Resolution 2024-33016RESOLUTION NO. 2024-33016
A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, ACCEPTING THE
RECOMMENDATION OF THE FINANCE AND ECONOMIC RESILIENCY
COMMITTEE AT ITS MARCH 22, 2024 MEETING TO PRIORITIZE
$189,252 IN EDUCATIONAL ENHANCEMENTS FOR PRIVATE AND
CHARTER SCHOOLS DURING THE FY 2025 BUDGET PROCESS AND
ON A RECURRING BASIS THEREAFTER FOR THE SEVEN PRIVATE
AND .CHARTER SCHOOLS CURRENTLY ACTIVE ON THE QUALITY
EDUCATION COMMITTEE; FURTHER PRIORITIZING $393,163 AS A
ONE-TIME ENHANCEMENT FOR FY 2025 FOR THE SEVEN PRIVATE
AND CHARTER SCHOOLS CURRENTLY ACTIVE ON THE QUALITY
EDUCATION COMMITTEE; AND FURTHER AUTHORIZING THE CITY
CLERK AND CITY MANAGER OR HIS/HER DESIGNEE TO EXECUTE
ALL AGREEMENTS OR DOCUMENTS NECESSARY TO SUPPORT THE
EDUCATIONAL ENHANCEMENTS CONTEMPLATED UNDER THIS
RESOLUTION.
WHEREAS, in January 2008, the City of Miami Beach entered into an Education
Compact with the Miami- Dade County Public Schools to Enhance Learning Opportunities
for Youth; and
WHEREAS, the Education Compact reflects the desire of the Miami Beach
community to support excellence in the City's public schools and enhance the health and
well- being of our City's youth; and
WHEREAS, the City of Miami Beach's advisory Committee for Quality Education
in Miami Beach Schools was established in 1999 to make recommendations to the City
Commission and to investigate, develop, and carry out plans to promote and ensure the
provision of quality education in Miami Beach schools; and
WHEREAS, the City of Miami Beach through the Office of Education and
Performance Initiatives provides programming to students enrolled in six local Miami -
Dade County Public Schools: Biscayne Beach Elementary, North Beach Elementary,
Miami Beach Fienberg Fisher K-8 Center, Miami Beach Nautilus Middle, Miami Beach
South Pointe Elementary, and Miami Beach Sr. High; and
WHEREAS, Ordinance 2023-4540, codified in Sections 2-190.134 through 2-
190.138 of the City Code, was recently expanded to include twenty-six (26) voting
members, including eleven private/charter Miami Beach schools who have inquired about
existing City funded educational enhancements; and
WHEREAS, existing City funded educational enhancements include the purchase
of Agenda Planners, STEM Equipment, STEAM+ Programming, College Prep
Programming, Dual Enrollment, College Transcripts, Mental Health, Stop the Bleed Kits,
Math Tutoring, Reading Interventionist, Math Interventionist, IB Program, Anti -
Defamation Leage "No Place for Hate", Drug Prevention, Extra -Curricular FREE
Afterschool Enrichment, Common Threads, Youth Job Fair, Substitute Teacher, and
Virtual Tours; and
WHEREAS, -the additional private/charter schools included in the Ordinance
include: Casa Dei Bambini, Klurman Mesivta, Le Petite Papillon Montessori, Lehrman
Community Day School Inc, Mater Beach Academy, Mechina of South Florida (the
Mesivta of Greater Miami), Montessori Academy at St. Johns, Rabbi Alexander Gross
High School & Hebrew Academy, St. Patrick Catholic School, Temple Beth Sholom .
Innovative School, and Yeshiva Elementary School; and
WHEREAS, this item was referred for a discussion at the Finance and Economic
Resiliency Committee by Commissioner Rosen Gonzalez at the July 26, 2023
Commission Meeting, to discuss funding for educational enhancements; and
WHEREAS, the item was presented at the February 23, 2024 Finance and
Economic Resiliency Committee meeting and returned to the March 22, 2024 meeting
with additional information from the private/charter schools who have active Quality
Education Committee (QEC) members regarding their interest in existing educational
enhancement programs developed, implemented, funded and managed by the City's
Education and Performance Initiatives Division; and
WHEREAS, the City of Miami Beach Chief Education officer met with
private/charter Miami Beach schools between February 29, 2024 and March 6, 2024 to
discuss current educational enhancements available to youth in Miami Beach through
various partnerships, including the public schools. Following each meeting, individual
school Quality Education Committee representatives provided a ranking of current
educational enhancements of interest for their school; and
WHEREAS, according to school administration -provided enrollment information,
there are currently 2,612 youth from early childhood to grade 12 attending seven (7)
private/charter schools in Miami Beach of which 54% (1,419) are Miami Beach residents;
and
WHEREAS, currently, there are 6,148 Miami Beach K-12 youth attending public
schools across Miami -Dade County. As of March 2024, 4,839 or 78.7% are attending
public schools in Miami Beach; and
WHEREAS, an estimated $908,508 is allocated annually to various city funded
and implemented educational enhancements; and
WHEREAS, at the March 19, 2024 meeting, a 15-0 motion was passed
unanimously by the Committee for Quality Education members for to request the Mayor
and Commission continue to sustain current public school educational enhancements and
support the newly prioritized educational enhancements for the private and charter
2
schools. The amount reflected for the private and charter schools is estimated based
upon current public school enhancement programs and may not be reflective of actual
funding needs. The public, charter and private school representatives are united and
committed to,all improvements and enhancements for the educational needs of all Miami
Beach children. These enhancements should only be an expansion and never a reduction
ofcurrently funded public school enhancement programs; and
WHEREAS, Vice -Mayor Rosen Gonzalez motioned at the March 22, 2024 Finance
and Economic Resiliency Committee to discuss this item at the upcoming Commission
meeting, with -a second from Commissioner 13hatt, and favorable recommendation. of
making this a priority during the FY 2025 budget process for $189,252 on a.recurring
basis:and $393,163 as a one-time enhancement for the -seven (7) private/charter schools:
with active membership on the Quality Education Committee; and
WHEREAS, the .Administration' also recommends that any new .program be
considered as part of the FY 2025 budget process; and
WHEREAS, additionally, implementation of any combination of the requested
educational enhancements at private/charter schools will require: an educational
specialist position to develop, implement, and manage all programsfor.each individual
-private and charter school. Funds for this position- may partially come from 'allocated
administrative funds. for other educational programs currently underway..
:NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT DULY RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY
COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, that the Mayor and City
Commission hereby accept the recommendation of the Finance and Economic Resiliency
Committee at its March -22, 2024 meeting to prioritize. $189,252 in educational
enhancements for private and charter schools during the FY 2025 budget process and
on:a recurring basis thereafter for the seven private and charter schools currently active
on the Quality. Education Committee; and further prioritize $393,163 as a . one-time
enhancement for the seven private, and charter schools currently active on. the Quality
Education Committee; and further authorize the City Clerk and City' -Manager or his/her
designee to execute all agreements or documents necessary. tosupport the educational
enhancements contemplated under this resolution.
PASSED AND ADOPTED this day of P4,1V 2024.
ATTEST:. SAY 21 224
RAFAEL E. GRANADO, CITY CLERK STEVEN MEINER, MAYOR
Sponsored by Commissioner Kristen Rosen Gonzalez
Co -Sponsored by commissioner David Suarez
'Co -Sponsored by commissioner Joseph Magazine
.3
APPROVED:AS TO .-
FORM & LANGUAGE
& FOR EXECUTION
City Attorney Date
519/24, 9:17 AM
Item Coversheet
M
MIAMI BEACH
TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Commission
FROM: Rickelle Williams, Interim City Manager
DATE: May 15, 2024
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM
SUBJECT: A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH,
FLORIDA, ACCEPTING THE RECOMMENDATION OF THE FINANCE AND ECONOMIC
RESILIENCY COMMITTEE AT ITS MARCH 22, 2024 MEETING TO PRIORITIZE $189,252 IN
EDUCATIONAL ENHANCEMENTS FOR PRIVATE AND CHARTER SCHOOLS DURING THE FY
2025 BUDGET PROCESS AND ON A RECURRING BASIS THEREAFTER FOR THE SEVEN
PRIVATE AND CHARTER SCHOOLS CURRENTLY ACTIVE ON THE QUALITY EDUCATION
COMMITTEE; FURTHER PRIORITIZING $393,163 AS A ONE-TIME ENHANCEMENT FOR FY
2025 FOR THE SEVEN PRIVATE AND CHARTER SCHOOLS CURRENTLY ACTIVE ON THE
QUALITY EDUCATION COMMITTEE; AND FURTHER AUTHORIZING THE CITY CLERK AND
CITY MANAGER OR HIS/HER DESIGNEE TO EXECUTE ALL AGREEMENTS OR DOCUMENTS
NECESSARY TO SUPPORT THE EDUCATIONAL ENHANCEMENTS CONTEMPLATED UNDER
THIS RESOLUTION.
Vice -Mayor Rosen Gonzalez motioned at the March 22, 2024 Finance and Economic Resiliency Committee to discuss this item at
the upcoming Commission meeting with a favorable recommendation of making this a priority during the FY 2025 budget process
for $189,252 on a recurring basis and $393,163 as a one-time enhancement for the seven (7) private/charter schools with active
membership on the Quality Education Committee. Commissioner Bhatt seconded with all in favor. The administration also
recommends that any new program be considered as part of the FY 2025 budget process. Additionally, implementation of any
combination of the requested educational enhancements at private/charter schools.will require an educational specialist position to
develop, implement, and manage all programs for each individual private and charter school. Funds for this position may partially
come from allocated administrative funds for other educational programs currently underway.
BACKGROUND/HISTORY
This item was referred for a discussion at the Finance and Economic Resiliency Committee by Commissioner Rosen Gonzalez at the July 26,
2023 Commission Meeting (attachment A), to discuss funding for educational enhancements. The item was presented at the February 23,
2624 Finance and Economic Resiliency Committee meeting and returned to the March 22, 2024 meeting with additional information from the
privatelcharter schools who have active Quality Education Committee (QEC) members regarding their interest in existing educational
enhancement programs developed, implemented, funded and managed by the City's Education and Performance Initiatives Division.
The City of Miami Beach's advisory Committee for Quality Education in Miami Beach Schools was established in 1999 to make
recommendations to the City Commission and to investigate, develop, and cavy out plans to promote and ensure the provision of
quality education in Miami Beach schools. .
The Ordinance 2023-4540, codified in Sections 2-190.134 through 2-190.138 of the City Code, was recently expanded to include
twenty-six (26) voting members, including eleven private/charter Miami Beach schools who have inquired about existing City
funded educational enhancements (attachment B). The existing City funded educational enhancements are provided in
the document entitled Educational Enhancement Options (attachment C).
Additional private/charter schools included in the Ordinance:
• Casa Dei Bambini
• Klurman Mesivta
• Le Petite Papillon Montessori
Lehrman Community Day School Inc
• Mater Beach Academy
• Mechina of South Florida (the Mesivta of Greater Miami)
• Montessori Academy at St. Johns
Rabbi Alexander Gross High School & Hebrew Academy Miami
• St. Patrick Catholic School
• Temple Beth Sholom Innovative School
• Yeshiva Elementary School 445
https:/Imiamibeach.novusagenda.com/AgendaWeb/CoverSheet.aspx?ltemlD=34825 113
5/9/24, 9:17 AM
Item Coversheet
ANALYSIS
Dr. Leslie Rosenfeld met with private/charter Miami Beach schools between February 29, 2024 and March 6, 2024 to discuss
current educational enhancements available to youth in Miami Beach through various partnerships, including the public schools.
