Settlement Agreement — Z7
SETTLEMENT'AGREEMENT'
The -AT &T Corp:, on behalf of its •Corporate Officers and in their Corporate
capacities ( "AT &T Corp. "); the .City of Miami , Beach, for themselves and all. persons
or. entities .claiming by or them, and 'their directors,;, officers; principles, agents,
'. successors in interest. and Located at -1700 Convention Centers Drive, Fourth . Floor,
Miami .Beach, Florida 33139 assigns (collectively "Miami Beach "), hereby 'enter into this
Settlement .Agreement (the "Settlement Agreement") ,dated
,
:2011; -to :;settle as follows:
. a
RECITALS
WHEREAS, ..the City of Miami Beach has maintained an :.Agreement with the
AT &T Corp since .'December 8 2009,. and said'' Agreement provides 'emerg,ency 911
telephoner service and su,pport.for. the Miami Beach Police Department Public Safety
ComCnunications Unit; and
WHEREAS, the Agreement mandated that the quality. of the telephone,. service
would - meet specific industry standards, -which included but was not limited. to; the clear
and consistent - audible 'telephone transmissions and reception for: a monthly , fee of
$3,254.17 ,per morith; and
WHEREAS,',-the quality of the - telephone -' service has been 'functioning below .
industry standards with .poor audio transmissions, reception quality' -and the inability t0
dial. certain area codes; and
WHEREAS, the automatic call distributor and. management information ,software
:portion of the. AT &T Corp.. telephone system 'has not functioned as designed, and has
failed to distribute' inbound telephone calls equitably to -the Public Safety
Communications Unit. - Communications.'. Operators, and `in" some instances, failed: to
completely distribute telephone calls as required under the Agreement; and
WHEREAS, Ahe - City of - Miami Beach," by -and through Miami Beach Police
Department, withheld
$58 the monthly . 'fee payments in 'the total,,'. amount of .
; 639.81; and
WHEREAS °the. Parties -, have reached a settlement in regards to the City of
Miami Beach for its account under,nu.mber 305W93- 06200010445 (the "Account ".); and
:WHEREAS approval of the proposed, Settlement Agreement is in ahe best
intere .'WHEREAS.,,
t of the City of -Mi - ami Beach in "that it..avoids further cost and risks of `litigation
and protects -:the City of Beach from future, litigation and expense; and
WHEREAS, the -Parties believe it - would be in their best interests; -
and the
interests of .the citizens 'and - residents of. Miami Beach, to agree to the ..provisions of .this
Settlement - Agreement.
•
i
Page :1 of 6
Settlement Agreement
AT &T Corp: of Miami Beach :
Account No. 305W937'06200010445
. NOW; THEREFORE in consideration'of.th:e mutual.'agreecnents, undertakings
and representations. in this Settlement Agreement, :and other good and,
- valuable consideration the receipt and sufficiency.of which are hereby, acknowledged by
the' Parties AT &T-Corp. and Miami.Beach agree as
A. The-foregoing , recitals are true, accurate and correct and are incorporated :
herein by'this reference.
B.. General S.ettlement;Conditions.
J. Upon the full execution of this Settlement, Agreement, AT &T Corp. ~shal.l
` credit -ahe amount of $58,639.81 to the Account; which amount being .credited may be
subject . °to adjustment due 9 Y: _ to the applicability, of -, Re ulator Fees and Taxes, in full
. .. _
. i
settlement of the Dispute (Account No. 305W93- 06200010445 from 12/09 to 4/11)
2.': The, 'Parties shall execute this Settlement Agreement regarding all claims'.
based on 'the allegations set forth in the Dispute; and all claims that were o could have.
been brought .in the: Dispute, and AT &T Corp. and Miami Beach shall. provide - a release
as to: all .claims. that were or could -have been brought on .behalf of AT &T Corp. against
Miami .Beach orany of their officers; directors, principals o.r= agents, or in their individual
capacities relative to :Account No.`305W93- 0620001'0445 surrounding_the dispute as set
forth in the. Recitals: _
3 The' Parties shall beartheir own attorneys :fees and ,c ,. ,
' osts surro.un:ding the
'Disp_ute,, and 'shall . not be entitled to any attorney's lees' surrounding the Settlement.
