2013-28211 Reso RESOLUTION NO. 2013-28211
A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA,APPROVING THE GRANT OF THREE(3)EASEMENTS
TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION (FDOT) FOR THE
CONSTRUCTION, INSTALLATION, MAINTENANCE, REPAIR, AND
REPLACEMENT OF: 1) A STORMWATER PUMP STATION AND ASSOCIATED
INFRASTRUCTURE ON WEST AVENUE AT 6TH STREET; 2) A STORMWATER
PUMP STATION AND ASSOCIATED INFRASTRUCTURE AT THE WESTERN
TERMINUS OF 10TH STREET; AND 3) A STORMWATER PUMP STATION AND
ASSOCIATED INFRASTRUCTURE AT THE WESTERN TERMINUS OF 14TH
STREET; PROVIDED, HOWEVER, THAT THE AFORESTATED GRANT IS
SUBJECT TO AND CONTINGENT UPON SUCCESSFUL NEGOTIATION OF THE
FINAL EASEMENT AGREEMENTS BETWEEN THE CITY AND FDOT, WHICH
EASEMENT AGREEMENTS,IF SUCCESSFULLY NEGOTIATED AND FINALIZED,
SHALL BE SUBJECT TO FINAL APPROVAL BY THE CITY MANAGER AND CITY
ATTORNEY; FURTHER AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR AND CITY CLERK TO
EXECUTE THE FINAL EASEMENT AGREEMENTS, IF AND WHEN FINALIZED.
WHEREAS,the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT)is proposing to install three(3)
stormwater pump stations on Alton Road as part of the improvements planned between 5th Street
and Michigan Avenue; and
WHEREAS,the pump stations are to be located on West Avenue, at 5th Street;Alton Road,
at 10th Street; and Alton Road, at 14th Street; and
WHEREAS, the City believes that the impacts associated with installing the pumps in the
street, and the subsequent need to close the street during pump station maintenance, can be
reduced by relocating the pump stations; and
WHEREAS,the FDOT contractor has submitted a cost savings initiative to FDOT requesting
permission to relocate the aforestated pump stations from their proposed locations above, to new
locations at West Avenue, at 6th Street; and the 10th Street and 14th Street ends at Biscayne Bay;
and
WHEREAS, relocating these pump stations will result in reduced traffic impacts to the
residents and businesses on Alton Road,West Avenue, and Lenox Avenue during construction,and
will make the long-term maintenance of the pump stations less impactful; and
WHEREAS, FDOT requires that its facilities located outside of its rights-of-way be placed
within easements granted to FDOT; and
WHEREAS, FDOT will require three(3)easements in order to relocate the pump stations to
the proposed new locations; and
WHEREAS, granting approval of the easement agreements now subject and conditioned
upon successful negotiation of the final agreements,will expedite the re-design and permitting of the
pump stations and the adjustment of utilities(which would not otherwise begin until FDOT grants its
approval of the cost savings initiative); and
WHEREAS, the time saved will allow the pump stations to be constructed earlier, providing
much improved stormwater service to the area at an earlier date and reducing the risk of the FDOT
contractor abandoning the cost savings initiative for fear of exceeding the allowable contract time
and incurring liquidated damages; and
WHEREAS, the proposed locations of the pump stations at the 10th Street and 14th Street
ends have been determined, but the precise location of the pump station at West Avenue and 6th
Street has not yet been determined.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT DULY RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND THE CITY
COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA,that the Mayor and City Commission
hereby approve the grant of three (3) easements to the Florida Department Of Transportation
(FDOT)for the construction, installation, maintenance, repair, and replacement of: 1) a stormwater
pump station and associated infrastructure on West Avenue at 6th Street; 2) a stormwater pump
station and associated infrastructure at the western terminus of 10th Street; and 3) a stormwater
pump station and associated infrastructure at the western terminus of 14th Street; provided,
however, that the aforestated grant is subject to and contingent upon successful negotiation of the
final easement agreements between the City and FDOT, which easement agreements, if
successfully negotiated and finalized, shall be subject to final approval by the City Manager and City
Attorney; further authorizing the Mayor and City Clerk to execute the final easement agreements, if
and when finalized.
PASSED AND ADOPTED this 8th day of May, 2013.
