2017-29697 Reso RESOLUTION NO. 2017-29697
A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, ACCEPTING THE RECOMMENDATION OF THE
CITY MANAGER PERTAINING TO THE RANKING OF PROPOSALS WITH
RESPECT TO PHASE I OF THE RFP SELECTION PROCESS PURSUANT TO
REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS (RFP) NO. 2016-204-KB, FOR DESIGN/BUILD
SERVICES FOR A NEW PARKING GARAGE FACILITY AND RELATED
INFRASTRUCTURE FOR THE COLLINS PARK PARKING GARAGE.
WHEREAS, on September 14, 2016, the City Commission approved the issuance of
RFP 2016-204-KB; the RFP was issued on September 16, 2016, with an opening date of
November 4, 2016; and
WHEREAS, in accordance with Section 287.055 of the Florida Statutes, the RFP
provides for a two-step, phased evaluation process; and
WHEREAS, the Phase I selection process, which is the subject of this Resolution,
relates to the qualifications, experience and availability of the proposers and key members of
the design-build team, including the lead designer and lead construction firm; and
WHEREAS, only those Proposers short-listed during Phase I are authorized to proceed
to Phase II of the RFP selection process, in which price and detailed technical proposals based
on the approved Design Criteria Package (the "DCP") will be considered; and
WHEREAS, the City received proposals in response to the RFP from the following
seven (7) firms:
• Burke Construction Group
• Finfrock Construction, Inc.
' • Kaufman Lynn Construction
• KVC Constructors, Inc.
• Munilla Construction Management
• Plaza Construction Group Florida, LLC
• Stiles Construction; and
WHEREAS, on November 28, 2016, via LTC # 511-2016, the City Manager appointed
the Evaluation Committee, which consisted of the following individuals:
• Sabrina Baglieri, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, Capital Improvement Program
Division, City of Miami Beach
• Monica Beltran, Assistant Director, Parking Department, City of Miami Beach
• Ray Breslin, Resident and Collins Park Neighborhood Association President
• Adrian Morales, Senior Administrative Manager, Property Management, City of Miami
Beach
• Mark Milisits, Asset Manager, Tourism, Culture and Economic Development, City of
Miami Beach; and
WHEREAS, the Evaluation Committee convened on December 19, 2016 to consider
proposals received, in an effort to assist the Administration in short-listing at least three (3) firms
to proceed to the Phase II selection process of the RFP; and
WHEREAS, the Phase I rankings of the Evaluation Committee are more fully set forth in
the Commission Memorandum accompanying this Resolution; and
WHEREAS, after reviewing all the qualifications of each firm and having considered the
Evaluation Committee's comments and rankings, the City Manager has recommended that, for
Phase I of the selection process, the Mayor and the City Commission shortlist the four (4) top-
ranked firms, all of which received a first or second place rank by at least one (1) committee
member, namely: KVC Constructors, Inc., the first top-ranked firm; Plaza Construction Group
• Florida, LLC, the second top-ranked firm; Finfrock Construction, Inc., the third top-ranked firm;
and Kaufman Lynn Construction, the fourth top-ranked firm, to permit all four proposers to be
further considered in Phase II of the RFP evaluation process.
• NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT DULY RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY
COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, that the Mayor and City
• Commission of the City of Miami Beach, Florida hereby accepts the recommendation of the City
Manager pertaining to the ranking of proposals with respect to Phase I of the RFP selection
process pursuant to Request For Proposals (RFP) No. 2016-204-KB, for design/build services
for a new parking garage facility and related infrastructure for the Collins Park parking garage,
and authorizes (1) KVC Constructors, Inc., (2) Plaza Construction Group Florida, LLC, (3)
Finfrock Construction, Inc., and (4) Kaufman Lynn Construction, to be further considered in
Phase II of the RFP evaluation process.
PASSED AND ADOPTED this 1/ day of -km-for/2017.
Philip Lend >4 4/or
ATTEST:
Al
Rafae . Granado, L'y :Jr I
,s, APPROVED AS TO
i -At 0 FORM&LANGUAGE
• RP D�P�rD 8 FOR EXECUTION
h IWC H rZp��r ati . .