Following each meeting, individual school Quality Education Committee representatives provided a ranking of current educational
enhancements of interest to their school community which is attached in the document entitled Private/Charter Educational
Enhancement Programs of Interest (attachment D). School site administration provided school enrollment numbers as well.
There are currently 2,612 youth from early childhood to grade 12 attending seven (7) private/charter schools in Miami Beach of
which 54% (1,419) are Miami Beach residents.
Currently, there are 6,148 Miami Beach K-12 youth attending public schools across Miami -Dade County. As of March 2024, 4,839
or 78.7% are attending public schools in Miami Beach. The City of Miami Beach districtwide attached map reflects public school
enrollment of Miami Beach youth residents across the Miami Dade County Public Schools (attachment E). Below is a listing of
Miami Beach public schools and the percent attending that are Miami Beach residents per the map received from the public school
district on March 13, 2024:
1. Miami Beach Sr. High 71 %
2. Miami Beach Nautilus Middle School 81%
3. Miami Beach Fienberg Fisher K-8 96%
4. Miami Beach South Pointe Elementary 95%
5. North Beach Elementary 93%
6. Biscayne Beach Elementary 91 %
An estimated $908,508 is allocated annually to various city funded and implemented educational enhancements with the
breakdown by school available on the MB Public School Enhancement Distribution chart (attachment F).
At the March 19, 2024 meeting, a motion was passed unanimously by Committee for Quality Education members regarding
educational enhancement (attachment G):
Made by Faiza Liban
Second by Chana R. Eisner
The Committee for Quality Education would like to request the Mayor and Commission continue to sustain current public school
educational enhancements and support the newly prioritized educational enhancements for the private and charter schools. The
amount reflected for the private and charter schools is estimated based upon current public school enhancement programs and
may not be reflective of actual funding needs. The public, charter and private school representatives are united and committed to
all improvements and enhancements for the educational needs of all Miami Beach children. These enhancements should only be
an expansion and never a reduction of currently funded public school enhancement programs. The Committee for Quality
Education urges the Mayor and Commission to support the above request.
Motion Passage: Votes 15-0
SUPPORTING SURVEY DATA
49% of residents were satisfied or very satisfied with public schools in Miami beach.
FINANCIAL INFORMATION
FY 2025 $582,415
FY 2026 $189, 252 recurring
CONCLUSION
Was this Agenda Item initially requested by a lobbyist which, as defined in Code Sec. 2-481, includes a principal engaged in
lobbying? No
If so, specify name of lobbyist(s) and principal(s): N/A
Applicable Area
Not Applicable
Is this a "Residents Right to Does this item utilize G.O.
Know" item,_pursuant to Bond Funds.?
Cly Cade Section 2 -14? -
No No
Strategic Connection
Prosperity - Be known for (K-12) educational excellence.
Legislative Tracking
Education and Performance Initiatives
446
hftps://miamibeach.novusagenda.com/AgendaWeb/CoverSheet.aspx?ltemlD=34825 2/3
519/24, 9:17 AM
ASE
Commissioner Kristen Rosen Gonzalez
ATTACHMENTS:
Description
❑ Attachment A - Commission Referral
❑ Attachment B - Ordinance
❑ Attachment C - Educational Enhancement O ns
❑ Attachment D - Private Charter Enhancement Programs of Interest
0 Attachment E - MDCPS MB Public School Enrollment
0 Attachment F - MB Public School Enhancement Distribution
❑ Attachment G - LTC 097-2024 QEC Motion March 2024
0 Resolution
447
Item Coversheet
https://miamibeach.novusaoenda_com/AgendaWeb/CoverSheet.aspx?ltemlD=34825 a 313
MIAMIBEACH
ATTACHMENT A
Commission Referral Committee Assignments -C4 A
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM
TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Commission
FROM: Commissioner Kristen Rosen Gonzalez
DATE: July 26, 2023
SUBJECT: REFERRAL TO FINANCE AND ECONOMIC RESILIENCY COMMITTEE ON JULY 28, 2023 TO
DISCUSS FUNDING FOR EDUCATIONAL ENHANCEMENTS.
SUPPORTING SURVEY DATA
N/A
FINANCIAL INFORMATION
TBD
Applicable Area
Citywide
Is this a "Residents Right to Does this item utilize G.O.
Know' item, pursuant to Bond Funds?
City Code Section 2-14?
Yes No
Strategic Connection
Prosperity - Be known for (K-12) educational -excellence.
Lggislative Tracking
Commissioner Kristen Rosen Gonzalez
Description
[] Educational Enhancements
448
ATTACHMENT B
Ordinance No. 2023-4540
ORDINANCE NO. 2023-4540
AN ORDINANCE OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF'THE CITY OF
MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, AMENDING CHAPTER 2 OF THE MIAMI BEACH
CITY CODE, ENTITLED -ADMINISTRATION," BY AMENDING ARTICLE III,
ENTITLED "AGENCIES, BOARDS AND COMMITTEES,- BY AMENDING
DIVISION 30, ENTITLED "COMMITTEE FOR QUALITY EDUCATION IN MIAMI,
BEACH SCHOOLS,- BY AMENDING SECTIONS 2-190.135-2-190.137
THEREOF TO EXPAND THE COMPOSITION OF THE COMMITTEE INCLUDE
REPRESENTATIVES FROM PRIVATE AND CHARTER K-12 SCHOOLS IN
MIAMI BEACH TO BETTER SERVE INTERESTS OF ALL STUDENTS IN THE
CITY; AND, PROVIDING FOR REPEALER, SEVERABILITY, CODIFICATION,
AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, the City of Miami Beach's advisory Committee For Quality Education In
Miami Beach Schools was established in 1999 to make recommendations to the city
commission and - to investigate, develop, and carry out plans to promote and ensure the
provision of quality education in Miami Beach public schools; and
WHEREAS, the Ordinance, codified in Sections 2-190.134 through 2-190.138 of City's
Code of Laws and Ordinances CCity Codej, requires for the Committee to be composed of
fifteen (15) voting members and three nonvoting ex -officio members; and
WHEREAS, the Mayor and City Commission determined that it is in the best interest of
the City to amend the composition of the Committee to include representatives from all K
through 12 schools in the City of Miami Beach, including private and charter schools, to better
serve the interests of all students in the City.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION
OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA:
SECTION 1. Sections 2-190.135-2.190-137 of Division 18, of Article III, of Chapter 2 of the City
Code, entitled "Administration," is hereby amended as follows:
CHAPTER
ADMINISTRATION
ARTICLE Ill. AGENCIES, BOARDS AND COMMITTEES
DIVISION 30. COMMITTEE FOR QUALITY EDUCATION IN MIAMI BEACH SCHOOLS
Sec. 2-190.134. Established.
