Aaron Rene Resnick - Ananthan K. Thangavel r
Q
MRECE{s IBEACH e e
IVEDA Office of
nventin Center Drive_: :• ,
MiamrBeach, FL'33139 �: FEB'FEB�,2tt8 2023
305.673.74.11
LOBBYIS
CITY OF IVIIAMI BEACH'
��'� s. �.- �. _ T REGISTRATION FORM -
Lobbyist means all:persons°employedor.retained,,whether paid or.not, by;a principal who seeks t 0 ncourage,he pas,geLdefeat or'
modification of any ordinance,'resolution, action or decision of any commissioner, any,action, decision, recommendation,of the City
'k' .Mena er,oran ; board`.or committee;'gran ,-action;decision'or recommendation ofanyCi
•'� 9 Y'CityY pity personnel during the time period of the,`
entire,decision-making process,on,such,action; decision;or recommendation that'foreseeably will be,heard or reviewed by the City-- ,
• Commission, or a City board or committee:'The;term specifically includes the principal as.well as any employee'engaged,in lobbying
activities.:The term•"Lobbyist°has'specific exclusions. Please refer,to City Code Chapter 2,,Article VII,,Division 3,entitled"Lobbyists,°- '
--for additional information. : - '
,Instructions:;:Please complete all,sections of this form and submit the`conipleted'form,with the applicable.fee;to the Office of the City ,
Clerk. If you need more space to complete an answer use a separate sheet(s)of-paper. If you have nothing,to report in a particular. • ,,
,section, you must:write "none" or "n/a":'in that section. Any change to' any information originally filed,'or any additional City
, Commissioner or personnel,who are,also sought to be lobbied„shall require•that the lobbyist file an amendment-to the registration.form."
The•lobbyist has a continuing duty to supply information.and amend the.forms filed throughout the period that the lobbying occurs. }
- ' ,;Separate registration forms'shall be required for`each'principal represented'on each specific issue. -
I. LOBBYIST INFORMATION 'rt .
Aaron'
.Resnick Rene.' • .
"NAME OFLOBBYIST — - (Last)--- -___.: _-, -:(First) --:_ ---,(Middle Name) - .-----
Law Officesof Aaron Resnick, P A 100.Biscayne Blvd, Suite 1607, Miami, FL 3313.2
'-LOBBYIST BUSINESS NAME AND-ADDRESS'•;' (Neither'andStreet) --'- _ :(City.) - :(State). 'lap Code)
LOBBYIST BUSINESS TELEPHONE NUMBER - - CELLULAR TELEPHONE NUMBER: - EMAIL-ADDRESS '
,II. PRINCIPALINFORMATION . -
1330 15th.Street LLC Q h -.
� V navy gr10
`,, NAME-OF-PRINCIPAL -- --(Last)-- �-- ~ ,•(First) - (Middle-Name) _
133015 Street,Miami Beach,_Florida 331.39
,qPRINCIPAL`BUSINESS NAME AND ADDRESS' ' -(Number and Street) '-_ - - ' (City) '"(State) • — ' (Zip Code)--- -
-
- (818) 667-1.975 , ': , - -(818)-667-1975 ',' athangavel@lakshmi-capital coal.
,- - , • :PRINCIPAL BUSINESS TELEPHONE NUMBER "-- ' --. CELLULAR TELEPHONE NUMBER:, : '.,':EMAIL ADDRESS
cn' C 3'n". -4' ^.� WC' .+'.' � F—_��-,r—r d;i =t'a '+- e t ... a-'-�;—±£ �+ e•a-s, Sw-.s:. ���Y�,,
Pursuantf67cdy Cods Sectiim -4-026)(1)(a) rA Pikai al ofanyacorFsoration,rpaitnership;or other e6fity=whorappaars�as=a Lobbyist on behalf of_that ., • -
, entity,.without special.compensation°or reimbursement for the appearance;whether direct,indirect or;contingent,to,express support of or opposition to`,`
an'item shall regeter with the Clerk-as'reclaim j y thissubsection,but shalii net be required to_pay arty registration fees "'� -" wLL - `
If the principal is a Corporation, Partnership,or Trust, the following information,MUST be;provided
pursuant to City Code Section 2-482(c); • '
,;• , , ,, , . • NAME OF CHIEF OFFICER,PARTNER,OR BENEFICIARY(if none,write NIA)S;,Thangavel Fainiv2006 Irrevocable-Trust ,
-` •' NAME OF-ALL-PERSONS HOLDING,DIRECTLY`OR INDIRECTLY,A5%'OR'MORE OWNERSHIP INTEREST IN SUCH
• Trustees:Anathan Than aver and
'' - CORPORATION,PARTNERSHIP OR TRUST•,(if none,write N/A).::_ 9 __ , -
Atul Thangavel _
- Page 1 of 5 -
NotaryCam Doc ID: eb979781-e983-4450-9318-82ec680803a0 '
III. ISSUE TO BE LOBBIED:
Describe with as much detail as is practical, including but not limited to a specific description where
applicable of a pending request for proposal, invitation to bid, or public hearing number.
Advocate on behalf of 1330 15th Street LLC at upcoming Miami Beach Board of Adjustments Meeting Pertaining to
Variance Request for the Premises Located at 1330 15 Street, Miami Beach, Florida 33139.
IV. CITY AGENCIES/INDIVIDUALS TO BE LOBBIED:
Pursuant to City Code Section 2-482(a)(4), list the City Commissioner or City personnel sought to be
lobbied, and whether the lobbyist has entered into any contractual relationship (paid or unpaid) with
said City Commissioner or City personnel from 12 months preceding such commencement of service
with the City to the present date, stating the general nature of the subject contractual relationship.
Full Name of Individual and Contractual Relationship(If yes,explain) YES NO
Title of Person to be Lobbied
Planning Department and Building Dept.Staff X
Board of Adjustments X
Pursuant to City Code Section 2-482(g), every registrant shall be required to state the extent of any
business, financial, familial or professional relationship, or other relationship giving rise to an
appearance of an impropriety,with any current City Commissioner or City personnel who is sought to
be lobbied as identified on the lobbyist registration form filed.
List any Business, Financial, Familial or Professional Relationship, or other relationship giving rise to an
appearance of impropriety(if none,write N/A):
n/a
V. DISCLOSE RATE AND AMOUNT OF LOBBYIST COMPENSATION — Be Specific. (Note that a
contingency fee is prohibited pursuant to City Code Sec. 2-485.3):
$500 an hour
Page 2 of 5
NotaryCam Doc ID: eb979781-e983-4450-9318-82ec680803a0
The following six(6)questions MUST be answered:
1) ' Pursuant to City Code Section 2-488,entitled"Prohibited Campaign Contributions By Lobbyists On Procurement Issues":
Yes.)(No• Are you lobbying on a present or pending bid for goods,equipment or services,or on a present or .
pending award for goods,equipment or service?
2)- Pursuant to City Code Section 2-490,entitled"Prohibited Campaign Contributions By.Lobbyists On Real Estate Development
Issues":
• ,;_Yes ANo: .. Are you lobbying on a pending application for a Development Agreement with the City or application
,for change of zoning map designation or change to the City's Future Land Use Map?,
3) , Pursuant to City Code Section 2-482(h),any person (except those exempt from the definition of"lobbyist" as set forth in
Section 2-481)who only appears,as a representative of a not-for-profit corporation or entity without special compensation or
reimbursement for the appearance,whether direct or indirect to express support of or opposition to any item,shall register with
the city clerk as required by this section,but shall not be required to pay any registration fees. .
Yes.XNo: Are you representing .a'• not-for-profit corporation or entity without special compensation or
• reimbursement?
4)4) Pursuant to City Code Section 2-481,the term "lobbyist"specifically excludes the following persons: Expert witnesses who
provide,only scientific,technical or other specialized information or testimony in public meetings; any person who only appears
as a representative of a neighborhood association without compensation or reimbursement for the appearance,whether direct, i
indirect or contingent,to express;support of or opposition to any,item;and any,person who only appears as a representative of
not-for-profit community based organization for the purpose of requesting, a grant without special compensation or
reimbursement for the appearance.
YesX No: Are you providing only scientific,. technical or other specialized information; appearing as a
representative of a neighborhood association without special compensation or reimbursement or
:representing a not-for-profit based organization for the purpose of requesting a grant without.,
special compensation or reimbursement?
5) ' Pursuant to City Code Section 2491(1), no campaign consultant shall lobby the City Commission for a period of 12 months
following the swearing in of any elected official(s)for whom the campaign consultant provided campaign consulting services
within the past election cycle.See Section 2-491 for more information.
YesX No: Have you provided,campaign consulting services to an incumbent member of the City Commission
within the past election cycle?If yes,please list the incumbent members)of the.City Commission:
Yes XNo If yes,,has it been leis•than 12 months since the elected officials)whom you provided campaign)
consulting services was sworn in?
6).` ,Pursuant to City Code Section 2-482(a)(4)a., a lobbyist who has within the past election cycle provided campaign consulting
services to an incumbent member of the City Commission (which lobbying activity is not otherwise prohibited by Code section
2-491) shall disclose such particular service on his/her lobbyist registration form and shall orally disclose such particular
;;,service before lobbying the City Commission at a°public meeting.
Yes)No: ,Have you provided campaign consulting services to an incumbent member of the City Commission
within the past election cycle?If yes,please list the incumbent members)of the City Commission:
Yes X;No: If yes:were you promised oe did You receive economic consideration in exchange for campatgn'
consultin services?"
....TO BE COMPLETED CITY.CLERK'S_STAFF.ONLY _.
Annual Registration fee• I °]Yes I, I No' Amount Paid$ • MCR# • Date Paid:_
Lobbyist Registration Form received and verifred.by..
FAcLERi$ALL1aFOitMS\LOBBYIST FORMSlLobbyistRegistsation Fors Revised 03-11-20'REG.doc Revised 03/11/2020
• Page 3of 5
NotaryCam Doc ID: eb979781-e983-4450=93.1.8-82ec680803a0
-- .
.., , .
. „
. . ,
. .
• • r.,,
. -
1VI. • SIGNATURES UNDER:.OAT-14::
,
:ON FEBRUARY_28 OrBACH YEAR. EACI-CLOBBYISILSHALLBUBMITTOLTHEOFFICBfOF THE CITY:CLERK'A,
SIGNED STATEMENT UNDER OATH‘ LISTING LOBBYING 'EXPENDITURES;,_AS WELL AS COMPENSATION
RECEIVED FOR THE PRECEDING CALENDAR YEAR WITH REGARDTO THE SPECIFIC ON_WHICTITHE
;LOBBYIST HASEBEEK,ENGAGED:TO.-.LOBBY.:;„.:Af_STATEMENT;SHALL.BEEILED,_EVEN.'IFTHERE.HALBEEN:NO'
EXPENDITURE OR COMPENSATION,DURING.THEREPORTING;,,PERIOD.r
.Signature of Lobbyist ,_ :------- - :-,- - '..-..-:----:--,_______._.__- 'Date -(--24Lr2_0.2_3
. '
1.dtitblettinly!!!SWeer of affirrd.that 11 of the foregoing feat 'statements, and diSclosures irt this'form are'true ab-d COrrect,
an'Killiat I have read or am familiar with the provisions contained in Chapter 2,'Art:VII:i.Diyisibn:3', entitled' :'Lobbyist s" of
.._
'die Miami padri City Code and all reporting re. .
-- reneits
Signature of Lobbyist
Date _2_- I,. Ia /7_O 1_.. . .
.,,.
. ... . .f thlateteriZ 7rOrgailee - 2/22/2023
Signature of Priticipa. _ .... _ . - : . _ .- !Date -,
..„... , . .
VII'. N9TART,S)GNATIJRE ,AND:SAL:,
, • . , ,
LOBBYIST: PRINCIPAL
, .
`State of flioii 619.., „ ,; ; :State Cf.-Virginia--
- ,
County 6f...... . .1.74100:19c_)',-- '‘'' .
County of: _Alexandria City
. .
Sworn to affirmed) before me Sworn to(or affirmed)and subscribed before nie,
„ _
means of ysical presence : '- :by nilaft! of ci physical presence
or,:-0:onlirie notari4ation, . ._...,.-- - - . - :or online notarization,
thi122_,Pday,of ..,c-CAP-_TYP".-Ilfl- . . _ 20 24by' :this 22,day of-,_ ,February...,...,_„ ....,..:20. by,
_Ananthan Thangavet___
___ _______ .,
NAME OF LOBBYIST , NAME OF PRINCIPAL
N y Commission.expires: 04/30/2024
:. i
---Produced ID „ . 'Produced ID.,- Drivers Licensemm...„
FORM OF IDENTIFICATION '
: FORM OF IDENTIFICATIONc
/-'
ersbnally Know, i -
. ersoriallY Knovv! .0.
: -
iSignatine of Notary,Pu,, ic ' ! Signet re _ .
. 140(24_041; !MOOS
---Kristen-Renee„GanzalPz.- - ,.- - .. .
Name of Notary Ty.-iidifsinkdiWtcar-.2-,--4.--!§-:',_, .7' Name of NOtary,Typed, Printed or Stafripecii- ---
!..ii. iiDlik OiASit . , , Completed via Remote Online Notarization using 2 way AudioNideo technology.
1
---(NQT? 3Y SEAL) ,g v;:Pt; I! ,ccr,„ission#jiki2957807c'
(N.P.VRY'S_-F.AL 4I llai-l'li h-mkalimi0aEldNih-)iiglNlhiEgiEb Gi-aollNilaAlLlaEZ
i-d'li •:- I - ' ' --`
,i:34 -Ally:CcmniExpireiect 4,2026t! ,,. ! 0 Electronic Notary Public_1 `:'.. • •'''iicalded throt. ri Iiilonal Rotary:Auk , 0 Commonwealth of-Virginia
Registration No.,7.8880q4 P.
• I The'term lobbyist specifically-exa0 the fdlloWingrperson :" i My Commission Expires Apr 0,'2024 p .
, . ... .,...P.p.....mr.r.prweer._ . -..4. ..
Expert witnesses who provide only scientific, technical or-other specialized information or testimony in public Meetings;any person who
only appears as,eSrepresen.tetiVe2 of a neighborhood association.without compensation or reimbursement for the.appearance i whether
direct, indirect or dOntingeht,,1b-exprest support of-or opposition to any.-itern;.,and any person who only appears as a representative of
notTfor7profit community based organization for the purpose,of requeOng a grant without special,compensation or reimbursement for,
the eppea'rence,
'Page 4 of 5
. . ,
• .
NotaryCam Doc ID: eb979781-e983-4450-9318-82ec680803a0
. .
. . .
• MIAMI BEACH •
City of Miami Beach,1700 Convention Center Drive,Miami Beach,Florida 33139,www.miamibeachfl.gov
Office of the City Clerk
Rafael E. Granado, City Clerk CityClerk@miamibeachf.gov
Tel: 305.673.7411, Fax:305.673.7254
NAME OF LOBBYIST: Aaron R. Resnick
1) LOBBYIST FEE EXPENDITURE AND COMPENSATION STATEMENT
Pursuant to City Code Section 2=485(d), the City Clerk.shall notify any lobbyist (or
principal)who fails to file timely a Lobbyist Fee Expenditure and Compensation Statement
(Statement). In addition to any other penalties that may be imposed as provided in
Section 2-485.1, a fine of $50.00 a day shall be assessed for Statements filed after the
due date. The City Clerk shall notify the Miami-Dade County Commission on Ethics and
Public Trust of the failure of a lobbyist (or principal) to file the Statement or pay the
assessed fines after notification.
Any lobbyist, who fails to file the required Statement by April 30th of each year, shall be
automatically suspended from lobbying until all fines are paid, unless the fine has been
' appealed to the Miami-Dade County Commission on Ethics and Public Trust.
I hereby acknowledge that on February 28 of each year, I shall submit to the City Clerk a
signed Statement under oath listing all lobbyist expenditures, as well as compensation
received, for the preceding calendar year with regard to the specific issue on which I have
been engaged to lobby.
2) LOBBYIST WITHDRAWAL
Once an issue I have registered to lobby has concluded or I am no longer lobbying on
that issue, I shall immediately file a Notice of Withdrawal with the Office of the City Clerk.
3) ANNUAL LOBBYIST REGISTRATION FEE
I understand annual registration of all lobbyists shall be required for each 12-month period
commencing October 1 of each year, and the fee for such annual registration shall be
$500.00 pursuant to Section 2-482 of the Miami Beach City Code.
Signature of Lobbyisi Date
F:\CLERI$ALLIaFORMS\LOBBYIST FORMS1Lobbyist Registration Form Revised 03-11-20 REG.doc
Page 5 of 5
NotaryCam Doc ID: eb979781-e983-4450-9318-82ec680803a0
_ .
IAMFBEACH
City OrMictitii Beach,1700 Convention;Center Drive,Miami Beach,Florida 3-3139,www.miarni4eachfLgov
Office•oFtlie City Clerk,
Rafael"E,Granada,City Clerk CilyClerk@mtamibeacfragoy
Id:305,673.74'11,+clic;30.673,7254 •
NAME OF LOBBYIST: Aaron R.Resnick
1) LOBBYIST FEE EXPENDITURE AND COMPENSATION STATEMENT
•
Pursuant to City 000:1009.0b Clerk shall notify any lobbyiSJ-(or
priflOW*(MtOiltgifilk.,tlitioV0,,00154)0:;F*;**/-0(0e, q0,T,c.:9;fp:p,19..potion-:-AtatooePt
(qt0061:041 )6,.40ifio,34: :01i4:3:00(0,60i4;,th*••tfiY1,4*.Atilp*cli*10,..dy*Cjil
• Section 2-485.1, a fine of $50.00 a.day shall be.assessed for Statements filed'after the
due odfot Tho-:::co;--;troZchalf.Otifil0100iitlicerqurity-f0019,0466,9rv-06,10'46c1
Public Trust. of the failure of a lobbyist (or principal) to' file the Statement or pay
asteated4inea;afferbOtifiCatiOn,
„ , . , •
AnY.IlObbYiet;-*haifaile to filetheifequired.Statennent by Aprilytr.-Of,eadli,year, shall
automatically suspended from lobbying until all fines are paid, unless the fine has been
aPpealecittO..theVjatrii2Dade:COunty-CommisaiOn on Ethics and,Public Trust.
-
•
1 hereby acknowled!e that on February.20.of each year, I shall submit to the City Clerk a
signed Statement under oath liating,#1,1obbyist expenditures, as well as compensation
reCeiVek,fOr.,-ttiereceaibg,calendar year vittri,regard to the specific issue on whidhflhave
been engaged to lobby.
4 LOBBYIST WITHDRAWA1,
Once an issue I have registered to lobby has concluded or t am no longer lobbying on
that issue,I shall immediately file a Notice of Withdrawal with the Office of the City Clerk,
3) ANNUAL LOBBYIST REGISTRATION,FEE
understand annual registration of all,lobbyists shall be required for each 12-month period
commencing October 1 of each year, and the fee for such .annual registration Shall be •
$500.00 pursuant to Section 2482'of the Miami'Beach City Code.
_
Signature of Lob byia Date
PACLERISALLIeFORMSLOBBYIST FQRAZIEIgbbyist Registration Form Revised 0341.20 REg.doc
Page 5 of 5
. ....: .
ril ,„.. , ;...„ , .., ,i.,„,,_.....„.*„, ,,,,„:.-„,„, ,
:,,,,.,.. u, ,,,,,,,,-„,...f,,,, ,, ..., :,- ..-,..,, ,,,,,,z,,,,,, , . 1
r:,.,,.:,?,z ,,„ . :,,,, ',..., 1 ;.:1 --. „,,,,,, ,,,,, -,,,,,, .1.-- 1
m c
- 'RECEIVED
,L.,.,:_.;_.; -1,,L:. •.,-,.1.3_,..: ,...-4,;....::: 24,.,'.:,,,,,.... 1
_ ...
41,,k0Mikiii140.:61i FEB 2 8 2023
1700donventiUrTteritere:0003
Mimi:Boott KI0tiot- 4003
;'..7.1 :::*.:0.4k0000ittlaw
,otilogivoAtitke2, . •
Tel ,atitAti.,444:1
3 2 * .
CIIN OF nBECALCERHK
05673454
- : I, i OFFIOffiCE0C:FuMT:10A:OMCnilv:
. .
ANNUAL LOBBYIST REGISTRATION FORM
Name:. Aaron Resnick
Business Name:Law Offices of Aaron Resnick PA
Address: 100 Biscayne Blvd, Suite 1607, Miami, Florida 33132 •
Office Telephone Number: (305) 672-7495 •
, .
Oeitutar Telephone Number: (305) 672-7496 ,
Broil Address: . .q rP§P i Oc@tbefi rn:111 iP r11 i-PP M. . .. .. ... .... . . _. . . .. . .. . .. .
If more than one:lob-WA please list:, .
1)
'2) ,
,:3)
. •
6)
7)
StibitAittilii, fdrinYt704lie Pfficb,,ortiie tityj Clerki Aland Wittil ai OtfoOk'4614600 for, eaerii
lubbl,kiet;.;Pleasolnalceible;obeet(e) payable to tiie,Cor,,et Miami Beeck
. . .
For City'Clerk's Office'Use;Only •
MCR,ik
Artiotift paid: bete paid:
Processed nyi, _ .„ , . Date:.. .. .. .. . .
P'..ACLERISALLCaFORMSAILOBEIY16tFOttIVS'WiNUALLOBBY(St•REGIStRATION.k)Fkrvi reg.docx
• Miscellaneous.Cash Receipt
CITY OF MIAMI BEACH . o- No 431296
❑Cash p Credit Card r Check#`�
•
\ ! `' -2, � ,1 d.t ,TFtf•-� .'~~.. F" ?,-, ,:.,..I " xra:., ��l.a �a
Received of•
Address
For
II
• Miscepaneous MCR7.,,2023
2 a i, ,;4 • b..+" o . 2121203_01:0Pn3: .r .. 005977 0014Adnan.V: .08
Payment Amount 850 00
(TH'ffIS INFORMATION MUST BE CO;;L",'!-:17,
D) Office of:'Finance Director
, ;,� ,-tdA t 1 b ' ,-. i
. • Account,number • By
• Prepare`r �k ` .> -. Dept . , EXTt '— 1,� ,
„: : ..., .. ...,., . ;,. i,,,
y .
: ,.:1
.'-',;1,;:'if: � :- a ,
, ,.:
2023 Item: MCR
1 @ 850.00
MCR OPEN (MCR) 850.00
•
850.00
Subtotal 850.00
Total 850.00 •
•
: CHECK 500.00
Check Number003760
350.00
CHECK
' Check Number003764
Change due 0,00
Paid by: LAW OFFICES OF AARON RESNICK,
P.A.
•
IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIUIIIIIIIV IIll IDVIII III
MO
• r —
a1ytl11t�laM,61
�::w v.w, —. m
•
-. 'aaRMtitm Fq • , �`' -./� J �.J