Loading...
Resolution 2024-33001 RESOLUTION NO i 2024-33001 A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, APPOINTING RICARDO J. DOPICO AS THE CITY ATTORNEY FOR THE CITY OF, MIAMI BEACH, AND AUTHORIZING THE CHAIR OF THE FINANCE AND ECONOMIC RESILIENCY COMMITTEE TO NEGOTIATE THE TERMS OF AN EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENT WITH MR. DOPICO, WHICH AGREEMENT WILL BE SUBJECT TO FINAL APPROVAL BY THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION. WHEREAS, on February 26, 2024, City Attorney Rafael A. Paz submitted a letter to the Mayor and City Commission advising the Commission of his decision to step down as City Attorney; and - WHEREAS, on March 13, 2024, following Mr. Paz's resignation notice, the City Commission initiated an internal selection process for a permanent City Attorney; and WHEREAS, on April 3, 2024, the City Commission unanimously appointed Deputy City Attorney Ricardo J. Dopico as Acting City Attorney until the expiration of Mr. Paz's employment agreement on May 3, 2024, following which Mr. Dopico will serve as City Attorney; and WHEREAS, the City Commission desires to provide certain benefits and to establish certain conditions of employment for Ricardo J. Dopico in his capacity as City Attorney(including the period of time when Mr. Dopico shall serve as Acting City Attorney, prior to the expiration of Mr. Paz's employment agreement); and WHEREAS, Mr. Dopico desires to accept the position of City Attorney for the term of the Employment Agreement. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT DULY RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, that the Mayor and City Commission hereby appoint Ricardo J. Dopico as the City Attorney for the City of Miami Beach, and authorize the Chair of the Finance and Economic Resiliency Committee to negotiate the terms of an Employment Agreement with Mr. Dopico, which Agreement will be subject to final approval by the Mayor and City Commission. PASSED and ADOPTED this I day of kri i , 2024. ATTEST: teven Meiner, Mayor APR 1 6 2024 APPROVED AS TO 4. 18"'" 11'.. FORM &LANGUAGE Rafael . Granado City Clerk &FOR EXECUTION 5 1111(ORtItATOk g • pc aldta.940; 4 tali h1 RC t, City Attorney Date New Business and Commission Requests - R9 AG_ MIAMI BEACH COMMISSION MEMORANDUM TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Commission FROM: Alina T. Hudak, City Manager DATE: April 3, 2024 SUBJECT: DISCUSSION AND TAKE ACTION REGARDING THE SELECTION PROCESS FOR THE APPOINTMENT OF THE CITYATTORNEY. RECOMMENDATION Pursuant to Commission direction, recruitment was completed and is submitted for Commission consideration. BACKGROUND/HISTORY As directed at the March 13, 2024 Commission meeting, the Human Resources department proceeded with the internal recruitment for the City Attorney position. The posting for the position was advertised on the City's website on March 14, 2024. The advertisement closed on March 22, 2024. We received two applications for the position. These two applicants are Ricardo Dopico, Deputy City Attorney, and Robert Rosenwald, Chief Deputy City Attorney. The applications and resumes were emailed to the Mayor and City Commissioners on March 22, 2024, and are attached for your reference. If a candidate is appointed at the April 3, 2024 City Commission meeting, the appointee would serve as Acting City Attorney effective immediately, until City Attorney Paz's departure date. With respect to the proposed employment agreement for the new City Attorney, historically, the City Commission has delegated to the Chair of the Finance and Economic Resiliency Committee ("FERC")the task of reviewing each new Charter Officer's proposed compensation and terms, subject to final approval by the Mayor and City Commission. If the City Commission desires for Commissioner Magazine, the current FERC Chairperson, to review and negotiate the proposed employment agreement terms with the new City Attorney, the proposed agreement would be drafted following such discussions with FERC Chairperson Magazine and placed on the May 15, 2024 City Commission agenda for final review and approval. SUPPORTING SURVEY DATA N/A FINANCIAL INFORMATION N/A Page 1338 of 1445 Applicable Area Citywide Is this a "Residents Right Does this item utilize G.O. to Know" item, pursuant to Bond Funds? City Code Section 2-14? Yes No Strategic Connection Non-Applicable Legislative Tracking Human Resources ATTACHMENTS: Description D Applications and Resumes Page 1339 of 1445 Ricardo Dopico Person ID:57319019.SSN:us-ex-5310 Received:3117/24 922 PM EMPLOYMENT APPLICATION CITY OF MIAMI BEACH Received: 3/17/24 9:22 1700 Convention Center Drive 3rd Floor PM -- - - - Miami-Beach, Florida 33139 For Official Use Only: MIAMI BEACH 305-673-7524 DNQ: httD:!/www.miamibeachfl.aov QUAL: DNQ a Experience Dopico, Ricardo J. 0Training• 02147 CITY ATTORNEY 0Other: I T ii; ! , :-1 4 ".,F NAL.INIEORMA71O :.:: _ . .... .... POSITION TITLE: EXAM ID#: • CITY ATTORNEY 02147 • 'NAME:(Last,First, Middle) 'SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER: Dopico,Ricardo J. ADDRESS: (Street,Cit State/Province,Zip Postal Code) EMAIL ADDRESS: ricardodopico@miamibeachfl.gov iOYF TICATIbfk (PERENCE: • ` HOM�P�OI� � IREF • Email DRIVER'S LICENSE: DRIVER'S LICENSE: LEGAL-RIGHT TO WORK IN THE UNITED STATES? • Yes a No State: FL Number. • Yes D No What is your highest level of education? Doctorate MINIMUM COMPENSATION: ARE YOU WILLING TO RELOCATE? $168.27 per hour; $350,000.00 per year aYes D No ■Maybe • IAft1(AT TYPE OF JOB ARE OU LOOKING FOR? • Regular TYPES OF WORK YOU WILL ACCEPT: Full Time SHIFTS YOU WILL ACCEPT: Day,Evening _ OBJECTIVE: My primary objective is to provide,and to inspire the entire legal team at the Office to continue offering,superior legal services to the • Mayor,Commissioners,City Manager, City departments and all City boards and committees, consistent with the goals and policy objectives of the City Commission. I intend to strengthen our already stellar legal team and to develop a cross-training program to ensure redundancy for key positions. . f ,` y - i,"�! tui .k "usr...- • .- _r. ,..; :cr.,. . ••: _.'- .• Y�TiQki..•..... - .... .._. v.-n.__. - ... ..._...._ ..1. r. _", DATES: SCHOOL NAME: From: 9/1991 To: 6/1994 Harvard Law School LOCATIONZCity,State/Province) DID YOU GRADUATE? DEGREE RECEIVED: Cambridge, Massachusetts •Yes DNo Professional -MAJOR: UNITS COMPLETED: Juris Doctor 6-Semester DATES: SCHOOL NAME: From: 9/1985 To: 6/1989 Harvard College •- 'LOCATION:(aty,State Province DID YOU GRADUATE? — DEGREE RECEIVED: Cambridge, Massachusetts •Yes allo Professional MAJOR: UNITS COMPLETED: A.B. 8-Semester • _ ..r_A.• _.. _ �_�xIIl11�IC EXP)= ICE r i - �':.