There is hereby established the Committee for Quality Education in Miami Beach Schools
- whose-purposes.-power.and-duties,._composftion,_members hip_qualfications, and general _
governing regulations are as follows.
449
Sec. 2-190.135. Purpose.
The committee's purpose is to guide the city's efforts toward providing the best education
possible in Miami Beach pWAG K through 12th grade schools.
Sec. 2490.136. Powers and duties.
The committee is vested with the power and authority to make recommendations to the city
commission and to investigate, develop, and carry out plans to promote and ensure the
provision of quality education in Miami Beach puhiie K through 12!grade schools.
Sec. 2-190.137. Composition; knowledge and experience.
The committee shall consist of 45 twenty-eix save% (2fffi voting members and three
nonvoting ex officio members to be comprised as follows:
(1) A representative selected by the Parent Teacher Association of North Beach
Elementary.
(2) A representative selected by the Parent Teacher Association of Biscayne Beach
Elementary.
(3) A representative selected by the Parent Teacher Association of Miami Beach
Feinberg -Fisher K-8 € w* .
(4) A representative selected by the Parent Teacher Association of Miami Beach
South Pointe Elementary.
(5) A representative selected by the Parent Teacher Association of Miami Beach
Nautilus Middle School.
(6) A representative selected by the Parent Teacher Association of Miami Beach High
School.
(7) A representative selected by the Parent Teacher Association of Ruth K. Broad
Elementary School.
(S) A representative selected by the Parent Teacher Association of Treasure Island
Elementary School.
(9) A representative selected by the Parent Teacher Association,
or an equivalent
. parental organization of Rabbi Alexander Gross High School & Hebrew
Academy.
(10)A representative selected by the Parent Teacher Association,
or an equivalent
parental organization of Yeshiva Elementary School.
(11)A representative selected by the Parent Teacher Association.
or an equivalent
parental organization of St. Patrick Catholic School.
(12)A representative. selected by the Parent Teacher Association,
or an equivalent
• oarental organization of Casa Dei Bambini.
(13)A representative selected by the Parent Teacher' Association,
or an equivalent
parental organization of Lehrman Community Day School Inc.
(14)A representative selected by the Parent Teacher Association,
or an equivalent
parental oraanizatton of Klur�nan "_It�esiwta
2
450
U
(15)A representative selected by the Parent Teacher Association. or an equivalent
parental organization of Temple Beth Sholom Innovation School.
(16)A representative selected by the Parent Teacher Association. or an equivalent
parental organization of Mater Beach Academy.
(17)A representative selected by the Parent Teacher Association, or an a uivalent
parental o anization of Montessori Academy at St. Johns.
(1$)A re resentative selected by the Parent Teacher Association or an a uivalent
Parental organization of Le Petite Pa illon Montessori.
(1'9)A representative selected by the Parent Teacher Association, or an equivalent
parental organization of Mechina of South Florida (the Mesiivta of Greater Miami).
((201 Seven members of the public with knowledge or expertise with regard to
education issues who shall be direct appointments by the mayor and each city
.commissioner with no more than three who can be employed or contracted by
Miami -Dade County public schools.
students attending a Miami Beach school who are also City of Miami' Beach residents. The city
commission shall designate two of its members to serve as city commission liaisons who shall
report to the city commission actions of the committee for quality education; the city manager
shall further designate a member of city staff to serve as a liaison who shall report the
committee's: actions to the city manager.
'Sec. 2-190.138. Supporting department.
The supporting department shall be the office of the city manager.
SECTION 2. CODIFICATION
It is the intention of the Mayor and City Commission of the City of Miami Beach, and it is
hereby ordained that the provisions 'of this ordinance shall become and be made part of the
Miami Beach City Code. The sections of this ordinance may be renumbered or relettered to
accomplish such intention, and the word 'ordinance' may be changed to "section," "article," or
other appropriate word.
SECTION 3. REPEALER
All ordinances or parts of ordinances in conflict herewith be and the same are hereby,
repealed.
SECTION 4. SEVERABILITY
if any section, subsection, clause or provision of -this Ordinance id -held invalid, the
remainder shall not be affected by such invalidity.
3
451.
SECTION S. EFFECTIVE DATE.
This Ordinance shall take effect on the q day of /JW&CA. 2023.
PASSED AND ADOPTED this ol;- dayof f 6 4r 2023.