T:\AGENDA\2017\1 -January\Procurement Department\RFP 2016-204-KB Collins Park Parking Garage\2016-204-
KB(RFP)-Design Build Services for Collins Park Parking Garage(Phase I) -Reso.doc
•
Resolutions - C7 C
MIAMI BEACH
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM
TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Commission
FROM: Jimmy L. Morales, City Manager
DATE: January 11, 2017
SUBJECT: A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, ACCEPTING THE RECOMMENDATION OF THE CITY
MANAGER, PURSUANT TO REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS (RFP) NO. 2016-204-
KB, FOR DESIGN/BUILD SERVICES FOR A NEW PARKING GARAGE FACILITY
AND RELATED INFRASTRUCTURE FOR THE COLLINS PARK PARKING
GARAGE (PHASE I SHORTLISTING).
RECOMMENDATION
Adopt the Resolution.
ANALYSIS
On April 13, 2016, the City Commission requested that the Professional Services contract with
Zaha Hadid/BBA joint venture be terminated after deliberation of the final valued engineered
redesign of the Collins Park Parking Garage Project submitted on March 31, 2016.
The Commission directed Administration to proceed with a new solicitation for professional
services for the design and construction of a new parking garage that would meet the City's
parking needs and that could include retail component, art galleries, art anchor tenants,
workforce housing for artists, and a beautiful wrapped shell design. The directive also included
coordination with the Collins Park Neighborhood Association and all affected neighborhoods.
On April 20, 2016, the City issued a Request for Qualification (RFQ) for the selection of a
Consultant to prepare Design Criteria Packages (DCP) for several Parking Garages. The
selected Consultant has been tasked with preparing a DCP that would include concise
performance-oriented specifications for the Collins Park Parking project. The purpose of the •
DCP is to furnish sufficient information to allow Design-Build (DB)firms to provide a response to
the City's Request for Proposals (RFP) for Design-Build services. The process to prepare the
DCP is estimated to be 90 days. The DB firm will be required to seek all necessary City
approvals during the design process.
The Administration, in an effort to proceed with a design-build method of procurement,
requested proposals from DB Firms for the design, permitting, construction administration, and
the construction of a new parking garage facility and related infrastructure for the Collins Park
Parking Garage. The Parking Garage design is anticipated to be a conventional parking garage
145
structure wrapped with an aesthetically pleasing architectural element.
RFP PROCESS
On September 14, 2016, the City Commission approved the issuance of RFP 2016-204-KB.
The RFP was issued on September 16, 2016, with an opening date of November 4, 2016. A
pre-proposal conference to provide information to the proposers submitting a response was
held on September 27, 2016.
In accordance with Section 287.055 of the Florida Statutes, the RFP provides for a two-step, •
phased evaluation process. The Phase I selection process, which is the reason for this item,
relates to the qualifications, experience and availability of the proposers and key members of
the design-build team, including the lead designer and lead constructor. Only those Proposers
short-listed during Phase I are authorized to proceed to Phase II of the RFP selection process,
in which price and detailed technical proposals based on the approved Design Criteria Package
(the "DCP")will be considered.
The City received proposals in response to the RFP from the following seven (7)
firms:
Burke Construction Group
• Finf rock Construction, Inc.
• Kaufman Lynn Construction
KVC Constructors, Inc.
Munilla Construction Management
Plaza Construction Group Florida, LLC
Stiles Construction
On November 28, 2016, the City Manager appointed the Evaluation Committee via LTC # 511-
2016. The Evaluation Committee (the "Committee") consisted of the following individuals:
• Sabrina Baglieri, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, Office of Capital Improvement
Projects, City of Miami Beach
• Monica Beltran,Assistant Director, Parking Department, City of Miami Beach
• Ray Breslin, Resident and Collins Park Neighborhood Association President
• Adrian Morales, Senior Administrative Manager, Property Management, City of Miami
Beach
• Mark Milisits, Asset Manager, Tourism, Culture and Economic Development, City of Miami
Beach
The following individuals were appointed as alternates:
• Diego Lopez Medina, Capital Projects Coordinator, Office of Capital Improvement
Projects, City of Miami Beach
• Roberto Rodriguez, Capital Projects Coordinator, Office of Capital Improvement
Projects, City of Miami Beach
• Thais Vieira, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, City Manager's Office, City of Miami
Beach
The Committee convened on December 19, 2016 to consider proposals received. The
Committee was provided an overview of the project, information relative to the City's Cone of
Silence Ordinance and the Government Sunshine Law. The Committee was also provided
general information on the scope of services, references, and a copy of each proposal. The
146
Committee was instructed to score and rank each proposal pursuant to the evaluation criteria
established in the RFP. The evaluation process resulted in the ranking of proposers as indicated
in Attachment A.
CITY MANAGER'S REVIEWAND RECOMMENDATION
After reviewing all the qualifications of each firm and having considered the Evaluation
Committee's comments and rankings, the City Manager recommends that, for Phase I of the
evaluation process, the Mayor and the City Commission shortlist the four(4) top ranked firms, all
of which received a first or second place rank by at least one (1) committee member, including:
KVC Constructors, Inc., as the first top ranked firm, Plaza Construction Group Florida, LLC, as
the second top ranked firm, Finfrock Construction, Inc., as the third top ranked firm, and
Kaufman Lynn Construction, as the fourth top ranked firm, to be further considered in Phase II
of the evaluation process. During Phase II, the shortlisted teams will present their design,
technical and cost proposals.
The following are brief bios of each recommended firm according to the information presented
in their proposals.
KVC Constructors, Inc.:
KVC (Prime Proposer) is a Miami-Dade based Design/Build company that has earned a strong
reputation for excellence in delivery of a broad range of construction services and projects and
has.developed a niche in the construction of parking and mixed-use facilities. In the last 12
months alone, KVC has either successfully completed or has worked on five major parking
garages including Braman Motors Parking Garage, City View Parking Garage, Museum Parking
Garage, The Palms Parking Garage and Wynwood Parking Garage.
In addition to those mixed-use garages, KVC is proud to have been the Design-Builder for the
City of Miami Beach's Pennsylvania Avenue Design-Build Parking Garage in collaboration with
Frank Gehry, which was the recipient of an Awards of Excellence from the Florida Parking
Association. KVC has assembled a team of design and construction professionals who we have
worked together for more than 25 years, and are currently working with on multiple parking
garages as well as other projects. The make-up of the design team includes well respected
design firms that are leaders in their respective fi elds. This includes Wolfberg Alvarez &
Partners (WA), Hershell Gill Consulting Engineers (HGCE), Kimley-Hom, and Shulman +
Associates, all who have long established reputations for design excellence. As our parking
consultant, Kimley-Horn's project manager, Mark Santos, P.E., is a certified Parksmart Advisor,
which adds additional value to the team.
Plaza Construction Group Florida. LLC:
Plaza Construction Group Florida, LLC, as Prime Proposer, in a design-build partnership with
Heery International, Inc. (Plaza/Heery), is pleased to present our qualifications for the Collins
Park Parking Garage. We offer a dynamic and fresh approach that will give the City of Miami
Beach the best option in achieving its vision. Our team is committed to bringing together
functional design, efficiency, environmentally sound and aesthetic appeal, in keeping with the
character of the immediately adjacent cultural center and Collins Park Neighborhood. Our
design-build team includes the most qualified professionals with experience in design-build
management, parking garage expertise, and familiarity with construction in Miami Beach. We
have built over 3.4 million square feet of facilities just-blocks from Collins Park, giving us
unparalleled insight & knowledge of your site conditions, neighborhood and overall building
147
requirements. Our recent successes demonstrate that our completion of similar projects is
proven.
Heery International, our proposed Architect of Record, with one of the largest parking structures
completed in Florida, located in Miami-Dade County, has been intimately involved with the
Collins Park Neighborhood Association, and understands the stakeholders needs and culture.
Our commitment in delivering value through design is extended with the inclusion of Elliot +
Associates Architects as lead designer, whose parking garage portfolio is award winning and
nationally recognized. Additionally, Tim Haahs offers extensive parking garage experience, and
along with TLC Engineering, Kimley-Horn, Miller Legg, ATC, & Garth Solutions, that have in-
depth working experience with the City and familiarity with the proposed site conditions and
project requirements.
Finfrock Construction, Inc.:
Finfrock Construction Inc. in association with Arquitectonica, ArquitectonicaGEO and Kimley-
Horn is pleased to respond to the request for proposals for the Collins Park Parking Garage.