Agreement, or the enforcement *of the 'Settlement Agreement.
4 This Settle ment.Agreement shall be construed, enf 'rced -and 'interpreted. .
in accordance 'with the laws of the .State of Florida. jr n the event that .an - ambiguity or
i
question -of. intent 'or interpretation arises, this Settlement Agreement shall - be construed"
as if crafted jointly by each of the Parties hereto and � no presumptions or. burdens of.
�~j; proof shall -arise favoring any party by:virt,ue.'of the a.uthorship ` of .the provisions of
ahe Settlement Agreement. The Parties jointly conclude that- ��should - this `Settlement
Agreement be challenged by any..;of the Parties, that venue forbringing such challenges_
.shall take place in the County :of Miami -Dade; Fonda.
5. Actions ,taken by any of
Ac the Parties hereto ,Pursuant or in furtherance of
the provisions hereof shall not be admissible in any Legal. proceeding . in the event the
transactions contemplated :hereunder, are not. performed ,or consummated, except as :
, necessary.tb enforce.the terms of this Settlement:- Agreement. .,
.
6 The Parties a ree -the „ will :take an and all' - a
9 y y . ctions consistent - with the .
:intent and purpose of- this, :Settlement Agreement and requirements 'of' appi,icable law;
and, :execute, acknowledge,'subscribe -and deliver 'any .and. all `further documents and
instruments as. may be: reasonably necessary to : effectuate -.the purposes of this
Settlement. Agreement.
P.age2of6
Settlement.Agreement
AT &T Corp and City`of Miami Beach .
Account ^No'..305W93- 06200010445
7. The_'Parties understand and agree that no party admits:liabilit' of any sort
., reason of the above - incidents, acts, casualties, events; representations, omissions,.
conduct, or- interpretation. The Parties also understand and agree fhat this Settlement
Agreement constitutes the good faith compromise .of the Dispute. and is 'made in good
faith to terminate any further controversy respecting all :claims-for damages, causes 'of:
action, or potential fibbility which. could have been ascertained` by..reasonable diligence
:which either.Party to this Settlement Agreement may have asserted now, or.. may 'assert
• in the future because of any damages incidents; acts,. casualties, or
events, described
,. or alluded to in this Settlernent.Agreement.
8. The Parties acknowledge that this Settlement Agreement constitutes the, .
entire agreement. They further= acknowledge that they have .read it :and . understand it
that the terms and: conditions of ahis Settlement Agreement were arrived at in 'arm's
length negotiations between the Parties with.all,Parties provided tlie,opport'unity.to seek
°the advice..of legal :counsel;,that each - Party's legal counsel did or could have reviewed
this .Settlement Agreement; and that each Party has given due:, and - full. consideration to
'the :le al ostion of the other in regard to the
g p g provisions contained herein.
.9.. This Settlement Agreement .shall be deemed - drafted by - ' all, Pasties and
there shall be no 4 presumption against any. party relating to the .drafting of the Settlement
Agreement, and the language used herein. .
10. Any notices required p m
q fired or ermitfed to "be given under this Settlement
Agreement . shall _be in writing and shall . be deemed to have been given if delivered . by
hand., sent by recognized overnight . courier such as` Federal Express) .or mailed ..b
.9 9 � - Y
'certified or registered :maill, return - .receipt requested, in 'a postage prepaid envelope,: and
. 'addressed as follows:
If to the Customer at: City of Miami Beach -
17.00 Convention Center. Drive ;
- Fourth `Floor. .
Miami Beach, Florida 3313:9
°Attn: City_Ma'nager
With a copy to:` City of Miami Beach
u 1700 Convention Center Drive
Fourth Floor
' M iami , Bea'c'h, ' 331'39.
Attn: ; City Attorney
If to AT &T Corp.
AT &T Corp Accounts Receivable: :Management.
