2001-3338 ORDORDINANCE NO. 2001-3338
AN ORDINANCE OF THE MAYOR AND CITY
COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH,
FLORIDA, AMENDING MIAMI BEACH CITY CODE
CHAPTER 78, ARTICLE II THEREOF, ENTITLED
"EMPLOYEES' BENEFIT PLAN", SECTION 78-31
THEREOF ENTITLED "DEFINITIONS" BY DEFINING
"DOMESTIC PARTNER", AMENDING SECTION 78-34
ENTITLED "AGREEMENTS OF MEMBERS" TO PERMIT
DOMESTIC PARTNERS AND THEIR CHILDREN TO
OBTAIN HEALTH BENEFITS, AMENDING SECTIONS 78-
81 ENTITLED "GROUP HEALTH INSURANCE",
SUBSECTION (e) AND 78-82 ENTITLED "HEALTH
MAINTENANCE ORGANIZATIONS (HMO)"
SUBSECTION (e) TO INCLUDE DOMESTIC PARTNERS
FOR INCLUSION WITHIN THESE SECTIONS;
PROVIDING FOR A REPEALER; SEVERABILITY;
CODIFICATION; AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, On November 6, 2001, the voters of Miami Beach approved the following
ballot question on the City of Miami Beach November 6, 2001, Special Election ballot:
Shall City's Special Related Acts Section 27 regarding City's health plan for city officers and
employees be mended to include dependent coverage for "domestic partners" (in addition to
existing coverage of spouse and minor children) of City officers and employees; defining
"domestic partnership" as a committed relationship between two persons who consider
themselves as a member of each other's immediate family and have registered their partnership
with the City pursuant to procedures established by ordinance?
WHEREAS, this legislation is now necessary in order to incorporate the approved
measure in the City Code;
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY
COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA:
SECTION I. That Miami Beach City Code Chapter 78, Article H, Section 78-31 entitled
"Definitions" is hereby amended by adding the following definition following the definition of
"Domestic Partner":
Sec. 78-31. Definitions.
The following words, terms and phrases, when used in this article, shall have the
meanings ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different
meaning:
Board means the governing board as provided for in this article.
Domestic Parmer means a person with whom a member has entered into a Domestic Partnership
as defined in sec. 62-126, and registered and documented according to the requirements of sec.
62-127.
Member means any regular employee of the city participating in the plan.
Plan means the City of Miami Beach Employees' Benefit Ham.
Regular employee means:
(1)
Any member of the city commission, officer, department head, regular employees in the
legal department employed on a full-time basis, servant or agent of the city regularly
receiving compensation from the city for personal services; except, unless otherwise
qualified, members of boards or commissions, officers and employees who receive no
salary or a nominal salary, contractual employees or persons who are employed on a
provisional, original probationary or other temporary status under civil service
regulations. For the purpose of this article, persons otherwise meeting this definition who
are granted leaves of absence under civil service procedures or by the city commission
and persons otherwise meeting this definition who are injured in line of duty with the city
and who are receiving compensation under the workers' compensation law, shall be
considered as regular employees during such periods of absence from active duty with
the city until formally separated from service with the city; and members who are retired
for service or disability under any city pension system and pensioners, subject to such
conditions as hereinafter specified, shall be considered employees. In all cases in which
the above definition requires interpretation, the board shall decide who is a regular
employee within the intent of this article.
(2)
Any employee whose employment with the city is terminated, voluntarily or
involuntarily, and who, at the time of such termination of employment, possesses a vested
right to future pension benefits from any pension system of the city, shall not be eligible
for membership in the plan until such time as pension benefits become payable to him,
except as allowed by federal law.
SECTION 2. That Miami Beach City Code, Chapter 78, Article II, Section 78-34 entitled
"Agreement of Members" is hereby amended as follows:
See. 78-34. Agreements of members.
(a) Members shall enter into agreements with the plan, which agreements shall be
prepared by the board and approved by the city commission, and which may provide for
optional benefits as follows:
(1) Hospitalization
(2) Hospitalization and surgical
(3) Hospitalization, medical service and surgical
(b) Such agreements may be for members only, may be for member and spouse or
domestic paxtner, or may be on a family basis including spouse or domestic partner and
unmarried children of either or both the member, spouse. or domestic partner under the
age consistent with state and federal law.
SECTION 3. That Miami Beach City Code Chapter 78, Article H, Section 78-81
entitled "Group Health Insurance", Subsection (e) thereof is hereby amended as follows:
See. 78-81. Group health insurance.
