The URL can be used to link to this page

Resolution 2018-30570 RESOLUTION NO. 2018-30570 A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, ACCEPTING THE URBAN LAND INSTITUTE (ULI) FINAL EVALUATION REPORT OF THE CITY'S STORMWATER MANAGEMENT STRATEGY, WHICH REPORT WAS FUNDED BY 100 RESILIENT CITIES, AND IS ATTACHED HERETO AS EXHIBIT A. WHEREAS, at the January 2018 Sustainability & Resiliency Committee meeting Commissioner Mark Samuelian introduced an item to review the City of Miami Beach's Stormwater Resilience Program; and WHEREAS, the City is interested in obtaining a third-party assessment of the current program; and WHEREAS, the City is a member of the 100 Resilient Cities (100 RC) Network, an organization dedicated to support cities as they face growing fiscal and development pressures due to climate change, urbanization and globalization; and WHEREAS, the Urban Land Institute is a 100 Resilient Cities platform partner and is dedicated to creating thriving communities across the globe with expertise in land use. planning and real estate; and WHEREAS, through the City's membership in 100 Resilient Cities Network, 100 RC has graciously agreed to fund the Stormwater Resilience Program review effort; and WHEREAS, the Urban Land Institute Technical Assistance Advisory Panel Review was held from April 16-19, 2018, in Miami Beach, Florida. NOW, THEREFORE, BE R DULY RESOLVED THAT THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, hereby accepts the Urban Land Institute (ULI) Final Report evaluating the City's Stormwater Management Strategy, which report was funded by 100 Resilient Cities, and which report is attached hereto as Exhibit A. PASSED and ADOPTED this /7 Of OC74 b 'r•, ZO/ P. ATTEST: Dan Gelber, Mayor 10 ViY �Nv;'. S APPROVED AS TO Ra ael E. Granado, City Clerk_ --.� y FORM & LANGU. E �:•" ► & FOR EXEC i 'N * INCORP ORATED: .(02viy 1\c ,! C Attorney Date �H_26 111114., V Resolutions - R7 0 MIAMI BEACH COMMISSION MEMORANDUM TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Commission FROM: Jimmy L. Morales, City Manager DATE: October 17, 2018 SUBJECT: A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, ACCEPTING THE URBAN LAND INSTITUTE (ULI) FINAL EVALUATION REPORT OF THE CITY'S STORMWATER MANAGEMENT STRATEGY, WHICH REPORT WAS FUNDED BY 100 RESILIENT CITIES, AND IS ATTACHED HERETO AS EXHIBIT A. RECOMMENDATION Adopt the Resolution. ANALYSIS At the January Sustainability and Resiliency Committee, Commissioner Samuelian introduced an item to review the city's stormwater resilience program. Staff advised that with the support of the Rockefeller Foundation's 100 Resilient Cities (100 RC) Network, the Urban Land Institute (ULI) has been invited to assess the City of Miami Beach's current stormwater management strategy. SRC reviewed the project scope and forwarded to the full Commission in March for approval. In April a multidisciplinary global team convened in Miami Beach to review our program. The Urban Land Institute (ULI) is the oldest and largest network of cross-disciplinary land use and real estate experts in the world dedicated to creating thriving communities around the globe. Their goal is to make cities better places to live for people from all walks of life. ULI is also a 100 RC platform partner, part of a professional network that provides resilience-building tools and services to 100 RC cities. ULI panels are intensive, on-site engagements conducted by volunteer panelists that provide strategic advice to governments and organizations on a wide variety of land use challenges. This four-day event convened senior practitioners from a variety disciplines, such as urban planning, engineering, science, finance, insurance etc. Panelists spent hours in reading background material, attending staff orientations and tours, conducting stakeholder interviews, and hosting a public listening session. The final onsite deliverable was a panel presentation to the city at a public meeting.At that meeting the panel shared their recommendations on: Program vision: • Integrate stormwater management into the larger resilience strategy • Enhance trust, trust the public, increase transparency • Elevate aesthetics and function to perpetuate city's cultural relevance • Actively use green and open spaces for sponge function • Increase long term financial and comprehensive protection Page 1114 of 1637 • Go big on the resilience brand —distinguish yourself from your coastal competitors Program principles: • Maintained urgency, • incrementalism&evaluation, • transparency, • ecological health, • financial pragmatism, • co-benefits, social equity, • cultural identity, • living with water. CONCLUSION It is recommended that the City Commission accept the Urban Land Institute Final Report (attached) for staff implementation. Certain recommendations may require additional Commission approvals and will be vetted through the committee process. Legislative Tracking Office of the City Manager ATTACHMENTS: Description ❑ Resolution o Exhibit A: Urban Land Institute Advisory Services Panel Report- Miami Beach o ULI Presentation Page 1115 of 1637 Miami Beach Florida . April 16-19, 2018 1111P11"I' .+'ti ,...,...,=, , yrc-0r mer.+ ,:11111.e_!nv y�y� n�nr" . -mow - nensawt p cg er IV API • • Urban Land uLi Institute Page 1117 of 1637 Miami Beach Florida Stormwater IVanacement and Climate Adaptation Review April 16-19, 2018 Urban Land ROCMEEEREOFELLER THE OCMO FOUMOAi(p, ULA Institute 100 RESILIENT Page 1118 of 1637 About the Urban Land Institute THE URBAN LAND INSTITUTE is a global,member- a variety of factors affecting the built environment,includ- driven organization comprising more than 42,000 real ing urbanization,demographic and population changes, estate and urban development professionals dedicated to new economic drivers,technology advancements,and advancing the Institute's mission of providing leadership in environmental concerns. the responsible use of land and in creating and sustaining Peer-to-peer learning is achieved through the knowledge thriving communities worldwide. shared by members at thousands of convenings each ULI's interdisciplinary membership represents all aspects year that reinforce ULI's position as a global authority on of the industry,including developers,property owners, land use and real estate. In 2017 alone,more than 1,900 investors,architects,urban planners,public officials,real events were held in about 290 cities around the world. estate brokers,appraisers,attorneys,engineers,finan- ciers,and academics.Established in 1936,the Institute Drawing on the work of its members,the Institute recog- has a presence in the Americas,Europe,and Asia Pacific nizes and shares best practices in urban design and devel- regions,with members in 76 countries. opment for the benefit of communities around the globe. The extraordinary impact that ULI makes on land use deci More information is available at uli.org.Follow ULI on sion making is based on its members sharing expertise on Twitter, Facebook,Linkedln,and Instagram. Cover:Katharine Burgess/ULI. ©2018 by the Urban Land Institute 2001 L Street,NW Suite 200 Washington,DC 20036-4948 All rights reserved.Reproduction or use of the whole or any part of the contents of this publication without written permission of the copyright holder is prohibited. 2 Page 1119 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report About ULI Advisory Services THE GOAL OF THE ULI ADVISORY SERVICES program assessments of a sponsor's issues and to provide recom- is to bring the finest expertise in the real estate field to mendations in a compressed amount of time. bear on complex land use planning and development projects,programs,and policies.Since 1947,this program A major strength of the program is ULI's unique ability has assembled well over 600 ULI-member teams to help to draw on the knowledge and expertise of its members, sponsors find creative,practical solutions for issues such including land developers and owners,public officials, as downtown redevelopment,land management strategies, academics,representatives of financial institutions,and oth evaluation of development potential,growth management, ers.In fulfillment of the mission of the Urban Land Institute, community revitalization,brownfield redevelopment,military this Advisory Services panel report is intended to provide base reuse,provision of low-cost and affordable housing, objective advice that will promote the responsible use of land and asset management strategies,among other matters.A to enhance the environment. wide variety of public,private,and nonprofit organizations ULI Program Staff have contracted for ULI's advisory services. Paul Bernard Executive Vice President,Advisory Services Each panel team is composed of highly qualified profession- als who volunteer their time to ULI.They are chosen for their Thomas W.Eider knowledge of the panel topic and screened to ensure their Senior Vice President,Advisory Services objectivity.ULI's interdisciplinary panel teams provide a holis- Beth Silverman tic look at development problems.A respected ULI member Vice President,Advisory Services who has previous panel experience chairs each panel. Paul Angelone Director,Advisory Services The agenda for a three-day panel assignment is intensive.It Cali Slepin includes an in-depth briefing day composed of a tour of the Associate,Advisory Services site,meetings with sponsor representatives,and interviews James A.Mulligan with 15 to 30 community representatives,followed by Senior Editor two days of formulating recommendations.Long nights of Laura Glassman,Publications Professionals LLC discussion precede the panel's conclusions.On the final day Manuscript Editor on site,the panel makes an oral presentation of its findings Brandon Weil and conclusions to the sponsor.A written report is prepared Art Director and published. Anne Morgan Because the sponsoring entities are responsible for signifi- Lead Graphic Designer cant preparation before the panel's visit,including sending Kurt Wisthuff,Arc Group Ltd extensive briefing materials to each member and arranging Graphic Designer for the panel to meet with key local community members Craig Chapman and stakeholders in the project under consideration,partici- Senior Director,Publishing Operations pants in ULI's panel assignments are able to make accurate Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1120 of 1637 3 Urban Resilience Panels THE URBAN LAND INSTITUTE HAS JOINED with 100 from climate change.These panels also build from ULI Resilient Cities(100RC)—pioneered by the Rockefeller member knowledge of land use,real estate,and develop- Foundation—as a platform partner,supporting cities in ment to help cities foster an environment in which the the 100RC network in their efforts to be more resilient private sector can productively contribute to resilience and to design and implement comprehensive resilience building.In summary,the guidance from these panels strategies.Together,they acknowledge 100RC's defini- is intended to offer cities strategies to more effectively tion of resilience:the capacity of individuals,communi- address the impacts of climate change on a day-to-day ties,institutions,businesses,and systems within a city to basis,support an environment conducive to investment, survive,adapt,and grow,no matter what kinds of chronic and make infrastructural investments that will not only stresses and acute shocks they experience.Implied in that improve preparedness but also strengthen social cohesion, definition is the ability not just to recover and bounce back economic development opportunities,and environmental but also to bounce forward and thrive.The platform part- performance. nership will host ULI panels within 100RC cities,thereby creating a powerful nexus of knowledge and resources. ULI Program Staff ULI will also support 100RC cities through other means, Billy Grayson such as collaborative local projects and outreach with Executive Director, Center for Sustainability and ULI's network of District Councils and National Councils. Economic Performance Katharine Burgess Since 2014,ULI has undertaken a series of Advisory Senior Director,Urban Resilience Services panels across the United States to assess how cities can better prepare for changes deriving from global Leah Sheppard climate change and foster more resilient approaches to Associate, Urban Resilience land use.Advisory Services panels are intensive,on-site Erica Ellis workshops led by a dedicated team of ULI members, Intern,Urban Resilience who work with a host city to address complex land use Rachael Hartofelis challenges.Panelists complete site tours,briefings,and Intern,Urban Resilience stakeholder outreach and engagement,followed by Julie Medley intensive research,deliberation,and collaboration,to Executive Director,UU Southeast Florida/Caribbean produce a series of recommendations for the host city. Mallory Barker The environmental vulnerabilities faced by panel host Associate,ULI Southeast Florida/Canbbean cities have ranged from rising sea levels and exacerbated drought and air temperatures to more extreme conditions, such as floods and wildfires. The objective of these panels is to offer strategic guidance that will assist in cities'formulation of plans and poli- cies and that will,in turn,make their communities more resilient and create stronger responses to and recoveries from both peak events and the long-term stresses arising 4 Page 1121 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report 01 ''of moo _ 1 491111110111k: '... * - ''401 4'4,j.....1*011101111.6111 ,2 s k ' - Ai -- .r.- 4 y�64m.1 "+-. a� , �: r '7' - : - 'Ps,rr IMIkb, ,,, 40, 6 , y 31111014 . 1, Mill 'NO , ,..• 1 p i i or , , 1. 1 Pi 1 , 7- _, ...... , ir, 4. 41. „„, .4 f! � r+ — 1� I, ►'�. ''.t1^ 1, ' i i, sift s,' iii;;I . t —••• , R f; The Miami Beach panel spent _ y an intensive three-and-half days , `^ W in Miami Beach,researching, I'" a -41, ` ''. w interviewing residents and " 4‘-. , 11 stakeholders,and presenting r a its recommendations. Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1122 of 1637 5 Acknowledgments THE URBAN LAND INSTITUTE WISHES TO THANK Wilson has also been an important resource and guide for the city of Miami Beach for hosting this panel and the the city of Miami Beach throughout the Greater Miami and Rockefeller Foundation's 100 Resilient Cities initiative for the Beaches Resilience Strategy process. sponsoring this panel.In particular,ULI thanks Mayor Dan Gelber and City Manager Jimmy Morales for initiating this The panel also extends its thanks to the many stakehold panel and offering the panelists and the ULI team access ers from Miami Beach who participated in the panel through to Miami Beach staff,knowledge,and resources.In addi the interview process and who attended the public listening tion,a special thank you for hosting ULI and facilitating the session and final presentation.This group included resi panel's work is extended to the chief resiliency officer and dents,community and civic leaders,local designers, assistant city manager,Susanne Torriente,and the deputy environmental activists,academics,business leaders, resiliency officer,Amy Knowles,who led preparation for real estate developers,and many others.Throughout the the panel and ensured the panel's access to critical infor week the panel was continuously impressed with the level mation and viewpoints,showing a very clear commitment of passion and involvement from the community and its to the city and resilience. interest in stormwater management and resilience. Many other dedicated staff members from the city of Mi- ami Beach provided excellent support to the panel during preparation and the panel's visit,including Eric Carpenter, assistant city manager;David Martinez,capital improve- ments director;Roy Coley,public works director;Thomas Mooney,planning department director;Elizabeth Wheaton, environment and sustainability director;Maria Hernandez, Miami Beach Convention Center project director;Kayla Martinez,environmental and sustainability office associ- ate;Cynthia Casanova,Parks and Recreation;Nestor Na- varro,GIS manager;Naima de Pinedo in the Office of the City Manager;and Grace Castro,special events manager, and Denis Wolpert from the Bass Museum of Art. The panel would also like to thank the 100 Resilient Cities initiative for its generous financial support of the panel, which made the project possible,and for all the services provided to the city through its engagement with the network.Staff from 100RC who provided leadership and support to the Miami Beach team and ULI on this project included Jeb Brugmann,Smita Rawoot,and Eric Wilson. 6 Page 1123 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report Contents ULI Panel and Project Staff 8 Executive Summary 9 Guiding Principles 15 Background 19 Current Stormwater Management Program 21 Infrastructure 30 Physical Design and Typology 43 Creative Placemaking 48 Governance 55 Financing 61 Regulations 63 Communications 71 Conclusion 79 Appendix: Summary of Recommendations 80 Notes 82 About the Panel 84 Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1124 of 1637 7 ULI Panel and Project Staff Panel Chair Walter Meyer Joyce Coffee Founding Principal Local Office Landscape Architecture and President Adjunct Professor,Parsons The New School Climate Resilience Consulting New York,New York Chicago,Illinois Christian Nyerup Nielsen Panel Members Senior Director,Climate Adaptation,Landscape and Flood Risk Management Juanita Hardy Ramboll Water Senior Visiting Fellow,Creative Placemaking Copenhagen,Denmark Urban Land Institute Mark Osler Washington,D.C. Associate Vice President and Coastal Science and Jeff Hebert Engineering Practice Lead Vice President for Adaptation and Resilience Michael Baker International The Water Institute of the Gulf Alexandria,Virginia Baton Rouge,Louisiana Greg West Phillip Kash President and CEO,ZOM Principal Chair,ULI Southeast Florida/Caribbean HR&A Advisors Miami,Florida Washington,D.C. Greg Lowe ULI Project Staff Global Head of Resilience and Sustainability Katharine Burgess Aon Senior Director,Urban Resilience London,United Kingdom Julie Medley Executive Director,ULI Southeast Florida and Caribbean • _ Nicole Martinez r',. Contributing Writer . . Mallory Barker Associate,ULI Southeast Florida and Caribbean y Leah Sheppard a� r NELAiiitt- r ` ' ..4 .1 .• 4 Associate,Urban Resilience 7 >" ti +R� 4.,,f , 'ja -�� '' w. � Erica Ellis t Intern,Urban Resilience - • Rachael Hartofelis Intern,Urban Resilience Panelists tour Miami Beach, led by Elizabeth Wheaton, the city's environment and sustainability director. 8 Page 1125 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report Executive Summary INCORPORATED IN 1915 on a seven-mile stretch of �`r, MonMow. m porous substrate land along the Atlantic Ocean,the city ofpin, fa :are Para Miami Beach has nearly 100,000 residents and welcomes �.d � cdarn ctedM �� millions of visitors annually.A coastal barrier island,home N°'*'""PO. to significant tourism and magnificent art deco archi eeel,n muwlr �}, ®aimotto tecture,the city is a cultural and touristic center that is rtsn,.w w°esynePast surrnain extremely vulnerable to weather and the sea.For instance, Ihromood the region is one of the most at risk to sea-level rise in kuomishoe' Ea w..t LAI* hums qtia the country and is vulnerable to three sources of flooding: °Do"'' Non r coastal flooding including king tides,flooding caused by mop rainfall,and flooding from groundwater. unit s,t. r °Acne Brach 0110.41 k1 40 The city of Miami Beach has shown an impressive corn- CtsnyMarm Ci mitment in the last few years to addressing these flooding vulnerabilities,including identifying the funding for and be- .11...1ach ,, ginning execution of a projected$600 million stormwater chit *Mirkcteac°0 •.. management program,sourcing financing independently of """"'""' C)�A�nle � � federal and state funds.Referred to throughout this report 0 i0wn"0"N0 rho,9 Miami Foe,.teka,d s The city of Miami Beach is as the stormwater management program,this program tr..,..Q located on a barrier island off O V1j•'�'1"'."'9`"1"` 8 the southeast coast of Florida. comprises infrastructural investments and policy changes related to climate adaptation as relevant to stormwater, king tides,and sea-level rise.As of early 2018,the city is • Establishing a freeboard above Federal Emergency about 15 percent into this ten-year program that includes Management Agency(FEMA)base flood elevation; infrastructural updates as well as updates to both land use • Introducing additional commercial height standards; and development codes,as follows: • Increasing setbacks and open space for single-family • Improving drainage systems; homes;and • Elevating roads and public seawalls; • Requiring sea-level rise review criteria for land • Installing pumps to replace aging gravity use boards. stormwater pipes; The Miami Beach Rising Above website provides informa- ■ Replacing much of the water,wastewater,and tion about many of these infrastructural investments and other utilities; policies,as well as other initiatives relevant to climate adaptation.The city is also participating in the Rockefeller • Increasing seawall height; Foundation's 100 Resilient Cities(100RC)initiative and will • Increasing base flood elevation; be authoring a resilience strategy in coordination with city of Miami and Miami-Dade County efforts. Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1126 of 1637 9 e'?. ` • How can the city best communicate with residents and stakeholders about potential solutions and costs and otherwise engage community in the ongoing stormwater and flood management program? "il ,, } z r In addition,panelists were asked to identify possible future 01 1 . ...A 0y, ��'100a- opportunities,including the following: 1�^ ■ How can the city ultimately advance climate adapta- k" *' • tion in private development,including residential and T commercial development,including perhaps adaptation .t).F'4 _1i l+ i, ,'� I $ I :- ,, strategies such as raising buildings? ii •a 4 ' � '- ■ What strategies could be used to involve the private ��' sector,public/private partnerships,or both in the de- 1 v v sign,funding,and delivery of stormwater management Miami Beach is well known and flood mitigation strategies? for one of the most notable ensembles of historic art deco The Panel's Assignment . How might the city use its upcoming business case architecture in the United States. analysis to advance future climate adaptation and With the support of the 100 Resilient Cities initiative, the Urban Land Institute was invited to assess the city's stormwater management decision making? current stormwater and climate adaptation strategy.At an In summary,the Advisory Services panel was tasked with Advisory Services panel held over the course of three days, examining Miami Beach's current stormwater management ULI-member experts from around the globe convened to and climate adaptation strategy to assess its efficacy while both assess the current framework and propose additional making recommendations for future planning and develop- efforts to further bolster the city's existing strategy.The ment of the resilience strategy,which will address flooding, city asked the panel to address the following questions: among other issues. ■ Is the city of Miami Beach on the right track in its ap- proach to mitigate flooding caused by tidal and ' y � ' rain events? ` o ■ Is the city of Miami Beach on the right track in terms -, Y of elevating roads,harmonization,placemaking,and . f . ' F , 1 aesthetics? Y '�., A. • Is the city of Miami Beach's neighborhood and project • I :. , , ' r r i / ;4014:4''..$ :y boundary map and strategy for project prioritization and 4� sequencing sound? W • What other investments in public infrastructure im- Elevated streets,along with pumps placed in public rights-of-way provements could occur where construction is already and green spaces,are an integral part of the city's stormwater management strategy. underway? 10 Page 1127 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report For clarification,in this report the panel uses the , following terms: I •...•- . � .�.r j t. 1 I t ° r ■ Stormwater management strategy refers to the$600 • �_1f 1-,.u ti 4 ,t jj.g. i ', �' i_1 million funded program of work already underway that t� ♦ 11p �... „t' �, 'P includes infrastructural improvements such as the intro- ac . duction of pumps and elevated streets and development f , •* •�` code updates and addresses risks including stormwater -_�. - ).?:1 , . ,,, management,king tides,and sea-level rise. 4 ,,•f ,•� - 406, • Miami Beach Rising Above refers to the website,com- J munications collateral—such as email,PR materials, -. , l brochures,newsletter,and app—and branding devel- \ . oped after the launch of the stormwater management ' - -- strategy,which has also more broadly addressed Miami i '�, ., -> : .„ 4 ' • :, t. Beach's climate adaptation efforts. _'_; Elizabeth Wheaton of the city • Resilience strategy refers to the current strategy being of Miami Beach explains to developed through the 100 Resilient Cities initiative, Panel Recommendations panelists how the Stormwater management system functions. which is likely to address water management and other The panel's assessment centered on studying Miami related resilience factors alongside other issues relevant Beach's environment, land use,and development patterns to social,environmental,and economic resilience.A in the context of flooding vulnerability and the stormwater 100RC Resilience Strategy is a roadmap or call to action management program currently underway.In addition to addressing a city's people,projects,and priorities that is meeting with Miami Beach officials and hosting a public the product of six to nine months of consultation.'This listening session,the panelists conducted anonymous strategy will be coordinated with strategies created by interviews with local community and neighborhood as- the city of Miami and Miami-Dade County,which are sociation leaders,business owners,developers,pres- also a part of the 100 Resilient Cities network. ervationists,and academic professionals to make these determinations and reviewed materials provided by the The recommendations of this report are not only meant city,ULI,and other interested parties. for Miami Beach but are also intended to be considered within the development of Greater Miami and the Beaches First,the panelists assessed Miami Beach's stormwater Resilience Strategy.Although Miami Beach has sought this management strategy and identified its strengths and service,certainly much of south Florida and other corn- opportunities for improvement.They agreed that Miami munities in the United States and abroad can learn from Beach's proactive approach in triaging the problem and the report. acting upon solutions is commendable.The city has been This report is based on the panelists'work during the extremely process oriented,taking careful steps to under- week of the Advisory Services panel and the final presen- tationstand the scientific data and implement solutions. on April 19,2018.The recorded presentations can The city's decision to elevate the most problematic roads be accessed on the Miami Beach Rising Above website, while upgrading and enhancing its stormwater pumping www.mbrisingabove.com. system is an essential part of its strategy for incremental adaptation,which can be built on over time.The city suc- cessfully implemented fundraising strategies to finance Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1128 of 1637 11 these projects,which were not opposed by residents or fee represented an opportunity that the city could pur- commercial business owners.The city's planning includes sue without oversight or approval from even the county, a flooding risk estimate that prioritizes the city's implemen- although permitting and regulations are followed.The tation plan according to an area's vulnerability to flooding. city's property values—some of the highest in the southeastern region of the United States—have allowed The panelists were also impressed by Miami Beach's col the city to rapidly pursue mitigation and establish fund- laborative relationship with regional entities,including the ing sources that are likely to remain stable even in the neighboring jurisdictions,and the city's decision to assess face of changes in federal and state policy.Therefore, its strategy and recalculate its approach midstream and preserving property values is critical to ensure funding over time.The city's willingness to implement continuous availability for future stormwater and resilience invest- learning and remain adaptable as it searches for solutions ments and is a topic explored in this report. suggests that Miami Beach has the opportunity to enhance its broader resilience to flooding and climate impacts with ■ Crafted thoughtful communication materials and a more integrated approach. vehicles on the overall resilience program:The Miami Beach Rising Above initiative offers excellent In short,the city acted with courage to fix sunny day and communication materials on the city's investments in stormwater flooding.The panel was particularly impressed stormwater management and climate adaptation,which that the city has taken the following actions: explain key issues in a tone accessible to a range of • Applied good practice for initial stormwater pump stakeholders. rollout and street elevations:These infrastructural investments have made a noticeable difference for neighborhoods that once regularly experienced sunny- Shocks day flooding,such as Sunset Harbour. Hurricanes/tornadoes (22%) • Designed using climate change risk estimates:Mi- ami Beach designs to climate change projections from Economic crash (11%) the Southeast Florida Climate Compact—the regional Infrastructure failure: cyber- climate governance structure for Broward,Miami-Dade, security/communications (9%) Monroe,and Palm Beach counties—and plans for high Infrastructure failure: tides.2 The compact is one of the leading examples transport access (9%) of U.S.regional collaboration,and the city should be applauded for its collaboration with the compact and for using forward-looking rather than historic data for Inadequate transportation infrastructure decision making.The city also monitors system (15.5%) flood levels itself and compares observations to these Sea-level rise (15.5%) projections. Aging infrastructure (15.5%) • Raised funds through fees and bonds rather than relying on state or federal funding:Importantly,un- Lack of affordable housing (14%) like many other U.S.cities at such risk,the city of Miami Beach has entirely funded its stormwater management Access to quality education (7%) program without contributions from federal and state u As a part of the city's work with 100RC,the city participated in a programs.In fact,the implementation of a stormwater resilience diagnostic to identify and prioritize its stresses and shocks. 12 Page 1129 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report Livin. wi ater. r.��vanci • + •a+tine • w '. ago. .0V1. ,,Nine Pros.erit : ;.� n conomy or RESILIENT A TI,•J., is Communit : GREATER MIAMI y. ..F.`a. &THE BEACHES 3t fir Miami Beach's resilience Leadership for Tomorrow: strategy includes six"discovery •Me areas,"which are key issues of O"C"`"' 5 identified in the 100RC s:: W resilience assessment. This .y ?'� • • ■■ s panel's recommendations are • J R * phi r primarily relevant to the living- with-water discovery area. • Collaborated both interagency and within regional ficient to address the extent of risk faced by the city and partnerships:As noted above,south Florida and Miami does not reflect its cultural leadership.Accordingly,the Beach offer a tremendous example of regional col- panel proposes a series of opportunities for improvement, laboration,particularly because of the Southeast Florida which should be incorporated into an expanded strategy Climate Compact,in which the city of Miami Beach that seeks to more broadly address resilience beyond actively participates,including current participation on stormwater management.Key opportunities explored in the Steering Committee.Beyond this,Miami Beach this report include the following: has closely coordinated with the city of Miami and the Miami Dade County resilience offices through 100 ■ Integrating flood management within the larger Resilient Cities. resilience strategy:Integrating the stormwater man- agement plans with broader goals in the emerging re- • Implemented multiple levers,including policy silience strategy will enable the city to embrace a more changes:The stormwater management program not comprehensive and holistic plan for"living with water." only funded infrastructural investments,but the city This is critical given the extent of flooding and climate also revised land use policies to support the desired risk faced now and in the future.This strategy should outcomes.Future efforts including the resilience plan also include investing in technology,such as enhanced and Miami Beach Rising Above should continue to fol- modeling,to better inform the city on the varied types of low this precedent. flooding risks and the cost/benefit of different interven- tions▪ Examined program cost/benefit:Through this Advi to address them. sory Services panel, Miami Beach welcomed outside ■ Enhancing public trust,trusting the public,and experts to critique and offer strategies to continue increasing transparency:Although city staff currently to iterate and improve the stormwater and resilience spends significant time and effort on community out- program underway. reach,past efforts have not been as successful as they The panelists agreed that the city's stormwater manage- could have been.The early stages of the stormwater ment strategy,although a good start,is not currently management program were implemented in emergency suf- Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1130 of 1637 13 j improve collateral public benefits from investment in '''r ' . infrastructure. . pplig .. . • Increasing long-term financial and comprehensive 5� protection:A comprehensive resilience strategy will :, -ii t increase both infrastructural and financial protection, << ;11 , • considering how the city can leverage a range of fund- ','1 it 111<f _:`' fi,, ing sources and be strategic about its approach to risk. Although already we/known _ as a beachfront destination, Miami Beach has the opportunity ,,;;F a, _ ■ Embracing the resilience brand—distinguishing to distinguish itself as a ......: coastal community with its Miami Beach from coastal competitors:Miami resilience efforts. s Beach has the opportunity to be an international leader in resilience and climate adaptation.Embracing this response mode and formed residents'initial impres- opportunity and communicating about it will distinguish sions,leaving many feeling they were not provided with the city from its coastal competitor cities and potentially meaningful opportunities for input.Since that time,the help residents,businesses,and other stakeholders city has broadened its resilience work and engagement, appreciate the value of the proactive alternative Miami particularly through its work under the umbrella of 100 Beach has chosen. Resilient Cities.Future efforts should better integrate The panel's recommendations were guided by a key set of public comment and outreach into the decision-making principles,set out in the next section,that considered both process,provide significant opportunities for the public the city's and its residents'and businesses'priorities,as to weigh in,and increase transparency of the city's well as the impressions of and reactions to the implemented investments,the cosUbenefit,and the likely timeline of stormwater plan thus far.Following the introduction of various climate adaptation investments.Future efforts these principles,this report contemplates an integrated should also report on bay water quality-monitoring, solution for future stormwater management and resilience individual projects'progress against planned timelines, work addressing the following elements: and outreach efforts. • Infrastructure; • Elevating public aesthetics and function to perpetu- ate the city's cultural relevance:Flood mitigation • Physical design and typology; should not be implemented independent of public ■ Creative placemaking; aesthetic concerns. Future investments in stormwater management and resilience should also seek to improve • Governance; health and quality of life and build from the culture of arts,heritage,and placemaking in Miami Beach. ■ Financing; • Actively using green and open space:Green and ■ Regulations;and open space offer an important opportunity to man- • Communications. age and infiltrate water,given their permeability and sponge functions—meaning the ability to absorb water Strategies for each of these elements are explored in detail naturally. Green infrastructure and open space also in individual sections of this report. offer opportunities to enhance overall quality of life and 14 Page 1131 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report Guiding Principles MIAMI BEACH IS CURRENTLY CHARTING a course ', tt'j i •. that could become a model for global cities adapting to s`;• r. • ' ` sea-level rise.The city's commitment to taking a proactive . 1. ' ", `" .---- rn+cse fl l 4:4771 I iMIANgm approach to resilience has already positioned it as a world 1 •'• •�- leader in the climate adaptation space.A next step will ,// �,+ involve more fully embracing dynamic and holistic solutions /, A !a!�l 'W and communicating these better to residents,businesses, - - - . . 4 ., 1, .' !"4 i_" j. \ other stakeholders,and the city's many visitors.Because R Pumps and generators the city's competitors,particularly for tourism and coastal --`- w I $.1•1'.1' = installed in the Sunset Harbour neighborhood are a visible part living,are also coastal,Miami Beach has the chance to dif- x of the city's stormwater strategy. ferentiate itself from other cities by embracing the brand it defined in its Miami Beach Rising Above living-with-water for the program.Investing in climate adaptation infra- communications and proactively preparing for a changing structure to protect against flooding is critical for the city's climate and the related impacts. near-term and long-term future.In light of current and growing risks,the program needs to continue to innovate, The panel developed the following guiding principles to and by maintaining this urgency,Miami Beach will continue advance future stormwater management and resilience to be in the lead compared to its fellow at-risk coastal work.These principles are relevant to all of the recommen- communities. dations in this report. Maintaining Urgency Using Incrementalism—Phases and Evaluation Miami Beach began its stormwater management and Resilience entails both being ready to bounce back climate adaptation strategy with unusual speed and a"get after a shock event and being able to regularly adjust it done"attitude.As the program evolves,future phases and recalibrate to changing environmental,social,and should strive to be more transparent and collaborative with economic conditions.It is important that the city has residents while maintaining the initial sense of urgency set implemented the first crucial resilience strategy phase and is evaluating it. Launch Preliminary Resilience Meeting Assessment+ Discovery Areas PHASE I GM&B il INSTITUTIONALIZE PHASE II STRATEGYRESILIENCEAND IMPLEMENT The delivery plan for the Greater Miami and the W Beaches Resilience Strategy I includes a variety of strategies Agenda-Setting Discovery Area Opportunity for community involvement, Workshop Analysis Assessment 8 assessment,and analysis. Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1132 of 1637 15 explaining the technologies the city has put in place to address flooding.All stakeholders need more information 0 \v. •>:' f on the larger vision of risks and solutions and the costs le:;` ..:, �, and benefits of the proposed interventions,as well as the 4+r : 4' �; . f :41, expected timeline of various investments and the basic t-`.`4%,,e ,��. t ' science behind the plans. Materials should also give \- '.1:1;471& r'..f,,' f ',44;4, comparative context for what Miami Beach's future would Maintaining the quality of s 'r- .0. ,�t 5 t be if proactive adaptation were not carried out. Biscayne Bay is critical for the o X#113`�>{v., 0i .! it- sustainability of both the city3 fi �� ,� ' �y� ti,t ": � %4Ie '• 7� Residents and businesses should also be presented with and its surrounding ecosystems. o .iro�s '' . ` ruiTt clear information on how to adapt properties as well as given toolkits on likely costs and strategies to invest in Moving forward,the stormwater management plan must climate adaptation at the scale of the single-family home be designed for incremental evaluation and change to and large and small-scale multifamily buildings.Although respond to the availability of new technologies,data sets, the local government can provide some of these resources and economic and physical realities.A key new technol and collateral information on how to adapt private property ogy may be the addition to the city's tool set of a physical at the building level,this is also an opportunity for private model that,for instance,helps identify the best solutions sector leadership from the design,real estate,and building and define benefits for the riskiest areas,which is explored technology sectors. in more detail in the"Infrastructure"section of this report. Inaddition,the financial and regulatory markets are Technologies and strategies in use should be regularly becoming more and more sophisticated about the physical evaluated and modified in a continuous improvement impacts of climate change;for instance, Moody's and process and considered against the principles described in Standard&Poor's investor services are including exposure this document.Moreover,a key aspect of incrementalism to climate hazards in their city bond credit evaluations. is offering opportunities for input from affected community Accordingly,Miami Beach needs to be forthright about members to ensure that all are part of the solution,which what scenarios of climate change suggest about its future is also a way to build transparency. exposure as well as about what changes it has already ob- served and how it is applying solutions to this knowledge. Ensuring Transparency Comparing itself to other coastal communities and sharing Initial stages of the stormwater management plan were information about the investments in adaptation the city swiftly implemented with some public presentations but has made will be crucial and can help the city differentiate relatively minimal opportunities for public input and corn- itself from competitors. ment—and without clear information about the costs and benefits.As a result,many residents deeply distrust the Respecting the City's Ecological flood-related decisions the city has made and feel unfairly Endowment inconvenienced or concerned about changes occurring near their properties.As the stormwater management plan Biscayne Bay is a precious resource for Miami Beach and advances and the city continues with its resilience plan, the whole region—and a shared responsibility for all of agencies must ensure a transparent process with robust Miami Dade County.The city's stormwater management two-way communications. plan must respect this tremendous natural capital. Ample collateral communications are currently prepared for Miami Beach has taken care to remove trash and sediments Miami Beach Rising Above,including excellent materials from the pump stations.However,with the introduction of 16 Page 1133 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report more pumps and generators,a risk exists that the quest r --- �-- •r i'... i` tib _ for peak-event preparedness eclipses the need for t ` fl • • f., sustainability and respectful use of natural resources. If _ I, . -" . �; 4 The stormwater management plan must recognize this ,,. . I. :, potential tension,ensure a commitment to the natural _ -,` environment,and communicate these values to residents, 14 --= who are currently concerned about this possibility.Ensur ing frequent monitoring,such as in-pump water quality r, - monitoring that is reported to the public in real time,will be ` ` _ 1 one aspect of the solution.Regional cooperation will also continue to be a part of the solution for enhanced water Complete street infrastructure, quality because 8,000 outfalls exist countywide. as seen here in Vancouver, and economic development goals.For example,raised British Columbia,could be streets represent the opportunity to implement complete integrated with planned Maintaining the ecological treasures of the area is not only road elevations tol maximize important because of residents'values:the beach and the streets investments such as bike lanes and improved the efficiency of the city's sidewalks,which are in line with the city's current Street infrastructure investments and ocean are the primary draw for Miami's many tourists and provide co-benefits. therefore represent an important component of economic Design Guide. development. Other co-benefits include decreased impacts from extreme storm events,faster rebounds for affected areas,improved Exercising Financial Pragmatism resident health because of more welcoming physical Miami Beach is admirably financing its stormwater spaces that encourage walkability and bikeability,more improvements without state and federal support through opportunities for public art,and reduced congestion due increased stormwater fees and the issuance of bonds.In to alternative transportation modes. future,the city should continue to self-finance,assuming that minimal support will be available from the federal and Prioritizing Social Equity state governments. Although Miami Beach is a very wealthy city overall,many The city would also be unwise to assume that federal households have significant needs:according to 2016 programs such as the National Flood Insurance Program U.S.Census Bureau figures, 16.7 percent of residents live (NFIP)will continue indefinitely,so Miami Beach should below the poverty line.The city needs to ensure that low be prepared for the impact on residents and the tax base income populations are given priority for investments in if NFIP were to change significantly.Miami Beach is lucky stormwater management because the most vulnerable are to have an extraordinarily strong tax base and economy, the least likely to have needed resources of their own. and it is far better placed than cities across the country to The city will also be a stronger and more resilient corn- finance the ambitious infrastructural improvements that munity when there are more housing options affordable for the island needs.Elements of the recommendations in this people at a range of income levels.Currently,50 percent report focus on maintaining this tax base to ensure the of renters are rent-burdened,and 38 percent of home- increasing funds that will be needed to enhance resilience. owners are house-burdened.A household is burdened if it pays more than 35 percent of its income on shelter. Recognizing Co-benefits In addition,the median income of$49,444 obscures the Investing in new stormwater infrastructure presents an inequality shown by the mean income,which jumps to opportunity to advance Miami Beach's other quality-of-life $95,728 because it accounts for the highest incomes.' Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1134 of 1637 17 Diversity,including income diversity and racial diversity, makes for culturally relevant and vibrant places and helps employers find candidates for a range of positions and ' needs.While the goal of enhancing affordable housing and income diversity reaches beyond the remit of a stormwater • . •, ,' t.management program,it is a critical goal to inform the 1�riri' t • city's broader resilience work. , I. _ Preserving Cultural Identity . - Miami Beach is known internationally for its distinctive art The idea of Iwfng with water could become part of Miami Beach's deco architecture,world-class beaches,and thriving arts branding in the future. scene, including Art Basel.These cultural characteristics feed thriving hotel,tourism,and restaurant industries and branding as well as its resilience and stormwater manage- drew 16 million people to the Greater Miami metropolitan ment strategies.More information on the appropriate area in 2016. technologies and the mindset of living with water are found The stormwater management and climate adaptation in the"Infrastructure"section of this report. strategy should strive to maintain this unique sense of place and build from it;even pumps and generators can be Taking a Long-Term and Regional made more aesthetically pleasing if designed in partner- Perspective ship with local artists.That being said,to adapt to the future,residents,businesses,and city stakeholders need The city of Miami Beach has made impressive invest to take a broader and more flexible view of what cultural ments in climate adaptation and stormwater manage and built identity comprises,rather than preserving the ment.Immediate, incremental investments in stormwater entire built environment exactly as is. management and climate adaptation are a good start,but more is needed to secure the city's long-term future,given flood vulnerability and both observed and predicted sea- Living with Water level rise.Building from initial efforts and taking a more Water has always been a key part of Miami Beach's holistic approach to adaptation that can be incrementally identity:the beautiful beaches and bay are cherished by evaluated and strengthened are critical.No matter what residents and draw visitors from around the world.Thanks climate change scenario one refers to,a consensus exists to the stormwater management and resilience work that the world's current population is enjoying a more already underway,the city is also a leader—regionally, stable climate than it will experience not only in the coming nationally,and increasingly globally—in adapting to rising decades,but also well into the next century. sea levels,king tides,and increased precipitation.The city has made significantly more progress than peer cities Taking this longer-term view,sharing it with residents,and around the world. encouraging other communities in the regional economy to do so should be part of the city's overall program of work. Now is the time to capitalize on this leadership as efforts Compared to the alternative lack-of-action scenario,the mature and climate-related coastal pressures grow for costs and inconveniences that lie ahead for Miami Beach people around the world."Living with water"could become should be understood in the context of the impact of grow- part of Miami Beach's tourism and economic development ing flood-related risks. 18 Page 1135 of 1637 A 1111 Advisory Services Panel Report Background SOUTH FLORIDA'S STORMWATER vulnerabilities start '°"' from the ground upward.The geology of south Florida is ""'""' fossilized coral limestone,which serves as the foundation __ " a ^n t,---4 ' for Miami Beach's road construction. Many of the streets ‹, '` in the city have about eight inches of crushed limestone 1 Y„�� '"-.' and asphalt topping.When water rises through this porous �_ '�""� ' II him ita:II limestone—whether caused by stormwater or high-tide events,such as the annual king tides—the limestone ele- fir a , ment experiences water cycling that degrades the struc- �;= . tural integrity of the base and shortens the lifespan of the + ` t I 9 Y P s,1. + I city's roads.Consequently,the city frequently experiences ' ries , :, flooding that significantly hampers accessibility during �` �~ y these high-tide and stormwater events. ► ?,,, !LIR. ; -1 • South Florida has experienced numerous peak events and storms over the years,which have led to local innovations 'am ;I in resilience and preparedness with global impact.De- — li OM a cades of crippling storms in the early 20th century led toy' the 1957 South Florida Building Code,which was adopted - ' '�"� F in Dade and Broward counties.Although the south Florida '.°'`,.! 1.1111411. � . code was strong, it had enforcement issues.After Hur- Nitio • ricane Andrew in 1992,Miami-Dade County implemented an unprecedented series of wind resilience codes as a reaction to the storm's widespread destruction.In addition, \ ,u/'' the county required licensure of building code enforcement '-4.11 1 Miami Beach's low elevation, i 4;•4:-:., < as shown on this map,is officials to amplify regulation.The policies were integrated �r one of its key vulnerabilities. into the Florida Building Code,approved in 2002,the J The bayfront coast is notably vulnerable. state's first overarching code.° ELEVATION Miami Beach Platted in a traditional grid,Miami Beach has a building typology that mixes residential,multifamily,commercial, oa:v hotel,and historic buildings.Each typology contributes financially to Miami Beach;taxes paid by residential,mul- tifamily,and commercial properties represent a significant portion of city revenue,while historic buildings are cultural assets that largely drive tourism investment in the region. Many of Miami Beach's buildings are likely to need to be Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1136 of 1637 19 SOUTH BEACH CROSS SECTION A Bay 5,dc Afton Road Mut.d.an Ave. Wast,mgton AW Oc on Dt Beech 2.40 11 2.51 ft 2.83 ft 4.74 ft • 5.11 ft 11.01 ft • • • n1 Over 20 percent of the to properties in Miami Beach r W r r ,1 1 � �� f' lie below 3.7 feet NAVD,and � 's 1° ; r t1 ,� 93 percent are within the 1 r i" 1'C 't' f f e e f 't( ` FEMA-designated Special Flood Hazard Area. adapted to remain resilient,but current regulations present As a result of the high property values,property taxes in significant challenges for city officials.Nearly 30 percent Miami Beach make up over half the operating budget,at of property located in Miami Beach sits within its historic 53 percent.The city's secondary revenue source is tour- districts.These properties in particular are at a greater ism,at 12 percent.The city has a$610.9 million operating risk of damage from sea-level rise;67 percent of those budget and a$59.8 million capital budget.In addition, properties are partially or fully at an elevation lower than the city's current bond ratings are stable and well rated 3.7 feet NAVD(North American Vertical Datum of 1988). across the board.The city's Stormwater Revenue Bonds As a whole,93 percent of Miami Beach properties are in of 2017 in the amount of$156.5 million were rated by the Special Flood Hazard Area. Moody's Investors Service as Aa3 with a"stable outlook" The city's assessed property value totals$37.4 billion, and by Standard&Poor's Financial Services as AA—with a"stable outlook." representing over 13 percent of the county's property values on only 0.4 percent of the land.However,this statistic obscures the fact that Miami Beach faces income inequality:the poverty rate is 16.7 percent.'Furthermore, the vast majority of the city's properties are insured under the National Flood Insurance Program.Any changes in the NFIP would therefore significantly impact Miami Beach because of the high level of coverage.One mitigation step Miami Beach has taken is joining and aggressively participating in the NFIP Community Rating System,which recognizes floodplain management strategies as a form of risk reduction.Through this program,residences and businesses save$6.5 million annually. 20 Page 1137 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report Current Stormwater Management Program MIAMI BEACH'S POROUS GEOLOGY and the threats of sea-level rise and regular sunny-day flooding present ` , existential threats,which are top of mind for many in the community.This section introduces Miami Beach's effortsw, to address stormwater management and tidal flooding,as ��, well as other relevant work led by the city.This high-level -• ! _ introduction summarizes information presented to panelists , 1° ' , at the beginning of the panel.More information can be ' _.i I found on the Miami Beach Rising Above website,www. _ . , �` 1 'F , mbrisingabove.com. ` 'i i. - ' -__ �° _ Miami Beach has had policies,plans,and infrastructure ,._ in place to address stormwater management since the : A` A''. . 'az, z 1990s.The program in effect today was kick-started in s• : lope \NNNo 2013,when the city began an aggressive stormwater plan Newly installed stormwater that identified its most at-risk neighborhoods and used a infrastructure can be seen here to 3.7 feet NAVD,and its approach was to identify the in Sunset Harbour. 30-year projection timeline for sea-level rise in an effort to city's most vulnerable areas and prioritize those regions identify a strategy going forward.Road elevation was a key successively. component of the new strategy.In simple terms,the city came to the decision on road elevations as follows: Since making these design decisions,the city has since observed 2.2 feet NAVD high-tide elevations in 2016 and • At the beginning of the stormwater management 2017,indicating that the earlier estimates are unlikely to program,Miami Beach officials identified that the mean be sufficient if trends continue,particularly for a 30-year high-water elevation figure being used to design new window. stormwater projects-0.6 feet NAVD—did not account for higher stormwater and tide events. As part of this effort,the city also made key improvements to existing stormwater management systems,effectively ■ To correct these measurements,the city assessed every implementing a road elevation strategy that retrofitted tidal event over the last several years and identified that existing or installed new pumps and treatment systems to the highest-elevation non-storm-related event occurred improve flooding and address water quality issues.These at 1.7 feet NAVD. updated pumps were installed with generators to prevent • Using that figure,the city created a 30-year planning overflow flooding during power outages.At the time,the horizon that accounted for a 12-inch projected increase city aimed to tackle the harmonization of private property in sea level,arriving at a base elevation of 2.7 feet with the elevated citywide pump infrastructure,but that NAVD.Under these guidelines,Miami Beach identified topic remains highly debated to this day. that the crown of area roads would need to be elevated Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1138 of 1637 21 r" Unified Sea level Rise Projection (Southeast Florida Regional Climate Change Compact,2015) 70 J u. I GO Year Median iARS USACE High NOAA High e'—' (inches) (inches) {inches) Y ,7 h c i 2030 6 10 12 E ° in 2060 14 26 34 2100 31 61 81 3; L r 2•" — c 20 5 " 147—.— The Southeast Florida Regional . . Climate Change Compact 10 iti!-w ,- 4M+/k4i..r s- i as iv.. •.� ""-. developed unified sea-level- ;:----- rise projections for the region _ --,"...- in 2015,which Miami Beach 1 u adopted for its planning 'a 1992 1000 20i0 2010 ?030 ?D40 1050 1I)w) 2070 l0ND 2090 ?IOD in 2016. 6 Year Policy Focusing initially on this component,the city passed a resolution to modify the design criteria for tailwater eleva- In 2013,the city began its most ambitious stormwater tion to 2.7 feet NAVD for all tidal boundary conditions.By management program yet,to tackle sunny day flood December 2014,the city was able to pass a resolution ing faster and more aggressively.The city committed to that raised the standard seawall height to 5.7 feet NAVD investing nearly$600 million to raise roads to a 3.7 foot with an additional cap of two feet,and this resolution was NAVD and improve stormwater drainage in the most subsequently amended in 2015 to require seawalls to be vulnerable areas:the plan projected that nearly 60 percent designed to reach 5.7 feet NAVD with an interim condition of Miami Beach—owned roads will be elevated to meet the of 4.0 feet NAVD in consideration of existing homes.In elevation goal of 3.7 feet NAVD. 2015,the city also approved the sale of over$100 million in stormwater bonds in an effort to finance the stormwater management program. ' ` '� In addition,the citymade strides in updating land use and • "'T '.■�. ' P 9 ; it� • "� development codes,establishing a minimum of one-foot P t , r.�- ;_ , and maximum of five-foot freeboard elevation for every -- "a - building in the city.Regulations pertaining to the calcula- tion of building height and minimum elevations of required f yards in single-family districts were also implemented o ♦ • :. `• under this plan.More recently,sea-level rise and resilience " •-- k;:.- criteria must be considered by the city's land use boards. Sunny-day flooding,pictured here near Washington Avenue in Miami In its initial effort,the city created a sequencing chart Beach,is a persistent threat that the stormwater management program seeks to address. laying out a capital improvement program by neighborhood with a funding timeline.This sequencing chart is based 22 Page 1139 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report upon identifying which neighborhoods are most vulnerable and also have neighborhood improvement projects already L.A. '. - underway.To finance this project,the city can bond$100 w 1 3 million per fee increase,with fees set at$7 per residential pori >,,• . ; d d ! unit per month.The city also received modified tax incre- M/ ment financing from the county. :�. �► .:it.. Miami Beach is installing a total of 42 monitoring wells in The current program has nested sets of three at 14 different locations throughout g installed new drainage pipes the city to develop a comprehensive groundwater program. throughout the city,such as �... o this one on Alton Road. This plan accounts for groundwater as a key component of flooding in the stormwater management master plan and considers its direct interaction with surface waters This creates a situation in which Miami Beach is maintain and sea-level-rise effects.The city has already completed ing both state and city pumps. substantial drainage and road elevation improvements to a number of vulnerable areas,and the plan provides Historic Preservation for flexibility among residents.For example,residents in Historic districts in Miami Beach are highly vulnerable lower-elevation areas are given the option of connecting and highly valuable.Most of the properties within these their storm drains into the citywide system,which has districts were built at low elevations,and design guidelines achieved 50 percent resident buy-in. have yet to adapt for sea-level rise.Moreover,the city takes a district versus individual property approach to his- Water Quality toric preservation;rather than identifying a neighborhood's As one of 30 permitted entities to discharge stormwater most important buildings,the Historic Preservation Ordi in Miami-Dade County,Miami Beach manages 4 percent nance designates an entire neighborhood as a protected of the 8,000 outfalls within the county.As part of the district,applying stringent design and build regulations city's stormwater master plan,officials set out to improve to properties located within that district.Miami Beach its discharge management to prevent trash and sediment currently has 14 historic districts,with over 44 percent of from being discharged into waters.Streets are swept daily, assessed property value found within a historic district. removing 450,000 pounds of material that would have Currently,the city is upgrading existing guidelines to better eventually flowed into the bay.Miami Beach has upgraded adapt historic buildings for sea-level rise.The city is retain- its pump station maintenance so that refuse is being dis- ing an architectural firm to lead a team with experience posed of properly.The city uses a vacuum truck to extract in historic guidelines,urban planning,and climate change and discharge large trash and sedimentation at a regional and is considering tangible ways to adaptively use building landfill,with some city pumps being cleaned as frequently first floors,given their flood vulnerability. as every week.Nonetheless,the city receives frequent expressions of concern and criticism from residents who Environmental Resources and believe the drainage pumps are contaminating the bay. Green Infrastructure Further complicating the issue is that several of the city's Enhancing and using natural resources is a critical com- pump systems are managed by the state,and the city fre- ponent of Miami Beach's resilience strategy and broader quently interfaces with state officials who put the burden work in planning policy.Potential exists for natural resources of proper disposal of their state-owned pumps on the city. Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1140 of 1637 23 1it s "!'p'' ' t g e1 a . ,,,. ,1::. , ... . i •If; x`h. i area I. itt —!........,,..,....., ...e.„„A.1.. .. ., 11/2., :. .-7 .„ . . „..,: Miami-Dade County Beach `i.'4‘,,°'..4,4,_ * ) 4,r ., j, Erosion Control and Hurricane ., ; ,' Surge Protection Project .. 1):t • deposited 18,500 truck-hauls I, 4 ' M rt y of sand in Miami Beach in a }+..'- . . t y. 2016 alone.Depicted are the m ' + "s' A"i beach before(left)and after - -f1: the protection project. o to play a more prominent role in the city's stormwater ■ In partnership with the Florida Department of Trans- management strategy and urban design aesthetic. portation,the city is currently upgrading the storm- water system and elevating Indian Creek Drive.This Current environmental resources and sustainability prof project will protect a hurricane evacuation route from ects underway include the following: tidal flooding and improve water quality going into the Environmental resources adjacent Indian Creek Waterway,which is part of the • The Miami-Dade County Beach Erosion Control and Biscayne Bay aquatic preserve.To enhance this project, Hurricane Surge Protection Project has been ongoing the city is proposing the first in water hybrid shoreline since the 1970s.It provides storm protection and ero that includes a mangrove planter waterward of a new sion control and a variety of environmental,recreational, elevated seawall. and economic co-benefits. • Farther north,the Brittany Bay Park shoreline project ■ In 2015,the city of Miami Beach established a citywide has been redesigned to incorporate mangrove and wet- Coastal Dune Management Plan to outline the frame land species by pulling the seawall into the park to cre work and specifications the city will use to foster and ate a living shoreline inside the existing park footprint. maintain a healthy,stable,and natural dune system.As This project includes a walkway and waterway overlooks a result of the plan,the dune system successfully pro to connect the public with the natural environment. tected the city from storm surge and substantial sand ■ The Muss Park Seawall Enhancement project included loss,demonstrating the value of natural infrastructure the construction of a seawall,designed strategically to in resilience. protect existing mangroves that had naturally recruited 24 Page 1141 of 1637 A Ull Advisory Services Panel Report along the shoreline.This project pulled the seawall Environmental Design(LEED)Gold certification or Living back into the park around the mangrove and created Building Challenge certification for new construction additional space to plant more red mangroves. over 7,000 square feet or ground-floor additions to existing structures that encompass over 10,000 square • The beachwalk corridor is an alternative transportation feet of additional floor area.If an applicant chooses not pathway that will connect the city north—south from to pursue green building certification,it is required to Government Cut to 87th Terrace.Through the imple- mentation of the beachwalk,the city has been able to pay a percentage of its construction valuation into a sustainability fund that will be used for environmental expand its alternative transportation network while also and sustainability related public improvements. reinforcing the adjacent coastal dune system. • The city is focusing on green infrastructure as an in- ■ Miami Beach's transportation master plan prioritizes pe novative approach to resilience.However,because of destrians and emphasizes that trees enhance walkabil- the existing regulatory requirements,the city notes that ity.The city has completed a GIS inventory of all trees in gray infrastructure is easier to build and finance.City parks and public rights-of-way and is currently seeking officials are working closely with regulatory agencies to proposals to develop a street tree management plan. overcome challenges to the implementation of green • In 2015,the city established a Tree Preservation infrastructure and are seeking grant and nontraditional Program to permit the removal of trees on public and funding to realize these projects. private property.Applicants are required to mitigate tree canopy lost through replanting or contributing to the Communications Tree Preservation Trust Fund. The city of Miami Beach has implemented a communi- Sustainability cation strategy for Miami Beach Rising Above intended • In 2015,the city completed its first greenhouse gas to inform residents of its progress on overall resilience inventory that included assessment of government planning efforts.The city regularly shares key information operations and community-wide emissions.The built on its stormwater and flooding challenges and plans and is environment is the largest source of greenhouse gas correctly focusing on reaching all stakeholders in the city. emissions.In 2016,the city passed a green build These methods include the following: ing ordinance that requires Leadership in Energy and • • t fi Ups• Y • WI ('0L 4 4 The Brittany Bay Park project „<1 m will create a living shoreline r �� _ that includes walkways and 1"4overlooks for members of the 2, public to enjoy. Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1142 of 1637 25 4 Neighborhood Case Studies Miami Beach's sequencing model approach has been 'm implemented in key areas across the city.In an effort to help panelists understand firsthand how these improve- ments have been carried out,city staff led tours for panel- ists to key areas at various stages of investment,including r A those described in the following sections. The Miami Beach Rising Above , website is a central resource a = -- r = � Sunset Harbour for sharing Miami Beach's ; climate adaptation research, 1 The Sunset Harbour area of Miami Beach was once planning,and opportunities 6 d for involvement a plagued by intense flooding during high-tide and storm- water events.As the area began to grow commercially, • Regular communications in the city's printed magazines the city realized that a substantial road elevation project for residents; would need to be implemented to protect those assets. The result includes one of the city's most ambitious road • Hosting community meetings throughout the city's elevation projects and a buzzing commercial area.The city neighborhoods; anticipates that private infrastructure will adapt incremen- ■ Strong engagement on social media channels;and tally along with its own public infrastructure plan. ■ The city's Rising Above website,which is the corner- Dade Boulevard,the main thoroughfare running through stone of this effort and includes critical information Sunset Harbour,was raised about 30 inches,with a new regarding the Miami Beach Rising Above program. pump station installed along the canal that runs parallel to Residents and business owners can log in and obtain the street.Roads in Sunset Harbour were also raised,and specific information about their properties,read about split-level sidewalks were installed to alleviate flooding for the scientific reports that have led the city to adopt businesses that have yet to raise their structures.As de- these resolutions, use an innovative adaptation calcula signed,higher elevation sidewalks spill excess water into Sunset Harbour, which was tor,and sign upfor updates on public meetings the street drainage,whereas their lower counterparts have a pilot site for shay receerntly g g separate drains that have been installed to absorb overflow improvements,has recently seen town hall sessions. sustantialcommercial growth and protect commercial properties from flooding.The city and new development notes that removing street parking was integral to complet- ., liftik �. ,,,M ing this project.Now,most visitors to Sunset Harbour park --`.ti , f ';it, - ' ",tin one of two parking garages located in the area. 1 1. E ;1 • * i .1; � `'', ' y.; '+ ' —-.•-- A recent storm event led the city to make upgrades to ,,, = the generator systems powering the pumps within Sunset ---- -- ‘-'1.2', r- =rte . I Harbour.Formerly,the pumps relied on power from Florida i. ..„. . .`!+ .t{ '7. = - . Power&Light,one of the largest electrical companies in �. �y •.;x .44 --.�- --� — " , Florida.If a storm event caused a power outage,then the �., , w : pumps would be unable to run.Instead,the city installed a permanent generator and is currently considering beautifi- 1 Th , mils-4,1•4:. - cation improvements to these pump stations. 26 Page 1143 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report t� A iDR1VEkS-• • Sunset Harbour, • Sunset Harbour, • Elevated Streets Miami Beach Miami Beach • Improved • Sunny Day Stormwater System Flooding • low Elevation • Enhanced Pedestrian Access • Low Percentage cr4, The Sunset Harbour elevation Tree Canopy • Green Infrastructure project incorporates resilience drivers to respond to local 5 shocks and stresses. Palm and Hibiscus Islands bilitation,relining of pipes,and replacement of lateral con- Palm and Hibiscus Islands represent one of the residential nections.In addition to upgrading the stormwater system, areas with the highest land values in Miami Beach and a the city is installing a pedestrian lighting system on the key part of the city's tax base.The islands have under- islands and will underground franchise utilities on Hibiscus gone substantial neighborhood improvements and boast Island.The overhead-to-underground utility conversions some of the most engaged and active residents in the city. have been a point of contention among city residents. Debates on recent projects have been vigorous and can delay construction. Miami Beach Convention Center The epicenter of economic impact in Miami Beach,the In addition to roadway elevation,the city has installed yard Miami Beach Convention Center was long slated for drains to which property owners can connect their drain renovation and improvement.Comprising 25 acres in pipes in an effort to communally manage runoff.Other the center of Miami Beach,the new Convention Center infrastructure improvements include sanitary sewer reha- project master plan incorporates two new public parks and increases green space by 12 acres.The Convention Center is a$620 million project being referred to as the city's r ., ,- new civic heart because a six-acre public park is being •> .�~ ' constructed in the center,surrounded by several existing t ►�� "- and important public spaces,the Holocaust Memorial,and • l !w the Botanical Garden as well as the existing City Hall.The % building was also required to remain open to support major • ' ' economic drivers such as Art Basel Miami Beach. rt5 ` " The Convention Center site is also the location of two of Miami Beach's largest pump stations and is therefore a significant component of the city's overall stormwater plan. The pumps located on the Convention Center campus Hibiscus island is a manmade island in Biscayne Bay with highly desirable property. will interconnect runoff from two separate and adjacent Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1144 of 1637 27 mahogany trees will be installed along the Dade canal to create a living shoreline,and a new 3.5-acre open space •i i , , iiiiii 4 will include bicycle paths,public art,and restoration of 11/ the oldest public building in Miami Beach,the historic Carl ( rr Fisher Clubhouse. Ns ' • Renovation of the Convention Center was designed on a - 30-year time frame for resilience,and all critical emergen- 5 4 cy systems and generators have been raised to the second .' --- T `j floor of the building,23 feet above sea level.Approached + incrementally,the renovation of the Convention Center was designed to enhance residents'quality of life while sustain- ing and facilitating continued tourism investment. The Miami Beach Convention Center was $620 million neighborhoods and drain the entire area reachingup to Flamingo Park Historic District renovation on a 25-acre site in g 9 the heart of the city. Lincoln Road,a popular tourist spot.In this area,roads Located in the heart of South Beach,the Flamingo Park were elevated to 6.1 feet NAVD,and the building was Historic District embodies a variety of architectural styles raised by four inches to meet current FEMA flood elevation and is greatly admired by preservationists.The western requirements,although officials note the building could portion of the area sits at an extremely low elevation,and have been raised more if not for the city's requirement much of the area's prewar and early postwar construction to remain open throughout the three-year construction make road elevation and adaptable use quite challenging. period.In response to water contamination issues,the However,some progress has been made,and recently a pump stations include measures such as vortex treatment raised street elevation was completed for 11th Street to systems for stormwater quality.The design for the area will the immediate east and west of Meridian Avenue,one of increase the pervious area by 245 percent. Mangroves and i te;11 r R ----H---.7-- I 4.41 ',._- \ v L....i I MIL * IIII The Convention Center renovation , •o V" . incorporated Me public parks,a 1 «r _ • living shoreline,and two of the ; S s ��,.. city's largest pump stations. Q',r 4y- 28 Page 1145 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report Ale ori.1.i _ „........;.4:;,--;...r ,_IL,„,,,,,„:.:.,„,-_,.. .,,,,,...,,,,,,��. ' s• '3t ri p er . lei r�f~+i�I elf Mr! `';. cy • A � •°.�.ui�G�tt,�hill rill ritospr ' ' • ; :b. , u�., • '- "i -Y d!I Mi ■J I A �}s I - 21 eV fi^ wri �r d � � e° MiiiiWir r.' +tJ a E .4t:... w w • �`1 ,�~ North Beach,as seen here in . , iv j a 2008,is considered a prime ' i 1 area for future development ' . : ",„,, .. - Ili 9 opportunities. the district's main thoroughfares.The city also elevated ments to promote walkability:updated mobility schemes, the sidewalk and proposed that property owners raise their reimagined height and density designations,and wider front yards to accommodate the elevation increase. sidewalks. The city recognizes that many of its efforts within the Within North Beach lies the Tatum Waterway,one of the Flamingo Park Historic District are innovative,but a climate city's poorest neighborhoods,that sits on one of the lowest adaptation plan is likely to require the raising of historic base elevations in Miami Beach.During high-tide events, buildings,which is extremely costly and challenging to bay water overflow is severe.As a result,the city installed execute under current guidelines.Moreover,the placement one of its first pump stations in this neighborhood,using of stormwater infrastructure in the area,such as pumps an axial flow pump system instead of a submersible pump, or generators,requires review by the historic preservation while incorporating plants for beautification.Because board.In addition to reformulating the historic preserva- seawall overflow is a significant issue here,the city must tion ordinance,city officials are considering new methods determine whether a mandatory assessment is needed to for maintaining this district,such as the installation of a raise private seawalls throughout the area. mature tree canopy. The following sections of the report discuss the panel's Tatum Waterway and the North Beach recommendations regarding individual elements of an Master Plan integrated solution for future stormwater management and As one of the last remaining development frontiers in resilience work. Miami Beach,North Beach is poised for a major redevel- opment that incorporates many neighborhood improve- Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1146 of 1637 29 Infrastructure MIAMI BEACH HAS MADE A COURAGEOUS START Current flood management practice is rightly focused on to combat sunny-day flooding and stormwater through its alleviating flooding as a whole and clearing the surface existing stormwater management program.The city should water as efficiently as possible.However,future holistic be commended for its timely action, investment in physical flood risk management should differentiate contributions infrastructure,identification of self-funding sources for from the three discrete sources,understand how each physical infrastructure to address flooding,decision to in- source influences the others,and strategize accordingly. clude sea-level rise and increased precipitation in planning, Any strategy should include increased collaboration with and close collaboration with the Southeast Florida Regional the local community and education about the mechanics of Climate Compact and the regional participants in the 100 flooding and how the city's infrastructure investments are Resilient Cities initiative. addressing existing and future risk.In addition,all invest- ments should seek to serve multiple purposes to achieve However,Miami Beach is significantly at risk,so more the highest possible benefit/cost ratios and maximize infrastructural advancement and investment are necessary. ownership and support from the citizens,companies,and The city is vulnerable to three distinct sources of flooding: organizations in the city. is Coastal flooding including king tides; To build a more holistic strategy and increase the city's ■ Flooding caused by rainfall;and preparedness for the increasingly severe impacts of climate change,the city should strive to incorporate the • Flooding from groundwater. following recommendations: • Improve the flexibility and robustness of the current system. 40 i '.. ice' b ti ! : ■ Enable more informed decision making and risk man- M agement through enhanced modeling. 5 \tom �• ,� -. -...� �� ax 1 ■ Implement blue and green infrastructure to advance Miami Beach's investment in stormwater infrastructure can x - f .: a more integrated and holistic approach to living be seen throughout the city in _ with water. its new,elevated pumps. ■ Ensure appropriate modeling,study,and funding avail- '1 ability for green and blue infrastructure projects. ■ Implement living-with-water pilot projects. .- }' ` �.L• • Create tools and highlight o opportunities for living-with- �. PP Sunny day flooding is a • water projects at the building level. common problem;here,Brickell ,„ _ Bay Drive,in nearby Miami, flooded during a normal high ;r ' • • Consider a level-of-service(LOS)concept to guide tide in 2016. future decision making. 30 Page 1147 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report • Address water quality concerns. Improve Flexibility and Robustness ■ Improve communications about and education on engi- of Current System neering and infrastructural solutions. The city's current plan for stormwater infrastructure, More information about all of these recommendations including pumps and elevated streets,is well tested and follows,starting with recommendations related to the two thoroughly designed but lacks flexibility—the system is not primary elements of the city's current approach—flood- designed to adapt.This lack of flexibility is the Achilles's water pumps and elevated roads—and moving to new heel of the current system.Indeed,the system is costly to options informed by a robust optimization model. install,operate,and maintain and is—at this stage—not Green and Blue Infrastructure Green and blue infrastructure are approaches to water •,t ,,,. management that incorporate natural processes to l manage and treat water.Rather than speeding water 'li`.-f r`_ �r :... '-, underground or away from a site or road,green and �` t ' .'h . , .%:..::.,. _e blue infrastructure slow water down and integrate it into i• natural systems,often conveying it and treating it through k,i', ''' '� . . .'i t. '! ' landscape amenities. o These terms can refer to a wide variety of different Planting of mangrove trees is a green infrastructure strategy processes and approaches at the site or regional scales that can provide protection from storm surge while enhancing the that can function in many different climates and habitats. biodiversity of the ecosystem. IN Green infrastructure manages water through natural • Blue infrastructure works with the natural hydraulics processes,slowing water to be absorbed and filtered of the aquifer and can refer to new canals,wetlands, through a combination of vegetation and soils. and retention on urban plazas and other public facilities Approaches include living shorelines,mangrove managing water during extreme rain events. plantings,rain gardens,bioswales,cisterns,and many other technologies that can be implemented At the scale of a real estate project,green infrastructure independently or together in a"rain chain,"funneling may refer to design features that will capture and slow the water from one source to another. release of water after routine and peak rain events.Green infrastructure may also refer to public works projects EA 4c implementing landscape systems in parks,rights-of-way, ',. , j' I` j 4,1101g and elsewhere to create a community-wide or citywide ;4 :p • etcq `a j network for water conveyance. f �`� ,: Green and blue types of technologies have many 1 1 benefits compared to traditional gray infrastructure such 4 ,,. as pumps and pipes:the former are more affordable, offer opportunities for enhanced green space,can be • implemented incrementally,and have public health ' benefits.Cited benefits of green and blue infrastructure A• have included improved water quality,reduced water use, o „�.'.<''. flood risk mitigation,improved wildlife habitat,enhanced A rain garden acts as a sponge,helping water permeate the real estate value,enhanced recreational spaces,cost ground naturally while also nurturing the landscaped plants. savings,and opportunities for green jobs. Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1148 of 1637 31 completely guaranteed to function during all peak events First and foremost,the current stand-alone pump and pipe because of reliance on a generator-backed power system. solutions are not particularly flexible to changes in bound- Not all pumps are backed by standby generators,and even ary conditions,power outages,and exceeding of design these will not necessarily provide sufficient robustness. criteria.Opportunities to improve include the following: Nor does the system provide ample collateral benefits to the local community. • Implement storage volume upstream to retain runoff and reduce peaks at pumping stations;for example, Furthermore,how long the system will continue to function use storage in public parks,porous sub-base of roads, well is unclear,taking into account development in climate private cisterns,swales,and tree strips,many of which change projections,maintenance of systems,and so on. can be implemented with green and blue infrastructure. Going forward,the city should identify a broader range of ■ Improve design and increase capacity of gravitational strategies,including blue infrastructure,green infra- overflows from pump stations by installing flap weirs structure,and seawall improvements,together with its designed to extreme events. committed pumping systems and elevated streets,to both introduce more flexibility in managing water and offer more • Implement a monitoring system for tracking infiltration visible collateral benefits to the local community. to pipe systems(and for calibration of hydraulic models). The city should consider implementing electrical and infrastructure enhancements to mitigate extreme weather, Trends in Hydraulic Design to supplement a generator-backed pump system that presents issues with power backup supplies.The system The hydraulic design of drainage systems is linked with many uncertainties,especially considering the life also needs to be"safe to fail,"allowing controlled flooding span of the structures.These uncertainties should in the case of some extreme events. be addressed in a structured way split topic by topic. Street elevation is another key component of the city's Opportunities to improve include integrating the following: current strategy.Raised land has been a tested success- • Factors to accommodate for increase in extreme ful solution to alleviate tidal flooding in new development precipitation caused by climate change during and,to a lesser extent,in retrofit solutions.Where street the lifetime of the pipes:these factors should be derived using the most updated data and provide elevations are determined to be the best flood mitigation recommendations for a factor for design criteria solution,the city could improve and further optimize this and for stress test(this would often be a factor strategy to local areas with more information on geology 1.2-1.4 for design criteria rainfalls and as much and groundwater,which is explored further in an upcoming as 1.8 for the extreme rainfalls—corresponding to section on modeling.Opportunities to improve include the an expected increase in rain intensity of 20 to 80 following: percent,depending on return period); ■ Factors to accommodate for building out and • Revisit the criteria and time span for the solution densification on private and public property 1.0-1.2, (through community and risk modeling,explored in a which is directly related to the ongoing trend to pave subsequent section). and build and to connect more impervious areas to the drainage system;and • Better understand the context with groundwater and the aquifer. ■ Factors to accommodate for general uncertainties in model and rain statistics 1.2-1.3(uncertainties on ■ Explore solutions related to porous geology. dimensions,levels,state of repair). 32 Page 1149 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report I oar# ■ Precipitation;and .- . , um s III : licate.However,the city will need to develop staff capacity The city currently has a pipe-network model that allows it to make the best and most efficient use of such a tool and to simulate the hydraulic load in the drainage systems and will require external expertise to procure technology. on the pumps during heavy rainfalls.In addition,the city is logging water levels and groundwater tables in boreholes. Any flood mitigation could be input into this tool, including These assumptions and others relevant to the feasibility of pumps as well as green and blue infrastructure,the results a model include the following: simulated,and the benefits of this action would be clearly quantified.These quantified benefits could then be compared ■ The city's pipe network is currently about 90 percent with the costs to implement and thus enable informed modeled and can be exported. economic choices about the city's future.Importantly,this tool would allow the city to clearly quantify and communi • Geology can be modeled as an equivalent porous cate the outcomes of any chosen mitigation action. medium,and an additional geophysical survey will take place at project level. In addition to the flood risk calculation tool,the city can calculate the value of the co-benefits and build the business • Digital elevation is mapped in a detailed DEM(in grid case on a complete cost/benefit analysis.A clear cost/ cells about four feet by four feet). benefit analysis is an important tool for decision making, • Logging of groundwater and water level in the bay is and this integrated water model is the best possible way to continuing. simulate current and future conditions,and directly quantify the benefits expected from any given mitigation action. ■ Five to eight rain gauges will be installed close to exist ing SCADA(Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition) points for calibration. Digital Elevation Models ■ Eight clamp-on meters or channel-flow meters will be A digital elevation model(DEM)is a digital three- rented and installed for a six-to eight-month period. dimensional elevation model that shows the terrain's As a next step,the city should couple the pipe-network surface.These can sometimes be referred to as digital terrain models or digital surface models.Digital surface model with a digital elevation and groundwater model models,however,usually include the objects on the to make more informed decisions regarding flood risks. land,such as buildings or trees.They are most often This digital model would function as a comprehensive created using satellites,radar,remote sensing,or other simulation incorporating physics related to groundwater aerial techniques instead of by direct physical survey.A and stormwater levels,which would allow the city to DEM is the foundation of most hydrological models for flooding and drainage,and accurate modeling depends quantify and compare risk when making decisions related on its quality. to resilience.An integrated model of digital elevation of this nature would require a geophysical survey of parts of the The quality of a DEM is ultimately determined by the island,but its implementation is relatively cost-effective, scale and type of survey technique.A model that is more detailed,and uses newer technology,will be fairly easy to execute,and can be carried out and imple- considered more useful and accurate.However,such mented in the model over time,for example,when detailed models are more expensive to survey,and the file sizes information is required in relation to detailed design on are more difficult to manage. project level. 34 Page 1151 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report Established computer programs could independently After procuring and implementing this digital model,the model these scenarios.To begin work implementing a city of Miami Beach could then make informed decisions model,the city would likely require both the purchase of (risk/benefit-based management)regarding flood protec- modeling software(which would represent both a fixed tion strategies.A more comprehensive model would do upfront cost and an ongoing license and maintenance fee) the following: and a separate engagement of consulting expertise to build,calibrate,and verify the model. • Calculate risk for various impacts,such as different types of storm conditions or volumes of rainfall or levels Engagement of a third party to provide quality control of king tides; review of the model is also recommended.The city might consider engaging a consultant to serve as an owner's • Enable the city to be more informed before investing in representative during the procurement process for identify- specific civil works actions,such as raising a seawall, ing both the model and the associated consulting services. implementing more pumps,or building more blue/green This engagement would be similar to the common practice infrastructure; of hiring someone in this role to oversee large construction ■ Help formulate optimal socioeconomic protection levels projects on behalf of a government owner. and define collateral benefits; This owner's representative should have technical knowl- • Work in"safe-to-fail"limits to infrastructure,allowing edge of complex,integrated hydraulic modeling and provide for effects of extreme events; the city with the expertise to parse and compare the proposed products and consultants'proposals.This owner's • Create safer guidelines for densification,climate representative may possibly be able to provide the third- change,system data,and rain statistics;and party quality review but is not required to have this capacity. • Allow flexibility for climate change,system data,and Over the medium to long term,the city should consider rain statistics. adding a member of staff,such as a"flood risk model As an example,if the city could create large-scale reten- manager"position,to monitor the city's use of the tool. tion in park areas,thereby reducing the flood risk further The flood risk model manager would track use of the downstream,the model would be able to predict the model,ensure that the information is up to date,and benefit/cost ratio of such an investment,including the become the city's in-house"guru"on the tool.Many following elements: members of staff should be literate and comfortable with the tool and be able to input scenarios for modeling and • Capital and operational expenditures; subsequent decision making. ■ Reduced damages; The end goal is a model that accurately represents the • Reduced investments in underground infrastructure;and interplay among the coastal,precipitation,and ground- water flooding sources,as well as the ground elevations, ■ Co-benefits in terms of health effects,increased prop- pipe networks,pump facilities,and land use throughout erty value,and so on. the entire city.It will be an accurate digital model of the city,which can be used to simulate any flood mitigation Another scenario would be to model reduced saltwater proposal under consideration. flooding.Under a given management scenario,it would be possible to eliminate sunny-day flooding caused by upwell- ing of groundwater during high tides.But what would the Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1152 of 1637 35 Iterative process A �, 1 2 3 4 uj DEIRISK'NEERM ) KDESIGN I EF ECTPLAN& jE ANALYZE $BENEFITS N V) FLOOD MODELING INTEGRATED FLOOD MODELING CAPITAL COST AND J MIKE Urban.MIKE PLANNING&DESIGN MIKE Urban,MIKE OPERATION OVER TIME O Food and MIKE 21 Adobe and CAD Flood and MIKE ZI Excel O RISK MAPPING COST-INVESTMENT RISK MAPPING AVOIDED DAMAGES AND FME and CADSS Excel FME and CADSS CO-BENEFITS OVER TIME Excel th '. r .., 111 4 4 '^ TIME W l s , . •', - 4 t 4 r 1. The modeling process requires a layered approach 3 ,,. . _ - __ _ _ _ in terms of both programs TWE and iterative steps. * \. ...1 \.. _ _' ~ �J \ J \ optimum mix of street elevation and pump capacity be now Implement Blue and Green and in the future?With this tool and updated climate sce- Infrastructure narios,the city could accurately simulate all three sources of flooding in the city,answering these vital questions. With the knowledge of an enhanced hydraulic model,the city can better explore a more diverse array of options Building and using the model is likely to take a year or so. for flood mitigation from all three flooding sources.Green The city's ongoing use and upkeep of the model would and blue infrastructure will be key options to explore and include keeping the model calibrated by monitoring flow integrate into the current strategy,particularly given the rates and levels in pump stations and selected manholes. opportunities for co-benefits. Broadening Miami Beach's strategy beyond pumps and -# _:1 ' ' I. street elevation to integrate green and blue infrastructure ... and other innovations in resilience could lead Miami Beach + to become a worldwide model of living with water.With this approach,resilient infrastructure should not only clear water away during tidal flooding and peak rain events but --Y also identify opportunities to improve quality of life through Vie. - _,,;;• , _ vibrant public spaces,water features,and water recycling. i§ ;, '' , . a.)- Blue and green infrastructure should be key components 3> ' of this strategy and offer many opportunities for co- Planting mangroves is a natural o J benefits related to public space,aesthetics,water quality, way to protect the shoreline. eg and recreation. 36 Page 1153 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report The city should consider the following strategies: • Changes in land use to allow more of the preceding options. • Living shorelines; A more integrated living-with-water approach will not only ■ Mangrove plantings; include the incorporation of more types of flood mitigation ■ Rain gardens and bioswales; infrastructure,but will also require more structured col- laboration and potential cofunding of infrastructural invest- s Porous pavement; ments across city departments.Strategies to introduce this • Cisterns; type of interagency planning could include the following: • Tree strips and cells; ■ Ensure fluency with the outputs of the hydraulic model and the opportunities for better understanding the ■ Multifunctional use of parks and plazas;and impact of different flood mitigation mechanisms and Living with Water: New Technologies, Attitudes, and Design Aesthetics Miami Beach has the opportunity to be a world leader If implemented successfully,living with water could be in the concept of living with water.This theme could more than an infrastructural approach and become part be a core component of the stormwater management of Miami Beach's tourism and economic development and resilience strategies,as well as the city's economic branding.For instance,tourists could come to Miami ready development,tourism,and placemaking strategies.The to ride amphibious vehicles or tour newly implemented approach entails not only the use of different technologies natural coastlines and mangroves;small businesses to manage water,but also different attitudes about interested in climate adaptation would relocate here to convenience,mobility,health,and aesthetics.Notably, find peers and clustered work environments for climate living with water would entail embracing green and blue technology and green infrastructure.However,to ensure infrastructure that can manage water using natural that the city maintains this resilience leadership,prioritizing systems. the minimization of greenhouse gas emissions from fossil fuels in the stormwater and flood resilience solutions The visual effects of blue and green infrastructure are implemented will also be key to maintaining a reputation as very different from pumps or pipes that send influxes of a climate leader. water out of sight and out of mind.Adopting a living-with- water approach would therefore require that Miami Beach residents,businesses,and stakeholders change some of a their comfort levels about ponding,minor flooding,and - , � visibility of water in the public realm.Notably,water is likely ``•4,, ' I! , . to be more visible after storm events and take longer to subside.Aesthetics are also different:instead of monotone - A, ,t:.. ° ;M '4 r manicured lawns,a green infrastructure palette typically .'_(�, . , sT includes more wild-looking native plants that can,although - . will not necessarily always,look unkempt when they are ,:. t 5. at peak ecological function.These plantings can be part ' ‘''''''C:04..2.1). ' ''of beautifully textured compositions that would contribute :, ; infrastructural cost/benefit analysis across different Implement Living-with-Water agencies. Pilot Projects ■ Prepare two or three integrated/interagency master Miami Beach should create iconic pilot projects that involve plans per district,developed through charrettes with the community to determine the best future approaches communities and agencies. for resilience and to test and explore the living-with-water • Integrate stormwater master plans at the highest level of concepts.These pilot projects should represent exciting city planning to ensure harvesting of budget synergies opportunities to both enhance resilience and introduce with other investment plans and projects and the least co-benefits related to green infrastructure,public space, possible nuisance for the citizens. and quality of life.Pilot projects are excellent opportunities for community engagement and for broadening public • Build the clear business case based on the cost of doing understanding of the goals of the stormwater management nothing,the traditional solution,and the living-with- program. water approach,generating co-benefits that in many cases exceed the reduced damages and other tangible Communities in Miami Beach that experienced the first outcomes. phases of stormwater investment were complimentary about how the program has improved sunny-day flooding • Invest in high-quality pilot projects to generate enthusi- and eliminated the many related inconveniences they once asm and ownership of the living-with-water concept. experienced on a regular basis.However,these same citi- zens showed clear concern about how the pump program in Examine the land use ordinance to plan for future had been implemented,citing concerns about reduced flood mitigation needs and potential changes to built environments. quality of public spaces or low-quality streetscapes—and even questionable public safety near pumps that block vision and views.These responses represent a clear Ensure Appropriate Resources for missed opportunity:communities that experienced early Green and Blue Infrastructure phases of investment are the best candidates to become The city is currently advancing some blue and green ambassadors for the program and to inspire and excite infrastructure projects that align with the living-with-water neighborhoods that will receive investment later.Launch vision,including living shorelines and green infrastructure ing pilot projects that represent innovative approaches and in park design.However,the funding sources are inde respond to community interests will better serve the city pendent of those currently being used for the stormwater and help generate community buy in for the program. management program,and some are grant based or oth- Iconic pilot projects could include the following: erwise not as reliable as those in use for the stormwater program.These green infrastructure investments are also ■ Green and blue infrastructure designed into iconic not necessarily being modeled and considered in conjunc- public parks,or even pocket parks; tion with the stormwater management program underway. • Raised streets,including coordination with other desired A more holistic approach should not only offer funding infrastructure investments,such as bike lines or bike- for innovative green and blue infrastructure strategies share stations; but also ensure that their contributions are effectively measured and studied in the context of overall flood • Centralized stormwater retention; mitigation efforts. • Retention on private property(e.g.,the development of a "climate neighborhood"); 38 Page 1155 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report Ecological Design for Bishan Park, Singapore One of the largest parks in central Singapore has under- percent more conveyance capacity.It also connects to the gone an ecological renovation.Originally constructed in city's greater drainage system.8 1988,the 62-acre park was built around a portion of the Kallang River,which had been channeled through a The park was planned to provide multiple benefits. constructed canal.The canal,however,was at maximum Landscaping was carefully considered to maintain and 75 feet wide,making for limited drainage,and its concrete encourage rich biodiversity,and bridges and stepping construction created a physical division within the park. stones help integrate recreation and learning.In addition, Because water is a critical resource for the island of new playgrounds seek to engage families,including the Singapore,the large park was seen as an opportunity for water playground,an active,partially inundated play collection.In 2009,Ramboll Water partnered with the area that won the Singapore Design Award.8 Outdoors, Public Utilities Board(PUB)and the National Parks Board the park encourages active learning,providing materials to restructure the park,hoping to make it more dynamic for self guided trails.Many local schools visit it for this and ultimately more efficient for stormwater.The project purpose and have even created their own trails throughout. became a case for PUB's Active,Beautiful,Clean Waters To create a truly varied recreational experience,users program,which seeks to transform existing areas into ones can also book particular areas or visit a number of on-site that serve both form and function—beauty,recreation, businesses and restaurants.Importantly,much of the and stormwater collections park was built with accessibility in mind,including the playground areasi0 The project centered on restructuring the Kallang River, taking it out of its concrete casing and making it a more Implementing the new river system actually cost Singapore natural river system.It took nearly a dozen experimental 15 percent less than constructing the concrete canal, trials to come to a decision about the right bio-engineering showing that sometimes a slew of benefits can actually standards both to create the system and to prevent soil come at lower cost.'And today,more than 3 million people erosion!Hydraulic models also helped the teams plan. visit the area annually.12 Bishan Park is an exceptional The new river follows a floodplain concept and allows example of how an area can fulfill PUB's Active,Beautiful, for widening up to 330 feet into the park,permitting 40 Clean Waters program,integrating design elements with critical function. _ 6.0111111 a The cleansing biotope helps filter the water before it is returned The Kallang River was removed from its concrete encasing and to the drainage system in the park. now can widen up to 330 feet in flood conditions,increasing conveyance by 40 percent. Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1156 of 1637 39 • Retention in the sub-base of streets; • Operating expenses; • Cleansing biotopes,which are assemblages of plants • Savings on other capital expenses such as upgrades of in a filter medium,for example wetland cells,that can sewers and wastewater treatment plants;and cleanse water,absorb nutrients,and provide filtration; ■ Co-benefits. • Private landowner adoption of indoor and outdoor adap- tation strategies;and The optimum LOS concept would consider how flooding disruptions inconvenience the community at a district • City action on private seawalls and other barriers. scale.This approach then integrates community prefer- ence on level of mitigation into the decision-making Create Tools for Building-Level process,working across agencies and integrating public Living-with-Water Projects engagement into the process. Building owners are an important part of the solution to This LOS strategy may mean conducting direct cost living with water and have a responsibility to design their analysis,or cost/benefit analysis,to compare and find projects for flood waters.They should be encouraged to the optimum net present value of a plan.For example, follow the city's leadership by implementing flood water if local stakeholders are interested in protection beyond management strategies on and in their properties.The city the 100-year storm,this strategy could factor in the likely can also provide them with further resources and toolkits costs and determine whether there is appetite to fund the on climate adaptation segmented for different property intervention. types;this possibility is explored in more detail in the "Communications"section of this report. Address Water Quality Concerns Water quality frequently presents an issue within storm- Consider Level of Service in Future water infrastructure,and the city has thus far done a very Decision Making good job at implementing solutions to uphold the area's The city of Miami Beach requested the panel's thoughts water quality.However,the city should take this work to about the current phasing and sequencing of the storm- the next level,including state-of-the-art systems such as water management work.To date,the strategies for green infrastructure and cleansing biotopes. pumping and roadway elevations have largely been based Pumped systems including a traditional grid,sand trap, on the amount of surface water that is expressed and the and vortex have a tendency to underperform and fail dur- roadways relevant to a specific design elevation.Mov- ing extreme events.Moreover,the citizens and stakehold- ing forward,the city might consider instead pivoting to a ers of Miami Beach are clearly concerned about water level-of-service model that considers flooding disruption in quality and the potential water quality implications of the terms of likely flood frequency,depth,and duration. pump system. To decide on the socioeconomic optimum level for flood Going forward,the city should implement state-of-the-art management,different options should be calculated in treatment systems through green infrastructure that will terms of the following: absorb pollutants while increasing flexibility.Upstream ■ Reduced damages; green infrastructure should be a key aspect of the living- with-water plan but also include outlets with cleansing • Capital expenses; biotopes for treatment and polishing of water quality by filtering,sorption,and sedimentation. 40 Page 1157 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report Level-of-Service Approach to Flood Protection Climate projections are showing a strong trend toward The LOS concept has some clear advantages when more extreme weather.Most scientists and experts compared to traditional planning and design approaches: generally agree on the magnitude of the sea-level rise, whereas the extreme rainfalls are harder to predict, ▪ Strong business case to support investments in flood especially because of their often very local character— protection; both statistically and in short-term forecasts.The threats ■ Clear definition of responsibility between the city and its are imminent,but in many cases the traditional planning citizens and companies;and approach is insufficient or not fit for the purpose. ■ LOS based on actual flood events regardless of Thus,many cities are moving toward a flood protection the reason—rainfall,storm surge,groundwater,or planning approach based on a cost/benefit analysis,which malfunction of system. combines the calculated risk of doing nothing with the benefits and costs related to adapting.The cost/benefit In order to calculate and implement the optimum level analysis also allows monetization of the co-benefits from of service for the city of Miami Beach,an integrated and investing in green infrastructure.The concept can be dynamic hydraulic model including runoff from rainfall, framed as the level-of-service(LOS)approach.The LOS groundwater and infiltration,sea level,and overland flow approach refers to the planning method,in which cities needs to be built.This should be combined with a spatial clearly define the maximum level or frequency of floods model of assets,land use,and socioeconomic information acceptable during a given time period.It has the potential to calculate the risks and benefits.To ensure the best to reduce damages and nuisance,environmental,and business case,all relevant strategies and visions for the 911 health-related issues. city should be incorporated into the adaptation design and subsequent business case. In Copenhagen,for instance,the city guarantees that no flooding will occur during a ten-year storm,while four OPTIMUM inches of flooding is allowed during a 100-year storm. SERVICE LEVEL (Both measures factor in the expected impact of climate l Costs change.)The city provides flood control on public right-of- ' l way and drainage from private property up to a ten-year storm.Beyond this,or if the private landowner wants a higher level of protection than four inches,it is up to the E l individual landowner.Furthermore,the city guarantees that the plans will improve—or have no negative impact on— , J ~ et value, the quality of the receiving waters. 0 SO Si S2 -3 This level of service is based on socioeconomic calculations of the capital investments,operation,and SERVICE LEVEL maintenance of a suggested plan over time,compared The approach requires finding the optimal service level of flood to the benefits of reduced damages and downtime of protection where benefits and costs are maximized. businesses,improved connectivity,and co-benefits from green solutions. Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1158 of 1637 41 ; patterns and available data mean that new information : is often available,changing the context behind decision w i l making. "t ; ; Local stakeholders clearly articulated that the outreach } process that led to the current stormwater management ES r system was not sufficient.Stakeholders particularly noted the minimal opportunities for community input and a tone Pollutants from upstream can i` ,, that did not welcome input.The outreach process also contaminate the water around Miami Beach. a f� ; w •4 • did not provide enough time or interagency coordination opportunities to streamline the stormwater management investments with other desired infrastructural upgrades. More information on the overall communication strategy for the future resilience and stormwater management strate- gies is available later in this report.On the infrastructure and engineering side,the panel recommends the following: • Consider adding a"climate science translator"role ►`�-- � to city staff to map best state of science into basis of design criteria,inform all city design decisions,and / help communicate vulnerabilities,risk,and mitigation opportunities to the public,including what will happen in • .— ‘416) a do-nothing scenario. • Continually monitor different areas for changing The city removes pollutants conditions and strategize about how to communicate from its waterways three times o f • a week. new information to residents and businesses as new information becomes available. Beyond implementing further infrastructural investments • Ensure that communications are clear regarding the to protect water quality,the city should prioritize transpar- anticipated time frame for implemented infrastructure ently communicating the outcomes to local constituencies. and the overall cost/benefit analysis and rationale For example,the city currently has 80 sampling locations: behind implementing different types of technology and making the data publicly available would be one opportuni- infrastructure. ty that could facilitate innovation with the potential interest and involvement of local activists and citizen scientists. Were Miami Beach to not stay on the vanguard of infrastructure planning and implementation related to Improve Communications about stormwater management and climate adaptation,the pros- pacts fora continued high quality of life are unlikely.Thus, Engineering and Infrastructural continuing to evolve and mature the city's infrastructure Solutions strategy is imperative. How are local stakeholders currently connecting and digesting the best information available?Flood vulnerability in Miami Beach is a complex issue,and evolving weather 42 Page 1159 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report Physical Design and Typology MIAMI BEACH'S PHYSICAL TYPOLOGY presents • Pursue opportunities with solar and renewables. a unique opportunity to craft a more innovative and cost-effective solution than the present stormwater ■ Consider long-term options for neighborhood design management system.This more holistic strategy could and green space. better respond to natural topography and land and water conditions,incorporating green infrastructure,parks, Select Interventions Responding to open spaces,and opportunities for the incorporation of the City's Beach/Bowl/Bay Typology renewable energy that will increase preparedness for The island of Miami Beach follows a beach/bowl/bay peak events and power failure. typology.The beach dunes are at a higher elevation than The following recommendations,as well as ideas and the center of the city,which is its lowest base elevation examples of how to achieve this goal,are discussed in area.However,design analyses completed during the more detail below: panel noted that the bay side of the island is also slightly elevated,which creates a bowl in the center of the island • Select design and infrastructure interventions that that is currently a major challenge for the city.Moreover, respond to the city's beach/bowl/bay typology. an analysis of the water levels within this bowl reveals a ■ Look to golf courses as underused green spaces for freshwater bubble,mostly rainwater,that is interfacing with water management. rising tides.This fact explains why flooding is especially prevalent within this area:the freshwater runoff from leaky • Consider modifying road specifications for permeability. pipes is creating optimal conditions for flooding. BAY BOWL BEACH fn •n 151/ BISCAYNE SM,T TER A� `> BAY g An illustration of the beach/ bowl/bay typology that results F' o n Too n 11 in a freshwater"bowl"in the `k s center of the island. Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1160 of 1637 43 Currently,about 20 percent of the island is within this OPEN SPACE BREAKDOWN urban bowl condition,according to topographical analyses conducted during the panel's visit.This percentage will �w.._.-.�S ;c:: grow as new bayfront towers create an architectural levee �i'•'. of elevated floors,gardens,and seawalls.Notably,the � � majority of Miami Beach's historic districts are located 9� within this bowl. silly. Miami Beach's future resilience plan should respond to the • • natural conditions at each portion of this typology when E. implementing strategies for water management.In the :k beach upland zone("beach zone"),for example,water can ,r be buffered,stored,reused,and released;this is the partettt:s; . of the island with the most"room"to store water in the lt�1/1< ash fr landscape and architecture. r� . iF iir tiro �; .. lir •• Development should incentivize or require on-site water :_t r storage and could incorporate blue roofs and walls and cisterns. `' ua, • Green infrastructure and green streets should be de -1--t,„ _+ �r«••r signed with capacity to retain,purify,and release water. i dlb ad: MITI uu� u:y; iitu u • FEMA is currently in the midst of a floodplain mapping ,14:�>a update,to be completed in 2019.After mapping is ,1411j, update, updated,the city should consider whether dunes should • be modified to comply with the FEMA 540 rule,which ie could improve the city's rating in the NFIP Community Rating System. SPACE ALLOCATED TO GOLF COURSES Miami Beach In the"bowl zone,"the focus is managing the interface O 7.000 4.000' between freshwater,saltwater,and groundwater.The key O goal is storing and conveying water through the rainwater/ Golf courses are the largest source of open space in Miami Beach, making them a critically underused land area for stormwater groundwater interface,including within parks and green management potential. spaces. • Groundwater monitoring and management should be a In the"bay zone,"a living shoreline meets and manages top priority. the freshwater/saltwater interface.Architecture,open space,and the seawall can work together to manage • Green streets could store water uphill. potential inundation.Note that this typology is likely to • Blue streets should be designed for conveyance and fil- "lift"in the future,creating more of a bowl condition,as tration,conveying and percolating water,and ultimately property owners harmonize with the seawall.Accordingly, conducting it toward the bay treated and without the future finished floor elevations may be higher than those use of pipes. seen today. 44 Page 1161 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report Look to Golf Courses as Underused resources.These golf courses represent great opportuni- Green Spaces ties for water storage for the following reasons: Currently,Miami Beach has about 17 percent green • They include artificially elevated land. space as a percentage of overall land area,including the • They are connected to the groundwater. beachfront,active open spaces,and golf courses.Future approaches to water management and resilience should Future water management efforts,supported by the use these open spaces,including green infrastructure outputs of the city's hydraulic model,should explore op- designed to manage both groundwater and stormwater. portunities for taking advantage of the green absorption In comparison,leading U.S.cities for public open space potential of golf courses. include Washington,D.C.,with 21.9 percent,New York with 21.3 percent,and San Francisco with 19.6 percent 73 Modify Road Specifications to According to calculations completed during the panel,of Enhance Permeability Miami Beach's open space The roads of Miami Beach offer another opportunity to ■ Roughly 5 percent is the beachfront; better live with water and be prepared for flooding events, and they are currently a major part of ongoing public works ■ Roughly 5 percent is active open spaces like fields;and through the stormwater management program. However, ■ Roughly 7 percent is golf course. existing road specifications can fail prematurely under ris- ing groundwater,including in the following ways: At the moment,the golf courses represent the largest ■ Creating hydrostatic pressure under impervious roads single type of open space on the island,and they are that scour the sand foundation; currently incredibly underused as water management Adapting Parks for Water Management: Emerald Isle, North Carolina Emerald Isle is one of several communities that have begun Environmental Quality's Universal Stormwater Management to use local parks for the purpose of stormwater detention. Program authorizes the town to enforce not just its local The small island notably lacks public land and thus has had ordinances,but also related state policies,thus allowing to work with the resources that it can access to address it to have stronger regulating power.The stormwater stormwater concerns.Nine different stationary pumps are program helps support the overarching Pamlico Sound set in different neighborhoods that use an automatic float Regional Hazard Mitigation Plan,a five-county plan system to flow through underground pipes'^They lead to required by both state and federal policies and approved by a specific area of Emerald Isle Woods Park designated for FEMA,to help alleviate drainage,water quality,and storm hiking and passive stormwater accumulation;other parts surge concerns from yearly hurricanes 16 of the park include a nine-hole golf course.The stormwater area is planned so that the natural environment treats the The stormwater system has been a top funding priority water,since state policies prohibit depositing it into the for the town of Emerald Isle,and funds to support it are Atlantic Ocean or Bogue Soundly allotted by a capital project ordinance.A recent pump cost the town around$150,000,which included consulting with The island began to focus on its stormwater concerns engineers and a negotiated construction cost with local in 2004,when an update to the Land Use Plan required builders.''Although the current system has helped alleviate drainage systems and development regulations for on-site many concerns,the town continues to prioritize ways to stormwater retention.The North Carolina Department of improve and expand upon the program. Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1162 of 1637 45 A Permeable Plaza: Giralda Avenue in Coral Gables In Coral Gables,Florida,Giralda Avenue was recently ! ' - T' - 3 • completed as part of the city's Miracle Mile project,which � , • spans a total of four blocks.Giralda Avenue,physically tir• , l` . n divided from the Mile itself,was designed to become a 3§I! 9 curbless pedestrian plaza.The entire project,designed — 4 . in collaboration with Local Office Landscape and Cooper k, Robertson,works to integrate both resilience and art, (\. creating paving patterns that imitate tropical raindrops t8 Giralda Avenue,part of the Coral Gables Miracle Mile district,is a pedestrian plaza designed with resilience in mind. The stormwater system was designed to withstand rains of 7.5 inches per hour,which far surpasses the code. The$20 million project took years to complete.The city This system used porous paving,which blends permeable commission,whose membership was evenly split between products such as rubber to absorb more water.The project the city and property owners,initially approved funding also used hurricane-wind-resistant planting techniques, in 2014.Property owners in the Business Improvement which plant trees deeper into the ground so as a network District paid a special assessment tax dependent on they can collectively mitigate groundwater.A testament to location:35 percent if directly on the Mile or plaza,and structural soil and decentralized line drains,Giralda Avenue 15 percent if adjacent to it.To help diminish these costs, recently withstood Hurricane Irma while neighboring the city agreed to pay interest for two years and raised streets experienced intense flooding.To further synthesize parking meter fees to ease parking costs for businesses.20 these elements with the streetscape,the project plans to The project is a laudable example of integrating several cover stormwater utility boxes in artwork i9 solutions into one,merging economic improvements, artistic elements,and resilience initiatives. - IP 4 k,.'ate`"'" ae�' ""��` ,•b...— Nef4ic.ndt}cpKh TWO, SSo4E THEE GFATE =' F FIRa<( .. _ .. rffA S;r, .. _ . — — MAIMS 0011011 PUH h�l...l,i�•d ....�- - •••: r'n aITEAlIcS`I U)C4' t piton IN Pitruft MEP WM'S VErroftn- Dior tllu-rK mss. 11041100STE7hUI •• �,"�, ."O.. SEWER win pr.,irwry.Lahr. 4S _.:.g r g LOCAL OFFICE g The integrated stormwater system is designed to withstand rains of 7.5 inches per hour,surpassing local code requirements. 46 Page 1163 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report • Removing fines from the lime rock base;and While analyzing the stormwater management program,the ■ Creating large cavities and potholes. panel discussed and explored how building and neighbor- hood types could evolve with climate adaptation.One long- Coastal resilience specifications for porous paving can term typology that may become more prominent because have as much as twice the life of existing road standards of the increasing effects of climate change and increased and overcome the shortcomings of older versions of flood risk is the neighborhood in which not every property porous paving,with lower maintenance requirements.In decides to adapt,owing to the cost of home elevation and addition,these systems offer significant water quality ben- other measures. efits.The city should look into using these road specifics If neighborhoods evolve as renovation of every property tions and moving toward a porous road model. becomes cost prohibitive,Miami Beach may follow prec- edents in other U.S.cities to create floodable public green Pursue Opportunities with Solar spaces in neighborhoods where residents are interested and Renewables in relocation.The public green spaces could serve a flood Moving forward,the city should embed solar and re- function and become valued amenities and centers for newables into the resilience strategy and the stormwater neighborhood character,following the historic precedents management strategy.Strategies could include the follow- of cities such as Savannah,Georgia,whose squares pro- ing elements: vide valuable public gathering spaces and form a crucial part of the city's character. ■ Incentivizing the incorporation of renewables,energy resilience,and water reuse systems into new develop- ment,as discussed in the"Regulations"section of this report.Note that precedent exists for these types of regulations and incentives,such as Miami Beach's cur- rent green building ordinance. • Partnering with utilities or infrastructure providers, such as Miami-Dade Water and Sewer Department and Florida Power&Light,to establish frameworks for more widespread adoption. Consider Long-Term Options for Neighborhood Design Miami Beach's neighborhood typologies are as iconic as the city's natural landscape typologies.Culture,architec- ture,and the arts are critical aspects of the city's identity and draw,and the corresponding policies are explored in the"Creative Placemaking"and"Governance"sections of this report. Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1164 of 1637 47 Creative Placemaking ARTS,CULTURE,AND DESIGN are core elements of lyr Miami Beach's identity and key draws for this international "4 ... tourism destination.The city recognizes that its cultural capital is a major economic driver and an important attrac- i I tion for the approximately 12 million people who visit Miami ` r Beach proper each year.21 From the allure of its natural r. 1 LL environment to its historic communities and art-centric -- °^, x CA culture,the city should implement creative placemaking • • • • • • techniques as an important factor in its stormwater man- • • • • • • • • • o agement and resilience strategies.Creative placemaking Color and texture are integral to the Miami Beach art deco style. intentionally leverages the power of the arts,culture,and creativity to serve a community's interests while driving a districts,is the nation's largest collection of art deco,with broader agenda for change,growth,and transformation. more than 800 buildings constructed in the style.24 The Miami Beach has been a cultural icon for nearly a century. city has continued to hone in on the arts in recent years, The art deco architectural style that the city is known for by first hosting the annual art fair Art Basel in 2002.Today began as far back as 1923 and spanned a 20-year the event hosts 250 international galleries and more than period.22 Its prominence was recognized as early as 1979, 82,000 guests in a matter of days.Economists have esti- when it became the first 20th-century neighborhood to be mated that south Florida benefits from$400 million to$500 recognized by the National Register of Historic Places.23 million in annual economic impact from this art week.25 The art deco architectural style Even today,this national district, made up of four local of Ocean Avenue is part of The residents of Miami Beach have stressed the impor- Miami Beach's cultural identity. tance of maintaining the cultural identity of the city and f• _ its neighborhoods as it proceeds with implementation .,,> 1 /9j *f of its stormwater management and resilience plans. . 'r Placemaking is a strategy that can address this concern. • .4' s" '� Placemaking refers to the act of creating a sense of place .„ > r or identity. Creative placemaking leverages art and culture -. i �� 1,, , ' II .: interventions in the process.According to a 2010 study by ty ! -s ;d.. ' U t ;vati& 1p. the National Endowment for the Arts,creative placemaking y<•4, I i ' Ali C "-v ,',•<` ^q ,, l - 4 "animates public and private spaces,rejuvenates struc- wigi — isile A 1v4 ai.-4- . tures and streetscapes,improves local business viability moi! . i r t. F. ..tv �_ .. .t; 410-!. �.� and public safety,and brings diverse people together to 1 celebrate,inspire,and be inspired."26 " Incorporating creative placemaking into the resilience and o. . -„,, stormwater management plans would enhance the overall 48 Page 1165 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report value of the stormwater management mitigation efforts and offers a number of benefits,including the following: ■ Improving the aesthetics of visible components of the =-c • city's stormwater management program,including the k *j'• 1' L�f mow: '` ';• raised streets,pumps,and generators; ■ Presenting physical components in ways that are cultur- `- „ . `-.� ally relevant to the neighborhood or place; * Wynwood Walls,a graffiti and {' I street-art open gallery,hosts special exhibitions for Art Basel • Enhancing awareness and understanding of the city's s in Miami. resilience program through solutions that are informa- tional in nature; Partner with Local Arts and Culture ■ Building buy-in and support for the Miami Beach resit- Stakeholders fence program through early engagement of artists and All of the city's placemaking efforts will be most effective residents;and when developed in partnership with stakeholders already • Branding Miami Beach as the Resilient Art City. engaged in the dynamic arts and culture scene in Miami Beach.The city should work in partnership with key orga- When properly executed,creative placemaking is wholly nizations,such as the following: synergistic,benefitting both private and public stakehold- ers by cementing the city's cultural aesthetic and driving • Miami Design Preservation League; more economic investment into the region.The city,in ■ ArtCenter South Florida,one of Miami Beach's largest turn,benefits from increased spending and tax revenue to drive its resilience plan forward. and longest-standing artists'studios; • Universities,including those that have considered the Strategies such as these to incorporate creative place visual arts and design in their approach to this topic, making into the stormwater management and resilience including strategy are described in the following sections: • University of Miami,which is incorporating sea-level • Ensure that partnerships with local arts and culture rise in its curriculum across numerous disciplines, stakeholders are embedded in the placemaking strategy. including the School of Marine and Atmospheric • Incorporate public art in the stormwater management Science,School of Architecture,College of Engineer- strategy. ing,and College of Arts and Sciences,among others;27 and • Involve and engage artists in the design process. • Florida International University,which includes the • Create open spaces that respond to resilience needs Lincoln Road—based Miami Beach Urban Studios, while engaging local artists and designers. and its Sea Level Solutions Center,which is incorpo- ■ Incorporate creative placemaking strategies into the rating design technology such as 3D printing into its overall resilience communications plan. work,and has hosted events such as a symposium on sea-level rise and the public realm;28 and Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1166 of 1637 49 Evacuteer: Placemaking and Preparedness In New Orleans,Evacuteer merges hurricane awareness r t programming with a creative use of placemaking. ' Sculptures around the city help direct residents to locations °° at which they can meet during mandatory evacuations, ,y which are called EvacuSpots.These locations serve to - co.,sump tvAregister people,pets,and luggage and transport them to i u►w w+ ink safe locations if they lack their own resources.Seventeen F,. ,', = --- EvacuSpots dot the city,including four specifically near senior centers.Although official signage was in place,originally concerns existed over its visibility to users.29 WN- As a result,in 2013,Evacuteer partnered with the Arts _..._.-- Council of New Orleans to hold a design contest to create F sculptures at the various locations.The winning design, by artist Douglas Kornfield,resulted in a$200,000 public art project throughout the city.39 The design was selected for its clarity and interpretation. Each EvacuSpot sculpture has a plaque that indicates pick-up ins The hailing-a-cab gesture is universal,making it easily understood and avoiding anxiety-inducing interpretations. managed by the New Orleans Office of Homeland Security The gesture also fits New Orleans well—although and Emergency Preparedness,or can dial 311—which unintended,it is serendipitously the same one used to also hosts Evacuteer volunteers.32 collect beads during Mardi Gras.However,the focus is in functionality.Each sculpture has a plaque on its leg The program has been in place since just after Hurricane indicating registration rules and instructions.In addition, Katrina,when New Orleans sought to find ways to better they are built to last:at 14 feet tall and 800 pounds, protect its citizens from risk.As a result,in 2005,the city the stainless-steel structures were designed for up to developed the City-Assisted Evacuation(CAE)program to 200 years of wear and tear.31 In 2015,Evacuteer began help an estimated 35,000 to 40,000 of its residents who a fundraising program to light them,to ensure that lack safe evacuation transportation.CAE provides trans- the figures are visible at all times.For help in locating portation to safe shelter and a ride back when the city is them,citizens can go to the city's NOLA Ready website, opened.During Hurricane Gustav,Evacuteer was formed as a temporary volunteer program to help with the first CAE evacuation,but was authorized by the city to permanently operate when the city found opportunities in the system. Today,more than 500 volunteers a year are trained by l Evacuteer to help not just with evacuations,but also with community outreach,education,and risk awareness.33 By initiating a sculptural element to the EvacuSpots, the program makes it easy for the community to locate ~ evacuation areas.As important,the art serves as a persistent reminder of prevailing risk and emergency awareness without negative connotations.Evacuteer An illuminated EvacuSpot sits outside the Arthur Monday Center shows how creative visibility in the public realm can in New Orleans. amplify programming that lacks existing infrastructure. 50 Page 1167 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report • Art Basel,which presents an incredible opportunity to pump stations that are currently deemed to be disruptive engage both the international artists'community and the or unsightly,or artists could be involved in developing international community of art enthusiasts and buyers. cladding or accompanying sculptural pieces.When used to showcase art,the pumps offer an opportunity to celebrate Incorporate Public Art in the unique aspects of Miami Beach and the different char- Stormwater Management Strategy acters of various neighborhoods.Instead of looking like invaders,the pumps could become local landmarks and Miami Beach's current stormwater management program signifiers of neighborhood identity or interests. features significant gray infrastructure components.In particular,the pumps and generators are large and often The public and other stakeholders should have a key role unwieldy structures,which look out of place in a right- in selection and procurement of these public art works. of-way or park.Numerous residents participating in the The city could take the following actions: panel's interview process complained about the aesthet- • Partner with the Art in Public Places(AiPP)Committee ics of the pumps,describing them as an eyesore in an to create a strategy for creating a new iteration of otherwise vibrant and architecturally exciting city.Some AiPP art works in conversation with stormwater also noted public safety concerns when the pumps had a management plans. lack of visibility from the street or well-lit areas. • Identify artists through a request for proposals procure- Incorporating public art into this stormwater manage- ment process,highlighting strategies to include and ment infrastructure has exciting potential to address such draw local artists. concerns and otherwise build Miami Beach's brand as a resilient arts city.Accordingly,the city should actively • Engage artists for both site-specific installation opportu- include art in current and future stormwater management nities and opportunities that could be prototyped for use investments.For example,public art could be installed at at more than one pump or generator station. { 1. ;!'1.Ir. 0V I1 ,. . .f 4 � rx r•� �� :S: iar . iw La �� !1 , y3y! .qtr r'' ':. '' 1,,., .i �, j 4 _ __ 1 Collins Park now hosts Miami �.—_ .�• a Mountain,a 41 toot sculpture ----- ---— 1, "a by Ugo Rondinone that was recently acquired by the Bass a Museum of Art. Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1168 of 1637 51 Placemaking and Water Management The city of Miami Beach can look to several nationalit •examples of best practices in resilience and creative `�ti S lit .r,' //�-9 placemaking,particularly in the design of public spaces that effectively manage water. ` OA . -rr. -•. + 1 .i,.: ;rr,al Vine Street,Seattle,Washington .. -r« �' %` The Vine Street installations in the Belltown neighborhood f - _ " ' { of Seattle take innovative approaches to showcasing � _ »_.�, " 0�� the management of water in an urban context.Located :•_M` = t • .1 ii ''` ... '' in the downtown waterfront area,Belltown is one of the , '``" . , r.,.-,-_,- 'i i" most densely populated neighborhoods in the city and ','•�." t 1 dominated by impervious surfaces. e. - " _ — --- In the mid-1990s,a group of residents organized the ti Growing Vine Street initiative to implement artistically The ten-loot-high Beckoning Cistern distributes water down die designed green infrastructure along an eight-block strip hill in a series of cascading planters when it becomes full. of the street,ultimately connecting the community to the waterfront.The residents'group partnered with Seattle through a candelabra form vegetated downspout,then Public Utilities(SPU),the Seattle Office of Arts and distributes the water into a series of cascading planters. • Culture,and other city departments to pool resources and a The Cistern Steps installation is a tiered series of community input,while raising awareness of SPU's water biofiltration basins that directs water through a dramatic conservation efforts.3° zig-zagging channel of planters that taper down from a The driving priority of Growing Vine Street is to capture plaza,flowing into a pool at the bottom of the hill3 • and naturally filter rain and stormwater runoff before Most of the green infrastructure projects along Vine Street channeling it into Elliott Bay.A few projects along Vine are designed to amuse pedestrians while processing runoff Street demonstrate the potential impact of integrating art through an ecological approach. into stormwater capture-and-release infrastructure. Confluence Park,San Antonio,Texas in The Beckoning Cistern,a ten-foot-high,six-foot- Confluence Park is part of a more than$400 million river diameter cylinder collects roof runoff that is first filtered ...., restoration project to upgrade San Antonio's water storage systems.The Mission Reach Ecosystem Restoration and i `F • I ! Recreation Project spans over eight miles,and Confluence litI Park serves as a five acre gateway to its trails and • ,� ;' ,:,f.,_.._ •- conservation •systems.The park is •centered on its •signature Vit, _ ` >� landmark,the BHP Pavilion,which serves not only as an event '- M .•- • .T.,-..1- a ' and meeting place but also as a way to collect and store ,,---T�- .-:" rainwater.36 The pavilion was designed by Andrew Kudless of - .!'�='-�v ___ ..A`?5'� Matsys Design,who worked in close collaboration with the • • -, i ,P":— 4r- t i architect and designer at the start of the project.Its"petals" ,� lead to underground storage and an embayment,which „"""' n & together collect over 200,000 gallons of rainwater for irrigation'� and plumbing.3'The park's use of regional ecosystem Environmental sculptor Buster Simpson designed several pieces plantings also allows for less landscaping and water usage, for Vine Street,including this feature on a building facade,which and the educational facility,Estela Avery Classroom,features a helps filter rain and stormwater runoff. green roof and solar panels to work toward energy neutrality." 52 Page 1169 of 1637 A UU Advisory Services Panel Report housing projects sited nearby.One of the projects hopes to bring in over$1.5 billion in impact through 2,100 housing x units and nearly 1,500 employees."Confluence Park's diverse benefits demonstrate how creative placemaking -- — ` ^ r can dramatically enhance a city's resilience strategy. f Tanner Springs Park,Portland,Oregon _ 4 Tanner Springs Park is located in the Pearl District of o Portland on land that was previously a wetland and lake. t>>_' ' As the city's population grew,the water system was �� rerouted via an underground pipe system and filled to allow Confluence Park's landscape is largely composed of native species creation of warehouses and rail yards,which have since that are irrigated by rainwater captured in on-site storage containers. been replaced by the current vibrant neighborhood with shops,open spaces,and residences.43 Local residents advocated reclamation of two blocks of the ii ot ,. ..: former wetlands to create Tanner Springs Park.Emphasis on the area's native wetlands and industrial history is a key theme seen throughout the design of Tanner Springs E I f- ' Park.The design intentionally connected the urban park with Tanner Creek,which previously flowed through the L4 ' ,. " area.The park also includes an Artwall,which runs along , the edge of the park and is made up of recycled railroad ' ` ` track with fused glass images of hand-painted dragonflies, spiders,amphibians,and insects.Children are encouraged i. Weekly yoga sessions are a part of the events and programming to explore local species of plants and insects in the schedule that keep the park engaged with its community.Here a yoga class gathers under the central pavilion,which serves as a splash pond and floating decks.E4 The park is a product water management feature. of an intense community engagement process led by a local stakeholder steering group to ensure that the park The Estela Avery Classroom supports the pavilion and represents the community's vision. grounds the park's education-focused mission.The classroom provides a free educational facility,supported by an education u endowment,and even free transportation for participating schools.The pavilion and classroom are both frequently used - '- 1 for educational programming,including free tours and field ., - trips,while the pavilion itself is highlighted by regular yoga - -- f j t.: 14" _ 1- sessions,as well as special events put on by the city,such as -a. ,, ' its Get Out and Play initiative.39 ' • , Funding for the park came from both public and private sources,but the majority was covered by private donations , \ /. ; to the managing San Antonio River Foundation:"The private funding included a$750,000 gift by Estela Avery, With the help of local stakeholders,two blocks of former the foundation's former director,to build the Estela Avery wetlands were reclaimed to create a dynamic outdoor space. Classroom 41 The city has already seen an economic benefit returning on the$13.5 million investment,with many new Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1170 of 1637 53 ■ Include citizens,key stakeholders,and arts partners in water infrastructure and providing important opportunities the selection and award process. for outreach through descriptive signage and accompany- ing educational materials.Artful cisterns,water recycling ■ Consider opportunities for synergy with national events systems,rain gardens,and more can add texture and in Miami Beach,such as Art Basel. personality to water management schemes and anchor memorable public spaces. Involve and Engage Artists in the Design Process Incorporate Creative Placemaking Elaborating on the preceding ideas,artists could go Strategies in the Resilience beyond proposing accompanying visual or sculptural art Communications Plan pieces for stormwater management infrastructure and become involved in the actual infrastructural design pro- Creative placemaking is a dynamic topic that can be more cess.For example,artists could contribute to the design of likely to engage stakeholders than discussions of storm water management.Content on creative placemaking should pumps as follows: be integrated into the overall communications materials for ■ Establishing design points or requirements,such as so- Miami Beach Rising Above and used as a tool to engage lutions that are culturally relevant,educate and inspire, more residents and broaden the reach of the plan. and use historical facts,data,and metrics. • Establishing partnerships with the city arts depart- ment,local nonprofits,and businesses to consult in the creative placemaking process.Note that many leading local universities and groups are already engaging in the intersection of the arts and sea-level rise. • Awarding artists formal roles in the design and imple- mentation processes to engage with the engineers or design team. Create Open Spaces Responsive to Resilience Needs While Engaging Local Artists Parks and green spaces should be a key strategy of the city's overall resilience and stormwater management plans, an idea that is explored at length in other parts of this re- port.Creative placemaking can then be a core component of the design and planning for these public spaces.Many nationally recognized parks have used the arts as part of stormwater management plans,both beautifying storm- 54 Page 1171 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report Governance THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH has taken a bold first step in addressing its stormwater management challenges, - which have been exacerbated by changes in the climate. However,to continue to develop and expand such an ambi- tious,costly,and dynamic program will require a greater • focus on governance. • A key driver of the ability of any community to effectively • deliver,monitor,operate,and maintain interventions for 41411111W-- stormwater management and climate adaptation is the governance of the system.Implementing a multifaceted ° r , plan,including gray and green infrastructure and many ve- hides for funding and community involvement,will involve �4 more complex governance structures than are currently in ° j' place.Enhanced governance will ultimately deliver a more ` a data-driven resilience program that is rooted in efficiency, Miami Beach City Nall is the transparency,and accountability and that is more likely to central civic and government Establish a Rising Above Program building in Miami Beach. garner community support. Delivery Office The panel's recommendations for governance of the future Miami Beach currently has dedicated resilience staff lo- resilience and stormwater management plans include the cated in the City Manager's Office and supported through following: the Rockefeller Foundation's 100 Resilient Cities initiative. • Establish a Miami Beach Rising Above program delivery This team is currently leading the development of the city's office or realign existing departments. resilience plan in partnership with counterparts in the Offices of Resilience in Miami-Dade County and the city • Create a scientific advisory panel through the program of Miami, managing a full assistant city manager portfolio, delivery office. including the Building,Planning,Code,Environment and • Establish an agency for public investment and develop- Sustainability Departments,and managing other special ment in resilience. initiatives such as the city's participation in the Bloomberg Mayor's Challenge.The team has leveraged and grown the • Establish a community adaptation fund. Miami Beach Rising Above branding and communications • Establish a robust risk transfer department. collateral and integrated new climate adaptation content along with the information provided on the investments in • Consider new strategies to better align historic preser- stormwater management.The City Commission has a Sus- vation and climate adaptation work. tainability and Resiliency Committee,established in 2015, that provides a forum for policy development and review. Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1172 of 1637 55 Separate from the staff team responsible for resilience Create a Scientific Advisory Panel strategy,the city of Miami Beach should open a Rising Above delivery office to monitor and communicate the A key component of the program delivery office should effectiveness of its Rising Above program,or realign exist- be the establishment of a scientific advisory panel to ing departments to create such a team.This office can provide data-driven recommendations on how the city can commission new tools for project performance,community continue to advance its resilience work.This panel should outreach,and codesign of stormwater management sys be focused on generating recommendations relevant to the tems.A delivery office like this is likely to make the Rising city over the long term,considering the current program's Above program more sustainable over time and would be 30 year horizon and the strategies and investment that a platform to help local stakeholders and the public better could be required for 40-,50-,60-,and 70-year horizons. understand the program's performance and opportunities The panel could also introduce new strategies for bench for improvement.The current lack of public understand- marking to acknowledge increased future risk and the ing of aspects of the existing program,and the likely time changing climate.Such a panel should be coordinated frame for the investments in stormwater management, with the efforts of and data from the Southeast Florida indicates a need for both better communications and a Climate Compact. dedicated vehicle. Establish an Agency for Public This separate project delivery office could serve the follow- Investment and Development in ing roles: Resilience I. Develop tools that promote greater transparency The future viability of Miami Beach is rooted in the financial on project selection,development,funding,and ability of the city and property owners to continue invest- expenditures; ments in adaptation and stormwater management proj- • Monitor and communicate project performance; ects.Additional sources of revenue will be needed as the city aims to meet 30-year and future-year benchmarks. is Manage strategic communications,community out- Furthermore, more flexible sources of revenue are needed: reach,and community codesign,and facilitate creative the current stormwater management program exclusively placemaking and artist engagement in projects;and funds gray stormwater investments,such as pumps and ■ Embark upon the establishment of a scientific advisory enhanced street elevations,and does not include funding services panel to review and advise the city on the latest eligible for investment in green infrastructure and nature climate science data and relevant tools(more below). based solutions such as mangroves.The current program also has not focused on fostering investment at the prop- Given the excellent regional collaboration already underway erty owner scale,instead focusing on investment in critical in the Greater Miami area through the Southeast Florida public infrastructure. Climate Compact and the resilience strategies supported by the 100RC initiative,some scope exists for a program The establishment of an agency for public investment and delivery office to be a regional vehicle.Although this would development that can capture additional value from real certainly add complexity to the task,it opens up the op- estate and direct it toward a suite of resilience projects and portunity for regional comparison and the exploration of investments is needed and would streamline the financing goals district by district. of the many facets of such a complex program.Such an agency has the potential to set the national standard for investment in risk reduction projects. 56 Page 1173 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report This agency would be tasked with creating strategies to ■ Exploring potential for additional revenue as a result of capture increased real estate values and leverage them for group reduction in insurance(through a special assess- public investment in resilient infrastructure,including blue ment district or other instrument);and and green infrastructure and a community adaptation fund. The agency may also establish opportunities to encourage • Administering a community adaptation fund. development that would contribute to the tax base through incentives,streamlined permitting programs,or tools such Establish a Community Adaptation as special assessment districts.The last could be a key Fund tool for the city,but they need to be approved by the county A key opportunity for this agency will be establishing a in each instance.The enhanced real estate value generated community adaptation fund,which could assist homeown- could then contribute to the construction,operation,and ers,businesses,institutions,and other property owners maintenance of resilient infrastructure projects. with retrofits and investments.Designed to leverage public This agency could be responsible for the following: investment and encourage more widespread adoption of resilient design,the fund could provide low-cost loans and • Establishing opportunities for incremental value capture grants for projects in line with the city's overall adaptation from real estate that could be directed toward resilience goals,such as the following: projects; • Home elevations; ■ Directing investment and development of resilience projects(including green and blue projects involving • First-floor retrofits; nature-based defenses,as well as gray infrastructure • Private seawall enhancements;and projects); • Investment in on-site water management mechanisms, • Managing operations and maintenance of green and such as cisterns,green infrastructure,and permeable blue resilience projects; surfaces. ■ Exploring opportunities for special assessment districts This fund would contribute to individual mitigation projects and embarking on the partnerships and coalition- by homeowners and businesses and respond to commu- building needed to accomplish these with the county nity concerns about the ability to fund individual projects and others; such as seawall contributions.A fund like this would be a valuable resource for the resident and business community and would ultimately fortify the city by creating a stronger kit network of solutions across the island. • Establish a Robust Risk Transfer .,. , ...4 R. ' • t Department Currently,the city's human resources department man- ages risk transfer and insurance.The city should instead create a risk transfer department that would be tasked 8 ' with developing and administering innovative solutions for A community adaptation fund would assist residents with making the insurance,including opportunities for insurance savings necessary improvements to their homes to protect them,as with this through investment in resilience and mitigation projects. elevated home in the Northeast. Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1174 of 1637 57 K Ili u 71- ^ S A'r. ' ?• �,71 '4; 1/•0 qt) '.�,z The art deco style in Miami , , , - t,[' Beach historic districts is = - "" M • S .4••11. �}-rJ —._ .. ' l , world renowned.The Breakwater `-- i ' �' ' . Hotel(tar right)was built in :Lopilh, a streamlined modern style k t in 1939. 0 3 This department is likely to require new staff,including locally,the city and heritage community will have the op- experts in finance. portunity to lead a national conversation regarding how to respect and care for cherished historic assets in the face The degree of capital investment and exposure to risk in of environmental vulnerability. Miami Beach requires a creative approach to managing that risk.By implementing new insurance solutions and The city is already moving in this direction. For example, programs such as a special assessment district for both in 2017 the city released a request for qualifications driving public investment and transferring risk,Miami (RFQ)for a consultant to provide input into historic district Beach has an opportunity to set the national standard for resilience and adaptation guidelines.These guidelines risk reduction in the wake of sea-level rise. will address the renovation,elevation,and repurposing of historic structures in vulnerable parts of the city,consider- Align Historic Preservation and ing both increasing tidal flooding and sea-level rise.The RFQ requested a multidisciplinary team,with expertise in Climate Adaptation Strategies engineering,architecture,planning,historic preservation, Miami Beach's art deco architecture is a vital component hydrology,geotechnics,and cost consulting. of the city's identity,a key contributor to the architectural heritage of the country as a whole,and a very important A recent edition of the National Trust for Historic Preser- economic development and tourism generator.Visitors vation's Forum Journal noted that"climate change and from across the country and world flock to Miami Beach rising sea level mandate a new kind of assessment of the for this historic architecture as well as the natural assets vulnerability of historic resources,requiring stakeholders to such as the ocean and beaches,which first drew settlers look at adaptation options and to decide what will be saved from the northeast United States to Miami.Preserving the for future generations.'45 Miami Beach is well positioned to city's culture and architecture is an inherent aspect of sup- develop tools and frameworks that vulnerable cities across porting the city's economy. the country can use to both safeguard heritage and sup- port the related decision-making process. The city's existing heritage regulations and governance have done a formidable job of preserving the integrity of First,the extent of the risk faced by the city mandates the city's historic architecture.However,given the extent a more extensive survey of the vulnerability of historic of the risk that the city faces and the vulnerability of many assets.The city should use the new modeling technology historic buildings,all stakeholders must begin to recon- (discussed in the"Infrastructure"section of this report)to sider what preservation means and strategize accordingly. better understand the vulnerability of historic districts over If Miami Beach successfully engages in this conversation the upcoming decades and share this information with all relevant stakeholders.All the relevant stakeholders can 58 Page 1175 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report then use this information to better understand context, LE6Err0 consider adaptation options,and strategize about which historic assets should be prioritized to be saved for future ? .. generations. Unfortunately,no one-size-fits-all solution or easy answer 47. .,, for how to achieve the continued preservation of Miami Beach's historic districts exists.Quite possibly,the entire spectrum or ensemble of historic architecture in Miami Beach may not be able to be saved,given both the inten- • sity of the threat and the cost of adaptation measures such as elevating buildings.If this is the case,the city and all associated stakeholders will need to strategize about how to protect the most important"historic jewels." Local stakeholders should be prepared for this eventual- ity and begin to strategize about how to fund climate s , adaptation measures for historic buildings and how to ' -r( prioritize these investments if entire building ensembles cannot be safeguarded.These discussions may ultimately include revisiting historic district regulations and modifying - approaches to heritage regulation,such as revising policies for contributing and noncontributing buildings within neigh- 1 This map shows historic borhood ensembles,or introducing opportunities to enable 7i districts,indicated in blocks of pastel colors,and road climate adaptation investments for historic buildings. elevations,indicated in a ; 1 g. spectrum of blue to red. The Throughout this process and before major decisions on > lack of red and orange roads on a individual policies,buildings,or ensembles move forward, the map showstvulnerability .;, of the historic areee as. the city should better equip heritage professionals and ROAD ELEVATIONS IN HISTORIC DISTRICTS others to be informed about these issues.For example,the Miami Beach "Regulations"section of this report explores how to embed 6 knowledge of climate adaptation,water management, and resilience into local decision-making groups,such as In short,while moving forward with preservation aspects review boards.City officials and local boards should also of its governance strategy,the city should take the follow- continue to contribute to and build from conversations that ing steps: are already underway locally,such as through the Miami Design Preservation League's annual Resiliency Workshop, ■ Continue to recognize the inherent value of the city's and engage with international conversations on historic historic architecture. preservation and sea level rise,such as the"Keeping Undertake new assessments of the city's historic History above Water"conference series.Requiring resources,given the extent of vulnerability to climate review boards to adhere to performance-based goals on change,using the modeling technology previously managing stormwater in historic districts will also lead to explored in this report. discussion about opportunities and tradeoffs,as explored in the"Regulations"section of this report. Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1176 of 1637 59 Miami Design Preservation League Annual Resiliency Workshop Miami Design Preservation League,the city's preeminent as the city's planning director,city commissioner,and a local preservation organization,held its Annual Resiliency Historic Preservation Board member. Workshop on April 7-8,2018.The event began with a lecture series,followed with a day of site assessments in The workshop focused on five key lessons learned:change the Flamingo Park neighborhood.The workshop focuses beginning at the local level,interdisciplinary efforts,effective on"solution-based ideas"for resilience and preservation government communication and early stakeholder involve and uses a multidisciplinary approach.Attendees and ment,economic incentives for preservation adaptations, speakers included keynote speaker from FEMA Nicholas and how to continue to lead in resilience efforts as a city. A.Shufro,lawyers,engineers,academics,and designers, With over 30 percent of the building stock designated as as well as City and local government representatives such historic on the local level,preservation is and will be a critical element of plans for the resilience of Miami Beach. • Establish performance-based goals for managing storm- Keeping History above Water water in historic districts,and work with key stakeholtl 'Keeping History above Water"is an annual preservation ers to establish innovative ways to achieve these goals conference addressing the challenges of sea-level rise (more information in the"Regulations"section of this and historic preservation and exploring precedents and report). potential solutions.The conference recently began in 2016 with the Newport Restoration Foundation(NRF)and • Implement changes in local review boards to improve was hosted by Annapolis,Maryland,in 2017,including knowledge of resilience in everyday decision making participation by ULI's Urban Resilience program. (see the"Regulations"section of this report). The conference strives to create an interdisciplinary • Begin to establish strategies to fund necessary adapta environment for people involved in preservation—from tion work,consider how adaptation fits into existing elected officials to designers to engineers—to discuss protecting historic structures,emphasizing real-world preservation policies,and strategize about phasing of applications.46 After the initial year,the NRF partnered investments,prioritizing the city's"historic jewels." with the U.S.chapter of the International Council on Monuments and Sites to create a Knowledge Exchange • Be ready to lead this conversation internationally,building on Climate Change and Heritage 47 Through this from dialogues already underway locally and nationally. exchange,diverse historic communities,including critically endangered ones such as Annapolis and New Over the long term,the city should be ready to critically ex- Orleans,have had the opportunity to engage in an amine what comprises historic preservation and consider international dialogue on historic coastal resilience. definitions focused on both strict preservationist approach- es and approaches focused more broadly on urbanism, ' walkability,and district character that may support more adaptation investments being made. _`rr=`Il �¢ ;`�. Other cities across the world are likely to look to Miami 1 / _ ,. • Beach for leadership on this topic and learn from the city's • process and decisions. -- A packed room shows the popularity of the"Keeping History Above Water:Annapolis"conference of 2017.Professionals and officials meet annually to discuss strategies to adapt and protect historic structures from sea-level rise. 60 Page 1177 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report Financing FINANCE IS CRITICAL for an effective stormwater Once costs and benefits are assessed,the city needs to management and climate adaptation strategy and will be carefully consider the most effective revenue streams that front of mind as the city of Miami Beach determines how link to the benefits businesses and residents receive from to implement the many strategies needed to better live investments that improve stormwater management and with water. climate adaptation.The following revenue streams could be considered for contribution: Sources of finance include public and private capital as well as contingent capital,such as insurance.A close ■ Assessment districts,such as a business improvement relationship exists between insurance and capital flows. district,where a special levy can be introduced,although Insurance can lower the cost of capital as it reduces the they will require approval of the County Commission; risk of default. Lenders typically require insurance for loans,both commercial and residential. • Incremental finance or land value capture districts where increases in value tied to stormwater management and The city should take a holistic view of finance that climate adaptation can be used to finance solutions; recognizes the role stormwater management and climate adaptation play in the pricing of insurance premiums.This • Incentive programs or fines stemming from building ensures a stable tax base and good credit rating so the owner lack of action; city is able to deliver the stormwater management infra- • Increases in stormwater fees and other rates;and structure Miami Beach needs to adapt to climate change. By retaining a robust tax base and growing economy,the • State and federal grants that may be available—the city city will have a range of revenue streams to consider. should decide when these sources may be appropriate, without relying on these funds because they may not be Building on the recently commissioned stormwater busi- available in perpetuity. ness case analysis,the city needs to continue to progress on a more comprehensive approach in evaluating existing The need for adapting private properties to the risks of costs and benefits of stormwater and adaptation financing sea level rise is a significant burden for many businesses decisions: and residents.A community adaptation fund could be a unique solution. • The core of an effective risk financing strategy should be a total cost of risk(TCOR)approach.TCOR is a ■ The establishment of a community adaptation fund finance strategy that looks at underlying exposure and would provide low-interest loans to help residents and expected losses and then examines the cost of risk businesses finance the large upfront costs of retrof it engineering,insurance,and risk retention.It allows the ting properties.This could be tied to the property tax so most efficient use of capital for a given risk appetite. the loan gets transferred to a new owner,similar to a property-assessed resilience method tied to a mortgage. • Operations and maintenance costs need to be taken into consideration when evaluating solutions. Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1178 of 1637 61 • The fund could adopt a blended finance approach,using • Regular engagement with credit rating agencies to ensure an initial source of public capital backed by private a stable credit rating,keeping the cost of borrowing and sector capital that could be tied to reduced insurance associated taxes affordable,and emphasizing that the premiums,enhanced property values,workforce hous- city is reducing the vulnerability component of risk; ing,and the like. • Regular engagement with the insurance industry for To secure the public balance sheet,the city should feedback on how the city's investments in stormwater consider insurance as a form of risk transfer that can play management and climate adaptation can be reflected in an appropriate role in reducing the burden on taxpayers insurance premiums,thereby benefiting businesses and by offloading the balance sheet risk of implementing large residents; resilience projects. • A clear communication strategy aimed at investors • Take a TCOR approach in deciding where engineering to demonstrate that Miami Beach has a healthy and solutions should be used,where insurance should be prosperous future;and used,and when the risk should be retained by the city • Engagement with residents and businesses on the and its residents. changing landscape of climate risk disclosure from ■ Consider insuring key infrastructure critical to maintain- international regulators and financial institutions,to enable ing the resilience of Miami Beach to lower the burden more open conversations about how improvements the additional repair costs place on the city's ability to city is making have a positive impact on asset values. service the debt of building resilient infrastructure. By bringing together new revenue streams that are equi- • Because 84 percent of properties in Miami Beach are table,risk based,and tied to the total cost of risk,the city covered by NFIP,outline an insurance pool for the city has the opportunity to explore new risk transfer solutions should NFIP undergo significant negative changes in and communicate its strategy with financial stakeholders the future.Insurance pools have been successfully in a way that improves confidence. implemented in the Caribbean,New Zealand,the United Kingdom,and other parts of the world to ensure access In summary,the panel recommends that the city do the to affordable insurance. following: • Discuss the role parametric insurance,which pays a • Continue to comprehensively evaluate existing resilience preagreed amount when a particular condition is met, costs and benefits. could play in dealing with some of the chronic risks • Find effective revenue streams to link to stormwater and sunny-day flooding and noncatastrophic storms present resilience benefits. to the stormwater system. • Establish a community adaptation fund. ■ Advocate for living with water to insurers diversifying their portfolio and otherwise potentially moving policies ■ Use insurance as a form of risk transfer to reduce away from coastal Florida. taxpayer burden. Finally,finance must be integrated into the city's commu- • Integrate financing into the communications strategy. nication and engagement strategy.Finding a credible and clear way of communicating how investments in resilience benefit credit ratings, lenders,investors,taxpayers,and visitors includes the following: 62 Page 1179 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report Regulations MIAMI BEACH'S CURRENT STORMWATER manage- ment '•'� strategy focuses largely on investments in public ' infrastructure.However,the regulation of private develop- ment offers an important opportunity that is not thoroughly ] .y integrated into the current water management strategy. • - Sea-level rise and sunny-day flooding present grave ai_1 ° threats to the community.Addressing these issues should ® j 3 This Publix supermarket be a high priority for any new development and should be was initially built at a higher considered alongside long-time priorities such as historic i I 8 elevation,so when loval roads • were raised,it actually became preservation and environmental impact. x more accessible. Using regulatory tools to influence the development and the incentives will not generate the additional tax money redevelopment of property will allow Miami Beach to take required to invest in resilient infrastructure. advantage of the natural building cycle to spread the cost of enhancing resilience over time and leverage private Miami Beach should consider the following regulatory financing and expertise.Miami Beach is in a privileged opportunities: position given the high value of land and the desirability ■ Embed water management goals in development regu- of the community:the city should leverage this private lations and/or incentivize resilient design. financing and expertise to help achieve the goals of a more ambitious resilience plan. • Leverage and reform regulatory boards. Precedent already exists for these types of regulatory • Adjust stormwater fees. changes in the recent ordinances offering increased height ■ Create an islandwide sea barrier,including enacting and density for taller first floors to accommodate climate regulations to allow centralized efforts. adaptation measures.Increased regulations specifically addressing stormwater will allow the city of Miami Beach • Continue to support elevation for new construction. to regulate private development to accommodate green infrastructure and manage water at the parcel and building Embed Water Management Goals in levels,as well as continue to invest in neighborhood and Development Regulations citywide infrastructure.The city can also use its existing regulatory infrastructure to incentivize increased storm- To implement the integrated water management strategy water management at the parcel level. necessary to protect Miami Beach,the city will have to manage water at the parcel and building levels as well as Implementing new regulations is likely to require an invest- continue to invest in neighborhood and citywide infra- ment in additional city staff,which is critical to manage structure.Parcel and building level water management a potential uptick in development approvals or a more can make a huge contribution.For example,Philadelphia's complex process. If development is backlogged or delayed, Green City, Clean Waters plan,kept 1.5 billion gallons of Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1180 of 1637 63 polluted water out of the rivers annually in its first five years, There,new development projects must adhere to a points- using 1,100 individual stormwater tools implemented by based resilience quotient,a matrix featuring building-scale both private developers and Philadelphia Water.48 interventions related to risk reduction,stormwater man- agement,and energy resilience,all of which are awarded Embedding water management in private development different numbers of points. regulation can be accomplished through a mix of require- ments and incentives such as rebates,density bonuses, Moving forward,the city should take the following actions: and expedited permitting.In Miami Beach,almost all new development and most rehabilitation and redevelopment • Continue to allow greater height and density,given require the approval of multiple regulatory bodies,and the future loss of usable space(i.e.,floors designed to further certainty in the approvals process can be a key accommodate future raised entryways)as groundwa motivator for the incorporation of sustainable or resilient ter rises and tidal and stormwater flooding increase. design approaches. Although increased height may not always be politi- cally popular,additional elevation can offset the loss of Beyond the recent ordinances addressing building height, ground-level floors for productive use. Miami Beach already has other incentives in place to encourage sustainable design,but it does not currently • Develop additional design standards and specifications have incentives for stormwater management specifically. to help mitigate the impact of increased height.These For example,developments larger than 7,000 square feet resources will not only be critical for Miami Beach but are required to comply with LEED Gold or more stringent will also be important resources for many other cities parameters."On the water conservation side, Miami-Dade grappling with sea level rise. Water and Sewer Department has irrigation restrictions • Explore opportunities for incentives for multifamily and and offers rebate programs related to water efficiencies for commercial properties that specifically incorporate landscapes,showerheads,toilets,and faucets.50 Incentives stormwater management,green infrastructure,cisterns, are also in place for other types of development,such as and other opportunities for water capture and reuse. density bonuses for the incorporation of affordable housing. Incentives could include the following: The city also should look into models for incorporating re- • Streamlined development approval process; silient design into regulations,whether through incentives or requirements.Norfolk,Virginia,provides one example. • Greater density,addressing setbacks,height,or floor/area ratio; • Flexibility on historic preservation requirements;and • Public financing in the form of grants,loans,or guarantees for single-family housing. pool--- The Miami Beach Properly Management Facility,constructed in 2009,was required to be certified LEED Gold. 64 Page 1181 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report Examples of Stormwater Management Policies Cities across the United States have taken a range of approaches to stormwater management policies.The following policies,which do not reflect all policies in each market,represent a cross section of types and approaches that may be relevant to Miami Beach.5t City Policy type Example project Further information Administrator For more information A nonresidential property must The program relies on ERUs to calculate Stormwater pay a fee calculated on its fees.The ERU increases yearly based on the Services,under impervious area,its number Consumer Price Index.An ERU in Boca Raton is htlps://Www.myboca.us/693/ Boca Raton,FL Fee of equivalent residential units determined as 2,837 square feet,the average the Department Stormwater-Management (ERUs),and$3.35,the current amount of impervious surface on a local of Municipal value of one ERU. residence. Services The city purchased 19 Charlotte has operated a buyout program Charlotte- http://charlottenc.gov/ Charlotte,NC Buyout and buildings of apartments in a since 1999.Originally using FEMA funding, Mecklenburg Storm Water/Flooding/Pages/ acquisition floodplain and relocated the it now relies on stormwater fees to help fund Storm Water FloodplainBuyoutProgram. residents. the program. Services aspx On a mandate from the mayor,the city A new development must overhauled the Floodplains section(Chapter Houston Public https://library.municode.com/ Houston,D( Regulation be built two feet above a 19)of its Code of Ordinances in early 2018, Works/Houston fx/houston/codes/cotle_of_ 500 year floodplain, amending all 42 pages.Development must City Council ordinances?nodeld=COOR_ now reference a 500-year floodplain instead CH19FL#fn_81 of a 100-year floodplain. Stormwater regulations are one aspect of New development, Philadelphia's Green City,Clean Waters plan, Philadelphia redevelopment,and which addresses stormwater quantity and https://www.pwdplanreview. Philadelphia,PA Regulation Water retrofits trigger stormwater quality through strategies for public and private org/manual/chapter-1 management requirements. investment,using both development regulations Department and stormwater billing. The Stormwater Overlay area requires that https://library.municode.com/ A new home bein built in the any development or land disturbance that g meets its requirements(even 10,000 square ordinasburgh/codes/cotle_oi_ Pittsburgh,PA Regulation Stormwater Overlay must go feet of disturbance,less than one-quarter of Department of rdinances?nodeld=PIZOCO_ through a Stormwater Plan City Planning TITNINEZOCO_ARTIIIOVZODI_ an acre)must submit a Stormwater Plan.The Review. plan requires existing conditions,a stormwater CH906ENOVDI_ analysis,premits,and maintenance programs. 906.07STMAOVDI The program seeks to prevent downspout The city encourages private water from causing sewer system backups. Portland Portland,OR Voluntary stormwater management From 1983 to 2011,56,000 downspouts were Environmental https://www.portlandoregon. program through the Disconnected removed in Portland,and today the program Services gov/bes/54651 Downspouts Program. helps prevent 1 billion gallons of water from entering the system annually. The market for Stormwater Retention Credits Stormwater D.C.'s Department of Energy enables developers to purchase credits toward D.C.Department Washington,DC Retention Credit and Environment has created compliance with current stormwater regulations. of Energy and https://doee.dc.gov/src Trading System the first stormwater credit The market also creates an opportunity for Environment market in the United States. landowners to receive an income stream from functioning green infrastructure. Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1182 of 1637 65 Leverage and Reform Regulatory Strategies for ensuring that water management is addressed Boards could include the following: Miami Beach has a very robust regulatory infrastructure ■ Add members to the Historic Preservation Board and the system,including four regulatory boards governing new Design Review Board,either in the existing seats or by development: creating additional seats,who have expertise and back- ground on water management and climate adaptation. • Historic Preservation Board; To effectively consider and advance water management • Design Review Board; goals,members with appropriate technical backgrounds are needed.Given that Miami Beach is a leader in re- m Planning Board;and silience,locating individuals with the appropriate water • Zoning Board of Adjustment. management and resilience expertise to sit on these boards should not be difficult.Having this perspective Miami Beach should leverage these regulatory boards and and knowledge base consistently represented and part revisit their charters and missions to ensure that water of board deliberations and decisions will ensure that management is prioritized at the building and parcel levels. the topic remains a priority. In addition,existing board Although the city and its boards are taking steps in that members should receive training on these topics to give direction,the missions and charters of existing boards them clear guidance on the strategies they should be should be expanded to give equal priority to water man- using and applying.There is precedent elsewhere in agement.Water management is an existential issue for the United States for requiring training on this topic.In Miami Beach,and it must be given an equal footing with 2017,Rhode Island approved legislation that required other public priorities, including design,historic preserva- all members of local planning commissions or boards to tion,and economic development. receive training on floodplain development and sea-level rise,including modules on climate change,flooding, mapping tools,and stormwater. The Natural Building Cycle • Allow real estate professionals to participate on these The natural building cycle is the pace at which boards,because real estate expertise is needed to buildings are reinvested and updated or replaced. understand how to effectively finance potential future Working within the context of this cycle can minimize retrofits or investment in resilient infrastructure.Cur- potential disruptions and excess costs,as well as rently,restrictions limiting participation from developers prevent risks from adapting aging buildings.When constructing new buildings,flood adaptation measures include rules against members contracting with the can be integrated more seamlessly.Established city and against using Community Development Block structures could receive resilience adaptations when Grants. being maintained,for instance by adding energy- efficient windows instead of making a like-for-like • Provide training and technical support to both boards replacement.Less invasive interventions could be on water management issues(as referenced above). used for older buildings,such as operational changes, This should include training and context on current chal- including moving storage that is at risk for flooding. lenges,projected future conditions,tools available to By leveraging the building cycle,owners can make building adaptations more efficient and accessible.52 manage water,and the city's stormwater management and resilience strategies. 66 Page 1183 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report • Provide specific measurable water management goals that the boards are responsible for helping achieve A for the respective watersheds and districts.Providing , • • the boards with measurable goals at the district andri e4 r watershed levels will give them greater flexibility in -. • how they balance historic preservation,design,and '"` 'z� economic development goals on a property-by-property • _ ��,t '' basis and will enable them to put site-specific decisions a� 1 ! • and tradeoffs into context.For example,a district could " fi`1' � a Stormwater fees have helped g fund stormwater infrastructure be required to achieve 100,000 gallons of water stor- ` • kb.— • 4 and hazard mitigation. age,which would need to be allocated within both new development and public spaces and rights-of-way. permeable driveways,green roofs,and green spaces to lower fees.This updated structure will reward property • Ensure that the planning department has the staff and owners that effectively manage water on their property and outside support to review and approve proposed devel- decrease the burden on pumps. opment and redevelopment projects.Additional staff with technical knowledge will be needed to support the At this point,the stormwater fee has been a very effective boards in their decision making.Without this staff,the tool for raising funds as well as awareness of stormwa approval process will bottleneck,and the pace at which ter investment.A next step will be modifying the fee to water management is improved will grind to a halt. encourage on-site water management at the parcel level. This modification will also offer an educational opportunity to share tools for on-site water management(such as Adjust Stormwater Fees cisterns,permable pavers,and so on)with homeown- A mix of incentives and requirements will nudge more ers within the city's broader Miami Beach Rising Above property owners in Miami Beach to capture,contain,and communication efforts.Implementation of on-site water treat water on their own properties,which will greatly management can even lead to zero fees for homeowners benefit the city as a whole.Central to this strategy is the generating zero runoff. stormwater fee.53 The city should be applauded for re- cently introducing a fee and using it to fund the stormwater Models for the city to consider include the following: management improvements underway—and for passing • Rates based on square feet of connected this fee without major opposition.The city's entrepreneur- impervious area; ial approach of using this fee,given the opportunity for its introduction without involvement from the county,should • Other,more complex rate formulas,such as also be lauded.However,the current flat rate does not • Fees based on impervious areas as a percentage encourage retention of water on private property. of gross area; As a next step,the city should adjust the current storm- • Fees based on an average of impervious area per water fee structure from a uniform fee across the board single-family residence;and to one that assigns a fee according to each property's runoff levels.This structure would look at both the size of • Fees based on the likely runoff factor on site,consid- a lot and the percentage or area of connected green and ering impervious area,slope,and soil type;and permeable surfaces,thereby encouraging investment in Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1184 of 1637 67 Stormwater Fee Structures Stormwater fees can take a range of forms,many of which encourage homeowners,businesses,and developers to implement on-site stormwater management and decrease impervious surfaces.This explanation of different types of fees has been sourced and subsequently modified from a report produced by the Bureau of Governmental Research in New Orleans.For more information,see the source notes. Type Details Formula Charged by gross property area Development intensity as compared to the percentage of Fee:Gross area x Rate applicable impervious area,charging more for to percentage of impervious area sprawling structures. Charged by classifying parcels Dual fee into categories for residential or Fee: Rate per type of parcel nonresidential and levying a flat fee. Based on the impervious area Fee:(Impervious area rate x Equivalient hydraulic area(EHA) compared to total gross area,as a Impervious area)+(Pervious area combined effect. rate x Pervious area) Based on the average impervious surface area of a local single- Residential fee: 1 ERU(base Equivalent residential unit(ERU)' family residence.The ERU value rate); Nonresidential fee:Total is used for single residences,but impervious area/1 ERU x ERU fees for other types are calculated base rate based on their individual surfaces. Flat-parcel fee A standard fee per parcel. Fee:Rate per parcel Gross area Based on total gross area of a Fee:Gross area x Rate per square property multiplied by a base rate. foot Fee based on the runoff of a property, Runoff including volume and rate,based Calculations vary on different environmental factors. Charged by measuring the total Fee:Total impervious area x Rate Total impervious area impervious area and multiplying by per square foot a base rate. Sources:Bureau of Governmental Research,Beneath the Surface:A Primer on Stormwater Fees in New Orleans(New Orleans, February 2017), www.bgr.org/files/reportsBGR StormwaterFees2017 Report.pdt;Amanda M.Dritschel, The Impact of Different Stormwater Fee Types:A Case Study of Two Municipalities in Virginia"(MS thesis, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, 2016),https.//vtechworks.lib.vtedu/bitstream/handle/10919/71379/Dritschel AM T 2016.pdf?sequence=l&isAllowed=y. *1 ERU is the average impervious area for single-family residences within the relevant jurisdiction. ■ A trading system for retention volume,such as Wash- These systems can lead to more widespread adoption ington,D.C,'s Stormwater Retention Credit system. of green infrastructure across a greater metropolitan This type of system offers developers the opportunity to area,including underserved areas as well as areas purchase stormwater retention credits implemented off experiencing redevelopment.The implementation of site,but within the watershed,of a development project. green infrastructure on underserved sites can also offer opportunities for cottage industries related to green infrastructure maintenance and workforce training. 68 Page 1185 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report Create an Islandwide Sea Barrier The city currently instructs property owners to manage • • seawalls on a parcel-by-parcel basis.This approach does not encourage consistency in terms of height and quality and therefore does not provide the level of protection required. t As part of a more holistic resilience strategy,the city In Miami Beach,seawalls should enact new regulation for a centralized approach • J generally have been managed creating an islandwide sea barrier that could incorporate on a parcel-by-parcel basis, 44. which prevents cohesive both walls and barrier protection.Investing in a seawall '�r~ ` o protection. Stormwater Retention Credit Systems Mount Olivet Cemetery,built in 1858,recently just finished annual fees for its impervious surfaces,stemming from a the first phase of a green infrastructure program that charge of$25.18 for every 1,000 square feet.55 The rate was designed to pay for itself.The unlikely candidate is a drastic increase from 2009,when it was$1.24 for the was approached by the Nature Conservancy(TNC)to same area.DC Water,which charges the fee,is steadily participate in a local Washington,D.C.,program in which increasing its regulation as a part of a 20-year,$2.4 billion stormwater retention credits(SRCs)can be bought and project to reduce the more than 3 billion gallons of runoff sold.The cemetery has converted 18,000 of its 437,000 and sewage that enters the Anacostia and Potomac rivers square feet to date,creating bioretention cells and rain each year." gardens as well as other projects the staff could easily maintain,and hopes the credits it earns from such projects The upfront costs for the cemetery's program came ultimately will pay the$1.7 million tab fronted by District from outside sources.The funding came from District Stormwater LLC." Stormwater LLC,a new investment fund created by NatureVest,the TNC's investment sector,and Encourage Washington,D.C.'s SRC program began in 2013,when the Capital,a firm specializing in social and environmental local Department of Energy and Environment created more issues.Prudential offered the$1.7 million necessary,and stringent stormwater retention rules.To help cope with the program plans for repayment through SRCs exclusively, the changes,it introduced SRCs,which can be bought relieving the Archdiocese of financial responsibility.Such and sold on an SRC Market,the first of its kind in the projects have become increasingly popular in the District, United States.Developers whose projects cannot meet the with only 15 credits sold in its first year,increasing to stormwater requirements are allowed to purchase credits 105,000 in 2017.57 from entities that produce more than what is required. The plan envisioned the creation of opportunities for TNC's urban conservation director,Kahlil Kettering,has landowners such as churches,community organizations, lauded the efforts of the program,saying that the SRC and cemeteries,including those in underserved parts of market"is great because it provides an opportunity to the city,where excess land could be converted into green bring in new sources of funding to do conservation projects infrastructure with income-producing potential. and also show that you can use private equity[to finance] conservation outcomes."58 As an additional perk,the TNC approached the Archdiocese of Washington.D.C., Archdiocese's connections to the greater Catholic Church which manages the site,and proposed a stormwater create an information network that can spread stormwater program that would not just satisfy requirements,but could knowledge.DC Water's SRC program is a success story generate enough revenue to pay for itself through such that has the potential to creative positive outcomes not excess credits.The program was especially appealing just for the ecosystem,but for both buyers and sellers in a to the cemetery,which was facing almost$140,000 in development market. Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1186 of 1637 69 could have benefits beyond greater protection,such as °- the potential for an improved NFIP Community Rating "' , , , g System rating. i.it• ` To undertake this approach,the city could create the fol- k lowing plan elements: R ` "" r ■ Special assessment districts for affected properties, / ,�: ;.i which could include waterfront properties,properties =E;' :, p on and in the vicinity of the waterfront,or all of Miami ,� 'rr..;‘.440,.71,,:.,.I. di Beach—given that the entire city will be protected by an enhanced seawall,this final option may be the most i.,• f 910 appropriate; / fr' _ ■ A user fee;and , ea I :',1 rt • Other public funding mechanisms. `; i-_._ g Approval by the Miami-Dade County Commission is Ramps help with access to elevated buildings. required for implementation of a special assessment district.Recognizing that many funding partnerships and chitectural precedents on the island.Many local stakehold- other partnership arrangements are in place throughout ers and community members articulated concern about the county and in Miami Beach,the city should pursue this building elevation during the panel's visit,alluding to cost, strategy,given the urgency of enhancing the seawall. compromised aesthetics,and reduced privacy. Seawall investment and enhancement along private prop- Although the issues mentioned are valid concerns,the city erty could be addressed through the proposed community should continue to encourage the elevation of buildings adaptation fund. because of the dire need for protection from sea-level rise and potential peak storm events.As waters rise and Continue to Support Elevation for flooding becomes more regular,elevated buildings—or New Construction buildings with"floodable"first floors—will be the most Elevation is a very political topic in the community,given prepared to endure and will shoulder fewer costs for dam- the importance of Miami Beach's historic fabric and the ar- ages.Allowing additional building height will offset the loss of the ground-level floors for productive use. -, u -,441 As buildings are torn down or retrofitted in natural building Ali`°` i cycles, requiring elevation or flood-ready design on the '1 ground floor is appropriate.It is the most reasonable way to pace these investments,given the astronomical cost of t ;y. + Tr• S I f' raising many of the existing structures at one time. :,1 --,?r�- . }`� Moving forward,the city should continue to strategize about New construction in Miami ��`' 'c ' , : how to most sensitively promote building elevation and Beach is designed with living " °o,�.. * . . °t'° ` � ; � r.�� `'.,: ,, "'�*� �� ,�„ minimize potential impact on neighbors,including through space well above ground, 3 * .. s,_tr t.T _, allowing the ground floor .., .. the development of design frameworks and use constraints. to flood. Ste.. '4'; '7. .` . . 70 Page 1187 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report Communications MIAMI BEACH'S STORMWATER MANAGEMENT ;: f plan initially did not have a robust communications plan, • .41 and many residents interviewed during the panel process - .` complained about an early lack of information or op- portunity to engage meaningfully in discussions about '4 local infrastructural investments.However,the city has I • - since made great strides in communicating its resilienceNip C challenges and efforts to the local community,including H A packed house attending the through the Miami Beach Rising Above website.The city ULI panel presentation in April 2018 shows the engagement of should be recognized for the following robust and proactive ti local stakeholders. communications efforts: • Diverse methods of communication and community ■ Miami Beach Rising Above branding,which embraces outreach,which have included the following: the city's living-with-water dynamic and enables it to control the narrative and take ownership of its future. • Strong engagement on social media channels; The issues facing the city are complex,far reaching,and • Publications in magazines for residents;and divisive,however,and will continue to challenge the city • Hosting neighborhood meetings and educational for the rest of its foreseeable future.Addressing them will programs; require unceasing commitment,aggressive short-and long-term planning,innovative solutions,difficult decisions, ■ Tools and resources for residents,including workshops, and continual assessment and adaptation. reference guides,and personal impact calculators; Projections of weather patterns, impacts,and interven- • Development of the Rising Above website to serve as tion results vary considerably,and the city's response an all-inclusive resource and guide on the city's chal- will change significantly over the course of its adaptation lenges,plan,and efforts; process.One thing that is certain is that Miami Beach's future will involve living with higher levels of water more • High-quality communication materials; often.The city needs to recognize that communicating this ■ Commitment to including and engaging all of the city's future to its residents and weaving it into the city's identity stakeholders; are necessary to garner long-term support for adaptation measures. • Development of crucial channels of communica- tion within the community through engagement with Moving forward,the city should maintain its focus on com- neighborhood leaders,homeowners associations,and munications as a key tool to the success of its long-term community groups; survival.In addition to continuing to pursue current strate- gies,the city should strive to incorporate the following • Collection and analysis of data regarding outreach efforts recommendations: to date,and subsequent adaptation of strategies;and Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1188 of 1637 71 • Build on comprehensive efforts and focus on promoting The Miami Beach Rising Above website is one critical re- the Miami Beach Rising Above website as the primary source with strong branding and a positive outlook,which resource for residents and business owners. embraces the city's living-with-water dynamic and enables it to manage the narrative.The website is an all-inclusive • Be bolder in its communications,engagement,and resource and guide to the city's resilience challenge and marketing strategies. includes materials that are clear,concise,and accessible • Build public trust through constancy,clarity,and im- to community members without technical knowledge of proved transparency. engineering and climate change. • Create a broad communications plan focused on resil- The city has also complemented this website with diverse ience and stormwater management,including informa- methods of communication and outreach,including social tion developed specifically for different audiences. media engagement,neighborhood meetings and educa- tional programs,articles in magazines for residents,and • Improve the diversity and robustness of communications. other engagement with neighborhood leaders,homeown- • Leverage others to spread the city's messaging,grow ers associations,and community groups. networks,and gather support. The city cannot hope to achieve the necessary work to • Create opportunities to celebrate successes. adapt to climate change without a base of widespread and dedicated community support and engagement. Miami More information on each of these recommendations Beach should actively and aggressively build this base follows. within its community and must leverage its community to spread its message and contribute to its solutions. Promote the Rising Above Website Throughout these efforts,the city should focus on promot- as the Primary Resource ing the Miami Beach Rising Above website as the primary, comprehensive resource for the city's residents and Since the early days of the stormwater management pro- business owners and enabling community members and gram,the city of Miami Beach has made significant strides leaders to share and promote the city's message and goals The Miami Beach Rising Above in communicating resilience challenges and opportunities. within their own networks. website offers an excellent guide to local resilience planning. xw • CLIMATE SCIENCE - CI: MA'Tf CLIMATI `; ._ ADAPTATION MITIGATION a1 - .. �;_ - `., `RESlUENCY STORMWATER \ , _ IIK � X-IRAI to 2, .�.t+.isx ►, i.ii ar .1 2 i.. . 72 Page 1189 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report Be Bolder in Communications Strategy Northern Virginia: "Only Rain Down the Storm Drain" Although the existing communications portfolio,particularly the Miami Beach Rising Above website,offers excellent The Northern Virginia Clean Water Partners have worked to create a regional stormwater campaign, resources,the city can do more to communicate climate helping mitigate a polluted runoff problem in the challenges and hone the messaging for both local and region."Only Rain Down the Storm Drain"branding global audiences. was introduced in 2011,including a website and regional radio spots. The city of Miami Beach is on the front lines of resilience challenges worldwide,and its process and strategies are Each year,efforts have expanded into a larger being watched and analyzed by municipalities around campaign,where televised public service announcements and internet ads increasingly inundate the world.The current headlines and narrative are often the market.To augment the marketing efforts,storm dire and paint the city as one of the first global victims of drains in cities such as Alexandria are labeled with climate change. the logo—featuring a shad,a local fish—and tell the location of the drainage output for awareness.59 The city should not shy away from this narrative and avoid discussing the difficult questions and topics it raises. More recently,in 2018 the program began a"Write as Instead,the city should strive to embrace its challenges as Rain"subcampaign,using messages written on the sidewalk in resin polymer.An example features a shad part of its current identity and shape the narrative.Miami with"Your river starts here"written above it,combining Beach should aggressively promote itself as the leader in the recognizable image with pleas for awareness.The climate resilience,serving as a testing ground and case writing appears only when exposed to water,reminding study to communities worldwide. citizens to be aware when it rains,and lasts for two to three months 6° The city has the potential to capitalize on its testing-ground status and should actively promote Miami Beach as the The combination of efforts over the years has largely been successful:in 2017,a regional survey resilient city at both local and global levels by communicat- showed that 62 percent of residents recognized the ing the city's adaptation measures and successes to key campaign logo,and 24 percent reported seeing the industries and power players around the world,including advertisements.61 those key to the city's financial success,such as investors, Currently,19 partners make up Clean Water credit rating analysts,politicians,and trade partners.The Partners,including governments,school systems,a communications strategy should also strive to combat university,independent water and sewer authorities, misleading information and negative media narratives: private businesses,and the Virginia Coastal Zone Miami Beach must be able to respond quickly and boldly Management Program.The program operates under to misinformation and negative press. the jurisdiction of the Northern Virginia Regional Commission,a political subdivision of Virginia made up of a group of local commissioners.62 The structure Build Public Trust through Clarity of Clean Water Partners allows the group to pool and Transparency resources to reach a broader audience for marketing and awareness efforts.The regional collaboration is Miami Beach's flood vulnerability is a complex and ever- an important example for municipalities to consider, changing issue.As weather patterns change,new adapta- especially when working with watersheds that tion methods are designed and studied,and lessons are transcend legal boundaries. learned,the city's approach and stance on many issues Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1190 of 1637 73 • Establishing a call-in resource center to answer the a r community's questions on resilience and resilience measures,serve as dedicated help resources to resi u' "�/ �e: dents and business owners,and field questions from Residents of Miami-Dade County '� `� the greater public;and meet at a local engagement session led by Catalyst Miami. : • Maintaining consistency among the communication Inclusive,transparent outreach r efforts will be critical in repairing 111 - • channels and methods used over time. a feeling of distrust felt by many s local people during the initial Few things will remain constant in the city's adaptation stormwater planning process. 3 strategy as it moves forward.Crucially,the city needs to emphasize communication on the adaptation process and and methods will continue to change and develop.This long-range plan over specific challenges and measures, constant evolution poses difficulty for the city in building while still taking the time to recognize benchmarks and a sense of trust with the community,which often relies on achievements.It should also strive for increasing transpar- clarity and continuity of messaging to grow public trust. ency by taking the following steps: Constancy,transparency,and robust public engagement • Own rather than avoid the city's resilience identity and and involvement are crucial aspects of any communica- living-with-water future. tion strategy because of their importance in growing the public's trust.These goals will be particularly crucial in • Acknowledge uncertainties,mistakes,and the unknown. Miami Beach as the city strives to address immense and • Ensure that communications are clear regarding complex challenges and implement monumental changes anticipated timelines for adaptation projects and the in a landscape of public fear,hopelessness,uncertainty, rationale and the cost analyses behind the city's deci- and mistrust. sion processes. Key local leaders and communicators—mayors,commis • Regularly bring in outside experts on climate topics. sioners,and trusted community and business leaders— should be identified,trained,and kept up to date on • Be willing to discuss and tackle tough topics and resilience measures,progress,and successes,and they answer difficult questions. should be provided with talking points relevant to their sec- tors.These messages will resonate with a broader range • Proactively address specific community concerns that of residents and other stakeholders and reach further arise,such as water quality. than messaging from experts on resilience or stormwater • Share live or near-live data publicly on the following: management.The city must work to maintain constancy and continuity of its communication,messaging,and • Flood levels; message-bearers by taking the following steps: • Water quality; • Naming dedicated community leaders as spokespersons • Service status; to share the city's resilience messaging with the public across platforms to clarify messaging and put trusted • City service response times;and faces before the public; • Resilience spending and budget. 74 Page 1191 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report Time will test the city's adaptation approaches and mea- Create a Broad sures and will provide clarity on successes,mistakes,and Communications Plan failings.To maintain the highest possible level of public trust throughout the adaptation process,the city should To increase community support,address issues of strive to refrain from"saving face"regarding mistakes mistrust,and ensure that a range of audiences is reached, rather than risk jeopardizing transparency and losing the the city should create a comprehensive and diverse tom public's trust. munications plan related to stormwater management and resilience.Much of this work is already underway but may The city should be clear and open about the fact that it is not necessarily be coordinated into a comprehensive corn- on the cutting edge of flood adaptation and is forging its munications plan about climate adaptation,clarifying how own path,which will require continual learning as well as different audiences are reached. adjustment and refinement of methods and approaches. The city should also acknowledge where mistakes have The plan should outline the stormwater management been made in the past and highlight opportunities for and resilience strategy and leverage neighborhood-level public engagement to galvanize support and rebuild the organizations and their leaders to communicate the city's community's sense of trust. challenges and strategies to the rest of the community. As described earlier,a key part of this plan is educating Stormwater Pump Station " "h UPGRADES 111 Rainfall High Tide EYent The eiecwcuec sy1em.s situated Ina higher lerel o prawn,realwrnon in cote of / big tiaadngt due M hurricanes i a Vit' Biscayne lay Water �i p `:• Capture •" Bar Screen Collects largo Vortex .1101 pieces d Winer Structure r t t y y r Ems' Rcc,ovas dt. Seawall d Rip Rap New 5.7' NAVA stow! Visuals on the Miami Beach Rising Above website explain the Aeration Chamber Backflow Pr.vnt.r functionality of new stormwater Oil totals at and is `6- infrastructure infrastructure to a lay audience. removed uslna vortex!'nvclu Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1192 of 1637 75 private citizens and providing them with tools and informa- ■ Renters in both single-family homes and multifamily tion they need to share the city's resilience messaging units; effectively within their own networks.This plan could also incorporate the communications strands for separate but ■ Small businesses; relevant communications initiatives,such as communica- ■ Hotels and other hospitality companies;and tions plans related to the Community Rating System or pilot projects featuring community engagement,such as ■ Civic and institutional buildings. the Bloomberg City Challenge. Residents participating in the interview process for the Part of the communications plan may also be providing panel expressed interest in having more information technical knowledge and toolkits specifically for different on personal adaptation measures that could be taken groups able to advance climate adaptation at the property alongside the city's infrastructural investment strategy and scale,such as the following: particularly requested information tailored to different sce- narios,that is,to single-family homeowners with complete • Homeowners of historic single-family homes; control of their property or a condominium owner making ■ Homeowners of recently constructed single-family decisions collectively with a condominiium board. homes; Increase Diversity and Robustness ■ Homeowners in small,multifamily co-op units; of Communications • Homeowners in larger multifamily units; The city should expand the robustness and diversity of its communication strategy to include pilot projects,educa- tional programs and events,and creative placemaking Training Stakeholders in strategies. Resilience The Building Resilience Network,based in Los Angeles, For example,Miami Beach should use living-with-water pi has become a leading example of stakeholder training lot sites and neighborhoods to provide the community with for resilience efforts,with a focus on training about how tangible examples of its proposed adaptation methods. to embed resilience into operations.The organization Pilot projects and case studies are excellent methods for offers training and workshops on resilience strategies broadening public understanding and acceptance for new with businesses,organizations,and communities. or complex interventions.These pilot projects should be One of the premier clients is LA Metro,the public used to explore and test the city's living-with-water adap- transportation network for Los Angeles County,which tation concepts and represent the city's vision for its future has open training sessions for all employees and aesthetic,public space,and quality of life.These pilot sites partners.Its training program reviews resilience topics, should be constantly promoted and referenced to raise then moves into identifying risks,preventive efforts, strategies and planning,and working with stakeholders. awareness of intervention methods,serve as measures of success,and educate and dispel misleading information Ninety-minute sessions are held once a week,and half- and negative press. day workshops once a quarter,with employees being able to opt in as desired.Members of the public are The city should continue to develop and implement welcome to attend workshops.Additional specialized educational programs,tours,and events to communicate workshops are available to focus on efforts for specific its resilience to a broader base of individuals and should teams or projects within LA Metro.Other clients are welcome to customize training for their own needs. use creative placemaking and public educational elements to augment the city's messaging and provide tangible 76 Page 1193 of 1637 A till Advisory Services Panel Report Resident Satisfaction with Cleanliness of , 40% Canals/Waterways by percentage of respondents wtto rated S3% the Item as"excellent"or"good° M frcIu ne'don't Snow') 57% 61% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% The city should be proactive 2016 2014 am 2012 imp 2009 in responding to community concerns,such as the 2016 CITY OF MIAMI BEACH RESIDENT SURVEY, ETC INSTITUTE g perception of water quality. examples to the public.Some of this is already underway network of community-led outreach partners to spread through the Rising Above website, including the develop- the city's message and lead discussions and adaptation ment of app-based and mobile tours of climate adaptation solution processes within their own networks.This should investments at Sunset Harbour and South Pointe Park. be done through a multifaceted approach including the following: Other communications projects underway,such as the flood communications technology being piloted through ■ Aggressive engagement in community-led planning and the Bloomberg City Challenge,represent exciting consensus-building processes; opportunities that should be embedded in the overall communications plan. ■ Growing a network of community outreach ambassadors and partners to reach a much larger audience including low-income and underserved communities that histori- Solicit Community Input and cally have been excluded from planning and engage- Leverage Other Resources ment processes; The city faces a particularly difficult issue of lack of ■ Partnering with local organizations and community community trust.Because of mistakes made in the past, groups;and many stakeholders now distrust the city's information, measures,and spokespeople.Rebuilding this trust will be ■ Leveraging the community's top communicators and a long process,which the city cannot afford to wait for to business and community leaders to spread information move forward.To address this issue and leverage existing within their respective circles. resources,Miami Beach should actively strive to grow a Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1194 of 1637 77 The city should inform and educate community and busi- buy-in,assisting other neighborhoods throughout their ness leaders and champions on the challenges,plan,and stormwater improvement processes,and inspiring them process,and provide them with the information and talking to contribute to the process and develop and champion points they need to communicate the resilience plan within solutions.Success of a program like this relies on resi- their respective communities. dents feeling engaged,valued,and informed throughout the process,as opposed to simply happy with the Neighborhoods in Miami Beach that have already experi- ultimate results. enced the first round of stormwater interventions generally responded positively regarding their effectiveness,even Miami Beach should also consider encouraging citizen sci- if they were not complimentary of the process.However, entists to collect and contribute data,soliciting community- many residents outside these neighborhoods still seem based observation and reporting,particularly on hot-topic confused about the interventions and unaware of their issues such as flood levels,water quality,and power successes,a clear missed opportunity for the city to use outages.This increases transparency,community sense existing pilot projects and community support. of contribution and ownership,and provides more varied opportunities for resident engagement and education. The communities and areas that have already seen posi- tive impact from the stormwater interventions should be leveraged as pilot projects and community ambassadors, Recognize Achievements and educating other neighborhoods and community groups Successes on the program and interventions,generating community The city of Miami Beach's resilience challenges will not have an end point,and its adaptation process will be con- tinuous and ongoing.To maintain community morale and '- sustain its commitment over the long term,the city needs SEPTEMBER 2 , to build workable goals and benchmark points into its plan that will allow the city to measure its progress,celebrate its achievements,and rally engagement and support for i next phases in the process. 4 - BEFO • ' 4 'SIR 2017 11 AFTER The improvements in Sunset Harbour are an example of one of Miami Beach's many storm water successes. 78 Page 1195 of 1637 A ULt Advisory Services Panel Report Conclusion THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH has made a proactive increased environmental volatility in the future.Accord- start to addressing sunny-day flooding,beginning execution ingly,efforts to address flooding will require an incremental of a projected$600 million stormwater management pro- approach,including regular opportunities for evaluation gram.The city has shown a clear commitment to addressing and recalibration.The city also should regularly step back this challenge,identifying local funding sources and making to ensure that climate adaptation efforts are benefitting the swift progress in the most affected neighborhoods. entire community,including low-income households,and Moving forward, Miami Beach needs to broaden its preserving the city's vibrancy and historic character. approach to more holistically and effectively address the The city asked this panel to evaluate the stormwater man- extent of flood risk faced by the city and enhance overall agement program and provide feedback,to help develop a resilience to the impacts of climate change,including more holistic vision for resilience in Miami Beach.However, sea-level rise.Strategies for flood mitigation need to ad- the bigger—and unspoken—question was what the long- dress the three distinct sources of flooding vulnerability: term opportunities are for the city,given the extent of risk coastal flooding,including king tides;flooding caused faced.Although the future is uncertain,the panel concluded by rainfall;and flooding from groundwater.An enhanced that the answer is in the city's hands.To make progress strategy should both approach these types of flood risk and address menacing environmental challenges,all in an integrated way and address other social,economic stakeholders need to show a willingness to work together, development,and environmental issues.Living with water as well as have some level of comfort with the likely costs is likely to be a key theme,and this proactive approach and inconveniences that will arise.Stronger collaboration will also present opportunities related to the city's brand- and greater interconnectedness among stakeholders and ing and cultural identity,particularly in comparison with between the city and stakeholders will be crucial. its coastal competitors. Miami Beach is already a national and international leader Resilience planning should not only entail investment in in its proactive approach to climate adaptation and is in gray infrastructure,as does the current plan,but also a good financial and cultural position to hone a living-with- adopt blue and green infrastructure tools and maxi- water approach.To move toward a more resilient future, mize impact through design,placemaking,governance, the community,the city,and its stakeholders should finance,and regulation strategies.Furthermore,the plan continue to build on the work already underway,crafting needs to prioritize clear outreach to and opportunities for a more integrated overall strategy and striving to preserve input from local stakeholders,residents,and the busi- and enhance the value,sense of place,and identity that is ness community,many of whom did not feel sufficiently unique to Miami Beach. engaged in past efforts. The challenges the city is facing do not have a finish line;they are ongoing.The impacts of climate change can already be seen,and the community will experience Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1196 of 1637 79 Appendix: Summary of Recommendations Topic Recommendation Page • Improve flexibility and robustness of current stormwater system 31 • Create an integrated,hydrodynamic computer model to better inform decision making on flooding issues and risk management 33 • Engage an owner's representative to consult on product selection • Purchase integrated modeling software • Add"flood risk model manager" position to ensure most productive use of model i • Implement blue and green infrastructure to advance a more holistic living-with-water approach 36 • Ensure appropriate modeling,study,and funding availability for green and blue infrastructure for living-with-water projects 38 • Implement living-with-water pilot projects 38 • Create tools for living-with-water projects at the building level 40 • Consider a level-of-service concept to guide future decision making 40 • Address water quality concerns 40 • Improve communications about engineering and infrastructural solutions 42 • Select design and infrastructure interventions that respond to the city's beach/bowl/bay typology 43 o • Within the beach zone, incentivize or require on-site water storage at the building scale • Within the beach zone,design green infrastructure and streets with capacity to filter water • Within the beach zone,explore opportunities for dunes to comply with FEMA 540 rule • Within the bowl zone,prioritize groundwater management •u • Within the bowl zone, implement green and blue streets to convey water o • Look to golf courses as underused green spaces for water management 45 ■ Consider modifying road specifications for permeability 45 L • Pursue opportunities with solar and renewables 47 a • Consider long-term options for neighborhood design and green space 47 • Partner with local arts and culture stakeholders 49 • Incorporate public art in the stormwater management strategy 51 • Identify artists through an RFP process • Include citizens,key stakeholders,and arts partners in selection and award process as d • Identify opportunities for synergy with national events such as Art Basel a ■ Involve and engage artists in the design process 54 CCS • Create open spaces that respond to resilience needs while engaging local artists 54 • Incorporate creative placemaking strategies in the communications plan 54 • Establish a Miami Beach Rising Above program delivery office 55 • Create a scientific advisory panel through the program delivery office 56 • Establish an agency for public investment and development in resilience;that agency would do the following: 56 • Establish opportunities for incremental value capture from real estate for use in resilience projects • Direct investment and development of resilience projects • Manage operations and maintenance of green and blue resilience projects • Explore opportunities for special assessment districts • Establish a community adaptation fund 57 • Establish a risk transfer department 57 • Consider new strategies to align historic preservation and climate adaptation 58 80 Page 1197 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report Topic Recommendation Page • Continue to comprehensively evaluate existing resilience costs and benefits 61 • Find effective revenue streams to link to stormwater and resilience benefits 61 • Establish a community adaptation fund 61 • Use insurance as a form of risk transfer to reduce taxpayer burden 62 • Outline an insurance pool for the city as a backup to NFIP • Consider parametric insurance • Advocate for living with water to insurers U- • Integrate financing into the communication strategy 62 • Engage with credit rating agencies to ensure stable credit • Engage with insurance industry regularly for feedback on resilience results • Create a communication strategy for investors • Engage with residents on climate risk disclosure • Embed water management goals into development regulations and/or incentivize resilient design 63 • Continue to allow increased heights and denisities to accommodate future raised entryways and floods • Use design standards to mitigate impact of height increases • Explore resilience incentives for multifamily and commercial properties • Leverage and reform regulatory boards 66 • Ensure that charters address water management at building and parcel levels o • Add climate or water management experts to Historic Review and Design Review Boards • Train existing board members on resilience • Ease restrictions on development and real estate professionals c • Provide boards with measurable water management goals • Hire additional staff to support and review development projects •Adjust stormwater fees 67 •Adjust from flat fee to one that accounts for property runoff •Allow fee to incentivize or encourage on-site water management • Create islandwide sea barrier, include enacting regulations to allow centralized efforts 69 • Continue to support elevation for new construction 70 • Promote Miami Beach Rising Above as the primary comprehensive resource 72 • Be bolder in engagement,communication,and marketing strategy 73 • Build public trust through constancy,clarity,and improved transparency 73 • Provide city leaders with training and talking points to spread resilience message • Name local leaders as resilience spokespersons o • Establish call-in resource center for resilience questions • Maintain consistency among communication channels • Share live data publicly on response times,spending,service,and water systems E • Create a broad communiciations plan focused on resilience and stormwater management 75 o • Increase the diversity and robustness of communications 76 • Solicit community input and leverage community members and leaders 77 • Create a network of community outreach ambassadors • Partner with local organizations and community groups • Consider encouraging citizen scientists to help with data collection • Recognize achievements and successes 78 Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1198 of 1637 81 Notes 1 "City Strategies,"100 Resilient Cities,updated 2018,https:// 16 Town of Emerald Isle:Comprehensive Land Use Plan,January 24, www.100resilientcities.org/strategies/. 2018,https://www.emeraldisle-nc.org/Data/Sites/1/media/pdfs/ 2 The current road elevation strategy is based on a king tide draft-emerald-isle-comp-plan_?-11-2017.1-small.pdf. elevation of 1.7 North American Vertical Datum(NAVD)in 2014, 17 Rush,Memo-09-13-2016-Item13. requiring an additional one foot of elevation to account for projected sea level rise elevation and another additional 18"Miracle Mile Streetscape,"Cooper Robertson,updated 2018, foot to elevate a road out of water for a 3.7 NAVD crown-of- www.cooperrobertson.com/work/miracle_mile_streetscape. road elevation. 19"Miracle Mile Improvements,"Cooper Robertson for the city of 3 Burden is defined as paying more than 35 percent of one's Coral Cables,July 2014,https://www.miamidade.gov/neatstreets/ income for housing.In addition,the median income of$49,444 library/coral-gables-slreetscape.pdf obscures the inequality shown by the mean income,which jumps 20 Monique 0.Madan,"Gables Commissioners Approve Downtown to$95,728 because it accounts for the highest income values. 'Streetscape'Plan,"Miami Herald,September 4,2014, ("American Factfinder,"U.S.Census Bureau,updated 2018, www.miamiherald.com/news/IocaVcommunity/miami-dale/coral- hitps://factfinder.census.gov/faces/nav/jsf/pages/index.xhtml.) gables/article1986898.html. 4 Rick Dixon,Florida Building Commission,"The Florida Building 21 Chabeli Herrera,"Miami-Dade Tourism Got'Knocked Down'in Code:Florida's Response to Hurricane Risk"(PowerPoint 2017.But Things Are Looking Up for Next Year,"Miami Herald, presentation,2009),https://www.sbafla.com/method/portals/ November 1,2017,www.miamiherald.com/news/business/ methodology/windstormmitigationcommittee/2009/20090917_ article182166466.html. dixonflbldgcode.pdf. 22"Miami Beach Historic Districts,"Miami Design Preservation 5 "American FactFinder,"U.S.Census Bureau,updated 2018, League,accessed June 2018,www.mdpl.org/about-us/about- https://facttinder.census.gov/faces/nav/jsf/pages/index.xhiml. miami-beach-design-styles/miami-beach-historic-districts/. 6 "Bishan-Ang Mo Kio Park,"2016 ASLA Professional Awards, 23"Miami Beach Historic Districts Database,"Miami Design American Society of Landscape Architects,https://www.asla. Preservation League,accessed June 2018,haps://www. org/2016awards/169669.html. ruskinarc.com/mdpvmb. 7 "Kallang River @ Bishan-Ang Mo Kio Park,"Singapore Public 24"Miami Beach,"mdpl.org. Utilities Board,2018,https://www.pub.gov.sg/abcwaters/explore/ bishanangmokiopark. 25 Vanessa Borge,°Art Basel,Miami Beach,Make 5 Year Deal 8 "Bishan-Ang Mo Kio Park,"ASIA. Official,"CBS Miami,October 5,2017,http://miami.cbslocal. com/2017/10/05/art-basel-miami-beach-pen-5-year-deal/. 9 "Bishan-Ang Mo Kio Park,"Rambo!!Group,updated 2018, 26 A.Markusen and A.Gadwa,Creative Placemaking:A White Paper www.ramboll.com/projects/singapore/bishan-park. for the Mayors'Institute on City Design(Washington,DC:National 10"Bishan-Ang Mo Kio Park,"Singapore National Parks Board, Endowment for the Arts in partnership with U.S.Conference of 2018,https://www.nparks.gov.sg/gardens-parks-and-nature/ Mayors and American Architectural Foundation,2010),3. parks-and-nature-reserves/bishan---ang-mo-kio-park. 27 Peter E.Howard,"Built Environment,"UM News Special Report, 11 "Bishan-Ang Mo Kio Park,"ASLA. Coral Gables,Florida,2018,http://climate.miami.edu/built- environment/. 12"Kallang River Bishan Park," World Landscape Architect,March 28,2012,http://worldlandscapearchitect.com/kallang-river- 28"Sea Level Rise and the Public Realm,"FIU/Miami Beach Urban bishan-park-singapore-atelier-dreiseitl/#.WyOar6dKi00. Studios,Miami Beach,Florida,June 9,2017,http://carta.fiu.edu/ mbus/event/fiuupenn-sea-level-rise-and-the-public-realm/. 13"ParkScore,"The Trust for Public Land,2018,http://parkscore. ipl.org/#sm.008w3jayl clgeeal l at11734mparo. 29"Evacuteer,"Evacuteer website,updated 2018, www.evacuteer.org. 14 Frank A.Rush Jr.,Memo-09-13-2016-Item13,to Mayor Barber and Board of Commissioners re Osprey Ridge Storm Water 30 Doug MacCash,"Giant Silver"EvacuSpots'Stick Men Point to Pump Station,September 13,2016,Town of Emerald Isle,North Hurricane Evacuation Sites in New Orleans," Times-Picayune, Carolina,https://www.emeraldisle-nc.org/memo-09-13-2016- 9,2013,https://www.nola.com/arts/intlex.ssf/2013/05/ item13. giant_silver_evacuspots_stick.html. 15 Frank A.Rush Jr.,Emerald Tidings(newsletter),January 2016, 31 MacCash,"Giant Silver'EvacuSpots.'" https://www.emeraldisle-nc.org/emerald-tidings-Jan2016. 32°Evactueer,"Evactueer. 82 Page 1199 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report 33"Evactueer,"Evactueer. 51 See,for example,Boca Raton:"City of Boca Raton Stormwater Management Regulation Compliance,'Restoration and Recovery, 34"Concept,"Growing Vine Street,updated 2018, 2014,http://rrstormwater.com/city-boca-ratan-stormwater- www.growingvinestreet.com/. management-regulation-compliance;Boca Raton Municipal 35"Growing Vine Street:The Beckoning Cistern and the Cistern Facilities and Services User Fee Schedule,October 1,2017, Steps,"Penn State Artful Rainwater Design,2014,https:// https://www.myboca.us/DocumentCenterNiew/6645/User-Fee- artfulrainwaterdesign.psu.edu/projecV%E2%80%9Cgrowing-vine- Schedule-100117-PDF?bidld=;Charlotte:Michaela L.Duckett, street%E2%80%9D-beckoning-cistern-and-cistern-steps. "Doral Apartments Coming Down,'Charlotte Post,July 7,2010, www.thecharlottepost.com/index.php?src=news&submenu=N 36"About Confluence Park,"Confluence Park,San Antonio River ews&srctype=detail&category=News&refno=2765;Houston: Foundation,accessed 2018,http://confluencepark.sariverfound. Keaton Fox,'On Close Vote,Council Approves New Rules for org/about-confluence-park'. Building in Floodplains,"KTRK-ABC13 News,April 4,2018, http://abc13.com/new-rules-for-houston-buildings-to-meet-500- 37 Kathleen Petty,"San Antonio River Foundation Unveils Park Meant year-f loodplains/3301062/;Pittsburgh:"Stormwater,"Pittsburgh for Education and More,"San Antonio Magazine,January 2018, Department of City Planning website,updated 2018,http:// www.sanantoniomag.com/January-2018/Confluence-Park'. pittsburghpa.gov/dcp/zoning/stormwater.html. 38"About Confluence Park,"San Antonio Found. 52 City of Boston,Climate Ready Boston:Executive Summary, 39"About Confluence Park,"San Antonio Found. December 2016,p.16,https://wwvv.boston.gov/sites/default/ files/02_20161206_executivesummary_digital.pdf. 40 Zeke MacCormack,"San Antonio's New Confluence Park Hailed as a'Game Changer,"My San Antonio,March 2018,https:// 53"Schedule A Modification to Stormwater Utility Ordinance,"Miami www.mysanantonio.com/news/local/article/San-Antonio-s-new- Beach Ordinance,August 18,2016,www.ordinancewatch.com/ Confluence-Park-hailed-as-12726215.php. files/82613/LocalGovernment115689.pdf. 41 Rocio Guenther,"Estela Avery's$750K Gift to Fund Confluence 54 Zoe Sullivan,"D.C.Cemetery Finds New Life as Stormwater Park Classroom," The Rivard Report,September 2017,https:// Retention Model,"Next City,June 5,2018,https://nextcity.org/ therivardreport.com/estela-averys-750k-gift-to-fund-confluence- daily/entry/dc-cemetery-finds-new-life-as-stormwater- park-classroom/. retention-model. 42 Daniel McGraw,"Confluence Park Celebrates San Antonio's 55 Sullivan,"D.C.Cemetery Finds New Life." Shifting Water Management Policy,"Urban Land,March 20, 56"Historic D.C.Cemetery Partners with Environmentalists to 2018,https://urbanland.uli.org/ptanning-design/confluence- Reduce Impervious Space,"Stormwater Report,February 27, park-celebrates-san-antonios-water-management-legacy/. 2018,http://stormwater.wef.org/2018/02/historic-d-c-cemetery- 43"Tanner Springs Park,"Portland Parks and Recreation,updated partners-environmentalists-reduce-impervious-space/. 2018,https://www.portlandoregon.gov/parks/finder/index.cfm? 57"Stormwater Database,"Department of Energy and Environment, propertyid=1273&action=viewpark. DC.gov,updated 2018,https://octo.quickbase.com/up/ 44"Tanner Springs Park,"Landezine,2013,www.landezine.com/ bjkxxcfcp/g/rb7/eg/va/levels.html?sitelevel=2&pagerecord= index.php/2013/03/tanner-springs-park-by-atelier-dreiseity. 90&userrole=Everyone%200n%20the%20lntemet. 45 John Englander,"Climate Change and Rising Sea Level: 58 Sullivan,"D.C.Cemetery Finds New Life." Implications for Historic Preservation,"Forum Journal 29,no.4 59"Only Rain,"Northern Virginia Clean Water Partners,updated (2015):3-8,https://forum.savingptaces.orglHigherLogic/System/ 2018,http://www.onlyrain.org/. DownloadDocumentFile.ashx?DocumentFileKey=58856f28-e8be- 9094-1148-5f67534d5263&forceDialog=0. 60 James Ivancic,°The Message:Nothing but Rain,Please," Fauquier Times,July 18,2018,https://www.fauquier.com/news/ 46"About,"Keeping History above Water,updated 2018, the-message-nothing-but-rain-please/article_b586a3f0-860f- http://historyabovewater.org/about/. 11 e8-8ed7-d3d3faed522e.html. 47"Interdisciplinary Partnerships:We're All in This Together," 61 Northern Virginia Clean Water Partners,2017 Summary,updated Keeping History above Water,October 19,2016,http:// 2018,http://docs.wixstatic.com/ugd/200411_5168bba9ef2a435 historyabovewater.orgfinterdisciplinary-partnerships-were-all- 0b9c8c6d0ac39d487.pdf. in-this-together/. 48"5 Down,20 to Go:Celebrating 5 Years of Cleaner Water and 62"About NVRC,"Northern Virginia Regional Commission,updated Greener Neighborhoods,"Philadelphia Water Department,2018, 2018,https://wmv.novaregion.org/8/About-NVRC. www.phillywatersheds.org/what_were_doing/documents_and_ data/cso_long_term_control_plan. 49 Joey Flechas,"Miami Beach Wants Developers to Go Green or Pay Fee,"Miami Herald,April 29,2016,www.miamiheratd.com/ newsllocal/community/miami-dade/miami-beach/ article74643237.html. 50"Miami-Dade Water and Sewer Department Rebate Programs," Miami-Dade Water,updated August 1,2018,www.miamidade. gov/water/library/rebate-programs.pdf. Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1200 of 1637 83 About the Panel Joyce Coffee IBM in 2005,she founded Tiger Management Consulting Group,a global training and business consulting firm. Panel Chair Chicago,Illinois She is the former executive director of CulturaIDC,where she worked closely with developers to integrate arts and Coffee is the founder and president of Climate Resilience culture into development projects across the Washington, Consulting and an accomplished organizational strategist D.C.,area.She currently serves as an executive coach and visionary leader with over 20 years of domestic and with Right Management and on many nonprofit art boards international experience in the corporate,government,and in the region. nonprofit sectors,implementing resilience and sustain- ability strategies,management systems,performance measurement,partnerships,benchmarking and reporting. Jeff Hebert She is a senior sustainability fellow at the Global Institute Baton Rouge,Louisiana of Sustainability,where she advises various high-level resilience groups,including the Global Adaptation and Re- Hebert serves as the Water Institute of the Gulf's first vice silience Investment work group and the National Science President for adaptation and resilience,where he leads Foundation's Urban Resilience to Extremes Sustainability the interdisciplinary work being done to help communities Research Network. better adapt to changing environments.In addition,Hebert is an adjunct faculty member in the graduate sustainable She received a BS in biology,environmental studies,and development program at the Tulane School of Architecture. Asian studies from Tufts University and a master's in city planning from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Before joining the Water Institute,he served as deputy Coffee holds the LEED AP professional credential from the mayor and chief administrative officer of the city of New U.S.Green Building Council. Orleans and as the city's first chief resilience officer,where he developed the city's first climate action strategy.Before joining the city of New Orleans,Hebert served as the Juanita Hardy director of community planning for the Louisiana Recovery Washington,D.C. Authority following the devastation from hurricanes Katrina and Rita. Hardy is the ULI Senior Visiting Fellow for Creative Placemaking,where she supports the Institute's Building He holds a bachelor's degree from New York University, Healthy Places Initiative.As the senior visiting fellow,Hardy earned a master's degree in city planning from the Mas- has done extensive writing and research on creative place- sachusetts Institute of Technology,and is a graduate of the making and has worked with ULI District Councils on pro- Achieving Excellence in Community Development program gramming and capacity-building activities.Hardy has over at Harvard University's Kennedy School of Government, 43 years of business experience,including 31 years with where he was a Ford Foundation Fellow. IBM,and over 35 years in the arts as a nonprofit leader, trustee,collector,and patron of the arts.After retiring from 84 Page 1201 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report Phillip Kash Walter Meyer Washington,D.C. New York,New York Kash is a principal at HR&A Advisors specializing in Meyer is an adjunct professor at Parsons the New School climate adaptation and housing affordability for cities.He for Design and founding principal of Local Office Land- has led the evaluation of climate risks for cities,developed scape Architecture.Operating between infrastructure, adaptation strategies,and supported the implementation urbanism,and territory,the firm has won awards from of adaption projects.Most notably,Kash developed the across the disciplines of architecture,landscape archi- climate change adaptation plan for the city of Boston,is tecture,public policy,science,and art.Before founding supporting the implementation of a resilience district in the the firm in 2006,Meyer worked in urban and landscape Gentilly neighborhood of New Orleans,and advised on the design at Cooper Robertson and Wallace Roberts&Todd. development of 100 Resilient Cities. He received his bachelor's degree in landscape architec- He also leads HR&A's housing affordability work to help ture from the University of Florida and his master's degree cities create neighborhood,city,and regional housing from the Harvard University Graduate School of Design. plans;develop new affordable housing programs and poli- cies;and redevelop public housing.Before joining HR&A, Christian Nyerup Nielsen Kash was a director at Enterprise Community Partners and led multiple technical assistance engagements focused on Copenhagen,Denmark disaster recovery,resilience,and affordable housing. Nielsen is the senior director for the global division for Cli- mate Adaptation, Landscape and Flood Risk Management Greg Lowe at Ramboll Water.He has more than 20 years'experience London, United Kingdom in stormwater management and engineering and extensive experience with project management of large-scale Lowe is global head of resilience and sustainability at Aon projects within infrastructure planning,urban development, plc,the leading provider of risk management,insur- and resilience planning,including flood risk management ance and reinsurance brokerage,and human resources for cities,regions,and infrastructure owners. solutions and outsourcing services.He is focused on leveraging Aon's leading proprietary analytics platforms to Nielsen's international expertise in the field of climate ad meet the needs of clients looking to address disaster risk, aptation and flood risk management has been developed climate finance,and the global protection gap.Heading and implemented on numerous projects on a global scale, Aon's strategy on sustainability and systemic risk,Lowe including the screening of megacities in Asia for the Asian leads dialogues with clients,investors,and regulators on Development Bank,Cloudburst Pilot for the New York City global environmental issues.He has collaborated with Department of Environmental Protection,storm surge pro organizations as varied as the United Nations,the OECD, tection planning for Washington,D.C.,low-impact develop- and the Urban Land Institute.Before working at Aon,Lowe ments in Copenhagen,and the detailed flood protection was an executive director at Willis Towers Watson,having plans for Copenhagen and Gothenburg,Sweden. begun his career in investment banking at UBS. He holds an MSc in environment and development from the London School of Economics and a BA in political economy from the University of Maryland. Miami Beach,Florida,April 16-19,2018 Page 1202 of 1637 85 Mark Osler Greg West Alexandria, Virginia Miami,Florida Osler serves as an associate vice president of Michael The president and chief executive officer of ZOM Holding Baker International and leads the firm's coastal science Inc.,West is responsible for all of the company's real and engineering practice,where he focuses on the analy- estate activities.Since joining ZOM in 1997,he has been sis of coastal hydrodynamics,impacts of sea-level rise, involved with all aspects of the development process, and resilient coastal design.He has provided management including identifying new opportunities and compiling and technical leadership for a range of coastal resilience due diligence and underwriting parameters.He has been projects,from rural community settings to urban,state, directly responsible for over$3.5 billion of development. and nationwide studies,encompassing considerations Before joining ZOM,he worked in a development capacity of riverine and coastal flood risk,changing precipitation for Paragon Group,where he implemented new multifam- patterns,and tsunami risk.Following Superstorm Sandy, ily developments and repositioned existing projects in the Osler led the flood risk vulnerability study and resultant Midwest and Florida. flood mitigation design at the World Trade Center,as well as analyses of climate change impacts to JFK,LaGuardia, West received a BA in accounting from Southern and Newark airports. Methodist University and has received two MS degrees from Texas A&M University in land development and He serves on the National Institute of Building Sciences construction management.He serves on the board of Scientific Resolution Panel,an independent group that re- directors of the National Multifamily Housing Council and views the accuracy of FEMA's flood analysis and mapping. sits on the Advisory Board and Management Committee Osler holds a bachelor's degree from Lehigh University and of ULI Southeast Florida. a master's degree from the University of Delaware's Center for Applied Coastal Research. 86 Page 1203 of 1637 A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report • „,..> a1 w i ria H . R �� Urban land Institute , 2001 L Street, NW Suite 200 Washington, DC 20036-4948 ®Printed on recycled paper. Page 1204 of 1637 •‘4 , \~.•'-':-'• ""-.-- 111111111114;221 ' "- ,:mT-1 : - , ' I, 7FIPP. :7,,-:' ' -'- ,,,•.,':•. . - ,„-. ,,,+* :, ''s ••-•-,...;:„),„i: : • ,. ,..!..' .., ',.k•t" ''... d.! .17, - '', '-'--r- ••••7 •-• i.-..;\:',......'. ;:t-'sitv,,ar7- , ,.,,.....,;',Itv%-ez,s.14.•riz..., - " -• '1,i„,•.,.. .1' : .....,„,,,...s.11.„ ,..,'74,44...,zr•k4. 1. ; . . .„ .'''' ,-;,-.., .. "t"a,..---:::•'..•••- - ,.' , -.:..A.''' •' .'.--$ , ' • -— - - - •- - • -•- ' , ....-.,..- __y,.7:15 .. i .i ,'',' .` ' • '''' •.:4 '', ,ik't '-‘ `,- ,1 • .),• -r-4' e, _ ... ............. Alifr,.1 .1 ' ‘s... , MOM- 4...trt I - - -,---/,' t•'' ' •.:,t4,,,r' '•••• •,?, 1 • •-.7..-' ...4.. - - • ' ' . • . ‘,s,.:4- 71-7-'W.; I ., , ,.,,,_ •• •7 . -, . •' "...4#"":----.4 -...z.V.,.... ' ..; ,-, . • • AI 4•4410irs . , t II!' ' . ' °1 .'•• t•t., 4,* • ---• S. 01 ' ,.••'• •'It liti •,::'., • 4 I 'f'.\7 1 . ' i•• •‘ :1' i• . \ '''• ... '. -'" y , 7 14 ., •ii \- .., ,.. • • \'..'' fa-,4c,, ., 4 • e. . , s Y•,,,, . . . ..,.....- ...... .. .. !!. ..-----• -- "411111/ . ' 4.• . . --.... - ,,/ _—4.-,..,--- --,..,,.......:‘,:•-•-,-,...,,,,- ,. .. •,, , ;•.-- -...-, • ,---. ?"-, ';',C- id i , ' ' ;I i ' . • '..'"`' :1 ' ' . '.. -, .._.,,, ,,;, -;," -'-' ,7:...F --A. '--- -•'''''--- ---'''''''''z' - ', :, - --------- ==- - / 1 0 _ . ..,• . .. . . , . -.• , , , asi.eadia4( uj 7 Ca_ -.....— 0 ,,. , I t. ......ta Ci) 4 .14Xiiri) i! < nr") ; 1 . -.,.- r" 4 - t. ' -• CZ < . li.A...--ri-r.. .::;., • Tr A.4. co co ,-- . , C\I , 0 •-•/41/4.. 4- ..a. 4 .14. • ' . •' ' 7',4. ' ' a) cy) .. , OSS° co .5 - • ' liaTaillit \ i:.I' iiiloi- .' ..j•r_.- • . ' .. . ,,,- .,- ,,...• dir A .....: , 7,.1 .,. 11r. - . tr...., .. , s. -. • ...,. 5 4* , r • . . 4.,.441L .10., t f .' 5 .,,..•-J1/4. ` q *s ' - •,4•• • ' t .40 •L• . • ,., kk• _.. __ IL. .....L__ It /•.,%;.•,. S. 4 1.0 j At'-I\ •' . • 4 II 1 A i 1, Hil 1 ..1,. 44001cIviirmov.:-.. . tailtirte,‘ ' • ' i : , ,, k -..t-''t', : '. t'; , ' • It:t , 'dr : ' t It ' ' •• 4 ' ' I 1 I „ i: t',• , \ 'N. • -— . .,... ....* .., . \ s....!-,: . - . 1 111 if ,. . I it' • ie, . Ilk e . ,,1 `Z\ ...)\14( ,...;•.t, .. fy I CO Ma 01111111 47,6.dim *Ma Oft OEN mow V) atm -t, Ite ; ___..1 i e•c44, .i r ' — . : ‘etiZ.- : ,* I `f ,�fx {c II !:',. i) :), At,{! tyet +l f' • Z 0 v) 0 \ L 00 Qi 0L r j �I p •� � � j cn` v CN O LJ..— CU Q� : Qj 0 0 ca...Z 4---1 Z •�.Z Q c ••t-• ....Z 0 v 0 L- p O 'i N z Q1 v o Qp Q, o �� Za, 4-J � v � Q = O i Z v) `tit U Z Q- C3 Z • . Q W �Q � vO o � 'o 4 _J I— ,, ,z...,_ • Z V)Z —C.3 (D I— CO QJ •Zvv -00 •� Q, wPw __. c:).. c,„ v CU Z Z v O v Lf) C3 QJ _Z Z E v� z c3 I o OQ.) O � L- ZQQjjj Zv ( � � � >. 0 � � s -0 Z � Z L v � -is.) Q.) -4--) O - O QJ `'�4....) Q.)`ti v v 0 4' 4� i L I' rIIf)qj V) v z� � L vv v � v0 OCD HO • • . • . , . ..,„ .. ,i ,\ - t 4 r f O N- . e' ' is " , 04100.... — ' s k Am o A. ' ish a, '+ 'III le cli). /i , Ate. y , • ... it" . gill' t10 ck, a QJ •- v V 4) ._ •_ ,. 0 CLrIA .I_- Jr1-:',•111:i.'% .,5,,.., } s ),1T `i ? r 1 Q ••'•/,ti ?`' r H. • �1 .. ' zi .. 4; �, ._ ( i rf `�! v ,' ‘4Irtic,7.- . t --Nomi 06 , I two/ LLJ . ---111111.1A ' *2 c f: 3 �R{{ vil (..) Q.) ti O i o co 0 N r CD 73 ( aaz E z z ............ , ,. L. , , "..... "1 .._ .79. Q j t O z v a z a' O •� o a •� I . •� z 0 v z O O z . 0 • •Z a) `; v cn v _I szu D cC • • • • • • • • • • C 0 Q) •v) : N C co u : Q1 L u v) U Q v Q) j. co O � C) c > > W — n' QU H C C - QO C O Oi Q ru 025 C t1A fB (75 C L d. L W > C -- — Q-1 C t O -3 a) •- a) CD a) a) Cll v) Z U CCI- § o E ' 0a) if L L C cu au �L C o U Si. C13 C (L) V v � E2 c 0 C < O L — s cc co N p U a) C j. Wu) N a) on C CD N C6 rt3 0 a) 4,7' QJ C •i-J L 7/?) L (3 o ° E a) L C - }' C Q O tiA , L � � -o U E a) Lu O O O }' C • O L E • • • • • •4-I Q) E U > o 4--' �, C o v N -0 o 0 E cL 4-0a_ 00 0 OL +� an a-J v s_ i C: `- 73 c >,... .1_) CLQ U i . • CU D -0 CU 4-, v) hn •,_ E ECU 0 0- N o - 4-0v 0 CID s_V _ U E .., N +-.) .� v 0 o m > LU L _l J V " • • • • • • • �A/' 4— , .. . 0 i. 0 z 0 a) , ._ > w , 4- 4— R5 4-0 in W . . 1 13 C • D • • Z 0 <- I— . U , < . 1., . . C) (0 >.• (1) CN a) I ID ro c (7, C cu a) 0) co a. 0 -0 F _o 4--• . . co cu co r—(1) -o I C 0 coco 0 3 no a— m 1 1) 0 a) a) 0 ( ..'7) V) 0 L L--. co , -0 c D I— L,i 0 — , 4 , E C UC w 4— 0 .— f-, (i) 0 ...." s_ c 0 0_ — U ;.1.,) L9 b.1) Ill (1) 0 . • D >- (13Q.) _C ^ > U 0 CD 0 � C s_ �N CU Q) 0_ mQ01 • t1D x--I d) -: 'c C LLCC co) ,� co _ O ' v) m � .-4=, C R5 5 c O CC -0 Q^ 0_ ^ •- O^ > > N Uco - -U) C) W CB co 0 (- (1) z � � o � � � � � s_ Qc gilt • • NM (0 -0 a C 4-) N tau a) Loh cu C C Ct V2 (1`3 ,N ...J C Q •_ — CU U O - c� -� -1--' ct$ o — _0 c c W LL O ' -0 — _c ,-, 4-, vi U = C u - CU n 1-- ca +� co +J a) L D Q� — �� v 0 � c� � O� E wctE > cE � � CU _J ozu V U . • • .g !! if li t.-' p g z . , ....\ g i 'I\,\ 3 i :rte ' :s` ,V^ i. ` _ , , -. , i\VolA, W u 'ig i t V) 1 -- t 1 El g d Y 7Wy Z i_� o F aI1 1 I J Q N Q N O co }J [n ' Coas '� t r ^s• d 4 J Z - ' Ir L ii •O. le y to0 -0 t v = H •i ,0 L. 0 aa CU E -0 4../ ,v • :: _ on o z a 0 y _c cn 0 c6 a E L 4-, a Q.) vn o 0 75 L_ .E 0.0 E a ° -a s U O O ra vo E E > a , C QO av4,1 a co c co U UCU 1„. -I-1 Z +- .- > a) CU > v �. Z i Z OCU CI) CD , a 1— tio c 0) t I- Q CU z ° COU 4--) i • • v Co cRS co W c o 0 N o� C6 '47, c co ..E. Q 0 U v L Q +J CO a CL c 4- E U ON > Q O a) a) v 4-1 L > v co v Tco 0 — U °C Q U C a_ cn v U 0 -.0 •_ 0 `+— U __ ^ ' j c l- .42 E L-, tio O N W • • -+--, ci) E uL Q c6 cn U -c +-, E „o , i: c Tc-c) I— co co 4— 0 •- v > - Q C4- 2 < C C cu � � C ru ru O — cn U UU- Q U Dcc w . • . . L (1) -0 L C-0 ai O 0 � v) U a0 � 00 +-, � aW o U V) D p 0 O p c N� ' 1z `7 C >. LQ) 0- N V) ' 4 N •— CD 0 L N c� (3)---- z f Z •N U v) -� N N — LI- at c >, — N Q) " I 1 J co a) W 73 'U-0 O � — C O Q c C L. OD fD (3 CC - n (13CIo •- N cu •n3 � ' EQ vp v)_ (0 U co Q � >, 0- cu - �.� v) O � 0 (0 D v)) > C .. W000 cv) 0 •CC) OL. cn — — :— E 0 ' — Q 0 �_C aj Q+-+ V m� ws_ U5_ Sv wD Q . . c .EO 4-- n U p `n ~ i_ 0 E �_ �_ Q) co CD 0 U CD 0 O 0 i N .0 o Q 0 0 c 0 C C O N c Q v �~ N .F.J a> Ln 2 '+-' a ca v) 0) O CO `� `� v C co _ U ._ C " U 0 p 0 O U U c6 L, 0:3 CI3 c (3 a--+ +-+ c N a--+ 0 ._ CU C v) _ +, Q. .— p O 725 4-1 — c w tE 13 E a3 al c. •tg C •2, N aA 0 •E. L- .�7 Z'S : E N +- o ca c}n D U >. E •.E v1 c N E c to N E N (0 hr1L- cu O C v) - C - > a0 •2 Ev D 0.) CO J Q — = O L Q U .— — — N D cc . . . • . • Q) `.=.•1 S. .ii • W Z'• it no 0 cu LA CD N � Ctap __ Q) Q ` __- =__ C6 CD O O U -� N U C= v O _., C •� > , a) s_ a) t' LI- Sri (nC� :r:@ r • ^�sw::- ? i)),:‘,10-. Q) K , rj V CO D 00 -0 CU • Q • • • C v N _C -0 aA ate--+ CD N 0 ._ 0 Q) — O v iC in r ^ N CO -o 4- cu = Q1 C VJ 0 Q) a--+ >> LO & bnC O v v 0 OIf 'L '_ L Co , • Q) tio •n E j co CD I a) CD cn •> Q) -C3 OD E v C6 4- N N - L C C D o E 3 a) 0 0 C6 4A L+- U O 4 , c O Q Eu .„ , , E c 4_, Q) co (/--;- Q) s_ (- ._ 4_, _ co > E Q)4-0a--, cn i-- .4-,, U Q t�A cn N N •— O �+- _I Ea') > N � vo 'no o0 D CCw -0 —I w C Q U cn - U U • • k ,„ Q) , 1: 1 I0 Co Q) s is t} :'- . CO >'• L Ca 161 a--1 L a) O >- %. R, •_ C , s ��.5 ' 411.R. O a) !t O -0 C a) 4,: , •.... C D - 1.10)' oc0 4-' 0 --- 2- +-1 CD +-1 , 4_) / /"� g t�U C (6 . C6 c tJ J ,' , d .„ ,... Oc E ce < „, ,, z •O .- c .o � . i, 0 — — up s N Q f ,,1!+I • • Y '1 ,� } ,A,''• ► i' N 4- V) O 4-1 +j vco C N N N a • C.) N (B .� 73 O C — +� C •— _0 O U (t3 D U_ _O CO (13 CO TO Va cu o Q c >o D ..0l_ E .'— E 4u E E 4-' O >. (1) E E - u E 4-) an 0 L 0 = .- U . f7 - ._ C U E 0 V �' U O > (D O - oc a) ,� .0 E a, V +� -0 (3 (AD U 'c __I Q) co ? O cl 0 CD E +_' OD CU S_ '1__ a) D 0 D C Lcu 0 0 (1) 4-1 0_ Q CO CO .4-1 U — U (r) CC _ • • • • • • • a) • 0 OO a O L .Q O N c O 3 s O E 0 V N • 3 �_ v, t3O .8 i 73 O � iss 0 3 -. O C3 C3 --~ ii* 4 px Z3 ;' U Q 4) NC 0 x X c. , _c D o E o U 0 N (0 d tt ♦♦, t ,. it -.„ . 4. , it.:. ,,,,,. ..t..\ ', ' / "tti_ 1. -.4 . , Tht : it ,,,,, • / 1 ^.` , .e . , , , fii ... ; ; . • .4., - .1 4-4 ,b, _ yr t„il CD e T 1 • 1 ii, B I t' /� t itItlie .)rit a ,. jiiiiii :1A _....v.„--,(:' , ,z .-..-..iii„, U) t . ,. , .,,,....., ,,,, 14,.,' ' .x' , `, ., , ..-`.,: ,-.4 m • r as $ Q. lJ •s a ��a . v ! . \\ \ � k/ \ y> § . « z »: 0 2 0 k7 al C C.I. 0 _ } \\ I ` C .c a) E / \ E O ■ a C ) 0 1 f / � � � E k 1 ) { = 32e (.4 = > § 0 � 0 ± ..-„, 0 Cr) \ a) ƒ ) 0 / % w > / § E ° { / t \ & £ c ) E © 7 o C \3af 0 e £ ± c o..,...". 5 ° 0 / Q c % a \ § / ( f \ ® } D \ { \ T. / ®0) \ u \ U o / ) ° o ° ® 2 ` e \\ / \ \ k � __LI / / '� \/ \ / 9 E \ o E j g G 2 « 6 4 @ ® § % e c •; z / ® ° S o � \f E k { 0 $ \ $ o i E E r \ fa § .- f \ -o\ § 0 « / \ o £ _2 < 0$ 7 » o = c _ / ` ° � �> f\ k § \ 2E \ @f ƒ � / . $ §} \ � _{ /f / § / \ \ \ . Eo -C ) \ � ` ® / � ° { la ca) — ° 7 � / o � Ry a r0 ! \a \ �\ / eSf2 \ $ $ 2 \ F / H CD �� \ F{ \ { 23f [ \5 ] [ \ -o 2 E g = 5 a < &i o 2 / 6 / E < f \ E , , ! . , ! 6 Lll al } } EmNm,'wNra'l \ dEo a 2 H _ a a mm�»e&q ƒ +, O 1_ iI O C — f � v) U F .o � � `r) � o a) E F • —C N c6 O 4.-) N U w � +J C r a_ EO n C •'•— C— •- > 0 Q) 4-) c./) co co Q U _ c� V 0 - U •> W .� a.) 0 (-1 U CIO C Q_ oC � _c Du D .— N Q) E >.. r v '- 0 (I) 4--j N On 0 C a••, U O L cn > a--- > U O OM CO 2Ucc -0 r _o m 0 coN. (O 1 0 Lid ,- 45 O N_ Cal) N m a < 7 > Ltd CO ..... 0 v) ^� (I) W < rYg) a--) X a) <z 7... .,..... , 1,.. .:..,-,._'..4.., ... ,,. 1 i, ;11111114i, ;,,,,:,,,,,,,v,,,:;:A.,,:. ,'`It'.,14-4- : L'. ., -.----- ''.. ''.... . , . - .,: : i ,';'•-.- •-•' :'•4,::. ,:?.......4... .• .1_ • -,:- - •• ••- , ',v.. ..,... J• . , • ' ' •'-,-..,..__. ":..-m-r--,..1,,..<:N,i .. , V .,,..,._,-.:4.;:'‘-,' '. k..-,..-, ..- , / . , ._.;,-..,,•:,, •,- ..,, .... :..-... •-..... -•._ ‘• . '1..,a.m4,•:':-„sA‘ ' .,," A - i ..,, . .---.. 0' - , • ,.....7 ) i ,,,,.,.,,.*LeAle‘' • i ..-• NC; • •-4- •- ' ' .--;* • -v. ':•'` in ..-.---i •.• • ... .. 1 ----1 ftl ‘,. . • .';ii.'!: ..ZIF:,/!':•••••. '. .i' %,-- —.—.. '‘, ., .,...%, - % ?_!• • " '•t • ..1.:'•• • .%Alf- ....N. . . • — ''.4./14.-t "t`k. .t,„k.. _ .., t, - - i , ,,t.,,,.,„:.:..._........._____,..._.1 „ ' \'..\:' : ,...,,. k l'• 4114/1190040,'%'' ,:'-• .,. ' 0 •,-,.'. .: ¢VZ" .,:: 4 , ; .., 14 .., . iltki virmr.7-7, --------- - ----- i. __- -- —i ..-. ... * • , • , s . VAIN* .- -__---_,-..•.......-. •• • - . \,: ' ---.-- .V.;Prit'..; .. ' S.7... .k.a.... -Y,,..;_';',.,i. •"`-'"., , i \.....„•, . . , ,,, ...„...-- .. „f„,.----,--,..-,., .: l'''.-:-1.V...!,': --,*,-'*.,_---ts-i--.,.-1 . . '_..': iw .• •. . .,..., ....., ° ,.........-----:.• -- . V-.i.._.:_,,--' - ___-=-,,r..... .Milleir A....,. ‘•%%. . # •••'• e • ....., ,, ,,.._ .. . ,.. . . . ' 1 ,4, , • ,f -'' - . • • #4 4 I imusio M .-I-_ (....) : ,. ... ....... . ......,_ .41 Id 41 At 34_4(_. 0 7 > . ..: ,. .. • . .. . . LUL„or.: . . ...,,,,• , ,-.);17 .,,,... ,.•-.....--.,• ..i. CC)— — 0 •• ,. . - . . • . (f) , I • r) 4 1140741 ''. •C ,:j.i,.,..0...r..... : ; , i IMMI CZ < 'Pt^ . .. ' : . . r••• co co ,- .,---. - _ .,.. . ,.Tt.-:1-<-4.• • 4.„ t‘' '".” -.......,': --4 , ' 0. 0111111 , 4b-' - ;:irl,for? - . c\i c\I - ....t. .. - -4,, , •1 - ,' ri!* -41 k. • . , . •• . '- ',`:.t,' •• e . Artaar. .. e• ...... ..., '. ,vaikl -, - • i •- '' -.., :.- ., Nil 1 . ' 'v•A, Ais - \ r 41 , . . ....,.,....,• ... .., k..,,. ,.... . , '. .t•:-.1.: 1114° ' ti t: ..- .110111111* , .."-,.. .; . I i • le , 9. .. •• i :.. ,., •--x.j IV I%. ... : .. . ... . .• . - . I' _— - 4 Sit ,‘ , 4 141i .•, II :,.•I • , ,...._ , __., • - --• •• - 1.1111 . i , i • 4 . \ ll - , . . .- f::. --'\''-' ,,..d. . . . II • '.r A _. \ ‘ • \, .. ••• . _, 1 pi hi I -.• .-1 o' . AP-- \--MgilinlibMilig— 1 •" , , , qt . „.. = . I ' , . • • \ 1 El k