2004-25459 ResoRESOLUTION NO.
2003-25459
A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY
COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH,
FLORIDA, APPROVING THE CREATION OF
RESTRICTED RESIDENTIAL PARKING PERMIT
ZONE Il/LAKE PANCOAST; AND EXPANDING
EXISTING RESIDENTIAL PARKING PERMIT ZONE
TWO/FLAMINGO PARK TO INCLUDE THE 500
BLOCK OF ESPANOLA WAY.
WHEREAS, the Lake Pancoast neighborhood is bounded by Pine Tree
Drive on the west, Inter-Coastal Waterway on the east, 23rd Street/Dade
Boulevard on the south, and a single family neighborhood to the north; and
WHEREAS, a residential parking program is recommended due to
intrusion noted from adjacent commercial, entertainment, educational and
recreational land uses displacing residential parking during various hours of the
day for substantial periods of time; and
WHEREAS, residents of the Lake Pancoast neighborhood have submitted
a petition requesting the establishment of a restricted residential permit parking
program for their neighborhood; and
WHEREAS, the Administration has reviewed and surveyed the areas in
question and formulated boundaries, including the following streets and cross-
street for inclusion in the program:
West 24th Street between Pine Tree Drive and Lake Pancoast Drive
West 24th Terrace between Pine Tree Drive and Flamingo Drive
West 25th Street between Pine Tree Drive and Flamingo Drive
Pine Tree Drive (eastside) between W. 24th Street and W. 25th Street
Flamingo Drive between W. 24th Street and W. 25th Street
Flamingo Place between W. 24th Terrace and W. 25th Street
Lake Pancoast Drive between W. 24th Street and W. 25th Street; and
WHEREAS, a publicly noticed workshop was held on August 13, 2003, in
order to discuss and receive input for the establishment of a residential parking
program for the Lake Pancoast neighborhood; and
WHEREAS, the City's Transportation and Parking Committee received
public input from affected residents and discussed this item at a regularly
scheduled (publicly noticed) meeting of the Committee on October 7, 2003; and
WHEREAS, the City's Transportation and Parking Committee endorsed the
recommendations of the Administration to create Restricted Residential Permit
Parking Zone 11/Lake Pancoast; and
WHEREAS, the Mayor and Commission amended the Resolution on the
floor to allow 50% of the zone to be restricted 24 hours, seven days a week and
50% of the zone to be restricted parking 6:00 PM to 7:00 AM Monday to Friday
and 24 hours Saturdays, Sundays, and Holidays; further requesting the
Administration to monitor this situation for six months to ensure its effectiveness;
and
WHEREAS, the 500 block of Espanola Way is currently unregulated and it
is completely surrounded by regulated on-street parking and all areas are
regulated by either commercial parking regulations (parking meters, loading
zones, etc.) or residential parking restrictions (Residential Parking Permit Zone
Two/Flamingo Park) during certain days and hours; and
WHEREAS, the competition for these unregulated parking spaces is fierce
and can be a serious detriment to residents' quality of life; and
WHEREAS, notwithstanding the residents' parking needs, the 500 block of
Espanola Way is cleady adjacent to an active entertainment district where there
is a high demand for commercial parking; and
WHEREAS, in order to peacefully co-exist residential and commercial
corridors must maximize parking opportunities by sharing the limited parking
supply; and
WHEREAS, residents of the 500 block of Espanola Way petitioned the
Administration to expand the existing residential parking permit zone (Flamingo
Park/Zone Two) to include the 500 block of Espanola Way; and
WHEREAS, the Administration reviewed the request and formulated
various recommendations for resident review, comment, and input at a publicly
noticed workshop to be held with affected residents; and
WHEREAS, a publicly noticed workshop was held on Wednesday, August
20, 2003, to receive comment and input from affected residents regarding the
proposed expansion of the zone to include the 500 block of Espanola Way; and
WHEREAS, affected residents discussed issues relating to construction,
valet parking, disabled parking, residential parking, commercial (metered, loading
zones, etc) parking, and enforcement on the 500 block of Espanola Way; and
WHEREAS, the Administration in conjunction with the affected residents
(workshop participants) formulated recommendations, supported unanimously, to
address each of the issues raised as follows:
South Side of the 500 block of Espanola Way: All parking spaces
are to be metered; however, Residential Parking Permit Zone Two
decals would be honored at these meters first-come, first served. It
was further stipulated that this metered area would not be used for
valet parking purposes; however, could serve other temporary
purposes such as film/print and/or construction needs.