(a) Member. The contribution of a member shall be half the costs of the benefits
provided for in his agreement, as such costs are determined by the board.
(b) City. The contribution of the city on behalf of the members shall be half the
cost of the benefits provided for in the agreements as such costs are determined by
the board.
(c) Medicare pensioners' contributions. The contribution of those employees,
retirants, pensioners and dependents age 65 and over, eligible for Medicare
benefits and who are members of the plan shall be half the cost of the benefits
provided for in the plan for those employees, retirants, pensioners and dependents
age 65 and over, eligible for Medicare benefits as such costs am determined by
the board, plus half the cost of the contribution for Medicare benefits, but in no
event shall such total contribution exceed the contribution of members of the plan
who are not eligible for Medieare benefits and have a similar agreement for
individual membership or for a family basis.
(d) City's contribution to Medicare pensioners. The contribution of the city on
behalf of the members of the plan age 65 and over and eligible for Medieare
benefits shall be half the costs of the benefits provided for in the agreements as
such costs are determined by the board plus half the cost of contribution for
Medicare benefits; but in no event shall the total of such contribution by the city
exceed the amount of contribution respectively for any other agreements under
the plan which covers members only who are not eligible for Medicare benefits or
which covers members and their families, none of whom are eligible for Medicare
benefits.
(e) Husband and wife or domestic partner members. Whenever a husband
and wife or domestic partners am both members of the plan, and either has an
agreement with the plan providing for benefits on a family basis, and either is
making contributions for the same, the other spouse or domestic partner shill not
be required to contribute to the plan. Any members believing they qualify under
this provision shall file a notice with the personnel director on a form prescribed
by him. Such notice shall be signed by both husband and wife or by beth
domestic partners and shall indicate from which spouse's or domestic partner's
pay contributions am to be deducted. Such notice shall become effective as of the
first pay period following the date of the election, subject to review by the board,
which shall disallow any election it finds to be improper. Thereafter contributions
shall be made as provided in the notice, but there shall be no refund of any
contributions made prior to the effective date of any notice.
SECTION 4. That Miami Beach City Code Chapter 78, Article 1I, Section 78-82
entitled "Health Maintenance Organization (HMO)", Subsection (e) thereof is hereby
amended as follows:
Sec. 78-82. Health maintenance organization (HMO).
(b) Member. The contribution of an HMO member shall be half of the costs of
the benc~ts provided for in his agreement, as such costs are determined by the
board.
(1) The contribution of the city on behalf of HMO members shall be half of the
cost of the benefits provided for in the agreements as such costs am
determined by the board.
(2) The city shall continue to contribute at the same rate for members who are
absent on authorized leave, sickness or military service and shall contribute at
the same rate on behalf of retirants who elect to continue their agreements and
pensioners who elect to become members of the plan. The board shall
ascertain annually the total amount of contribution to be made by the city on
behalf of members of this plan and shall certify such amount together with an
estimate of administrative costs to the city manager for his review,
recommendation and submission to the city commission for its approval and
inclusion in the annual budget.
(c) Medicare pensioners' contributions. The contribution of those employees,
retirants, pensioners and dependents age 65 and over, eligible for Medicare
benefits and who am members of the plan shall be half the costs of the benefits
provided for in the agreements of those employees, retirants, pensioners and
dependents age 65 and over, eligible for Mcdicarc benefits as such costs arc
determined by the board, plus half the cost of the contribution for Medicam
benefits; but in no event shall such total contribution exceed the contribution of
members of the plan who am not eligible for Medicare benefits and have a similar
agreement for individual membership or for a family basis.
(d) City's contribution to Medicare pensioners. The contribution of the city
on behalf of the members of the plan age 65 and over and eligible for Medicare
benefits shall be half the cost of the benefits provided for in the agreements as
such costs are determined by the beard plus half the cost of contribution for
Medicare benefits; but in no event shall the total of such contribution by the city
exceed the amount of contribution respectively for any other agreements under
the plan which covers members only who are not eligible for Medicare benefits or
which covers members and their families, none of whom are eligible for Medicare
benefits.
