C6B-Report- Neighborhood-Community Affairs Committee Meeting On April 24 2012lt\ MIAMI BEACH -
City of Miami Beach, 1700 Convention Center Drive, Miami Beach, Florida 33139, www.miamibeachfl.gov
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor Matti Herrera Bower and Members of the City Commission
FROM: Jorge M. Gonzalez, City Manager
DATE: May 9, 2012
SUBJECT: REPORT OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD/COMMUNITY AFFAIRS COMMITTEE HELD ON
TUESDAY, APRIL 24, 2012.
A meeting of the Neighborhood/Community Affairs Committee was scheduled for Tuesday, April24,
2012 at 3:00 pm and was held in the City Manager's Large Conference Room, 4th Floor of City Hall.
Commissioners in attendance: Mayor Matti Herrera Bower (departed meeting at 5:03pm),
Commissioners Edward L. Tobin, Jorge Exposito (arrived at 3:33pm), and Michael Gongora (arrived
at 3:33pm and departed at 5:15pm). Members from the Administration and the public were also in
attendance. Please see the attached sign-in sheet.
THE MEETING OPENED AT (3:30PM)
1. DISCUSSION REGARDING LICENSING AND AUTHORIZATION REQUIREMENTS FOR
MOBILE FOOD TRUCKS AND PROPOSAL FOR A CITY SPONSORED FOOD TRUCK
FESTIVAL.
(4:57PM)
Assistant City Manager Hilda M. Fernandez explained that the topic of food trucks was requested
to return to the Neighborhood/Community Affairs Committee (NCAC) for further discussion. A
North Beach community meeting was held. Businesses and residents were invited to attend as
well as City staff and a representative from the food truck industry. Several options were
discussed and a concept introduced. At the conclusion of the discussion, it was determined that
there was enough support to have a pilot program, perhaps tied in with another event. The City
will also ask the local businesses to participate.
Commissioner Tobin stated that he would like to see three (3) events as a pilot program and that
there must be consistency with the time and dates selected. The City needs to invite participation
by the restaurants, as well as be hospitable and sensitive to their needs.
Commissioner Exposito made a motion for the Administration to identify three (3) dates with
consistent days and times and move forward with a pilot program. He asked that, moving forward,
once the pilot program is assessed, that these mobile businesses provide nutritional information
for their offerings so the community knows what they are eating.
Mayor Matti Herrera Bower wanted to know if this would be treated like any other special event
and emphasized the need for these companies to be treated equally. The food trucks must take
care of bathroom, sanitation and other security needs. She wants to ensure that for-profit
companies are treated the same.
Jim Heins spoke regarding the history and concept of the food truck infusion.
67
Agenda Item C <e_8
Date £--'1-!L,
City Commission Memorandum
May 9, 2012
Report of the Neighborhoods/Community Affairs Committee of April24, 2012
Page 2 of9
ACTION: Administration to identify three (3) dates with day and time consistency and move
forward with a pilot program for the food trucks and return to the Neighborhood/Community Affairs
Committee with results.
2. DISCUSSION REGARDING COMMUNICATIONS ABOUT THE PROGRESS OF PROJECTS
AND CONSTRUCTION TO THE LOCAL RESIDENTS.
Referred at February 8, 2012 Commission, Item R9G
(Requested by Commissioner Jorge R. Exposito and referred to committee by acclamation)
Deferred at March 27. 2012 NCAC
(6:33PM)
This item was referred by Commissioner Exposito for an overview of the steps that the Public
Works and CIP offices take to communicate the progress of projects and construction to the
public. Public Works Director Fred Beckman began the discussion stating that the City has
contractual commitments from contractors regarding project progress. The City's CIP Public
Information Officer (PIO), Maria Palacios, is an expert at outreach and communications.
Therefore, the City currently has multiple tiers of communication with the public.
o PIO Identifies stakeholders and begins to build a stakeholders email database
o PIO schedules, coordinates planning, and attends stakeholder construction kick-off
meetings outlining the work and anticipated impacts.
o PIO walks door to door with door hangers notifying residents and businesses when
each new phase of work begins.
o PIO sends an email blast every Friday with latest project information to affected
residents and business
o PIO handles phone calls and emails responding to complaints
o PIO follows through and closes the loop on issues that have been raised
Commissioner Exposito wanted to have this type of information in an easy-to-access format, such
as on the City's website to eliminate the need for phone calls. He would like to see the
information readily accessible to anyone at any given time. The Commissioner requested an
interactive map be available for easy navigation.
Maria Palacios spoke regarding the ongoing efforts in revamping the CIP web portal. The goal is
to give a detailed overview of each project at its various stages including funding. An interactive
map will also be available for citizens to click and easily see the types of construction.
Additionally, one of the key factors in the communication efforts is to develop a comprehensive
database.
Commissioner Exposito mentioned that this is essential. Case in point, he received about 15 calls
from the Bayshore neighborhood where residents were reporting pipes sticking out from the
ground and water was being wasted. He was able to learn, that this was the way to flush out the
system while necessary upgrades are completed. These calls would have been avoided if this
information were accessible online. He noted that he is glad to see this joint venture with Public
Works and CIP and appreciates all the efforts.
Christine Florez spoke regarding the search engine on the City's website.
ACTION: Commissioner Tobin requested an update on the City's website during the upcoming
retreat.
68
City Commission Memorandum
May 9, 2012
Report of the Neighborhoods/Community Affairs Committee of April 24, 2012
Page 3 of9
3. QUARTERLY CRIME STATISTICS (RECURRING ITEM ON A QUARTERLY BASIS).
Commission Item R9D, Apri/13, 2011
(Requested by Commissioner Tobin)
Last report to NCAC January 30, 2012
(5:15PM)
Major Angel Vazquez began by reporting crime statistics. Commissioner Tobin asked how these
statistics are analyzed and by whom.
Major Vazquez explained that key staff meets weekly, quarterly and annually to review the
statistics and devises action plans. At the request of Commissioner Tobin, a quarterly report was
shared. Commissioner Tobin was concerned that he had been advised that the City's statistics
were higher than the City of Miami.
Assistant Police Chief Mark Overton introduced himself. He shared the information most recently
gathered and the current action plan. Several meetings have taken place during his three weeks
with the City in which the Department sought to identify the root problems as well as address their
symptoms. The City has seen some slight increase in robberies as well as burglaries. Thefts are
down as well as aggravated assaults. The Department has been able to identify trends that will
help for future planning. One consideration to deter crime would be to close the beach (sand
area) with some sort of gate as well as signage indicating that the beaches are closed; this will
allow the officers to challenge trespassers. This is an issue that the Department would like
assistance from the Commission to address. Increases in prostitution in the entertainment districts
as well as house burglaries in the Venetian area are also concerns. The Department has
increased enforcement efforts to address prostitution.
Commissioner Tobin wanted to ensure that the Department is not changing the Sector program.
He also mentioned concerns with the North Beach area regarding crime, drugs, homeless, alcohol
establishments, low level narcotics, vagrants, prostitution, hundreds of condoms next to the tot lot
and dunes. He wanted to make sure that Police is addressing all of these issues. This is a
decades old problem and he wants to make sure the City is doing something about it. Residents
feel that the North end does not get enough attention.
Assistant Chief Overton assured the committee that the Department is currently working in this
area and has more enforcement, as well as a beat detail.
Commissioner Exposito asked Assistant Chief Overton to feel free to communicate and speak up
and let the Commission know what they can do to help. He further stated that during his
campaign in 2009, the common sentiment from the residents, specifically the older residents, was
the fear of going out to catch a bus. Perhaps talking to the residents in the area, Police can
gather feedback directly from them to help identify those concerns. He urged continuation of the
beat detail.
Major Vazquez discussed the statistics with the committee.
Carla Probus spoke regarding the possibility of having certain beach entrances fenced. She was
also expressed her concern with the City park maintenance. She wanted this to be considered
and brought to the Commission. Commissioner Tobin stated that he will make a referral.
Assistant City Manager Hilda Fernandez indicated that the Administration is already getting
estimates for gates at various points on the beach.
ACTION: Discussion only.
69
City Commission Memorandum
May9, 2012
Report of the Neighborhoods/Community Affairs Committee of Apri124, 2012
Page4 of9
4. QUARTERLY PROJECT STATUS REPORT. (FOOT Alton Road Project)
Commission Item R9C, July 13, 2011
(Requested by Commissioner Gongora)
Last discussed at NCAC November 10. 2011
(7:08PM)
ACTION: Deferred to a future meeting.
5. QUARTERLY REPORTS REGARDING WASHINGTON AVENUE.
Commission Item C4H, October 19, 2011
(Requested by Commissioner Gongora)
(6:50PM)
Commissioner Tobin asked that the Planning Department share its urban plan when completed.
For the last twenty years, the City has tried to do something about Washington Avenue but
nothing seems to take place.
Assistant City Manager Jorge Gomez stated that in prior years, Commissioner Liebman attempted
to pass an ordinance that limited the amount of tattoo parlors. Commissioner Tobin stated that
Tattoo Parlors are a symptom of something else.
Assistant City Manager Gomez commented that it could also be the landlord's lack of oversight.
He asked if the Commissioners wanted to legislate and target that industry.
Commissioner Tobin does not want to tell anyone that they can't be here; he wants alternatives on
what the City can do to improve the area. If the area smells and drug transactions are taking
place, then that is the type of tenant that these landlords are going to get. He stated that he would
like for someone to create a plan and share it with the committee.
Assistant City Manager Hilda M. Fernandez provided an update to everyone on the most recent
efforts regarding Washington Avenue. At the request of Commissioner Libbin, a public workshop
was recently held at The Wolfsonian. It was well attended by residents, business owners and City
staff. During the meeting, short-and mid-term steps, as well as long-term solutions requiring
funding were discussed requiring a policy decision.
Sheryl Roberts spoke.
Commissioner Tobin does not know if going back to the community and asking them for the best
way of handling urban planning is the best approach given the professional talent available in the
City. Assistant City Manager Fernandez stated that the Planning Department is currently working
with Florida International University to create a plan.
Carla Probus spoke.
Commissioner Tobin expressed reservations regarding this approach. He wanted specifics as to
the vision and who within the City would bring it to fruition.
Assistant City Manager Gomez stated that the City can't compel an owner to improve his or her
business. The City can help as much as possible as was done on Ocean Drive.
ACTION: Administration to come back with a comprehensive plan.
70
City Commission Memorandum
May9, 2012
Report of the Neighborhoods/Community Affairs Committee of April24, 2012
Page 5 of9
6. FILM PERMITS
a. DISCUSSION REGARDING THE GUIDELINES FOR FILM PERMITS ISSUED IN
RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOODS.
Commission Item C4F1, March 21, 2012
(Requested by Mayor Mattie Herrera Bower, Commissioner Deede Weithorn and Vice-
Mayor Jerry Libbin)
b. DISCUSSION REGARDING PROPOSED AMENDMENTS TO THE CITY'S FILM AND
PRINT GUIDELINES.
Commission Item C4F2, March 21, 2012
(Requested by Administration)
(3:28PM)
Max Sklar introduced the item. The last time the City's Film & Print Guidelines were amended
was April 2001. The City decided to take a look at these guidelines. The Tourism and Cultural
Development office has been working with the Production Industry Council (PIC) for several
months to review the current Film and Print Guidelines and recommend any needed amendments.
Recently, however, concerns had been raised by a resident about the frequency of permits issued
for film/print activities in residential neighborhoods and specifically single family homes. Max
Sklar shared those proposed amendments that were non-controversial first. (See page 24 of
agenda package). Most of these proposed amendments are regulations primarily intended to
enhance public safety. Direction from the Committee was requested regarding the current
residential notice requirements. In particular, the issue introduced and discussed was the
proposal by resident Irwin Friedman to limit the number of days of filming in a residential
neighborhood in a month that only require notification to neighbors. This was the result of activity
of use in his neighbor's house. He proposed five days, after which consent would be required. Mr.
Sklar explained that, at present and due to a loop hole, it is up to 14 days without consent, which
could result in a production company taking a one-day break and filming another 14 days-or a
total of 28 days in a month. Staff acknowledged that this was an issue and recommended
language to remove that loophole. However, direction was requested on the maximum number of
days of filming with only notification.
Commissioner Gongora stated that he is having concerns with a particular problematic house that
has caused several issues. He does not want to put a freeze on the production industry because
of one bad house. He wants us to deal with that particular house. Assistant City Manager
Fernandez addressed Commissioner Gongora's comments. The issues raised by this particular
property were not related to film permits.
Several residents, production industry representatives and business owners spoke on the issue of
limiting production days:
Bruce Orosz
Todd Glaser
Gloria Bierman
Alex Tachmes
Irwin Friedman (Mr. Friedman read his comments for the record, see attachment)
AI Crespo
Hugo Rodriguez
Alana Rothlein
Noreen LeGault
Leah Sokolowsky
Christina Labuzetta
Sandy Lighterman
71
City Commission Memorandum
May9, 2012
Report of the Neighborhoods/Community Affairs Committee of April 24, 2012
Page 6 of9
Jennifer Radzikowski
Clint Phinney
Andy Schetter
Maria Chavez
Andrew Nathanson
Adam Shedroff
Erin Lucas
Julie Chang
Cesar Valdesuso
Margarite Ramos
Michael Bernstein
Mickey Minagorri
Patti Hernandez
Norma Quintero
Commissioner Tobin would like to experience the film permit process to better understand it.
It was requested that staff coordinate a meeting between residents and the industry to see if there
could be agreement on the issue of number of days of filming in a residential neighborhood.
ACTION: Administration to schedule a community meeting with the Industry and residents to
discuss.
7. DISCUSSION REGARDING THE FINE SCHEDULE FOR A PROPOSED ORDINANCE
AMENDING THE FOLLOWING CHAPTERS IN THE CODE OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH TO
PROVIDE CIVIL ENFORCEMENT AND PENAL TV PROVISIONS TO REPLACE CRIMINAL
MISDEMEANOR ENFORCEMENT AND PENAL TV PROVISIONS AS FOLLOWS: AMENDING
CHAPTER 70 ENTITLED "MISCELLANEOUS OFFENSES," BY AMENDING ARTICLE I,
ENTITLED "IN GENERAL," BY AMENDING SECTION 70-6, ENTITLED "PENAL TIES," TO
PROVIDE CIVIL PENAL TIES AND SPECIAL MASTER ENFORCEMENT PROVISIONS
RELATIVE TO THE PROHIBITIONS IN CHAPTER 70, EXCEPT FOR VIOLATIONS OF
SECTION 70-3 ENTITLED "VIBRATION"; BY AMENDING CHAPTER 74 OF THE MIAMI
BEACH CITY CODE ENTITLED "PEDDLERS AND SOLICITORS," BY AMENDING ARTICLE I,
ENTITLED "IN GENERAL," BY AMENDING SECTION 74-1 ENTITLED "SOLICITING
BUSINESS IN PUBLIC FROM PEDESTRIANS," BY PROVIDING THAT THE SOLICITATION OF
ANY FOOD, BEVERAGE OR SERVICE IS ALSO A PROHIBITED ACTIVITY AND PROVIDING
CIVIL PENAL TIES AND SPECIAL MASTER ENFORCEMENT PROVISIONS; BY AMENDING
CHAPTER 82 OF THE MIAMI BEACH CITY CODE ENTITLED "PUBLIC PROPERTY," BY
AMENDING ARTICLE I, ENTITLED "IN GENERAL," BY AMENDING SECTION 82-1,
ENTITLED "CONDUCTING BUSINESS ON STREETS, PARKS OR OTHER PUBLIC
PROPERTY," BY PROVIDING CIVIL PENAL TIES AND SPECIAL MASTER ENFORCEMENT
PROVISIONS; PROVIDING FOR REPEALER; SEVERABILITY; CODIFICATION; AND AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
(DEFERRED TO FUTURE MEETING)
Commission Item RSA, April11, 2012
(Requested by Commissioner Weithom)
There was no discussion. Item was deferred prior to the meeting.
ACTION: Item deferred to a future meeting of the Neighborhood/Community Affairs Committee.
72
City Commission Memorandum
May 9, 2012
Report of the Neighborhoods/Community Affairs Committee of April 24, 2012
Page 7 of9
8. DISCUSSION REGARDING THE 41 5 r STREET LIFE SAFETY RECOMMENDATIONS FROM
THE COMMITTEE FOR QUALITY EDUCATION.
Commission Item C4E, March 21, 2012
(Requested by Commissioner Weithom)
(5:42PM)
Karen Rivo, Chair of the Education Committee spoke regarding improvements. However, she
expressed concern with the crosswalk located on 41st Street and Garden Avenue. The proposal
from the Education Committee was to move the crosswalk with the lights from 41st Street and
Garden Avenue to 41st Street and Jefferson Avenue.
Public Works Transportation Manager Jose Gonzalez spoke regarding the recent study
conducted in January 2012. The study concluded that a new traffic signal is not warranted at the
intersection of 41st Street and Jefferson Avenue for the following reasons; signal proximity,
pedestrian volume and accident volume. However, the Public Works Department requested that
FOOT revisit the January 2012 traffic safety study and, in particular, to consider relocating the
existing signal at 41st Street and Garden Avenue to Jefferson Avenue (where the majority of
students are currently crossing) rather than add a new one. The City believes that the potential
signal relocation would improve the safety of pedestrians crossing at Jefferson Avenue, while not
impacting existing signal proximity along the corridor. The results of the supplemental analysis
are anticipated by the end of May 2012.
Commissioner Tobin wants the City to take a look at this area to ensure that the City is addressing
safety and pedestrian concerns.
Commissioner Exposito stated that it would be good to look at the light while exiting the
causeway; at a specific angle, it looks as the light is green. So by moving it to the requested spot,
it will ease the visibility coming from the Causeway.
Commissioner Tobin addressed Mrs. Rivo with regards to student safety at the middle school.
Mrs. Rivo announced a meeting that will be held tomorrow at David's Cafe to address certain
concerns by the Miami-Dade County Public Schools superintendent.
Gabrielle Redfern spoke regarding the lack of school nurses and the importance of having them
at our schools.
Dessiree Kane spoke and commented on how her son taught her about drugs and how it
happens on in school grounds. She suggested having a police dog to sniff for drugs.
Commissioner Tobin stated that he will speak to the School Board to consider.
Leonor Hernandez spoke regarding her own experience.
ACTION: The Committee directed Public Works Transportation Manager Jose Gonzalez to work
with FOOT.
73
City Commission Memorandum
May9, 2012
Report of the Neighborhoods/Community Affairs Committee of April24, 2012
Page 8 of9
9. DISCUSSION REGARDING MASS TRANSIT CONNECTIVITY WITHIN MIAMI BEACH AND
WITHIN MIAMI-DADE COUNTY.
Commission Item C41, March 21, 2012
(Requested by Commissioner Tobin)
(5:54PM)
Transportation Manager Jose Gonzalez introduced himself and explained his past role in the City
of Miami and his current role in the City of Miami Beach. The Administration is currently working
with Miami-Dade Transit, Miami-Dade Metropolitan Planning Organization and the Florida
Department of Transportation on various short term and long term transit projects. The current
project pertains to Miami-Dade Transit, Local circulator (South Beach Local}, Airport Flyer/Route
150 and Bus Routes servicing Miami Beach and vicinity.
Commissioner Tobin wanted to know about available benchmarks that are being used to identify
the future vision of the City's transit issues. Is there any city that stands out when it comes to
great transportation? Portland, WA was mentioned.
Assistant City Manager Gomez stated that the reason Portland has a great system is due to the
strong commitment from the community to get involved and engaged in the transit system, as well
as the importance of getting other agencies involved in the process. Miami Beach has a historic
community and is fully built-out. The City cannot widen its streets to create more capacity on our
roads.
Commissioner Tobin asked what can be done. Is there any school of thought to have a
discussion with developers to look at opportunities?
Assistant City Manager Gomez indicated that the City is currently having discussions with specific
developers regarding improvements to transit and dedicating land to future right of way
expansion. Assistant City Manager Gomez also stated that we need to have a dedicated system;
something similar to Baylink and that until the City becomes part of a bigger network, it will remain
isolated.
Commissioner Exposito mentioned that as he has stated in the past during commission meetings
that the FCC corridor now wants to do some type of a light rail north and South, One of the things
that he has asked of the County Commissioners is to include Miami Beach as part of that plan.
The City needs to begin discussion with Miami Dade Transit. In addition, he wanted to explore
the possibility of having loops for the South, North and Middle areas.
Assistant City Manager Gomez commented that the City is already looking at technology and
options to move forward with some local routes.
Jose Gonzalez stated that we are currently working on some short term goals.
Gabrielle Redfern spoke.
Commissioner Exposito is happy to learn that we are working on connectivity at each point of
interest.
Public Works Director Fred Beckman stated that once the study is concluded we will present
funding source and needs. This should be ready within the next couple of months.
Christine Florez spoke
74
City Commission Memorandum
May 9, 2012
Report of the Neighborhoods/Community Affairs Committee of April24, 2012
Page 9 of9
Gabrielle Redfern spoke
Paul Janas spoke
Clotilde Luce spoke
Commissioner Tobin would like to further discuss this issue at the retreat.
ACTION: Administration (Jose Gonzalez) to send Commission and present community members
the consultant's agreement and scope of services.