North Side of the 500 blockof EspanolaWay: The first parking
space, from east to west, is to continue to be used as a
"construction parking space*) from 6:00 A.M to 6:00 P.M. and valet
parking drop-off/pick-up from 6:00 P.M. to 6:00 A.M. until alternative
arrangement can be made to relocate the valet drop-off/pick-up area
to another more suitable location. The second parking space, from
east to west, would be a commercial loading zone from 7:00 A.M. to
6:00 P.M./Monday-Friday and would revert to a restricted residential
parking space from 6:00 P.M. to 7:00 A.M. Monday-Friday and 24
hours a day Saturdays, Sundays, and Holidays. The third and fourth
parking spaces, from east to west, would be restricted residential
parking space; and
WHEREAS, the City's Transportation and Parking Committee discussed
and endorsed the aforementioned recommendations for the 500 block of
Espanola Way at their regularly scheduled (publicly noticed) meeting on October
7, 2003; and
WHEREAS, the Mayor and Commission amended the Resolution on the
floor to not honor residential parking zone two parking decals during the business
hours of 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM Monday through Friday on the 1400 block of Drexel
Avenue (cul de sac to 15th Street).
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT DULY RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND
CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, the creation
of Restricted Residential Parking Permit Zone 11/Lake Pancoast; and expanding
existing Residential Parking Permit Zone Two/Flamingo Park to include the 500
block of Espanola Way is hereby approved.
D AND ADOPTED this
MAYOR
ATTEST:
CITY CLERK
14th
day of
January
,, 2004
APPROVED AS TO
FORM & LANGUAGE
& FOR EXECUTION
JMG/CMC/SF
T:~AGENDA~2002\SEP2502\CONSENT~lakepancoast500blkespway.res.doc
Resolution No. 2004-25459
CiTY OF MIAMI*BEACH
COMMISSION ITEM SUMMARY
Conde.-._-ed Title:
I^ resolution of the Mayor end City Commission of the'City of Miami Beech, Florida, approving the
creation of Restricted Residential Parking Permit Zone 11/L.eke Penceast; and expending ex~lJng
Residential Perking Permit Zone Two/Flamingo Perk to include the 500 block of Espanola
IWhether to approve the creation of Restricted Residential Parking Permit Zone 11/I.ake Pancoast; a'nd
expand existing Resldenital Parking Permit Zone Two/Flamingo Park to include the 500 block of Espanola
Way?
~m Summarylla_aoommendatlon: , ,
The Administration has received pstttions from residents of each neighborhood (Lake Pancoest and E.s~nola
Way) requesting the creation of a residential parking program for lake Pancoast and expanding the ex;sting
residential zone to include the 500 block of Espanola Way. The Administration has held publicly noticed
workshops with each affected area and received their input, comments, and endorsement. Currently, each
neighborhood has areas of unregulated parking generally for residential use. Residents' parking is being
displaced by employees and/or patrons of abutting competing commercial, entertainment, educational, or
recreational land uses. The creation of Residential Parking Permit Zone 11/Lake Pancoest and the expansion
of Residential Parldng Permt Zone Two/Flamingo Park to include the 500 block of Espanolao
The Administration recommends the adoption of the resolution.
Advisory _r~__rd Recomme~ta,ion:
The Transportation and Parking Committee endorsed these recommendations at their regularly scheduled
meeting on October .7, 2003.
Financial Information:
Amount to be expended:
8ource of Amount Account Approved
Funds: t
, 4
Finance Dept. Total
Sign-Off'a: . .
IDepar~ent Director I' c#Y Ma '-m "er' 1 Mini"' i; ]
T:~E N~3~~ epk~urememorlelde/.~um .CCC ~
Agenda Item
Date
CITY OF MIAMI BEACH
CITY HALL 1700 CONVENTION CENTER DRIVE MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA 33139
www.ci.miami-beach.fl,us
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM
To:
From:
Subject:
Mayor David Dermer and Date: January, 14, 2004
Members of the City Commission
Jorge M. Gonzalez
City Manager
A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, APPROVING THE CREATION OF RESTRICTED
RESIDENTIAL PARKING PERMIT ZONE ll/LAKE PANCOAST; AND
EXPANDING EXISTING RESIDENTIAL PARKING PERMIT ZONE
TWO/FLAMINGO PARK TO INCLUDE THE 500 BLOCK OF ESPANOLA WAY,
ADMINISTRATION RECOMMENDATION
Adopt the Resolution.
ANALYSIS:
The City's Parking Department has received requests in the form of two petitions from the
Lake Pancoast and Espanola Way residents to create an RPP (Residential Parking Permit)
zone for the Lake Pancoast neighborhood and amend existing Residential Parking Permit
Zone Two (Flamingo Park) to include the 500 block of Espanola Way, respectively. The
following is a summary of the Parking Department's findings and actions regarding both
requests to date:
Residential Parkin.q Permit Zone 11 (Lake Pancoast):
The Lake Pancoast neighborhood is bounded by Pine Tree Drive on the west, Inter-Coastal
Waterway on the east, 23rd Street/Dade Boulevard on the south, and a single family
neighborhood to the north. A restricted residential parking program is recommended due to
intrusion from adjacent commercial, entertainment, educational and recreational land uses
displacing residential parking during various hours of the day for substantial periods of time.
The following are various generators and hours during which residential parking is being
displaced within the noted areas:
Generators of Parking (non-residential) Hours
Collins Avenue and 23ra Street Employees Day/Night
Beachgoers (crossing footbridge at 24th Street and Collins Avenue)Day
Area School Students Day
Patrons of Restaurants/Nightclubs on 23rd Street Night
General visitors seeking "free" parking Day/Night
J~nu~ry ~4, 200~
Comml~aion ~,~rnor~ndurn
Cm.#on of L~k~ P~nco~/An~ndrn~nt to Re~id~nt~l P~ridng P~rmi~ Zor~ Two
P~e 2 of 5
Subsequently, a petition was received from various homeowner associations in the "Lake
Pancoast" neighborhood to develop and implement an RPP (Residential Parking Permit)
Zone. The City of Miami Beach Parking Department formulated recommendations for
affected residents to review, comment, and provide input. A publicly noticed Workshop was
held at 6:00 P.M. on Wednesday, August 13, 2003, at the FlU/Women's Club, located at
2401 Pine Tree Drive, Miami Beach, Florida. The Workshop was held in order to provide
information and recommendations regarding the implementation of an RPP and request
comments, suggestions, and input from the affected residents in order to develop a
consensus. Residents were advised that the proposed residential program would be referred
to the City's Transportation and Parking Committee and ultimately to the Mayor and City
Commission for ratification. The following is a summary of the recommendations proposed
for the Residential Parking Program:
reet
North: Northerly line of 25t~ Street*
East: Easterly line of Lake Pancoast Drive
West: Easterly line of Pine Tree Drive
* Notes: Residents agreed to extend the northern boundary to the north side of 25"'
Street for the first six months of the program; however, residents reserve the right to
delete the north side of 25~ Street at the end of the first six (6) month interval.
Restricted pa~lna Houm:
Restricted residential parking 24 hours a day/seven days a week.
Residential parklna Permit Zone Feee:
Annual Permit Fee*:
Annual Visitor Hang-Tag*:
$50.00 (plus tax) per vehicle.
$50.00 (plus tax) (one hang-tag per
resident). Visitor "Scratch-Off" 24 Hour
hang-tag: $1.00 (plus sales tax) per
hang-tag. Five (5) hang-tags may be
purchased monthly up to six months in
advance. Additional hang-tags are
available for parties, social affairs, etc.
Requirements:
Bona fide residents of the Zone would be mailed a registration/decal purchase Package.
Each resident that wishes to park vehicle(s) in the restricted parking areas outlined above
must register to participate in the "Lake Pancoast" Residential Parking Permit Program
(Zone11 ). Copies of the following documents would be required to register and purchase
a decal/hang-tag for the zone:
o Government Issued Photo Identification.
o Proof of residency such as current (within last 30 days) utility bill (electric,
gas, phone, etc.).
January 14, 2004
Gornmi.~ion Memorandum
Creation of Lake Pancoast/Amendment to Residential Parking Permit Zone Two
Pege 3 of 5
O Valid vehicle registration**
Notes: *All annualized ~cs may be prorated semi-annually.
**Vehicle registration(s) with outstanding parking violations will not be
allowed to participate in the residential parking progrern. All outstanding
parking violations must be satisfied prfor to participation.
Promulaatlon of Reaulaflons:
Signs would be posted in the areas promulgating the appropriate restriction, including
arrival signs warning drivers they are entering a restricted parking area as well as
trailblazing signs to commercial parking facilities. Typically two to thrcc signs per block
face would be installed promulgating the parking restrictions. Vehicles parking within
these posted areas must display a valid residential parking decal, visitor hang-tag, or
"scratch-off' hang-tag.
Progressive enforcement would commence on an agreed upon date for a period of thirty
(30) days in the form of warnings. This would graduate to the issuance of parking citations
for a period of thirty (30) days, and subsequently, vehicle impoundment may be necessary
to properly enforce the parking regulations/restrictions.
Pot_entlaJ Add!tional (~.~treet Parking for Residents:
The Administration is currently negotiating with the WolfsonianlFIU to utilize the Women's
Club parking facility for various uses including future overflow residential parking needs.
500 BI0(~k of E_%nz_nola Way ~x_~an~ion (Flamlnao Park/Zone Two):
The 500 block of Espanola Way is currently unregulated and it is completely surrounded by
regulated on-street parking. All areas are regulated by either commercial parking regulations
(parking meters, loading zones, etc.) or residential parking restrictions (Residential Parking
Permit Zone Two/Flamingo Park) during certain days and hours. The competition for these
unregulated parking spaces is fierce and can be a serious detriment to residents' quality of
life. Notwithstanding the residents' parking needs, the 500 block of Espanola Way is clearly
adjacent to an active entertainment district where there is a high demand for commercial
parking. The peaceful co-existence of residential and commercial corridors is the very
essence of urban life in South Beach. To this end, the residents of the 500 block of Espanola
Way, to their credit, recognized this fact and embraced it. This is evidenced by their
concurrence to the proposed recommendations for the south side of the 500 block of Espanola
Way stated below.
Numerous residents on the 500 block of Espanola Way requested that their block be included
into the existing Residential Parking Permit Zone Two/Flamingo Park. The City of Miami
Beach Parking Department held a publicly noticed workshop on Wednesday, August 20, 2003,
January f4, 2004
Commission Memorandum
Creation of Lake Pancoast/Amer~.ir~nt to Residential Perking Permit Zone Two
Page 4 of 5
to receive comment and input from affected residents regarding the proposed expansion of the
zone to include the 500 block of Espanola Way. Issues discussed at the workshop included
construction, valet parking, disabled parking, residential parking, commercial (metered,
loading zones, etc) parking, and enforcement.
The Administration, in conjunction with the affected residents (workshop participants),
formulated recommendations, supported unanimously by participants, to address each of the
issues raised as follows:
South ~iide of the ~00 block Of EeDanola Way:
All parking spaces are to be metered; however, Residential Parking Permit Zone Two
decals would be honored at these meters first-come first served. Currently, there are
various expanded areas where residential permits are honored at parking meters.
