03-31-2017 MinutesMIAMIBEACH
City of Miami Beach, 1700 Convention Center Drive, Miami Beach, Florida 33139, www.miamibeachfl.gov
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor Philip Levine and Members of the City Commission
FROM: Jimmy L. Morales, City Manager
DATE: April 26, 2017
SUBJECT: REPORT OF THE FINANCE AND CITYWIDE PROJECTS
COMMITTEE (FINANCE) MEETING ON MARCH 31, 2017
The agenda is as follows:
1. Discussion On Creation Of Economic Development Goals And Objectives And A
Citywide Economic Development Strategy Plan. (December 14, 2016 Commission
Item C4B)
ACTION
Item not heard. No action was taken.
2. Discussion Regarding Future Uses Or The Potential Sale Of Vacant City-Owned
Land Located At 226 87th Terrace. (October 19, 2016 Commission Item C4A)(July
13, 2016 Commission Item C4J)
ACTION
Commissioner Aleman mentioned that she read both of the appraisals and she knows
they came in very close to each other, one at $5 million and one at $5.2 million. She
would like staff to look into what the square footage was for the property that was sold to
David Martin. What was that area compared to this land area as a data point? She would
like this information included when the item comes back to the Committee.
Item deferred to the May 19, 2017 Finance and Citywide Projects Committee meeting.
3. Discussion Regarding A Skate Park/Parking Structure At 72nd Street Parking Lot
(P92). (February 8, 2017 Commission Item C4B)
ACTION
The Committee motioned the following in regards to the Skate Park and Parking
Structure at 72 Street Parking Lot:
• The Committee directed staff to work on the calculations for the buildable
footprints of the 72 Street parking lot and the volumetric analysis to tell the
Committee how many parking spaces and how much square footage can be
City of Miami Beach,1700 Convention Center Drive, Miami Beach, Florida 33139,www.miamibeachfl.gov
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM
TO:Mayor Philip Levine and Members of the City Commission
FROM:Jimmy L. Morales, City Manager
DATE:April 26, 2017
SUBJECT:REPORT OF THE FINANCE AND CITYWIDE PROJECTS
COMMITTEE (FINANCE) MEETING ON MARCH 31, 2017
The agenda is as follows:
1. Discussion On Creation Of Economic Development Goals And Objectives And A
Citywide Economic Development Strategy Plan.(December 14, 2016 Commission
Item C4B)
ACTION
Item not heard. No action was taken.
2. Discussion Regarding Future Uses Or The Potential Sale Of Vacant City-Owned
Land Located At 226 87th Terrace.(October 19, 2016 Commission Item C4A)(July
13, 2016 Commission Item C4J)
ACTION
Commissioner Alemán mentioned that she read both of the appraisals and she knows
they came in very close to each other, one at $5 million and one at $5.2 million. She
would like staff to look into what the square footage was for the property that was sold to
David Martin. What was that area compared to this land area as a data point? She would
like this information included when the item comes back to the Committee.
Item deferred to the May 19, 2017 Finance and Citywide Projects Committee meeting.
3.Discussion Regarding A Skate Park/Parking Structure At 72nd Street Parking Lot
(P92).(February 8, 2017 Commission Item C4B)
ACTION
The Committee motioned the following in regards to the Skate Park and Parking
Structure at 72 Street Parking Lot:
•The Committee directed staff to work on the calculations for the buildable
footprints of the 72 Street parking lot and the volumetric analysis to tell the
Committee how many parking spaces and how much square footage can be
Page 2 of 5
available for other uses, and to included space for appropriate amenities. Staff
should work with Commissioner Aleman to look at possible footprints to
maximize space.
• The Committee asked staff to put a bid package together for design criteria of a
parking structure and a recreational park that includes a skate park. In addition,
the Committee simultaneously directed staff to come back to the Committee after
working with Commissioner Aleman regarding the options for where the structure
will go in order to engage a multidisciplinary designer.
• The Committee recommended moving forward with adding a capital budget
request for consideration in the budget process for the design of the parking
garage.
The Committee motioned the following in regards to the Steering Committee's request
for the four-block area of 72 Street to 76 Street:
• The Committee directed staff to go back to the North Beach Steering Committee
and reconfirm what their goals and objectives are for the study of the 4-block
area, determine how best to accomplish them, and bring it back to the Committee
for consideration.
