C6B-Report- Land Use And Development Meeting On July 9 2014g MIAMI BEACH
City of Miomi Beoch, 1700 Convention Cenler Drive, Miomi Beoch, Florido 33139, www.miomibeochfl.gov
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor Philip Levine and Members
FROM: Jimmy L. Morales, City Manager
DATE: July 23,2014
SUBJECT: REPORT OF THE JULY 9,
COMMITTEE MEETING
014 LAND USE AND DEVELOPMENT
A Land Use and Development Committee meeting was held on July 9, 2014. Land Use
Committee Members in attendance were Commissioners Joy Malakoff, Deede Weithorn,
Jonah Wolfson and Michael Grieco. Members from the Administration, including, Joe
Jimenez, Thomas Mooney, Raul Aguila and Gary Held, as well as members of public, were
also in attendance. Please see the attached sign-in sheet.
The meeting was called to order at 10:05 AM.
1. PARKING DISTRICT NO. 5 - SUNSET HARBOUR.
(RETURNING FROM THE JANUARY 22, 2014 LUDC MEETTNG
ORIGINALLY REFERRED BY CITY COMMISSION
NOVEMBER 14. 2012 C!ry COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM RsA)
AFTER.ACTION:
Thomas Mooney provided an overview and summary.
Comm. Weithorn suggested eliminating the sunset provision entirely, due to the success of
the garage.
MOTION: DWMG (3-0)
Refer an Ordinance to the Planning Board, as recommended by the Administration, with the
removal of the sunset provision.
2. ST. PATRIGK'S SCHOOL ROW PARKING AND TRAFFIC ANALYSIS.
(RETURNTNG FROM THE JUNE 12,2014 LUDC MEETTNG
ORIGINALLY REFERRED ON
JUNE 5. 2013 GITY COMMTSSTON MEETING, ITEM C4J)
AFTER-ACTION:
Jose Gonzalez, Transportation Director, provided an overview of the item, including a
summary of the County position that pedestrian access should be maintained, as part of any
vehicular closure.
Comm. Wolfson suggested that the City continue to work with the County to allow
pedestrian access to be closed.
The City Attorney was asked to research the authority of the County to require pedestrian
access, over City objections.
Agenda 11sm C(.rB
oate -7431V307
City Commission Memorandum
Repoft of Land Use & Development Committee Meeting of July 9, 2014
Page 2 of 4
Fr. Roberto Cid, from St. Patricks, addressed the Committee regarding the safety and
security of the student body. Additionally the Director of the school and a parent expressed
concern with the safety and security of the children.
Comm. Grieco indicated that it would be important to hear the views of affected residents
surrounding the school.
MOTION: JWMG (4-0)
1. Direct the Administration to continue to work with the County to permit both the
pedestrian and vehicular closing of Meridian Avenue between Barry Street and 39th
Street.
2. Refer an item to the Full City Commission for either the July 23, 2014 or July 30,
2014 meeting, so that the Commission can formally endorse the proposal to close
Meridian Avenue to both vehicles and pedestrians.
3. DISCUSSION ON THE PROPOSED TERMINAL ISLAND RESIDENTIAL PROJECT.
(RETURNTNG FROM THE APRIL 9,2014 LUDC MEETING
ORIGINALLY REQUESTED BY CITY COMMISSION
FEBRUARY 12. 2014 CITY GOMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4G)
AFTER.ACTION:
Neisen Kasdin provided an overview of the proposal and revised Term Sheet.
Joe Jimenez updated the Committee on the content of the Term Sheet, as well as additional
items not mentioned in the term sheet, that would be a requirement of a future Development
Agreement and enabling legislation.
Members of the public addressed the Committee.
MOTION: MG / DW (3-0)
Endorsed the proposed Term Sheet and recommended the following:
1. The City's Outside Counsel should be subsidized by the developer;
2. The timeframe for completing the Development Agreement should be expedited, if
feasible;
3. Additional public notice for future hearings, beyond that mandated by State or City
law, shall be provided;
4. Recommended a referral to the Planning Board for all required Code and
Comprehensive Plan amendments.
4. DISCUSSION ON TELECOMMUNIGATIONS ORDINANCE.
(RETURNING FROM THE MAY 7,2014 LUDC MEETING
ORIGINALLY REFFERED BY CITY COMMISSION
MARCH 5. 2014, CIry COMMISSION MEETING ITEM C4B)
AFTER.ACTION:
Continued to a date certain of September 3,2014.
5. DISCUSSION ON AN OVERLAY DISTRICT FOR WASHINGTON AVENUE AND
NORTH BEACH.