(e) Husband and wife or domestic varmer members. Whenever a husband
and wife or domestic partners are beth members of the plan, and either has an
agreement with the plan providing for benefits on a family basis, and either is
making contributions for the same, the other spouse or domestic partner shall not
be required to contribute to the plan. Any members believing they qualify under
this provision shall file a notice with the personnel director on a form prescribed
by him. Such notice shall be signed by both husband and wife or by both
domestic parmers and shall indicate from which spouse's or domestic nartner's
pay contributions are to be deducted. Such notice shall become effective as of the
first pay period following the date of the election, subject to review by the board,
which shall disallow any election it finds to be improper. Thereafter contributions
shall be made as provided in the notice, but there shall be no refund of any
contributions made prior to the effective date of any notice.
SECTION 5. REPEALER.
That all ordinances or parts of ordinances in conflict herewith be and the same are
hereby repealed.
SECTION 6. SEVERABILITY.
If any section, subsection, clause, or provision of this ordinance is held invalid,
the remainder shall not be affected by such invalidity.
SECTION 7. CODIFICATION.
It is the intention of the Mayor and City Commission of the City of Miami Beach,
and it is hereby ordained that the provisions of this ordinance shall become and be
made part of the Code of the City of Miami Beach, Florida. The sections of this
ordinance may be tenumbered or re-lettered to accomplish such intention, and the
word "ordinance" may be changed to "section", "article", or other appropriate
word.
SECTION 8. EFFECTIVE DATE.
This Ordinance shall be effective December 29, 2001.
PASSED AND ~t'~~
ADOFrED t ' ~ y f ecember
,2001.
ATTEST:
CITY CLERK
APPROVED AS TO
FORM & LANGUAGE
& FOR EXECUTION
CITY OF MIAMI BEACH
on WMnesday, ~cember 19, 2001, ~ the times lasted below, to consealer the adeptson o the o owing or snan~s.
at11:10 a.m.:
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING CHAPTER 2 OF THE MIAMI BEACH CI~ CODE ENTITLED "ADMINISTRATION', BY AMENDING
A~ICLE III THEREOF ENTICED "AGENCIES, BOARDS, AND COMMI~EES"; BY AMENDING DIVISION 18 ENTITLED "COMMUNI~
RE~TIONS BOARD"; BY AMENDING SECTION 2-190.14 ENTICED "COMPOSITION' BY AMENDING THE MEMBERSHIP OF THE
~ARD TO INCLUDE FOUR ADDITIONAL VOTING MEMBERS PROVIDING FOR REPEALER CODIFICATION; SEVERABIU~ AND
AN EFFECTIVE DATE. RBA AN ORDINANCE AMENDING ORDINANCE NO. 1335, THE CLASSIFIED EMPLOYEES' LEAVE
~RD~NANCE~BYAMEND~NGTHEPR~V~S~NSF~RACCUMU~Ti~NANDPAYMENT~FANNUALAND~CKLEAVEC~NT~NGENT
UP~NC~LLECTWEB~GAiN1NGANDAPPR~vAL~YT~EBARGA~N~NGUN1TSPR~RT~MPLEMENTAT~NF~REMPL~YEES
IN C~IFICATIONS GOVERNED BY ~iON CONTACTS TO THE E~ENT SUCH APPR~AL IS NECESSARY; PROViDiNG FOR A
REP~LER, SEVERABILI~, CODIFICATION ~D AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
Inquiries may be dire~ed to the C~ Mangers ~ce at (~5) 67~7010.
at 11:25 a.m.:
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING Mi~I BEACH CI~ CODE SPECIAL REMTED ACTS, A~ICLE IX, ENTITED
FOR FIREFIGHTERS AND POLICE OFFICERS IN ~E CI~ OF MtAMI BEACH", SECTION 62 THEREOF ENTITLED "DEFINITtQN~
PROVIDE A DEFINITION OF "DOMESTIC PAR~ER", AMENDING SECTION ~ THEREOF ENTICED 'COMPUTA~ OF CREDIT~LE
SE~ICE BY CREATING A SUBSECTION (D) FOR PURCHASE OF ADDITIONAL CREDITABLE SERVICE FOR PREVIOUS
ENFORCEMENT EXPERIENCE, AMENDING SECTION 66 THEREOF ENTITLED "PENSION SYSTEM FOR OiSABILI~ AND
RETIREMENT OF MEMBERS OF POLICE ANd FIRE DEPA~MENTS" BY CREATING A SUBSECTION (J) FOR PURCHASE OF UP TO
AN ADDITIONAL SIX PERCENT (6%) BENEFIT MULTIPLIER, AMENDING SECTIONS 68, 69, 70 (A), AND 85 ~EREOF ~ DESIGNATE
DOMESTIC PARTNERS AS POTENTIAL RECIPIENTS OF SURVIVOR BENEFITS UNDER THE PENSION P~N; PB~iDING A
REPEALER C~USE; PROVIDING A $EVERABILI~ C~USE; CODIFICATION; PR~IDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
P~N', SECTION 78-31 THEREOF ENTITLED "DEFINITIONS" BY DEFINING "DOMESTIC PA~NER", AMENDING SECTION 78-~
ENTITLED 'AGREEMENTS OF MEMBERS' TO PERMIT ~MESTIC PA~NERS AND THEIR CHILDREN TO OBTAIN HEALTH
BENEFITS, AMENDING SECTIONS 78-81 ENTITLED "GRIP HEALTH INSURANCE", SUBSECTION (El AND 78-82 ENTITLED
"HEALTH MAINTENANCE ORGANISTiONS (HMO)' SUBSECTION (El TO INCLUDE DOMESTIC PA~NERS FOR iNCLUSION
WITHIN ~ESE SECTIONS; P~ViDING FOR A REPEALER; SEVERABILi~; CODIFICATION; AND AN EFFECTWE DATE.
