Resolution 2021-31536 RESOLUTION NO. 2021-31536
A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY
OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, ACCEPTING THE RECOMMENDATION OF
THE CITY MANAGER FOR THE RANKING OF PROPOSALS PURSUANT
TO REQUEST FOR QUALIFICATIONS (RFQ) NO. 2020-096-ND, FOR
PROFESSIONAL ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING SERVICES IN
SPECIALIZED CATEGORIES ON AN "AS-NEEDED BASIS"; REJECTING
ALL PROPOSALS RECEIVED FOR THE DISCPLINE OF LEED
COMMISSIONING, AND AUTHORIZING THE ADMINISTRATION TO ENTER
INTO NEGOTIATIONS WITH THE ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING
FIRMS, AS SET FORTH IN EXHIBIT "A", FOR THE DISCIPLINES OF
GENERAL ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES ENGINEERING, LANDSCAPE
ARCHITECTURE, MECHANICAL, ELECTRICAL AND PLUBMING
ENGINEERING, ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING, PLUMBING ENGINEERING,
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING, STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING, CIVIL
ENGINEERING, STORMWATER ENGINEERING, AND SECURITY AND
SAFETY ENGINEERING; AND FURTHER AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR AND
CITY CLERK TO EXECUTE AN AGREEMENT WITH EACH OF THE
RECOMMENDED PROPOSERS UPON CONCLUSION OF SUCCESSFUL
NEGOTIATIONS BY THE ADMINISTRATION.
WHEREAS, on March 18, 2020, the City Commission approved the issuance of Request
for Qualifications (RFQ) No. 2020-096-ND for Professional Architectural and Engineering
Services in Specialized Categories on an "As-Needed Basis"; and
WHEREAS, Request for Qualifications No. 2020-096-ND (the "RFQ") was released on
April 10, 2020; and
WHEREAS, a voluntary pre-proposal meeting was held on April 23, 2020; and
WHEREAS, on June 5, 2020, the City received one hundred thirty-five (135) proposals;
and
WHEREAS, as is customary, the City Manager appointed Evaluation Committees (the
"Committee") by discipline to review the proposals received for each discipline; and
WHEREAS, because of the overwhelming number of responses, the evaluation
committees had to be broken up into groups; and
WHEREAS, on December 9, 2020, via Resolution 2020-31512, the Mayor and City
Commission accepted the City Manager's recommendation pertaining to the ranking of
proposals for the first group which included: general architecture; planning and urban design
architecture; town planning architecture; historic preservation architecture; interior design /
space planning; coastal engineering; contamination assessment, remediation, and reporting
engineering; geotechnical engineering; and surveying; and
WHEREAS, this resolution addresses an award recommendation for the second group
that was not included as part of Resolution 2020-31512, which includes: landscape architecture;
LEED commissioning; civil engineering; stormwater engineering; structural engineering;
mechanical, electrical, and plumbing engineering; electrical engineering; plumbing engineering;
mechanical engineering; security and safety engineering; and general environmental services
engineering; and
WHEREAS, the Committees for the second group consisted of the following individuals:
LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE
• Barbara Hernandez, Division Director— Park Development and Special Projects, Parks
and Recreation Department
• Rodney Knowles, Greenspace Division Director, Public Works Department
• Omar Leon, Urban Forester, Environment and Sustainability Department; and
CIVIL ENGINEERING
• Mariana Evora, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
• Giancarlo Pena, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
• Mina Samadi, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital Improvement
Projects; and
ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING
• Mariana Evora, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
• Francisco Garcia, Senior Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management
Department
• Olga Sanchez, Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management
Department; and
GENERAL ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES ENGINEERING
• Mariana Evora, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
• Giancarlo Pena, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
• Elizabeth Wheaton, Director, Environment and Sustainability Department; and
LEED COMMISSIONING
• Carla Dixon, Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital Improvement Projects
• Flavia Tonioli, Sustainability Manager, Environment and Sustainability Department
• Thais Vieira, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, Office of the City Manager; and
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING
• Mariana Evora, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
• Francisco Garcia, Senior Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management
Department
• Olga Sanchez, Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management
Department; and
MECHANICAL, ELECTRICAL & PLUMBING ENGINEERING
• Mariana Evora, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
• Francisco Garcia, Senior Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management
Department
• Olga Sanchez, Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management
Department; and
PLUMBING ENGINEERING
• Mariana Evora, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
• Francisco Garcia, Senior Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management
Department
• Olga Sanchez, Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management
Department; and
SECURITY AND SAFETY ENGINEERING
• Steve Feldman, Captain, Police Department
• Francisco Garcia, Senior Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management
Department
• Matthew LePera, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department; and
STORMWATER ENGINEERING
• Mariana Evora, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
• Giancarlo Pena, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
• Mina Samadi, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital Improvement
Projects; and
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING
• Ariel Guitian, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital Improvement
Projects
• Giancarlo Pena, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
• Olga Sanchez, Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management
Department; and
WHEREAS, the Committees were provided an overview of the project, information
relative to the City's Cone of Silence Ordinance and the Government Sunshine Law, general
information on the scope of services, and a copy of each proposal; and
WHEREAS, the Committee was instructed to score and rank each proposal pursuant to
the evaluation criteria established in the RFQ; and
WHEREAS, the Evaluation Committee process resulted in the ranking of proposers as
indicated in Exhibit"B"; and
WHEREAS, staff recommends the rejection of all proposals received for the LEED
commissioning discipline, as the evaluation committee stated that the firms that provided
proposals were not specialized in LEED commissioning and failed to mention key components
such as renewable energy and water conservation; and
WHEREAS, after reviewing the results of this phase of the evaluation process and staff's
recommendations, the City Manager recommends that the Aadministration be authorized to
enter into negotiations with the following:
• Landscape Architecture: Keith and Associates, Inc., Curtis & Rogers Design Studio,
Inc., Perkins + Will Architects, Inc., Savino & Miller Design Studio, P.A., Craven
Thompson & Associates, Inc., WGI, Inc., EDSA, Inc., CPH, Inc., Calvin, Giordano &
Associates, Inc., and Chen Moore and Associates, Inc.;
• Civil Engineering: CES Consultants, Inc., A&P Consulting Transportation Engineers,
Corp., Nova Consulting, Inc., Ardurra Group, Inc., CDM Smith, Inc., EAC
Consulting, Inc., Schwebke-Shiskin & Associates, Inc., Kimley-Horn and
Associates, Inc., Chen Moore and Associates, Inc., 300 Engineering Group, P.A.,
Calvin, Giordano &Associates, Inc., and CPH, Inc.;
• Electrical Engineering: Wolfberg/Alvarez and Partners, Inc., A&P Consulting
Transportation Engineers, Corp., BCC Engineering, Inc., McFarland-Johnson, Inc.,
Exp. U.S. Services, Inc., Black&Veatch Corporation, and H.W. Lochner Inc.;
• General Environmental Services Engineering: Miller, Legg & Associates, Inc., E
Sciences, Incorporated, WGI, Inc., Nova Consulting, Inc., Coastal Systems
International, Inc., Stantec Consulting Services Inc., Kimley-Horn and Associates,
Inc., Calvin, Giordano &Associates, Inc., and T.Y. Lin International;
• Mechanical Engineering: Wolfberg/Alvarez and Partners, Inc., McFarland-Johnson,
Inc., Black&Veatch Corporation, and Exp. U.S. Services, Inc.;
• Mechanical, Electrical, and Plumbing Engineering: Wolfberg/Alvarez and Partners,
Inc., Exp. U.S. Services, Inc., McFarland-Johnson, Inc., 3FM Engineering, Inc.,
Hazen and Sawyer, P.C., and WGI, Inc.;
• Plumbing Engineering: Wolfberg/Alvarez and Partners, Inc., Black & Veatch
Corporation, and Exp. U.S. Services, Inc.;
• Safety Engineering: Ross & Baruzzini, Inc., McFarland-Johnson, Inc., and
SpectrumHaven, LLC;
• Stormwater Engineering: CES Consultants, Inc., Hazen and Sawyer, P.C., A&P
Consulting Transportation Engineers, Corp., Aluces Corporation, T.Y. Lin
International, Ardurra Group, Inc., CDM Smith, Inc., Schwebke-Shiskin &
Associates, Inc., AECOM Technical Services, Inc., Craven Thompson &Associates,
Inc., Chen Moore and Associates, Inc., 300 Engineering Group, P.A., and Nova
Consulting, Inc.; and
• Structural Engineering: Moffatt & Nichol. Inc., Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc.,
BCC Engineering, Inc., Biller Reinhart Engineering Group, Inc., Master Consulting
Engineers, Inc., R.J. Behar & Company, Inc., WGI, Inc., A&P Consulting
Transportation Engineers, Corp., 305 Consulting Engineers, LLC, Chrome
Engineering, Inc., CONNECT Engineering, LLC.
WHEREAS, in accordance with Section 287.055, Florida Statutes, known as the
"Consultants' Competitive Negotiation Act", the City may enter into a "continuing contract" for
professional architectural and engineering services for projects in which construction costs do
not exceed $4 Million or for study activities for which the fee does not exceed $500,000; and
WHEREAS, the City Manager and Administration recommend the Mayor and City
Commission approve this Resolution, rejecting all proposals received for the discipline of LEED
Commissioning; and authorizing the Administration to enter into negotiations with the
architectural and engineering firms listed in Exhibit "A" attached to this Resolution, for the
disciplines of General Environmental Services Engineering; Landscape Architecture;
Mechanical, Electrical, and Plumbing Engineering; Electrical Engineering; Plumbing
Engineering; Mechanical Engineering; Structural Engineering; Civil Engineering; Stormwater
Engineering; and Security And Safety Engineering, and further authorizing the Mayor and City
Clerk to execute agreements with each of the recommended proposers upon conclusion of
successful negotiations by the Administration.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT DULY RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY
COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, that the Mayor and City
Commission hereby accept the recommendation of the City Manager for the ranking of
proposals pursuant to Request for Qualifications (RFQ) No. 2020-096-ND for Professional
Architectural and Engineering Services in Specialized Categories, as set forth in the RFQ, on an
"As-Needed Basis"; rejecting all proposals received for the discipline of LEED Commissioning;
and authorizing the Administration to enter into negotiations with the architectural and
engineering firms listed in Exhibit "A", for the disciplines of General Environmental Services
Engineering; Landscape Architecture; Mechanical, Electrical, and Plumbing Engineering;
Electrical Engineering; Plumbing Engineering; Mechanical Engineering; Structural Engineering;
Civil Engineering; Stormwater Engineering; and Security And Safety Engineering; and further
authorizing the Mayor and City Clerk to execute an agreement with each of the recommended
proposers upon conclusion of successful negotiations by the Administration.
PASSED AND ADOPTED this 13 day of J�1' G%202/•
ATTEST:
7"-*/-7-d
RAFAEL E. GRA ADO, CITY CLERK DAN GELBER, MAYOR
APPROVED AS TO
FORM& LANGUAGE
INCORPORATED' , & FOR EXECUTION
H r
I _ S 7
CitY Attorney if Date
Resolutions -C7 D
MIAMI BEACH
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM
TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Commission
FROM: Raul J.Aguila, Interim City Manager
DATE: January 13, 2021
SUBJECT:A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY
OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, ACCEPTING THE RECOMMENDATION OF
THE CITY MANAGER FOR THE RANKING OF PROPOSALS PURSUANT
TO REQUEST FOR QUALIFICATIONS (RFQ) NO. 2020-096-ND, FOR
PROFESSIONAL ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING SERVICES IN
SPECIALIZED CATEGORIES ON AN "AS-NEEDED BASIS"; REJECTING
ALL PROPOSALS RECEIVED FOR THE DISCIPLINE OF LEED
COMMISSIONING, AND AUTHORIZING THE ADMINISTRATION TO
ENTER INTO NEGOTIATIONS WITH THE ARCHITECTURAL AND
ENGINEERING FIRMS, AS SET FORTH IN EXHIBIT "A", FOR THE
DISCIPLINES OF GENERAL ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
ENGINEERING, LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE, MECHANICAL,
ELECTRICAL AND PLUMBING ENGINEERING, ELECTRICAL
ENGINEERING, PLUMBING ENGINEERING, MECHANICAL
ENGINEERING, STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING, CIVIL ENGINEERING,
STORMWATER ENGINEERING, AND SECURITY AND SAFETY
ENGINEERING; AND FURTHER AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR AND CITY
CLERK TO EXECUTE AN AGREEMENT WITH EACH OF THE
RECOMMENDED PROPOSERS UPON CONCLUSION OF SUCCESSFUL
NEGOTIATIONS BY THE ADMINISTRATION.
RECOMMENDATION
The Administration recommends that the Mayor and City Commission of the City of Miami
Beach, Florida approve the Resolution accepting the City Manager's recommendation
pertaining to the bids received, pursuant to RFQ 2020-096-ND, for professional architectural
and engineering services in specialized categories, as noted herein in accordance with Section
287.055, Florida Statutes.
BACKGROUND/HISTORY
Section 287.055, Florida Statutes, outlines the process by which agencies in the State may
utilize contracts with architects and engineers on a continuing basis. Maintaining continuing
contracts with architects and engineers helps to expedite the award of a project when the
construction cost of each individual project does not exceed $4 million or, for study activities, if
Page 153 of 1954
the fee for professional services for each study does not exceed $500,000.
In accordance with State law, the City maintains agreements for professional architectural and
engineering services in specialized categories to be utilized on an "as-needed-basis". The
current agreements have been extended on a month to month term, until such time as the new
contracts are awarded and executed pursuant to this RFQ.
In order to establish replacement contracts, the Administration has released Request for
Qualifications (RFQ) No. 2020-096-ND to solicit qualifications from architectural and
engineering firms, including professional qualifications in the following specialized areas:
Architecture — General; Architecture — Landscape; Architecture — Planning and Urban Design;
Architecture — Town Planning; Architecture — Historic Preservation; Engineering — General
Environmental Services; Engineering — Mechanical, Electrical & Plumbing; Engineering —
Electrical; Engineering — Plumbing; Engineering — Mechanical; Engineering — Structural;
Engineering — Civil; Engineering — Geotechnical; Engineering — Coastal; Engineering —
Contamination Assessment, Remediation, and Reporting; Engineering — Stormwater; Interior
Design/Space Planning; LEED Commissioning; and Surveying.
ANALYSIS
On March 18, 2020, the Mayor and City Commission authorized the issuance of the RFQ. On
April 10, 2020, the RFQ was issued.A voluntary pre-proposal conference to provide
information to proposers submitting a response was held on April 23, 2020. Two addenda were
issued. The Procurement Department issued bid notes to 32,493 companies utilizing
www.bidsync.com website. 492 prospective bidders accessed the advertised solicitation. RFQ
responses were due and received on June 5, 2020. The City received a total of one hundred
thirty-five (135) proposals from the following firms (some firms submitted proposals for various
categories):
2 Plus Architects, Inc.
300 Engineering Group, P.A.
305 Consulting Engineers, LLC
3FM Engineering, Inc.
A&P Consulting Transportation Engineers, Corp.
AECOM Technical Services, Inc.
Allan T. Shulman Architect, P.A.
Aluces Corporation
Alvarez Engineers, Inc.
APX Engineering Group, LLC
Architectural Design Collaborative, Inc.
Ardurra Group, Inc.
BC Architects AIA, Inc.
BCC Engineering, Inc.
BEA Architects, Inc.
Bender&Associates Architects, P.A.
Berenblum Busch Architecture, Inc.
Page 154 of 1954
Biller Reinhart Engineering Group, Inc.
Biscayne Engineering Company, Inc.
Black&Veatch Corporation
Blascom Engineering, Inc.
Brindley Pieters&Associates, Inc.
Brooks + Scarpa Architects, I nc.
Bruce Howard &Associates of Florida, Inc.
Calvin, Giordano &Associates, Inc.
Castillo Engineering, Inc.
CDM Smith, Inc.
CES Consultants, Inc.
CFM Architects, Inc.
Chen-Moore and Associates, Inc.
Chrome Engineering, Inc.
Coastal Systems I ntemation I, Inc.
CONNECT Engineering, LLC
CPH, Inc.
Craven Thompson&Associates, I nc.
CSA Central, Inc.
Cummins Cederberg, Inc.
Curtis & Rogers Design Studio, Inc.
D.L. Fields Consultants, LLC D/B/A DLFC Architects
Department, LLC
DESMAN, Inc.
Disamerica Consulting Group, Inc.
DN'A Design&Architecture, Inc.
Douglas Wood Associates, Inc.
DTM Tech, Inc.
E Sciences, Inc.
EA3 CMI Engineering, Inc
EAC Consulting, Inc.
Eastern Engineering Group Company
EDSA, Inc.
Exp. U.S. Services, Inc.
F.R.Aleman&Associates, I pc.
Ferguson Glasglow Shuster Soto, Inc.
Florida Transportation Engineering, Inc.
Gallagher Bassett Services, Inc.
Garcia Mullin Group, LLC
GFA International, Inc
GHD Services, Inc.
GRAEF -USA Inc.
H.W. Lochner, Inc.
Hadonne Corp
Hardesty& Hanover, LLC
Hazen and Sawyer, P.C.
HP Consultants, Inc.
Page 155 of 1954
HSQ Group, Inc.
J&M Engineering, P.C. D/B/A M&J Engineering, P.C.
Javier E. Bidot&Associates, P.S.C., Corp.
JSK Architectural Group, LLC
KCI Technologies, Inc.
Keith and Associates, Inc.
Kimley-Hom and Associates, Inc.
Longitude Surveyors, LLC
LUSEO Group LLC
M.C. Harry and Associates, Inc.
Maser Consulting, P.A.
Master Consulting Engineers, Inc.
McFarland-Johnson, Inc.
McLaren Technical Services, Inc.
Milian, Swain, &Associates, Inc.
Miller, Legg &Associates, Inc.
Moffatt& Nichol. Inc.
Morabito Consultants, Inc.
Moses and Associates, Inc.
Mott MacDonald, LLC
Nova Consulting, Inc.
NOVA Engineering & Environmental, LLC
NV5, Inc.
Nyarko Architectural Group, Inc.
OLANZ Architecture and Design Corp.
Palenzuela& Hevia Design Group
Perkins +Will Architects, Inc.
PMM Consulting Engineers, Corp.
Premiere Design Solutions, lnc.
Professional Service Industries, Inc. D/B/A I ntertek PS I
PT Suppliers LLC D/B/A Risk and Design Consulting
R.E. Chisholm Architects, Inc.
R.J. Behar& Company, Inc.
R.J. Heisenbottle Architects, P.A.
Radise International, L.C.
Rene Gonzalez Architects, Inc.
RMS Building Envelope Consultants, LLC
Rodriguez Architects, Inc.
Ross & Baruzzini, Inc.
Ross Engineering, Inc.
RVD Architect, Inc.
RVL Architecture + Design, P.A.
Salt Michelson Architects, I pc.
Savino & Miller Design Studio, P.A.
Schwebke-Shiskin&Associates, Inc.
Song &Associates, Inc.
SpectrumHaven, LLC
Page 156 of 1954
SRS Engineering, Inc.
S/T/A Architectural Group, Inc.
Stanley Consultants, Inc.
Stantec Consulting Services, Inc.
T.Y. Lin International
Terra CMI Engineering, LLC
Terracon Consultants, Inc.
The BetaJones Group, Inc.
The Corradino Group
The Tamara Peacock Company Architects of Florida, Inc.
TSAO Design Group, Incorporated
Universal Engineering Sciences, LLC
V3 Architectural Group, Inc.
Waggonner& Ball, LLC
Walker Parking Consultants/Engineers, Inc.
Wannemacher Jensen Architects, Inc.
WGI, Inc.
William B. Medellin Architect P.A.
William Lane Architect, Inc.
Wingerter Laboratories, Inc.
Wolfberg/Alvarez and Partners, Inc.
Youssef Hachem Consulting Engineering, Inc.
Zyscovich Inc.
As is customary, the City Manager appointed Evaluation Committee (the "Committee") by
discipline to review the proposals received for each discipline. Because of the overwhelming
number of responses, the evaluation committees had to be broken up into groups. On
December 9, 2020, via Resolution 2020-31512, the Mayor and City Commission accepted the
City Manager's recommendation pertaining to the ranking of proposals for the first group which
included: general architecture; planning and urban design architecture; town planning
architecture; historic preservationrarchitecture; interior design / space planning; coastal
engineering; contamination ssessment, remediation, and reporting engineering; geotechnical
engineering; and surveying.
This agenda item addresses an award recommendation for the second group which includes:
landscape architecture; LED commissioning; civil engineering; stormwater engineering;
structural engineering; mechanical, electrical, and plumbing engineering; electrical engineering;
plumbing engineering; mectllanical engineering; security and safety engineering; and general
environmental services engineering. The Evaluation Committees for these disciplines include
the following individuals.
LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE
• Barbara Hemandez, Division Director— Park Development and Special Projects, Parks and
Recreation Department
• Rodney Knowles, Greenspace Division Director, Public Works Department
• Omar Leon, Urban Forester , Environment and Sustainability Department
Page 157 of 1954
CIVIL ENGINEERING
• Mariana Evora, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
• Giancarlo Pena, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
• Mina Samadi, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital Improvement
Projects; and
ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING
• Mariana Evora, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
• Francisco Garcia, Senior Facilities, Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management
Department
• Olga Sanchez, Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management Department
GENERAL ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES ENGINEERING
• Mariana Evora, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
• Giancarlo Pena, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
• Elizabeth Wheaton, Director, Environment and Sustainability Department
LEED COMMISSIONING
• Carla Dixon, Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital Improvement Projects
• Flavia Tonioli, Sustainability Manager, Environment and Sustainability Department
• Thais Vieira, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, Office of the City Manager
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING
• Mariana Evora, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
• Francisco Garcia, Senior Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management
Department
• Olga Sanchez, Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management Department
MECHANICAL, ELECTRICAL& PLUMBING ENGINEERING
• Mariana Evora, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
• Francisco Garcia, Senior Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management
Department
• Olga Sanchez, Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management Department
PLUMBING ENGINEERING
• Mariana Evora, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
• Francisco Garcia, Senior Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management
Department
• Olga Sanchez, Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management Department
SECURITYAND SAFETY ENGINEERING
• Steve Feldman, Captain, Police Department
• Francisco Garcia, Senior Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management
Department
• Matthew LePera, Civil Engineer II, Public Works Department
STORMWATER ENGINEERING
Page 158 of 1954
• Mariana Evora, Civil Engineer I I, Public Works Department
• Giancarlo Pena, CMI Engineer I I, Public Works Department
• Mina Samadi, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital Improvement
Projects
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING
• Ariel Guitian, Senior Capital Projects Coordinator, The Office of Capital Improvement
Projects
• Giancarlo Pena, Civil Engineer I I, Public Works Department
• Olga Sanchez, Facilities Capital Projects Coordinator, Property Management Department
The Committees were provided an overview of the project, information relative to the City's
Cone of Silence Ordinance and the Government Sunshine Law. The Committees were also
provided with general information on the scope of services and a copy of each proposal. The
Committees were instructed to score and rank each proposal pursuant to the evaluation criteria
established in the RFQ. The Evaluation Committee process resulted in the ranking of
proposers as indicated in Exhibit B. A summary of each top-ranked firm is available upon
request.
Staff from each of the departments that most use the contracts for each discipline
recommended the number of proposers that should be awarded in each category based on
rankings and expected usage. Staff recommends the rejection of all proposals received for the
LEED commissioning discipline, as the evaluation committee stated that the firms that provided
proposals were not specialized in LEED commissioning and failed to mention key components
such as renewable energy and water conservation.
SUPPORTING SURVEY DATA
According to the 2019 Community Satisfaction Survey conducted by ETC Institute, the
residents rated the most important capital improvement projects. In order to facilitate the
completion of these important capital improvement projects, the City intends to partner with
qualified architectural and en6ineering firms to provide services in various specializations.
FINANCIAL INFORMATION
The cost of the related services, determined upon successful negotiations, are subject to funds
availability approved through the City's budgeting process.
Amount(s)/Account(s):
CONCLUSION
After reviewing the proposals received and the results of the Evaluation Committee process, I
concur with staffs recommendation to award contracts to the firms listed in Appendix A, for
each respective category, based on ranking and expected project volume. Therefore, I
recommend that the Mayor and City Commission approve the Resolution authorizing the
Administration to enter into negotiations with the architectural and engineering firms listed in
Exhibit A attached hereto for the disciplines of landscape architecture, civil engineering,
Page 159 of 1954
electrical engineering, general environmental engineering, mechanical engineering, MEP
engineering, plumbing enginering, security and safety engineering, storm water engineering,
and structural engineering; further rejecting proposals received for the discipline of LEED
commissioning; and authorizing the Mayor and City Clerk to execute agreements upon
conclusion of successful negotiations by the Administration.
Applicable Area
Not Applicable
Is this a"Residents Right Does this item utilize G.Q.
to Know" item. pursuant to Bond Funds?
City Code Section 2-14?
No No
Legislative Tracking
Capital Improvement Projects/Procurement
ATTACHMENTS:
Description
❑ Exhibit A
o Exhibit B
❑ Resolution
Page 160 of 1954
EXHIBIT A
Landscape Architecture Mechanical Engineering
Keith and Associates,Inc. Wolfberg/Alvarez and Partners,Inc.
Curtis&Rogers Design Studio,Inc. McFarland-Johnson,Inc.
Perkins+Will Architects,Inc. Black&Veatch Corporation
Savino&Miller Design Studio,P.A. Exp.U.S.Services,Inc.
Craven Thompson&Associates,Inc.
WGI,Inc. Mechanical,Electrical,and Plumbing Engineering
EDSA,Inc. Wolfberg/Alvarez and Partners,Inc.
CPH,Inc. Exp.U.S.Services,Inc.
Calvin,Giordano&Associates,Inc. McFarland-Johnson,Inc.
Chen-Moore and Associates,Inc. 3FM Engineering,Inc.
Hazen and Sawyer,P.C.
Civil Engineering WGI,Inc.
CES Consultants,Inc.
A&P Consulting Transportation Engineers,
Corp. Plumbing Engineering
Nova Consulting,Inc. Wolfberg/Alvarez and Partners,Inc.
Ardurra Group,Inc. Black&Veatch Corporation
CDM Smith Inc. Exp.U.S.Services,Inc.
EAC Consulting,Inc.
Schwebke-Shiskin&Associates,Inc. Security and Safety Engineering
Kimley-Horn and Associates,Inc. Ross&Baruzzini,Inc.
Chen Moore and Associates,Inc. McFarland-Johnson,Inc.
300 Engineering Group,P.A. SpectrumHaven,LLC
Calvin,Giordano&Associates,Inc.
CPH,Inc. Stormwater Engineering
CES Consultants,Inc.
Electrical Engineering Hazen and Sawyer,P.C.
Wolfberg/Alvarez and Partners,Inc. A&P Consulting Transportation Engineers,Corp.
A&P Consulting Transportation Engineers,
Corp. Aluces Corporation
BCC Engineering,Inc. T.Y.Lin International
McFarland-Johnson,Inc. Ardurra Group,Inc.
Exp.U.S.Services,Inc. CDM Smith Inc.
Black&Veatch Corporation Schwebke-Shiskin&Associates,Inc.
H.W.Lochner Inc. AECOM Technical Services,Inc.
Craven Thompson&Associates,Inc.
General Environmental Services Engineering Chen Moore and Associates,Inc.
Miller,Legg&Associates,Inc. 300 Engineering Group,P.A.
E Sciences,Incorporated Nova Consulting,Inc.
WGI,Inc.
Nova Consulting,Inc. Structural Engineering
Coastal Systems International,Inc. Moffatt&Nichol.Inc.
Stantec Consulting Services Inc. Kimley-Horn and Associates,Inc.
Kimley-Horn and Associates,Inc. BCC Engineering,Inc.
Calvin,Giordano&Associates,Inc. Biller Reinhart Engineering Group,Inc.
T.Y.Lin International Master Consulting Engineers,Inc.
R.J.Behar&Company,Inc.
WGI,Inc.
A&P Consulting Transportation Engineers,Corp.
305 Consulting Engineers,LLC
Chrome Engineering,Inc.
CONNECT Engineering,LLC
Douglas Wood Associates,Inc.
Page 161 of 1954
EXHIBIT B
ARCHITECTURE -LANDSCAPE
RFQ 2020.006 ND PROFESSIONAL 0) CI c LOW c
ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING SERVICES
IN 8PECIALIZED CATEGORIES ON AN"AS- Michael Atkin Y Barbara Hernandez Y Omar Leon . Aggregate i
NEEDED BA - il re go
Totals a
Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative subtotal
01
Keith and Associates,Inc. 100 5 105 1 100 5 105 1 98 5 103 1 3 1
Curtis&Rogers Design Studio,Inc. 100 5 105 1 100 5 105 1 97 5 102 5 7 2
Perkins+Will Architects,Inc. 100 5 105 1 96 5 101 6 _ 98 5 103 1 8 3
Savino&Miller Design Studio,PA 100 5 105 1 96 5 101 6 98 5 103 1 '. 8 3
Craven Thompson&Associates,Inc. 100 5 105 1 94 5 99 10 98 - 5 _ 103 1 12 5
WGI,Inc. 100 5 105 1 96 5 101 6 97 5 102 5 3;: 12 5
EDSA,Inc. 100 5 105 1 96 5101 6 96 5 101 10 17 7
_
CPH,Inc. 100 5 105 1 90 5 95 12 97 5 102 5 ' 18 8
Calvin,Giordano&Associates,Inc. 100 3 103 11 100 3 103 3 99 3 102 5 .." 19 9
Chen-Moore and Associates,Inc. 100 3 103 11 100 3 103 3 99 3 102 5 19 9
Miller,Legg&Associates,Inc. 100 3 103 11 100 3 103 3 98 3 101 _ 10 24 11
Department,LLC 100 5 105 1 88 5 93 14 96 5 101 10~. 25 12
Bruce Howard&Associates of •
Florida,Inc. 100 5 105 1 90 5 95 12 95 5 100 14 I 27 13
Kimley-Hom and Associates,Inc. 100 _ 3 103 11 90 3 93 14 98 3 101 10 1'' 35 14
KCI Technologies,Inc. 100 3 103 11 94 3 97 11 97 3 100 14 p 36 15
Stantec Consulting Services,Inc. 100 3 103 11 _ 90 3 93 14 97 3 100 14 39 16
Florida Transportation Engineering,
Inc. 95 3 98 17 90 3 93 14 94 3 97 17 48 17
7::411041474., •..,i r .In. r ,![ yrS. ?lR S ;1 1,41 Ixl. [i5 '�L^„
h✓�]sti4 'Eb1'�-�',���'• I ..;1 ,�� ti ,..,
Total awta0
ntiva l
(Volum.of Work•
Proposer Volume GOVAN* Volumeof Work Pointy Valararr'a Pointe Veteran's)
_
Bruce Howard S Associates of Florida,Inc.--- $0 5 0 5
Calvin,Giordano&Associates,Inc. 5415.055 3 0 3
Chen-Moore and Associates.Inc. $1,115,001 3 0 3
CPH,Inc _ $0 5 0 $
Craven Thompson&Associates,Inc._ 5123,051 5 0 5
Cures&R•• Design Studio,Inc. __ $0 5 0 5
Deportment LLC 10 5 0 5
EDEA,Inc. 10 5 0 5
Florida Transportation Engineering.Inc. $201,020 3 0 3
KCI Technologies,Inc. $030,003 3 0 3
Keith and Associates,Inc $0 5 0 5
KimleyHorn and Associates,Inc. $1,162177 3 0 3
Mlles.Legg a Associates,Inc. _ $359,51$ 3 0 3
Perkins•NAI Architects,Inc. $0 5 0 5
Swim&Maier Design 51000,P A KIM 5 0 r..—_
Stantec Corralling 5mmces,Mc. 81179,591 3 0 3
WGI,Inc. $1) S 0 5
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 162 of 1954
EXHIBIT B
EBINNEE11190.c .
_ - _,.____
412101141513 141310101141.41111110551110 P. Um
N 5024111•0•42001111111054113 111•110011200
I 91093333.Pow
I M.ROMP.
01503404140400441111105102 I
00911•133 9•9/11101193 WNW 119•1131139 369301311.• 0•10301 NNW@ 12301121104 .......
CES Can010324.Inc
N 5 _ 103 L..'7 _i_. In _.1 g .. 6 ___g.....- - -6.--I. ..
SAP Cons0Ins 10052511122
2•450•0.022. ...-0.-A ..1 - 05 L_ ' S - 012 1 N .__,_ 5 57 2_4„____Ii
0213.99399.329 It _ 117 7 _22 ___ 6 N _ET 2-4- It •-I
Mum 13•_s_vp.,50. VI 5 65 -11 P.. _____O___Lk_-I-_AC . __.s-_St_ 7 --.M_• t
ow 5012 Ise VI 5
NC C0140521.N. 112 .. 3 li _,111 113 5 fp_ 5 ft ...,.. r _ 97 2,....__ __...i
12244004.0101•54•400•0155. .AT 3 N 2.5. .5 3 101 3 10 -
INN.*NS 63639•99133. .242, 3 .w 3_...1I 3 y_ 07 13 20 11
CAN MON End 5042001112 Inc N 3 w •S N I__ 27 13 g 3 03 15 _ .33- 11
300 Ensivemine C40,PA N 5 IN 2 92 A N 5 IS . 9. BO 27.211--_..,__j_T.. 10
CaNn.000100 5 74023045 IN. - N 3 . N 15 54 ._3_. 37 713, .g 3 N 5 IS -II
CNC Inc OS 5 27 14 IR -_.-3
07 13 09 5 N N . 30 IS
.,.... .
13440 54012.•54440004 Inc 113 5 as u__ es
:
117 12 67 : 39 It46.._5.2
O RB 50210.14.ins 70 . .3 g JA N 13 SO N
New NS fe,P.C. _ 90 0 1111 5 N A 92 n 93 _ 5_ 63 IS - 01 .111
ILA NM 20.210N1,0_2_. 63 5 OS _J.L 03 __.3._-_50 10 N .._ .* 33 •: 91 .i!
'Z‘Two 3012/2410442010221.Ins. NI _ .5 VI. N. N 3 97 13 SO .,,,__ 3 ___ 31 24
11470 .112. 112 I 26 17, 56 3 _ N 10 57 3 153 3/_. 64 If
t.32 Can.N. ....- 75
: N 22- 10 56 22 33 5
-13.40 II 2•2142 C.445041 72 17 It_ II 94 27 g _ 6 93
Ovonn Th4220011.01404112•4 Ina 76 5 45 .10, Se t 101 3 22 .3 47 --ii--.1- 56 30
.1314.913•Hower 1.1.0 __ ,-:5 15 ,26 133 $ 51 30 N os W_ ji
01123.j_.4222 2.99.3.662.. 76' 3 /II .„2_2...-- 923_, 1 23 25 00 .2. 53 ros , es 11
5012142 51004•44•2210•4122 N 5 70 9955 -,_.4. DS 23 IN 5 N 15 37 *
105 Ca02154,15020400.LLC 15 10 N 37 01 10 O. 10 B2 10 32 31 . 133 99
34•444c Cons21.02 Sen.,IN 75 __. J 71 22 @ 3 95 @ 33 . 1 B1 *_...., 60 35
..1 Enemming,P.C.exiiikiii1J
104040014.P C n 31-_ W .__3_, N W... N :IRO --- 1: _ :2 .,_. ; ;
3I75 .5- E* c 53 5 Is il in _5 .lit _Ail,_
mcLemn 7•250041 9•1•Kat,Inc.Ns .
00404 2m.4nne.00 N 5 75 M.- .W.. 6 55 23 22455 50 37 79 25
Bnc050.2_NInimm Caren,N. 10 0 - 75 _2_6 .* .. 5 17 jii--._1,,,. . : N 42 21 SO
Pm.U S.$woonc.p I 0 50 33 N 6 12- 5
52 L
W W1 NW BODOC••••.BC. 72 0 77 24 II 2__ 51 30 14N 30 - 64 32
--100&ma IN. 40 0_ .52 AS MI a 11 _N II
i .12 . .. - g Al
56649 5655120505 _ g__1. OB 33 N 3 .g 30 N Alt.--W... 03 -12
H IN
15921 03 ' N 5 ft ,34 21 _._ 5 AL 15 49---. 5 al _S_• !L.____ 19,
C421164 En0neems.mc a 6 75 25 N .E, a rar 02 _ .4 se
.._
1.1.111110.•04240.BONN Inc 115- S 70 26 1114 5 __N__ 35 N 5 II .„ _11. 90 37
O 45633c.C011.11111.1 Onal0.Inc. M 3 10 as ss s 50 .1 g 34 102 39
663 CM, rI41.30 . A ss ss 64 5 _423. 30 39 5 993 , 103 N
COPINECT Pm*.LLC: __ _.*1 _5_ - 01 30 110 S .,.. ..W--.1,44 52 ..11 _,_ ,. 5
ORAN•23255. 45 3.2 3 U • 5 _..._22_36 :,.. 110 .49
Jena CM 2204.2•__02,.1.1q_ - 40 2_ _ 46 :It_i 2o i- _n_ Ask el 5 67 3T.s,_ 115 _22
113411W4.1i-0•4 e re42,215 5 45 41 10 IN 37 111 N 41 I@ 43
Ita'1047000j0s.Inc. 3 43 41 SO 3 g 16 J._ 1 63 i--'3 123_. 46
Ilvv,"eral
...........
00•••••••••••
_....•3••••••• .-•-.M-....•3. ...51•‘• 11.-....-23301..-.
1015.05.•O..•• • . 1. 3_ - I
12 4. _••••42.2.__,P.4 •
. 5970.2_-...-nr!..5e-,L70._____... __. ...A.
.322.52N0 0
0100_1 2. I
•••••••••••••0.••••ma 1141.1.1 .... • ......-..1. ..--,
I....33..12E0P • • L --1--,
Smart••••••• 1n •
00 400•••0000.., MUM
ft1.9M.M...2 • = _51-.---l---
• ..
sr 3404 - •
02 c. 0 513. • - . S .. 4 __________
04400•000.4 0 4 2.. --1--
P- 4.22.-.001Ip S. ---I
9139019,..ft L. . •
ORM • --.--
34.003@m152.L 1 • ....-.. .........-,
CM Coed In Mk. II •
*90,29.906,32 1, • 1
9,10.919 .,_ •• •
-,..__991..., • • -L--.
.4.92693_4._ 9 , • , ..t__3
.221.9••09 • S •
N B 1.8.••• • . 1 • -L-_-
. .03_,......00 9
I.
1.•••••••,...PC • E ------
.M. ..• • ___.._i. ...5.191. 1.12,2•E - 12 • L__.--1.--
........as ....... 5 .1_---1----.
• • -.----1.--.
gotr,.........1. ......... _ MM..... 4. A-.--1.--
.g UMW...,M am ••••••• 9
• ._____
2................. MIL ,.. t 0_ --1---
rn.••••••••••40•• WAR 4. 4 .--L--.
324.050260 • A • _.. ....0-
Pompom 11••••••••••Pe
g r 4 or..•_••set•• •• • •
39.91.191. • _ .J. 1_
e.now..•••••••••Ms .. 00.••• . ... ..- • .--.1..-..-
- 1_-..--1--,
1M0,...1•1!,.. 0.•••• 1
Sam 0•••••••rm.In RM. 4
....2•1012133•1-0 " - _t_.-*-2--
If 444404040 0 • -
LF03 DISPLAY AMMO 000.2.FOAL MINIM 30511902 CONSTITUTE AN AWARD 119-COM66113310311.
•
Page 163 of 1954
EXHIBIT B
ENGINEERING-ELECTRICAL
in
FIFO 2020-096-ND PROFESSIONAL ARCHITECTURALen rc� Low c
AND ENGINEERING SERVICES IN SPECIALIZED Mariana Evora 52 Francisco Garcia Olga SanchezA ate
CATEGORIES ON AN"AS-NEEDED BASIS" c C c Aggregate
m
re t6 Totals
Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal
Wolfberg/Alvarez and Partners,Inc. 90 5 95 2 100 5 105 1 90 5 95 1 4 1
A&P Consulting Transportation
Engineers,Corp. 100 5 105 1 96 5 101 4 80 5 85 3 8 2
Y
BCC Engineering,Inc. 90 3 93 3, 98 3 101 4 90 3 _ 93 2 9 3
McFarland-Johnson,Inc. 70 5 75 5 100 5 105 1 75 5 80 6 12 4
Exp.U.S.Services,Inc. 60 5 65 7 100 5 105 1 75 5 80 6- w 14 5
Black&Veatch Corporation 80 5 85 4 94 5 99 8 80 5 85 3 15 6
H.W.Lochner Inc. _ 60 5 - 65 7 96 5 101 - 4 75 5 80 6 T 17 7
Calvin,Giordano&Associates,Inc. 70 3 73 6 92 3 95 9 80 3 83 5 I 20 8
GRAEF-USA Inc. 60 5 65 7 96 5 101 4 70 5 75 9 20 8 -
LUSEO Group LLC 60 5 65 7 90 5 95 9 70 5 75 , 9 k.. 25 10
apC
>, ,:,,T,'," , a ,; .- t',I to ''''1,,
•ra . ..:.. -.:._--';':4--z-,,-,,,: .,::"41.1.4,'
, ,W�1 'yX::.J.1.7'.,..,,.10'.:::''''',-....7..•:; :-1:, ' vy,
$1:•
Triad Quantitative
(Volume of Wort
Proposer VOkarw of Work VOkan of Wait Parts Veteran's Points Veteran's)
MP Consulting Transportation Engineers,Corp. 532,216 _ 5 0 6
BCC Engineering,Inc. 5711,062 3 0 3
Black&Veatch Corporason 50 5 0 5
Calvin,Giordano 6Associates,Inc. 54152125 3 0 3
Epp.U.S.Services,Inc. 50 5 0 5
GRAEF-USA Inc. 50 5 0 6
H.W.Lochner Inc. $0 5 0 5
LUSEO Group LLC 50 5 0 5
McFarland-Johnson,Inc. $0 _ 5 0 5
rWolAergrAlvarez and Banners,Inc. --_ _ - $200,226 5 - 0 .. . a
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 164 of 1954
EXHIBIT B
ENGINEERING-GENERAL ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
RFQ 2020-OH-NO PROFESSIONAL e
ARCHITECTURAL IN SP RAL AND ENGINEERING g C c LOW c
SERVICES IN SPECIALIZED CATEGORIES ON Mariana Evora Giancarlo Pena 3: Elizabeth Wheaton
AN"AS-NEEDED BASIS-
2
a Aggregate Totals a:
W
Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal 1
Miller,Legg&Associates,Inc. 95 3 98 2 98 3 101 1 90 3 93 2 5 1
E Sciences,Incorporated 95 3 98 2 96 3 99 3 90 3 93 2 7 2
WGI,Inc. 90 5 95 4 92 5 97 4 90 5 95 1_ 9 3
Nova Consulting,Inc. 90 5 95 4 95 5 100 2 80 5 85 7 13 4
Coastal Systems International,Inc. 90 3 93 6 88 3 91 7 90 3 93 2 15 8
Stantec Consulting Services Inc. 90 3 93 6 88 3 91 7 90 3 93 2 15 5
Kimley-Horn and Associates,Inc. 100 3 103 1 89 3 92 6 75 3 78 10 17 7
Calvin,Giordano&Associates,Inc. 80 3 83 10 85 3 88 10 90 3 93 2 22 8
T.Y.Lin International 85 5 70 11 89 5 94 5 80 5 85 7 23 9
Cummins Cederberg,Inc. 60 5 65 12 84 5 89 9 80 5 85 7 ,[, 28 10
Milian,Swain&Associates,Inc. 80 5 85 9 83 5 88 10 70 5 75 11 _ 30 11
GHD Services Inc. 85 5 90 8 62 5 67 14 70 5 75 1133 12
Hazen and Sawyer,P.C. 65 0 65 12 85 0 85 12 70 0 70 14 38 13
McFarland-Johnson,Inc. 40 5 45 14 70 5 75 13 70 5 J 75 11 38 13
Professional Service Industries,
Inc. 35 5 40 15 20 5 25 15 60 5 65 15 45 15
J&M Engineering,P.C. 20 5 25 17 20 5 25 15 60 5 65 15 47 18
Gallagher Bassett Services,Inc. 30 5 35 16 20 _ 5 25 15 40 5 45 17 48 17
Exp U.S.Services,Inc. 15 5 20 18 20 5 25 15 40 5 45 17 50 18
Nova Engineering and
Environmental,LLC 10 5 15 19 20 5 25 15 40 5 45 17y- 51 19
t. 1. a cr a,ym - �r. 44
.&..kn ,T' '; fav r '4'
Total Warr6tative
(Volume of Work«
Proposer Valoms aft* Velum of Wm*Pointe Valarentt Pointe Veteran's)
Can,Giordano&Associates,Inc. $416,121 3 0
M 3
Coastal S gams Intemasonal,Inc. $574,311 3 0 3
Cummins Cederber$,Inc. $ t 5 0 - 5
E Sciences.Incorporated $641.4$1 3 D 3
top U.S.Services,Inc, M 50 5
Gallagher Bassett Services,Inc. >o 55 5
GHD Services Inc- $1 5 0 6
Hazen and Sawyer,P.C. $2,113,167 00 0 _
J 6 M Engineering,P . H 50 6
Kimley-Horn and Associates,Inc. $1,112,477 30 3
McFarland-Johnson,Inc. $0 5 5 6 _
Milian.Swain&Associates.Inc. _ se 5 0 5
Miller,Lugg BAseociatea,Inc $369,176 30 3
Nova Consulting,Inc. 7A 5 0 6
Nova Enpinaennp and Envkonmen[al,LLC 70 6 0 5
ProfonWonel Service Industries.Inc. M 5 0 6
Stantec Consulting Services Inc. $1,671,113 3 A 0 3
T.V.Lin International M 5 0 6
WGI,Inc. $1 5 0 — 5
LFOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 165 of 1954
EXHIBIT B
LEED COMMISSIONING
RFQ 2020-096-ND PROFESSIONAL
Fl!
ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING c vs Low C
SERVICES IN SPECIALIZED CATEGORIES
Carla Dixon Y Flavia Tonioli Aggregate
� cc
ON AN"AS-NEEDED BASIS" Totals re
Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal
Exp. U.S. Services, Inc. 60 5 65 _ 1 65 5 70 1 2 1
GRAEF- USA Inc. 50 5 55 2 30 5 35 2 L:1 4 2
v '7 m II,: ��. 4m ���py y,�. hslly "I w n_w.+ l;'i ill l �' r p � �"�k„' g"
l ;"4 ��1: lr�i , � '�75 I t G5 A e�, i ...Awe.i.:,..:: : o, I h I,�. .,,u.. lu^ Z:i I i14 i'. �,7 l+ C 'qF IINip F x 1:1
4. �� I k a.0 � i�''._`a�,r4°u.�� .: an .l, i#� ��l iy � . � - Yh. .x;�' a 4 h
Total Quantitative
(Volume of Work+
Proposer Volume of Work Volume of Work Points Veteran's Points Veteran's)
Exp.U.S.Services,Inc. 50 5 0 5
GRAEF-USA Inc. $0 5 0 5
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY. FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 166 of 1954
EXHIBIT B
ENGINEERING -MECHANICAL
RFQ 2020-096-ND PROFESSIONAL
ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING C Co C LOW C
SERVICES IN SPECIALIZED Mariana Evora Y Francisco Garcia Y Olga Sanchez Aggregate
CATEGORIES ON AN"AS-NEEDED c c e
BASIS" co I; Totals 12
Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal
Wolfberg/Alvarez and
Partners,Inc. 100 5 105 1 100 5 105 1 90 5 95 1 3 1
McFarland-Johnson,Inc. 70 5 75 4 100 5 105 1 75 5 80 3 I. 8 2
Black&Veatch Corporation 98 5 103 2_ 96 5 101 5 80 5 85 2 r 9 3
Exp.U.S.Services,Inc. 68 5 73 5 100 5 105 1 75 _ 5 80 3 w. 9 3
GRAEF-USA Inc. 80 5 85 3 98 5 103 4 70 5 75 5 . 12 5
r F.31iP^r li�'.s'r .'.Y.` 44WRatai .'I..:;t ^iii • ',..ii`,,s, C,a 4 .8. ,..r 3n 03,$i i J..
Total Quantitative
(Volume of Work(-
Proposer
Proposer Volume of Work Volume of Work Points Veteran's Points Veteran's)
Black&Veatch Corporation $0 5 0 5
Exp.U.S.Services,Inc. $0 5 0 5
GRAEF.USA Inc. $0 5 0 5
McFarland-Johnson,Inc. $0 5 0 5
Wolfberg/Alvarez and Partners,Inc. $205,228 1 5 0 5
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 167 of 1954
T.
e k a c w . ' S -.M /a 3 7 m 7 =c plc!
c ? a 5 k
211
m $ 5 � g i; f'° S.S- § ib
_ Fi i m 7 u q, _ ao
- P. mon
Z c. fg m g
1;
oA
1:, nA Bi a
nA w
m -m
o
11
m
O S °1 % pp
k.
rz I Q 1
2 ' Cn(n (Si U1 U1 O UI cm N Cn in
re
z s s a
O . N co N O N M u P U
Ell O g _ (�pp e
CD CO y a ; O m ig N W 8CO 2SU°8 IF
IF
O61
co -1
p cl A,'-'-. 'Oa 0) ao (o-.co (n w-• Ranking
_, z
co -1 r_ P
cn 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 , 14 .�1� e h 18888880, 88181;;A „i m
e— Z .�
D 1 cm Cr (n CR (n O(n (n(n(n 0CI w
v
m - m 3
n , I ^ rn
IV 3 I
3 c
m
Z a w 2 888 ccii(pii(ci+
v
z (o at of cm -.8 a Ranking
0 0 Ui $ vI 0 0 zA al 8 II
1
O
m
m
0
01(1) 01 cn cm O Cn cn U1 Cn 1 7
R 0
< S
S R
a
c
z4z423 ER 233232g 23232R #
co 0'N . a w-• a U,�-1 Ranking
-It
Cmr I
co"cc .i .i cmc.ca -•(0m p m E
e
ro .i v a s a CIN+{ Ranking 1
o
EXHIBIT B
ENGINEERING-PLUMBING
RFQ 2020.0➢6ND PROFESSIONAL 71
ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING co Low co
SERVICES IN SPECIALIZED Marlene Evora g Francisco Garcia Y Olga Sanchez .EAggregate E
CATEGORIES AN"AS NEEDED 4 i2 a &
¢ c c
l:� Totals i°
Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative _Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal
Wolfberg/Aivarez and
Partners,Inc. 100 5 105 1 100 5 _ 105 1 90 5 _ 95 1 3 1
Black&Veatch Corporation 98 5 103 2 99_ _ 5 104 3 80 5 85 2 7 2
Exp.U.S.Services,Inc. 71 5 76 4 100 5 105 1 75 5 80 3 8 3
McFarland-Johnson,Inc. 84 5 89 3 98 5 103 4 75 5 80 3 T— 10 4
•
GRAEF-USA Inc. 70 5 75 5 98 5 103 4 70 5 75 5 14 5
4;: -.d6n atSii1.17: t6'agiiiki�h art tiui ` .-:-.'"Z ,Z4.v .�^S'"lu;'„yr, :.._y , ewl.c( ._.
tote)Quantitative
(Volumes or Woit•
Proposer Volume of Work Velums of Work Points Veteran's Points VatennY)
Blade&Veatch Corporation $0 5 0 5
Exp.U.S.Services,Inc. $0 5 0 5
GRAEF-USA Inc. $0 5 0 5
McFarland-Johnson,Inc. _ $0 5 0 5
Woltherp/AWarez and Partners,Inc. noun 5 0 5
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 169 of 1954
EXHIBIT B
ENGINEERING - SECURITY AND SAFETY
RFQ 2020-096-ND PROFESSIONAL O) C I Low 0
ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING C
SERVICES IN SPECIALIZED CATEGORIES Steve Feldman Francisco Garcia
Yc ,: Aggregate
ON AN"AS-NEEDED BASIS" oC ",j'' Totals 12
Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal
Ross & Baruzzini, Inc. 95 5 100 1 100 5 105 1 2 1
McFarland-Johnson, Inc. 85 5 90 2 96 5 101 3 5 2
SpectrumHaven, LLC 80 5 85 3 98 5 103 2 .'_ 5 2
� '�aC d W"'�, ,� ury m,�w+w�C yarn k^"��"^ a fin,M� T n�.�,..r •m n �
��' tax74,f�"Ta ,,'3"li�Iq x 4 X r fill ih� � "'�.. e. p '"i I N�1,%�w,'l Za� �'I �PNNiarL�iy�Il.o,tw �aa;'S.T it 1t� i ;
. ..+�g.r h.r.Vp�dk��I�.'fP� � ��Y"�_SII �'df I w.. `r�+�'
Total Quantitative
(Volume of Work+
Proposer Volume of Work Volume of Work Points Veteran's Points Veteran's)
McFarland-Johnson,Inc. $0 5 0 5
Ross&Baruzzini,Inc. $0 5 0 5
SpectrumHaven,LLC $0 5 0 5
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY. FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 170 of 1954
EXHIBIT B
ENGINEERING-STORMWATER
RFC 10049860 Wror.an.K urcHir[crunu [[�^^ lar
MO 6gaE91YN8EAAtp B.rtcul¢r0 rY 0!69n I 01Y99MYP.. M.Same81 69911919
G760016Ma M'AFrt®01 Mgr TOYY
04d1115159 09w8M8n MOM 0oI6.90a 0... E9 SOME On01019W Cl068h8r9 69MMM
CESCmrJYM.,Inc. 100 6 106 1-97 102. 2 91 5 W 2 5 1
Nunn NW Bar's.P.C. 100 0 100 3 96-.. 9! 5 96 ... 0 96 _3 13 2
MP ComWrg Ti.rWpwn69n
0n68.. Com 958 100 3 95 _
M 100 3 82 __,...... 87 ._ 8..ip. 14_-_-s,.8
Mc.Corpora9on ._._ 90 6 859 90 103 1 90 95 _1 14 _3
T.Y.Un GEoW. rW1 00 5 96 0 93 96__- 6 84 W I�__-15 6
C1M9 S EOl IncInc. _._ 97 5 950 6 90 ._ 94.-. 0 76 _.. 91 S 20 8
COM SmM Ir 97 5 102 2 94 __.._.. 94 78 91 0 27 T
6ECOMT-611Mlon6nI0LM99.Inc. 72 9 78 15 94 W 6 60 63 9 27 9
'Gwen Tanlpenn98•1580 888Inc. 76 3 78 17 92 95 9 80 93 _„10 30
Cmar17tcn9h9on6 8•15808888,Inc. M 5 70 17 94 .___. N 4 70 _ M i5-1.- 31 _ 19
300 6 r Moan and Mwd9Yw Inc. 99 _... 9 YB 5 92 95 9 700 ...__73 10 :, 32 11
300 Ergin.xhi�d�w _. 85 5 93 7 59 _94 11 70 75-_19 .' 34 12
Now Enoine .lm 73 5 78 11 98 _� 17 84. _9p _-E h 31 1
BCC Ei d0,nn I Yc._ 75 3 78 11 91 94, 11 85 99. 21 43 14
NSW Loc N 4Inc. 86 5 70 17 68 _-. 03 17 80 :53_,9 43 14
I in9.7-FWn end M9odYYS 1ne. 96 3 86 0 81 W 11 80 _ _ _38 N
EAC CS*60n.9,Inc. a 5 85 29 05 84_... 11 76 81 12 55 17
WMn.Smi 6Aw9da97s Inc.nc 72 5 - 77 14 9s 90 21-- 95 -- 70 - 20 55 10
Storm.Conaul8q S.Mwc Inc. ... _..�__...-_ 3 87 21 88 -__..— 91 20 78_. .. _... 79 14 56Ii
Cahn Giordano 6 A9Mwa,Inn85 3 60 20 - 93 17 80 67 _26 62 20
568 09464 5065 Inc. 85 _... 5 ae 70 17 W _. 95 23_.... 00 _ 08 22 82 10
Blank Veatch Q 70 _ 5 75_ t__ 50 __. 56 9 660 --- _ --65 2z 83 22
R.J.Betty 6 Company,Inc __ 62 _. 5 67 21 96 94 _-Ti- 56 $$ _.-__I_..6....!T
AN9roz En5n.era Inc. 50 5 55 26 SO___...__. 65 Te ...-..70 d....... 75 __78 I,_80 24
Coaata15i9wn.hMwae.Nl Inc.-_- 80 -..3__. 63 24 86 _.. .. 64 22 _.-60-_. 3 63_ 25 , 71 26
IMOG1oW.In. 10 548 28 50 _.__05 24 66._.,_..__6 _Tt,-_ 19 __ 71 25
E& or
Ma,I 60 3 63 24 50 63 _34 78 3 79 14 72 27
CONNECT En99iee!S 1,_LLG- N 8 46 28 50 56 26 60 6 __. 05 22 78 26
JIM 11CWPEngineering,P.C.DIEM MU x
CSACR6g P;C._ _ 40 5 55 281._._50_.. 55 26 55 5 BD �29 83 30
CSA Cannow.In 40 5 N 38 __. _..... 65 28.- 55 5 51 ?0 83 >a
MID Servioea.Na. 70 8 36 31 60 58 20 56 5 81 30 an 5,___ ____5_1
EIP.U.S.Ser9b.4 khc30 8 31 50 66 18 50 5
:_L____1_4;
8_.. 32 09 72
KWh TIM A4.0 66 Inc. _— 30 —__5 3531 50 55 26_ 50 _.. s 99 32.' N i2
---_
TM B9hram9 Gh9W.Inc.ch20 5 25 34 80 95 24 50 5 55 .... 32_ 90 38
NCI Technologies,Inc. 28 3 36 50 69 34 55_._.___3 5e 31 ',. 100 36
NA444Veld
1M•
PT.. e..*MM P... eye
a.
asM.rM 0..e.PA —..-- 9P.. r
N
/POW PK..e.+o...c...... Make
bum annum Inc Pe •
Mbora One,nc w
___._. _ _A.
Cohn.msc t N.....
.e I-a
_--__Call en.Inc 0
o..,am...e..,....R.
• nos:..:,..ham ~ -------- -
Olnennen
'=tebe
`'---- PA'
▪ Mond
auies•. _..._L -..A
OW hswra - _. w
..s.N Pam,PG� _-_ ...�. _�... �..__..___.-__ }
aa►+y.PO.01110A6.1 .P.9. To _'__—
PPlb..9..be OWN '
P.e
...ste..r.. w
r..a..9..._._......_ w
111....zo.....a.. ........—_ w
.rar.....9..P. ..__--..- wzN. .i___-.......___
Ilb•Pepbeltbe be Pb
e.wo.+.w:r.a P9_Ia
9
W.rr:.ammer ..
FON DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL NAMING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 171 of 1954
EXHIBIT B
ENGINEERING-STRUCTURAL
—7- _
AW iaMImN90tANC4fNNaGeIiM MIN OYISNI I OlNrorb PNr
G1190Nle 011•1114411900 WSW II; Totals
41.+2110 4114M9M- 11110OW OasMa4 S Clew**** *Mold 11
Moffatt 0 Nicht.Inc. 96 5 101 1 _95 5 100 1* 2_
Klmly-Nan and AsaodSM0,Inc. 98 _ 3 99 2 97 3 100 1 �i 3
BCC Endnrnng,Inc 94 3 97 3 97 3 100 1 Ji _ 4
Biller Reinhart Engineering Group.Inc 90 5 95 4 95 5 100 1 __
Consulting Engines*,Inc 90 5 95 4 94 5
99 5 y 8 ,
R.J.Bahar 8 Company,Inn. 99 5 95 4 94 5 99 5 9
WGI,Inc. 85 5 00 9 93 _ 5 98 8 10
AAP Conaultirp Tranmp:400n 11".
Engineers,Corp. 80 5 05 13 94 5 99 6;;... 10
305 Consulting Enpsws,LLC 75 10 85 13_ 85 10 96 8 21
Chrome Endn• ,Inc 00 _ 5 85 13 93 5
m_y98 9,� 21
CONNECT Engineering.LLC a6 5 90 6 88 5 93 13 21
Doudr Wold Associates,Inc 85 5 90 5 88 5 93 13:. 21
CSA Cantu*Inc. 92 5 87 12 e9 5 94 12 24 1
SW**Consulting Sews.Inc 55 3 88 11 90 3 93 13^, 24 1
MaINito Conaullants,Inc 90 6 95 _4 80 5 85 24; 28 I
GRAEF-USA Inc. 75 5 80 20 92 5 97 11• 31 16
Blank,/Consultenta Inc. 80 3 83 18 90 3 93 .13.`_31 16
Erten Ergnewing Group COR**** 50 _ 5 85 13 84 5 89 22', 35 18
Coastal Systeme International,Inc. _ 00 3 83 18 89 3 92 16,.L_ 38 19
Cummins CedwowO tn. 70 5 75 25 _ B6 5 93 13 1. 38 20
Hazen and Sawyer,P.C. .__M 0 00 _20 92 _ 0 52 18 t 36 28
GHD Services.Inc. 75 5 50 20 80 5 85 24!44 22
Yours*Had.wn Consultingf
Engi,wwmg,Inc 75 5 80 20 80 6 85 24'I_44 22
APX Engineering Group.LLC 70 5 75 25 86 5 91 20P.;_ 45 24
Garan Mullin Group.LLC 00 5 _ 85 13 70 5 75 324 45 24
PCorwul5ng Engineer.,Cork 70 5 75 25 88 5
MM 91 20 45 24
M.W.LochnerInc. 70 5 75 25 04 5 09 22 I 47 27
Hardesty&Hanover,LLC 70 5 75 25 00 5 85 24A 49 28
Mat MooOonald LLC 70 5 75 25 50 5 85 241 49 28
Walby Parlang Consultants/Engineers,
Inc. 70 5 75 25 80 5 85 241j_ 49 ....LS
DES_MAtylnc._ 75 3 78 24 00 3 _ 53 31�t 55 31
Esp.U.S.Sarvim,Inc _ 70 5 75 25 70 5 75 324.1 57 32
Mriwsn Technic*Setups Ina 80 5 86 34 60 5 05 24'. 55 33
PT Suppliers LLC OSA Risk and Design 11_
Consulting 65 5 70 33 70 5 75 3SI 05 34
r.ro
N..0 IP.•
_ Vabore al..0 va... rem r..,.+P.P. 00..00
S
rC.n...s..,w...n En....C. IN10
PPP Crw..00O,wettC N
<c �.
n .t. _.P.O. 0_
..in.r e,P 1..Y e.,...S. N 4
C...En.w.ass 10 __
0.1........1. $7..10
CONNECT,p.V%uC _ _ N
C.......•1. N
Onill Ow
21,+0121
0........... NwAN
c VS 3....0 w
a..6...LIC _ N
OHO a..uw 1. N A.
0
N
WU. -9
..c..raE,e,... N
. ,........,Inc 0 ,
N
LC N
PSI C..5Y.,,..0 N
PTSW..LLC ON.w...e.lw Camas N
C^•.••4•• N
M.'"AN
Ca.....0..u..u. NAP.N
WMwr..i,am,..w......m. H.UN — --.�—.
ea,R
........w.Cr,..a Ew...eea. N
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CONONTUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 172 of 1954
EXHIBIT A
Landscape Architecture Mechanical Engineering
lKeith and Associates,Inc. Wolfberg/Aivarez and Partners,Inc.
Curtis&Rogers Design Studio,Inc. McFarland-Johnson,Inc.
Perkins+Wilt Architects,Inc. Black&Veatch Corporation
Savino&Miller Design Studio,P.A. Exp.U.S.Services,Inc.
Craven Thompson&Associates,Inc.
WGI,Inc. Mechanical,Electrical,and Plumbing Engineering
EDSA,Inc. Wolfberg/Alvarez and Partners,Inc.
CPH,Inc. Exp.U.S.Services,Inc.
Calvin,Giordano&Associates,Inc. McFarland-Johnson,Inc.
Chen-Moore and Associates,Inc. 3FM Engineering,Inc.
Hazen and Sawyer,P.C.
Civil Engineering WGI,Inc.
CES Consultants,Inc.
A&P Consulting Transportation Engineers,
Corp. Plumbing Engineering
Nova Consulting,Inc. Wolfberg/Alvarez and Partners,Inc.
Ardurra Group,Inc. Black&Veatch Corporation
CDM Smith Inc. Exp.U.S.Services,Inc.
1EAC Consulting,Inc.
Schwebke-Shiskin&Associates,tnc. Security and Safety Engineering
Kimley-Horn and Associates,Inc. Ross&Baruzzini,Inc.
Chen Moore and Associates,Inc. McFarland-Johnson,Inc.
300 Engineering Group,P.A. SpectrumHaven,'LLC
Calvin,Giordano&Associates,Inc.
CPH,Inc. Stormwater Engineering
CES Consultants,Inc.
Electrical Engineering Hazen and Sawyer,P.C.
Wolfberg/Alvarez and Partners,inc. A&P Consulting Transportation Engineers,Corp.
A&P Consulting Transportation Engineers,
Corp. Aluces Corporation
BCC Engineering,Inc. T.Y.Lin International
McFarland-Johnson,Inc. Ardurra Group,Inc.
Exp.U.S.Services,Inc. CDM Smith;nc.
Black&Veatch Corporation Schwebke-Shiskin&Associates,Inc.
H.W.Lochner Inc. AECOM Technical Services,Inc.
Craven Thompson&Associates,Inc.
General Environmental Services Engineering Chen Moore and Associates,Inc.
Miller,Legg&Associates,Inc. 300 Engineering Group,P.A.
E Sciences,Incorporated Nova Consulting,Inc.
WGI,Inc.
Nova Consulting,Inc. Structural Engineering
Coastal Systems International,Inc. Moffatt&Nichol.Inc.
iStantec Consulting Services Inc. Kimley-Horn and Associates,Inc.
Kimley-Horn and Associates,Inc. BCC Engineering,Inc.
Calvin,Giordano&Associates,Inc. Biller Reinhart Engineering Group,Inc.
T.Y.Lin International Master Consulting Engineers,Inc.
R.J.Behar&Company,Inc.
WGI,Inc.
A&P Consulting Transportation Engineers,Corp.
305 Consulting Engineers,LLC
Chrome Engineering,Inc.
CONNECT Engineering,LLC
Douglas Wood Associates,Inc.
Page 178 of 1954
EXHIBIT B
ARCHITECTURE-LANDSCAPE
600010a93NO PROFESSIONAL �` oh g • Low g
i ARCHITECTURAL N10 ENGINEERING SERVICES; MiChaOi Atkin Barbara Hernandez f I Omar Leon I sAwn".I s i
M SPECIALVEO CATEGORIES ON As.AS. 1 I I=.
NtID®eAsiS' —4 — i ' ;a I r Totals !i
Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal _, Qualitative i Quantitative I Subtotal ; Qualitative 'Quantitatlea I Subtotal 1 1
Keith and Associates,Inc. 1 100 5 105 11 100 5 ; 105 11: 96 i 5 t 103 •, 1 3 +1
Cues S Rogers Design Studio,Inc I 100 5 105 1, 100 1 5 105 ;1 97 1 5 t 102 i 5 `, 7 2 i
Perkins+WIl Architects,Inc. 100 5 105 t I 96 ' S 101 6'; 98 1 5 103 1 1 !, 6 ;3
Sanno&Miller Design Studio,P A 100 5 105 1 i 96 5 101 t 8 1 98 5 i 103 1 L. 6 3 1
Craven Thompson S Associates.Inc.I 100 5 105 1• 94 5 99 10� 96 5 l 103 1 12 1 S{
WGI,Inc 1 100 5 105 .1-' 96 I 5�—101 ;6 97 -_I-_ 5 102 -_-L- 5 , 12 1 5 1
lire 1 100 5 105 1 96 I 5 ' 101 1 6 I 96 5 t 101 1 10 17 ;7 I
�CPH,Ina 100-_} 5 _- 105 1 90 1 5 95 1121 97 , 5 1 102 5 _ 18 .,8 I
Calvin,Giordano&Associates,Inc 100 3 - 103 11� 100 t 3 103 1 3' 99 3 1 102 1 5 19 9'
Chen-Moore and Associates,Inc. 100 1 3 103 '111 100 I 3 103 j 3 99 3 102 5 19 ;91
MAIM,Legg S Associates.Inc. I 100 3 103 :111 100 ` _..1_._.., 103 ;3 I 96 3 1 101 1 10 , 24 111
Department,LLC 100 5 105 : 1 SS 5 `�93 141 96 i_ 5___•: 101 _ -,10. __-- 25 i 121
Bruce Howard&Associates of - I ,
Floods,Inc. 100 1 5 106 ' 1- 90 5 , 95 i 121 95 1 5 100 14 27 ;13�
ICS I�e-Hum and Associates,Inc , 100 3 103 ,111 90 1 3 1 93 114-, 96 1 3 1 101 10 i 35 114i
KCI Technologies,Inc 1 100 3 103 11' 94 3 I 97 111; 97 3 1 100 t 14 36 ;151
Stantec Consulting Services,Inc i 100 3 103 111 90 3 I 93 114i 97 i 3 , 100 14 39 1 16!
Ronda Transportation Engineering, 1 I l I
Inc I 95 3 95 171 90 i 3 ...._-_93 .1141_-.-.94 i 3 I 97 , 17 1 . 48 ;17
•
e1++Nbrh1.
1 •
Aa0ao,10A,1ae
1.0.0 ♦Nhaes alMMY vee.el w.al Pena Winn's hies aM
e�e...we.JAA.Meaw.NPo.... 1 a 5 0 I
Co.OaAs...aw 4 Ass Inc (
arM1s,Ox 3 0 3
+
TA.nW..and Aa..eM.inx 11.110101 3 •--__ -- 0 a
cart Re I so a I a a
Ca.w Orono.s Ames.. I 113511% i I 0 0
CwAaq.n o.qn wnyk -_._.�._.._...M 3 1 a S
o.wwe.NLLC _._a....__-^- S._._...---{ a 1
EO10 K 1 M a I 0 e
M.#..101.0MEAn.wns v Mstlts 3 0 3
Ne#N100111002.bl 5100.410 _ 3 I 0 I 3
Ave Ae A.rsea..Ix r sa3 0 { s
14NsriM.N Ass.eaW.1x , 1111.10200 _ ] ____r_. 03 0 ! a
MAM.l.10 A A...e aA. I 11M11s 3 0 3
swve•wewsewm.•x 1 M _ 3 # 0 s
WNW A war 0..0 MLe e 0t into, s i 0 a
ews
sCes•aq es Asne0"., fta.s.a] 3 0 3
_......_..._ -...... _4_11!
- i
eel,Yoe _-_ _ _ s 0 s
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOM MENOATION.
Page 179 of 1954
EWW[EMO CML y/
fi
�;4----------.-::: .. e tt i i
�.a.a••• i 41;
Nor i MINCaIM•M.=:=:saw
iiin E� ®sem i• ��� u
.9fw. I} 9 f I : :4-.1- J
f s . t_1
...-..St...," r; Y • . . D 4 I. t LI. s 4 .
' .
..m:• - . -, a
•
if 11,�
•
.wa.w.......••.w..PORR WEEa.Y..aNRYa.Waxaalsa.M1F
Page 180 of 1954
EXHIBIT 3
ENGINEERING-ELECTRICAL
• 1 ' 1
NFQ2o2OEo1O PROFESSIONALNICNTECTURAI.I I gt - to I i
AND ENGINEERING SFAvICES IN SPECIALIZED I Manana Evora IY` Francisco Garcia -i Olga Sanchez E Low
CATE00RESON AN•AI.NEEDEDeASS { a- !Ii I c A00so0S 1
Total
Owlitativa�Quantitative Subtotal i I Ou.*ssiw ' Quandtativa I Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative. Subtotal I I
Woilbery_rAlvaaz and Partners,Inc 90 5 95 2 100 5 105 1` 90 , 5 95 1 4 1 1
A&P Consulting Transportation
Engineers,Corp 100 5 I 105 i 1, 96 1 5 101 ,4. 80 - 5 - 65 3 8 ' 2
'iBCC Engineering,Inc 90 3 93 `3 96 4. 3 101 41_ 90 3 1 93 � 2 i 9 :3
MCFartand•Johnson,Inc. 70 5 75 •5 100 I 5 105 t 75 5 , 60 6 I 12 •
!Eats U.S Services,Inc. 60 5 65 !7I 100 ` 5 105 t 751 5 60 i 6 14 5,
L3.4_45.&Veatator Ceration� so i 5 85 ,4 94 1 5 t 99 {9 60 5 I 85 : 3 • is �6
M.W.Lochner Inc. 60 5 __ 65 7: 96 S Wt ;4 75 • S so ' 6 - _17 7
Calan,Giordano&Associates,Inc 70.• 3 73 6 92 I 3 95 i 9 I 60 t 3 { 63 + 5 {{ 20 6 1
GRAEF-USA Inc. 60 - 5 65 ',7, 965 I 101 ,4 70 i 5 1 75 9 20 9 i
'LUSEO GrOuP LLC 60 - 5 85 :7 I 90 I 5 I 95 ;9 70 , 5 75 I 5 I I 25 1101
L�_ - O1..r.a►aW
[ total er.esrr e I
• { Oboes atON.AeI
rre05*45 *duns ems&, v.,.ut wan runt. War.w.0 .61.6.51
LAY C.nt'.ra T,.Nrsmr.Enew.r.Cry _533.25* 2 e a i
AMC E.e..•1.s T 2111,013 3 5 3 '
,ICs..5aN.1 IA.wew..Ix MGM • 3 1 3 3
I E.S u S.nee.,au la S 5 5
'Mame•us*uu M 1 5 s
NW l..Mw Ire 10 , 51 0 5
Iluszo c.wuc 2s s e s
0/555IW.10en5w.ut 20 -__ S 0 a
IWWbne•AMru.N..nr.n.IK _ laths , 5 a S
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 181 of 1954
EXHIBIT B
ENGINEERING-GENERAL ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
I I Fa 701aa1FNaPanrft510r1K ?g s , i
MaIiERUPII'1lIO DtanrEERNa Mariano Evora g 'F Elizabeth Wheatony ,i,
'i Gisncarb Pena
SE ACESw1FECML ifiCATS 0NESON az az I S : Aggregate ,
Ail'ASNF®E9easlr 11 C Totals ;
Qualitative I Quntfative Subtotal Qualitative I OtanBlatlra Subtotal t _Qualtalve I-Quantitative Subtotal j
MAer.Legg 6 Associates,Inc 95 i 3 96 12 95 3 L 101 j 1 90 3 I 93 1 2 _ 5 `1
E Sciences,Incorporated 95 3 96 t 2 96 3 I 99 3_ _ 90 ___7 93 2 - 7 2
WGI,Inc. 1 90 1 5 95 '4 92 , 5 97 4 _90 __ 5 I 95 1 9 _ 3
'Now Cons 9tin9,Inc 90 I 5 95 4 95 I 5 100 12 60 T 5 I 65 i 7 13 '4
Coastal Systems International,Inc. 90 I 3 93 6 58 3 91 1 7 90 i 3 93 2 15 5
[Maniac Consulting Services Inc. 90 1 3 93 16 6e t 3 91 j 7 90 3 93 2 I:I 15 .6
"KtmleyHom and Associates,Inc 100 I 3 133 i 1 89 i 3 ; 92 t 6 75 5 3 76 1 1151 .117 7
'Calvin,Giordano&Associates,Inc 60 3 53 110 85 I 3 66 :10 90 3 93 t 2 22 5
;T.Y Lin International 55 _ 5 70 `11 e9 5 I 94 15 50 6 65 1 7 23 9
!Cummns Dederbel9,Inc- 60 5 55 ,12 84 I 5 e9 19 80 5 e5 7 ({. 2e ;19
'Italian,Swen ea Assocetes,Inc. 50 5 65 1 9 53 5 66 110 70 5 1 75 ` 11 E 30 '11
•GIIO Services Inc S5 5 9D i 6 62 • 5 67 114 70 5 75 11 33 112
+Hazen and Sawyer,P.C. 65 0 65 112 65 t 0 65 112 70 i 0 70 1 14 -.1 3e 131
McFarandJohnsn,Inc 40 1 5 45 '14 70 5 t 75 t 10 70 t 5 75 : 11 3e 13
!Professional Seance Industries, i I
line. 35 I 5 40 15 20 i 5 ` 25 '15 50 5 65 • 15 ' 45 15'
t I
t.J 6M Engineering,PC 20 5 25 117 20 5 25 I15 60 5 I 55 15 47 +tel
Ga 0 Bassett Services,Inc 30 5 35 `1{ I 15 20 I 5 1 25 t15 40 ' 5 45 I. 17 - 45 j 17
IEzp U S.Services.Inc. 15 5 20 11e 20 I 5 25 15 40 5 46 ` 17 50 116
Now Engineering and , I - 1
Environmental.LLC 10 5 15 19 20 1 5 25 115 40 ! 5 i 45 I 17 _ 51 119
rrra`. ree
1 00/MMtees.
Mm., Mum wwew I mm..also P.M m.Nf P.m. 'Yer""*1
la.,cnmro n A..m'e.,,C 1.4?..... . o
.� y�in it..
':y 'MIAS 0
In. yme K 00 0
IE Seerw.:ywpenna MCA.. 0 •
'Eno Us 1.-tem`'c a 0 1 ,
e.eane amens.rve.y n 0 4
iwc Mem::s at 1 0 '
'+.wan ane Emn0 PC aata.ar ' 0 '
1,amca,e.e,{tie a i s
iw,rq.ce.,m Memes.t N,.Wn
tc
•an S.n-sa.aa.:..•-.0 a I 0 ..
!e ,:nal Amae..',< IMM i C .
gym..Grew"Inc is ! 1 c - -
Wa•Evan.q.mE...•Penu:-..0 a i C
'.evy.Cenvsn:4 Seventh NAa./a , 0
wA::w_--. __60 .__ _ 0
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CO N5 TI FU TE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 182 of 1954
EXHIBIT B
LEED COMMISSIONING _
RFQ 2020.096-ND PROFESSIONAL is
ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING c c Low c
SERVICES IN SPECIALIZED CATEGORIES
Carta Dixon Y Flavia TOn101i Y Aggregate Y
ON AN'AS-NEEDED BASIS' A 99re
ce re Totals al
Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal
Exp.U.S.Services,Inc. 60 5 65 _1 65 5 70 1 2 1
GRAEF-USA Inc. 50 5 55 2 30 5 _ 35 2 4 12
P
1
Total Quantitative
(Volum.of WWII
Proposer Volume of Work I Volume of Work Points Veteran's Points Veteran's)
Esp U S Sonnets,Ine f0 5 0 5
GRAEF-USA Inc. $0 5 0 5
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 183 of 1954
EXHIBIT B
ENGINEERING-MECHANICAL
RFS la7Dl%.lt PROFESSIONAL— —I---------- ff
lTECTURAL AMD ENdMF8ING Low j c
ARC
S M 9s SPECIALIZED Mariana Evora - Francisco Garcia g
1 Olga Sanchez C Y
CATEGORIESON AN'AS-NEEDED ± c Aggregate 1 c
BASIS' i - -T. C _ KTI
Qualitative Quantitative I Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative 1 Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal
WolfbergiAlvarez and
Partners,Inc. 100 5 I 105 1 100 5 105 1 90 5 95 , 1 _ 3 1
McFarland-Johnson,Inc. 70 5 75 4 100 5 105 1 7S 5 80 ' 3 8 2
Black&Veatch Corporation 98 5 103 2 96 5 101 5 80 5 .. 8.5 2 9 1 3
Exp U.S Services,Inc 68 5 I 73 5 100 5 105 1 75 5 80 3 _ 9 3
GRAEF-USA Inc. 80 I 5 l 85 3 98 5 103 4 70 5 75 5 12 5
•
•
I
Ta a,v.navn
Qvahw..N W.rk
5spr01 I Velun..l WOO Vekn,e M Wart Pont. V.M.rr.Pooh VNNan ti
,Wes&Veatch C.r..nns M a 0 5
IE..u5 Senn..VK M 3 0 S
IOMEF•USA Inc 50 5 0 5
FtkF.nsMJshann,he It 5 0 S
IWWM,VAN.,ee an PvVn.in< 1200.115 S 0 E
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 184 of 1954
EXHIBIT B
ENGINEERING-MEP
1
RPO moos-NOPROFESSIONAL ARCNITEChMAL I 4 g
NC ENGINEERING SEANCES INSPECINJZ® Mariano Evora 3I Francisco Garcia Olga Sanchez g Law gl
CAAE90RIEa ON AS'ASNEMED SACS' ill
C I A00nWab.!i'
2 LL�� Taws til
• Qualitative i QuantitaNw Subtotal 1 ' Dwl„Mivs Gwmitatiw Subtotal , Qualitative ;Quantitative Subtotal
Worlber91Alvarez and Partners.Inc 95 _i 5 100 I 100 1. 5 105 1 9D 5 95 1 1 , 3 .1
Exp U S Saracas.Inc 91 • 5 96 1.3; 100 5 105 r 1, 75 5 90 , 5 f 9 '2 1
,McFarland-Johnson,Inc 61 5 66 .5', 100 5 105 1 75 5 00 5 1 11 3
3FM Enywearing,Inc. 71 I 5 76 .6! 99 _5 _ _ _ 103 +6 1 90 5 95 1 1 iii. 13 ••o I
Hazen and Sawyer,P C 100 � 0 100 1 i 100 0 100 /0i 90 0 • 90 3 F 14 5
WGI,Inc T69 i 5 73 !9 j 100 5-��-----105 j 11 75 5 ,--90 I_5 It,,, 15 1 6
',DIM Tech Inc. 70 5 75 t 6, 99 S_ 104 5 80 5 55 i 4 1 17 ;7
Moses&Associates.Inc 71 I 5 76 6 I 96 5 103 6 75 550 + 5 f. 17 ,7
GRAEF-USA,Inc 84 5 69 1 4 i 96 $ 103 ,61 70 5 75 9 1 19 9
GSA,fnc. I 65 : 5 70 101 96 5 101 ;9, 70 5 • 75 - 9 I 26 1,101
0..uso.nr
•
• A.a OraSla0e
1 1wArerw.a•
01e50a« 005,0.50#210,5 I Volume•I.M*Pans Sa•aa.•...AS SSIa10V '
SF Si Sweeny 1% 11.101 I 0 S
c .Inc S OSS 5 0 5
u
O {
nATe.1.IR. 10 I s 0 s
is*ustvve...ec ie s o s
OMEF.uSA.w M 1 S 0 I
NuenaMYw•r.PC 11.1.11.052 L 0 ' 0 0
i1kFMra lnw•n,Int so I S 0 S
!.bM.SAaOe.Y..int SO S ; 0 S
,WOI.Ne M i S i o 9
,w.er Wouwo.M P.m%5.0 1210.120 .1. '
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
•
Page 185 of 1954
EXHIBIT 3
ENGINEERING•PLUMBING
r NM 2001%ND PROFESSIONAL
ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING an oa 0 LOW 0
SEHMCES M SPECULIZED Mariana Evora Y Francisco Garcia i Olga Sanchez .E Aggregate
CATEGORIES ON AN'ASNEEDED c e cc
` MSIS' _ Totals
Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal
IWdfberglAlvarez and
(Partners.Inc. 100 5 105 1 100 5 105 1 90 1 5 95 1 3 1
Black&Veatch Corporation 08 5 103 2 99 5 104 3 80 5 85 2 7 2
;Black
U S.Services,Inc 71 5 78 4 100 5 105 1 75 5 80 { 3 B 3
McFarlarKI-Johnson,Inc 84 5 89 3 98 5 103 4 75 ' 5 80 3 104
IGRAEF-USA Inc - 70 5 75 5 9B 5 103 ,4 70 5 75 i 5 ., 14 1 5
aer ee.wen.e. -_ -
Teseitiveraueve
Mem MSnA•
PrOPaaer WMre Mvrwk vnWD cram~IN Wren.P.M. Wbrf.)
rwu wsm Ov.vamn M s 0 1
rr.U S Ser.ea rr M S 0 a
IGRAtF•USA I.t a S o a
N.ranana4anrwn.ns a s 0 s
wdatadNwrs Near Ps...a.me MUM f a a
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 186 of 1954
EXHIBIT B
ENGINEERING -SECURITY AND SAFETY
RFC/2020-0964N0 PROFESSIONAL
ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING e c Low c
Steve Feldman Francisco Garcia
SERVICES IN SPECIALIZED CATEGORIES
Y Y Aggregate i
ON AN"AS-NEEDED BASIS" to w Totals frl
Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal Qualitative Quantitative Subtotal
Ross&Baruzzini,Inc. 95 5 100 1 100 5 1051 2 i 1
McFarland-Johnson,Inc. 85 5 90 2 96 5 101 ! 3 5 1 2
SpectrumHaven,LLC 80 5 85 , 3 98 5 1 103 1 2 5 2
Total Quantitative
(Volume of Work•
Proposer Volume of Work Volume of Work Points Veteran's Points Vetaran's)
McFanand•Johnson,Inc. 50 5 0 5
Ross&Banzznn,ilc. $0 5 0 5
SpectrumHaven,LLC 10 5 0 5
FOR DISPLAY PURPOSES ONLY.FINAL RANKING DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN AWARD RECOMMENDATION.
Page 187 of 1954
31+10T8
115100111E621 NG-STGRMWAiP
—t
ugr= °rwlw—'yI-. . O...At. —'-1 r
rq
!CU C•4664.•43 Wa T 1 - --
-: Tlw.Ii w . ' 3 `
] ., u t
43)»3.':NC M« �
11rr....v«.. �... n 1�> fy 1 )
1". .r1�MF {•� 3 33l3.�) 1 q 1 1i-' C B
� .66.rI.3:4....z. IiSi I i R 3 r5 3 7' 11 37—T
E tea...ie : : . 71 11 » `.f w 1) » i I.!! e
BCC S.yw+1. { » 1M 11 5
it N N :� N I S 2S i U N
.«.W AM«Y.�s pp iS 1 S I r 1 IS /1 II N
'4C CO3y...6% b r 111 IgS r 1 {n 5 I% 112 II 33
Isw.6�«w:..�.r. })1 r rd pyp 1p rs 1-7:74:1—A-4
01 Evotto n•741 65 I.Ault'. <ay..r• e 3 ti �3 fd s u » s t ID AS 66 n �7 » f3
Rl lrwl w1 15 1 17 I!: » 1 3 W �rl u I s s; 31 v 33
A..n.t.; . 1 s 1/ 33 s 3 »
.v .... ...:_ _,.___ ,°___,,.I - 1 .� ,1 b� —i—..N-1. MT, 3 A.—11 u
w
IC05655C7 5yrw•6154 S C-._!_-- .3 171 51, !
W 45.••••• .1
q CLANA 5
rpr q » I S N » >O 3 53 131 15 S » 1 - 1, 11,
CYC«va 9 '�!IL:. 39 3 ....y. �111� I` 10
'Iwo Sl..w _ .»_ 1 3 1—�� - SS..it- » I -., 1 H J T �
SEo VI Swim 11 1 5 3q3 )1 350� 31 k fS t: i—j7
M.:--.71,7.1—_ ` 2 . 1--rii - 1i i _.Z...111. ».-.4 n - n�
_ ._ A I 1 _ -[1 _r3= r r I 33 .UI 55 3_. - .1, a
1........---.--.--... —..--6•16••••• -
am
i
•
.• _rte_ .--�--
PIM BURN MUCUS 0111.I FOAL 8•1156111 NN 1164 CONS11IVT1 IN 4615560611604•••111611011 --
Page 188 of 1954
MINT•
fwa3a37+ro•on3CTUR LL
1pprr arr `f ....a....
weans 'r•s f
�
••••
.
e. x{sti •••••• • s ,
wnf. + • 3
,inneprio,wol Amazon ire m !) 1. 3 , +m 1. 1 E
CCqG4: '
' % % , m !
lwra C...maen..a. Itt n w )
r 1 i{
�v.�...a s+ns. Ea m i. 1. I s a s 4
SI.mw�,F•a-...._,LC n r 3 r ' m r
^gIZIC..4,....,....,....,,r‘ l
' �l f m S m 1.1 S'
��1.•r�99t was Pr 737,Sema Ire .1 . m ,, % ) A a It j
•49.30.6.94.4..9 N •. m r i$i1 I1{
.a
GE1 41.4I-4S IS 3Q A Sr S', •I If
6•4,41c441.4113-4 I a ! m N .3 3• .•f
E..em Erone+a Group C..aw I m a . M 4 lr 36 +f
Came fa•••A.A..*'aN m II N A :e a 11
Leaver."0 1 3 1
m 1IT A a •6 r m
C.0 39.3.a C m ! A A Y 'm
6..a t34 m 36 m N 34 y
tx
I4y'¢.3.2. w.v ; n m 33 m i M 1' v a
.YE..va.,q Or.uC ) a }{ 3 3! a a. 4 'r,
u'ao w n G,ew.-c q ,� 3 ff 3 3 73 ,A, V .Y
...C..ul.a4Aa as Gall ; 3 3 3 M f' �15 • 4
w.a.rr•.. 3 ; 3 a 1• r R. a P
,kar...rLN.aw.'.0 f 3 j f 3 r a I r 34 • r
a.gr'ay.ti,G.ay.Ep+..i 3 i 3
S .,3. N a )a • ill
W.L..37..vfra.• pp
'9Efv.n irc I` i e 33 I I N 3 k {31
.,34.23 f.- I71 . S! I 6 n IN 13 . 44 31 a
.35.3'•rnpi u+m PC r ; ! a 431 N 1 a 14 Si I.
m 34.0.,,-C 72293w w O..y;
W a 4.. r•_ 4........: -- i
�
_� •
+-----}-- -'--...
I
�'� j •
aaa la
sr�
•
I
'- ---E-------'4--t-i
'y..� ._._ , i I- 111— H
IraNINA,.wnrfa...3731.WNW*oaf l5CtaNMYTO a AMMO 9110049•010411101111 1
Page 189 of 1954
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK