The URL can be used to link to this page

390-10 Hispanic Representation on Miami Beach Committees & Boards 1995 ^:r HISPANIC REPRESENTATION ON MIAMI BEACH COMMITTEES AND BOARDS: A LONGITUDINAL COMPARISON OF NOVEMBER 1991, NOVEMBER 1992, FEBRUARY 1993, FEBRUARY 1994, NOVEMBER 1994, & FEBRUARY 1995 by Dr. Abraham D. Lavender * Department of sociology and Anthropology Florida International university North Miami, Florida 33181 Telephone 940-5923 Corrected Copy as of ~arch 26, 1995 ** Data as of February 23, 1995 * with assistance from sagi Shaked, F.I.U. Intern. ** Two people originally counted as having been appointed by commissioner Liebman were actually hold over appointments from former commissioner ResniCk, made in October 1993. -/ .!>,. HISPANIC REPRESENTATION ON MIAMI BEACH COMMITTEES AND BOARDS: A LONGITUDINAL COMPARISON OF NOVEMBER 1991, NOVENBER 1992, FEBRUARY 1993, FEBRUARY 1994, NOVEMBER 1994, AND FEBRUARY 1995 by Dr. Abraham D. Lavender * FEBRUARY 18, 1995 Data as of FEBRUARY 23, 1995 * With assistance from Sagi Shaked, F.l. U. Intern. Table 1 below shows the summary data for four dates, showinq chanqes in percentaqes of Hispanics appointed to boards and committees by the previous and current Mayor, previous and current commissioners, and previous and current city Manaqers. The total number of appointees analyzed is about 364 (see paqe 3). Table 1: Summary Lonqitudinal comparisons of Hispanic Appointees Nov. Nov. Feb. Feb. Nov. Feb. 1991 1992 1993 1994 1994 1995 Mayor Gelber 8.5% 17.9% 20.0% 37.8% 40.5% 32.5% six commissioners 7.0% 6.7% 7.2% 22.4% 25.5% 24.1% commission as a Body 10.2% 13.2% 15.9% 19.8% 25.2% 24.3% Total Mayor and Comm. 8.3% 10.9% 12.6% 23.2% 27.1% 25.2% City Manaqer 8.9% 7.7% 37.0% 33.3% 34.3% Total Mayor, comm., and City Manaqer 8.4% 10.5% 24.4% 27.7% 26.1% Remaininq appoint- ments made by previous Mayor, Comm., and City Manaqers 4.3% 0% 0% Total Previous and Current Appointments (employee elected appointees not in- cluded) 22.7% 27.2% 25.5% 1 ~. .... Table 2 below shows Hispanic appointments to the seven more important policy making committees and boards, with comparisons for dates. Figures for the Code Enforcement Board were included in 1991 and 1993, but are not included now because of recent changes to that board. Parenthese numbers show the number of appointments made by the Mayor, commission, or city Manager, and do not include employee elected members or appointments made from other sources. to POlicy-Making Table 2: Longitudinal summary of Hispanic Appointments committees and Nov. 1991 Board of Adjustment (5) Housing Authority (5).. Nuisance Abatement Board (5) Personnel Board (6).. Planning Board (7) Visitor/convention Auth. (7) zoning/Design Review Board (7) 1 o 1 o o 1 o Total (41) 3 Percent Hispanic 6.1% Of 38 appointments made by current Mayor, Commissioners, and City Manager, percent who are Hispanic.. N/A Boards Feb. 1993 1 1 1 o o o o 3 ("Power Boards") Feb. Nov. Feb. 1994 1994 1995 1 2 o 1 2 2 3 1 2 1 2 2 2 3 1 2 1 2 2 2 3 11 13 13 6.1% 26.8% 31.7% 3L.7% N/A 31.4% 34.2% 34.2% *Figures for Tables 1 and 2 are based on committee and board memberships maintained by the city Clerk's Office, Miami Beach, with updates resulting from appointments made through November 2, 1994. Ad hoc committees and boards are not included and appointees to the Dade County Library Board and Performing Arts Board are included. The classification of appointees is made based on first and last names, personal knowledge, and consultations with various individuals. The author believes the list to be correct, but recognizes that a few individuals might be misclassified, and welcomes any corrections. **Two members of the Housing Authority were appointed by former Mayor Daoud; neither is Hispanic. Mayor Gelber has appointed three members, two of whom are Hispanics. Three members of the Personnel Board, none Hispanic, were appointed by former commissions. Three members were appointed in 1992, 1993, and 1994, two of whom are Hispanic. 