=�a:-=:��:.�r..-...:�. .._..� I ...g. ._ ..,;. - - . -.., . '* •fie. .. " _. :...._. .__..: : .. ,. _. .._.. DATES: . EMPLOYER: POSITION TITLE: From: 12/2021 To: Present City of Miami Beach Deputy City Attorney ADDRESS: (Street, City,State/Province,Zip/Postal Code) COMPANY URL: 1700 Convention Center Drive,Miami Beach, Florida, 33139 www.miamibeachfl.gov PHONE NUMBER: . SUPERVISOR: • 3056737000 Rafael Paz-City Attorney HO1�RS PER WEEK: SALARY: #OF EMPLOYEES SUPERVISED: 40 $22,187.95/month 13 DUTIES: Lead transactional attorney for and legal advisor to all City Departments,including the Office of Capital Improvements, Public Works, Facilities and Fleet Management, Economic Development, Procurement, Parks and Recreation,Tourism and Culture, Human Resources, and Finance. * Brief the Mayor and Commissioners on complex transactions and other matters. * Collaborate with the Office of the City Manager and Department Directors on negotiations with City contractors,vendors and other stakeholders and presentation of items at Commission and Committee meetings. * Participate in meetings with residents and neighborhood associations regarding matters of special concern. * Negotiate and draft documents memorializing any complex legal transactions, including development agreements, leases;concession Page 1340 of 1445 Ricardo Dopico Person ID:57319019,SSN:xxx-xx-5310 Received:3/17124 9:22 PM agreements,license agreements,settlement agreements,easements,design-build agreements,construction agreements, professional services agreements,sponsorship agreements, management agreements,employment agreements and grant agreements. * Draft agenda items for Commission and Committee meetings, including resolutions,ordinances,memoranda,and referrals. *Advise Department Directors and City staff with pre-litigation communications and settlement negotiations for large construction and public.works projects. _ . * Review procurement documents for legal compliance and sufficiency and respond to bid protests. *Advise City staff and Inspector General with contract interpretation and enforcement. * Direct outside counsel on transactional and litigation matters,including bond issuances by the City and the City Center Redevelopment Agency. *Assist City Attorney with budgetary matters, including reviewing and approving all expenditures. * Represent the Finance and Economic Resiliency Committee and the Ad Hoc North Beach Community Redevelopment Agency Advisory Committee, review meeting agendas, and attend and participate in meetings. _ a DATES: EMPLOYER: POSITION TITLE: From: 7/2000 To: 12/2021 Estefan Enterprises,Inc. Vice President and General Counsel ADDRESS: (Street,City,State/Province,Zip/Postal Code) COMPANY URL: 420 Jefferson Avenue, Miami Beach, Florida,33139 www.estefan.com PHONE NUMBER: I-SUPERVISOR: MAY WE CONTACT THIS EMPLOYER? 3056957000 Emilio Estefan/Gloria Estefan-Chairman of •Yes allo . the Board/Vice President and Board Member HOURS PER WEEK: SALARY: #OF EMPLOYEES SUPERVISED: 40 $20,833.33/month 4 DUTIES: Responsible for the operations of the Business and Legal Affairs Department for every Estefan family line of business,including hospitality (hotels, restaurants),real estate,and entertainment. *Led all business and personal legal matters for Gloria and Emilio Estefan and their family, including personal services agreements, organization and maintenance of all operating companies,financial transactions, and security matters. d * Negotiated and drafted agreements related to various investments including real estate,cosmetics and an NFL team. *Managed the exploitation and protection of Estefan brands and other intellectual property valued in excess of$500 million. *Negotiated and drafted construction loan agreements,design professional agreements,and owner- contractor agreements for all construction projects. * Responsible for government relations(regulatory permitting, concessions and other matters). . * Performed Human Resources function across every Estefan business and/or project(including domestic staff). Developed, trained, and advised on all employment policies, and collaborated with field managers to ensure compliance in all areas of labor and employment law. *Oversaw corporate governance and regulatory compliance efforts across all lines of business. * Provided legal support to the board of trustees of The Gloria Estefan Foundation. *Teamed with risk management consultants and brokers to obtain the most cost-effective insurance coverages(both commercial and personal Tines)and supervised claims processing. REASON FOR LEAVING: To work in the public sector. • DATES: EMPLOYER: POSITION TITLE: From: 8/1998 To: 7/2000 Recording Industry Association of America Vice President,Latin Music ADDRESS: (Street,City,State/Province, Zip/Postal Code) 'COMPANY URL: 1 1025 F St NW, 10th Floor,Washington, District of Columbia, 20004 www.riaa.com PHONE NUMBER: SUPERVISOR: • MAY WE CONTACT THIS EMPLOYER? ] 2027750101 Hillary Rosen-President and CEO •Yes 0No 9 HOURS PER WEEK: SALARY: # OF EMPLOYEES SUPERVISED: -1 40 ' $10,000.00/month 2 DUUTIES: * Launched the Association's Latin-focused office. . * Liaised between the Association and the U.S. Latin divisions of Sony, Warner,Universal, BMG, EMI and numerous independent labels. *Acted as Association's media spokesperson on industry issues and handled-artist relations. REASON FOR LEAVING: I was recruited to become the General Counsel for Estefan Enterprises. . DATES: : EMPLOYER: POSITION TITLE: From: 9/1994 To: 7/1998 Steel Hector&Davis LLP Associate ADDRESS: (Street, City,State/Province, Zip/Postal Code) Miami, Florida . --SUPERVISOR: MAY WE CONTACT THIS EMPLOYER? - Joseph W. Pallot-Partner oyes ■No HOURS PER WEEK: : #OF E 4FLOYEES SUPERVISED: . 40 ' 1 ' DUTIES: Tax and Commercial Divisions *Represented publicly traded and private companies In various industries(e.g., healthcare, energy, professional employment organizations, family office)in the areas of public and private debt and equity financings,SEC reporting and compliance,mergers and acquisitions, executive compensation,corporate governance and operational support. *Negotiated and drafted principal and ancillary project documents for multiple transactions, including for an international joint venture petrochemicals project with investment totaling more than$1 billion. * Drafted estate planning documents for resident and non-resident clients,including wills, trusts, irrevocable life insurance trusts and powers of attorney. BAR MEMBERSHIP Florida Bar:Admitted 1995, Bar No, 52050. Page 1341 of 1445 Ricardo Dopico Person ID:57319019.SSN:xxx-ex-5310 Received:3/17124 9:22 PM [REASON FORTEA ING: I left Steel Hector&Davis to pursue an opportunity with the Recording Industry Association of America. During my tenure there,Steel Hector&Davis was one of the"big three" law firms in the State of Florida.A few years after my departure,the firm significantly contracted due to the departure of many partners and associates.It was eventually acquired by Squire Sanders&Dempsey (now Squire Patton Boggs).The reason you may not contact this employe�r.