In summary, the FCWPC requested that the Commission move forward with a bid
package for the 72nd Street lot, while simultaneously staff is to prepare several design
options for the location of the garage. Further, the Committee sought to have a budget
line item for design of the project included in the FY 2017/18 budget. They further
requested that the 72nd street lot item be separated from any discussion on the larger
scope of an area public space plan requested by the Mayor's North Beach Master Plan
Steering Committee while sending the area public space plan back to the Steering
Committee for clarification of what that committee would like included in the plan.
4. Discuss The Key Development Parameters For The Barclay Plaza Apartments
Workforce Housing Project. (March 1, 2017 Commission Item C4A)
ACTION
The Committee recommended moving forward with amending the prior Barclay Plaza
Apartments workforce housing resolution to expand the eligibility to households earning
between 80 and 140 percent AMI.
The Committee directed staff to wait for the completion of the financial analysis by
Concourse Group in order to establish base rents for the Barclay Plaza Apartments.
The Committee recommended moving forward with establishing a minimum two-year
tenure for workers within the City who wish to reside in the building.
The Committee recommended moving forward and including the parking lot and pool
area for development to maximize the number of units developed on site; recognizing
that the City would prefer that there are good amenities on site.
The Committee recommended moving forward with allowing for consideration the
Page 2 of 5
available for other uses, and to included space for appropriate amenities. Staff
should work with Commissioner Alemán to look at possible footprints to
maximize space.
•The Committee asked staff to put a bid package together for design criteria of a
parking structure and a recreational park that includes a skate park. In addition,
the Committee simultaneously directed staff to come back to the Committee after
working with Commissioner Alemán regarding the options for where the structure
will go in order to engage a multidisciplinary designer.
•The Committee recommended moving forward with adding a capital budget
request for consideration in the budget process for the design of the parking
garage.
The Committee motioned the following in regards to the Steering Committee’s request
for the four-block area of 72 Street to 76 Street:
•The Committee directed staff to go back to the North Beach Steering Committee
and reconfirm what their goals and objectives are for the study of the 4-block
area, determine how best to accomplish them, and bring it back to the Committee
for consideration.
In summary, the FCWPC requested that the Commission move forward with a bid
package for the 72nd Street lot, while simultaneously staff is to prepare several design
options for the location of the garage. Further, the Committee sought to have a budget
line item for design of the project included in the FY 2017/18 budget. They further
requested that the 72nd street lot item be separated from any discussion on the larger
scope of an area public space plan requested by the Mayor’s North Beach Master Plan
Steering Committee while sending the area public space plan back to the Steering
Committee for clarification of what that committee would like included in the plan.
4. Discuss The Key Development Parameters For The Barclay Plaza Apartments
Workforce Housing Project.(March 1, 2017 Commission Item C4A)
ACTION
The Committee recommended moving forward with amending the prior Barclay Plaza
Apartments workforce housing resolution to expand the eligibility to households earning
between 80 and 140 percent AMI.
The Committee directed staff to wait for the completion of the financial analysis by
Concourse Group in order to establish base rents for the Barclay Plaza Apartments.
The Committee recommended moving forward with establishing a minimum two-year
tenure for workers within the City who wish to reside in the building.
The Committee recommended moving forward and including the parking lot and pool
area for development to maximize the number of units developed on site; recognizing
that the City would prefer that there are good amenities on site.
The Committee recommended moving forward with allowing for consideration the
Page 3 of 5
inclusion of a commercial accessory use as part of the development proposal to
strengthen its financial viability.
The Committee directed staff to use the eligible 537 City employees as a sample to
calculate family composition in order to decide what mix of units to prefer on-site.
5. Discussion Regarding Transitioning To Non-Gas Powered Leaf Blowers For City
Staff And Contractors. (March 1, 2017 Commission Item R9R)
ACTION
The Committee recommended moving forward with the transition to non-gas powered
leaf blowers. Existing gas-powered blowers would continue to be used until they reach
the end of their useful life.
6. Discussion Regarding The Maintenance Of Public Bathrooms Citywide. (February
8, 2017 Commission Item C4N)
ACTION
Item deferred pending direction from the Neighborhood/Community Affairs Committee.
7. Discussion Regarding A One Cent (0.01) Food And Beverage Tax Supporting
Public Schools Within Miami Beach City Limits. (March 1, 2017 Commission Item
R9F)
ACTION
The Committee recommended amending the FY2017 budget for the Dual Enrollment
and Licensed Clinical Social Worker programs that are pending budget appropriation in
order to commence in August 2017.
Motion made by Commissioner Aleman to find funding for the existing enhancements in
FY 2017 budget for the Dual Enrollment and Nurse Initiative programs (current and
enhanced); seconded by Commissioner Malakoff.
The Committee recommended moving forward with option 6 of the memo to create a
non-profit to raise funding for public school education enhancements in Miami Beach.
Staff is to work with the City Attorney's Office.
Motion made by Commissioner Malakoff to form a 501(c)(3) in the City of Miami Beach
to fund public school education enhancements (Option 6); seconded by Commissioner
Aleman.
The Committee directed staff to work with the Committee for Quality of Education
members and Miami Beach public school Parent Teacher Student Associations (PTSAs)
to talk to all interested people in the area and identify what enhancements would be
proposed for funding from a new revenue source earmarked for education. Staff would
then develop a budget for enhancements that do not encroach on the domain of the
School Board or supplant School Board funding and come back to the Committee in
order to examine a funding source.
Page 3 of 5
inclusion of a commercial accessory use as part of the development proposal to
strengthen its financial viability.
The Committee directed staff to use the eligible 537 City employees as a sample to
calculate family composition in order to decide what mix of units to prefer on-site.
5. Discussion Regarding Transitioning To Non-Gas Powered Leaf Blowers For City
Staff And Contractors. (March 1, 2017 Commission Item R9R)
ACTION
The Committee recommended moving forward with the transition to non-gas powered
leaf blowers. Existing gas-powered blowers would continue to be used until they reach
the end of their useful life.
6.Discussion Regarding The Maintenance Of Public Bathrooms Citywide.(February
8, 2017 Commission Item C4N)
ACTION
Item deferred pending direction from the Neighborhood/Community Affairs Committee.
7. Discussion Regarding A One Cent (0.01) Food And Beverage Tax Supporting
Public Schools Within Miami Beach City Limits. (March 1, 2017 Commission Item
R9F)
ACTION
The Committee recommended amending the FY2017 budget for the Dual Enrollment
and Licensed Clinical Social Worker programs that are pending budget appropriation in
order to commence in August 2017.
Motion made by Commissioner Alemán to find funding for the existing enhancements in
FY 2017 budget for the Dual Enrollment and Nurse Initiative programs (current and
enhanced); seconded by Commissioner Malakoff.
The Committee recommended moving forward with option 6 of the memo to create a
non-profit to raise funding for public school education enhancements in Miami Beach.
Staff is to work with the City Attorney’s Office.
Motion made by Commissioner Malakoff to form a 501(c)(3) in the City of Miami Beach
to fund public school education enhancements (Option 6); seconded by Commissioner
Alemán.
The Committee directed staff to work with the Committee for Quality of Education
members and Miami Beach public school Parent Teacher Student Associations (PTSAs)
to talk to all interested people in the area and identify what enhancements would be
proposed for funding from a new revenue source earmarked for education. Staff would
then develop a budget for enhancements that do not encroach on the domain of the
School Board or supplant School Board funding and come back to the Committee in
order to examine a funding source.
Page 4 of 5
The Committee directed staff to work with the City Attorney's office to look at renewals of
vendor contracts, franchises, or licenses where the City could require or request that the
vendor provide public benefits for educational enhancements in Miami Beach schools,
such as Waste Hauler's contracts currently provide.
The Committee directed staff to come up with a visionary plan for option 3 of the memo,
dedicated millage for Public Education, and bring back to the Finance and Citywide
Projects Committee to consider.
The Committee recommended moving to full Commission to provide a resolution to help
Miami-Dade County Public Schools (M-DCPS) with legislative priorities to increase
funding for both the early education (VPK program) and per student K-12 funding
allocation from the State.
Motion made by Commissioner Aleman to provide a resolution to support M-DCPS
legislative priorities including early childhood programs (VPK) and per child funding;
seconded by Commissioner Arriola.