(RETURNING FROM THE JUNE 12,2014 LUDC MEETING
ORIGINALLY REQUESTED BY COMMISSIONER JOY MALAKOFF
MAY 21.2014 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4B)
a. WASHINGTON AVENUE
308
City Commission Memorandum
Report of Land Use & Development Committee Meeting of July 9, 2014
Page 3 of 4
AFTER.ACTION:
Thomas Mooney provided an overview and summary of the item.
Saul Gross addressed the Committee and discussed the make-up and intentions of the
recently formed Mayors Blue Ribbon Panel on Washington Avenue.
Comm. Malakoff recommended that the Blue Ribbon Panel strive to complete its
recommendations by late September.
Michael Larkin addressed the Committee on behalf of the owners of the 600 and 700 blocks
of Washington Avenue.
MOTION: MG/DW (3-0)
Continued to the September 3,2014 Land Use Meeting.
b. NORTH BEACH
AFTER.AGTION:
Commissioner Malakoff suggested that a North Beach Master Plan should be part of the
overlay process.
Joe Jimenez discussed the importance of a plan for the west lots along Collins Avenue.
MOTION: MG/JM (2-0)
Continued to the September 3,2014 Land Use Meeting. The Committee recommended a
Master Plan be developed for for Ocean Terrace, 71st Street and the West Lots along Collins
Avenue.
6. DISGUSSION REGARDING CREATION OF THE FAENA OVERLAY DISTRICT.
(REQEUSTED BY COMMTSSTONER JOY MALAKOFF
JUNE 11. 2014 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4G)
AFTER.ACTION:
Thomas Mooney provided a brief overview.
Niesen Kasdin and Alan Faena provided a power point presentation.
MOTION: MG / DW (3-0)
Endorsed the proposal and recommended Planning Board approval.
7. REZONING OF THE CITY.OWNED LAND AT 226 87TH TERRACE FROM GU TO
RM.2.
(REQUESTED BY COMMISSIONER DEEDE WEITHORN
JUNE 1I. 2014 GITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4J}
AFTER.ACTION:
Thomas Mooney provided an overview and summary of the item.
Graham Penn, Attorney for the owner & developer of the adjacent private land, addressed
the Committee.
MOTION: DW / MG (3-0)
Endorsed the proposal and recommended the required legislation and Comprehensive Plan
Amendments be referred to the Planning Board.
309
City Commission Memorandum
Report of Land Use & Development Commiltee Meeting of July 9, 2014
Page 4 of 4
8. AN ORDINANCE RELATED TO CHANGES TO SETBACKS FOR INTERNAL
DRIVEWAYS, USE STANDARDS FOR CERTAIN HOTELS IN THE MR.2 ZONE,
SETBACKS FOR CERTAIN BUILDINGS WITHIN 250 FEET OF NORTH SHORE
OPEN SPACE PARK, THE STANDARDS FOR GARAGES PROVIDING PUBLIC
PARKING WTHIN 250 FEET OF NORTH SHORE OPEN SPACE PARK.
(REQUESTED BY DEEDE WEITHORN
JUNE 11. 2014 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4K)
AFTER.ACTION:
Thomas Mooney provided an overview and summary of the item.
Graham Penn, Attorney for the owner & developer of the adjacent private land, addressed
the Committee.
MOTION: DW / MG (3-0)
Endorsed the proposal and recommended the required legislation be referred to the
Planning Board.
9. DISCUSSION REGARDING THE PROPOSAL FOR THE PARTIAL TRAFFIC
CLOSURE AND MASTER PLANNING OF OGEAN DRIVE.
(REQUESTED BY Crry COMMTSSTON
JUNE 11. 2014 CIry COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM RgH)
AFTER.ACTION:
Joe Jimenez provided an overview and summary of the item.
Marlo Courtney, Frank DelVecchio and Jo Manning addressed the Committee.
MOTION: MG / DW (3-0)
Endorsed the proposal and referred to the City Commission with the following
recommendations:
1. To further study the expansion of the sidewalk on the east side of Ocean Drive;
2. The filing of an application for Historic Preservation Board approval;
3. The inclusion of the project in the Capital Budget for FY 2015; and
4. Any additional Ordinance Amendments that may be necessary for sidewalk caf6
operations.
10. DISCUSSION: RECOMMENDATION FOR A REFERRAL TO A FUTURE LAND USE
AND DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE MEETING
MOTION: MG / JM (3-0)
Recommend that the City Commission refer the following to the Land Use Committee:
Discussion: Proposed amendments to the City Code pertaining to:
1. Alcoholic Beverage Establishments (Chapter 6)
2. Requirements for determining the size and square footage of "Accessory Uses"
in relation to the main permitted use.
3. The clarification of threshold standards for Neighborhood lmpact
Establishments.
The Meeting Adjourned at 12:45 PM
Attachment
*df$rnr',r
m:\$cmb\ccupdates\land use and development committee\2o14\july 9, 2014\repo( of the ludc meeting of july 9, 2014.docx
310
J'Ain.\.
ooultoo
J
=t
lrJ
c)
\'r-
.J
-l^.' '>)
Q)
--.J
a
l''
-+9')-.\
-\:
./\
,ry
a)
<
Q)
rJ
a)
i
\
,f-
\
a/
i)
Y,
@l
r;1)
i)
,J
,J
a
;
a)
.,-)-'
a)a::{
0!
s(
?
I
c'a
0_
a)
N
U
$
r{(
\
Jsv)
Q)
$
Cb
\rl
G)
-l
u
"i
a)
\
t\
rlf,
^')
\
)
)
I
@
v
-/l(-(-l
.J
€
\
U
N-\
-\
d
a)
tr
..B
N\u\
{-
^\'-.+-
@
)\
{I
_ss6\.;
o
FlL
-.o
@
s:1.
ES
E
G)
-\
\.1
(
e)
{ta
a)
.-a.
-{,
<!+
Xo
+
c.l
oIt)Eas
o(\l
d)o
E
Eoo
Ec(E
oof
o(L
foo
d!
=o@
oz
uJo
ur{
=3H=
fr9,(JE
UH
P,,
o
=
\\\)
tr
UJo
=fz
Fo
Fzoo
).
/::
r-f
ILl
),-{
I
)
.1
\.)
I(D
)-)-
I
,-,::
^J
I
(
.tF L
/_L.)
f-f -
-lv
', l
L,\
I
l-1..,(]
[rr
It\
N
-:rr)
^jU
)---
t-'
rn
\)
t
s
\
.$\
..$
w
(r-
LS"
A
tr-
0
q
N
rt-'t
{
.$
r-
r-
3
'.?
t5
q)
cn
-!-
)-.4
=J\s*
L,2(t
\c\N
lS
Ir,
F-
f\A
V\don
Q
(-t
r,J
t
4.
i
l ---
I
(t
IIJ
=z
,-7
J)
-J
1'Jfv
c.i
,/-
)-
d.
t-
.j
-\-:i
c"j
r'=
..
,.j
,-
+
\J\
J-I
c,
.(
::
\
\
(o
,)
).:
:1.-
J
1
l-'
c)
_).A
-)
U
F-
t{.{
N
N
d
\N
P
A
a(\
\
t"
D
\
$
:N
C
:v\.
\'
\
,U
d
)
"SJE
\s
J
=.$
-|/1..]
v-]
\\\n
\
\\
\
P
J{
JJ
d
2(
9z')
(o
,\
\h
€
+a
=5
!)
\
"\r
1,
(\
d
t\
i--'4
v
oi
c
.s)o
$
go
Eo.9o
o,o
oz
tr
TU
TU
l.U
IUFFc)
=gZ,-+.,1 coxoor-ra.f -CFrL) A
frR s I
Eg:4 EO= E EJ- t or.JJ o tHroOz
lU
U)f
oz
311
Xoo!$
a.l
oo
o
;
.9)
@\t
oNoq)
.E
Eoo
o
Eo.oo
0)o
Ec6ool
EE(E
Ja
UJF
o
0-lOo
co
=o6:
@o
UJtoo
J
=a
IIJ
a)
i,-i
_i
J
G)@
(
c,,
I
\$
-$
*tI(
c)
0
-sI
s
Q)a)G)G)c)o e)Q)a)c)@ Q)G)@ e)e)
ulI
o
v<
JUJuto-<Fc)
u=i'9o=
UH
Pd
To
=
l
\
\
tr,
UJo
=fz
Fo
Fzoo
'p-\
t\rUrr
o-
f,
i
I
I
\0()o
d
a
(\
\!t
b<r\
IIJ
=z
)
--tv
*Jt.fiJ
)/_.
-)(--\
-N
r
t,tr*-
f--)
4-.\-\\)\-
-!i-
oie{
qt
s
d
*e
sN lON
(o
c\t t-
C\l
@N o)N o(a -(o c.i
(f)
c"i(o $(9 r{)
(f)
(o(o F(o @
(f)
o)(a o$
oz
trtu
IU
tu
r.uFFa
=-oZ.-+,l-\COxoo:=6 6
frR s IEg4 EO= E EJ- t oI.IJ O EHroOz
r.u
U)f
oz
312