ATTEST:
2-1 FES 2 8 2023
Rafaef E. Granado, City Clerk
Dan Gelber, Mayor
(Sponsored by Commissioner Kristen Rosen Gonzalez)
4
452
u
APPROVED AS TO
FORM & LANGUAGE
& FOR EXECUTION
City Afbomey cab
ra.�rrT�IP
MIAMIBEACH
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM
TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Commission
FROM: Rafael A. Paz, City Attorney
DATE: February 22, 2023
10:35 a.m. Second Reading Public Hearing
SUBJECT: AN ORDINANCE OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY
OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, AMENDING CHAPTER 2 OF THE MIAMI
BEACH CITY CODE, ENTITLED "ADMINISTRATION," BY AMENDING
ARTICLE III, ENTITLED "AGENCIES, BOARDS AND COMMITTEES," BY
AMENDING DIVISION 30, ENTITLED "COMMITTEE FOR QUALITY
EDUCATION IN MIAMI BEACH SCHOOLS," BY AMENDING SECTIONS 2-
190.135-2-190.137 THEREOF TO EXPAND THE COMPOSITION OF THE
COMMITTEE INCLUDE REPRESENTATIVES FROM PRIVATE AND
CHARTER K-12 SCHOOLS IN MIAMI BEACH TO BETTER SERVE
INTERESTS OF ALL STUDENTS IN THE CITY, AND, PROVIDING FOR
REPEALER, SEVERABILITY, CODIFICATION, AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
ANALYSIS
Pursuant to the request of Commissioner Kristen Rosen Gonzalez, the above -referenced Ordinance
is submitted for consideration by the Mayor and City Cormiission at the February 1, 2023
Commission meeting.
The Ordinance will be submitted viaSupplemental Agenda.
SUPPORTING SURVEY DATA
NIA
Is this
a "Residents
Right
to Know"
item
pursuant
to
CjW Code
Section
2-142
No
Legislative Tracking
Office of the City Attorney
SRonsor
Does this item utilize 0.0.
Bond Funds?
No
453
Page 433 of 1109
Commissioner Kristen Rosen Gonzalez
ATTACHMENTS;_
Description
Commission Memorandum
Ordinance
454
Page 434 of 1109
.;VtlA.VIIBEACH
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
RAFAEL A. PAZ, CRY ATTORNEY
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor Dan Gelber and Members of the City Commission
Alina T. Hudak, City Manager
SECOND READING
FROM: .Rafael A. Paz, City Attorney
DATE: February 22, 2023
SUBJECT: AN ORDINANCE OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, AMENDING CHAPTER 2 OF THE
MIAMI BEACH CITY CODE, ENTITLED "ADMINISTRATION;' BY
AMENDING ARTICLE III, ENTITLED "AGENCIES, BOARDS AND
COMMITTEES," BY AMENDING DIVISION 30, ENTITLED "COMMITTEE
FOR QUALITY EDUCATION IN MIAMI BEACH SCHOOLS," BY
AMENDING SECTIONS 2-190.135-2-190.137 THEREOF. TO EXPAND
THE COMPOSITION OF THE COMMITTEE INCLUDE
REPRESENTATIVES FROM PRIVATE AND CHARTER K-12 SCHOOLS
IN MIAMI BEACH TO BETTER SERVE INTERESTS OF ALL STUDENTS
IN THE CITY; AND, PROVIDING FOR REPEALER, SEVERABILITY,
CODIFICATION, AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
The attached Ordinance was prepared at the request of Commissioner Kristen Rosen
Gonzalez. The Mayor and City Commission approved the Ordinance on first reading at
the February 1, 2023 City Commission meeting. No changes have been made between
.First and Second Reading. A Summary of the proposed Ordinance is set forth below.
The City of Miami Beach's advisory Committee For Quality Education In Miami Beach
Schools was established in 1999 to make recommendations to the City Commission and
to investigate, develop, and cant' out plans to promote and ensure the provision of quality
education in Miami Beach public schools.
The Ordinance, codified in Sections 2-190.134 through 2-190.138 of City's Code of Laws
and Ordinances ("City Code"), requires for the Committee to be composed of fifteen (15)
voting members and three nonvoting ex -officio members.
The proposed Ordinance would amend the composition of the Committee to include
representatives from all K through 12 schools in the City of Miami Beach, including. private
and charter schools, to .better serve the interests of all students in the City, for a_ total
number of 27 members.
RAP/FA/ag
455
Page 435 of 1109
ATTACHMENT C
Educational Enhancement Options
456
s
$2,000: per SchooG+ $1 per child
Provides agenda planners tostudents to help
Agenda Planners
per School contribution
All
enhance communication and time management
- - - -
i - ._.
- ... __ -_ _... �---•---
- _ -
I
skits
- --- --- ---- - - ---
STEM Equipment
$45,833 per School
All
Funds Science, Technology, Engineering, and
Mathematics (STEM) supplies and equipment
'T,
Infuses Science- Technology, Engineering, Arts,
}
¢
and Mathematics (STEAM) during the school day,
STEAM+ Program
f $60,500 'per School
'All
rining local rt organi ns into
ala zatio the
_
r
_t_
classroom
Provides a free SAT/ACT preparation program
College Prep Program
$12,500 per 500 kids
HS
during the summer and to high school students
during the school year
I OF $6,716 per Class
College/High school -courses offered at the
Dua[Enrollment
1 FIU $5,000
HS, Middle
High/Middle School site for'-
or'.MDC
MDC$5,000
credit
Transcripts
_
$75-$100 per child (Graduate
HS
Funds official transcript requests, for students
participating in City -funded Dual Enrollment
Provides Behavioral Health/Mental Health
Mental Health
$11,400 per day per School
All
support services from a Licensed Clinical Social
( Worker at the school site
Stop the Bleed Kit
$100 per Kit
All
Provide kit installation in each classroom for
essential bleeding control
Math Tutoring ASE
i $7,500 per School
HS, Middle
Provides one-on-one after-school math tutoring
to students
Reading Interventionist
$10,000 per School
Elementary
Provides one-on-one reading instruction during
the school day
(
? Provides one-on-one math instruction during the
Math Interventionist
1 .$10,000 per School •
-TBD
HS, Middle
s
schoolday '
IB Program
All
Provides International Baccalaureate (IB)
professional development training
Anti -Defamation League ' No
l
i-Im lements "A World of Difference' Anti -Bias
p
"No
$1,250 per training day
i -All
and Diversity Training, earning a Place for
Place for Hate"
Hate" designation --- ---- -_- -- -
Provides drug prevention and intervention
Drug Prevention
TBD
All
informational sessions.for parents/guardians of
Miami B_ea_ch teens
--
Fu nds STEAM (Science, Technology, Engineering,
Extra -Curricular Free ASE
$30,000 per School
Elementary
Art, and Mathematics) driven activities for
afterschool enrichment
Common Threads
Varies by program interest
Elementary
i
Offers youth and families hands-on cooking and
coordinated_ by Parks
nutrition programs
i
An event hosted at the school site that brings
Youth Job Fair
i
i $500 per School/ fair
HS
local employers to the High School to support
youth employment
Reimburses residents the cost to become a
Substitute Teacher
$350 per Sub Teacher+ CW parking All
qualified substitute teacher and provides free
citywide parking
Provides access to a virtual tour of the school
Virtual Tours
$3,333 per School
; campus in Miami Beach, highlighting programs
_
i
---
456
ATTACHMENT D
Private/Charter Educational Enhancements Programs of Interest
393,163 One-time
495,032 Recurring
457
Estimate Cost r
Recurring vs.