The Finfrock/Arquitectonica team is enthusiastically interested in the project because the
programmatic elements and scope of services requested so closely matches our experience
and expertise from completing similar projects. Finfrock and Arquitectonica were the
design/build team for The Venture's 720-car garage in Aventura.
As a fully integrated design-build firm, Finfrock has demonstrated its ability to provide design
conscious parking solutions to our clients here in the Florida market for the last 71 years. With
fully integrated precast manufacturing facility on our 103 acre facility in Apopka, Florida, Finfrock
has the ability to evaluate the specific design and budget parameters of a project utilizing a
seamless network of collaboration between designers, builders, and manufacturers all based
here in our facility. This approach has led to the successful completion of over 200 structures
and 135,000 spaces of parking provided in the Florida market alone.
Kaufman Lynn Construction
The Kaufman Lynn/Walker Parking/Currie Sowards Aguila team will work in partnership with the
City to develop a highly functional parking structure that is in harmony with its surrounding, and
has the flexibility to respond to changes in needs. Collectively, the team has completed 80
design-build projects. Throughout this work the team has always been able to correctly interpret,
and bring to fruition, the vision of the client according to the scope of the criteria already set
forth.
The proposed team listed for this project has first-hand knowledge and experience working with
municipal staff and building quality parking garages. Some of the projects completed by the
proposed staff include the Pompano Beach Pier Parking Garage, FAU Parking Garage Ill,
Nebraska Street Garage and many others. Kaufman Lynn Construction is highly skilled at
keeping the public safe and operations uninterrupted while building on active sites and makes a
concerted effort to being "good neighbors" and minimizing dust and noise. Each member of the
Design/Build team has extensive experience building a variety of projects together that add up
to decades of experience. The firms' mutual respect for each other's dedication to owner vision
and project successes, along with thriving working relationships among our combined staff,
place our team well ahead of our competition.
148
•
CONCLUSION
The Administration recommends that the Mayor and City Commission approve the Resolution
authorizing the City Manager's recommendation, for Phase I of the evaluation process, that the
four (4) top ranked firms, all of which received a first or second place rankings by at least one
(1) committee member, including: KVC Constructors, Inc., as the first top ranked firm, Plaza
Construction Group Florida, LLC, as the second top ranked firm, Finfrock Construction, Inc., as
the third top ranked firm, and Kaufman Lynn Construction, as the fourth top ranked firm, be
further considered in Phase I I of the evaluation process, which shall consider price and detailed
technical proposals for the project.
KEY INTENDED OUTCOMES SUPPORTED
Ensure Comprehensive Mobility Addressing All Modes Throughout The City
FINANCIAL INFORMATION
Grant funding will not be utilized for this project.
Legislative Tracking
Capital Improvement Projects /Procurement
ATTACHMENTS:
Description
❑ Attachment A-- Evaluation Committee Scoring and Ranking .
149
REOUEST:FOR.PROP,.OSALS(RFP)''
2016-2006 ",r, a;
}DESIGNIBUILD SERVICES FOR NEW
t:"1:,,ARKING°GARAGE'FACILITV`AND.`: -
;yy,�RELATEDjINFRASTRUCTURE FORy' 9 d t
COLLINS p PARK PARKING_GA RAGE;1 m .E m — rg
�'?: m o
').:,„.,.,,,V-g :. y�• u m LOW
�i �'i `_� .4.�,` vt Rankin ° �^ $ `� AGGREGATE
g Ranking Ranking a Ranking Ranking .• TOTALS Rank
Burke Construction Group 82 6 97 6 99 3 90 6 93 3 'F 24 5
k
Finfrock Construction,Inc. 95 2 99 4 93 4 92 4 99 1 15 3
Kaufman Lynn Construction 84 5 101 2 90 5 93 3 85 7 '4F 22 4
4
KVC Constructors 101 1 105 1 101 1 96 1 96 2 & 6 1
Munilla Construction Management 70 7 98 5 88 6 91 5 91 4 27 6
.
Plaza Construction 90 3 100 3 100 2 95 2 91 4 14 2
Stiles Construction 86 4 93 7 85 7 89 _ 7 _ 87 6 ; 31 7
Page 243 of 757
150