ATTEST:
a ' L ra Efower, Mayor
/ a el Granado, City Clerk \P... r'9
1,91 0
INCORP ORATED:
- y Attor V Date � ,
f" .. .... .:
T:\AGENDA\2013\May 8TDOT Alton Road Reso.doc C�'� �6 �
COMMISSION ITEM SUMMARY
Condensed Title:
A Resolution Of The Mayor And City Commission Of The City Of Miami Beach, Florida, Approving Th
Grant Of Three Easements To The Florida Department Of Transportation (FDOT) For The Construction,
Installation, Maintenance, Repair, And Replacement Of: 1)A Stormwater Pump Station And Associate
Infrastructure On West Avenue At 6th Street;2)A Stormwater Pump Station And Associated Infrastructur
At The Western Terminus Of 10th Street;And 3)A Stormwater Pump Station And Associated Infrastructur
At The Western Terminus Of 14th Street; Provided, However,That The Aforestated Grant Is Subject To An
Contingent Upon A Successful Negotiation Of The Final Easement Agreement Between The City An
FDOT, Which Easement Agreement, If Successfully Negotiated And Finalized, Shall Be Subject To Fina
Approval By The City Manager And City Attorney; Further Authorizing The Mayor And City Clerk To Execut
The Final Easement Agreement, If And When Finalized.
Key Intended Outcome Supported:
Improve storm drainage citywide
Supporting Data Surveys, Environmental Scan, etc.):
Per the Customer Satisfaction Survey, only 44% of residents rated storm drainage as excellent or good.
Item Summa /Recommendation:
The Florida Department of Transportation(FDOT)is proposing to install three stormwater pump stations on
Alton Road as part of the improvements planned between 5th Street and Michigan Avenue. The pump
stations are located on West Avenue at 5th Street,Alton Road at 10th Street,and Alton Road at 14th Street.
The FDOT contractor has submitted a cost savings initiative to FDOT to relocate these pump stations.The
City has stated to FDOT that it fully endorses the cost savings initiative to reduce traffic impacts to the
residents and businesses on Alton Road, West Avenue, and Lenox Avenue and for ease of long-term
maintenance of the pump stations.
Granting conceptual approval of the easement agreement now will expedite the re-design and permitting of
the pump stations and the, adjustment of utilities, which would not otherwise begin until FDOT grants
approval of the cost savings initiative.The time saved will allow the pump stations to be constructed earlier.
This will provide much improved stormwater service to the area at an earlier date and reduce the risk of the
contractor abandoning the cost savings initiative for fear of exceeding the allowable contract time and
incurring liquidated damages.
The Administration recommends adopting the Resolution.
Advisory Board Recommendation:
Financial Information:
Source of Amount Account Approved
Funds: 1
2
3
4
OBPI Total
Financial Impact Summary:
City Clerk's Office Legislative Tracking:
Richard Saltrick, Public Works X6565
Sign-Offs:
Department Director t City Manager City Mana r
JJF MT JLM
T:\AGENDA\2013\May 8\ OT Alton Road Sum.d
MIAMIBEACH AGENDA ITEM
..�. DATE
® MIAMI BEACH
City of Miami Beach, 1700 Convention Center Drive,Miami Beach, Florida 33139,www.miamibeachfl.gov
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor Matti Herrera Bower and Me bers of the ity Commission
FROM: Jimmy L. Morales, City Manager
DATE: May 8, 2013
SUBJECT: A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR ND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA,APPRO ING THE GRANT OF THREE EASEMENTS
TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION (FDOT) FOR THE
CONSTRUCTION, INSTALLATION, MAINTENANCE, REPAIR, AND
REPLACEMENT OF: 1)A STORMWATER PUMP STATION AND ASSOCIATED
INFRASTRUCTURE ON WEST AVENUE AT 6TH STREET; 2)A STORMWATER
PUMP STATION AND ASSOCIATED INFRASTRUCTURE AT THE WESTERN
TERMINUS OF 10TH STREET; AND 3)A STORMWATER PUMP STATION AND
ASSOCIATED INFRASTRUCTURE AT THE WESTERN TERMINUS OF 14TH
STREET; PROVIDED, HOWEVER, THAT THE AFORESTATED GRANT IS
SUBJECT TO AND CONTINGENT UPON A SUCCESSFUL NEGOTIATION OF
THE FINAL EASEMENT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY AND FDOT,
WHICH EASEMENT AGREEMENT, IF SUCCESSFULLY NEGOTIATED AND
FINALIZED, SHALL BE SUBJECT TO FINAL APPROVAL BY THE CITY
MANAGER AND CITY ATTORNEY; FURTHER AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR
AND CITY CLERK TO EXECUTE THE FINAL EASEMENT AGREEMENT, IF
AND WHEN FINALIZED.
ADMINISTRATION RECOMMENDATION
The Administration recommends adopting the resolution.
BACKGROUND
The Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) is proposing to install three stormwater pump
stations on Alton Road as part of the improvements planned between 5th Street and Michigan
Avenue. The pump stations are to be located on West Avenue at 5th Street, Alton Road at 10th
Street, and Alton Road at 14th Street.
During the FDOT design phase, the City unsuccessfully tried to convince FDOT to relocate the
pump stations from the Alton Road travel lanes where the City believes that the impacts associated
with installing the pumps in the street and the subsequent need to close the street during pump
station maintenance can be reduced by relocating the pump stations.
The FDOT contractor also believes that these pump stations can be constructed for less money if
relocated to the street ends. Consequently, it has submitted a cost savings initiative to FDOT
requesting permission to relocate the pump stations from West Avenue at 5th Street, from Alton
City Commission Memorandum-FDOT Alton Road
May 8,'2013
Page 2 of 3
Road at 10th Street, and from Alton Road at 14th Street to West Avenue at 6th Street and the 10th
Street and 14th Street ends at Biscayne Bay, respectively.
The City has stated to FDOT that it fully endorses the cost savings initiative for two reasons:
1. Reduction in traffic impacts to the residents and businesses, particularly on Alton Road,
West Avenue, and Lenox Avenue during construction
2. Ease of long-term maintenance of the pump stations
Under the current plans, the maintenance of traffic plan developed for this project consists of six
phases with multiple sub-phases. The construction of the pump station on West Avenue at 5th Street
would require nighttime shut downs of the westbound lanes to the MacArthur Causeway/1-395. It
would also close the outside through lane full-time. Southbound West Avenue traffic would be
detoured to Alton Road at 6th Street during this construction.The pump station construction on Alton
at 10th Street and 14th Street requires the closure of Alton Road to all but local traffic for the duration
of the construction. There would be multiple restrictions to traffic flow on Lenox Avenue, 91h Street,
11th Street, 12th Street, 15th Street, and West Avenue because of the detours.
Once the pump stations are constructed and in operation, the City will be maintaining them. Due to
the brackish groundwater and potential for accelerated corrosion of the pumps, motors, and
equipment, it is estimated that City will need to access the pump stations for maintenance six to
twelve times per year. In the presently proposed locations, the City will need to close the left-turn
lane, the inside northbound lane, and the inside southbound lane on Alton Road to perform
maintenance of the pump stations on 10th and 14th Street.
ANALYSIS
FDOT requires that its facilities located outside of its right-of-way be placed in easements. The City
has already provided easements to FDOT along 10th and 14th Streets for the proposed construction
of its outfall piping through Resolution No. 2012-27970 approved at the July 18, 2012 Commission
meeting. However, the proposed pump stations would not fit within the existing easement areas.
Therefore, additional easement areas would be needed in order to relocate the pump stations as
proposed.
Typically, FDOT requests easements for its facilities in the City right-of-way during the design phase
of a project, and time is built into the schedule for negotiation of the easement agreements and their
execution by the City Commission. However,this project is already in construction,and residents are
being impacted by the work. Granting conceptual approval of the easement agreement now will
expedite the re-design and permitting of the pump stations and the adjustment of utilities, which
would not otherwise begin until FDOT grants its approval of the cost savings initiative.At this time, it
is uncertain when that will occur. The time saved will allow the pump stations to be constructed
earlier. This will provide much improved stormwater service to the area at an earlier date and reduce
the risk of the contractor abandoning the cost savings initiative for fear of exceeding the allowable
contract time and incurring liquidated damages.
The proposed locations of the pump stations at the 10th Street and 14th Street ends have been
determined. The precise location of the pump station proposed to be relocated from West Avenue at
5th Street to West Avenue at 6th Street is not yet determined. Therefore, the FDOT contractor is
proposing to begin construction on the 10th and 14th Street pump stations and to construct the 6th
Street pump station once its location is finalized.
The additional area of the proposed easement on 10th Street is approximately 1,650.8 square feet,
and the additional area of the proposed easement on 14th Street is approximately 840.5 square feet
City Commission Memorandum-FDOT Alton Road
May 8,'2013
Page 3 of 3
(Attachments A and B, respectively). The area of the 6th Street easement is expected to be of similar
size.
CONCLUSION
The Administration recommends that the Mayor and City Commission adopt the resolution noting
that these easements will only be granted upon approval of the cost savings initiative by FDOT and
successful negotiation of an easement agreement.
Attachments:
A. Sketch and Legal Description of the 10th Street Proposed Easement
B. Sketch and Legal Description of the 14th Street Proposed Easement
MT/JJF/RWS
T:\HGENDA\2013\May 8TDOT Alton Road Memo.doc
E
„10 Z 6
w
r � ps� a$ 5 W -
0
3°
l�':; °° 3
3
D D b
< 7°u
qua'
jD
Hr
via
ou
uN
3
D
I
_ �o�
O 3a� Dom`
¢ W
¢
Z
u 8 o W<
¢D e
a 2 _ a <
l — °
U W °
0
r z m .
<
O <
;. ¢ x - _
w m
n�
oW
w
0 3°'z
ti O l-ed€;g a w�a€uR°< �s=`Yii Jo g
C U w <mmD DowW_ _nnDa=_`3� W u)mD�=mM1m mm=N >N
z ¢ ¢
n o _ -
P <m
.L
V
t4
Q (M/6.001) OVOH NO1IV 1— /06 OVO?J 31ViS
Y a°
we
F� OR _0.�a °o° �_z
W - eoz
Z. mar
e 1 i�v'i���o
wa
gm5A' W
od �\uQON g��
I o ;
�o ¢
Ww
¢
W
-w� W
- >w
� o
_
o '
If(rr o�N _ on Y
< you�umi 3
I Iz
Z i'i'o'"moi w
u) �j0 opU Qm
Lu o wa ia�W6
O I J °z
ra
ui I;''• ry W ao <
Z
(z _ e � o � '"��wwa W z
r Z ooa°o-z >
w< U
l ; o o I U ~wm ro�da�a 3 W to
z W o�p wuW 4� O W
0
06 u Dr-�ay 40H Zul W
a 1 I,.� 1 I o \a'v >wmwx u� O Um z
I�, m Sin �Ow O
o
NO
o
nz- J O W U�
Yo< waw W mF w
o a fl IV} \\ I N
o3a aT a400s a C7o
tom Z
\o
IE...,� m m w Y Y F
moatD '.I �� \m aO FZO vt;prY
o� mY . m�N o Oam Sao xo�o'w
to ZO \m 3 I °a 1'^- ioo�z�x
x w
room W\w I oa zW� owo .T-°aw
a
^
w I z
z-o aaowYa
a
w quo �'" „' i IL
u o_w Y m z
a
m � ul a
y
3" m >,V8 3NAVOSIO IT 3$
o
J8
z z ZYi
z _
° 1W
i
D[ N
x
o
3-3 a3,..... Y^�,mw
ti
LLI
^°on
I
w o O _
Cf
_.a ✓ w in
Y m
co
}" o 3°
GT kS O p °a 418u: w g< 22 sa o w B
w � �`mm��w w3�oww ,. na5raop s
V
Q �
(M/a ,00t) OVOa GVOa 31VIS
U z
a0.zomwwa
°a ox
z k+N wu omz�
ao Om ZZ -
_m wo
wa �O Ww�
a -mow ow
W uQary
<° °F�rvry
\ m o
x� -NOZ _
a _ -
z" W m e
-m�ry - w
i J = a � �o
T "saW� wo =
om wn"
o mm-go�
C)
Z Q �
O O
z I' ♦3 Q v �
3 0 N °ao oN g a
m ? H xow. sa`F
j Q. wa
ES
n','�• O
Ij % NON U)
/', w_ O owma oln�a wr o
Of C¢7 �z° a9w�pam�
m ,, z r <� NPrjioow DF
O U w U
O m H <N� W�zmoa°i W w h
II / Z - u m 3: W
0
¢ 6 1 D m Z W y FbF Nz o Z 0
1p
an d O N 0 Ul Wes° 3wa;a^^ ¢
v �903'S9'29"E O D ~ w0 °Zn^'oa°o Z W W
Q I 19.78 19.39' m ZO L� osi mum�aiwei Dy Z
w m w '•� vwi m °
m a D C. °w:i>az,.° D F Q
Via ° _ w > r on°a aox°m mw x
Z v N O m zo z° w 0¢ U
W m Q a zo°nWw^zo mF r
O _ z/�w `w N 7 CL W a u«oN_WNi 03 Y
Q ED N
Ali amain <t� w
g i wft wr W:zo
I Z.� ma-,o vi
uolnrvoocwiaw J
oF ?°m Na�Z°
a
�° orcao wio- g
wo S
1 zip - ioaow
aNm. °Na W
o
C o 0
5 Gob w°04�,140v1 a
I! z 4
o z3� wF7 j- Wa
z E 1
Ij ?< a ugo � w L,,Lry E�W`�
44 0
'r?it moo °uaua
TT
Ilk
d d
e D