10. DISCUSSION REGARDING A RESOLUTION GRANTING AND AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR
AND CITY CLERK TO EXECUTE AN AFTER-THE-FACT REVOCABLE PERMIT TO ASR
BERWICK FAMILY L TO PARTNERS, AS OWNER OF THE COMMERCIAL PROPERTY
LOCATED AT 335 WEST 47TH STREET, TO RETAIN A/C UNITS, A UTILITY ROOM, AND A
TRASH ENCLOSURE, CURRENTLY PLACED WITHIN THE PUBLIC CITY RIGHT-OF-WAY ON
WEST 47TH COURT. (Resolution No. 2012-27826 adopted and item referred to the
Neighborhoods/Community Affairs Committee in 90-days to review the progress made per the
recommendation as listed below. If the parties cannot agree then bring back to the City
Commission for reconsideration of the revocable permit).
a. City Department to get involved to improve the area
b. Both neighbors to meet and craft mitigation plan that includes:
i. monthly maintenance (consider someone neutral, a third party)
ii. enforce traffic and dumping issues
iii. eliminate standing water
iv. eliminate dead electrical conduits and/or open wiring
v. bulky trash or any type of work outside the building is not to be allowed
vi. obtain some type of uniformity with the iron gate by painting it
vii. If at referral meeting, the Committee does not recommend approval, then bring
back to Commission.
Commission Item RlA, January 11, 2012
(Requested by City Commission)
(5:12PM)
Public Works Director Fred Beckmann requested to defer discussion to a future meeting as an
agreement is still in the works and the attorneys were not present.
ACTION: The discussion was deferred to a future meeting.
THE MEETING ADJOURNED AT (7:10 PMJ
JMG~S/KT/BH
T:\AGENDA\2012\5-9-12\NCAC REPORT APRIL 24-2012.doc
75
SPEECH BEFORE NEIGHBORHOOD/COMMUNITY AFFAIRS COMMITTEE
April24, 2012
MY WIFE NORA AND I MOVED TO MIAMI BEACH, AS SNOW BIRDS, ABOUT
10 YEARS AGO. THIS CITY-THIS LOCATION-IS LIKE SHANGRI-LA TO US.
WE HAD A GOOD RUN ... THEN FROM DECEMBER 2011 TO FEBRUARY 2012,
THE TRANQUIL BEAUTY OF OUR SINGLE FAMILY NEIGHBORHOOD WAS
TRANSFORMED INTO A COMMERCIAL PRODUCTION ZONE. THERE WERE EVER
INCREASING FILM/STILL SHOOTS AT OUR NEIGHBOR'S HOME. A TOTAL OF 15 IN
3MONTHS.
THE NEIGHBOR IS VERY NICE, WE HAVE BEEN OVER FOR DRINKS, ETC.
HOWEVER, WE MOVED HERE FOR PEACE AND QUIET AND TRANQUILITY
AND VISITING WITH OUR GRAND KIDS. WE HAVE A RIGHT TO PEACE AND
TRANQUILITY IN OUR SINGLE FAMILY NEIGHBORHOOD!
WE MET WTH OUR NEIGHBOR, BUT WE WERE NOT ABLE TO LIMIT THE
SHOOTS BY AGREEMENT.
WE COMPLAINED TO THE CITY, WHO TOLD US THEIR HANDS WERE TIED
BECAUSE THE GUIDELINES ALLOW IT. SO, THE ONLY OPTION WAS TO AMEND
THE FILM/PRINT GUIDELINES.
I UNDERSTAND AND ACKNOWLEDGE AND APPRECIATE THE FILM/STILL
SHOOTS INDUSTRY, AND THE INCOME GENERATED BY THE INDUSTRY, TO OUR
HOTELS, RESTAURANTS, AND SERVICE INDUSTRIES LIKE CLEANERS, CATERERS,
ETC .... WE DO NOT WISH TO BLOCK THE FILM/STILL SHOOTS INDUSTRY. WHAT
WE DOW ANT IS FAIRNESS AND BALANCE ... TO BOTH SIDES.
SOMETHING THAT WILL ALLOW THE FILM/STILLS INDUSTRY TO PROSPER
WITHOUT HOMEOWNERS GETTING OVERWHELMED IN SINGLE FAMILY
NEIGHBORHOODS WITHOUT THEIR CONSENT.
AS YOU KNOW, WE ARE PROPOSING THAT THE CONSENT OF ABUTTING
NEIGHBORS BE REQUIRED IF THERE WILL BE MORE THAN 5 DAYS OF
PRODUCTION ACTIVITY IN A MONTH. FIRSTLY, 5 DAYS IS A LOT, AND THAT'S 60
DAYS/YEAR! THAT'S 2 FULL MONTHS WORTH OF FILM AND PRINT ACTIVITY,
WITHOUT ANY NEIGHBOR'S CONSENT, IN A SINGLE FAMILY NEIGHBORHOOD
WHERE COMMERCIAL USES ARE SUPPOSEDLY PROHIBITED! AND, BY THE WAY,
THERE ARE HOMEOWNERS WHO DON'T WANT ANY FILM OR PRINT SHOOTS AT
ALL IN RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOODS.
76
KEEP IN MIND THAT ANY COMMERCIAL ENTERPRISE IN A RESIDENTIAL AREA IS
TECHNICALLY PROHIBITED, BY MIAMI BEACH ZONING. FOR EXAMPLE, YOU
CAN'T HAVE ANY COMMERCIAL PARTIES IN SOMEONE'S SINGLE FAMILY HOME.
NOT ONE. AND EVEN IF IT'S JUST 5 PEOPLE AT THE PARTY, WITHOUT ANY
IMPACT ON NOISE, TRAFFIC OR ANYTHING ELSE! IT'S PROHIBITED. I DON'T
KNOW WHY THAT'S ANY DIFFERENT THAN COMMERCIAL USES FOR FILM/PRINT
SHOOTS IN SINGLE FAMILY USES. UNDER YOUR CODE, COMMERCIAL USES ARE
NOT ALLOWED IN SINGLE FAMILY NEIGHBORHOODS. PERIOD.
ANYWAY, WE WANT THE HOMEOWNERS ABUTTING TO HAVE A CHOICE.
AFTER 5 IN ONE MONTH, IF THEY SAY NO, IT'S NO WITH NO APPEAL. THIS IS FAIR
AND BALANCED.
IF THE FILM/STILLS INDUSTRY DOES NOT LIKE THIS, THE QUESTION IS
WHY?
DO THEY NOT CARE WHAT THE HOMEOWNERS WANT? IN THE CITY STAFF
MEMO, IT SAYS THE PRODUCTION INDUSTRY WANTS 13 DAYS PER MONTH WITH
NO NEIGHBOR CONSENT. ARE YOU KIDDING ME? THAT'S 156 DAYS PER YEAR OF
FILM AND PRINT SHOOTS IN A RESIDENTIAL AREA WITH NO CONSENT. THAT'S
ALMOST HALF THE YEAR! THAT IS NOT RIGHT. THAT IS NOT BALANCE.
HOMEOWNERS ARE ALREADY GIVING, ACCORDING TO OUR PROPOSAL, ...
5 DAYS-NO QUESTIONS ASKED.
DOES THE FILM INDUSTRY, WITH THE CONCURRENCE OF THE CITY, WANT
TO SHOVE IT DOWN THE HOMEOWNERS' THROATS??
THE CODE, AS IT IS TODAY, IS UNFAIR, UNREASONABLE, AND ACTUALLY
DOES SHOVE IT DOWN HOMEOWNERS' THROATS.
WE ONLY WANT A BALANCE.
• FIVE DAYS/MONTH WITHOUT CONSENT.
• ADDITIONAL DAYS REQUIRE ABUTTING NEIGHBORS CONSENT.
• AND IF YOU TRY, BUT CAN'T GET A RESPONSE FROM THE NEIGHBOR,
THE NEIGHBOR'S CONSENT IS DEEMED GIVEN! SO NO DELAY WILL
OCCUR TO THE PRODUCTION INDUSTRY IN HAVING TO TRACK
SOMEONE DOWN FOR CONSENT. THIS IS A VERY REASONABLE AND
BALANCED APPROACH.
CONTRARY TO THE SUGGESTION IN THE STAFF MEMO, THIS IS NOT AN
IRWIN FRIEDMAN ISSUE. IT'S AN ISSUE THAT IS IMPORTANT TO
HOMEOWNERS THROUGHOUT OUR CITY.
77
IN ADDITION TO THE PERSONS ATTENDING THIS MEETING TODAY
SHOWING THEIR SUPPORT, WE HAVE RECEIVED EMAILS OR LETTERS OF
SUPPORT FROM MEMBERS OF MULTIPLE HOMEOWNERS' ASSOCIATIONS
THROUGHOUT THE CITY INCLUDING:
1. LAGORCE ISLAND
2. MIDDLE NORTH BAY ROAD HOMEOWNERS ASSN
3. SUNSET ISLANDS 3 AND 4
4. ORCHARD PARK NEIGHBORHOOD ASSN; AND
5. PALM VIEW HISTORIC DISTRICT ASSN
LET'S VOTE, NO MORE SHOVING DOWN THROATS FOR US.
LET'S DO THE FAIR AND BALANCED THING, WHICH IS GOOD FOR ALL
PARTIES, INCLUDING THE FILM INDUSTRY. THIS IS A GREAT CITY WITH GREAT
HOMEOWNERS.
78
L ----.,..-------~ (9. MIAMI BEACH NEIGHBORHOOD/COMMUNI~ AFFAIRS COMMITTEE MEETING · Aprill24, 2012 ...... (Q PLEASE PRINT LEGIBLY NAME SIGN-IN SHEET ORGANIZATION I ~EPT. I PHONE NO. ~·-···· )
--------· -·-----o•M•---··• ·-. -----··----(9 MIAMIBEACH NEIGHBORHOOD/COMMUNI"Nl AFFAIRS COMMITTEE MEETING April ~4, 2012 . SIGN-N SHEET . PLEASE PRINT LEG/BL Y NAME ORGANIZATION I qEPT. I PHONE NO. I EMAIL ~-..::bt fr~clt~~~~L~I~~~~~ 0 -l£:,~(0 ~~------CO I ---, -..... -, v---v--" I :'Sc'' 9> 'w' -R ll '«"'~'li-I ,--,,--r ,----1 ,... --n-!='lv•)Y'''Ivw•'="' .. --. v ,,-,, .. 1 0 I U .. i { \ ~)w\\Nl~ro._\'111,·~ .. ~ \A/,..------t"-..1 ..---.:...1: ... -_ _.. ... If ...... ,~ -·.L.h-......... .:----..1 .. _t...,. • ..--11 •• J.. ... l:a-•• -...t -... -1,..1-. t--·-• .:L--a ,_J...t--1 l..:"""-..:-----·· ... :4.
L -· -··-· -···------·-·--· ·-----·--··---·--------·e MlAMIBEACH NEIGHBORHOOD/COMMUNil} AFFAIRS COMMITTEE MEETING Aprilt24, 2012 SIGN-IN SHEET PLEASE PRINT LEGIBLY NAME PHONE NO. EMAIL hc..t....2~v~r.J 00 ~ ;r r W I IV .Fv-( e, .J/'4. tL Ill ov;({ 13i-e.~ rua. ~lb./A IV Cllt<.DG"Aio I (!M B Col¥ COM.Oti~JtleE "/lAliJAl (!tJQj)~,Jo i AI tAUIAimCtf R. t;e'V [MA-({.;1/}-Clf'n/t-1 .. ' ~1\.en~c.. c,1 I Lo~op-A;f~~ \}J-l-1"> s ':. \AI-------:u-..J a.. --..r.J:---·~--U--" -. .£.1:---... .:--... ..1 ,_c_,. • .._ -U •• J,. ... lr.-•• -.J. --..I -1-. :--·-._-t.,_,.
J <9 MIAMtBEACH NEIGHBORHOOO/COMMUNIJ' AFFAIRS COMMITTEE MEETING April 24, 2012 SIGN-N SHEET ' PLEASE PRINT LEGIBLY . ORGANIZATION I fpEPT. I PHONE NO. EMAIL !5PI1 I n~-ON I-/.~. M\3\' I:> s-Oli'--\ k1e.PD "I ~ 1 rw_rmo/te. tvv;trn ,, " 4-1 trome: t r:: ~· r .!UTrt'jC a 1 -~ • r 1 Kfrl/(>f/n" rnwv aez l*"'~':'fl" 1 I!Avt lJitQso . I ! ~Eitdiv /Z6t?~ -1 C/&~-7 /-kJ ?/Jt1/3 ie£Jo ~t~·· tA.I-----m-..J,_ --.:..J: .... - -.. -u... .......... t..t: ........... .: ...... -... ..J .,_t,_,.,._ -U •• .L-1:.-··-..L --...1 -1-~•-_.,_. • .:L.,._,.;, '-'1!-:--1 l..: .. t-..: ... ----··-:a.•