Tota Number
MB Resident Students 33139,
School:
Programs Selected:
programming:
one-time
Students:
33140, 33141)
Parent Representatives:
Administration:
1. STEM Equipment
$ 45,833
One-time
540 students
153 (K-5 or 48%)
Danielle Cohen (QEC)
Jodi Brute
.ehrman Community
2, Reading Interventionist
10,000
Recurring
102 (Early Childhood or 46%)
Allf Zalaznik
Day School INC.
3. Agenda Planners
2,530
Recurring
Michelle Senevive
S 58,363
1. Math Interventionist
$ 10,000
Recurring
404 students
111(K-8 or 40%) Chana Eisner (QEC)
Martin Karp
2. Reading Interventionist
10,000
Recurring
69 Early Childhood or 54%) Ester Sigal
Rabbi David Nathan
Yeshiva Elementary
3. STEM Equipment
45,833
One-time
Zach Eisner
School
4. Stop the Bleed Program
1,600
One-time
Jared Mendel
5. Substitute Teacher Incentive
1;050
Recurring
Shalom Baskin
$ 68.483
1.Stem Equipment
$ 45,833
One-time
305 students
55 (K-5 or 77%)
Jacquelynn Powers (QEC)
Stacey Penson
2. Steam+ Program
60,500
Recurring
178 (Early Childhood or 76%)
Jen Burk
Shannon Koonin
3. Reading Interventionist
10,000
Recurring
remple Beth Shalom
4. Common Threads
3,000
Recurring
Innovative School
5. Anti -Defamation League
900
Recurring
6. Substitute Teacher
1,050
Recurring
7. Mental Health
11,400
Recurring
$ 132,683
1. Math Tutoring
$ 7,500
Recurring
56 students
37.(9-12 or 66%)
Shaye Guttenberg (QEC)
Rabbi Eli Durdi
2. College Prep
925
Recurring
Dr. Martin Karp
Rabbi Friedman
3. Mental Health
11,400
Recurring
Rabbi Winkler
4. STEM Equipment/STEAM+
45,833
One-time
Mechina of South
S. Extra Curricular Free ASE
30,000
Recurring
Florida (the Mesivta
6. Drug Prevention
3,000
Recurring
of Greater Miami)
7. Dual Enrollment
12,000
Recurring
8. Stop the Bleed
300
One-time
9. Virtual Tour
3,333
One-time
$ 114,291
1. STEAM+ Program
$ 60,500
Recurring
653 students
223 (K-12 or 41%)
Devorah Zeiger (QEC)
Reena Rabovsky
2. STEM Equipment
45;833
One-time
62 (Early Childhood or 54%)
Davord Werdizer
Rachel Weinberger
Rabbi Alexander
3. E5OL Interventionist
10,000
Recurring
Norit Rosenberg
Andrea Lucero
Gross High School
4. Reading Interventionist
10,000
Recurring
Licy Wolfson
Merideth Kaltman
&
S. Math Interventionist
10,000
Recurring
Hebrew Academy
6. Virtual Tours-
3,333
One-time
Miami
7. College Prep Program
4,325
Recurring
8. Dual Enrollment
20,000
Recurring
9. Transcripts
1,000
Recurring
10. Stop the gleed Kits
2,100
One-time
11. Extra Curricular Free ASE
30,000
Recurring
$ 197,091
1. Reading Interventionist
$ 10,000
Recurring
602 students
393 (K-8 or 65%) ,
Natassia Prudmikava
Marison Gomez
2. STEAM+ Program
60,500
Recurring
Fabiana Allegro
Carolina Heredia
3. STEM Equipment
45,833
One-time
Christine Perrin-Stocco (QEC)
Jocelyn Jinks
4. Mental Health
11,400
Recurring
Amelia Samtafe
Chloe Markowicz
Mater Beach
S. Extra Curricular FREE ASE
30,000
Recurring
Mariamely Leani
Anabel Verez
Academy
S. IB Program
58,333
One-time
7. Common Threads
3,000
Recurring
8. Math Interventionist
10,000
Recurring
$ 216,066
1. I -Ready Program Access
$ 10,000
Recurring
52 students
36 (K-5 or 69%)
Brittany Faw (QEC)
Cynthia Rodriguez
2. Reading Interventionist
10,000
Recurring,
Ms. Diaz
Montesori
3. STEM Equipment
45,833
One-time
Academy at St.
4. Virtual Tours
3,333
One-time
John's
S. Extra Curricular Free ASE
30,000
Recurring
6. Agenda Planners
2,052
Recurring
$ 101,218
TOTAL
$ 898,195J
2,612
1,419 (54%)
;
393,163 One-time
495,032 Recurring
457
lNe 105th St
N
W+E
S ATTACHMENT E
City Miami Beach Districtwidel,
a Public School Enrollment { ;
1
eed, sI
1St
N4 Both SS
North
Nora' ,raj Eay_vUlage
On% ..7_l__ _-
).land Treasure
t31 rsl d
•26
26-•'a�Itig,
.
tC i•:11.
iii: i
tc`e �•- j • a:6+xarra BEACH
t•..:,C4v T,• •'• ElEtlCNTAIIY
(:::I'. __x.••55 ����.\ �A: „r ..
