2001-24497 RESO
RESOLUTION NO. 2001-24497
RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION
OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH APPROVING THE
SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT WITH MIAMI-DADE
COUNTY FOR THE MIAMI BEACH MARINA SEW AGE
SPILL AND AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR, CITY CLERK
AND ANY OTHER NECESSARY CITY PERSONNEL TO
EXECUTE THE SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AND ALL
OTHER DOCUMENTS AS MAY BE NECESSARY TO CARRY
OUT THE INTENT OF THIS RESOLUTION.
WHEREAS, following the sewage spill at the Miami Beach Marina on or about
June 20, 2000, the City of Miami Beach and other governmental regulatory agencies,
including Miami-Dade County Department of Environmental Resources Management
(DERM) and Florida Department of Environmental Protection (DEP), have undertaken
investigations to determine the causes of the spill, to recover costs these agencies andlor
their governments incurred in connection with the spill, and to direct corrective action to
prevent the incident from recurring; and
WHEREAS, the attached settlement agreement reflects Miami-Dade County
DERM's review and assessment of the spill and the settlement of all possible issues with
respect to the claims of Miami-Dade County and DERM; and
WHEREAS, while the City is a party to this agreement as lessee of the
submerged bay bottom of the Miami Beach Marina, obligations of the City under this
agreement are solely in connection with the payments to be made by insurance companies
on behalf of third parties under whose policies the City is named as an additional insured;
and
WHEREAS, no liability for payment, or for any action related to the spill, is
admitted or imposed, express or implied, on behalf of the City, in this agreement; and
WHEREAS, the City Attorney expects to bring future resolutions to the
Commission for its consideration of (I) a settlement agreement reflecting DEP's resolution
of its investigation into the sewage spill, and (2) a settlement agreement to collect the
City's costs from the sewage spill; and
WHEREAS, based on the foregoing, the City Attorney recommends that the
Mayor and City Commission adopt this resolution approving the Agreement and
authorizing its execution.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY
COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, that the Settlement
Agreement with Miami-Dade County, for the Miami Beach Marina sewage spill, attached
to this Resolution is hereby approved and the Mayor, City Clerk and any other necessary
City personnel are hereby authorized to execute the Settlement Agreement and all other
documents as may be necessary to carry out the intent of this Resolution,
PASSED and ADOPTED this 27th day of June
~A
,2001.
MAYOR
ATTEST:
~( P t<ML--
CITY CLERK
APPROVED AS TO
FORM & LANGUAGE
& FOR EXECUTION
~
City Attorney
~""I 5"... 01
Date
F:\Atto\$al1\Sheila\Reso-ord.cm\MBMarinaSewageSpill.Res
2
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
~ efJldmme 71-
F lOR 0 A
MURRAY H. DUBBIN
City Attorney
Telephone:
Telecopy:
(305) 673-7470
(305) 673-7002
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM NO.
L{J.~-OL
SUBJECT:
Mayor Neisen Kasdin DATE: June 27, 2001
Members of the City Commission
Jorge M. Gonzalez, City Manager . O..D V
Murray H. Dubbin, City Attorney M ~-
RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF
THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH APPROVING THE SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENT WITH MIAMI-DADE COUNTY FOR THE MIAMI
BEACH MARINA SEWAGE SPILL AND AUTHORIZING THE
MAYOR, CITY CLERK AND ANY OTHER NECESSARY CITY
PERSONNEL TO EXECUTE THE SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT
AND ALL OTHER DOCUMENTS AS MAY BE NECESSARY TO
CARRY OUT THE INTENT OF THIS RESOLUTION.
TO:
FROM:
RECOMMENDATION
The City Attorney recommends that the Mayor and City Commission adopt the
accompanying resolution approving execution of the subject Settlement Agreement with
Miami-Dade County.
ANALYSIS
Following the sewage spill at the Miami Beach Marina on or about June 20, 2000, the
City of Miami Beach and other governmental regulatory agencies, including Miami-Dade
County Department of Environmental Resources Management (DERM) and Florida
Department of Environmental Protection (DEP), have undertaken investigations to
AGENDA ITEM )27 F
DATE ~-,;zJ-cr
1700 Convention Center Drive - Fourth Floor -- Miami Beach, Florida 33139
Commission Memorandum
June 27, 2001
Page 2 00
determine the causes of the spill, to recover costs these agencies and/or their governments
incurred in connection with the spill, and to direct corrective action to prevent the
incident from recurring,
The attached settlement agreement reflects Miami-Dade County DERM's review and
assessment of the spill and the settlement of all possible issues with respect to the claims
of Miami-Dade County and DERM. While the City is a party to this agreement as lessee
of the submerged bay bottom of the Miami Beach Marina, obligations of the City under
this agreement are solely in connection with the payments to be made by insurance
companies on behalf of third parties under whose policies the City is named as an
additional insured, No liability for payment, or for any action related to the spill, is
admitted or imposed, express or implied, on behalf of the City, in this agreement.