333 Commerce Street, FLR 20
Nashville; TN - 37201 -1800
a e `3 'of 6
Settlement Agreement
_AT &T Corp. _and City of Miami Beach
Account No. 305W93= 06200010445
Notices personal .y delivered or sent by overnight courier shall be deemed given on the
date of delivery, and notices mailed in accordance -with the'.foregoing "shall be deemed
given upon receipt by the Parties:
- 1I.. The Parties - signing this Settlement Agreement represent and war rant that
they have Iull and complete Iegal and binding authorit y .'to enter into this .Settlement
Agreement. The ' Parties warrant- and represent that they have not sold; assigned;
transferred conveyed, or otherwise disposed of any of the claims demands, 6bli 9 ations,
or causes of action referred to in this Settlement Agreement.
12 This. Settlement' Agreement ' is :binding' on the Parties hereto and the.
Parties '.a ,agree to execute an and all documents necessary and consistent`'. with
.. g Y ` .
applicable law, to ratify, confirm, and perform the Perms- and s of this Settlement
Agreement. The terry' s of this Settlement shall be.binding on and inure to the'
benefit .of the Parties, their- legal . representatives, members, constituents; successors
assigns, subsidiaries and affiliates, and_ 'shall' supersede - all prior " discussions,
negotiations and agreements . among the Parties; concerning settlement. No
modification,` waiver, amendment, discharge, or change of this Settlement : Agreement
shall be valid unless the same. is in :writing- :and .signed by the Party against which the
enforcement of such modification, waiver, amendment, discharge, or change is sought.
arts, and the:
1 3:. : This 'Settlement Ag reement may be signed, in counter
p ,
signature counterparts of the Parties or their .authorized representative shall be treated
the -same as Jf this .Settlement Ag reement had - been* signed by all Parties or their
authorized re presentatives. A facsimile signature =be deemed the equivalent of on
original signature of a "Party or its authorized representative. .
14. Any prevention;.delay or stoppage. due .to lockouts; labor disputes;
acts of"God, inability, to obtain labor Or materials'or reasonable.substitutes therefore, riot,
civil commotion, fire or other.: casualty, 'and other causes beyond the reasonable control
of. - the 'Party obligated to perform, I excluding :the. 'financial inability of such .Party to
perform, shall excuse the performance by such Party :for' period- of time ..equal to any
such.. period : of prevention, delay or stoppage.. Any Party seeking: to - invoke this
.paragraph._,shail . provide written notice A the other. Party�as soon ' as reasonably
practicable under the circumstances,
15. In the event any provision term or - condition of this Settlement
A reement,
. . g on behalf .: of either Party, thereto. shall be inapplicable,,. invalid, illegal or
unenforceable in
a any respect, the remainder of this m
Settlement Agreeent and
for
application 'of such provisions, terms - or :conditions ' shall not, be affected thereby; - and
-shall be enforced to the fullest extent_.perm'itted by law:
16. It is- .hereby' .acknowledged by the Parties hat 'nothing contained in this
Settlement Agreement was intended to serve as a waiver of sovereign, immunity; as set `
forth and codified in Section 768.28 of the Florida Statutes; �by the -City of Miami :Beach
'to which sovereign immunit is applicable in "recover of damage in tort for money
9 Y PP Y' g Y
damages against the state or its agencies. or subdivision, or injury or Loss of property,
ersonal. injury, or death caused b the negligent or wron wrongful act or omission of an
P Y 9 Y -
- employee of the agency or subdivision while - acting within .the scope' of the employee's,
office or employment.
'Page 4of6
Settlement Agreement- ;
AT &T Corp..:and City of Miami Beach .
Account No. 3.0.5W93- 06200010445
• 17.. The Parties expressl acknowledge that it is not their intent: to� create -or
confer any 'rights or obligations in or upon any third' person or. entity .under this .
'Settlement Agreement. None of .the Parties - .intend to directly or substantial y benefit a
third party by this Settlement Agreement: The Parties agree that :there are no third party `
beneficiaries to this :Settle.ment. Agreement a_ nd that no third party shall be entitled to
assert a claim, against'- any of, th_e. :Parties based, upon this Settlement Agreement.
Nothing herein shall be construed as consent by an agency or, political :subdivision of the
State of, to be sued by third Parties.in. any manner. arising out of this.. Settlement
Agreel ent, or. other obligations, whether known or :unknown :to t he Parties.. :
•
A
V1/HEREFORE, the Pantie "s approve the above terms and enter into :this;
settlement of this Dispute between = them -as ; provided above' as of the date first entered.
above.
