1645-4 Historic Markers . • ' rn
HAL HERTZ
5720 ALTON ROAD/MIAMI BEACH,FLORIDA 33140/TELEPHONE (305)865-7383
•
, anuary 15 , 1987
"' 15 ili•i 8
Lit
Honoralbe Bruce Singer 4 Ji;.• ' ' `������1J
Commissioner, Miami Beach City Hall CrFi��
1700 Convention Centre Drive
Miami Beach, Florida 33139
Re: Historic Marker Project.
Dear Bruce,
As per your suggestion, I reviewed the twelve recommended suggestions
made by the Historic Preservation Board, for historical significance.
I must first commend the Board for their effort in this regard and
Nancy Liebman and Sandra Cook in particular for their dedication.
Although my research differs somewhat with theirs, in some instances ,
or perhaps my knowledge is in greater depth than that which I read in
their briefings , I took the time and the extended privilege to thumb-
nail my own account of these historical-- sites in brief.
I also recalled to your attention some other sites of historical sig-
nificance, not mentioned by the Historic Preservation Board.
It is always my pleasure to serve or help where I can in this City' s
best interests.
Most Sin -rely,
• HE
HH:med
HAL HERTZ
5720 AL'fON ROAD/MIAMI BEACH,FLORIDA 33140/TELEPHONE (305)865-7363
MIAMI BEACH
Today, Miami Beach embraces just eight square miles of enchantment.
There is no place quite like it, anywhere else on earth.
To write of it' s history now, is to do an injustice, for there is al-
most no such thing as a history of Miami Beach. For history implies
age, and Miami Beach, as a City, is still a youngster, despite it' s
magnificent early development.
But to preserve in memory, some of the very earliest sites or individ-
uals, who were of special importance in the embryonic stage of Miami
Beach - the following are of significance.
1. Captain Richard Carney House. In 1882 - 12' x 22 ' .
A small, portable house brought from New Jersey along with tents, wagons ,
tools , mules and several lifeboats along with men and provisions all
transported on a Mallory Line vessel bound from New York to Key West.
On a natural clearing on the site of today' s Lummus Park at about 10th
street, the portable house was bolted together and used as a headquarters
for Captain Carney, leader of the 25 man crew as well as Henry Lum, Ezra
Osborn and Elnathan T. Field. Years later, Carney took the portable house
with him to Coconut Grove; this was in the fall of 1886 . The house was
moved again in 1894 to South Bayshore Drive where it stands to this day.
2 . Lum Plantation - Charles Lum Homesite.
Charles Lum was 15 years old when he and his father, Henry Lum, first
came to Florida in 1868 . Two years later, in 1870 , these two came again ,
this time to Key West on a Clyde Steamer, from there they came to Miami
in a 16 foot sailboat. They visited Miami Beach, found three coconuts
growing at Brahman' s Landing which immediately gave them the idea for a
Coconut Plantation. They went back to New Jersey and did not return
again for 12 years. But, in the meantime, Charles and his father bought
a tract of beach land from the government for 35 an acre. The land they
bought stretched from 1st street to 15th street (most of this land was
later to comprise the Ocean Beach Development. ) In the spring of 1886 ,
Charles Lum, now married, built the first real home on Miami Beach. A
sure enough, two story home, complete even to roofed porch. He and his
wife lived here for three years and then history lost sight of them.
-1-
1
HAL HERTZ
5720 AL'fON ROAD/MIAMI BEACH,FLORIDA 331.0/TELEPHONE 13051 865-7363
3. Carl Fisher Homesite. The Shadows at the foot of Lincoln Road
and the Ocean.
It was during the winter season of 1915 that the Fisher home was com-
pleted and Carl and his wife , Jane, moved into the most sumptious home
built on the Beach. President Warren G. H,;,rding was known to play poker
here. Many of the nations ' richest industrialists were guests of the
Carl Fishers' . N.B.T. Roney bought the Fisher home and later sold it
to two gamblers. After Fisher' s death, they turned it into the Beach ' s
most exclusive gambling casino called the Beach and Tennis Club. Carl
Graham Fisher, the developing genius of Miami Beach, after squandering
a 50 million dollar fortune, died a poor man in a little house on 51st
street from a gastric hemorrhage in July of 1939 . . .For that which was
created here and exists today - Carl Fisher planted the first seeds of
development.
4 . John S. Collins - 1837-1928 .