2 TOTALS Total # # of % of of Appoint- Hisp. Hisp. ments Appts. Appts. Mayor Gelber 40 13 32.5 commissioner 23 3 13.0 commissioner 25 3 12.0 commissioner 24 4 16.7 commissioner 22 9 40.9 commissioner 23 8 34.8 commissioner 24 7 29.2 commission as a Body 144 35 24.3 Total Mayor and commission 325 82 25.2 City Manager Carlton 35 12 34.3 Total Current Mayor, Commissioners, and City Manager 360 94 26.1 Previous Mayor, Commissioner, and city Managers 8 0 0 Total Previous and current Appointments by Mayors, Commissioners, and city Managers (not counting employee elected appointees) 368 94 25.5 3 APPENDIX A: MEMBERS OF ALL COMMITTEES AND BOARDS CLASSIFIED AS HISPANIC OR NON-HISPANIC, AND BY SOURCE OF APPOINTMENT Non-Hispanic Members Jane Goodman Paula Harper Marcella Waldman Ruth Sackner william Kearns Mira Lehr Bruce Menin virginia M. siegel Mel Schlesser Jeffrey Bercow Arthur Unger Perry Fabian Harold segal Sean Breen Myles cypen David Dermer Jed Frankel Phyllis Miller Judy Drucker Hilliard Gold Joel Arnold Francis Mayville Tina weiss Elaine M. Baker Ben Rosenthal Jerry Libbin Cathy Leff Lyle Stern Jonathan Fryd Rabbi Phineas Weberman Jeff G. Abbaticchio John Fuller Edward Levinson Jonathan Beloff Barbara Gillman Barton Goldberg David winer Jack spirk Irving Kass Sharon Welkovitz Nancy Newman Gail Harris Faye Goldin Helene Owen Maria Harris COMMISSION AS A BODY 109 75.7% Art in pUblic Places Art in pUblic Places Art in Public Places Art in Public Places Art In Public Places Art in public Places Board of Adjustment Board of Adjustment Board of Adjustment Board of Adjustment Budget Advisory Budget Advisory Budget Advisory Charter Review Charter Review Charter Review Charter Review Charter Review Community Benefit community Benefit community Benefit community' Benefit community Benefit community Benefit community Benefit Community Benefit community Benefit community Development community Development community Relations Convention Center convention Center convention Center Equity Rate Equity Rate Equity Rate Equity Rate Equity Rate Equity Rate Equity Rate Fine Arts Fine Arts Fine Arts Fine Arts Fine Arts 4 Flo Moss Claire Warren sonya Raybin Nathan segel Larry Hudson David Berger J. F. Donnelly Anita Bernstein James Gleason cheryl Martin Les Beilinson Aliza Brenner Oren Brenner Gabriela L. Doyle Larry Fuller Jeffrey Galitz stephen Hertz Jeremy Hyne Jerry Libbin Solomon Lichter Jim Perry silvana Sorace Warren stamm Charles W. Burkett Gerald K. Schwartz Jeff Blumenthal Stanley Arkin John R. Gaffin Keith Kovens craig Robins Clark Reynolds Joy Alschuler Todd Tragash Saul Gross Mel Schlesser Sherna Brody Andy Parrish ~oAnn Sawitz-Bass George Lowander craig Robins Denis Russ Gary Gerson Saul Grossbard Donald Kahn Jack Lubin Roberta Swan John Wray Tom Brinkley Robert Christoph Jim Baumann George Lowander Ed Resnick Fine Arts Fine Arts Fine Arts Health Facilities Health Facilities Health Facilities Library (Dade) Loan Review Loan Review Loan Review Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Nuisance Abatement Nuisance Abatement Nuisance Abatement Nuisance Abatement performing Arts (Dade) Personnel Planning planning Planning Planning Planning Safe Neighborhood #1 Safe Neighborhood #1 Safe Neighborhood #1 Safe Neighborhood #1 Safe Neighborhood #1 Safe Neighborhood #1 Safe Neighborhood #1 Safe Neighborhood #1 Safe Neighborhood #2 Safe Neighborhood #2 Safe Neighborhood #2 Safe Neighborhood #2 Safe Neighborhood #2 Safe Neighborhood #2 South pointe South pointe South pointe South pointe South pointe 5 Herman Rubin JoAnn Sawitz-Bass Tamra Sheffman Edward L. Margolis T. C. Adder1y George T. Neary Christopher Perks Eric Jacobs Tony Goldman Jerrold Goodman I. stanley Levine Lisa Cole Werchafter Hispanic Members Carlos capote steve Zack Maria S. Pellerin Saul cimb1er Georgiana Young Raul Gorfink1e Jose smith Manuel Warszavski Gladys Hernando Oscar Baisman Pedro Adrian Alina Sardinas Jose Raif Mike Karpel Mijel Brazlavsky Neli Santamarina Zoi1a Datorre Jose smith Jose L. Raia Trudy cejas Betty capote Betty Gutierrez Roberto Datorre Diana Grub Oscar Baisman Jose Fernandez Neli Santamarina Gus Hernandez Gus Hernandez Mario Leon Roberto Datorre Matti Bower Noel Jimenez olga Garay Ada L1erandi South pointe South pointe South pointe private Industry Private Industry Private Industry Tourist/Convention VCA VCA VCA. VCA VCA Board of Adjustment Charter Review Charter Review Code Enforcement community Benefit community Development community Development Community Relations Community Relations convention center Equity Rate Equity Rate Health Facilities Health Facilities Hispanic Affairs Hispanic )\ffairs Library ('Dade) Normandy Shores Nuisance Abatement Performing Arts (Dade) Personnel Personnel Planning Planning South pointe South pointe South pointe Private Industry Tourist/Convention Tourist/convention Safe Neighborhood #1 Safe Neighborhood #1 Safe Neighborhood #2 VCA VCA 6 35 24.3% TOTAL 144 Non-Hispanic Members Dennis Morin Mrs. Andre Bialolenki Bernard M. Wall Janet Skiers-Kaeiser Donald Blechman Peggy Mckinley Lois Meitus Raymond Hulen Jim Knopke Howard Galbut Dr. Abraham D. Lavender Harriet Green Andrew Moriber Elaine Levine Sol Lichter Ronald Lowy Gerald Schwartz Deborah Turner Peter Liu Rabbi Irving Lehrman Belle Lehrman silvia Kaplan Dorothy serotta Irma Freedline Joyce Banks Ed Newman Hispanic Members Dixon Alvarino Elena Rosales Matti Bower Alfredo Rey Manny Diaz Frank Turcios Manuel carvajal Dr. Marta Amado Mayra Diaz-Buttacavoli Teresa Martiato Gema Ruis Alex Gimelstein Pedro L.Hernandez MAYOR GELBER Beautification Beautification Budget Advisory community Relations Convention Center Fashion, Film Fine Arts Fine Arts Golf Housing Authority Housing Authority Hurricane Hurricane Hurricane Hurricane Hurricane Hurricane pOlice & Fire police & Fire Safety Safety status of Women status of Women status of Women Tourist/convention Transportation community Development Housing Authority Housing Authority Hurricane Hurricane Hurricane Hurricane police Public Safety policemen & Firemen Recreational/Parks safety Committee Transportation Youth Center 27 13 TOTAL 40 7 67.5% 32.5% Non-Hispanic Members steven Bacon Michael Thompson Miriam Kassenoff John McDermott Irene Marie Toby Friedland Marcia Schwartz craig Rickert Dr. Elias Herschman Douglas Grenald Joe Fontana Felice Schwartz Robin weiss Henrietta Mehlman Evelyn Manset Gertrude Arfa Jack Hartley Jackie Buchsbaum Alan B. Fishman Robert N. Warren Hispanic Members Lydia Resnick Sarita Resnick Antonio purrinos COMMISSIONER EISENBERG Budget Advisory community Development community Relations convention Center Fashion, Film Fine Arts Fine Arts Golf police Public Safety Recreational/parks Recreational/Parks safety Safety status of Women status of Women status of Women Tourist/convention Transportation Transportation Youth Center Beautification Beautification Safety 8 20 87.0% 3 TOTAL 23 13.0% Non-Hispanic Members Lynn Russin Al Evans Tamara Nixon Deena Zaron Larry Perl Henri spiegel Kathe Richman Dava Lipsky Michael Lipsky Adam West Jerry Mandel JUlie Russin Bercow Ruth Fuller Josie Renin Ellen Shaw Elsie Howard Lisa Liotta Leon Manne Leila Hunter Doris Myers Gloria Salom Bunny Patchen Hispanic Members Marguer. Ramos Herrera Socorro Cortes Hector Garcia COMMISSIONER GOTTLIEB Beautification Beautification Budget Advisory community Relations convention center Fashion, Film Fine Arts Fine Arts Golf police public Safety Recreational/Parks Recreational/Parks Safety Safety status of Women status of Women status of Women Tourist/Convention Transportation TransportC'\tion Youth Center Youth center community Development Safety Safety 9 22 88.0% 3 12 . 