Resolution 2020-31512 RESOLUTION NO. 2020-31512
A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, ACCEPTING THE RECOMMENDATION OF THE CITY
MANAGER FOR THE RANKINGS OF PROPOSALS PURSUANT TO REQUEST
FOR QUALIFICATIONS (RFQ) NO. 2020-096-ND, FOR PROFESSIONAL
ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING SERVICES IN SPECIALIZED
CATEGORIES ON AN "AS-NEEDED BASIS"; AND AUTHORIZING THE
ADMINISTRATION TO ENTER INTO NEGOTIATIONS WITH THE
ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING FIRMS LISTED IN EXHIBIT A, FOR THE
DISCIPLINES OF GENERAL ARCHITECTURE, PLANNING AND URBAN DESIGN
ARCHITECTURE, TOWN PLANNING ARCHITECTURE, HISTORIC
PRESERVATION ARCHITECTURE, INTERIOR DESIGN / SPACE PLANNING,
COASTAL ENGINEERING, CONTAMINATION ASSESSMENT, REMEDIATION,
AND REPORTING ENGINEERING, GEOTECHNICAL ENGINEERING, AND
SURVEYING; AND FURTHER AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR AND CITY CLERK TO
EXECUTE AGREEMENTS WITH EACH OF THE RECOMMENDED PROPOSERS
UPON CONCLUSION OF SUCCESSFUL NEGOTIATIONS BY THE
ADMINISTRATION.
WHEREAS, on March 18, 2020, the City Commission approved the issuance of Request
for Qualifications (RFQ) No. 2020-096-ND for Professional Architectural and Engineering
Services in Specialized Categories on an "As-Needed Basis"; and
WHEREAS, Request for Qualifications No. 2020-096-ND (the "RFQ") was released on
April 10, 2020; and
WHEREAS, a voluntary pre-proposal meeting was held on April 23, 2020; and
WHEREAS, on June 5, 2020, the City received one hundred thirty-five (135) proposals;
and
WHEREAS, on October 27, 2020 the City Manager, via Letter to Commission No. 384-
2020, appointed an Evaluation Committee (the "Committee"), which included evaluation
committee members for each of the various disciplines set forth in the RFQ; and
WHEREAS, the Committee for the disciplines of landscape architecture, LEED
commissioning, civil engineering, stormwater engineering, structural engineering, mechanical,
electrical, and plumbing engineering, electrical engineering, plumbing engineering, mechanical
engineering, and security and safety engineering have yet to convene; and
WHEREAS, once the Committee for the aforementioned disciplines convenes, an
agenda item will be prepared and presented at the next available City Commission meeting; and
WHEREAS, the Evaluation Committee (the "Committee") for the discipline of general
architecture, the discipline of planning and urban design architecture, the discipline of town
planning architecture, the discipline of historic preservation architecture, and the discipline of
interior design /space planning consisted of the following individuals:
GENERAL ARCHITECTURE
• Francisco Garcia, Senior Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property
Management Department
• Elizabeth Piotrowski, Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital
Improvement Projects
• Colette Satchell, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital
Improvement Projects; and
PLANNING AND URBAN DESIGN ARCHITECTURE
• Josiel Ferrer-Diaz, Assistant Director, Transportation Department
• Rogelio Madan, Chief of Community Planning and Sustainability, Planning
Department
• James Murphy, Chief of Urban Design, Planning Department; and
TOWN PLANNING ARCHITECTURE
• Josiel Ferrer-Diaz, Assistant Director, Transportation Department
• Rogelio Madan, Chief of Community Planning and Sustainability, Planning
Department
• James Murphy, Chief of Urban Design, Planning Department; and
HISTORIC PRESERVATION ARCHITECTURE
• Ariel Guitian, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital Improvement
Projects
• Colette Satchell, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital
Improvement Projects
• Debora Tackett, Chief of Historic Preservation, Planning Department; and
INTERIOR DESIGN/SPACE PLANNING
• Francisco Garcia, Senior Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property
Management Department
• Rogelio Madan, Chief of Community Planning and Sustainability, Planning
Department
• Olga Sanchez, Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management
Department; and
COASTAL ENGINEERING
• Sabrina Baglieri, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital
Improvement Projects
• Luis Soto, Assistant City Engineer, Public Works Department
• Elizabeth Wheaton, Director, Environment and Sustainability Department; and
CONTAMINATION ASSESSMENT, REMEDIATION, AND REPORTING ENGINEERING
• Sabrina Baglieri, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital
Improvement Projects
• Matthew LePera, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
• Elizabeth Wheaton, Director, Environment and Sustainability Department; and
GEOTECHNICAL ENGINEERING
• Sabrina Baglieri, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital
Improvement Projects
• Giancarlo Pena, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
• Lisel Suarez, Civil Engineer I, Public Works Department; and
SURVYEING ENGINEERING
• Sabrina Baglieri, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital
Improvement Projects
• Brian Bellino, City Surveyor Manager, Public Works Department
• Lisel Suarez, Civil Engineer I, Public Works Department; and
WHEREAS, the Committees convened to review and score the proposals, as follows:
the Committee for the disciplines of geotechnical engineering, surveying, coastal engineering,
and contamination assessment, remediation, and reporting engineering, convened on
November 10, 2020, the Committee for the disciplines of general architecture and interior
design / space planning convened on November 16, 2020; and the Committee for the
disciplines of planning and urban design architecture, town planning architecture, and historic
preservation architecture convened on November 19, 2020; and
WHEREAS, the Committee was provided an overview of the project, information relative
to the City's Cone of Silence Ordinance and the Government Sunshine Law, general information
on the scope of services, and a copy of each proposal; and
WHEREAS, the Committee was instructed to score and rank each proposal pursuant to
the evaluation criteria established in the RFQ; and
WHEREAS, the Committee's ranking for the discipline of General Architecture was as
follows: Zyscovich Inc., as the first ranked proposer; Wolfberg/Alvarez and Partners, Inc., as the
second ranked proposer; RE Chisholm Architects, Inc., as the third ranked proposer;
Waggoneer & Ball, LLC, as the fourth ranked proposer; Allan T. Shulman Architect, P.A., BEA
Architects, Inc., and Song + Associates, Inc., as the tied fifth ranked proposers; Saltz Michelson
Architects, Inc. and Wannemacher Jensen Architects, Inc., as the tied eight ranked proposers;
TSAO Design Group, Incorporated, as the tenth ranked proposer; Brooks + Scarpa Architects,
Inc., as the eleventh ranked proposer; AECOM Technical Services, Inc., as the twelfth ranked