D ated: '
V1/ITNESSES: : AT &T Corp..
A uth orized* gnature for.
AT &T Corp: - _
- STATE OF FLORIDA
Qq SS:
a,9
COUNTY OF - M I E
HEREBY CERTIFY. that on this date,,before.me, �anofficer - duly- :authorized in
Count -
this State . .and to take ' acknowledgments, , personal)
y 9 personally .
authorized. Person for AT &T Corp., personally known
to. me or have produced identification',. named :in the .foregoing Settlement Agreement, :
and that he acknowledges executing the same freely and voluntarily,.
WITNESS my hand and official seal in `the County and State_ ast. aforementioned
this day 1CC E ��1� e V' 2011.. p Gk�U c Gt;G� R . m��4 -h �jj L
S S__ k l
.. it s.
•• O` e'- JOOiE C-COLEMAN -Nota . Public, State of�:Florida
:Notary.Pub is State of Ftarlda .
. : My Comm. 4
Expires _
COMMISS 965 CITY OF MIAMI.BEACH,
a 'Florida municipal corporation
, .
y:
Robert Pa • .
,:
D =
� Jocg G n z; Ci aria er
ORATE
age 5 of 6
�'/ 26
Settlement Agreement
:AT &T Corp. and .City of Miami Beach
Account - *No. '305W93- 06200010445 ' ,
1N.UVITNESS WHEREOF the parties have -set, their hands and seals on the..Aa
Y ,
and date first'written above. .
•
•, • ' OF MIAMI -BEACH FLORIDA,
nicipal corporation
ATTEST
INCORP ORgT
ED$y
B y .� ayor. Matti Herrera Bower
Robert Parcher;-
.•
STATE QF FLORIDA
- °SS
COUNTY OF MIAMI- DADS') .
h - .HEREBY .CERTIFY that on this day, of 201 c
V.
before me, an officer dul Y authorized in, this State. and County to take'ackno ivledgme'nts,
: ersonall a eared Matti ; Herrera ;Bower, .as .Ma oi, and - Robert Parches; as the Cit
P. y PI? Y y ,
Clerk, of the:,City of :Miami " Beach Florida, :a _municipal corporation of. the State. of. Florida'
on `behalf of such municipal corporation. They are personally known me,` named in the
foregoing° Settlement Agreement,. as well as personally appeared Jorge M.. Gonzalez, as
City `Manager, City of'.Miam :'Beach, - personal) known to me, =name.d.:in he fore oin
Y. g 9 .
'
General Release and. Waiver, and Ghat he acknowledged .executing the same freely and
vofiuntarily` behalf of 'the City; and that Have - acknowledged executing the same free "ly:
and voluntarily on behalf. of :the City..
WITNESS my hand and official seal in the County and .State "last 'aforementioned
this:; day of .201
2-
M.y Commissio xpires:
No
tary Pau Fi
blic Sta% ida a Large
` BEAUCyie,,��
P'�, oN
•• °
AP PR O VED AS TO FORM AND 2 F
' °� PQ y�9cn� =
- .LAN.GUAGE AND 'FQR EXECUTION:
o #DD 983701 0
e .publicUnde�° °
Cit t orne Pa��a�astit���
'
Page 6 o 6
GENERAL RELEASE AND WAIVER
KNOW-ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS:
That for value -received and other good and. valuable consideration; the receipt
and sufficiency of which 'are `hereby acknowledged, AT &T Corp., on behalf of the itself
and :its Corporate 'Officers, does .hereb:y for itself and its - :respective' heirs executors,
administrators., personal representatives; insurers, reinsurers, agents Successors, and
-assigns, and :any person : or -entity claiming by, through, - or for,:or succeeding. -to the right
of any .of the - foregoing. (hereinafter referred. to collectively as. "Reieasors" ) ; .relea'se,'
remise, acquit, satisfy, waive and forever discharge -the City of.Miaml its heirs;.