41
7 Or• s %
Ln L?dcd ?'
Intar..t -
• a
• �` Iwcjh
� •.i
fib!•
A
• ti +
• - isir{
• • %
Y..� . �v. KOIITH eEACB
.�=.=.'c .•� 'a•,S•S FLELEMTAi[Y f•{•
a
Source: Location Analytics App - 02/16/2024
s•.tv.wr s••w lrAoh
aawe.w . sekr� ([�rrl
�m Nom! f Y.u.as,
soli nsxn•.....ekm
rose
rhea �ve�onno••A,Jea.
wl] Mnv+iw Qrvrwn w,yn
.ow u.••. rhdmy s,w,•�..
fUl Ab w aeC� n
ssw h... ro.n
inl ad�i, a•....+W.s..s.
a.o•6+a,r r,rm • s
leu w.:n w.e+•. •.....
uu win a:a.a.e•.m, h,.se•
rwl roe. wo.a x+wa++.. wa
rws w•,•3 r+•w•,mrva..e
n(.cemw++t xlna
1 WRw,m•pmaw•
All wv O 1v Sw_.,c—
au Bros BM 1•,[,'a�+•1 (••r<•
W1 Co. G-
10 1.—
aan.. Y.wI Mp�YMN
�X.tl�n(lurtn by
lkwv,
sws a.••:.k+n
•n+, an1(I•,vdnrwMv,
uel IP,e•ec,W e..e
ax m C+welu.rr Snnra
]We .. fe�•mnv e,N.n h,
w�... a,wn 4•E (a..w Feuh
lOA W14rl.w hhh Xl.W
u.a a�w rw,a w...ow
....m. a •.h v,w,
mu w•+n•.•a.d,••nn w..
ine �>.o •+•+ro h.sm
raa •+wna+..,�hw...w sn
il., r J s•n sr..o� �+.n
0U1 WN•k(Mmnv,n
ml e.•e.. p.ur�• k,.. h�a
row � n-v�.erm. han
•••1+ �sr •r.u.
5.•wNM h,N1e
nU r ((•wnhr[nry(••fJ
wn ,•n Gne[Mn•r xiotl
ral2 [w.ma.•Da•d (tu.hn [km
sacs w•e u.,.z• • c e c•mn
sow so.e••o exlehise•m,
n hn 4•Mmr 4kLM X,�
u e•o-w�. �on.*�r+.•+e•w
e0U Sy,le•b.Nga•E r•m 4v
rel l,v, ua..u-.. nus
0af1 tbE GJwn lJauhw (u
n., Asn:>hrir
soa h•.<w u.�.,u ue...m..
sen x. s(ee•cw.n
YI• �4•.M.•y G..m
kr.. A•4m• I•a (whn
X� bse..eas•IG
)fel
T-1 1-1
mso•n,•e� .a.•r e•.
heel �.
}W M,an dnln.r
...Iprd uws.-roeee.
sna IbrJN,am,
sJ•.+..Ya• cro......r
rel x•,ro am,•,•esw.. wr„
nn d•.elh�kb,l
rms �.a.. .w.w.m...
sw we.•o sa.r •.s..k...
n» µn,� c•••ro+ak
Mi • ugEk
IO}• ta�, i••1r,o,o 6,d ✓pm N:
IYl M1W+w lk+.r,
sru •+..,., r e c•mn
M•�, 1•d.++yn• Ypm b
,rn� M.m •.eprwa, ••4+..r
•nA+IGct�,.+ar I h.nrmu•
(wdrMomie M+•a,anw
fi••aigl
• Miami -Dade County Public Schools
City Of Miami Beach
Students Residing within Municipality
y: n9Our JuO-M6
(Charter and Traditional Public Schools)
r
_J 458
Date: 2/28/2024
Governmental
Affairs
& Land Use
moo'
oa
t.: • �, MiamiBeath
st
•1
ptaott
•• „tea• • it 1
slang
r •T,
•
c-_�,I. r:,,Inst
�• .
itjVy'ii? o
Le end
A
��
(4•~"`
cm :..• r: '
': i• •;J
lu BEACH aLMI
Educational Facilities
c''°t
t,:
o.evrui E �1 EtZt •+-
Type
••nn
• Etementary school
land
`Z'
Lummao la}atttl
• K-BCWu Or Combin.don school
,
• Middle School
• Senior High School
Fisher tela
• Student Locations
aMunippal Boundary
.
Source: Location Analytics App - 02/16/2024
s•.tv.wr s••w lrAoh
aawe.w . sekr� ([�rrl
�m Nom! f Y.u.as,
soli nsxn•.....ekm
rose
rhea �ve�onno••A,Jea.
wl] Mnv+iw Qrvrwn w,yn
.ow u.••. rhdmy s,w,•�..
fUl Ab w aeC� n
ssw h... ro.n
inl ad�i, a•....+W.s..s.
a.o•6+a,r r,rm • s
leu w.:n w.e+•. •.....
uu win a:a.a.e•.m, h,.se•
rwl roe. wo.a x+wa++.. wa
rws w•,•3 r+•w•,mrva..e
n(.cemw++t xlna
1 WRw,m•pmaw•
All wv O 1v Sw_.,c—
au Bros BM 1•,[,'a�+•1 (••r<•
W1 Co. G-
10 1.—
aan.. Y.wI Mp�YMN
�X.tl�n(lurtn by
lkwv,
sws a.••:.k+n
•n+, an1(I•,vdnrwMv,
uel IP,e•ec,W e..e
ax m C+welu.rr Snnra
]We .. fe�•mnv e,N.n h,
w�... a,wn 4•E (a..w Feuh
lOA W14rl.w hhh Xl.W
u.a a�w rw,a w...ow
....m. a •.h v,w,
mu w•+n•.•a.d,••nn w..
ine �>.o •+•+ro h.sm
raa •+wna+..,�hw...w sn
il., r J s•n sr..o� �+.n
0U1 WN•k(Mmnv,n
ml e.•e.. p.ur�• k,.. h�a
row � n-v�.erm. han
•••1+ �sr •r.u.
5.•wNM h,N1e
nU r ((•wnhr[nry(••fJ
wn ,•n Gne[Mn•r xiotl
ral2 [w.ma.•Da•d (tu.hn [km
sacs w•e u.,.z• • c e c•mn
sow so.e••o exlehise•m,
n hn 4•Mmr 4kLM X,�
u e•o-w�. �on.*�r+.•+e•w
e0U Sy,le•b.Nga•E r•m 4v
rel l,v, ua..u-.. nus
0af1 tbE GJwn lJauhw (u
n., Asn:>hrir
soa h•.<w u.�.,u ue...m..
sen x. s(ee•cw.n
YI• �4•.M.•y G..m
kr.. A•4m• I•a (whn
X� bse..eas•IG
)fel
T-1 1-1
mso•n,•e� .a.•r e•.
heel �.
}W M,an dnln.r
...Iprd uws.-roeee.
sna IbrJN,am,
sJ•.+..Ya• cro......r
rel x•,ro am,•,•esw.. wr„
nn d•.elh�kb,l
rms �.a.. .w.w.m...
sw we.•o sa.r •.s..k...
n» µn,� c•••ro+ak
Mi • ugEk
IO}• ta�, i••1r,o,o 6,d ✓pm N:
IYl M1W+w lk+.r,
sru •+..,., r e c•mn
M•�, 1•d.++yn• Ypm b
,rn� M.m •.eprwa, ••4+..r
•nA+IGct�,.+ar I h.nrmu•
(wdrMomie M+•a,anw
fi••aigl
• Miami -Dade County Public Schools
City Of Miami Beach
Students Residing within Municipality
y: n9Our JuO-M6
(Charter and Traditional Public Schools)
r
_J 458
Date: 2/28/2024
Governmental
Affairs
& Land Use
ATTACHMENT F
Miami Beach Public School Enhancement Distribution
STEM
Virtual Tours
Agenda Planners $
1,733 $
3,024 $
1,039 $
1,953 $
3,119 $
1,812
STEAM+ Program
62,000
62,000
62,000
62,000
62,000
62,000
College Prep Program (Method
Learning)
-
-
-
-
12,500
Dual Enrollment (FIU, MDC, UF)
-
-
-
-
10,000
93,432
Transcripts
-
-
-
-
-
10,000
Mental Health
11,400
22,800
11,400
11,400
22,800
60,000
Math Tutoring
-
-
-
-
7,500
7,500
Reading Interventionists
10,000
10,000
10,000
10,000
10,000
-
Math Interventionists
-
-
-
-
10,000
10,000
International. Baccalaureate
8,333
8,333
8,333
8,333
8,333
8,333
Mti-Defamation League - "No Place
For Hate"
1,250
1,250
1,250
1,250
1,250
1,250
Drug Prevention Program
-
-
-
-
-
6,000
FREE Afterschool Enrichment Program
30,000
-
-
40,000
-
33,600
Youth Job Fair
-
-
-
-
-
1,000
Substitute Teachers
833
833
833
833
833
833
Recurring annually $
125,549 .$
108,240 $
94,855 $
135,769 $
.135,835
School Total 1 $ 134,712 1 $ 133,887 $ 121,8521$ 256,522 $ 174,0121$ 415,593
All schools excluding infastructure $ 1,236,578
One time expenditures 328,070
Recurring annually $ 908,508
459
M
DocuSign Envelope ID: 034205E7-EF394AC6-99E0.00496900065B ATTACHMENT G
. LTC 097-2024
Committee for Quality Education Motion
MIAMIBEACH
OFFICE OF THE CIN CLERK
NO. LTC # LETTER TO COMMISSION
097-2024
TO: Honorable Mayor Steven Meiner and Members of the City Commission
FROM: Rafael E. Granado, City Clerk
DATE: March 19, 2024
SUBJECT: Committee for Quality Education Motion
The Committee for Quality Education would like you to be aware of the following motion regarding
educational enhancements, approved at the March 19, 2024, committee meeting.
C: Executive Staff
Dr. Leslie Rosenfeld, Chief Education Officer
Attachment
JDG/LDR
,_G 0�0
460
h
DocuSign Envelope ID: 034205E7-EF39-4AC6-99ED-OC496900C65B
City of Miami Beach
Committee for Quality Education
Meeting of March 19, 2024
Members Present: Donielle Cohen, Laurie Kaye Davis, Brittany Faw, Seth Guttenberg, Beverly
Heller, Mary Keinath, Faiza Liban, James Orlowsky, Christine Perrin-Stocco, Jonathan
Rothman, Chana R. Eisner, Beth Edwards, Karen Fryd, Devorah Zeiger, Amy Ostroff and
Jacquelynn Powers
City of Miami Beach Liaison: Dr Leslie Rosenfeld
Commissioner David Suarez
Members Absent: Rina Bass, Evie Fernandez, and Marilia Kamil
Motion
Made by Faiza Liban
Second by Chana R. Eisner
The Committee for Quality Education would like to request the Mayor and Commission continue
to sustain current public school educational enhancements and support the newly prioritized
educational enhancements for the private and charter schools. The amount reflected for the
private and charter schools is estimated based upon current public school enhancement
programs and may not be reflective of actual funding needs. The public, charter and private
school representatives are united and committed to all improvements and enhancements for the
educational needs of all Miami Beach children. These enhancements should only be an
expansion and never a reduction of currently funded public school enhancement programs.
The Committee for Quality Education urges the Mayor and Commission to support the above
request.
Motion Passage: Votes 15-0
Absent for Vote: Jonathan Rothman
461