proposer; Ferguson Glasglow Shuster Soto, Inc., as the thirteenth ranked proposer; M.C. Harry
and Associates, Inc., as the fourteenth ranked proposer; S/T/A Architectural Group, Inc., as the
fifteenth ranked proposer; BC Architects AIA, Inc. and William B. Medellin Architect P.A., as the
tied sixteenth ranked proposers; OLANZ Architecture and Design Corp., as the eighteenth
ranked proposer; Berenblum Busch Architecture, Inc., as the nineteenth ranked proposer;
NOVA Engineering & Environmental, LLC, as the twentieth ranked proposer; RVL Architecture
+ Design, P.A., as the twenty-first ranked proposer; JSK Architectural Group, LLC, as the
twenty-second proposer; V3 Architectural Group, Inc., as the twenty-third proposer; Rene
Gonzalez Architects, Inc., as the twenty-fourth ranked proposer; Architectural Design
Collaborative, Inc., as the twenty-fifth ranked proposer; CPH, Inc. and DN'A Design &
Architecture, Inc. as the tied twenty-sixth ranked proposers; William Lane Architect, Inc. and
CSA Central, Inc. as the tied twenty-eight ranked proposers; Nyarko Architectural Group, Inc.,
as the thirtieth ranked proposer; Rodriguez Architects, Inc., as the thirty-first ranked proposer; 2
Plus Architects, Inc., as the thirty-second ranked proposer; D.L. Fields Consultants, LLC and
RVD Architect, Inc. as the tied thirty-third ranked proposers; Burton Hersh Architects, P.A.,
Palenzuela & Hevia Design Group, Inc. and RMS Building Envelope Consultants, LLC as the
tied thirty-fifth ranked proposers; The Tamara Peacock Company Architects of Florida, Inc., as
the thirty-eighth ranked proposer; CFM Architects, Inc., as the thirty-ninth ranked proposer; 3FM
Engineering, Inc., as the fortieth ranked proposer; and
WHEREAS, the Committee's ranking for the discipline of Planning and Urban Design
Architecture was as follows: Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc., as the first ranked proposer;
EDSA, Inc., as the second ranked proposer; Allan T. Shulman Architect, P.A., as the third
ranked proposer; Zyscovich, Inc., as the fourth ranked proposer; The Corradino Group, as the
fifth ranked proposer; Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc., as the sixth ranked proposer; Calvin,
Giordano & Associates, Inc., Stantec Consulting Services, Inc., and WGI, Inc., as the tied
seventh ranked proposers; BEA Architects, Inc., as the tenth ranked proposer; CPH, Inc., as
the eleventh ranked proposer; KCI Technologies, Inc., as the twelfth ranked proposer; Keith
and Associates, Inc., as the thirteenth ranked proposer; and Palenzuela & Hevia Design Group,
Inc., as the fourteenth ranked proposer; and
WHEREAS, the Committee's ranking for the discipline of Town Planning Architecture
was as follows: Calvin, Giordano &Associates, Inc., as the first ranked proposer; The Corradino
Group, as the second ranked proposer; Zyscovich, Inc., as the third ranked proposer; WGI, Inc.,
as the fourth ranked proposer; Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc., as the fifth ranked proposer;
and KCI Technologies, Inc., as the sixth ranked proposer; and
WHEREAS, the Committee's ranking for the discipline of Historic Preservation
Architecture was as follows: William B. Medellin Architect P.A., as the first ranked proposer;
Allan T. Shulman Architect, P.A., as the second ranked proposer; R.J. Heisenbottle Architects,
P.A. and S/T/A Architectural Group, Inc., as the tied third ranked proposers; M.C. Harry and
Associates, Inc., as the fifth ranked proposer; Bender&Associates Architects, P.A., as the sixth
ranked proposer; Berenblum Busch Architecture, Inc., as the seventh ranked proposer; JSK
Architectural Group, LLC, as the eight ranked proposer; DN'A Design &Architecture, Inc., as the
ninth ranked proposer; TSAO Design Group, Incorporated, as the tenth ranked proposer; The
Tamara Peacock Company Architects of Florida, Inc., as the eleventh ranked proposer; and KCI
Technologies, Inc., as the twelfth ranked proposer; and
WHEREAS, the Committee's ranking for the discipline of Interior Design / Space
Planning was as follows: Perkins + Will Architects, Inc., as the first ranked proposer; TSAO
Design Group, Incorporated and Zyscovich Inc., as the tied second ranked proposers;
Palenzuela & Hevia Design Group, Inc., as the fourth ranked proposer; Song + Associates, Inc.,
as the fifth ranked proposer; OLANZ Architecture and Design Corp., as the sixth ranked
proposer; Burton Hersh Architects, P.A., as the seventh ranked proposer; and Architectural
Design Collaborative, Inc., as the eight ranked proposer; and
WHEREAS, the Committee's ranking for the discipline of Coastal Engineering was as
follows: Moffatt & Nichol. Inc., as the first ranked proposer; Stantec Consulting Services, Inc., as
the second ranked proposer; Cummins Cederberg, Inc., as the third ranked proposer; AECOM
Technical Services, Inc., as the fourth ranked proposer; Coastal Systems International, Inc., as
the fifth ranked proposer; Mott MacDonald, LLC, as the sixth ranked proposer; GHD Services,
Inc., as the seventh ranked proposer; McLaren Technical Services, Inc., as the eighth ranked
proposer; T.Y. Lin International, as the ninth ranked proposer; and GRAEF — USA Inc., as the
tenth ranked proposer; and
WHEREAS, the Committee's ranking for the discipline of Contamination Assessment,
Remediation, and Reporting Engineering was as follows: Nova Consulting, Inc., as the first
ranked proposer; Professional Service Industries, Inc., as the second ranked proposer; E
Sciences, Incorporated, as the third ranked proposer; GFA International, Inc., as the fourth
ranked proposer; Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc., as the fifth ranked proposer; and GHD
Services, Inc., as the sixth ranked proposer; and
WHEREAS, the Committee's ranking for the discipline of Geotechnical Engineering was
as follows: Universal Engineering Sciences, LLC, as the first ranked proposer; GFA
International, Inc.; as the second ranked proposer; Professional Service Industries, Inc., as the
third ranked proposer; NV5, Inc. and Radise International, L.C., as the tied fourth ranked
proposers; Terracon Consultants, Inc., as the sixth ranked proposer; Wingerter Laboratories,
Inc., as the seventh ranked proposer; HP Consultants, Inc. and NOVA Engineering &
Environmental, LLC, as the tied eight ranked proposers; and Blascom Engineering, Inc., as the
tenth ranked proposer; and
WHEREAS, the Committee's ranking for the discipline of Surveying was as follows: F.R.
Aleman & Associates, Inc., as the first ranked proposer; Biscayne Engineering Company, Inc.
and Schwebke-Shiskin & Associates, Inc., as the tied second ranked proposers; Maser
Consulting, P.A. and Craven Thompson &Associates, Inc., as the tied fourth ranked proposers;
Longitude Surveyors, LLC, as the sixth ranked proposer; Calvin, Giordano & Associates, Inc.