executors administrators, personal representatives, insurers, reinsurers, - agents;
:successors and assi ns, :and any person or `entit :actin for, b or through, any of the
Y g Y g Y
foregoing (hereinafter referred - to collectively as ``Releasees' } of and .from any and all
manner - of actions, causes of action, suits; debts`; costs; attorney's fees, sums of..
accounts,.. reckonings - bonds, bills, specialties, covenants, controversies; loss of
services, obligations liabilities, agreements; promises, variances, disputes, trespasses;
damages,,- repairs., injuries; losses, liens, .judgments;. executions, complaints, claims,' R
counterclaims; cross - claims' and all demands whatsoever, in law or in equity, whether.
known or unknown, , director indirect -which .Releasors ever had, now have or which may
hereafter. accrue for., upon br by .reason of any matter, :cause.. or `thing whatsoever . from
the beginning .of the world to the day of the date of this General'Release and Waiver, in
connection with or in any way arising, out of,' or relating to,, :or which were or could have
been asserted in, 8'.$58,639.81 dispute on' AT &T Account No.:305W93- 0620001.0445,
more full described in
that Settlement Agreement dated 2011
Y g `- -�'
(collectively, the "Claims " ):
"
Releasors agree that they will ;forever refrain and'forbear .from any action : or other
proceeding of any kind whatsoever, by way of. action, defense; set -off , cross- complaint,
courterclaim;.third party action or otherwise; .against Releasees, or any of ✓them, based
on, relating. - to, arising out :of, - or- in, connection with" any of. the 'Clairris released and
`discharged hereunder.
Releasors hereby waive; �to the `fullest" extent. permitted,.by law the' benefits of a'ny `
,
statute, law, rule, regulation or common law which may limit the scope - of the covenants-
and releases contained herein.
Releasers_ intend .by - this General Release and Waiver to forever - .release; remise,.
acquit,_waive; satisfy p9d.forever discha.rge:Releasees - of and from any and all Claims
Page 1 of:4
s
J -
s 1
a
.. r
F
,
J
a and related rights described above, *it being understood that ali.of the Claims or related
g ,.
��.
right-persons' s: which the Releasors or any who. claim' by,` through- or under .the <
° Releasors, aor any of them, may have against the Rel 'as.ees shall �be forever released;
remised, acquitted, waived; satisfied and forever discharged - , and - Releasors shall. `be
forever. barred from .brin in or assertin '.the same in their, own name'or names jointly
n g 9 g .,
'-or .with, or through any other person,, natural, corporate . or - otherwise.
eleasors acknowled e that it is' -their inten
R tion that, 'upon execution. .hereof, "this :
g
4f 4. - General "Release and V1/aiver. sfiaii' .be effectiye. as a °.full accord and •satisfact'ion an d
settle m ent: of, and .as.� a bar to ;.:each and every one of
ahe Claims.:released" hereunder
whether known or unknown
• .. ..
. Releasors represent and' warrant that no claim -which they have or might have
had against Releasees has been assigned or transferred to any other.,pers.on or, entity,
and agrees to indemnify :Releasees `arid hold Releasees:- harmless from °any and all
liabilit , or ex en resulting from the assignment or transfer of .any. such clai
Y ms.
P
V Releasors acknowl�ed e 'and agree this
g g . s General' Release and Waiver :is given
for the_.com romise of" doubtful and dis uteri ,claims, and shall :not ±b
p p• e construed as an
admission against "interest or.'adrnissio:n` "of liability on:the part' of,the. Releasers as to °an
claim, counterclaim, demand;, *: controversy, "dispute, defense; action, cause of action; or
thing mentioned herein and compromised and settled heceb surroundin' .the: Claims;
and that �Releasors< deny Jiability``tl ere or and ;intend merely .to avoid" the costs of
litigation.:'.
Releasors ;confirm that they'. are 'com etent and. acknowled e that he terms of
p
. 9.
this .General Release and Waiver are , contractual and not a mere .recital., Furthermore,,
the 'Releasers acknowledge that the Releasers have .
not. been influenced in any manner
m'makin this :General.Release and Waive
r by any: representations - or statements made
by or on behalf of " the° Reieasees, that the Releasers have received the advice of counsel
_. in connection
ction with the. effect of the execution and delivery - - of. this General Release and
1Naive.r, that the Releaso`rs have carefully read , and fully understand the contents of this'
General Release and Waiver, .and ,that , the Releasers have duly. authorized`the -execution
- -of this.-General -Release .and Waiver freely. -and voluntarily intending and agreeing to. be
fully: bound
by the teems hereof:
This Genera[ Release. and ;Waiver shall remain in full force and and' survive
_
-
any Iuture 'dealings -among -the Rele'asors and - Releasees,, unlessthis-General Release
Page, of
N
and - Waiver shall hereafter be: modified ':by: an instrument in writing and signed_ by -the,' .
Rele'asors, and b 'duly authorized. resentative (s of the •Releasees
Y Y P „)
I.N WITNESS: WHEREOF the. Releasors a = . .
nd the .Re(easees have .caused this::
General Release and Waiver to be` executed in their. names and its seal. to `be affi by xed, _
its proper and duly authorized re resentative, this y j� `-- , 2011
p � d
a of
. . .
• R
ELEA$ORS:
WITNESSES:
AT &T Corp
rN
' L
Aut
horized.-Person for AT&T-Corp`
. -STATE OF-FLORIDA
t,)
u cL,i °) SS.
COUNTY OF
fHB�rBE
. .
r I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this date, before me, `an officer duly authorized: in'.
this State and County to take acknowledgments, ,personally appeared the. Authorized
Person for AT &T MCorp., ��f rl R• :wf1�'1 personally known o me ` ;
or has pro duced :identification named in :the foregoing :General Release and vvaiver and
that he acknowledges executin the same free) __and voluntaril
g� Y Y y
WITNESS rt my ; hand .and official seal. in the County. ands State last aforementioned
this - ernhe r rc.1 V.,.�`�±
day. of 2011
,
FLA
My Corrimission Expires:
_
z Nota ,Public,,Saate,of Flo'nda
JODIE C COLEMAN
Notary Public - State of Flordda r
My; Comm: Expires Feb 24, 2014
ELEASEES.
- Commiss600 4 OD 965343 , 'R
: CITY , OF MIAMI 'B
EACH,
a :Florida municipal' corporation
ATTEST:`
An .,
` P.,.► on lez C' Man e
°
Robert.Parcher' City. Cie
Dated: S JAW w � RP ORATED'
: IN. V1/ITNESS WHEREOF ahe arties - have set their'hands and 'seals on the da
p ., Y'
and date first written above.
e
'...
MIAML`BEACH,/F:LORiDA, .
al corporation `
ATTEST. ..•
,
By: att! Herrera over
Robert Parcher .City Cl k : NGOR
-
:
. p ORAT
' •'
ff
'o
: STATE, OF FLORIDA '•.. 2
CO.UNTY.OF MIAMI. DADE
HEREBY CERTIFY that on this . d6
y' .o 201
before rne, an .officer duly,autho'rized in this State and: County fo :take acknowledgments,
personally appeared Matti Herrera :Bower,• as Mayor, and Robert_,Parcher,. - as the City
-
Clerk, of -the City of Miami Beach, Florida, a.:municipal corporation of" the State of Florida,,,
on behalf o. such :municipal corporation. They, are personally known'to rne, named in the
for-egoing.Settlement Agreement,: as.well as :personally appeared. Jorge M. as
-
City Manager, Gity:of `Miami Bea`ch, - personall known to me named in.-the fore oin
Y g g
Ge n era l Release ` Waiver, and that h e = acknowledg - executing the same freely and'
voluntarily on ,behalf of the City andahat - have .acknowledged executing the same freely ;
and voluntarily orr:behalf of fhe City.
WITNESS my hand and official- seal in - the County . State.'last_aforementioned -
this day of 201 � .
My Commission &Xpir
.S • 4�
N tary. Publi � Large
,
Q,pI I1Z9 2 •
}} P
Q O
.. APPROVED AS TO FORM AND :. � d .� . d � 9 L
LANGUAGE AN: FOR EXECUTION: thN
dery e
/ [�
T.. A ny c3
AE
v
i� torn
PageA of 4.