at 11:35 a,m,:
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING MIAMI BEACH CiTY CODE CHAPTER 62, ARTICLE lit, ENTITLED "DOMESTIC PAR~ERSHIP",
SECTION 62-128 THEREOF ENTITLED "EMPLOYEE BENEFITS" TO PROVIDE H~LTH INSU~NCE BENEFITS TO CI~ OF MIAMI
BEACH EMPLOYEES' FOR THEIR DOMESTIC PARTNERS; PROViDiNG FOR REPEALER; SEVER~ILI~; CODIFICATION; AND AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
at 11:40 a.m.:
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING MIAMI B~CH Cl~ COOE CHASER 2 "AOMINIST~TI~', OlVISION 2THEREOF BY CRYING
SECTION 2-4~ ENTITLED "CONTINUING APPLICATION FOR ~0 YEARS A~ER Ci~ SEaICE"; PR~IDING FOR REPEALER,
SEVERABIU~, CODIFICATION, AND EFFECTIVE DATE.
Inquiri~ may be diretied to H~man Resour~s at (~5) 673-7524.
M 3:10 p.m.:
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING CHAPTER 14 QF THE MIAMI BEACH CI~ ~OQE BY AMENDING DWISION 2 ~EREOF ENTITLED
"PERMIT FEES", BY AMENDING SECTION 14~5 ~EREOF E~ITLED 'MECHANICAL PERMITS", BY AMENDING APPENDIX A TO
SECTION 14~5 ENTITLED 'FEE SCHEDULE" TO PROVIDE FOR FEES FOR THE W~TNESSING OF PERIODIC iNSPECTIONS AND
ACCEPTANCE TESTS BY AN ELEVATOR iNSPECTOR EMPLOYED BY ~E C$~ OF MIAMI BEACH ONCE EVERY YEAR AND ONCE_
EVERY 5 Y~RS; PR~IOING FOR REPEALER, SEVERAB~LI~, ~DIFECATION, AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
~ 3:20 p.m.:
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING CHAPTER 2 OF THE CODE OF THE CI~ OF MIAMI BEACH ENTITLED "ADMINI~RATION", BY
AMENOING ARTICLE VI THEREOF ENTITLED "PROCUREMEN~, BY AMENDING DIVISION 3 ENTITLED ~RACT
PROCEDURES', BY AMENDING SECTION 2-369; SAID AMENDMENT ALLOWING THE C1~ MANAGER A~HORI~ TO APPROVE
PURCHASES OF GOODS AND SERVICES UNDER CONTRACTS AWAROED BY OTHER MUNICIPALITIES tN THE STATE;
PR~iDING FOR REPEALER, SEVERABILI~, AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE,
inquiries m~ ~ dir~ed to ~e Pr~urement DepaRme~ at (~5) 673-7490,
Pumuant to S~on 286.0105, Fla. Stat.,the CiW here~ a~ises the pubtic ~at: if a ~mn decides to a~peal any d~ision made ~ ~e
CiW Commission ~th respe~ tQ a~ ma~er consider~ at its meeting or i~ hearing, ~ch pemon must ensure t~t a vedatim ~rd of
pr~eedings is made, which record includes the testimony and ~idence u~n which the appeal is to be ba~d. ~is n~ce d~s not
constitute consent by ~e CiW for the intr~u~ion or admition of othe~ise inadmissible or irrelevant evidence. nor d~s ~ author~
~ailenges or appeals not ~e~iB allied ~ law.