In sum, the Agreement provides as follows:
1. The Parties to the Agreement are Miami-Dade County, Miami Beach Marina
Associates, Ltd. ("MBMA"), RCI Marine, Inc., City of Miami Beach, Marin and Marin
Construction, Inc" Henry Joseph Deluca, Commercial Union Insurance Company,
Reliance Insurance Company, New York Marine and General Insurance Company, and
American Equity Insurance Company (all parties are collectively identified in the
Agreement as "Parties" except the County).
2. In the recitals on page one, the Agreement sets out the history of the sewage
spill.
3, Paragraph 1, beginning at page 2, provides for payment to the County of $2,5
million dollars, by the insurance companies on behalf of the Parties, and Paragraph 2
provides for such payment within 30 days of the effective date of the Agreement.
4. Paragraph 3 prevents Marin from performing any County work for two years,
commencing December 1, 2000.
5, Paragraph 4 directs MBMA to pursue an easement for the County for its 54-
inch sewage force main inside the Miami Beach Marina, and provides for consent by the
County for future use, modification or construction of the marina facilities within the
easement area. Paragraph 4 also includes a waiver by MBMA for compensation for the
easement, and provides for "locating" the main, and placing of concrete slabs over the
main to protect it.
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY ,1700 CONVENTION CENTER DRIVE, MIAMI BEACH. FLORIDA 33'39
Commission Memorandum
June 27, 2001
Page 3 00
6, Paragraphs 5 and 6 provide for releases by the County to the Parties, and by the
Parties to the County.
7. Paragraph 7 reserves the rights of the Parties to execute releases among them,
but confirms that this Agreement shall not be construed as such a release.
8, Paragraphs 8, 9, II and 12 are standard contract clauses.
9. Paragraph 10 provides that nothing in the Agreement constitutes an admission
of liability or wrongdoing or coverage of any kind by or between the Parties or by the
County.
We expect to bring future resolutions to the Commission for its consideration of (1) a
settlement agreement reflecting DEP's resolution of its investigation into this matter, and
(2) a settlement agreement to collect the City's costs from this matter,
Based on the foregoing, the City Attorney recommends that the Mayor and City
Commission adopt the accompanying resolution approving the Agreement and
authorizing its execution,
cc: Douglas M. Halsey, Esq., White & Case
MHD:RD:LAL:~
F:\A TTO\$ALL\SHEILA \RESO-ORD,CM\MBMaringSew-SpiILCM,rev,doc
OFFICE OF THE CITV ATTORNEV, 1100 CONVENTION CENTER DRIVE, MIAMI BEACH. FLORIDA 33139
"
,-.~,
JOOI-ZI{'f1r (L7F 0/'1'7)
:J.t(5 0Q \ !5
1.0-14-01
~- 7/2--01
SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT
BETWEEN
01 AUG - 3 r,i: 11 : "2 MIAMI-DADE COUNTY
AND
ell ~ ,,11 Ot<NM1AMIf'l!jj!ACH MARINA ASSOCIATES, LTD,
AND
RCI MARINE, INC.
AND
CITY OF MIAMI BEACH
AND
MARIN AND MARIN CONSTRUCTION, INC.
AND
HENRY JOSEPH DELUCA
AND
COMMERCIAL UNION INSURANCE COMPANY
AND
RELIANCE INSURANCE COMPANY
AND
NEW YORK MARINE AND GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY
AND
AMERICAN EQUITY INSURANCE COMPANY
This Settlement Agreement is entered into on this 02 ""'"
dayof~U n~
,2001, by
and between Miami-Dade County ("the County"), the Miami Beach Marina Associates, Ltd, ("MBMA"),
RCI Marine, Inc" the City of Miami Beach ("Miami Beach"), Marin and Marin Construction, Inc, ("Marin"),
Henry Joseph DeLuca ("De Luca"), Commercial Union Insurance Company ("Commercial Union"), Reliance
Insurance Company ("Reliance"), New York Marine and General Insurance Company ("New York Marine"),
and American Equity Insurance Company ("Al11erican Equity"). When used herein thr term "the Parties"
refers to all of the above entities but excludes the County.