Resolution No. 99-23225 established various expanded areas in various zones. Due to
the dynamics of residential parking users, it has been the Department's policy to honor
residential permits within these areas throughout the entire day first-come first-served. As
an example, if residential permits are honored strictly during the meter's hours of operation
(9:00 A.M. to Midnight) then residents that have non-traditional working hours would be
required to pay the meter at 9:00 A.M. and/or throughout the balance of the day.
Conversely, residents with traditional working hours would reap a benefit that the other
residents would not. It was further stipulated that this metered area would not be used for
valet parking purposes; however, could serve other temporary purposes such as film/print
and/or construction needs.
North ~Ide of the $00 block of EeDanola Way:
The first parking space, from east to west, will continue to be used as a "construction
parking space*) from 7:00 A.M to 6:00 P.M. and valet parking drop-off/pick-up from 6:00
P.M. to 7:00 A.M. until alternative arrangement can be made to relocate the valet drop-
off/pick-up area to another more suitable location. The second parking space, from east to
west, would be a commercial loading zone from 7:00 A.M. to 6:00 P.M/Monday-Friday and
would convert to a restricted residential parking space from 6:00 P.M. to 7:00 A.M.
Monday-Friday and 24 hours a day Saturdays, Sundays, and Holiday. The third and fourth
parking spaces, from east to west, would be restricted residential parking space.
On October 7, 2003, the City's TPC (Transportation and Parking Committee) endorsed the
Administration's recommendations to both create a new residential parking zone for the Lake
Pancoast neighborhood, including the aforementioned parameters for the program and
expand existing Residential Parking Permit Zone Two/Flamingo Park to include 500 block of
Espanola Way as described above. Subsequently, as required by the City Code, the Mayor
and Commission must hold a public hearing to recaive public comment, discuss, and, if
acceptable, approve the proposed recommendations.
January f4, 2004
Commission Memorandum
Creation of Lake Pancoast/Amendmont to Residential Parking Permit Zone Two
Page 5 of 5
For informational purposes, the notification efforts to all affected residents and businesses
were extensive. There were two publicly noticed meetings heid prior to today's City
Commission's public hearing for a total of three public hearings on the subject (Workshops on
Wednesday, August 13, 2003 and August 20, 2003; Transportation and Parking Committee
Meeting on October 7, 2003, and City Commission Meeting on November 25, 2003). On
November 25, 2003, the item was deferred to January 14, 2004. Notification of this and ell
other meetings was issued through the public notice process, including direct mail, to all
affected residents for each of the meetings held. Moreover, notices were also mailed to all
properties within 375 feet of the affected boundaries.
The Administration recommends that the Mayor and Commission approve a resolution to
create Residential Parking Permit Zone 11 for the Lake Pancoast neighborhood, as described
herein and expand existing Residential Parking Permit Zone Two/Flamingo Park to include the
500 block of Espanola Way, as described herein.
jMe~C,SF~
F:~iNG~,LL~SAUL~COMMRESO~kepancoaatS0(~keepwaY.~.~
PROPOSED RESIDENTIAL ZONE 11
(LAKE PANCOAST)
BOUNDARIES
SOUTH - SOUTHSIDE OF W 24TH STREET
NORTH - SOUTHSIDE OF W 25TH STREET
WEST- EASTSIDE OF PINE TREE DRIVE
EAST- EASTSIDE LAKE PANCOAST DR
W. 25 ST.
~ W. 24 TER~
LEGEND
[7-~"~'~ PARALLEL P~RKING
~ HEAD-IN PAFRKING
TOTAL SPACES: 204 +/-
w~t of Pr~ A~enue. ·
-cot~ 30~.2489 (vo~e), 3~73-7~..1~,~_d~ ~ ~o
OF
NOTICE OF A PUBLIC H RING
-- NOTICE · HEREBY gi~n th~ a Public Headng wffl ~ held ~ ~e Mayor and
Commission ~ t~ Cl~ of Miami B~ch, Florida, in the C~m~sion Ch~, 3~
floor; City Hall, 17~ ~nvent~on Center Drive, Miami Beach, Florida, ~
~n~day, danua~ 14, ~, at 5:~ p.m., to consi~ the establishme~ of a
Restrict~ R~idential Parking Zone ~r the ~ke Pancoast Neigh~o~ ~d
expanding exi~ing Resi0ential Paring Permit Zone Two ~l~ingo P~) on the 500
block of Espa~ola Way.
inquiries may ~ dir~t~ to the Parking ~pa~m~t (305) 673-75~.
INTERES~D PA~IES am Inv~ to appear at this m~lng, or to be mpmsent~
by an agent, or to ~press their views in writing addms~ to ~ Ci~ Commission,
~o ~e C~ Clerk 1700 Conve~on Ce~er Drive, 1 st Flor, C~ Hall, Miami B~ch,
Flodda 33139. Cop~ of th~ o~ln~ces am ~vailable for public insp~ion during
n~al ~ne~ ~u~ In t~ C~ Cle~'s ~ce, 1700 ~e~ion Ce~ DrNe, 1~
Root, Ci~ Hall Miami Beth, R~ida 33139. This m~ing may be continued and
un0er such cimum~ces add~i~al I~al n~ice ~u d not ~ p~ d~.
Ro~ E. P~her, CI~ Cle~
Cffy of Mi~i g~ch
Pu~a~ to ~ion 286,0105, F~. S~t., the Ci~ hereby ad~ses the public that: ~ a
~n ~iO~ to ~al any ~ision made by the Ci~ C~mi~lon w~h ~t
to a~y maffer ~nside~ a ~ts m~ti~9 Or its hearing, such ~ must ensure that
a ve~atlm ~o~ of t~ p~din~ ~s made, which ~o~ includ~ the testimo~
and ~ide~e upon ~tch the ap~l is to ~ ~s~, ~is notice d~s ~t co~u~
conse~ W the C~y ~r the int~uction or ~mi~n of othe~se inadmt~ible or
irrelevant ~iden~, nor do~ ~ auth~ize challenges or app~ls n~ ~he~i~
~llowed by law. To request this materia~ in ack.ibis format, sign I~guage
i~e~em information on access for pe~ns w~h disabilities, and/or any
ac~mm~at~n to ~i~ any d~ume~ or paAicipate in any c~ty-s~nsored
pr~lng pl~e co~t 305-604-2489 voice 305-673-7218 ~ five da~s in
advance to initAte your ~, ~ usam may a~ ca 71 Fo~da Helay
~ice). ~
~ ~232
CITY OF MIAMI BEACH
NOTICE OF A CITY COMMISSION
WORKSHOP MEETING
NOTICE IS HEREBY given that the City Commission ~ the City of Miami
Beech Florida, will hold a Wor'Kshop Meeting on Thursday, January 8,
2004, commenulng at 3..00 p.m., in the Commission Chambem, 3rd floor,
City Hall, 1700 Convention Center Ddve, Miami Beach, Florida, regarding
Cultural Aff~irs Strategic Planning.
The City Commission may discuss other City business at this meeting.
INQUIRIES may be directed to the Tourism and Cultural Development
Department at (305) 673-7577,
Robert E, Paroher, City Clerk
City of Miami Beach
Pursuant to Bect on 286.0105, Fla. Stat., the City hereby advises the
public that: If a person decides to appeal any decision mede by the City '
Commission with respect to any matter considered at Its meeting or Its
hearing, such person must ensure that a verbatim record of the
proceedings is mede, which recon:l includes the testimony and evidence
upon which the ap~lal ia to be based. This notice does not constitute
consent by the C~ty for the introduction or admission of otherwise
inadmissible or irrelevant evidence, nor does it authorize challenges or
appeals not otherwise allowed by law,
To request this material in accessible format, sign language interpreters,
nformation on access for persons with disabilities, and/or any
accommodation to~ review any document or participate in any city-
sponsored proceeding, please contact 305-604.248g.(voi__ce,), 305-673-
7218 {TRY) five days In advance to initiate your request, ~ IY users may
also call 711 (Florida Relay Benrica).