8. Discuss Engaging In A Pilot Program With A Cost Reduction Consultant. (March 1,
2017 Commission Item C4N)
ACTION
The Committee directed staff to work with departments to identify any other potential
areas that can be looked at by a cost reduction consultant and bring those back to a
future Committee meeting to provide further direction.
9. Discussion Of The Issuance Of New Money And Refunding Water And Sewer
Revenue Bonds. (March 17, 2017)
ACTION
The Committee recommended proceeding with the issuance of new money and
refunding the Series 2000 Water and Sewer Revenue Bonds.
10. Discussion Of The Issuance Of New Stormwater Revenue Bonds. (March 17,
2017)
ACTION
The Committee recommended proceeding with the issuance of new Stormwater
Revenue Bonds.
11. Discussion Regarding Proposed Interceptor Garage At 1623 West Avenue (Lot No.
P23). (September 27, 2016 Commission Item R9E)(Continued From September 14,
2016 Commission Item R9AA)
ACTION
Item not heard. No action was taken.
Page 4 of 5
The Committee directed staff to work with the City Attorney’s office to look at renewals of
vendor contracts, franchises, or licenses where the City could require or request that the
vendor provide public benefits for educational enhancements in Miami Beach schools,
such as Waste Hauler’s contracts currently provide.
The Committee directed staff to come up with a visionary plan for option 3 of the memo,
dedicated millage for Public Education, and bring back to the Finance and Citywide
Projects Committee to consider.
The Committee recommended moving to full Commission to provide a resolution to help
Miami-Dade County Public Schools (M-DCPS) with legislative priorities to increase
funding for both the early education (VPK program) and per student K-12 funding
allocation from the State.
Motion made by Commissioner Alemán to provide a resolution to support M-DCPS
legislative priorities including early childhood programs (VPK) and per child funding;
seconded by Commissioner Arriola.
8. Discuss Engaging In A Pilot Program With A Cost Reduction Consultant.(March 1,
2017 Commission Item C4N)
ACTION
The Committee directed staff to work with departments to identify any other potential
areas that can be looked at by a cost reduction consultant and bring those back to a
future Committee meeting to provide further direction.
9. Discussion Of The Issuance Of New Money And Refunding Water And Sewer
Revenue Bonds.(March 17, 2017)
ACTION
The Committee recommended proceeding with the issuance of new money and
refunding the Series 2000 Water and Sewer Revenue Bonds.
10. Discussion Of The Issuance Of New Stormwater Revenue Bonds.(March 17,
2017)
ACTION
The Committee recommended proceeding with the issuance of new Stormwater
Revenue Bonds.
11. Discussion Regarding Proposed Interceptor Garage At 1623 West Avenue (Lot No.
P23).(September 27, 2016 Commission Item R9E)(Continued From September 14,
2016 Commission Item R9AA)
ACTION
Item not heard. No action was taken.
Page 5 of 5
12. Discussion To Explore Placing Cameras On Every Corner Of The MXE (Mixed Use
Entertainment) District And On The Beachwalk, And Installing Emergency
Activation Boxes Along The Beachwalk. (March 1, 2017 Commission Item C4P)
ACTION
Item not heard. No action was taken.
13. Discuss An Arrangement With Sabrina Cohen Foundation For The Construction
And Operation Of An Adaptive Fitness Center At A Portion Of The 53rd Street
Parking Lot With Direction To Staff To Do Outreach To The Buildings Immediately
Adjacent. (March 22, 2017 Commission Item C4B)
ACTION
Item not heard. No action was taken.
Page 5 of 5
12. Discussion To Explore Placing Cameras On Every Corner Of The MXE (Mixed Use
Entertainment) District And On The Beachwalk, And Installing Emergency
Activation Boxes Along The Beachwalk.(March 1, 2017 Commission Item C4P)
ACTION
Item not heard. No action was taken.
13. Discuss An Arrangement With Sabrina Cohen Foundation For The Construction
And Operation Of An Adaptive Fitness Center At A Portion Of The 53rd Street
Parking Lot With Direction To Staff To Do Outreach To The Buildings Immediately
Adjacent.(March 22, 2017 Commission Item C4B)
ACTION
Item not heard. No action was taken.