WHEREAS, the County owns and operates a 54-inch sewage force main ("the main'') that runs from
the far southern portion of Miami Beach, across Government Cut, to Miami-Dade Water and Sewer
Department's ("W ASD's") Central District Wastewater Treatment Plant; and
o
WHEREAS, an average of twenty-five million gallons of sewage passes through the main each day
and there is no active alternative means of disposing of the sewage generated by Miami Beach other than
sending such sewage through the main to the Central District Wastewater Treatment Plant; and
WHEREAS, the main runs under a portion of the Miami Beach Marina owned by the City of Miami
Beach and used by MBMA to moor boats and over which MBMA has constructed finger piers and has
installed boatlifts; and
WHEREAS, Marin was retained to install further boat lifts at the Miami Beach Marina, such
installation involving the driving of concrete pilings into the bay bottom; and
WHEREAS, during the course of such pile driving, Marin drove a pile into the main, rupturing it lI1d
causing the release of raw sewage into Government Cut and surrounding waters; and
WHEREAS, the County incurred substantial costs due to the ruptured main; and
WHEREAS, all Parties hereto desire to completely resolve and settle all issues which were orcould
have been raised on all damages or costs of any nature incurred, including both direct and indirect costs
incurred by the County, its contractors, agents, or consultants, any claim the County may have to enforce
penalties against the Parties pursuant to any provision of the Miami-Dade County Code or other applicable
law arising out of the ruptured main, and any claim the Parties may have against the County arising out of the
ruptured main,
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual covenants and agreements set forth below, and
other good and valuable consideration, the sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged, the County and the
Parties agree as follows:
1. MBMA, RCI, City of Miami Beach, Marin, and DeLuca, by and through their
respective insurers, shall pay to the County the sum of $2.5 million dollars to be paid as follows:
Commercial Union (on behalf of
MBMA, RCI and City of Miami Beach)
$1,000,000.00
20f9
1
Reliance (on behalf of MBMA, RCI,
and City of Miami Beach)
$ 500,000.00
New York Marine (on behalf of
Marin)
$ 800,000,00
American Equity (on behalf of
De Luca)
$ 200,000.00
2, The payment contemplated in Paragraph 1 herein shall be made no later than 30 days
of the effective date of this agreement. It is understanding of the County and the Parties that
$350,000,00 of the above sum shall be deposited into the County's Biscayne Bay Environmental
Enhancement Trust Fund,"
3, Marin shall not perform work on any County contract, either as a prime or a sub-
contractor at any tier, for a period of two years, said period to retroactively commence on December
1,2000,
4, (a) To the extent permissible under the modified Submerged Land Lease No.
130765469 and the Marina Lease (as amended) between the MBMA and Miami Beach, MBMA
shall consent to or convey a 25 foot wide easement to the County, as necessary and at no cost to the
County, in a form acceptable to the County over those areas under which the main runs. To the
extent that the consent or conveyance of the easement requires the involvement of Miami Beach
and/or the State of Florida, MBMA will assist the County in seeking sa ' conveyance or consent
from Miami Beach and/or the State of Florida, MBMA shall be allowed to make use of, modify, or
construct boat slips, boatlifts, pilings, fmger piers, or other facilities which lie inside any existing or
future easement held by the County to the extent that the County expressly consents to such use,
modification, or construction. No consent shall be given except in writing from the Director of the
3of9
q
Miami-Dade Water and Sewer Department or his designee; said consent shall not be unreasonably
withheld and shall be either approved, denied or modified within 14 days of receipt of a written
request for such consent. Any denial of consent shall set forth the reasons for denial in writing and
shall to the extent possible set forth the modifications under which consent would be granted,
MBMA shall remain responsible for procuring appropriate permits for any such modification, use or
construction and consent given under this clause shall not waive or modify any applicable County or
other permitting requirements, MBMA shall permit the County to observe such modification or
construction at the County's discretion and shall provide the County not less than forty-eight (48) hours
notice prior to the commencement of construction,
(b) MBMA waives any legal right to compensation or other relief for the grant of such
easement to the County and also waives any legal right to compensation or other relief as may lrise out of the
County's reasonable withholding of or grant of consent to use of the marina structures as detailed in
Paragraph 4(a) herein,
(c) The County, at its sole expense, shall use reasonable efforts to locate the position of the
main as it passes under the Miami Beach Marina, MBMA shall provide assistance to the County insofar as
such assistance is limited to permitting the County to make use of areas inside the Marina, moving boats or
other vessels as needed, and curtailing activities inside the Marina which may disrupt the process oflocation,
such assistance to be made at MBMA' s sole expense.