and Hadonne Corp., as the tied seventh ranked proposers; KCI Technologies, Inc., as the ninth
ranked proposer; Miller, Legg &Associates, Inc., as the tenth ranked proposer; Javier E. Bidot&
Associates, P.S.C., Corp. and Keith and Associates, Inc., as the tied eleventh ranked
proposers; and Premiere Design Solutions, Inc., as the thirteenth ranked proposer; and
WHEREAS, after reviewing all the submissions and the results of the evaluation
process, the City Manager recommends that the Administration be authorized to enter into
negotiations with the following:
Zyscovich Inc., Wolfberg/Alvarez and Partners, Inc., RE Chisholm Architects, Inc.,
Waggoneer & Ball, LLC, Allan T. Shulman Architect, P.A., BEA Architects, Inc., Song +
Associates, Inc., Saltz Michelson Architects, Inc., and Wannemacher Jensen Architects,
Inc., for the discipline of General Architecture;
Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc., EDSA, Inc., Allan T. Shulman Architect, P.A.,
Zyscovich, Inc., The Corradino Group, and Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc., for the
discipline of Planning and Urban Design Architecture;
Calvin, Giordano & Associates, Inc., The Corradino Group, Zyscovich, Inc., WGI, Inc.,
Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc., and KCI Technologies, Inc., for the discipline of Town
Planning Architecture;
William B. Medellin Architect P.A.; Allan T. Shulman Architect, P.A.; R.J. Heisenbottle
Architects, P.A., S/T/A Architectural Group, Inc.; and M.C. Harry and Associates, Inc., for
the discipline of Historic Preservation Architecture;
Perkins + Will Architects, Inc., TSAO Design Group, Incorporated, and Zyscovich Inc.,
for the discipline of Interior Design/Space Planning;
Moffatt & Nichol. Inc., Stantec Consulting Services, Inc., Cummins Cederberg, Inc.,
AECOM Technical Services, Inc., and Coastal Systems International, Inc., for the
discipline of Coastal Engineering;
Nova Consulting, Inc., Professional Service Industries, Inc., and E Sciences,
Incorporated, for the discipline of Contamination Assessment, Remediation, and
Reporting Engineering;
Universal Engineering Sciences, LLC, GFA International, Inc.; Professional Service
Industries, Inc., NV5, Inc. and Radise International, L.C., for the discipline of
Geotechnical Engineering; and
F.R. Aleman & Associates, Inc., Biscayne Engineering Company, Inc., Schwebke-
Shiskin & Associates, Inc., Maser Consulting, P.A., and Craven Thompson &
Associates, Inc., for the discipline of Surveying; and
WHEREAS, in accordance with Section 287.055, Florida Statutes, the "Consultants'
Competitive Negotiation Act", this RFQ only applies to professional services pursuant to a
"continuing contract", for projects in which construction costs do not exceed $4 Million or for
study activities for which the fee does not exceed $500,000; and
WHEREAS, the City Manager and the Administration recommend the Mayor and City
Commission approve this Resolution, authorizing the administration to enter into negotiations
with the architectural and engineering firms listed in Exhibit A attached to this Resolution, for the
disciplines of General Architecture, Planning and Urban Design Architecture; Town Planning
Architecture; Historic Preservation Architecture, Interior Design / Space Planning, Coastal
Engineering, Contamination, Assessment, Remediation, and Reporting Engineering,
Geotechnical Engineering, and Surveying, and further authorizing the Mayor and City Clerk to
execute agreements with.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT DULY RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY
COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, that the Mayor and City
Commission hereby accept the recommendation of the City Manager for the ranking of
proposals pursuant to Request for Qualifications (RFQ) No. 2020-096-ND for Professional
Architectural and Engineering Services in Specialized Categories, as set forth in the RFQ, on an
"As-Needed Basis"; authorizing the administration to enter into negotiations with the
architectural and engineering firms listed in Exhibit A, for the disciplines of General Architecture,
Planning and Urban Design Architecture; Town Planning Architecture; Historic Preservation
Architecture, Interior Design / Space Planning, Coastal Engineering, Contamination,
Assessment, Remediation, and Reporting Engineering, Geotechnical Engineering, and
Surveying, and further authorizing the Mayor and City Clerk to execute agreements with each of
the recommended proposers upon conclusion of successful negotiations by the Administration.
PASSED AND ADOPTED this 9 day of Peep/'72020.
112-211---- --_
DAN GELBER, MAYOR
ATTEST:
K
./.
W IZ '��' " ,,,,'',� APPROVED AS TO
! l� '`r 'S�'ay. FORM 8 LANGUAGE
RAFAEL E. GRANADO, ITY CLERK = & FOR EXECUTIONINCORP ORATEDT
''''', ...i.... Al .../ei".5 , FaLIANIV,--- t.i ft,a
AO
• City Atlotrtey [kte
ATTACHMENT A
General Architecture Coastal Engineering
Zyscovich Inc. Moffatt& Nichol. Inc.
Wolfberg/Alvarez and Partners, Inc. Stantec Consulting Services, Inc.
RE Chisholm Architects, Inc. Cummins Cederberg, Inc.
Waggonner& Ball, LLC AECOM Technical Services, Inc.
Allan T.Shulman Architect, P.A. Coastal Systems International, Inc.
BEA Architects, Inc.
Contamination Assessment, Remediation,and
Song+Associates, Inc. Reporting Engineering
Saltz Michelson Architects, Inc. Nova Consulting, Inc.
Wannemacher Jensen Architects, Inc. Professional Service Industries, Inc.
E Sciences, Incorporated
Planning and Urban Design Architecture
Brooks+Scarpa Architects, Inc_. Geotechnical Engineering
EDSA, Inc. Universal Engineering Sciences, LLC
Allan T.Shulman Architect, P.A. GFA International, Inc
Zyscovich, Inc. Professional Service Industries, Inc.
The Corradino Group NV5, Inc.
Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. Radise International, L.C.
Town Planning Architecture Surveying
Calvin, Giordano &Associates, Inc. F.R.Aleman &Associates, Inc.
The Corradino Group Biscayne Engineering Company, Inc.
Zyscovich, Inc. Schwebke-Shiskin &Associates, Inc.
WGI, Inc. Maser Consulting, P.A.
Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. Craven Thompson &Associates, Inc.
KCI Technologies, Inc.
Historic Preservation Architecture
William B. Medellin Architect P.A.
Allan T.Shulman Architect, P.A.
R.J. Heisenbottle Architects, P.A.
S/T/A Architectural Group, Inc.
M.C. Harry and Associates, Inc.
Interior Design/Space Planning
Perkins+Will Architects, Inc.
TSAO Design Group, Incorporated
Zyscovich Inc.
Resolutions -C7 C
MIAMI BEACH
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM
TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Commission
FROM: Jimmy L. Morales, City Manager
DATE: December 9, 2020
SUBJECT:A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY
OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, ACCEPTING THE RECOMMENDATION OF
THE CITY MANAGER PERTAINING TO THE RANKING OF PROPOSALS
PURSUANT TO REQUEST FOR QUALIFICATIONS (RFQ) NO. 2020-096-
ND, FOR PROFESSIONAL ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING
SERVICES IN SPECIALIZED CATEGORIES ON AN "AS-NEEDED BASIS";
AUTHORIZING THE ADMINISTRATION TO ENTER INTO NEGOTIATIONS
WITH THE ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING FIRMS, AS INCLUDED
IN EXHIBIT A, FOR THE DISCIPLINES OF GENERAL ARCHITECTURE,
PLANNING AND URBAN DESIGN ARCHITECTURE, TOWN PLANNING
ARCHITECTURE, HISTORIC PRESERVATION ARCHITECTURE,
INTERIOR DESIGN / SPACE PLANNING, COASTAL ENGINEERING,
CONTAMINATION ASSESSMENT, REMEDIATION, AND REPORTING
ENGINEERING, GEOTECHNICAL ENGINEERING, AND SURVEYING; AND
FURTHER AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR AND CITY CLERK TO EXECUTE
AN AGREEMENT WITH EACH OF THE RECOMMENDED PROPOSERS
UPON CONCLUSION OF SUCCESSFUL NEGOTIATIONS BY THE
ADMINISTRATION.
RECOMMENDATION
The Administration recommends that the Mayor and City Commission of the City of Miami
Beach, Florida approve the resolution accepting the City Manager's recommendation pertaining
to the bids received, pursuant to RFQ 2020-096-ND, for professional architectural and •
engineering services in specialized categories in accordance with Section 287.055, Florida
Statutes.
BACKGROUND/HISTORY
Section 287.055, Florida Statutes outlines the process by which agencies in the state may
utilize contracts with architects and engineers on a continuing basis. Maintaining continuing
contracts with architects and engineers helps to expedite the award of project when
the construction cost of each individual project does not exceed $4 million, for study activity if
the fee for professional services for each study does not exceed $500,000.
In accordance with the state law, the City maintains agreements for professional architectural
Page 107 of 1707
and engineering services in specialized categories to be utilized on an"as-needed-basis". The
current agreements are on a month to month term until such time as the new contracts are
awarded pursuant to this RFQ.
In order to establish replacement contracts, the Administration has released Request for
Qualifications (RFQ) No. 2020-096-ND to solicit qualifications from architectural and
engineering firms, including professional qualifications in the following specialized areas:
Architecture— General;Architecture— Landscape;Architecture Planning and Urban Design;
Architecture—Town Planning;Architecture— Historic Preservation; Engineering — General
Environmental Services; Engineering— Mechanical, Electrical & Plumbing; Engineering —
Electrical; Engineering — Plumbing; Engineering— Mechanical; Engineering—Structural;
Engineering —Civil; Engineering — Geotechnical; Engineering — Coastal; Engineering —
Contamination Assessment, Remediation, and Reporting; Engineering — Stormwater; Interior
Design/Space Planning; LEED Commissioning; and Surveying.
ANALYSIS
On March 18, 2020,the Mayor and City Commission authorized the issuance of the RFQ. On
April 10, 2020,the RFQ was issued.A voluntary pre-proposal conference to provide
information to proposers submitting a response was held on April 23, 2020. Two addenda were
issued. The Department issued bid notes to 32,493 companies utilizing www.bidsync.com
website.492 prospective bidders accessed the advertised solicitation. RFQ responses were
due and received on June 5, 2020. The City received a total of 303 responses from the
following 135 firms (some firms submitted proposals for various categories):
2 Plus Architects, Inc. JSK Architectural Group, LLC
300 Engineering Group, P.A. KCI Technologies, Inc.
305 Consulting Engineers, LLC Keith and Associates, Inc.
3FM Engineering, Inc. Kimley-Hom and Associates, Inc.
A&P Consulting Transportation Engineers, Longitude Surveyors, LLC
Corp. LUSEO Group LLC
AECOM Technical Services, Inc. M.C. Harry and Associates, Inc.
Allan T. Shulman Architect, P.A. Maser Consulting, P.A.
Aluces Corporation Master Consulting Engineers, Inc.
Alvarez Engineers, Inc. McFarland-Johnson, Inc.
APX Engineering Group, LLC McLaren Technical Services, Inc.
Architectural Design Collaborative, Inc. Milian, Swain, &Associates, Inc.
Ardurra Group, Inc. Miller, Legg &Associates, Inc.
BC Architects Al A, Inc. Moffatt& Nichol. Inc.
BCC Engineering, Inc. Morabito Consultants, Inc.
BEA Architects, Inc. Moses and Associates, Inc.
Bender&Associates Architects, P.A. Mott MacDonald, LLC
Berenblum Busch Architecture, Inc. Nova Consulting, Inc.
Biller Reinhart Engineering Group, Inc. NOVA Engineering & Environmental, LLC
Biscayne Engineering Company, Inc. NV5, Inc.
Black&Veatch Corporation Nyarko Architectural Group, Inc.
Blascom Engineering, Inc. OLANZ Architecture and Design Corp.
Brindley Pieters &Associates, Inc. Palenzuela& Hevia Design Group
Brooks + Scarpa Architects; Inc. Perkins +Will Architects, Inc.
Page 108 of 1707
Bruce Howard &Associates of Florida, Inc. PMM Consulting Engineers, Corp.
Calvin, Giordano &Associates, Inc. Premiere Design Solutions, Inc.
Castillo Engineering, Inc. Professional Service Industries, Inc. D/B/A
CDM Smith, Inc. Intertek-PSI
CES Consultants, Inc. PT Suppliers LLC D/B/A Risk and Design
CFM Architects, Inc. Consulting
Chen-Moore and Associates, Inc. R.E. Chisholm Architects, Inc.
Chrome Engineering, Inc. R.J. Behar& Company, Inc.
Coastal Systems International, Inc. R.J. Heisenbottle Architects, P.A.
CONNECT Engineering, LLC Radise International, L.C.
CPH, Inc. Rene Gonzalez Architects, Inc.
Craven Thompson &Associates, Inc. RMS Building Envelope Consultants, LLC
CSA Central, Inc. Rodriguez Architects, Inc.
Cummins Cederberg, Inc. Ross & Baruzzini, Inc.
Curtis & Rogers Design Studio, Inc. Ross Engineering, Inc.
D.L. Fields Consultants, LLC D/B/A DLFC RVD Architect, Inc.
Architects RVL Architecture + Design, P.A.
Department, LLC Saltz Michelson Architects, Inc.
DESMAN, Inc. Savino & Miller Design Studio, P.A.
Disamerica Consulting Group, Inc. Schwebke-Shiskin &Associates, Inc.
DN'A Design &Architecture, Inc. Song &Associates, Inc.
Douglas Wood Associates, Inc. SpectrumHaven, LLC
DTM Tech, Inc. SRS Engineering, Inc.
E Sciences, Inc. S/T/A Architectural Group, Inc.
EA3 Civil Engineering, Inc Stanley Consultants, Inc.
EAC Consulting, Inc. Stantec Consulting Services, Inc.
Eastern Engineering Group Company T.Y. Lin International
EDSA, Inc. Terra Civil Engineering, LLC
Exp. U.S. Services, Inc. Terracon Consultants, Inc.
F.R.Aleman&Associates, Inc. The BetaJones Group, Inc.
Ferguson Glasglow Shuster Soto, Inc. The Corradino Group
Florida Transportation Engineering, Inc. The Tamara Peacock Company Architects
Gallagher Bassett Services, Inc. of Florida, Inc.
Garcia Mullin Group, LLC TSAO Design Group, Incorporated
GFA International, Inc Universal Engineering Sciences, LLC
GHD Services, Inc. V3 Architectural Group, Inc.
GRAEF - USA Inc. Waggonner& Ball, LLC
H.W. Lochner, Inc. Walker Parking Consultants/Engineers, Inc.
Hadonne Corp Wannemacher Jensen Architects, Inc.
Hardesty& Hanover, LLC WGI, Inc.
Hazen and Sawyer, P.C. William B. Medellin Architect P.A.
HP Consultants, Inc. William Lane Architect, Inc.
HSQ Group, Inc. Wingerter Laboratories, Inc.
J&M Engineering, P.C. D/B/A M&J Wolfberg/Alvarez and Partners, Inc.
Engineering, P.C. Youssef Hachem Consulting Engineering,
Javier E. Bidot&Associates, P.S.C., Corp. Inc.
JSK Architectural Group, LLC Zyscovich Inc.
As is customary, the City Manager appointed Evaluation Committee (the "Committee") by
Page 109 of 1707
discipline to review the proposals received for each discipline. Because of the overwhelming
number of responses,the evaluation committees, and the subsequent award recommendations,
had to be broken up into groups. The first group, which is the purpose of this item, includes:
general architecture; planning and urban design architecture; town planning architecture; historic
preservation architecture; interior design/space planning; coastal engineering; contamination
assessment, remediation, and reporting engineering; geotechnical engineering; and surveying.
The Evaluation Committees for these disciplines include the following individuals.
GENERAL ARCHITECTURE
• Francisco Garcia, Senior Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management
Department
• Elizabeth Piotrowski, Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital Improvement
Projects
• Colette Satchell, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital Improvement
Projects; and
PLANNING AND URBAN DESIGN ARCHITECTURE
• Josiel Ferrer-Diaz,Assistant Director, Transportation Department
• Rogelio Madan, Chief of Community Planning and Sustainability, Planning Department
• James Murphy, Chief of Urban Design, Planning Department; and
TOWN PLANNING ARCHITECTURE
• Josiel Ferrer-Diaz,Assistant Director, Transportation Department
• Rogelio Madan, Chief of Community Planning and Sustainability, Planning Department
• James Murphy, Chief of Urban Design, Planning Department; and
HISTORIC PRESERVATION ARCHITECTURE
•Ariel Guitian, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital Improvement
Projects
• Colette Satchell, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital Improvement
Projects
• Debora Tackett, Chief of Historic Preservation, Planning Department; and
INTERIOR DESIGN/SPACE PLANNING
• Francisco Garcia, Senior Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management
Department
• Rogelio Madan, Chief of Community Planning and Sustainability, Planning Department
• Olga Sanchez, Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management Department;
and
COASTAL ENGINEERING
• Sabrina Baglieri, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital Improvement
Projects
• Luis Soto,Assistant City Engineer, Public Works Department
• Elizabeth Wheaton, Director, Environment and Sustainability Department; and
CONTAMINATION ASSESSMENT, REMEDIATION,AND REPORTING ENGINEERING
• Sabrina Baglieri, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital Improvement
Projects
• Matthew LePera, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
Page 110 of 1707
• Elizabeth Wheaton, Director, Environment and Sustainability Department; and
GEOTECHNICAL ENGINEERING
• Sabrina Baglieri, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital Improvement
Projects
• Giancarlo Pena, Civil Engineer I I, Public Works Department
• Lisel Suarez, Civil Engineer I, Public Works Department; and
SURVEYEI NG
• Sabrina Baglieri, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital Improvement
Projects
• Brian Bellino, City Surveyor Manager, Public Works Department
• Lisel Suarez, Civil Engineer I, Public Works Department; and
The Committees were provided an overview of the project, information relative to the City's
Cone of Silence Ordinance and the Government Sunshine Law. The Committees were also
provided with general information on the scope of services and a copy of each proposal. The
Committees were instructed to score and rank each proposal pursuant to the evaluation criteria
established in the RFQ. The Evaluation Committee process resulted in the ranking of
proposers as indicated in Exhibit B.A summary of each top-ranked firm is available upon
request.