First came to Miami Beach in 1907 . On February 11 , 1928 at age 90 John
Collins was laid to rest, a happy man. Only 5 feet 2 inches tall , he
nevertheless was a giant of a man in his accomplishments . He truly was
one of God' s noblemen. Miami Beach is a monument of his vision and
courage and he rightfully earned the title of "The Father of Miami
Beach. "
(John Collins ' story is too expanded to detail in this thumbnail mention. )
5. Thomas Jessup Pancoast.
John Collins' son-in-law and right hand bower, served Miami Beach long
and faithfully in many capacities, from it' s infancy. . .was the Beach' s
second Mayor, elected in 1917 following J. N. Lummus . He was also one
of the five founders of the Miami Beach Chamber of Commerce and it' s
first president.
(Thomas Pancoast's story as it relates to Miami Beach' s early beginning
is too beautiful to be done here in thumbnail. )
-2-
HAL HERTZ
5720 ALTON ROAD/MIAMI BEACH.FLORIDA 33140/TELEPHONE 1305)865-7363
6 . Collins Bridge - formally opened June 12, 1913 . Rates were 10G
round trip - 20 - motorcycles - automobiles 70 plus 10G each
passenger.
This is one of the great, emotional, historical stories of John Collins
foresight and courage at age 74 , to envision the completion of the
world' s longest wooden bridge. It was originally called Collin' s Folly
and his heartaches attendant to it' s construction and the major role
that Carl Fisher played to help him, is worthy of in-depth telling.
7 . County Causeway - Now called McArthur Causeway.
5th Street and West Avenue was the Miami Beach Anchor. First proposed by
Mayor Watson of Miami in 1915 . However, it was in October of 1916 be-
fore real action was taken to finance this undertaking. Bonds were
voted in an issue of $600 ,000 . 00 . In much of 1917 work was actually be-
gun on the causeway. It was J.N. Lummus, first Mayor of Miami Beach,
who really persuaded the County Commissioners to apply to the government
for a permit and instilled life into the project. The causeway was com-
pleted on New Years Day, 1920 , by which time $625 ,000 . had been spent.
On Tuesday, February 17 at 2: 00 p.m. , the 3 mile causeway was opened to
the public for the first time.
8 . Star Island - 1917.
Dredged, bulkheaded and filled by Carl Fisher to originally house the
stables for polo ponies - later developed for homesites.
A great personal triumph for Fisher and his PreF$--O-Dight partner ,
James Allison - Great story if told in depth.
9. N.B.T. Roney and Roney Plaza Hotel.
Roney was one of the major influences in Miami Beach' s beginning and
the Roney Plaza Hotel was the crown jewel in the early years of Miami
Beach, ably promoted throughout the nation by Walter Winchell.
This is a major story told in depth.
-3-
HAL HERTZ
5720 ALTON ROAD/MIAMI BEACH,FLORIDA 33t40/TELEPHONE (3051 865-7363
10. Nautilus Hotel and Polo Fields.
Carl Fisher built 3 hotels at one time. The Lincoln - The Flamingo
and the Nautilus Hotel with it ' s polo field. The story of the
Flamingo' s crown of ground glass topped Florida 's 2nd tallest building
and was a beacon to Mariners at sea. The Nautilus story is one of Miami
Beach' s most interesting. From resort hotel to Navy Hospital to Miami
Beach Medical Center.
A great, great story.
11. Allison Hospital now St. Francis Hospital - 1924 .
I have already done this story and had it published.
12 . Harvey Firestone Estate - Site of Fountainbleau Hotel.
T- e tready—d®uled--±^t-mTr4bHi-sh ,
-4-
HAL HERTZ
5720 AL TON ROAD/MIAMI BEACH.FLORIDA 33140/TELEPHONE (305)865-7363
Suggested Important Early Historical Sites Not Yet Mentioned.
1. Smith ' s Casino - 1905-1912 . First Miami Beach bathhouse.
2. Joe' s Restaurant - 1918 - Miami Beach 's first restaurant.
3 . Lincoln Road Fishing Pier - First Pier in Miami Beach.
4 . Brahmans Landing - 1870 - where Henry Lum first found 3 coconut
trees which brought him back in 1882 to start a coconut plantation.
5 . Lake Pancoast - First Called Indian Lake - Crocodile nesting pool.
6. Roman Pools - Miami Beach ' s first sea water concrete swimming pool .
7. Miami Beach Municipal Headquarters - 1927 - built for $213 ,000 .
8 . Miami Beach Aquarium - 1919 - West Avenue at 5th Street
9 . Miami Beach Railroad.
10 . Miami Beach Dairy Farm.
11. John Collins Barn for his avocado farm. 41st at Sheridan Avenue ..
12. Pine Tree Drive - it' s purpose - 1909.