In ac~ffiance with the Ameri~ns with DiBbiliti~ A~ ~ 19~, per~ns ne~ing spedal a~ommodation to pa~cipate in this p~eeding
should contact the CiW Clerk's office no later than ~ur days prior to the p~eedin9, telephone (~5) 673-7411 ~r assimn~; if h~ring'
impaired, telephone the Florida Relay Se~ice numbers, (800) 955-8~1 ~DD) or (80Q) 955-8~0 (VOICE), ~r
........................ AD~
CITY OF MIAMI BEACH
COMMISSION ITEM SUMMARY
Condensed TItle:
IAn Ordinance to include a definition for Domestic Partners within the Miami Beach City Code.
Issue:
IShall the City of Miami Beach add e definition of Domestic Partner to the Miami Beech City Code?
Item Summary/Recommendation:
Adopt the Ordinance on the second and final reading. The voters of the City of Miami Beach passed a
referendum to provide Health Insurance benefits to Domestic Partners of City Employees. This
Commission Memorandum will add a definition of Domestic Partners to be added to the following sections
of the Miami Beech City Cede: Employees' Benefit Plan, Definitions, Agreements of members, Group
Health Insurance, and Health Maintenance Organizations. This will ensure that Domestic Partners and
their children will be eligible to obtain health benefits.
Advisory Board Recommendation:
IN/A
Flnenolel Informetion:
Amount to be expertdeal:
Source of ~!'~'
Funds:
A'E.D, E.
DATE
CITY OF MIAMI BEACH
CITY HALL 1700 CONVENTION CENTER DI~IVE MIAMI BEACH, FLOF~IDA 33139
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM
TO:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
Mayor David Definer and DATE: December 19, 2001
Members of the City Commission
AN ORDINANCE OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, AMENDING MIAMI BEACH CITY
CODE CHAFFER 78, ARTICLE H THEREOF, ENTITLED "EMPLOYEES'
BENEFIT PLAN", SECTION 78-31 THEREOF ENTITLED "DEFINITIONS"
BY DEFINING '"DOMESTIC PARTNER", AMENDING SECTION 78-~4
ENTITLED "AGREEMENTS OF MEMBERS" TO PERMIT DOMESTIC
PARTNERS AND THEIR CHILDREN TO OBTAIN HEALTH BENEFITS,
AMENDING SECTIONS 78-81 ENTITLED "GROUP HEALTH
INSURANCE", SUBSECTION (e) AND 78-82 ENTITLED "HEALTH
MAINTENANCE ORGANIZATIONS (HMO)" SUBSECTION (e) TO
INCLUDE DOMESTIC PARTNERS FOR INCLUSION WITHIN THESE
SECTIONS; PROVIDING FOR A REPEALER; SEVERABILITY;
CODIFICATION; AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
ADMINISTRATION RECOMMENDATION:
Adopt the Ordinance on the second and final reading.
ANALYSIS:
The first reading of the Ordinance took place on November 28, 2001.
It has been determined that it is in the City' s best interest to provide a health plan which is fair and
consistent for all City employees. On November 6, 2001, the voters of Miami Beach passed a
referendum to allow group health insurance benefits to the domestic partners of City employees.
The City's Health Plan for City Officers and Employees only included dependent coverage for
spouses and dependent children of City Officers and Employees. Dependent coverage for "Domestic
Partners" was not included. "Domestic Partners" of City Employees and Officers will be added as
dependents under the City's Health Plan. Under the City' s Code, the term "Domestic Partner" is
defined as a committed relationship between two (2) persons who consider themselves as a member
of each other' s immediate family and have registered their partnership with the City pursuant to
procedures established by Ordinance.
Commission Memorandum
DECEMBER 19, 2001 COMMISSION MEETING
Page 2
As to employees governed by union contracts, implementation of this measure is contingent upon
collective bargaining and approval by the unions to the extent such approval is necessary. In order
to implement the terms of the referendum, it is necessary for the Mayor and City Commission to
adopt the attached Ordinance to make the appropriate changes to Chapter 78, Article 1I, the
Employees Benefits Plan, of the City of Miami Beach Cede.
In addition, there is a Companion Ordinance on this agenda which amends the City' s Human Rights
Ordinance to add health insurance as one of the benefits for employees' domestic parmen.
CONCLUSION
By amending the Employees' Benefit Plan to allow domestic partners to receive group health
insurance benefits in order to provide a benefits plan which is fair and consistent for all employees.