improvements
• Pedestrianization of Drexel Avenue
• Restoration/repair of fountains and repair of associated equipment
Page 1032 of 1954
• Restoration of the Lapidus follies
• Upgrade existing light fixtures at existing locations
• Implementation of the concept for the Euclid Avenue oval
• Refurbishing the seating areas along the Lincoln Road corridor
• Refinish the existing piano keys using a more durable traffic coating
• Restoration of aluminum grates of at existing trench drains
• Lincoln Road directional and informational signage package
•A more significant Lincoln Road gateway sign at Washington Avenue, which also serves as a
component of the security barrier system
• A matching Lincoln Road gateway sign at Alton Road, which also serves as a component of
the security barrier system (this location and scope falls outside the original limits of the project)
• Design and installation of a playground
• Security barrier system, including planters, bollards,furnishings, etc.
The infrastructure upgrades and improvements listed above include water mains, sanitary sewer
and storm drainage scope of work.As the Lincoln Road plan includes replacement of paving on
Drexel and Meridian Avenues, it is cost effective to undertake these revisions at this time, and
will avoid future impacts to newly installed roads. The Public Works Department also deems
these improvements critical. The approximate total cost of the infrastructure improvements is
$5.2 million($3.4M water/sewer and $1.8M storm drainage).
The Administration and City Attomeys Office have reviewed the project scope for the Lincoln
Road project, as approved in the Interlocal Agreement between the City and Miami-Dade
County governing the use of RDA funds (ILA). Based on the project scope for the Lincoln
Road project (as approved in the ILA), the concurrence of Miami-Dade County would be
required to use RDA funds for the proposed water/sewer and storm drainage improvements.
The project description in the ILA did not contemplate underground improvements. If the City
Commission desires to use RDA funds for water/sewer and storm drainage improvements as
part of the Lincoln Road project, the Administration would need to contact Miami-Dade County,
and get the County's approval. The Administration does not recommend doing this at this time.
City staff believes that the current total project budget of $50 million could absorb the cost of
the infrastructure improvements. If these improvements are to be funded by the $10 million
dedicated to the improvements of the connector streets, it would, in all likelihood, prohibit the full
implementation of the proposed plan, providing only basic upgrades and repairs to both
Meridian and Drexel Avenues. Alternatively, the City could allocate additional funding to the
project through a budget amendment or through the next budget cycle. If this is considered as
an alternative by the City Commission, the City would propose to fund the $3.4M water/sewer
improvements from the recently approved $122M Water/Sewer Bond Program, and $1.8M
storm drainage from the Resiliency Fund.
On August 20, 2020, the LRBI D adopted Resolution No. 19-20-10. This Resolution urged the
City of Miami Beach to promptly enter into an agreement with James Comer Field Operations
to modify the Lincoln Road Master Plan in a manner that: (1) eliminates the most disruptive
element of the plan, the replacement of the sidewalks; (2) retains as many of the other design
elements of the Master Plan as possible, including the Gateway Trellis; (3) minimizes the
number of modifications to existing plans in order to expedite the permitting and construction
Page 1033 of 1954
process; ( 4) makes the installation of the designed bollards a paramount priority; and (5) stays
within a budget approved by the City Commission. Additionally, the Resolution urged the City of
Miami.Beach to authorize construction of a Modified Lincoln Road Master Plan with Burkhardt
Construction in the manner described above so that final permitting and construction can
commence at the earliest possible date.
INTERIM CITY MANAGER'S RECOMMENDATION
Having met with City staff and counsel for the LRBID since the December 9, 2020, City
Commission meeting, I concur with the Administration's analysis, as set forth herein. It is
anticipated that the revised scope of work, as proposed herein by City staff, can be completed
within the allocated total budget of approximately $52.4 million, equating to a construction
budget of $34 million to $36 million. Of this total $52.4 million project budget, the City has
already expended $5.6 million. In order to implement the changes detailed above, and maintain
the design character of the project, the City has requested a proposal from James Corner Field
Operations to revise the drawings. An amendment to JCFO's contract will be brought to the
City Commission for approval at a future date.
CONCLUSION
The Administration recommends adopting the Resolution.
Applicable Area
South Beach
Is this a "Residents Right Does this item utilize G.O.
to Know" item, pursuant to Bond Funds?
City Code Section 2-14?
Yes No
Strategic Connection
Prosperity- Revitalize targeted areas and increase investment.
Legislative Tracking
Capital Improvement Projects
Page 1034 of 1954