0% TOTAL 25 Non-Hispanic Members Andrew Lewis Hazel cypen Michael Milberg Scott Robins Father James Murphy Brad Krassner Bruce Orosz Merle Weiss Harold vinik James Balzano Paul Whitebrook David Fenton Mitchell P. Korus Brian Giller Bea Durchslag Bonnie Albert Dennis Scholl Dr. Zalman Bacheikovs Laine Unger Lynn W. Bernstein Hispanic Members Noel Suarez Julio Magrisso Laura Morilla Randall Robinson COMMISSIONER KASDIN Beautification Beautification Budget Advisory community Development community Relations Convention center Fashion, Film Fine Arts Golf police public safety Recreational/Parks safety , safety Safety status of Women status of Women Tourist/convention Transportation Youth Center Youth Center Fine Arts Recreational/Parks status of Women Transportation 10 20 TOTAL 24 83.3% 4 16.7% Non-Hispanic Members Leila shuminer Ruth Gudis Grace y. Durbin cynthia T. soloway Joe Pallant David Alschuler Marilyn Schlessler Emily Davis Murray Sheldon Belle D. Jurkowitz Randall Hilliard Michael Kosnitsky James E. Silvers Hispanic Members Dennis Leyva Oscar Sklar Eugene W. Rodriguez Julio Lora Roberto Menendez Maria Betot vivian Doyle victor Varela Adriana Savino-Miller COMMISSIONER LIEBMAN Budget Advisory community Development Fine Arts Fine Arts Golf police Public Safety Recreational/Parks Safety Safety Status of Women Transportation Transportation Youth Center community Relations Convention Center Fashion, Film Recreational/Parks Safety status of Women status of Women Tourist/convention Youth Center 11 13 S9.1% TOTAL 22 9 40.9% Non-Hispanic Members Barbara Gillman Alan Glackman steve Nostrand Andrea Ruskin Helen ciment Dr. Peter Laurence Aliza Brenner Jack Goldstein Bene Glackman Barbara Shack Wager Ronny singerman Marjorie Milberg Marty W. Wasserman Claudia Laurence Hispanic Members COMMISSIONER PEARLSON Beautification Budget Advisory convention Center Fashion, Film Fine Arts Recreational/Parks Safety Safety status of Women Status of Women Tourist/convention Transportation Transportation Youth Center Jose Lopez Maria E. Saboya Alina Hernandez-Tallaheche Jose Heres Remberto Cabrera Juan P. Llanera Enrique Madia Regina Suarez Beautification community Development community Relations Golf police Public Safety Recreational/Parks Safety status of Women 15 8 TOTAL 23 12 ' 65.2% 37.5% Non-Hispanic Members Donna Kern Bloom Shirley Raybin Bernice Martinez stuart Blumberg cindy Perlman Rosalie B. pincus Ralph Muskat Linda Gross cathy schwarz Robert Yaffe sylvia H. Hoppes Sharon Kersten Jacque Hertz Leonard Baker Judy Gopman Frances Giller Linda Felton Hispanic Members Tony ROdriguez Raul Sarraff Luis Canales Jose D. Manzanares-Desilva Andria Rivero Jacki Ruiz Lazaro Martinez COMMISSIONER SHAPIRO 17 Beautification Beautification community Development Convention Center Fashion, Film Fine Arts Golf Recreational/Parks Recreational/Parks safety safety status of Women Status of Women Tourist/convention Transporation Yout.fl Center Youth Center 7 Budget Advisory community Relations Fine Arts police public Safety Safety Status of Women Transportation TOTAL 24 13 70.8% 29.2% Non-Hispanic Members Saul Gross Stephen H. cypen Bernard zyscovich Jack Luft Judy Ford Dean R. Mielke Robert Thomas Dean R. Mielke Debra S. Scholl Linda polansky Sarah Eaton Robert Schuler Lee spiegelman Jack Bernstein Brian McDonough Joseph M. Fletcher Linda Michols Eddie Cox Kaslyn Mohamed Al sprigle Harold Rosen Robert spinney Natalie L. Tooks Hispanic Members Bernardo Fort-Brescia Fernando Alonso Aida M. curtis Jorge Montes Herb Sosa Anthony Noboa victor Diaz william Medellin Jose Galebert-Navia captain John Gonzalez Mayra Diaz-Buttacavoli Jorge Gomez CITY MANAGER CARLTON Design Review Design Review Design Review Design Review Employees' Retirement Employees' Retirement Employees' Retirement Firemen's Relief Historic preservation Historic preservation Historic Preservation Historic preservation Marine Authority Marine Authority Marine Authority Marine Authority Retirement-unclassified Retirement-Unclassified Retirement-unclassified Retirement-unclassified Retirement-Unclassified Retirement-Unclassified Retirement-Unclassified Design Review Design Review Design Review Employees' Retirement Historic preservation Historic Preservation Historic Preservation Historic preservation Historic Preservation Marine Authority police pUblic Safety Retirement-unclassified 23 65.7% 12 TOTAL 35 14 34.3% I FORMER COMMISSION Non-Hispanic Members 5 Sam Kantor Personnel Blackie Hunter Personnel Louis Harris personnel Greg Waldor Beautification Selma Grenald Beautification Hispanic Members 0 0.0% FORMER MAYOR Non-Hispanic Members 3 Johnny Wayne Housing Authority Peter Liu policeman , Firemen Debora Turner policeman , Firemen Hispanic Members 0 0.0% 15 .,,;r". HISPANIC REPRESENTATION ON MIAMI BEACH COMMITTEES AND BOARDS: A LONGITUDINAL COMPARISON OF NOVEMBER 1991, NOVEMBER 1992, FEBRUARY 1993, FEBRUARY 1994, NOVEMBER 1994, & FEBRUARY 1995 by Dr. Abraham D. Lavender * Department of sociology and Anthropology Florida International University North Miami, Florida 33181 Telephone 940-5923 Corrected Copy as of~arch 26, 1995 ** Data as of February 23, 1995 * with assistance from sag~ Shaked, F.I.U. Intern. ** Two people originally counted as having been appointed by Commissioner Liebman were actually hold over appointments from former commissioner Resnick, made in October 1993. -, , HISPANIC REPRESENTATION ON MIAMI BEACH COMMI1TEES AND BOARDS: A LONGITUDINAL COMPARISON OF NOVEMBER 1991, NOVENBER 1992, FEBRUARY 1993, FEBRUARY 1994, NOVEMBER 1994, AND FEBRUARY 1995 by Dr. Abraham D. Lavender * FEBRUARY 18, 1995 Data as of FEBRUARY 23, 1995 * With assistance from Sagi Shaked, F. I. U. Intern. Table 1 below shows the summary data for four dates, showing changes in percentages of Hispanics appointed to boards and committees by the previous and current Mayor, previous and current commissioners, and previous and current City Managers. The total number of appointees analyzed is about 364 (see page 3). Table 1: summary Longitudinal comparisons of Hispanic Appointees Nov. Nov. Feb. Feb. Nov. Feb. 1991 1992 1993 1994 1994 1995 Mayor Gelber 8.5% 17.9% 20.0% 37.8% 40.5% 32.5% six commissioners 7.0% 6.7% 7.2% 22.4% 25.5% 24.1% commission as a Body 10.2% 13.2% 15.9% 19.8% 25.2% 24.3% Total Mayor and Comm. 8.3% 10.9% 12.6% 23.2% 27.1% 25.2% city Manager 8.9% 7.7% 37.0% 33.3% 34.3% Total Mayor, Comm. , and city Manager 8.4% 10.5% 24.4% 27.7% 26.1% Remaining appoint- ments made by previous Mayor, Comm. , and City Managers 4.3% 0% 0% Total Previous and Current Appointments (employee elected appointees not in- cluded) 22.7% 27.2% 25.5% 1 "to.. Table 2 below shows Hispanic appointments to the seven more important policy making committees and boards, with comparisons for dates. Figures for the Code Enforcement Board were included in 1991 and 1993, but are not included now because of recent changes to that board. Parenthese numbers show the number of appointments made by the Mayor, Commission, or City Manager, and db not include employee elected members or appointments made from other sources. Table 2: Longitudinal summary of Hispanic Appointments to Policy-Making committees and Boards ("power Boards") Nov. Feb. Feb. Nov. Feb. 1991 1993 1994 1994 1995 Board of Adjustment (5) Housing Authority (5)** Nuisance Abatement Board (5) Personnel Board (6)** Planning Board (7) Visitor/Convention Auth. (7) zoning/Design Review Board (7) 1 o 1 o o 1 o Total (41) 3 Percent Hispanic 6.1% Of 38 appointments made by current Mayor, commissioners, and City Manager, percent who are Hispanic** N/A 1 1 1 o o o o 1 2 o 1 2 2 3 1 2 1 2 2 2 3 1 2 1 2 2 2 3 3 11 13 13 6.1% 26.8% 31.7% 31.7% N/A 31.4% 34.2% 34.2% *Figures for Tables 1 and 2 are based on committee and board memberships maintained by the City Clerk's Office, Miami Beach, with updates resulting from appointments made through November 2, 1994. Ad hoc committees and boards are not included and appointees to the Dade County Library Board and Performing Arts Board are included. The classification of appointees is made based on first and last names, personal knowledge, and consultations with various individuals. The author believes the list to be correct, but recognizes that a few individuals might be misclassified, and welcomes any corrections. **Two members of the Housing Authority were appointed by former Mayor Daoud; neither is Hispanic. Mayor Gelber has appointed three members, two of whom are Hispanics. Three members of the Personnel Board, none Hispanic, were appointed by former Commissions. Three members were appointed in 1992, 1993, and 1994, two of whom are Hispanic. 