�+Is that the firm_ no longer exists.,__ ___.. _ RTI AND LIGrENSES;;• _.. . „-.. . .. . I TYPE: - _._ ..._.__. ..._ . Bar Membership LICENSE NUMBER: ISSUING AGENCY: - 0052050 Florida Bar .wt.i:,i,,,,.:.7.[,!_,, sk OFFICE SKILLS: Typing: i Data Entry: LL OTHER SKILLS: LANGUAGE(S): ' French- • Speak ■ Read • Write Spanish- ■ Speak ■ Read • Write ir-t,ri:-.ram s -•r• ; OMONAt4NgOR1 1t0 , - Nothing Entered For This Section , S=c.&i- :i•,Y a� iy, . ..,.� :.}. ... -?r!e--iREif��NCE5:1 ... , ... .. � REFERENCE TYPE: NAME: POSITION: Professional Rafael Paz City Attorney ADDRESS: (Street,City,State/Province,Zip/Postal bode) 1700 Convention Center Drive, Miami Beach, Florida 33139 • EMAIL ADDRESS: PHONE NUMBER: rafaelpaz@miamibeachfi.gov 3057941793 i R�EFERENCE TYPE: NAME: POSITION: Professional ' Ruben Diaz Partner ADDRESS: (Street,City,State/Province, Zip/Postal Code) d 2 South Biscayne Boulevard,Suite 1900, Miami, Florida 33131 ' Y - EMAIL ADDRESS: PHONE NUMBER: ruben.diaz@foley.com 3056690901 REVERENCE TYPE: NAME: POSITION: Professional ' Abigail Watts Fitzgerald Principal . ADDRESS: (Street,City, State/Province, Zip/Postal Code) 2800 Ponce De Leon Blvd.,Coral Gables, Florida 33134 EMAIL ADDRESS: PHONE NUMBER: awf@wattsfitz-law.com 3059788521 REFERENCE TYPE: NAME: POSITION: Personal Curtis Miner ADDRESS: (Street, City,StateTProvince,Zip/Posta(Code) 5952 SW 102 Street, Miami, Florida 33156 EMAIL ADDRESS: - PHONE NUMBER: curt@colson.com 3059052970 REFERENCE TYPE: a NAME: POSITION: , ' Personal , Tania Dominguez ADDRESS: (Street,City,State/Province,Zip/Postal Code) 5952 SW 102 Street, Miami, Florida 33156 EMAIL ADDRESS: PHONE NUMBER: tdominguez@cisneros.com 3052057666 REFERENCE TYPE: NAME: POSITION: Professional Anne Estevez , ADDRESS: (Street,City, State/Province, Zip/Postal Code) 600 Brickell Ave,Ste 1600,Miami, Florida 33131 _ SAIL ADDRESS: PHONE NUMBER: ...aestevez@morganlewis.com 7862992256 Page 1342 of 1445 Ricardo Dopico Person RD:57319019,SSN:nu-Jut-5310 Received:311724922 PM Agency-Wide questions 1. Referral Source(Check only one [1]) City Employee Do you wish to claim Veterans' Preference?Please note that disclosure is voluntary,it is pursuant to Veterans Preference law,bonus points are added if applicable,information will be kept confidential in accordance with the ADA. it will be used only for ADA permitted purposes and refusal to disclose will not subject you to any adverse treatment. 2. For eligibility requirements,please visit http://www.floridavets.org/benefits/veteranspref.asp If you are claiming Veterans'Preference,it is your responsibility to submit documentation(DD 214 form,Member 4)sustaining your claim at the time of application.If you are claiming disability,a letter from the Florida Department of Veteran's Affairs or Department of Defense indicating your service-connected disability is required.PLEASE ATTACH APPROPRIATE DOCUMENTS TO YOUR APPLICATION. No If claiming Veterans'Preference,please indicate which category you are claiming.Under the State of Florida Veterans' Preference Law,preference In appointment shall be given by the State of Florida and its political subdivisions to those 3. persons in categories 1 and 2 and then to those in categories 3 and 4.If you are claiming Veterans' Preference,it is your responsibility to submit documentation(DD 214 form,Member 4)sustaining your claim at the time of application.If you are claiming disability,a letter from the Florida Department of Veteran's Affairs or Department of Defense indicating your service-connected disability is required.PLEASE ATTACH APPROPRIATE DOCUMENTS TO YOUR APPLICATION. The City of Miami Beach shall provide reasonable accommodations,due to any disability,for all applicants and 4. employees.Will you require any special accommodations prior to any test(s) and/or interviews for which you may be selected? No 5. Are you a current or previous City of Miami Beach employee? Yes • If you answered"Yes"to the previous question,please provide the following information:whether you are current or 6. previous employee of the City,current/previous classification(position),current/previous department/division;if already separated,year and reason for separation. When I was hired in December 2021,I was a First Assistant City Attorney. I was promoted to my current position as a Deputy City Attorney in April 2022. 7. Are you related to any City of Miami Beach employee(s)? No B. If you answered"Yes"to previous question,please provide the following information:employee's name,title, department/division,relationship to you. 9. May we contact your present employer regarding your record of employment? Yes 10. Are you currently a subject of any criminal or ethics investigation by any governmental agency?If so,please explain the nature of the investigation;otherwise,put"N/A." N/A 11. Are you a City of Miami Beach resident? No • Page 1343 of 1445 Ricardo Doptoo Person ID:57319019,SSN:xxx-xx-5310 Received:3/1724 922 PM )ob Soecific Supplemental Ouestions 1. Are you licensed to practice law in the State of Florida and be a member of The Florida Bar? Yes 2. Do you have senior level local government experience in a medium to large,complex urban setting in Florida,with experience as a government attorney in South Florida? Yes 3. Are you eligible to practice law in the State of Florida and in good standing with the Florida Bar? Yes 4. Do you have a Juris Doctor degree from an accredited school of law? Yes 5. Do you have prior experience representing a public entity in the State of Florida? Yes 6. I acknowledge that I am In good standing with all City policies including attendance and performance. Yes The following terms were accepted by the applicant upon submitting the online application: City of Miami Beach Social Security Number Collection Disclosure Statement:Pursuant to Section 119.071(5)(a), Florida Statutes, your social security number is requested for the purpose of employment identification and verification,determining eligibility for employment, the processing of city benefits,verification of benefits, income reporting,other purposes related to processing hiring,compensation, benefits or employment functions,credit worthiness, billing and payments,data collection, reconciliation, tracking,tax reporting,and identification and verification of business licenses and