Resolution 2024-33407 RESOLUTION NO. 2024-33407
A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING AND DIRECTING THE CITY
ADMINISTRATION TO AMEND THE CITY'S SPECIAL EVENT GUIDELINES TO
REQUIRE A "PHS ISLANDS SPECIAL EVENT PERMIT" FOR PARTIES AND
GATHERINGS IN SINGLE FAMILY HOMES ON PALM, HIBISCUS AND STAR
ISLANDS DURING MIAMI ART WEEK WHENEVER THE PARTY OR
GATHERING IS SO LARGE IN SCALE AND/OR INVOLVES SEVERAL
INSTITUTIONAL-OR COMMERCIAL-GRADE VENDORS, SERVICES, OR
EQUIPMENT SUCH THAT THE PRODUCTION OF THE EVENT IMPACTS
PUBLIC SAFETY, NEIGHBORHOOD TRAFFIC, OTHER RESIDENTS' RIGHT
TO A DECENT QUALITY OF LIFE, AND/OR THE RESIDENTIAL CHARACTER
OF SINGLE-FAMILY NEIGHBORHOODS ON THESE ISLANDS AND THE
SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOODS.
WHEREAS,the City's special events guidelines define a special event as"a non-recurring
special occasion or activity which is temporary in nature and has extraordinary or excessive
impacts on public health, safety and welfare." See Special Event Guidelines, p.3, attached as
Exhibit A; and
WHEREAS, in recent years, large-scale house parties and other special events have
occurred in the City's residential neighborhoods, including on Palm, Hibiscus, and Star Islands
("PHS Islands"), during Miami Art Week with so many attendees and the use of institutional grade
event equipment, to include large and powerful commercial grade speakers, large commercial
grade party and dancefloor lighting, large and commercial grade generators, and/or commercial
grade firework displays such that the party or gathering cannot reasonably proceed without
various violations of City Code and other laws, impact public safety by clogging the narrow
roadways on these islands and the roads approaching them such that emergency vehicles cannot
respond to emergencies in a timely fashion and by concentrating such a large number of people
in an area that, by its residential nature, does not allow for adequate and effective public safety
management of the crowds and the overflow from these crowds in the residential neighborhoods
on and around these residential islands; and
WHEREAS, these large and institutional parties and gatherings during Miami Art Week
on PHS Islands are so negatively impactful to public safety, neighborhood traffic, other residents'
right to a decent quality of life, and/or the residential character of single-family neighborhoods that
"extraordinary or excessive impacts on public health, safety and welfare" are produced such that
the Mayor and City Commission determine that they should not be allowed to proceed without the
property owner first applying for and obtaining a special event permit that may include limitations
and requirements (if it is granted at all) that would protect the City and residents' interest in
maintaining public safety, neighborhood traffic, other residents' right to a decent quality of life,
and/or the residential character of single-family neighborhoods on these islands and the
surrounding neighborhoods; and
WHEREAS, the Mayor and City Commission direct the City Administration to amend the
City's special event guidelines to require a "PHS Islands Special Event Permit" ("PHS
SEP")(which shall be separate and distinct from any issued pursuant to City Code Section 46-
156)for large parties or gatherings involving institutional-or-commercial-grade vendors, services,
or equipment in PHS Islands residential neighborhoods during Miami Art Week, which shall be
granted only if impacts to public safety, neighborhood traffic, residents' quality of life, and the
1
residential character of single-family neighborhoods can be adequately ensured in advance of the
event; and
WHEREAS, the amendments to the special event guidelines mandated by this Resolution
shall include the requirement for a PHS SEP for parties and gatherings on PHS Islands, during
Miami Art Week, where fireworks will be involved, more than 100 attendees may reasonably be
expected to attend; where more than 50 vehicles are expected to pick up/drop off passengers (or
park) on PHS, where institutional/commercial grade speakers, lighting, and/or generators are to
be utilized, or where institutional/commercial grade bars that are large enough to allow more than
one bartender to work behind each bar or the use of more than three (3) single-bartender bars
are to be utilized; and
WHEREAS, whenever a PHS SEP is required for a party or gathering on PHS Islands
during Art Basel Week, the application for PHS SEP shall incorporate a requirement for provision
of any information necessary to analyze and address any impacts to public safety, neighborhood
traffic, and/or other residents' right to a decent quality of life sufficient to allow the City
Administration to impose limitations or additional requirements sufficient to address these impacts
to the health, safety and welfare of PHS Islands residents and residents in surrounding
neighborhoods, or to allow the City Administration to deny the application altogether if these
enumerated interests cannot be adequately addressed; and
WHEREAS, a non-exhaustive list of requirements to obtain a PHS SEP shall be (1)
agreement by the property owner to the ability of City personnel to enter the private property for
compliance inspections prior to (accompanied by the owner or agent with mutually agreeable
scheduling) and during the party(at any time); (2)property owner must obtain all relevant permits
from all relevant City departments, such as, for example, obtain any required building permits
where required; (3) property owner shall be required to comply with the special event guidelines
and provide required documents, which include Certificate of Insurance and Indemnification; and
(4) any requirements imposed to protect the health, safety, and welfare of the PHS Islands and
surrounding neighborhoods' residents and visitors; and
WHEREAS, applications for a PHS SEP required by this Resolution shall be submitted
within the timeframe set forth in the guidelines for similar special events and shall be subjected to
review by all relevant City departments, review committees, and to advisory review and comment
by the PHS Islands Association; and
WHEREAS, any parties and/or gatherings on PHS Islands currently scheduled for Art
Basel Week 2024,which is December 2-8, 2024 that are required to obtain a special event permit
pursuant to this Resolution shall be allowed an expedited review and approval/denial process
from when a complete application and all supporting documents have been submitted; and
WHEREAS, any party or gathering on PHS Islands during Miami Art Week requiring a
special event permit pursuant to this Resolution that proceeds without the homeowner first
obtaining a special event permit and complying with all of its terms, conditions, limitations, and
requirements shall cease and desist and end the party or gathering upon demand by the City and
a code compliance violation shall be issued under all applicable provisions of the City Code. If the
owner, manager, director, or resident of the property does not comply with the cease and desist
demand, the Miami Beach Police Department may arrest each owner, manager, director, or
resident for resisting arrest without violence or any other applicable charge. Additionally, no
special event permit shall be granted for any event for a period of the next thirteen (13) months if
a party or gathering occurs without obtaining and complying with a special event permit, where
2
required, at any property.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT DULY RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY
COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, that the Mayor and City
Commission authorize and direct the City Administration to amend the City's special event
guidelines to require a "PHS Islands Special Event Permit", a set forth in the recitals above, for
parties and gatherings in single family homes on Palm, Hibiscus and Star Islands during Miami
Art Week whenever the party or gathering is so large in scale and/or involves several institutional-
or-commercial-grade vendors, services, or equipment such that the production of the event
impacts public safety, neighborhood traffic, other residents' right to a decent quality of life, and/or
the residential character of single-family neighborhoods on these islands and the surrounding
neighborhoods.
PASSED AND ADOPTED thiss2Vday of441w I/, 2024.qo
ATTEST: //,, , ' ,> / • f-eepoca
/.ice... ,fie ,7 o '
ii NOV 2 1 21 -'Mayor teve einer Arr-
• 1
Rafael E. Granado, City Clerk lr
__�N,! B ..4.,,
(Sponsored by Alex J. Fernandez) - : 1. ,t-`,'�'''
.IPI,,,,,,,T.„,
P1ORATED.+' /,
Cosponsored by Mayor Steven Meiner %, ..... �_d, G`'_=.
Co-Sponsored by Commissioner Tanya K Bhatt Bch. 26;.-
Co-Sponsored by Commissioner Laura Dominguez
Co-Sponsored by Commissioner Joseph Magazine
Co-Sponsored by Commissioner Kristen Rosen Gonzalez APPROVED AS TO
Co-Sponsored by Commissioner David Suarez FORM&LANGUAGE
XECUTION
(.4.A., 7 r
City omey Dote
3
Discussion Items - R9 AH
MIAMI BEACH
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM
TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Commission
FROM: Commissioner Alex Fernandez
DATE: November 20, 2024
TITLE: DISCUSS/TAKE ACTION—TIME SENSITIVE DISCUSSION RE PARTY HOUSE(S)
ON HIBISCUS ISLAND DURING ART BASEL WEEKEND.
RECOMMENDATION
BACKGROUND/HISTORY
The City has become aware of one or more homes on Hibiscus Island that have been purchased
by common owner(s) and transformed into large scale "party houses." Neighbors have been
awakened at all hours of the night by commercial grade speakers blaring music and booming
bass as well as commercial grade club lighting that has disturbed the peace and tranquility of this
neighborhood.We have now also learned that a commercial grade fireworks display from a barge
is planned for near midnight on December 5, 2024, during Art Basel week.
The City Administration and the City Attorney's Office are proactively working with the PHS
Islands Association in an attempt to ameliorate the negative impacts to the community of these
commercial grade parties going forward. I would like to discuss any potential new tools that the
City Commission could possibly provide to our City Administration and City Attorney's Office as
they work to protect our residents' quality of life.
ANALYSIS
FISCAL IMPACT STATEMENT
N/A
Does this Ordinance require a Business Impact Estimate?
(FOR ORDINANCES ONLY)
If applicable, the Business Impact Estimate(BIE)was published on:
See BIE at: https://www.miamibeachfl.gov/city-hall/city-clerk/meetinq-notices/
FINANCIAL INFORMATION
CONCLUSION
Applicable Area
Citywide
Is this a "Residents Right to Know" item, Is this item related to a G.O. Bond
pursuant to City Code Section 2-17? Project?
No No
Was this Agenda Item initially requested by a lobbyist which, as defined in Code Sec. 2-481,
includes a principal engaged in lobbying? No
If so, specify the name of lobbyist(s) and principal(s):
Department
City Attorney
Sponsor(s)
Commissioner Alex Fernandez
Co-sponsor(s)
Condensed Title
Discuss/Take Action—Time Sensitive Discussion Re Party House(S) On Hibiscus Island During
Art Basel Weekend. (Fernandez)