2 TOTALS Total # # of % of of Appoint- Hisp. Hisp. ments Appts. ApptS. Mayor Gelber 40 13 32.5 commissioner 23 3 13.0 commissioner 25 3 12.0 commissioner 24 4 16.7 commissioner 22 9 40.9 commissioner 23 8 34.8 commissioner 24 7 29.2 commission as a Body 144 35 24.3 Total Mayor and commission 325 82 25.2 city Manager Carlton 35 12 34.3 Total Current Mayor, commissioners, and City Manager 360 94 26.1 Previous Mayor, Commissioner, and City Managers 8 0 0 Total Previous and Current Appointments by Mayors, Commissioners, and City Managers (not counting employee elected appointees) 368 94 25.5 3 APPENDIX A: MEMBERS OF ALL COMMITTEES AND BOARDS CLASSIFIED AS HISPANIC OR NON-HISPANIC, AND BY SOURCE OF APPOINTMENT Non-Hispanic Members Jane Goodman Paula Harper Marcella Waldman Ruth Sackner william Kearns Mira Lehr Bruce Menin virginia M. siegel Mel Schlesser Jeffrey Bercow Arthur Unger Perry Fabian Harold segal Sean Breen Myles cypen David Dermer Jed Frankel Phyllis Miller Judy Drucker Hilliard Gold Joel Arnold Francis Mayville Tina weiss Elaine M. Baker Ben Rosenthal Jerry Libbin Cathy Leff Lyle Stern Jonathan Fryd Rabbi Phineas Weberman Jeff G. Abbaticchio John Fuller Edward Levinson Jonathan Beloff Barbara Gillman Barton Goldberg David winer Jack spirk Irving Kass Sharon Welkovitz Nancy Newman Gail Harris Faye Goldin Helene Owen Maria Harris COMMISSION AS A BODY 109 75.7% Art in Public Places Art in puhlic Places Art in pUblic Places Art in Public Places Art In public Places Art in Public Places Board of Adjustment Board of Adjustment Board of Adjustment Board of Adjustment Budget Advisory Budget Advisory Budget Advisory Charter Review Charter Review Charter Review Charter Review Charter Review community Benefit community Benefit community Benefit Community' Benefit community Benefit community Benefit community Benefit Community Benefit Community Benefit community Development community Development community Relations Convention Center convention Center convention Center Equity Rate Equity Rate Equity Rate Equity Rate Equity Rate Equity Rate Equity Rate Fine Arts Fine Arts Fine Arts Fine Arts Fine Arts 4 Flo Moss Claire Warren sonya Raybin Nathan segel Larry Hudson David Berger J. F. Donnelly Anita Bernstein James Gleason cheryl Martin Les Beilinson Aliza Brenner Oren Brenner Gabriela L. Doyle Larry Fuller Jeffrey Galitz stephen Hertz Jeremy Hyne Jerry Libbin Solomon Lichter Jim perry silvana Sorace Warren stamm Charles W. Burkett Gerald K. schwartz Jeff Blumenthal stanley Arkin John R. Gaffin Keith Kovens craig Robins Clark Reynolds Joy Alschuler Todd Tragash Saul Gross Mel Schlesser Sherna Brody Andy parrish JoAnn sawitz-Bass George Lowander craig Robins Denis Russ Gary Gerson saul Grossbard Donald Kahn Jack Lubin Roberta Swan John Wray Tom Brinkley Robert Christoph Jim Baumann George Lowander Ed Resnick Fine Arts Fine Arts Fine Arts Health Facilities Health Facilities Health Facilities Library (Dade) Loan Review Loan Review Loan Review Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Normandy Shores Nuisance Abatement Nuisance Abatement Nuisance Abatement Nuisance Abatement Performing Arts (Dade) Personnel Planning Planning Planning Planning Planning Safe Neighborhood #1 Safe Neighborhood #1 safe Neighborhood #1 Safe Neighborhood #1 Safe Neighborhood #1 Safe Neighborhood #1 Safe Neighborhood #1 Safe Neighborhood #1 Safe Neighborhood #2 Safe Neighborhood #2 Safe Neighborhood #2 Safe Neighborhood #2 Safe Neighborhood #2 Safe Neighborhood #2 South pointe South pointe South pointe South pointe South pointe 5 Herman Rubin JoAnn sawitz-Bass Tamra Sheffman Edward L. Margolis T. C. Adderly George T. Neary christopher Perks Eric Jacobs Tony Goldman Jerrold Goodman I. stanley Levine Lisa Cole Werchafter Hispanic Members Carlos capote steve Zack Maria S. Pellerin Saul cimbler Georgiana Young Raul Gorfinkle Jose smith Manuel Warszavski Gladys Hernando Oscar Baisman Pedro Adrian Alina Sardinas Jose Raif Mike Karpel Mijel Brazlavsky Neli Santamarina Zoila Datorre Jose smith Jose L. Raia Trudy cejas Betty Capote Betty Gutierrez Roberto Datorre Diana Grub Oscar Baisman Jose Fernandez Neli Santamarina Gus Hernandez Gus Hernandez Mario Leon Roberto Datorre Matti Bower Noel Jimenez Olga Garay Ada Llerandi South pointe South pointe South pointe private Industry Private Industry private Industry Tourist/convention VCA VCA VCA VCA VCA Board of Adjustment Charter Review Charter Review Code Enforcement community Benefit community Development community Development community Relations community Relations Convention Center Equity Rate Equity Rate Health Facilities Health Facilities Hispanic Affairs Hispanic j\ffairs Library (bade) Normandy Shores Nuisance Abatement performing Arts (Dade) Personnel Personnel Planning Planning South pointe south pointe South pointe Private Industry Tourist/convention Tourist/convention Safe Neighborhood #1 Safe Neighborhood #1 Safe Neighborhood #2 VCA VCA 6 3S 24.3% TOTAL 144 Non-Hispanic Members Dennis Morin Mrs. Andre Bialolenki Bernard M. Wall Janet Skiers-Kaeiser Donald Blechman Peggy Mckinley Lois Meitus Raymond Hulen Jim Knopke Howard Galbut Dr. Abraham D. Lavender Harriet Green Andrew Moriber Elaine Levine Sol Lichter Ronald Lowy Gerald Schwartz Deborah Turner Peter Liu Rabbi Irving Lehrman Belle Lehrman silvia Kaplan Dorothy Serotta Irma Freedline Joyce Banks Ed Newman Hispanic Members Dixon Alvarino Elena Rosales Matti Bower Alfredo Rey Manny Diaz Frank Turcios Manuel carvajal Dr. Marta Amado Mayra Diaz-Buttacavoli Teresa Martiato Gema Ruis Alex Gimelstein Pedro L.Hernandez MAYOR GELBER Beautification Beautification Budget Advisory community Relations convention Center Fashion, Film Fine Arts Fine Arts Golf Housing Authority Housing Authority Hurricane Hurricane Hurricane Hurricane Hurricane Hurricane police , Fire police , Fire Safety Safety status of Women Status of Women status of Women Tourist/convention Transportation community Development Housing Authority Housing Authority Hurricane Hurricane Hurricane Hurricane police pUblic Safety policemen , Firemen Recreational/parks Safety committee Transportation Youth center 27 13 TOTAL 40 7 67.5% 32.5% Non-Hispanic Members steven Bacon Michael Thompson Miriam Kassenoff John McDermott Irene Marie Toby Friedland Marcia schwartz craig Rickert Dr. Elias Herschman Douglas Grenald Joe Fontana Felice Schwartz Robin weiss Henrietta Mehlman Evelyn Manset Gertrude Arfa Jack Hartley Jackie Buchsbaum Alan B. Fishman Robert N. Warren Hispanic Members Lydia Resnick Sarita Resnick Antonio purrinos COMMISSIONER EISENBERG Budget Advisory community Development community Relations convention center Fashion, Film Fine Arts Fine Arts Golf police Public Safety Recreational/Parks Recreational/parks Safety Safety Status of Women Status of Women Status of Women Tourist/convention Transportation Transportation Youth center Beautification Beautification Safety 8 20 87.0% 3 TOTAL 23 13.0% Non-Hispanic Members Lynn Russin Al Evans Tamara Nixon Deena Zaron Larry Perl Henri spiegel Kathe Richman Dava Lipsky Michael Lipsky Adam west Jerry Mandel Julie Russin Bercow Ruth Fuller Josie Kenin Ellen Shaw Elsie Howard Lisa Liotta Leon Manne Leila Hunter Doris Myers Gloria Salom Bunny Patchen Hispanic Members Marguer. Ramos Herrera Socorro cortes Hector Garcia COMMISSIONER GOTTLIEB Beautification Beautification Budget Advisory community Relations Convention center Fashion, Film Fine Arts Fine Arts Golf police pUblic Safety Recreational/Parks Recreational/Parks Safety Safety status of Women status of Women status of Women Tourist/convention Transportation Transportation Youth Center Youth Center community Development Safety Safety 9 22 88.0% 3 12.0% TOTAL 25 Non-Hispanic Members Andrew Lewis Hazel cypen Michael Milberg Scott Robins Father James Murphy Brad Krassner Bruce Orosz Merle Weiss Harold Vinik James Balzano Paul Whitebrook David Fenton Mitchell P. Korus Brian Giller Bea Durchslag Bonnie Albert Dennis Scholl Dr. Zalman Bacheikovs Laine Unger Lynn W. Bernstein Hispanic Members Noel Suarez Julio Magrisso Laura Morilla Randall Robinson COMMISSIONER KASDIN Beautification Beautification Budget Advisory community Development community Relations Convention Center Fashion, Film Fine Arts Golf police public safety Recreational/parks safety . Safety Safety status of Women status of Women