LTC 157-2013 Noise Report: Q1-2013 (January - March 2013) m MIAMI BEACH a-
IR. _ I V f-
.
OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGFR 2013 MV - I P 9 �
NO. LTC # LETTER TO C66ISSION
157-2013 CI T"r (CLJLi i-i'S Ur F IICE
TO: Mayor Matti Herrera Bower and Mpbers,,o,f he City Commission
FROM: Jimmy L. Morales, City Manager
DATE: April 28, 2013
SUBJECT: Noise Report— Q1 2013 (January— arc013)
Thi s Letter to Commission (LTC) provides the January through March 2013 (Q1-2013) Noise
Quarterly Report in accordance to the 2008 Administrative Guidelines. The data and analysis
presented on this LTC reflects the enforcement efforts by the Building Department's Code
Compliance Division. As required by the Administrative Guidelines, the data is presented in a table
format (Attachment A), and noise related to commercial areas is further analyzed and presented in
Attachment B.
I. Summary
Data analysis reflects that during Q1-2013 (January through March 2013) there were a total of
1,280 cases opened by Code Compliance. Of these:
• 24 were canceled by the complainant,
• 10 cases were voided due to error,
• 13 were deemed to be duplicate complaints,
• 123 were referred to the Miami Beach Police Department, and
• 18 cases were not applicable to Code.
The high number of cases referred to the Miami Beach Police Department (PD) is due to calls for
service, between 1:00 AM to 6:00 AM, Monday through Wednesdays, and Thursdays, from 3:00
AM to 6:00 AM where Code Compliance received no report of the outcome; or a PD related issue,
such as disturbing the peace.
The total number of cases with a valid or not-valid disposition was 1,092 of which 1,083 were
addressed by Code staff and nine (9) were addressed by Police. Of the nine (9) cases handled by
Police, eight (8) were determined to be not-valid and one (1) was reported to Code to be valid for a
violation to be issued.
The analysis reflects that 694 cases (63.6°/x) took place at residentially zoned locations; 295 (27%)
were identified to have taken place in commercially zoned properties; and 103 (9.4%) took place
within public property (reflected as "Other' in Attachment A).
Historically, one of the key parameters in the analysis of noise data is the validity rate. According to
the data, of the 1,092 cases with a disposition, a total of 286 were deemed valid, for an overall
26.2% validity rate. When the analysis is conducted exclusively for commercial cases (295), the
validity rate increases to 30.2% (89 valid cases). This is the highest validity rate for commercial
cases since Q1 of 2009.
LTC—Q1 2013 Noise Report Page 2 of 5
II. Analysis
Residential noise complaints have historically made up for approximately two-thirds (2/3) of all
noise complaints; with the remainder made up by noise emanating from commercial properties
(approximately 27%), and from the public property. The table below provides a breakdown by noise
type for Q1-2013.
t3R ,.KIIOWN OF TOTAL CASES BY TYPE
''.i January 2013-March 2013
RESIDENTIAL 694 63.6%
COMMERCIAL 295 27.0%
OTHER 103 9.4%
TOTAL 1 1,092 100%
The chart below provides a historical perspective of both residential and commercial noise
violations, beginning on Q4-2007 through the current rating period.
Residential vs. Commercia Noise Violations
Historical Data by Quarter
Residential
Commercial
37
426 6 9 76 8�66 2
640 71 752 73 6 4
62
48 4 23 339 92 189 6 19 �'q 2
72 13 252 8 9 12 27
ti d'' tio ti o ti
ti o o ti p o oti ti otiti ti oti�oti otitioti�otiw otiw oti
ti ti ti ti ti ti
III. Commercial Noise Cases
As previously reflected, the noise validity rate for commercial cases for Q1-2013 was 30.2%. This is
highest rate since Q1-2009. The analysis also reflects a pattern of noise validity near at roughly 1
out of every 3 cases, over the last four quarters. The administration believes that this phenomenon
can be attributed to an increase in staff training, accountability and supervision. The trend analysis
is illustrated in the chart below.
Commercial Cases-Noise Valid"
r m
By Quarter-Q1 2013
0.0
25.0%
20.0%
1%
15.0 15.0 .` .2% 1%
10 do do do titi titi titi titi �� �� �� �� ��
',�. ati oti C�, c�, o"' oti C3, oti ati 0, c° ti
LTC—Q1 2013 Noise Report Page 3 of 5
A total of 295 cases were identified to have taken place on commercially zoned areas, of which the
highest number of commercial cases opened were for hotels (101 cases — 34.2%), followed by
restaurants (75 cases — 25.4%), and clubs (51 — 17.3%). The remaining breakdown is reflected in
Attachment B.
Supplementary analysis of the commercial cases and of the valid closure rates for Q1-2013 reflects
the following:
• During the reporting period, of the 295 commercial cases, 89 cases (30.2%) were closed
as valid. As previously mentioned, this is the highest validity rate attained by the Division
in the past five (5) years, and since Quarter 1 of 2009.
• Within commercial establishments, the percentage of cases closed as valid varied as
follows:
• Hotels: 28 cases (31.5% of the valids, and 9.5% overall),
• Restaurants: 27 cases (30.3% of the valids, and 9.2% overall),
• Clubs: 13 cases (14.6% of the valids, and 4.4% overall),
• Condo-Hotels: 10 cases (11.2% of the valids, and 3.4% overall),
• Bars: 8 cases (9.0% of the valids, and 2.7% overall)
• Retail Stores: 3 cases (3.4% of the valids, and 1.0% overall).
liAN
BARS
RESTAURANTS 8-9.0%
27 -30.3%
CLUBS
13 -14.6%
RETAIL
3-3.4%
CONDO-HOTEL
10- 11.2% HOTELS
28 - 31.5%
A. Type of Noise - Commercial Cases
A historic analysis clearly reflects that since the inception of the Noise Report, loud music has been
the most common type of noise. Attachment B reflects that during the rating period, loud music
accounted for 93.2% of the commercial cases (275). Further exploration reflects 17 cases (5.8%)
for"construction noise", followed by "barking dog" (3 cases, 1.0%).
LTC—Q 1 2013 Noise Report Page 4 of 5
B. Time/Day of Week of Commercial Noise occurring
An analysis of the time the violation took place reflects a return to the previous trend where the time
of the complaint again is relatively evenly distributed between Evening Shift (11 PM — 7AM) and the
Day Shift (7AM — 11 PM). This quarter shared the commercial cases with 158 (53.6%) for the Day
Shift and 137 (46.4%)for the Night Shift.
As it relates to the day of the week the noise case was opened, this pattern remains unchanged.
Without a doubt, the highest number of cases were opened for noise taking place on the weekends
(Fridays and Saturdays), with 42.7% of all the cases addressed during this two day period; and
57.6% if Sundays are included. As in previous reports, the busiest day of the week (in regard to
noise-related cases) is Saturday, accounting for 26.8% of all the cases. This quarter however, the
second highest day for reported cases was equally followed by Thursday and Friday with 15.9%
each.
C. Arrival Time
"Arrival time" reflects the time from when a call is received by Dispatch (which is operated by the
Parking Department); to the time the assigned CCO arrives to the location of the complaint. During
the rating period, the average arrival time (in minutes and seconds, mm:ss) for commercial cases
was 23:45, with an aggregate average time of 23:38 minutes for valid cases and 24:17 for non-valid
commercial noise cases. There appears to be little correlation in the response time with respect to
validity of the complaint.
The average time for CCO arrival is provided below, including residential and "other" cases as a
basis for comparison.
Average Time for Code Officer to Arrive Q1-2013
a Establishment Status
Type
,.
VALID
Residential€ 26:01
NON-VALID 494 26:56
978 Commercia 24:09 VALID
NON-VALID 194 24:17
Other 23:45 VALID 19:45
NON-VALID 77 24:35
All Cases 25:19 VALID 77 213 22:43
NON-VALID 1 765 26:02
'Average Time Calculated using only those cases with valid time data for both'Time Call Received by Dispatch"and
'Time of Arrival by Code Compliance Officer'
V. Special Events
During the reporting period, the City had two major events: Winter Music Festival and Spring Break,
both which significantly contributed towards a higher number of noise complaints and calls for
service. During the ten-day period between Thursday, March 14, 2013 and Sunday, March 24,
2013, the Code Compliance Division answered 240 noise complaints, which accounts for 21.9% of
all the calls received for the three (3) month period. This placed a great demand on Code
resources, necessitating staff adjustments by placing officers on mandatory 12 hours shifts (Alpha-
Bravo-Charlie Shifts).
LTC—Q 1 2013 Noise Report Page 5 of 5
VI. Special Masters Appeal Hearings
In accordance to the Administrative Guidelines, all noise cases are appealable before a Special
Master. Attachment C reflects the status of noise-related cases appealed or heard during this
reporting period. Of the 35 cases reflected in the report, 16 are for violations issued in 2012. Of
these 16, eight (8) were upheld, three were dismissed as per an order agreed upon between the
City Attorney's Office and the alleged violator, two (2) were determined not be proven valid with
clear and convincing evidence, and two (2) have not yet been heard,
This leaves 19 cases where the violation(s) were issued during this reporting period. These cases
include three (3) violations upheld, one (1) case was reduced to a warning as a result of a
preceding case, one (1) case determined to not be proven by clear and convincing evidence, and
14 have not yet been heard.
IV. Noise Ordinance Exemptions
During the rating period, there were no Noise Ordinance Exemptions.
V. CONCLUSION
The data reflects an increase in the validity rate which can be attributed to a number of factors
including improved accountability and oversight.
JLM/1"G/SS/HC/RSA
Attachments
Attachment A-Noise Case Data-Q1 2013
Attachment B-Commercial Noise Cases-Q1 2013
Attachment C-Special Masters-Q1 2013
FACODE\$ADM\Robert\NOISE REPORTS\Q1 2013\Q1 2013 LTC-4-26-13 LTC(rev rm).docx
ATTACHMENT A
ALL CASES
Noise Data 01/01/2013 - 03/31/2013 (Q1 -2013)
Total Number of Noise Complaint Cases •.- Disposition
Less Voided, Canceletl,
Code or PD
Duplicate complaints, Complaint Calls
Total Cases Opened Complaints not Applicable to Total with Dispositions Initiated Received Type #
Code Compliance
(Proactive)
1,280 188 1,092 33 1,059 Total Cases 1,280
Canceled- 59
Voided" 10
"Voided cases are cases that were entered in error, etc. Duplicate Complaint 3
" "Canceled calls are cases canceled by the complainant prior to a Code Officer's arrival Not Applicable to Code 3
Referred to PD 113
Valid Vi olation Breakdown Total Valid and Non -Valid Cases 1,092
Verbal 41 14.3% Valid Cases 286
Written Warnin 180 62.9% Non -valid Cases 806
Violation 65 22.7%
Total Val(tl Cases 286 100%
Noise by .• of Establishment
Total Cases Valid Non -Valid
Percentage of All Percentage of Percentage of
Number Of Cases Cases Number of Cases Cases Number of Cases Cases
Residential 694 63.6% 175 25.2% 519 74.8%
Commercial 295 27.0% ll 30.2% 206 69.8%
Other 103 9.4% 22 1.4 0 81 78.6 %
Totals 1 100% 288 808 73.8%
Residential = Apt, Condo, Single Family
Commercial = Bar, Club, Hotel, Hotel - Condo, Restaurant, Retail, Consfr -Com
Other = Bandshell, Beady, Public Property, etc..
Total Cases Valid Cases Non -Valid Cases
Percentage of All Percentage of Percentage of
Number of Cases Cases Number of Cases Cases Number of Cases Cases
APT 355 3205% 69 6.3% 286 26.2%
BAR 25 2.3% 8 0.7% 17 1.6%
CLUBS 51 4.7% 13 1.2% 38 3.5%
CONDO 171 15.7% 39 3.6% 132 12.1%
CONDO -HOTEL 36 3.3% 10 0.9% 26 2.4%
HOME 168 15.4% 67 6.1% 101 92%
OTHER 103 9.4% 22 2.0% 81 7.4%
RESTAURANT 75 1 6.9% 27 2.5% 48 4.4%
RETAIL 7 0.6% 3 0.3% 4 0.4%
HOTEL 101 9.2% 28 2.6% 73 6.7%
Totals 1 1 100% 286 28.2% 806 1 73.8%
04/26/2013 Page 1 of 3
.-
. Noise Cases by Noise NOisa T TOTALS Valid Cases Non,alid Cases
LOUD MUSIC 850 77.8% 238 21.8% 612 56.0%
LIVE ENTERTAINMENT 3 0.3% 2 0.2% 1 0.1%
BARKING DOG 109 10.0% 21 1.9% 88 8.1%
CROWD NOISE 2 0.2% 0 0.0% 2 0.2%
CONSTRUCTION 119 10.9% 21 1.9% 98 9.0%
OTHER 0 0.0% 0 0.0% 0 0.0%
HONKING CARS /ALARMS 9 0.8% 4 0.4% 5 0.5%
Totals 1 100%. 286 26.2% 806 73.8%
Call Time of D. Day of Week
ALL CASES VALID AND NON -VALID
Total 7a -lip tip -7a
of the following mornin
Monday 119 10.9% 65 6.0% 54 4.9%
Tuesday 83 7.6% 63 5.8% 20 1.8%
Wednesday 102 9.3% 82 7.5% 20 1.8%
Thursday 146 13.4% 89 8.2% 57 5.2%
Friday 183 16q8% 78 7.1% 105 9.6%
Saturday 267 24.5% 135 12.4% 132 12.1%
Sunday 192 17.6% 140 12.8% 52 4.8%
Totals 1,092 100'/ 652 59.7% 1 440
VALID
Total 7a -11p 11p Ta
ofthefollowin mornin
Monday 34 11.9% 11 3.8% 23 8.0%
Tuesday 21 703% 17 549% 4 144%
Wednesday 20 7.0% 14 4.9% 6 201%
Thursday 38 13.3% 21 7.3% 17 5.9%
Fnday 35 121% 14 4.9% 21 7.3%
Saturday 87 30.4% 43 15.0% 44 15.4%
Sunday 51 17.8% 38 13.3% 13 4.5%
Totals 286 100'/ 158 55.2% 128 44.8
NON -VALID
lip - 7a
Total 7a -11 p
of the following mornin
Monday 85 10.5% 54 6.7% 31 3.8%
Tuesday 62 7.7% 46 5.7% 16 2.0%
Wednesday 82 10.2% 68 8.4% 14 1.7%
Thursday 108 13.4% 68 844% 40 5.0%
Fnday 148 18.4% 64 7.9% 84 10.4%
Saturday 180 2243% 92 11.4% 88 10.9%
Sunday 141 17.5 102 123% 39 4.8%
Totals 806 100•/ 494 61.3% 1 312 38.7
�Call Time of D. Residential
ttp -7a
Total 7a - 11p (of the following morning)
RESIDENTIAL 694 63.6% 421 38.6% 273 25.0%
COMMERCIAL 295 27.0% 158 14.5% 137 12.5%
OTHER 103 9.4% 73 6.7% 30 2.7%
Totals 1,092 100% 652 59.7% d40 40.3%
04/26/2013 Page 2 of 3
.Breakdown ..
Total Cases Valid Cases Non -valid Cases
Totals 1,092 100% 286 261% 806 73.8%
Anonymous Complainant 758 69.4% 173 15.8% 585 53.6%
Anonymous with Contact
made 58 5.3% 18 1.6% 40 3.7%
Contact Information
Provided 243 22.3% 64 5.9% 179 16.4%
Internal 33 3.0% 31 2.8% 2 0.2%
04/26/2013 Page 3 of 3
ATTACHMENT E1
COMMERCIAL NOISE CASES
Noise Data 01/01/2013 - 03/31/2013 (Q1 -2013)
Dispositi ,Total NUmber of Noise Complaint Calls Received o f
Cases
Total Cases Less Code or Type # %
(Valid and Non -valid only) PD Initiated Complaint Calls Received
(Proactive) Valid Cases 89 30.2%
296 25 270 Non -valid Cases 206 69.8%
Total Valid and Non -Valid Cases = 295 100%
Yalid Violation Breakdown
Verbal 33 37.1%
Written Warning 26 29.2%
Violation 30 33.7%
Total Valid Ceses 89 100%
,Noise Cases by Type of Establishment
Location Type Totals % of Commercial Cases Valid Non -Valid
B Establishment Type
BAR 25 8.5% 8 1 2.7% 17 5.8%
CLUBS 51 17.3% 13 4.4% 38 12.9%
CONDO -HOTEL 36 12.2% 10 3.4% 26 8.8%
RESTAURANT 75 25.4% 27 9.2% 48 16.3%
RETAIL 7 2.4% 3 1.0% 4 1.4%
HOTEL 101 34.2% 28 9.5% 73 24.7%
Total 5 100 % 89 30.2 %
29 206 1 69.8
�N oise Cases by No
Noise Type Totals % of Commercial Cases Valid Non -valid
( By Type of Noise
LOUD MUSIC 275 93.2% 85 28.8% 190 1 64.4%
LIVE ENTERTAINMENT 0 0.0% 0 0.0% 0 0.0%
BARKING DOG 3 1.0% 0 0.0% 3 1.0%
CROWD NOISE 0 0.0% 0 0.0% 0 0.0%
CONSTRUCTION 17 5.8% 4 1.4% 13 4.4%
OTHER 0 0.0% 0 0.0% 0 0.0%
HONKING CARS /ALARMS 0 0.0% 0 0.0% 0 0.0%
Totals 295 100% 89 30.2 % 206 69.8%
jime of D. Da of Week of Call
ALL CASES VALID AND NON -VALID
11p -7a
Total 7a - 11p
(of the following morning)
Monday 30 10.2% 14 4.7% 16 5.4%
Tuesday 19 6.4% 18 6.1% 1 0.3%
Wednesday 29 9.8% 27 9.2% 2 0.7%
Thursday 47 15.9% 21 7.1% 26 8.8%
Friday 47 15.9% 12 4.1% 35 11.9%
Saturday 79 26.8% 35 11.9% 44 14.9%
Sunday 44 14.9% 31 10.5% 13 4.4%
Totals 295 1 100.0% 158 53.6% 1 137 1 46.4%
VALID
11p - 7a
Total 7a - 11p
(of the following morning)
Monday 10 11.2% 2 2.2% 8 9.0%
Tuesday 5 5.6% 5 5.6% 0 0.0%
Wednesday 8 9.0% 6 6.7% 2 2.2%
Thursday 18 20.2% 8 9.0% 10 11.2%
Friday 13 14.6% 3 3.4% 10 11.2%
Saturday 21 23.6% 8 9.0% 13 14.6%
Sunday 14 15.7% 9 10,1% 5 5.6%
Totals 89 100.0 % 41 46% 48 54
NON -VALID
11p - 7a
Total 7a - 11p
of the following morning)
Monday 20 9.7% 12 5.8% 8 3.9%
Tuesday 14 6.8% 13 6.3% 1 0.5%
Wednesday 21 10.2% 21 10.2% 0 0.0%
Thursday 29 14.1% 13 6.3% 16 7.8%
Friday 34 16.5% 9 4.4% 25 12.1%
Saturday 58 28.2% 27 13.1%_ 31 15.0%
Sunday 30 14.6% 22 10.7% 8 3.9%
Totals 206 100% 117 57% 89 43%
Breakdown of • •
Total Cases Valid Cases Non -valid Cases
Total Complaints 295 100% 89 30.2% 206 69.8%
Anonymous Com lainant 197 66.8% 45 15.3% 152 51.5%
Anonymous with Contact
made 11 3.7% 4 1.4% 7 2.4
Contact Information Provided 62 21.0% 16 5.4% 46 15.6%
,I nternal (Proactive) 25 8.5% 24 8.1% 1 0.3%
ATTACHMENT C
Disposition Information on
Date of Request Special Master Code Case Address Name Status
Violation Filed Case Number Number
09/15/2012 09/25/2012 JC13000048 CE12015217 4333 PINETREE DR Lance Burstyn SM 01/03/2013 - Based on an agreed Order between
(Tenant) City of MB and Petitioner, violation is valid. Guilty of 1st
Offense. $250 shall be paid by 2/4/13.
09/16/2012 09/25/2012 JC13000049 CE12015221 4333 PINETREE DR Lance Burstyn SM 01/03/2013 - Based on an agreed Order between
(Tenant) City of MB and Petitioner, violation not valid, case
dismissed.
11/05/2012 11/07/2012 JC13000127 CE13001169 520 79TH ST REYNIER SM 02/07/2013 - Guilty of 2nd Offense. $1,000 shall be
HONDARES paid by 4/8/13.
11/15/2012 11/21/2012 JC13000128 CE13001499 1427 WEST AV Barton G. Restaurant SM 02/21/2013 - Agreed Order prepared by Legal
Department with the alleged violator. Granted appeal.
11/21/2012 11/30/2012 JC13000133 CE13001723 6515 COLLINS AV DANIEL ETTEDGUI SM 04104/2013 - Violation not proven by clear and
convincing evidence to be valid. Case Dismissed.
11/26/2012 12/05/2012 JC13000134 CE13001835 1235 WASHINGTON Star Island SM 05/16/2013
AV Entertainement LLC
dba
12/02/2012 12/10/2012 JC13000135 CE13002066 1420 STILLWATER Fernando Raucci & SM 02/07/2013 - Violation not proven by clear and
DR W Monica convincing evidence to be valid. Case Dismissed.
12/02/2012 12/12/2012 JC13000136 CE13002067 1436 DREXEL AV Miami Eats, LLC dba SM 03/07/2013 - An agreed Order was suibmitted.
Pee Nero Case closed. 3rd Offense dismissed.
12/14/2012 12/17/2012 JC13000137 CE13002555 1436 DREXEL AV Miami Eats, LLC dba SM 02/07/2013 - An agreed Order was suibmitted.
Pee Nero Case closed. 3rd Offense dismissed.
11/17/2012 12/19/2012 JC13000138 CE13001593 1501 COLLINS AV Jaydeniz & Denis Inc. SM 02/07/2013 - Guilty of 1st Offense. $250 shall be
dba Buffalo paid by 4/8/13.
12/10/2012 12/21/2012 JC13000139 CE13002358 1525 EUCLID AV Alfredo Chong SM 02/07/2013 - Guilty of 1st Offense. $250 shall be
enant aid by 4/8/13.
12/07/2012 01/04/2013 JC13000155 CE13002256 701 11TH ST EUCLID LC SM 03/07/2013 - Appeal filed late. Guilty of 2nd
Offense. $1,000 shall be paid by 6/7/13.
12/2212012 01/04/2013 JC13000156 CE13002862 701 11TH ST EUCLID LC % SM 03/07/2013 - Guilty of 3rd Offense. $2,000 shall be
STUZIN & CAMNER paid by 6/7/13.
PA
01/10/2013 01/17/2013 JC13000157 CE13003528 1501 COLLINS AV 1501 COLLINS LLC SM 02/07/2013 - Guilty of 2nd Offense. $1,000 shall be
aid by 4/8/13.
01/01/2013 01/15/2013 JC13000158 CE13003175 1501 COLLINS AV TEQUILA CHICAS SM 04/04/2013 - Guilty of 1st Offense. $250 shall be
aid by 5/6/13.
01/23/2013 01/28/2013 JC13000225 CE13004051 1020 OCEAN DR CLEVELANDER SM 03/07/2013 - Prior written warning under
MBCH HOTEL CE12011957 dismissed resulting in CE13004051
reduced from 1 st Offense to Written Warning.
02/02/2013 02/07/2013 JC13000226 CE13004400 1801 COLLINS AV SHELBORNE SM 03/07/2013 - Guilty of 1st Offense. $250 to be paid
MBCH OCEAN BEACH by 4/8/13.
HOTEL CONDO
02/10/2013 02/20/2013 JC13000238 CE13004680 1235 WASHINGTON FIX REALTY L P SM 05/16/2013
AV
02/09/2013 02/19/2013 JC13000239 CE13004636 235 23RD ST ALAR -VER SM 05/16/2013
PROPERTIES INC
12/09/2012 12/14/2012 JC13000240 CE13002303 1144 OCEAN DR 1144 OD LLC SM 04/04/2013 - Guilty of 3rd Offense. $2,000 to be
aid by 817/13.
12/07/2012 12/14/2012 JC13000241 CE13002224 1144 OCEAN DR S & M AIRPLAINE SM 04/04/2013 - Guilty of 2nd Offense. $1,000 to be
ENTERPRISES LLC paid by 8/7/13.
12/13/2012 12/21/2012 JC13000250 CE13002517 1701 COLLINS AV 1701 COLLINS SM 05/02/2013
(MIAMI) OPERATING
COMPANY LLC
02/16/2013 02/26/2013 JC13000251 CE13005058 1135 8TH ST 770 MANAGEMENT SM 05/02/2013
LLC
02/08/2013 02/26/2013 JC13000252 CE13005464 235 23RD ST ALAR -VER SM 05/02/2013
PROPERTIES INC
02123/2013 02/26/2013 JC13000253 CE13005462 235 23RD ST LINK SM 05/02/2013
02/16/2013 02/26/2013 JC13000254 CE13005061 1501 COLLINS AV OCEAN ENDS LLC SM 04/04/2013 - Case not proven by clear and
D /B /A TEQUILLA convincing evidence to be valid. Case dismissed.
CHICAS
03/06/2013 03/12/2013 JC13000266 CE13006138 920 LINCOLN RD THE LAUREN SM 05/02/2013
INVESTMENTS
CORP
03/01/2013 03/06/2013 JC13000273 CE13005795 309 23RD ST OCEAN RESORTS SM 05/02/2013
INC
03/12/2013 03/20/2013 JC13000274 CE13002123 1111 COLLINS AV JAMES P SM 05/02/2013
SHANAHAN TR
03/16/2013 03/20/2013 JC13000275 CE13006814 1111 COLLINS AV TBS REALTY LLC, SM 05/02/2013
DBA DREAM -
MAERD SOUTH
BEACH.
Date of Request Special Master Code Case Address Name Status
Violation Filed Case Number Number
03/27/2013 04/05/2013 JC13000291 CE13007536 4385 COLLINS AV RYDER SM 06/13/2013
PROPERTIES LLC
03/21/2013 04/09/2013 JC13000292 CE13007203 4385 COLLINS AV SOHO HOTEL SM 06/13/2013
03/23/2013 03/29/2013 JC13000293 CE13007292 1020 OCEAN DR 2K SOUTH BEACH SM 06/13/2013
HOTEL LLC
03/10/2013 04/08/2013 JC13000294 CE13006365 1200 OCEAN DR 1200 OCEAN SM 06/13/2013
ASSOCIATES LTD
03/10/2013 04/08/2013 JC13000295 CE13006400 1200 OCEAN DR SOBE MIAMI LLC SM 06/13/2013
D /B /A PALACE