determining eligibility for business licenses. Your social security number will be used solely for one or more of these purposes. I hereby CONSENT for any duly authorized representative of the City of Miami Beach Police Department or Human Resources Department or Representative bearing this release or a copy thereof to obtain any information or records from persons,corporations,agencies, associations, institutions or organizations as may be relevant and necessary to determine my fitness and suitability for employment consideration with the City of Miami Beach. Such information and records may include, but are not limited to,those pertaining to abilities, affiliations,character, credit and finances,education,employment,family, insurance,judicial and law enforcement records, memberships, mental health, military, and motor vehicle operation and traffic history. I hereby AUTHORIZE and direct you to release such information and records upon request to bearer.This authorization is executed with full knowledge and understanding that: (1)Records and Information disclosed shall be for official evaluation of my employment application by the City of Miami Beach and are used as selection criteria ONLY where related to performance of the job(s)for which I have applied. (2)The City of Miami Beach will take measures to protect the aforementioned information and records against unauthorized disclosure. (3)Certain non-exempt portions of the background investigation process may be made available for inspection by third parties pursuant to the public records and other laws. (4)The City of Miami Beach can and may investigate the information and records mentioned above at any point in my employment with the City of Miami Beach,as a part of a disciplinary investigation; to confirm that I meet the minimum requirements of the position I am in; for purposes of conducting an updated background investigation when being considered for a change in my employment status/classification;or as deemed necessary by the City of Miami Beach for any legitimate purposes. I hereby RELEASE the custodian of such records, including the'City of Miami Beach and aforementioned persons,corporations,agencies, associations, institutions, organizations,and their employees,agents,and representatives, both individually and collectively, from any and all liability for damages by me, my heirs,family,or associates resulting from lawful compliance or any attempts at lawful compliance with this authorization, except for any damages resulting from knowingly providing false or misleading information or records about me.I certify that all of the Information on this application and on any documents I have submitted is true, accurate and complete to the best of my knowledge. I understand that all information and documents are subject to investigation and that exaggeration,falsification, misrepresentation,or omission is sufficient cause for disqualification,immediate dismissal from the City Service and/or disqualification from applying for any position in the service of the City of Miami Beach. I also certify that I understand all information on the job announcement and that this application and accompanying documents are considered to be public records unless otherwise exempt under Chapter 119, Florida Statutes. The City of Miami Beach is an equal opportunity/drug free employer and does not discriminate on the basis of an individual's race, sex, condition related to sex (pregnancy),color,religion,national origin,age(40 and over),genetic information, disability, marital status,familial status,citizenship, intending citizenship status and/or sexual orientation. No persons shall be denied employment solely on the basis of their disability,and the City will make every reasonable effort to accommodate such disability in the work setting.The above factors are NOT used as selection criteria,except in the rare instance where such factors are bona fide occupational qualifications.The above information may be used,however as identification factors in conducting the background investigation. Information and records,such as those listed in the "AUTHORIZATION AND RELEASE"form,will be obtained by letter,telephone,personal interview with primary and secondary sources,and other means as deemed necessary and appropriate. I understand that I will/may be scheduled for appointments for a physical examination, polygraph,or other background procedures. I UNDERSTAND THAT I MUST ATTEND THE INITIAL APPOINTMENT SCHEDULED FOR MY MEDICAL EXAMINATION,AND I MUST RETURN IN TWO DAYS FOR A FOLLOW UP EXAMINATION. I FURTHER UNDERSTAND THAT IF I DO NOT ATTEND MY APPOINTMENT(S)AS SCHEDULED,THAT I AM DECLINING ANY INTEREST IN EMPLOYMENT WITH THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH. I understand and acknowledge that my employment is contingent upon my successfully completing all background and medical processing. I understand that it is my responsibility to keep my address and telephone number(s) updated with the Human Resources Department. If I cannot be contacted, I may forfeit my eligibility for employment. FOR CURRENT CITY EMPLOYEES:I further understand that if I am applying for a promotion within the City that my continued employment and promotion is contingent upon my meeting (1)the background requirements for my current position and (2)any additional background requirements for any new classification. The information and records obtained are used as selection criteria only where related to performance of the job for which I have applied and am being considered. I CERTIFY THAT ALL THE INFORMATION ON THIS DOCUMENT IS TRUE,ACCURATE,AND COMPLETE TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE. I understand that City employees are expected to adhere to all applicable Federal,State and Local laws, regulations, ordinances, policies, rules, procedures, and any other governing document regarding the responsibilities described in the job description for the position I am applying for. I FURTHER CERTIFY THAT I HAVE READ AND UNDERSTOOD THIS EXPLANATION AND THE JOB DESCRIPTION FOR THE POSITION I AM APPLYING FOR.AND THAT I AM ABLE TO PERFORM THE ESSENTIAL FUNCTIONS OF THE CLASSIFICATION I AM Page 1344 of 1445 Ricardo Dopico Person ID:57319019.SSN:mix-ex-5310 Received:3/17/24 9:22 PM APPLYING FOR,WITH OR WITHOUT ACCOMMODATIONS. This application was submitted by Rlcardo J. Dopico on 3/17/24 9:22 PM Signature Date Page 1345 of 1445 Ricardo J. Dopico RicardoDopico@miamibeachfl.gov PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE City of Miami Beach, Miami Beach, Florida Deputy City Attorney December 2021 — Present Lead transactional attorney for and legal advisor to all City Departments, including the Office of Capital Improvements, Public Works, Facilities and Fleet Management, Economic Development, Procurement, Parks and Recreation, Tourism and Culture, Human Resources, and Finance. • Brief the Mayor and Commissioners on complex transactions and other matters. • Collaborate with the Office of the City Manager and Department Directors on negotiations with City contractors, vendors and other stakeholders and presentation of items at Commission and Committee meetings, • Participate in meetings with residents and neighborhood associations regarding matters of special concern. • Negotiate and draft documents memorializing any complex legal transactions, including development agreements, leases, concession agreements, license agreements, settlement agreements, easements, design-build agreements, construction agreements, professional services agreements, sponsorship agreements, management agreements, employment agreements and grant agreements. • Draft agenda items for Commission and Committee meetings, including resolutions, ordinances, memoranda, and referrals. • Advise Department Directors and City staff with pre-litigation communications and settlement negotiations for large construction and public works projects. • Review procurement documents for legal compliance and sufficiency and respond to bid protests. • Advise City staff and Inspector General with contract interpretation and enforcement. • Direct outside counsel on transactional and litigation matters, including bond issuances by the City and the City Center Redevelopment Agency. • Assist City Attorney with budgetary matters, including reviewing and approving all expenditures. Represent the Finance and Economic Resiliency Committee and the Ad Hoc North Beach Community Redevelopment Agency Advisory Committee, review meeting agendas,and attend and participate in meetings. Estefan Enterprises, Inc., Miami Beach, Florida Vice President and General Counsel July 2000—December 2021 Responsible for the operations of the Business and Legal Affairs Department for every Estefan family line of business, including hospitality(hotels, restaurants), real estate, and entertainment. • Led all business and personal legal matters for Gloria and Emilio Estefan and their family, including personal services agreements, organization and maintenance of all operating companies, financial transactions, and security matters. • Negotiated and drafted agreements related to various investments including real estate, cosmetics and an NFL team. • Managed the exploitation and protection of Estefan brands and other intellectual property valued in excess of$500 million. Page 1346 of 1445 • Negotiated and drafted construction loan agreements, design professional agreements, and owner-contractor agreements for all construction projects. __ • Responsible for government relations (regulatory permitting, concessions and other matters). • Performed Human Resources function across every Estefan business and/or project (including domestic staff). Developed, trained, and advised on all employment policies, and collaborated with field managers to ensure compliance in all areas of labor and employment law. • Oversaw corporate governance and regulatory compliance efforts across all lines of business. • Provided legal support to the board of trustees of The Gloria Estefan Foundation. • Teamed with risk management consultants and brokers to obtain the most cost-effective insurance coverages (both commercial and personal lines) and supervised claims processing. Page 1347 of 1445 Ricardo J. Dopico Page 2 of 2 Recording Industry Association of America, Miami, Florida August 1998—July 2000 Vice President, Latin Music • Launched the Association's Latin-focused office. • Liaised between the Association and the U.S. Latin divisions of Sony, Warner, Universal, BMG, EMI and numerous independent labels. • Acted as Association's media spokesperson on industry issues and handled artist relations. Steel Hector&Davis LLP, Miami, Florida September 1994—July 1998 Associate(Tax and Commercial Divisions) • Represented publicly traded and private companies in various industries (e.g., healthcare, energy, professional employment organizations, family office) in the areas of public and private debt and equity financings, SEC reporting and compliance, mergers and acquisitions, executive compensation, corporate governance and operational support. • Negotiated and drafted principal and ancillary project documents for multiple transactions, including for an international joint venture petrochemicals project with investment totaling more than $1 billion. • Drafted estate planning documents for resident and non-resident clients, including wills, trusts, irrevocable life insurance trusts and powers of attorney. BAR MEMBERSHIP Florida Bar:Admitted 1995, Bar No. 52050. EDUCATION Harvard Law School, Cambridge, Massachusetts J.D. cum laude June 1994 Activities and Distinctions: Harvard International Law Journal, Sports and Entertainment Law Committee and La Alianza. Harvard College, Cambridge, Massachusetts A.B. magna cum laude June 1989 Activities and Distinctions: Classical piano, theatrical production, Committee on Latin American and Iberian Studies, John Harvard Scholarship, Harvard College Scholarship. LANGUAGES • Fully Bilingual(English/Spanish) • Proficient in French INTERESTS • Weightlifting • Hiking • Classical piano Page 1348 of 1445 Robert Rosenwald Person ID:8077400,SSN:xxx4=r-7153 Received:3/20/24 9:47 AM . , .. . . EMPLOYMENT APPLICATION CITY OF MIAMI BEACH Received: 3/20/24 9:47 1700 Convention Center Drive 3rd Floor AM - - -- Miami Beach,Florida 33139 for_Official Use Only: AA I AM I BEACH 305-673-7524 htto://www.miamibeachfl.00v QUAL: DNQ: o Experience • . Rosenwald, Robert F. °Training 02147 CITY ATTORNEY •_ a Other: ... . , _ . .. . 013.6:.. .; gi. 4 ' i:: ''''::';4'gilfeiff-TIT0411,1914414tifORIAT.Pak!ii ',- ;t,U1-'i:'.-,:-.-:::, •••'',:VF]i2it POSITION TITLE: EXAM ID#: CITY ATTORNEY 02147 • NAME: (Last, First,Middles SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER: • Rosenwald, Robert F. d111=11111=1.1111 , - ADDRESS: (Street, City,State/Province,Zip/PostarCoae) EMAIL ADDRESS: 4.11111001M111••••11 : HOME PHONE: --'--"' NOTIFICA.-dON PREFERENCE: . . .. .. . 1111.111111111111111•1 Email DRIVER'S LICENSE: D ER S CEN E: ------ -LEGAL RIGHT TO WORK IN THE UNITED STATES? I •Yes D No State: FL Number:1111.1.111111.1m 111 Yes ° No . • What is your highest evel of education? Doctorate _. 3'.::24CPg4iligiii..ii:-.:.St.40ing(gglig4f.'.-,1.;1, ..:::j.!•;";;''' ;!..-:.-- !'; :.'.-: ' ':i.5L:K.-::!',t.f:•!:-f':f44-i'f.iii':i3t-qiis..;,. . -.11 ARE YOU WILLING TO RELOCATE? IlYes °No °Maybe kilAT iY13t OF SOBARE',1611LOOKING-Poit? Regular . . TYPES OF WORK YOU WILL ACCEPT: Full Time • . . . . SHIFTS You WILL ACCEPT: , - Day • _. . ., OBJECTIVE: Effectively serve the City of Miami Beach as the next City Attorney. .. .,.... .. . . .. . _... . .,.. _.„. --:•P,rgii-1, .';,.:=P!;!!,: ,i.:ii;•i:4.ili:Vii:',g;ii;;Sair. C1,i'ii,''..-•'•:'S:Nli :::F;-,Pi...................................................................?,..-,: '-:7.,:(,:;' ,..',-:, '"',,:?!:iill..4-r,":,',elii,,:iiiiitzK:j:Tic,;P.,t;i5r:.i;;Ti:iiii• DATES: ' Saii3t3e1VAME: From: 9/1994 To: 5/1997 ' University of Pittsburgh School of Law LOtAtIOiki:(tity,Slai.e/Province) . -•6tb You GRADUATEf I DEGREE RECEIVED: Pittsburgh , Pennsylvania IlYes °No Doctorate — . MAJOR: .. ........ . ....... . ..„... ........___.... .. . Law . . • ... „ ... ...., , . .„ _. .. . . : DATES: - EMPLOYER: POSITION TITLE: From: 11/2005 To: 3/2010 : ACLU of Florida Director, LGBT Advocacy Project -, ADDRESS: (Street, City, State/Province, Zip/Postal Cock) '-... .. Miami, Florida 'MAY WEtONTACT THIS EMPLOYER? : -- -"... ".. ...-- - . .. - - - •Yes allo HOURS PER WEEK: SALARY: #OF EMPLOYEES SUPERVISED: 40 $5,500.00/month 2 .. . .., . . DUTIES: • litigation ........................................................................................................................................:'-;::".,--•:::!:,•:-,-;-.:;•; :?.-:.::•:•.<:-,LT: t: i7:.tirttit.t. :zi,,,.,p, 71 TYPE: Pennsylvania Bar License 1-LICENSE NUMBER: 'ISSUING AGENCY: Pennsylvania Bar TYPE: Florida Bar License LICENSE NUMBER: ISSUING AGENCY: 190039 • Florida Bar . . . - :: :i;::'-ii:'4 .iii'6!.!ia7::';•;E;;:li::: i',,;-'4, ,'.::;E!''''.:.'.-":2.•::.:T,':..:•:'.:::,;.;;;:s.D1: 1-:;,-,V,:q•ii.,::.Z.ii;!gi.70041, !:,t::,i;:-:-',.;:,;;i:7„,..!.. i.,,,•::•:.,-• :,... ..:.. ..,::.,,"....,.,:ii:i,i,,;,i: :, ,i0::,-, 1414;-,z:•.I.-,'',:!•; Nothing Entered For This Section •- - •- - -- • - , . _ ... ..... . ........._. . . .....___. .. . . „ .. " ' -•"• ' - . -•••!.'.:2Y: -,!::':.'=!"';Q _:.. ;:--:: ,4 :':.;:•"; TIPN-.:',-, •,• : •'•;:1•' . : ' ;':;:;j"!iq. .;;..,:•j,i-:.r:R,,:.:,i:..!i::: :' :.:1 Page 1349 of 1445 Robert Rosenwald Person ID:8077400,SSN:xxx-xx-7153 Received:32024 9:47 AM { Nothing Entered For This Section I # C Jt,� . - REFERENCE TYPE: K ra :I NAME: POSITION Professional Stephen Urice ADDRESS: (Street, City, State/Province, Zip/Postal Code) 'EMAIL ADDRESS:. PHONE R: (215) 681-8833 • • Page 1350 of 1445 Robert Rosenwald Person ID:8077400,SSN:um-m-7153 Received:32024 9:47 AM Agency-Wide Ouestions 1. Referral Source(Check only one[1]) Other Do you wish to claim Veterans`Preference?Please note that disclosure is voluntary,it is pursuant to Veterans Preference law,bonus points are added if applicable,information will be kept confidential in accordance with the ADA. it will be used only for ADA permitted purposes and refusal to disclose will not subject you to any adverse treatment. 2. For eligibility requirements,please visit http://www.floridavets.org/benefits/veteranspref,asp If you are claiming Veterans'Preference,it is your responsibility to submit documentation(DD 214 form, Member 4)sustaining your claim at the time of application.If you are claiming disability,a letter from the Florida Department of Veteran's Affairs or Department of Defense indicating your service-connected disability is required.PLEASE ATTACH APPROPRIATE DOCUMENTS TO YOUR APPLICATION. If claiming Veterans'Preference,please indicate which category you are claiming.Under the State of Florida Veterans' Preference Law,preference in appointment shall be given by the State of Florida and its political subdivisions to those 3. persons in categories 1 and 2 and then to those in categories 3 and 4.If you are claiming Veterans'Preference,it is your responsibility to submit documentation(DD 214 form,.Member 4)sustaining your claim at the time of application.If you are claiming disability,a letter from the Florida Department of Veteran's Affairs or Department of Defense indicating your service-connected disability is required.PLEASE ATTACH APPROPRIATE DOCUMENTS TO YOUR APPLICATION. The City of Miami Beach shall provide reasonable accommodations,due to any disability,for all applicants and 4. employees.Will you require any special accommodations prior to any test(s) and/or Interviews for which you may be selected? S. Are you a current or previous City of Miami Beach employee? Yes If you answered"Yes"to the previous question,please provide the following information:whether you are current or 6. previous employee of the City,current/previous classification(position),current/previous department/division;if already separated,year and reason for separation. Current Chief Deputy City Attorney 7. Are you related to any City of Miami Beach employee(s)? 8. If you answered"Yes"to previous question, please provide the following information:employee's name,title, department/division,relationship to you. 9. May we contact your present employer regarding your record of employment? Yes 10. Are you currently a subject of any criminal or ethics investigation by any governmental agency?If so, please explain the nature of the investigation;otherwise,put"N/A." n/a 11. Are you a City of Miami Beach resident? No • • • • Page 1351 of 1445 Robert Rosenwald Person ID:8077400,SSN:na•xx-7153 Received:3/20/24 9:47 AM )ob Soecific Supplemental Questions 1. Are you licensed to practice law in the State of Florida and be a member of The Florida Bar? Yes 2. Do you have senior level local government experience in a medium to large,complex urban setting in Florida,with experience as a government attorney in South Florida? Yes 3. Are you eligible to practice law in the State of Florida and in good standing with the Florida Bar? Yes 4. Do you have a Juris Doctor degree from an accredited school of law? Yes 5. Do you have prior experience representing a public entity in the State of Florida? Yes 6. I acknowledge that I am in good standing with all City policies including attendance and performance. Yes The following terms were accepted by the applicant upon submitting the online application: City of Miami Beach Social Security Number Collection Disclosure Statement:Pursuant to Section 119.071(5)(a), Florida Statutes, your social security number Is requested for the purpose of employment identification and verification,determining eligibility for employment, the processing of city benefits,verification of benefits, income reporting, other purposes related to processing hiring,compensation, benefits or employment functions,credit worthiness,billing and payments,data collection, reconciliation,tracking,tax reporting, and identification and verification of business licenses and determining eligibility for business licenses.Your social security number will be used solely for one or more of these purposes. I hereby CONSENT for any duly authorized representative of the City of Miami Beach Police Department or Human Resources Department or Representative bearing this release or a copy thereof to obtain any information or records from persons, corporations,agencies,associations, institutions or organizations as may be relevant and necessary to determine my fitness and suitability for employment consideration with the City of Miami Beach. Such information and records may include, but are not limited to,those pertaining to abilities,affiliations,character, credit and finances,education,employment,family, insurance,judicial and law enforcement records, memberships, mental health, military, and motor vehicle operation and traffic history. I hereby AUTHORIZE and direct you to release such information and records upon request to bearer.This authorization is executed with full knowledge and understanding that: (1)Records and information disclosed shall be for official evaluation of my employment application by the City of Miami Beach and are used as selection criteria ONLY where related to performance of the job(s)for which I have applied. (2)The City of Miami Beach will take measures to protect the aforementioned information and records against unauthorized disclosure. (3)Certain non-exempt portions of the background investigation process may be made available for inspection by third parties pursuant to the public records and other laws. (4)The City of Miami Beach can and may investigate the information and records mentioned above at any point in my employment with the City of Miami Beach, as a part of a disciplinary investigation; to confirm that I meet the minimum requirements of the position I am in; for purposes of conducting an updated background investigation when being considered for a change in my employment status/classification; or as deemed necessary by the City of Miami Beach for any legitimate purposes. I hereby RELEASE the custodian of such records, including the City of Miami Beach and aforementioned persons,corporations, agencies, associations, institutions,organizations,and their employees,agents, and representatives, both individually and collectively,from any and all liability for damages by me,my heirs,family,or associates resulting from lawful compliance or any attempts at lawful compliance with this authorization,except for any damages resulting from knowingly providing false or misleading information or records about me.I certify that all of the information on this application and on any documents I have submitted is true,accurate and complete to the best of my knowledge. I understand that all information and documents are subject to investigation and that exaggeration, falsification,misrepresentation,or omission is sufficient cause for disqualification,immediate dismissal from the City Service and/or disqualification from applying for any position in the service of the City of Miami Beach.I also certify that I understand all information on the job announcement and that this application and accompanying documents are considered to be public records unless otherwise exempt under Chapter 119, Florida Statutes. The City of Miami Beach is an equal opportunity/drug free employer and does not discriminate on the basis of an individuals race, sex, condition related to sex(pregnancy),color, religion,national origin, age (40 and over),genetic information,disability, marital status,familial status,citizenship, intending citizenship status and/or sexual orientation. No persons shall be denied employment solely on the basis of their disability,and the City will make every reasonable effort to accommodate such disability in the work setting.The above factors are NOT used as selection criteria,except in the rare instance where such factors are bona fide occupational qualifications.The above information may be used, however,as identification factors in conducting the background investigation. Information and records,such as those listed in the "AUTHORIZATION AND RELEASE"form,will be obtained by letter,telephone, personal interview with primary and secondary sources, and other means as deemed necessary and appropriate. I understand that I will/may be scheduled for appointments for a physical examination, polygraph, or other background procedures.I UNDERSTAND THAT I MUST ATTEND THE INITIAL APPOINTMENT SCHEDULED FOR MY MEDICAL EXAMINATION,AND I MUST RETURN IN TWO DAYS FOR A FOLLOW UP EXAMINATION. I FURTHER UNDERSTAND THAT IF I DO NOT ATTEND MY APPOINTMENT(S)AS SCHEDULED,THAT I AM DECLINING ANY INTEREST IN EMPLOYMENT WITH THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH. I understand and acknowledge that my employment is contingent upon my successfully completing all background and medical processing. I understand that it Is my responsibility to keep my address and telephone number(s) updated with the Human Resources Department. If I cannot be contacted,I may forfeit my eligibility for employment. FOR CURRENT CITY EMPLOYEES: I further understand that if I am applying for a promotion within the City that my continued employment and promotion is contingent upon my meeting (1)the background requirements for my current position and (2)any additional background requirements for any new classification. The Information and records obtained are used as Selection criteria only where related to performance of the job for which I have applied and am being considered, I CERTIFY THAT ALL THE INFORMATION ON THIS DOCUMENT IS TRUE,ACCURATE, AND COMPLETE TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE. • I understand that City employees are expected to adhere to all applicable Federal, State and Local laws, regulations, ordinances, policies, rules, procedures,and any other governing document regarding the responsibilities described in the job description for the position I am applying for. I FURTHER CERTIFY THAT I HAVE READ AND UNDERSTOOD THIS EXPLANATION AND THE JOB DESCRIPTION FOR THE POSITION I AM APPLYING FOR.AND THAT I AM ABLE TO PERFORM THE ESSENTIAL FUNCTIONS OF THE CLASSIFICATION I AM Page 1352 of 1445 Robert Rosenwald Person 8077400.SSN:xxx-xx-7153 Received:3120124 9:47 AM APPLYING FOR,WITH OR WITHOUT ACCOMMODATIONS. This application was submitted by Robert F. Rosenwald on 3/20/24 9:47 AM Signature Date Page 1353 of 1445 ROBERT F.:ROSENWALD PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE Chief Deputy city Attorney City of Miami Beach 2010—Present Deputy City Attorney First Assistant City Attorney Senior Assistant City Attorney OVERVIEW: READY TO HIT THE GROUND RUNNING • Provide stability,continuity,and institutional knowledge gained from 13-year successful career advising four Mayors,three City Attorneys,and five City Managers(including two interim). • Manage City Attorney's Office team under the City Attorney. Leadership role in hiring and managing large staff of attorneys,paralegals,and assistants. • Lead City's legal strategy on conceptualizing and implementing City's cutting-edge public safety and resident protection legislation. ■ Draft, implement, and defend Mayor and City Commission's key legislation for every City department and discipline that contain inherent federal or constitutional concerns, shepherding ordinances through committees while developing defense strategies in anticipation of potential challenges. • Legal counsel to Public Safety and Neighborhood Quality of Life Committee since 2021, ensuring that legislative body observes Robert's Rules of Order while it complies with all applicable laws and ordinances. • Lead City's sophisticated litigation practice — personally litigated hundreds of City lawsuits leading to 130 published decisions and have led team of multiple lawyers in host of cases with successful results for 13 years. • Legal counsel to City in Labor negotiations and Labor relations to ensure compliance with Florida's Public Employees Relations Act and enforcement of City's management rights under applicable collective bargaining agreements. • Legal counsel to the Office of the Inspector General. • Resident expert on combatting state preemption claims for City Commission priorities. ■ Reputation for innovative legal strategies and cutting through bureaucracy to achieve City Commission's goals. • Pledge to use every means possible to defend the City's historic preservation efforts and prevent any - nuisance property owner from flaunting our rules through demolition by neglect. • Well-respected by City Commissioners,CAO staff, City departments, the legal community, and the public. Page 1354 of 1445 ROBERT F. ROSENWALD 1 RECENT ACHIEVEMENTS PROTECTING PUBLIC SAFETY AND RESIDENTS'QUALITY OF LIFE • 2024 Obstructing Street and Sidewalk Ordinance — Conceptualized the City's current, legally-sound legislation to prohibit blocking streets, sidewalks, and beach entrances by the homeless while limiting the time, place,and manner of political protests to areas where they will not block vehicle or pedestrian traffic. • 2023 Camping Ordinance—Led the strategy to enact the City's aggressive Camping Ordinance and properly train police officers on its implementation, while creating a compassionate pilot program to offer shelter and rehabilitation services at first appearance in municipal prosecution cases to offer homeless people the ability to obtain services and housing. • 2023 Nuisance House Lawsuit/Enforcement Court Strategy--Personally conceptualized and launched City's proactive nuisance house lawsuit/enforcement court strategy leading to consent decree, massive fines,and cessation of short-term rentals, commercial parties, and other nuisance activities at three multi-million- dollar party houses in high-end residential neighborhoods. • 2023 South of Fifth Alcohol Rollback—Led successful defense of Story Nightclub lawsuit,leading to the City's ability to enforce alcohol hours rollback in the SoFi neighborhood and resulting in the closure of that large nightclub in a residential neighborhood. • 2023 Federal Court Victory--Successfully defended City, Mayor, and City Manager in ACLU lawsuit arising out of Memorial Day actions by City Manager in McGriff v City of Miami Beach. • 2022 Reformed Sidewalk Café Program to Regain City Control-- Personally restructured the Sidewalk Café program, after adverse court ruling, to a contract-based model that allowed the City to take control and terminate bad operators,then successfully defended the new model in court against a challenge from those bad operators. • 2022 Spring Break Alcohol Emergency Order— Successfully led defense of March 2022 emergency order limiting alcohol sale hours against an emergency injunction challenge from package liquor store. • 2022 Spring Break Curfew--Led successful defense of emergency injunction proceeding in cases challenging the City's March 23, 2022 State of Emergency declaration and imposition of a weekend curfew for areas south of 23rd Street. The matter was the first emergency injunction hearing handled entirely in-house in many years. a 2018 SoFi Live Entertainment Ban — Conceptualized, drafted and successfully defended City's ban on live performances in the SoFi neighborhood in federal court. • Fighting Gambling-- Personally drafted City amicus brief opposing gambling in or near the City. • Drummers in South Pointe Park — Personally represented the City at shutdown of the SPP drum circle, resulting in peaceful end to drum circle without lawsuits or arrests. • Sex Trafficking of Minors -- Successfully led Club Madonna lawsuit — upholding constitutionality of City ordinance to curb exploitation of minors pethrroi ig arillAubs. ROBERT F.ROSENWALD PREVIOUS LEGAL EXPERIENCE Project Director I American Civil Liberties Union of Florida(ACLU) 2005—2010 Managed operations, budget, administrative functions, fundraising efforts, and organizational strategy for ACLU,directing advocacy law firm focused on protecting civil rights through litigation in Florida federal and state courts. Practitioner I Law Office of Robert Rosenwald 2000—2005 Litigation Associate I Morgan Lewis& Bockius, LLC 1998—2000 Federal Judicial Law Clerk I Honorable C.Clyde Atkins 1997—1998 • PROFESSIONAL LICENSURE Admitted to U.S. Court of Appeals I Eleventh Circuit Court 2008 Admitted to U.S. District Court I Northern District of Florida 2000 Admitted to U.S. District Court I Southern District of Florida 2000 Admitted to Florida Bar I Florida Bar Association 1999 Admitted to Pennsylvania Bar I Pennsylvania Bar Association 1998 EDUCATION Juris Doctor ( University of Pittsburgh School of Law 1997 ✓ Articles Editor for The University of Pittsburgh Law Review ✓ Invitation based upon grades in top 10%of first year law school class Bachelor of Arts,Political Science I California University of Pennsylvania 1993 COMMUNITY.INVOLVEMENT Board of Directors Member I Miami Beach Bar Association 2020—Present Member I City of Miami Beach Gay Business Enhancement Committee 2009—2011 AWARDS AND RECOGNITION Latino Justice(PRLDEF)Community Justice Leader 2019 ✓ Awarded for civil rights legal advocacy in the wage equality,immigrant rights, and LGBT arenas. Daily Business Review Most Effective Lawyers 2009 ✓ Awarded for Achieving Notable Success in the practice of public interest law. Page 1356 of 1445 THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK