LGBTQ Advisory Board Minutes - 3-9-2021
LGBTQ Advisory Committee
Committee Chair, Paul Thomas
Meeting Minutes
Tuesday, March 9, 2021
Members in attendance – Cindy Brown, Craig Garmendia,
Edward Kring, Gayle Durham, Michael Bath, Paul Thomas,
Riki Wilchins, Robin Schwartz, Sunny Weber
Others in attendance- Dan Rios, GMCVB, Officer Manny
Valdes, PD
Called to order at 1:08 p.m.
Ongoing Business:
A. Approval of the February 9, 2021 meeting minutes- February minutes have not been
sent. Morgan will send them for approval at the April meeting.
B. MBPD Updates – Officer Valdes provided some updates
a. MBPD has been busy with spring break but it hasn’t been bad.
b. Hate Summit planned for July. This is an opportunity to get together with people
of the community and conduct ongoing training. Didn’t have one last year
because of the pandemic.
c. Eddie shared reports from friends that their overall sense of safety is a concern -
people are getting jumped and beat up. He asked current efforts are in place to
help reduce violence against LGBTQ people in Miami Beach, especially during
periods like Spring Break when we have so many visitors who don’t share our
values. MBPD doesn’t have anything specific to the LGBTQ community but they
do have a lot more officers on the beat. There was a general consensus by the
committee that the streets don’t feel as safe as they used to be. Manny said it’s
going to be a while before it gets cleaned up. A lot has deteriorated in the past
few years. In response to Eddie’s comment that he’d love to see things done
sooner vs. later, Manny said that things are being done now but he’s unsure
how effective they are. Lights on police cards are one from sunset to sunrise to
send the message “we’re here – don’t do it.” There’s ramped up parking
enforcement on Collins Avenue. MBPD is trying to come up with different ways
to deter the crime and ensure that the police presence is more visible.
d. Gayle asked about the April 5th end of the curfew. It seems this was just
announced by Miami-Dade County, but it is unclear if Miami Beach will extend
the curfew further. Manny reported that there was talk that it would not end until
after Spring Break.
C. GMCVB / Marketing updates – Dan Rios provided some updates
a. GMCVB continues to get numbers in from Miami Land campaign that ended in
January. 240,000 bookings came from this 3-month campaign and more
bookings are still coming in. The campaign received 170 million impressions.
of which 10% (17 million impressions) came from the LGBTQ community.
Committee Members
Cindy Brown
Craig Garmendia
Daniel Diaz
Edward Kring
Gayle Durham
Herb Sosa
Mark Wylie
Michael Bath
Nikolas Montolio
Riki Wilchins
Robin Schwartz
Sunny Weber
b. Trying to expand social media reach. Getting ready to promote Miami Health
and Wellness program. GMCVB brought in a social media influencer who
experienced the Everglades and other outdoor activities.
New Business:
A. Discuss Vacancies on Committee
a. There are currently two vacancies, one for Commissioner Arriola and one for
Commissioner Steinberg.
b. When Liz left she asked Commissioner Góngora to put someone in her seat.
Nikolas Montolio was appointed in November but has never shown up. Morgan
had been in email communication with him, but he has been unresponsive since
November 10. Liz and Robin both tried to reach out to him. This is the third
meeting that he has missed. If he absent in April, he will be kicked off the
committee.
c. There was much discussion about the committee’s role in selecting appointees.
• The Committee can show support for a candidate, but it is up to the
mayor and commissioners who to appoint.
• There is a list of applicants for this committee online, but right now there
is an issue with the clerk’s website and the information showing is from
2019. Morgan will send the list of applicants to the committee.
• It’s not our job to find the next person but it would be helpful if we as a
group came up with some names and suggestions.
• If we come across people who would be good additions, then we should
ask them to apply.
• Liz left because she wanted to make room for someone who is nonbinary
to be on the committee.
d. Cindy is still in limbo position. The commissioners must approve her because
she doesn’t live or work on the Beach.
B. Discuss Gay Beach relocation
a. Discuss was held that a lot of confusion and buzz has been generated by an ad
from the Palace that says the Gay Beach is moving to 10th Street. It was unclear
if this is just a Palace marketing ploy or something official, but the general
consensus is that this is something the Palace is doing alone and that it was
irresponsible for them to make this statement.
b. There is concern that the area closer to 10th street is where a lot of college
partiers are and it may create uncomfortable situations.
c. It was expressed that when the City painted the crosswalk at 12th Street that this
was the designation of where the gay beach was. The Palace wasn’t the only
business on 12th Street. There were multiple businesses there. 12th Street is
also known around the world the gay beach.
d. There’s an official ribbon-cutting with Commissioner Góngora doing the cutting.
Paul to reach out to him to let him know the Committee is concerned about
safety, marketing, and tourism.
C. Discuss LTC re: rainbow flags on lifeguard stands- the LTC wording was straight
forward and the Committee agreed to move forward with it.
D. Pride Park was brought up- the Park across the street from the Convention Center is
not about LGBTQ Pride, it’s about City Pride. There’s going to be a Veterans Memorial
there and Paul heard there won’t be any kind of art put up that isn’t related to the
Memorial.
E. City’s Budget
a. Paul asked if someone could come in and explain how it works. There’s no
budget or pot of money that we aren’t tapping into. Morgan explained that every
department says what they need. If commissioners want something not in the
department’s budget, it’s discussed at a budget workshop in June. It’s tentatively
approved but goes to commission in September.
b. The LTC for $150,000 for LGBTQ initiatives is still pending. It will be brought up
at the Finance and Economic Resiliency Committee during the budget briefing
meetings. This when be the time to advocate for money. Paul suggests we bring
something to the table. Gayle suggested going privately to Commissioner
Góngora or Richardson instead of sending an LTC about our wishes and ask
them to present it. Paul doesn’t want to rely only on the gay commissioners;
they won’t be there forever. The committee will bring ideas to the next meeting
and we will agree on the top 3. After that each of us can talk to our respective
commissioners.
Subcommittees Reports and Next Actions
1) HRC Rating (Cindy, Paul, Eddie)- HRC hasn’t put out the 2021 requirements.
2) LGBTQ Visibility/Marketing/Tourism (Eddie, Gayle, Mark, Sunny, Danny, Herb,
Michael)- The subcommittee needs to set its next meeting.
a. Marriage Equality Month is moving forward thanks to Commissioners Góngora
and Richardson.
i. June 26 is now Marriage Equality Day in Miami Beach. Pride Month has
been moved to June. (Note: This has nothing to do with the Miami Beach
Gay Pride.)
ii. They City is going to fix the website for marriage requirements.
b. The LGBTQ memorial will be discussed at the next Neighborhood and Quality of
Life Committee meeting on March 22 (via Zoom)
i. There was some uncertainty about whether they will discuss creating a
backdrop for marriage ceremonies using the LGBTQ art sculpture or a
backdrop that is not marriage-specific but intended for everyone.
ii. Morgan will send an email about the Neighborhood and Quality of Life
Committee meeting in case we want to speak about it and will input all of
our emails to sign us up for notifications about meetings.
3) Health and Wellness (Craig, Riki, Paul)
a. There have been some discussions about why the City doesn’t have access to
state-level data. It’s something we may need to ask the city – can they obtain
that data and, if not, why?
b. We would like to know how healthcare changed during COVID: What entities
have had challenges and can the City do anything to help them? For public
entities, who is receiving money for healthcare-related service? How can we be
sure our community is being represented in health-related services? The
subcommittee is trying to find out what the City can do more to help.
c. Want to talk to Florida Health Justice Project of find out what is going on related
to our community in this area. This group healthcare attorneys fighting for
legislation in Tallahassee. Paul having breakfast with them Thursday.
4) Advocacy Subcommittee (Paul, Robin, Sunny, Eddie, Cindy)- No report.
Meeting adjourned at 2:20 p.m.