(d) MBMA shall place concrete slabs or other mutually accepted protection in the areas
where mooring slips exist or are to be created, on the bay bottom over the top of the main, as located by the
County, of sufficient width as to cover the diameter of the main plus five feet on either side of the main and
of sufficient thickness to prevent a pile being driven through the main, Such slabs or other protectim shall be
.
placed within 120 days of the County providing the MBMA with a reasonably accurate location of the pipe
40f9
~
and tbe issuance of any required permits for said installation, MBMA agrees to diligently pursue required
permits as soon as tbe locational information is provided by tbe County.
5, The County completely releases and forever discharges the Parties, together with their
past, present and future officers, directors, stockholders, attorneys, agents, servants, representatives,
employees, subsidiaries, affiliates, partners, predecessors and successors in interest and any and aU
other persons, firms or corporations with whom any of the former have been, are now, or may
hereafter be affiliated, of and from any and all past, present or future liability, in law or equity,
claims, demands, obligations, actions, and/or causes of action whether based on a tort, contract,
equitable subrogation, indemnification and/or fraud or other theory ofrecovery, and whether for
compensatory or punitive damages which the County and/or their beneficiaries may now have, or
which may hereafter accrue or otherwise be acquired, on account of or in any way growing out of a
claim arising out of the rupture of the County's 54-inch sewer force main which took place on or
about June 20, 2000, as a result of work being performed in and around the Miami Beach Marina,
This Settlement Agreement and Release, on part of the County, shall be fully binding and a complete
settlement between the County and the Parties herein.
The County and the Parties hereby acknowledge and agree that the Release set forth herein is
a General Release and further expressly waive and assume the risk of any and all claims for damages
that exist as of this date but that the County or Parties do not '<now or suspect to exist, whether
through ignorance, oversight, error, negligence or otherwise and which, if known, would materiaUy
affect their decision to enter into this Settlement Agreement and Release. The County further agrees
that it has accepted payment of the sum specified in Paragraph 1 herein as a complete compromise
5of9
(0
/'
and satisfaction of any disputed issues of law and fact, and ful!y assumes the risk that facts or laws
may be otherwise than it believes.
6, The Parties completely release and forever discharge the County, together with its
past, present and future officers, directors, stockholders, attorney's agents, servants, representatives,
employees, subsidiaries, affiliates, partners, predecessors and successors in interest, or and from any
and all past, present or future liability, in law or equity, claims, demands, obligations, actions, and/or
causes of action whether based on a tort, contract, equitable subrogation, indemnification and/or
fraud or other theory of recovery, and whether for compensatory or punitive damages which the
Parties and/or their beneficiaries may now have, or which may hereafter accrue or otherwise be
acquired, on account of or in any way growing out ofa claim arising of the rupture of the County's
54-inch sewer force main on or about June 20, 2000, as a result of work being performed in and
around the Miami Beach Marina, This Settlement Agreement and Release, on the part of the Parties,
shal! be fully binding and a complete settlemenl between the County and the Parties herein.
The County and the Parties hereby acknowledge and agree that the Release set forth herein is
a General Release and further expressly waive and assume the risk of any and all claims for damages
which exist as of this date but that the County or Parties do not know of or suspect to exist, whether
through ignorance, oversight, error, negligence or otherwise and which if known would materially
affect their decision to enter in this Settlement Agreement and Release. The Parties further agree
that they have accepted the County's release as recited herein, their obligation to pay the amounts
specified in Paragraph 1, and the other obligations described herein as a complete compromise and
satisfaction of any disputed issues of law and fact, and fully assume the risk that facts or laws may be
otherwise than they believe,
60f9
( (
7, The Parties may elect to execute special releases between or among
themselves; however, nothing herein shall be construed as a release between or among
the Parties,
8, This agreement is complete and contains the full understanding of the
Parties and the County, This agreement may not be modified without the express written
consent of the Parties and the County. This agreement supersedes all other terms,
provisions, or specifications of any prior documentation or agreement as may exist
between the Parties or the County,
9, This agreement is subject to approval of the Miami-Dade County Board of
County Commissioners,
10, Nothing contained herein constitutes an admission of liability or
wrongdoing or coverage of any kind by or between the Parties or by the County,
II, This agreement shall be interpreted according to Florida law,
12, . This Agreement may be executed in multiple counterparts, each of which shall
be deemed to be an original.
t"2.,
Witnesses:
~
~~~~
Attest:
By:
City Clerk
Approved as to form and
Legal sufficiency:
City Attorney
Witnesses:
Witnesses:
MIAMI BEACH MARINA ASSOCIATES, LTD.
By: Sobe Ma ' e, Jnc" its ole eneral Partner
By:
Print
Title:
RCI
CITY OF MIAMI BEACH
By Its Mayor
By:
Print Name:
Title:
MARIN AND MARIN CONSTRUCTION, INC.
By:
Print Name:
Title:
COMMERCIAL UNION INSURANCE COMPANY
(on behalf of Miami Beach Marina Assoc" Ltd. RCI Marine, Inc"
and The City of Miami Beach)
By:
Print Name:
Title:
80f9
\Vitnesses:
Witnesses:
Attest:
By:
~r PMck
City Clerk
APPROVED N3 TO
FORM & LANGUAGE
& FOR EXECUTION
~
'~').i-o ,
Date
Witnesses:
Witnesses:
-
Ml.\.\-U BEACH "'l.\RL'i,.\ ASSOCI..\ TES. 1 TD,
By: Sobe Marine. Inc,. its Sole General Partner
By:
Print Name:
Title:
Robert \V, Christoph
President
RCI "'l.\RIl'iE, INe.
By:
Print Name:
Title:
Robert W, Christoph
President
CITY OF MB,:.vrr BEACH
By!" M.y" ~~JA
By: Li/fIl
,
PrintName:~w;S~ O. KASDUI
Tit]e: MA'IOI'-
MARIN AND MARIN CONSTRUCTION, INC.
By:
Print Name:
Title:
COMMERCIAL UNION INSURANCE COMPANY
(on behalf of Miami Beach Marina Assoc., Ltd, RCI Marine, Inc.,
and The City of Miami Beach)
By:
Print Name:
Title:
80f9
'Nitn~sses:
Witnesses:
Attest:
By'
MIAMI BEACH MARlJ'/A ASSOCIATES, LTD.
By: Sobo Marine, lne" its Sole General Partner
By:
Print Name:
Title:
Robert W, Christoph
President
RCI MARIJ";E, ~c.
By:
Prim Name:
Title:
Robert W, Christoph
Pr~sicel1t
CITY OF MiAMI BEACH
By lts Mayor
By:
Ci~' C]~rk
Approved as \J forrr, and
LeBal !itl:fic:e:lcy:
City A !lorno)'
PrInt l'a:r.e:
Ti~ie:_~
,
<- :":~==ON'~C
P;intN ,e ~ ~"'d
T!t1e: _ !.L_-'
COMMERCIAL UNION r;SlIRANCE COYlJ>ANY
(on behalf cfMiami Beach Marina Assoc., Ltd, ReI Marille, be.,
.nd The Clly of Mi.mi Beach)
B)I,
Print Name:
Title:
8 cf9
i
I
I
,
,
I
i
I
I
..i,
i
Witnesses :
Witnoss0s:
Attest:
By:
City Clerk
Approved as to form and
Legal .ufficiency:
City Attorney
Witnesses:
Witne..es:
&+"'--.Q.
~-..- f/
v- .
MIAMI HEACll MARINA ASSOCIATES, LTD.
By: Sobe Marine, Inc" its Sole General Partner'
By:
Print Name:
Title:
Robert W, Christoph
President
RCI MAlUNE,INC.
By:
Print Name:
Title:
Robert W. Christoph
President
CITY OF MlAMlllEACH
By It!l Mayot
By:
Print Name:
Title:
MARIN AND MARIN CONSTRUCTION, INC.
By:
Print Name:
Ti1le:
COMMERCIAL UNION INSURANCE COMPANY
(on behalf of Miami Beach Marina Asloe" Ltd. ReI Marine, Inc.,
~, n.~""""l
By: ?1
Print Name: . }__!{,:~,t. 7
Title: A n-...~
80f9
JUN. -OS' 011T!;E) 17:5] BILZIN. <liMBERG, ET, AL
I
POI I
RE'LIANCE INSURANCE COMPANY
~n behalf of Miami Beach Mar.n. Assoc" Ltd" ReI Marine, Inc.
\' andTheC~'tYOfM" each)
Clrl\ Bv: ----~-
.. , -".
I'rintName: Jt,..<;t-.. ~E~....~
~ CwtIo (?.~,""c.J
\II' ,esses:
Witnesses:
Witnesses:
Attest:
Harvey Ruy;", Clerk
By:
Deputy CIerI:
Approved as to form and
Legal sufficiency:
Assisl...nt County Attorney
JUN-0S-2001 17:54
Title:
NEW YORK MARINE AND GENERAL INSURANCE
COMPANY
(on behalf of Marin and Marin COI\;!,tllCUO!l,,!I)t,). ,,; """ ,"""" vC''''''' "
By:
Print l'\ame:
Titlc:
A[\1ERICAN EQtJITY INSURANCE COMPANY
(on behalf on-lel1ry Joseph DeLlIca)
By:
Print Name:
Title:
MIAMI-DAIlE CO'CNTY
By lIS Board of COllnt)' Commissioners
By:
County Manager
90[9
94;;
P,ll
. 06/). 9/2001
09:46
~
06/D6/01 09:47 FAX
Witnf;1Sses;
Wi1:l1esses;
I~ j1J!
~
Witnesse!'
Attest:
Harvey Rtlvin, ClllTk
By:
Deputy Clerk
Approved. as to form al'ld
J;.egal roffioiency:
Assistant County Atto~ney
--
NO, 352
[;)10
Iai 011/011
RELUNCE INSURANCE COMPANY
(on beha\fofMiarni'Be~MariD.aAssoc" Ltd., ReI Mlll'iQe, me.
and The City of Miami Beach)
By:
l'rintName:
Title:
NEW YORK MARINE AJIij) GENERAL INSURANCE
COMP Am'
(on behalf of Marin and Marin Construction, Inc.)
f(J~
Sy:
Print Name: PAUL SMITH
Title: Loss .Secretary, MUTUAL MARINE OFFICE, MANAGERS
AMERICAN EQUlTYlNSURANCE COMPANY
(on behalf ofRemy Joseph OeTruea)
By:
Print Name:
Title:
MIAMI.DADE COUNTY
By Its Board ofCoUllty Commissioners
By:
C01,lnlY Manager
90f9
:,.... ~, .. ...t ..
OG:80 ~O, OG/LO 3WIl X~
'\--.-
'"-,,
: NOW;lJOl
Witnesses:
REUANCE JNStlMNCE COMPANY
(QIl bebalf (If MilLm i' Beach Marina Assoc., Ltd.., ReI Marine, 1no,
and The City ofMia.mi Beach)
'By:
Print Name:
Title:
Wi~e~ses:
NEW YORK MAJUlllE AND GENERA.I. INSURANC~
COMPANY
(on bebalf of Marin illd MlIl'in COllatrUctiol1.1nC.)
By:
Print Name:
Title:
Wi\11csses:
AMER1CAN 'EQtJlTY II'ISlllUNCE COMPAN):'
(on \:Iel1alf of Henry lpsepn De'L\\ca)
(~~~ ~~~
~ ~--.
Prilltl-olam~: ~?#- e::::::;...;?c.c::-
~;~~ 4-?.-4
By:
~L---d,~
r?U~: ~
Title:
Anes\;
li.a.r\ley R.u\ll\'\, Clerk
l\ItIAMJ.1)ADE COUNTY
B)lILS Board ofCoun1)1 COIl\misstoners
'By:
By:
COllnt)' Manager
Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
Legal ,umeieney:
AuiSl.ant Col,\nty Attome)l
2'd
W~L2:tt to, 02 lnr
Witnesses:
RELIANCE INSURANCE COMPANY
(on behalf of Miami Beach Marina Assoc" Ltd., RCI Marine, Inc,
and The City of Miami Beach)
By:
Print Name:
Title:
Witnesses:
NEW YORK MARINE AND GENERAL INSURANCE
COMPANY
(on behalf of Marin and Marin Construction, Inc.)
By:
Print Name:
Title:
Witnesses:
AMERICAN EQUITY INSURANCE COMPANY
(on behalf of Henry Joseph DeLuca)
By:
Print Name:
Title:
Attest:
Harvey Ruvin, Clerk
MIAMI-DADE CO
By Its Board unty ommissioners
B~~ By:
9of9
It.-(