Tourist/convention Transportation Youth Center Youth Center Fine Arts Recreational/parks Status of Women Transportation 10 20 TOTAL 24 83.3% 4 16.7% Non-Hispanic Members Leila Shuminer Ruth Gudis Grace y. Durbin cynthia T. soloway Joe pallant David Alschuler Marilyn Schlessler Emily Davis Murray sheldon Belle D. Jurkowitz Randall Hilliard Michael Kosnitsky James E. silvers Hispanic Members Dennis Leyva Oscar Sklar Eugene W. ROdriguez Julio Lora Roberto Menendez Maria Betot vivian Doyle victor Varela Adriana Savino-Miller COMMISSIONER LIEBMAN Budget Advisory community Development Fine Arts Fine Arts Golf police Public Safety Recreational/parks Safety Safety status of Women Transportation Transportation Youth Center Community Relations Convention Center Fashion, Film Recreational/Parks Safety status of Women status of Women Tourist/convention Youth Center 11 13 59.1% TOTAL 22 9 40.9% Non-Hispanic Members Barbara Gillman Alan Glackman steve Nostrand Andrea Ruskin Helen ciment Dr. Peter Laurence Aliza Brenner Jack Goldstein Bene Glackman Barbara Shack Wager Ronny singerman Marjorie Milberg Marty W. Wasserman Claudia Laurence Hispanic Members COMMISSIONER PEARLSON Beautification Budget Advisory Convention center Fashion, Film Fine Arts Recreational/Parks safety Safety status of Women Status of Women Tourist/convention Transportation Transportation Youth center Jose Lopez Maria E. Saboya Alina Hernandez-Tallaheche Jose Heres Remberto cabrera Juan P. Llanera Enrique Madia Regina Suarez Beautification community Development community Relations Golf police Public Safety Recreational/parks Safety Status of Women 15 8 TOTAL 23 12 ' 65.2% 37.5% Non-Hispanic Members Donna Kern Bloom shirley Raybin Bernice Martinez stuart Blumberg cindy perlman Rosalie B. pincus Ralph Muskat Linda Gross cathy Schwarz Robert Yaffe sylvia H. Hoppes Sharon Kersten Jacque Hertz Leonard Baker Judy Gopman Frances Giller Linda Felton Hispanic Members Tony Rodriguez Raul Sarraff Luis Canales Jose D. Manzanares-Desilva Andria Rivero Jacki Ruiz Lazaro Martinez COMMISSIONER SHAPIRO 17 Beautification Beautification community Development Convention center Fashion, Film Fine Arts Golf Recreational/Parks Recreational/Parks Safety Safety status of Women status of Women Tourist/Convention Transporation Youtjl Center Youth Center 7 Budget Advisory community Relations Fine Arts police public Safety Safety Status of Women Transportation TOTAL 24 13 70.8% 29.2% Non-Hispanic Members Saul Gross Stephen H. cypen Bernard zyscovich Jack Luft Judy Ford Dean R. Mielke Robert Thomas Dean R. Mielke Debra S. Scholl Linda polansky Sarah Eaton Robert Schuler Lee spiegelman Jack Bernstein Brian McDonough Joseph M. Fletcher Linda Michols Eddie Cox Kaslyn Mohamed Al sprigle Harold Rosen Robert spinney Natalie L. Tooks Hispanic Members Bernardo Fort-Brescia FernandO Alonso Aida M. curtis Jorge Montes Herb Sosa Anthony Noboa victor Diaz william Medellin Jose Galebert-Navia captain John Gonzalez Mayra Diaz-Buttacavoli Jorge Gomez CITY MANAGER CARLTON Design Review Design Review Design Review Design Review Employees' Retirement Employees' Retirement Employees' Retirement Firemen's Relief Historic preservation Historic preservation Historic preservation Historic Preservation Marine Authority Marine Authority Marine Authority Marine Authority Retirement-unclassified Retirement-unclassified Retirement-Unclassified Retirement-unclassified Retirement-Unclassified Retirement-unclassified Retirement-unclassified Design Review Design Review Design Review Employees' Retirement Historic preservation Historic preservation Historic Preservation Historic Preservation Historic preservation Marine Authority police Public Safety Retirement-Unclassified 23 65.7% 12 TOTAL 35 14 34.3% ! FORMER COMMISSION Non-Hispanic Members 5 Sam Kantor Personnel Blackie Hunter Personnel Louis Harris Personnel Greg Waldor Beautification Selma Grenald Beautification Hispanic Members 0 0.0% FORMER MAYOR Non-Hispanic Members 3 Johnny Wayne Housing Authority Peter Liu policeman , Firemen Debora Turner policeman , Firemen Hispanic Members 0 0.0% 15