Staff from each of the departments that most use the contracts for each discipline
recommended the number of proposers that should be awarded in each category based on
rankings and expected usage.
FINANCIAL INFORMATION
The cost of the related services, determined upon successful negotiations, are subject to funds
availability approved through the City's budgeting process.
CONCLUSION
It is important to note that the City received 303 proposals in response to the RFQ. Because of
the overwhelming number of responses, the evaluation process and award recommendation will
be divided into two phases. This first phase includes the award recommendation for the
following categories: general architecture; planning and urban design architecture; town planning
architecture; historic preservation architecture; interior design/space planning; coastal
engineering; contamination assessment, remediation, and reporting engineering; geotechnical
engineering; and surveying. It is anticipated that the remaining categories can be awarded at the
City Commission's January meeting.
After reviewing the results of this phase of the evaluation process and staff's recommendations,
I recommend that the Mayor and City Commission approve the Resolution authorizing the
Administration to enter into negotiations as follows:
Zyscovich Inc., Wolfberg/Alvarez and Partners, Inc., RE Chisholm Architects, Inc., Waggoneer
& Ball, LLC,Allan T. Shulman Architect, P.A., BEAArchitects, Inc., Song +Associates, Inc.,
Saltz Michelson Architects, Inc. and Wannemacher Jensen Architects, Inc., for the discipline of
General Architecture.
Page 111 of 1707
Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc., EDSA, Inc.,Allan T. Shulman Architect, P.A., Zyscovich, Inc.,
The Corradino Group, and Kimley-Hom and Associates, Inc., for the discipline of Planning and
Urban Design Architecture.
Calvin, Giordano &Associates, Inc., The Corradino Group, Zyscovich, Inc., W G I, Inc., Kimley-
Horn and Associates, Inc., and KCI Technologies, Inc., for the discipline of Town Planning
Architecture.
William B. Medellin Architect P.A.;Allan T. Shulman Architect, P.A.; R.J. Heisenbottle
Architects, P.A., S/T/A Architectural Group, Inc.; and M.C. Harry and Associates, Inc.,for the
discipline of Historic Preservation Architecture.
Perkins +Will Architects, Inc., TSAO Design Group, Incorporated, and Zyscovich Inc., for the
discipline of Interior Design/Space Planning.
Moffatt& Nichol. Inc., Stantec Consulting Services, Inc., Cummins Cederberg, Inc.,AECOM
Technical Services, Inc., and Coastal Systems International, Inc.,for the discipline of Coastal
Engineering.
Nova Consulting, Inc., Professional Service Industries, Inc., and E Sciences, Incorporated, for
the discipline of Contamination Assessment, Remediation, and Reporting Engineering.
Universal Engineering Sciences, LLC, GFA International, Inc.; Professional Service Industries,
Inc., NV5, Inc. and Radise International, L.C.,for the discipline of Geotechnical Engineering
F.R.Aleman&Associates, Inc., Biscayne Engineering Company, Inc., Schwebke-Shiskin &
Associates, Inc., Maser Consulting, P.A., and Craven Thompson&Associates, Inc.,for the
discipline of Surveying.
I also recommend that the Mayor and City Clerk to execute an agreement with each of the
recommended proposers upon conclusion of successful negotiations by the Administration.
Applicable Area
Not Applicable
Is this a "Residents Right Does this item utilize G.O.
to Know" item. pursuant to Bond F nds?
City Code Section 2-14?
No No
Legislative Tracking
Capital Improvement Projects/Procurement
ATTACHMENTS:
Description
o Exhibit A
o Exhibit B
Page 112 of 1707
EXHIBIT A
General Architecture Coastal Engineering
Zyscovich Inc. Moffatt& Nichol. Inc.
Wolfberg/Alvarez and Partners, Inc. Stantec Consulting Services, Inc.
RE Chisholm Architects, Inc. Cummins Cederberg, Inc.
Waggonner&Ball, LLC AECOM Technical Services, Inc.
Allan T. Shulman Architect, P.A. Coastal Systems International, Inc.
BEA Architects, Inc.
Contamination Assessment, Remediation,and
Song+Associates, Inc. Reporting Engineering
Saltz Michelson Architects, Inc. Nova Consulting, Inc.
Wannemacher Jensen Architects, Inc. Professional Service Industries, Inc.
E Sciences, Incorporated
Planning and Urban Design Architecture
Brooks+Scarpa Architects, Inc. Geotechnical Engineering
EDSA, Inc. Universal Engineering Sciences, LLC
Allan T.Shulman Architect, P.A. GFA International, Inc
Zyscovich, Inc. Professional Service Industries, Inc.
The Corradino Group NV5, Inc.
Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. Radise International, L.C.
Town Planning Architecture Surveying
Calvin, Giordano&Associates, Inc. F.R.Aleman &Associates, Inc.
The Corradino Group Biscayne Engineering Company, Inc.
Zyscovich, Inc. Schwebke-Shiskin&Associates, Inc.
WGI, Inc. Maser Consulting, P.A.
Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. Craven Thompson &Associates, Inc.
KCI Technologies, Inc.
Historic Preservation Architecture
William B. Medellin Architect P.A.
Allan T.Shulman Architect, P.A.
R.J. Heisenbottle Architects, P.A.
S/T/A Architectural Group, Inc.
M.C. Harry and Associates, Inc.
Interior Design/Space Planning
Perkins+Will Architects, Inc.
TSAO Design Group, Incorporated
Zyscovich Inc.
Page 114 of 1707
EXHIBIT B
ARCHITECTURE-GENERAL
e 0 .88n8IY0DLAA3.l 0IDAL Lcr.
MO FASCIAN611131WMI®FGU® Francisca Garcia 1AIn0Mh P1otlowu i Colette SWIMS §
unmuae4
•uEl�pur !81
Totals
OwONDo. 0lamtlb6n &GOAN Ct.Reo. OL1nObVn 6k01ON1 OSWIh.,01tstits r1 Bi/total
2nc6Nd1lnc 100 __—5 105 1 96 6,_--___ 101 1 BB 5 101 2 a 1
Wd15e0Ahae7 DAPurines.enc. ..9_.. ._5 104 6 96 5 101 1 96 5 _ 101 t 2 • 9 7
RECNaM4n Architect.Inc. 100 -- 5 - 105 I 5 99 4 88 J 91 15 20
.._ —B8_._._ 5.._ 4
Wp2Bever 6 Bee LLC5__.- .105 19 89 5 _.•.�_..
_9J 13 W 5 90. . ] 214 4
Alton T.Shulman Afdded.RAA: 100_..... J 103 9 94 3 _._.97 5I 92_._.._... 3 rt- 95 10 21 6
BEA 088599.lne 88 5 103 9 92 5„. 51...."$, 90 I 5 B5 1 10 ..24 6
San.1,Aefooates.lne .,_ 99.. ..._.�`_.. _.101 13 99 •1 90 I 5—_.. 95_-- „10 24 6
Sce6 97
Wo ornochr JenseArchitn
rchass. _-... ..64. 5_,. 99 19 92 ..3,�_ 97 5t 97 5 ...._._.9; 7 25 5
Wme0mada.Jemm NdiA010 Inc. _98 J 1014 6 94 ] 979 5 95 —_.5 .__BB 7 25 0
T Degmoo p,6 lncorooebd 89 ._ 5 101 8 91 _ S....___.� 9; _ 5_._ ..— BO 18 31 10,
Brook,a Smite Ar54Oeds,Inc —._190....._._5._.___10.51 76 __.6„._.. 80 231 92 5 .a. .97 B._ JJ 11
AECOMTBdOkA Services,stenSG_ 92_.,. ...5 97 19 80 35 93 13 98 3_._'_.._101 2 34 12
VMC,Hn e/wlow ucclal5.SG.Inc. 92 _._.._ 3 97 22 9 _._..3_..___. 95 91 . 5 .. _-1 2 _37_...17
OA Ardect AaeGdeleaIhc. _.... 98 ..._..-5 ...._109 22 93 3 89 9 98 3 ... 99... 9 37 14
SRAAA4NBMuA,Inc. Inc. 98 5 503 9 84_. 5_— 89 17 82 5�__.._ 87 17 ; 43 16
9CNn&Meda 1 ._ 98 ._ __.5 105 9 82 5 87 -19 82 5 „ 67 16^ 47 18
Wlelsm 6.Mede5ln Ardnted P.A. 100...__._ _.__. .. _._ _
... ........_ ......S _ 105 1 92 5 87 19 78
OLANZ Archledore anOe54n Coy_, ._.,_49, 5 104 8 90 S_,_ 86 11 87 72 35 52 16
_...5..._.._.._87
Beendum Butch chlIedure.Inc..__96_...._.6_ 101 13 7B—_____S-_ 83 22 82 __.. 5 B7 18 .' S3 .19
NOVA Engineering a EnNtomtmtel,
LLC 98_,-... 5 101 13 BO_.. 5 65 20 80 5 85 21 ' 54 20
RN.ArchAee•Deakp3 P.A. 90 _5 95 27 84........ 5— 89 '
do17i B0 .._...5_._._: 85 21 65 29
JSK Architectural Group.LLC 90 5 ._ 95 27 73 S„_..... 78 27. 88 6 � .. _. 13 87 22
VJrAlWedoY Gnaw.Inc. 98_ 5 93 31 85 , S_ 90 '18, 79 _._}......5 -_... 84 24 71 _23
Rpw_Ctovelee Ardtlleds.Inc. ..._ —_95,95,, _ 5 __190 17 75 5 80 _ t23, 71 • 5 .,. 76 .,52 _ 72 24
I
Archke]uM Onion CtllaSen7Ae.Inc,,_,_ 88 5 91 32 85 5 70 29 87 5 92 14 75 20
inc.CPN.ir — . _._ _.. _
5 9 22 60 _5 9955 37 82_.. ....-_6...._— 59 I 28 77 20
DMA Onion 6Artldtedwe,Inc. 95 5 I 100 ti 0 �_.._5 _�5__33.—BQ_ 5 54 24 79 _25
CSA Central.Inc. 81 5 26 70 55 .15-....85 79 5 .. 84 24 79 26
WNW,Lure Architect Inc. __.....8!.....___5..._.___88 36 87 6., ,_.. 92 15 78 5 _.._8327 • 79 26
•
_Nyorko Ardyledu.el Grotto.lrtc. -B6 5 91 32 75 _. _..5..__ B0 23 78 5 84 34 ' 70 30
R IMAM A...Inc. _.93.._ 5 _-97 22 65 5 _... 70 29 70 5—.__.__75 ._3_31., 84 31
1WFe A8SCOn0.Inc. 794
9 - .,-5 89 19 80 5 85 31 65 _.._5„.,. 70 38 BB 3
D.L..Fbtlf C5.InO 0.LLC _--89_ _._.. 5 94 30 58 _._5._.. .....63 35 77 5 ... ._.._81_._78 r.` 84 33
ROD Architect.Inc. _.._..90 .., 5 95 27 BO ,.__..5 65 31 es __.._5 .._._.. 70 36 94 33
Burton Berth .05 P.A. ...._ BO... 6 85 38 7'�L....,......._5... 80 23 65 $...__. 70 36 ii 98--..32
Palen8Wj g N0.10;D80 on GGrow.Inc ee 5 91 32 60 _.. 5
RMS Balms Emelcpe CenWente, .__..__ ..___5_ ��—_L1 b 82 28 :. BB 36
,LLC _._. 84._.._._5 89 36__.. 80 _._.._5...—__65 31 75..._, 5. ___. 80 . 31 98 35
TM Tenon Preack Company
ArdtSedad FRAMs.Inc. 84. __.6___^_,89 38 60 5 ...__. 65 31 70 . S _._55_... 33 100
38
CFM P088e.IetlInc. ..___ 66.._._ _...5 91 32 55 . 5— B0 38 85 .__.5.._.— ]0 1 38 104 59
39rEL DOODO.566. —78.... ......5 _.$3 40 40 6 _..45_._,739_ 55 t 5_,.___50 ' 40 .119.____.$15
• 9.10.14.. ..
jw..Wean•
Ramon Va...Iwo. Voomm,soonyOoms on...e..... Wm..
M▪CA.ToarEal Sonftss.Oa W.A.
KnOocsoorDeo.Coactaao OE LS
6 MOM.ON So
SU
fl▪hl•rthisos.iss s4
COO Cooll So MPS
..0011•11......... ..
win sr
11
WAS Noe..sonosrancoom SO
Slams.•RN DoutoOna• o.
e ms Oecoiaz Aroma.nic ..
.OA.s. __._._ ra
005
u..war.a..0 r. o.,
vrn.wa.uoay__ _. _
n o▪ e..•o .r. _.3.
,,,,000.a.WC SO
Volomosno.lorsmi Nowak si MOMS
Systomons MO.
IFOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL RANKING DOES NOT COMMUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 115 of 1707
EXHIBIT B
ARCHITECTURE-HISTORIC PRESERVATION
RFQ 2020-098•ND PROFESSIONAL
ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING SERVICES c e e LOW c
Ariel Gultian Colette Satchel! Debora Tackett
IN SPECIALIZED CATEGORIES ON AN"AS- c C C Aggregate C
NEEDED BASIS' re 2 Totals 2
Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal
William B.Medellin Architect P.A. 96 5 101 1 93 5 98 2 97 5 102 2 5 1
Allan T.Shulman Architect,P.A. 96 3 99 2 95 3 98 2 99 3 102 2 , 6 2
R.J.Heisenbottle Architects,P.A. 94 5 99 2 93 5 98 2 96 5 101 4 8 3
S/T/A Architectural Group,Inc. 92 5 97 5 93 5 98 2 98 5 103 1 8 3
M.C.Harry and Associates,Inc. 96 3 99 2 94 3 97 6 94 3 97 5 13 5
Bender&Associates Architects,P.A. 91 5 96 6 95 5 100 1 90 5 95 8 15 6
Berenblum Busch Architecture,Inc. 91 5 96 6 92 5 97 6 92 5 97 5 17 7
JSK Architectural Group,LLC 88 5 93 9 86 5 91 8 90 5 95 8 25 8
DN'A Design&Architecture,Inc. 80 5 85 12 82 5 87 9 92 5 97 5 26 9
TSAO Design Group,Incorporated 89 5 79 5 87 5
94 8 84 10 92 10 , 28 10
I ne l ar!lull d reawt:K .ornparly 88 5 93 9 78 5 83 11 80 5 85 12 32 11
KCI Technologies,Inc. 88 3 91 11 75 3 78 12 83 3 86 11 34 12
F.ptiameStMPONb. • • ..
Total Quantitative
(Volume of Work+
Proposer Volume of Work Volume of Work Points Veteran's Points Veteran's)
Allan T.Shulman Architect.P.A. 5570,000 3 0 3
Bender&Associates Architects $0 5 0 5
Berenblum Busch Architecture,Inc. 50 5 0 5
DN'A Design&Architecture,Inc. $0 5 9 5
JSK Architectural Group.LLC 50 5 0 5
KCI Technologies,Inc. $930,503 3 0 3
M.C.Harry and Associates,Inc. $370,472 3 0 3
R.J.Heisenbottle Architects,P.A. $0 5 0 5
S?IA Architectural Group,Inc. 50 5 0 5
The Tamara Peacock Company Architects of Florida,Inc. $0 5 0 5
TSAO Design Group,Incorporated $130,404 5 0 5
William B.Medellin Architect P.A. 5173,301 5 0 5
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 116 of 1707
EXHIBIT B
INTERIOR DESIGN/SPACE PLANNING
RFQ 2020.096•ND PROFESSIONAL
ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERINGc► w rLOW
SERVICES IN SPECIALIZED Francisco Garcia c Ro alto Madan ° Olga Sanchez
CATEGORIES ON AN"AS-NEEDED c g c Aggregate
12
BASIS" fa
W ce 12 Totals
Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal
Perkins+Will Architects,Inc. 99 5 104 2 98 5 103 1 90 5 95• 1 4 1
TSAO Design Group, •
Incorporated 98 5 103 3 89 5 94 3 80 5 85 2 8 2
Zyscovich Inc. 100 5 105 1 86 5 91 5 80 5 85 2 8 2
Palenzuela&Hevia Design
Group,Inc. 89 5 94 6 90 5 95 2 80 5 85 2 10 4
Song+Associates,Inc. 94 5 99 4 87 5 92 4 60 5 65 6 14 5
OLANZ Architecture and
Design Corp. 92 5 97 5 77 5 82 6 60 5 65 6 17 6
Burton Hersh Architects,P.A. 89 5 94 6 73 • 5 78 7 70 5 75 5 18 _ 7
Architectural Design
Collaborative,Inc. 87 5 92 8 70 5 75 8 60 5 65 6 22 8
Total Quantitative
(Volum.of Work
Proposer Volume of Work Volume of Work Points Veteran's Points Veteran's)
Architectural Design Collaborative.Inc. S0 5 0 5
Burton Hersh Architects,P.A. SO 50 5
OLANZ Architecture and Design Corp. S0 50 5
Palenzuela&Hevia Design Group SO 50 5
Perkins+Will Architects,Inc. SO 50 5
Song+Associates,Inc. SO 50 5
TSAO Design Group,Incorporated $130,404 5 0 5
Zyscovich Inc. $176,600 5 0 5
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 117 of 1707
6UNUeb t-N M V' N up A r• A O NC* a
w
A m '
J `C O CO co (O rn N N N 'N CO CO CO
WF
W
Q
6UpIU '- N COvIn co co co a) a)
goo C rn r` c0 C co O) in M cn in
a rn a) co co ao r- Is N- Is Is. CD CD
0
Ca
a
L m
a A
2 a as a) M Io In CO CO co co co in c0 co O
U 03
E 0
as
0
a
S 0 CD 0 sr N 0 0 0 O 0000
w
o) rn ao m co CO n n N- Is n CO CD
0
Z Cr
y6U!IUUa cO N - U) corn Lo rs rn CO I-N- 0
UJ 17-
0
p a
Qz rn° C) rnNmm 0) iCN E co COcocoocoocCD
a< N O
p C
OS . W
Z te
age l o�
CO Q '� a!c 0
In In CO In In CO CO CO) In 1n 1n CO 1n Un •V O lel to to na 0 tq til 0 tO 0 t"1 0 0 N Cr
- Z C 04
m O 0 >> s
X Z 0: O - f Z Z
LU
Lu
0. s
) '
rn rn rnm O (r` (O CO I` a OcI .
N. co r` r` (D CD 10 y F-
0
N.
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o co 0
j 0
W 6un uea r N 'Q st co N- N CO N O ,- cO v F-
co
F 0 r
Z r
( o s Vi8I. 00C') 1n1nN1n inM (oao In u) a)
a) a) rna) mmmrn NIs- I• CD CD s W 0)
Q e 0 d
o
L m ; a7 h L rY LO N t7 N el N N N 0
n to Z
■ E _
I C In to CO O (n 0) c+) CO In O In C') N In '
m CO
>°
o O I a
> Ii
a t e g n $ E. n Z
3 In N Is LOCO N N O 0 CO O CO O N e o N o w N u
m rn rn CO CO CO CO CO CO CO r. m ti CO CO e 6 n N d N g N N o
�'y M N M N M N N u)
V > W
U)
W a
gW2CO.4 ci Q c c 2a.
oo= ca H 6 .9
co y�=O - N C
y,W I"la y m CO 4-1
.V O 'j 0 co
Cy CO0.
`=CO 2 � Q c
cn O. o Q oco C Dai a s L w ° x
<620v c CO- ace CO C0 o = CO g
su.
II .1 0
Q p o
cm= Cl) U . O O O .- C - a g 1 i _ I c)
D Fo g + CU) LN S U0c ` tc _ 2 B . e
2
WY a) UC Cc) JOg Ed m
) Q g U C ° Q
d) a) D C ,f, l•- m m c
20 mnt m W CI- L.) a) o ( 6 ggaE - 5t5a mW Q NI- Y OV5m 0 Y Y1 [ ¢ m0- cic) am 12g ,-E3
N
EXHIBIT B
ARCHITECTURE-TOWN PLANNING
RFQ 2020-096-ND PROFESSIONAL '
ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING SERVICES c c c LOW e
IN SPECIALIZED CATEGORIES ON AN"AS Josiel Ferrer Rogello Madan a James Murphy Aggregate
NEEDED BASIS" co i ¢ _ Totals 12
Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal
Calvin,Giordano&Associates,Inc. 90 3 93 2_ 96 3 99 1 100 3 103 1 4 1
The Corradino Group 93 5 98 1 _. 85 5 90 3 94 5 99 3 iN 7 2
Zyscovich,Inc. 85 5 90 3 85 5 90 3 96 5 101 2 iiR 8 3
WGI,Inc. 80 5 85 4, 87 5 92 2 80 5 85 5 11 4
Kimley-Horn and Associates,Inc. 80 3 83 5 75 3 78 5 85 3 88 4 14 5
KCI Technologies, Inc. 75 3 78 6 70 3 73 6 80 3 83 6 18 6
. rolnit+ , .. . .
Total Quantitative
(Volume of Work•
Proposer Volume of Work Volume of Work Points Veteran's Points Veteran's)
Calvin,Giordano&Associates,Inc. $16,828 3 0 3
KCI Technologies.Inc. $930,503 3 0 3
Kimley-Hom and Associates,Inc. $1,162,477 3 0 3
The Corradino Group $31,500 5 0 5
WGI,Inc. SO 5 0 5
Zyscovlch,Inc. 5175,500 5 0 5
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL.RANKING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 119 of 1707
EXHIBIT B
ENGINEERING-COASTAL
RFQ 202009E-ND PROFESSIONAL ARCHITECTURAL in W a w
AND ENGINEERING SERVICES IN SPECIALIZED Sabrina Bogller' Y Luis Soto Y Elizabeth Wheaton Y Aggregate Lm
CATEGORIES ON AN'AS NEEDED BASIS t= m t=o
aG a Totals a
Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal
Moffatt&Nichol.Inc. 94 5 99 1 73 5 78 5 90 5 95 1 7 1
Stantec Consulting Services,Inc. 94 3 97 2 78 3 81 4 90 3 93 3 9 2
Cummins Cederberg,Inc. 90 5 95 6 82 5 87 3 90 5 95 1 10 3
AECOM Technical Services,Inc. 94 3 97 2 85 3 88 2 80 3 83 8 • 12 4
Coastal Systems International,Inc. 93 3 96 5 86 3 89 1 85 3 88 7 ' 13 5
Mott MacDonald,LLC 92 5 97 2 67 5 72 9 85 5 90 4 _ 15 6
GHD Services,Inc. 90 5 95 6 69 5 74 8 85 5 90 4 18 7
McLaren Technical Services,Inc. 88 5 93 9 72 5 77 6 85 5 90 4 19 8
T.Y.Lin International 89 5 94 8 70 5 75 7 75 5 80 9 • 24 9
GRAEF-USA Inc. 80 5 85 10 67 5 72 9 60 5 65 10 29 10
:: I( 1 Pgtle
Total Quantitative
(Volume of Work r
Proposer Volume of Work Volume of Work Pointe Veteran's Points Veteran's)
AECOM Technical Services,Inc. $424,498 3 0 3
Coastal Systems International,Inc. $574,388 3 0 3
Cummins Cederherg,Inc. SO 5 0 5
GHD Services,Inc. $0 5 0 5
GRAEF-USA Inc. SO 5 0 5
McLaren Technical Services,Inc. 00 5 0 5
Moffatt&Nichol.Inc. S0 5 0 5
Mott MacDonald,LLC SO 5 0 5
Stantec Consulting Services,Inc. $1,678,593 3 0 3
T.Y.Lin International 50 5 0 5
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 120 of 1707
EXHIBIT B
ENGINEERING -CONTAMINATION ASSESSMENT, REMEDIATION,AND REPORTING
RFC!202049S-ND PROFESSIONAL
ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING a fA ca al
SERVICES IN SPECIALIZED Sabrina Baglierl Y Matthew LePere Y Elizabeth Wheaton Y Aggregate Y
CATEGORIES ON AN'AS•NEEDED c c e e
BASIS' es
CC to
cc ga Totals
Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal
Nova Consulting,Inc. 94 5 99 1 87 5 92 2 90 5 • 95 1 4 1
Professional Service
Industries, Inc. 92 5 97 3 93 5 98 1 90 5 95 1 5 2
E Sciences,Incorporated 96 3 99 1 87 3 90 3 90 3 93 3 7 3
GFA International, Inc. 88 5 93 4 75 5 80 5 80 5 85 4 _ 13 4
Kimley-Hom and Associates 89 3 92 5 78 3 81 4 80 3 83 6 , 15 5
GHD Services Inc. 80 5 85 6 70 5 75 6 80 5 85 4 _ 16 6
Total Quantitative
(Volume of Work
Proposer Volume of Work Volume of Work Points Veteran's Points Veteran's)
E Sciences,Incorporated 5849,468 3 0 3
GFA International,Inc. 578,704 5 0 5
GHD Services Inc. $0 5 0 5
Kimley.Horn and Associates,Inc. $1,162,477 3 0 3
Nova Consulting,Inc. SO 5 0 5
Professional Service Industries,Inc. 50 5 0 5
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 121 of 1707
EXHIBIT B
ENGINEERING-GEOTECHNICAL
FIFO 2020-085-ND PROFESSIONAL ARCHITECTURAL e c c Low c
AND ENGINEERING SERVICES IN SPECIALZED Sabrina Bagged ;� Glancarto Pena Y Lisei Suarez YY
CATEGORIES ON AN'AS-NEEDED BASIS' c c c Aggregate e
co co a Totals 12
cc cc
Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal
Universal Engineering Sciences,LLC 95 5 100 3 97 5 102 1 93 5 98 2 6 1
GFA International,Inc 92 5 97 5 96 5 101 2 95 5 100 1 8 2
Professional Service Industries,Inc. 96 5 101 2 93 5 98 4 91 5 96 4 10 3
NV5,Inc. 94 5 99 4 92 5 97 5 92 5 97 3 12 4
Radise International,L.C. 98 5 103 1 90 5 95 6 86 5 91 5 • 12 4
Terracon Consultants,Inc. 91 5 96 7 95 5 100 3 79 5 84 7 17 6
Wingerter Laboratories,Inc. 92 5 97 5 89 5 94 7 81 5 86 6 18 7
HP Consultants,Inc. 80 5 85 10 88 5 93 8 76 5 81 8 26 8
NOVA Engineering&Environmental,LLC 88 5 93 8 87 5 92 9 71 5 76 9 26 8
Blascom Engineering,Inc. 87 5 92 9 87 5 92 9 70 5 75 10 . 28 10
Total Quantitative
(Volume of Work iv
Proposer Volume of Work Volume of Work Pointe Veteran's Points Veteran's)
Blascom Engineering,Inc. $0 5 0 5
GFA International,Inc 176,704 5 0 _ 5
—
HP Consultants,Inc. 10 5 0 5
NOVA Engineering&Environmental,LLC $05 0 5
NV5,Inc. $37,5505 0 5
Professional Service Industries,Inc. SO 5 0 5
Radise International,L.C. $192,138 50 5
Terracon Consultants,Inc. SO5 0 5
Universal Engineering Sciences,LLC 519704995 0 5
Wingerter Laboratories,Inc. $14,0365 0 5
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 122 of 1707
EXHIBIT B
SURVEYING
RFQ 2020-099-ND PROFESSIONAL a�
ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING SERVICES e C c Low e
Sabrina Ba lieri Brian Belllno Lisel Suarez
IN SPECIALIZED CATEGORIES ON AN"AS g e C C Aggregate e
NEEDED BASIS' cc a Totals i
el I
Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal
F.R.Aleman&Associates,Inc. 98 5 103 1 92 5 97 4 92 5 97 2 7 1
Biscayne Engineering Company,Inc. 94 5 99 3 96 5 101 1 89 5 94 5 9 2
Schwebke-Shiskin&Associates,Inc. 96 3 99 3 94 3 97 4 94 3 97 2 • 9 2
Maser Consulting,P.A. 94 5 99 3 93 5 98 . 2 83 5 88 9 14 4
Craven Thompson&Associates,Inc. 88 5 93 11 93 5 98 2 95 5 100 1 14 4
Longitude Surveyors,LLC 93 5 98 6 92 5 97 4 86 5 91 6 16 6
Calvin,Giordano&Associates,Inc. 93 3 96 8 91 3 94 7 87 3 90 7 22 7
Hadonne Corp. 92 5 97 7 89 5 94 7 84 5 89 8 22 7
KCI Technologies,Inc. 99 3 102 2 88 3 91 12 85 3 88 9 23 9
Miller,Legg&Associates,Inc. 92 3 95 10 87 3 90 13 93 3 96 4 27 10
sewer L.0 wt et kWSU<Aates,r. .L,., 91 5 96 8 87 5 92 11 71 5 76 13 32 11
r .
Keith and Associates,Inc. 81 '5 86 13 89 5 94 7 75 5 80 1232 11
Premiere Design Solutions,Inc. 84 589 12 88 5 93 10 76 5 81 11 33 13
Total Quantitative
(Volume of Work+
Proposer Volume of Work Volume of Work Pointe Veteran's Pointe Veteran's)
Biscayne Engineering Company,Inc. $114,881 5 0 5
Calvin.Giordano&Associates.Inc. $416,828 3 0 3
Craven Thompson&Associates.Inc. $123,861 5 0 5
F.R.Aleman&Associates,Inc. $0 5 0 5
Hadonne Corp. $0 5 0 5
Javier E.Bidot&Associates,P.S.C.,Corp. $0 5 0 5
KCI Technologies,Inc. $830,603 3 0 3
Keith and Associates,Inc. $0 5 0 5
Longitude Surveyors,LLC $0 5 0 5
Maser Consulting,P.A. 151,860 5 0 5
Miller,Legg&Associates,Inc. $359,915 3 0 3
Premiere Design Solutions,Inc. $0 5 D' 5
Schwebke-Shiskln&Associates,Inc. $477,742 3 0 3
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 123 of 1707