C6C-Report- May 27 2015 Land Use And Development Committee -LUDC- MeetingMIAMI BEACH
City of Miomi Beoch, ,l700 Convention Center Drive, Miomi Beoch, Florido 33.139, www.miomibeochfl.gov
COMMI MEMORANDUM
Mayor Philip Levine and Members f the City
FROM:Jimmy L. Morales, City Managerr
IDATE: June 10,2015
SUBJECT: LAND USE AND DEVELOPMENT qOMMITTEE MEETTNG OF MAy 27,2015
A Land Use and Development Committee meeting was held on May 27, 2015. Land Use
Committee Members in attendance were Commissioners Joy Malakoff, Ed Tobin, and Jonah
Wolfson. Commissioners Mickey Steinberg and Michael Grieco were also in attendance.
Members from the Administration, including, Joe Jimenez, Thomas Mooney, Raul Aguila,
Eve Boutsis, Eric Carpenter, Michael Belush, Carmen Sanchez and Rogelio Madan, as well
as members of public, were also in attendance. Please see the attached sign-in sheet.
The meeting was called to order at 3:03 PM.
1. DISCUSSION ON POSSIBLE AMENDMENTS TO CHAPTER 6 AND CHAPTER 142
OF THE CITY CODE.
(RETURNING FROM THE ApRtL 1, 2015 LUDC MEETTNG
SPONSORED BY COMMISSIONER JONAH WOLFSON
SEPTEMBER 10. 2014 CITY GOMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4O}
VERBAL REPORT
MOTION: Continued to June 17,2015 by Acclamation.
2. DISCUSSION ON THE COLLINS CANAL PROJECT.
(RETURNTNG FROM THE ApRtL 1,2015 LUDC MEETTNG
SPONSORED BY CITY COMMISSION
SEPTEMBER 10. 2014 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM RgG)
VERBAL REPORT
AFTER.AGTION:
Thomas Mooney introduced the item.
Commissioner Tobin expressed concerns over the aesthetics of the area.
Sheryl Gold addressed the committee.
Eric Carpenter described various aspects of the project.
Commissioner Malakoff expressed a need for temporary beautification of the area until the
final design of the area is approved.
Agenda ltem
Date
caczwrr70
Report of the Land Use & Development Committee Meeting of May 27, 2015
Page 2 of 5
MOTION: Continued to July 29,2015 by Acclamation
3. a) ANNUAL EVALUATION OF PARKING IMPACT FEE STRUCTURE.
(RETURNTNG FROM THE FEBRUARY 18,2015 LUDC MEETTNG
SPONSORED BY CITY COMMISSION
SEPTEMBER 17, 2Ol4CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM R7E)
b) DlscussroN REGARDTNG THE PHTLOSOPHY BEHTND PARKTNG TMPACT FEES
(RETURNTNG FROM THE FEBRUARY 18,2015 LUDG MEETTNG
SPONSORED BY COMMISSIONER JONAH WOLFSON
NOVEMBER 19. 2014 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4J)
AFTER.ACTION:
Thomas Mooney introduced the item.
Commissioner Malakoff expressed a need to require parking for scooters and electric
vehicles.
Commissioner Malakoff expressed concerns over the recommendation to increase the
percentage of accessory uses in Main Use Garages.
MOTION: Continued to July 29,2015 by Acclamation
4. a) DISCUSSION REGARDING SEAWALL CONDITIONS, ENCROACHMENTS
INTO PUBLIC PROPERTY FOR PRIVATE USE.
(RETURNING FROM THE ApRtL 1,2015 LUDC MEETTNG
SPONSORED BY CITY COMMISSION
FEBRUARY 11. 2015 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4J)
VERBAL REPORT
4. b) DISCUSSTON REGARDTNG THE DEGRADATTON OF THE SEA WALL !N THE
LAKEVIEW DRIVE NEIGH BORHOOD.
(SPoNSORED BY GOMMTSSTONER EDWARD L. TOBTN
MAY 20. 2015 CIry COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM RgF)
VERBAL REPORT
AFTER.ACTION:
Eric Carpenter introduced the item and described the conditions of seawalls.
Commissioner Tobin expressed concerns over the needs to improve seawalls
Members of the public addressed the Committee.
MOTION: 3-0 (ET/JW)
1. Refer an item regarding the repair of the Lakeview Drive Seawall to the full City
Commission with a favorable recommendation.
2. Direct the Administration to identify the worst seawalls to be budgeted for repair in FY
2016 and to update the Land Use and Development Committee on the worst Sea Walls
at the July 29, 2015 meeting.
5. AN AMENDMENT TO THE APPLICABLE SECTION OF THE CITY CODE
CLARIFYING THAT THE INCENTIVES ORDINANCE FOR THE RETENTION
71
Report of the Land Use & Development Commiltee Meeting of May 27, 2015
Page 3 of 5
OF ARGHITECTURALLY SIGNIFICANT SINGLE FAMILY HOMES, DOES NOT
APPLY TO SINGLE FAMILY HOMES LOCATED WITHIN A LOCAL HISTORIC
D!STR!CT.
(SPoNSORED BY GOMMTSSTONER JOy MALAKOFF
APRIL 15. 2015 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM G4C)
AFTER.AGTION:
Thomas Mooney introduced the item.
MOTION: 2-0 (JM/ET)
Recommend that the Ordinance be sent to the Planning Board with a favorable
recommendation.
6. DISCUSSION PERTAINING TO MEMBERSHIP REQUIREMENTS FOR
DESIGN PROFESSIONALS SERVING ON THE CITY'S LAND USE BOARDS.
(SPoNSORED By COMMTSSTONER JOy MALAKOFF
APRIL 15. 2015 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4D)
VERBAL REPORT
AFTER.AGTION:
RaulAguila introduced the item.
Members of the Committee discussed the item.
Commissioner Tobin expressed concerns over modifying the membership
requirements.
MOTION: Refer the item to the full commission by Acclamation.
7. DISCUSSION ON THE PROPOSED OCEAN TERRACE OVERLAY DISTRICT,
BOUNDED BY 73RD STREET ON THE SOUTH, 75TH STREET ON THE NORTH,
OCEAN TERRACE ON THE EAST AND COLLINS AVENUE ON THE WEST.
(spoNSoRED By VICE-MAYOR JONAH WOLFSON & COMMTSSTONERS
MICHAEL GRIECO AND JOY MALAKOFF AND CO.SPONSORED BY
COMMISSIONER DEEDE WEITHORN
APRTL 15. 2015 CITY COMMTSSTON MEETTNG ITEM C4E)
AFTER.ACTION:
Thomas Mooney introduced the item.
Niesen Kasdin made a presentation on the proposal for Ocean Terrace and
presented an amendment to the Ordinance requiring retail and restaurants along the
Collins Avenue frontage.
Members of the public addressed the Committee.
Commissioner Wolfson expressed the need for redevelopment of the area.
Commissioner Tobin described several of the challenges in the neighborhood.
Commissioner Steinberg expressed a need to have a traffic study prior to adopting
the Ordinance.
MOTION: 3-O (JW/ET)
72
Report of the Land Use & Development Commiltee Meeting of May 27, 2015
Page 4 of 5
Move the ordinance to the Planning Board as revised by the proposers, with the
modifications that were recommended by the Planning Department, and to incorporate as
an amendment that there be retail on Collins Avenue.
8. DISGUSSION RELATING TO AN AMENDMENT OF THE FAENA OVERLAY
DISTRICT.
(spoNSoRED By COMMTSSTONER MTCHAEL GRTECO
APRIL I5. 2015 CITY GOMMISSION MEETING, ITEM G4H)
AFTER.ACTION:
Thomas Mooney introduced the item.
Neisen Kasdin provided an overview of the proposal.
MOTION: 2-0 (ET/JM)
Recommend that the Ordinance be sent to the Planning Board with a favorable
recommendation.
9. WASHINGTON AVENUE BLUE RIBBON PANEL (WABRP) PRESENTATION WITH
FINAL RECOMMENDATIONS: INCENTIVES FOR DEVELOPMENT THAT DO NOT
!NCLUDE INCREASING FAR.
(SPoNSORED By COMMTSSIONER JOy MALAKOFF
APRIL 29. 2015 CITY GOMMISSION MEETING, ITEM RgA # 5)
AFTER.ACTION:
Thomas Mooney introduced the item.
The Chairman of the Washington Avenue Blue Ribbon Panel, Saul Gross made a
presentation on the recommendations of the Panel.
Members of the public addressed the Committee.
MOTION: 2-0 (ET/JM)
Recommend that the Ordinance be sent to the Planning Board with a favorable
recommendation.
10. ESTABLISH A WASHINGTON AVENUE TASK FORCE. DISCUSSION REGARDING
THE CREATION OF A PROCESS AND CRITERIA FOR PARKLET APPLICATIONS.
(SPoNSORED By COMMTSSTONER JOy MALAKOFF
APRIL 29. 2015 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM RgA # 8)
VERBAL REPORT
MOTION: Continued to June 17,2015 by Acclamation.
11. DISCUSSION REGARDING A MODIFICATION TO SECTION 142.108 OF THE LAND
DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS !N ORDER TO ELIMINATE ANY CONFLICT WITH
THE FLORIDA BUILDING CODE.
(spoNSoRED By COMMTSSTONER JOy MALAKOFF
MAY 6. 2015 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4B)
73
Report of the Land Use & Development Committee Meeting of May 27, 2015
Page 5 of 5
MOTION: Continued to June 17,2015 by Acclamation.
12.DISCUSSION REGARDING AECOM'S PROGRESS ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF
THE CITY'S COMPREHENSIVE RESILIENGY PROGRAM.
(spoNSoRED By COMMTSSIONER MIGHAEL GRTECO
MAy 6. 2015 Clry COMMISSTON MEETING, ITEM C4F)
PRESENTATION
MOTION: Continued to June 17,2015 by Acclamation.
13. DISCUSSION REGARDING THE PROVISION OF RENEWABLE ENERGY SOURGES
IN NEW CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS.
(spoNSoRED By COMMTSSTONER MtCKy STETNBERG
MAY 6. 2015 C!ry COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4H}
MOTION: Continued to June 17,2015 by Acclamation.
14. SIDEWALK CAFE OCEAN DRIVE UMBRELLAS
AN ORDINANCE OF THE MAYOR AND C!ry COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI
BEACH, FLORIDA, AMENDING GHAPTER 82, ENTITLED "PUBLIC PROPERTY,"
ARTICLE IV, ENTITLED "USES IN PUBLIC RIGHTS.OF.WAY," DIVISION 5,
ENTITLED "SIDEWALK CAFES," SUBDIVISION 2, ENTITLED "PERMIT," BY
CREATING SECTION 82.389, ENTITLED "ADDITIONAL MINIMUM STANDARDS,
CRITERIA, AND CONDITIONS FOR OPERATION OF SIDEWALK CAFES ON OGEAN
DRIVE BETWEEN sTH STREET AND 15TH STREET" TO PROVIDE MINTMUM
STANDARDS FOR UMBRELLAS AND AWNINGS, REQUIRE REGULAR
MAINTENANCE OF UMBRELLAS, AND PROVIDE PROHTBITIONS; AND
PROVID!NG FOR REPEALER, SEVERABILITY, COD!FICATION, AND AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
(SPoNSORED BY CITY COMMTSSION
MAY 20. 2015 CITY COMMISSION MEET!NG, ITEM RsB}
AFTER.ACTION:
Joe Jimenez introduced the item.
Members of the public addressed the committee.
Carmen Sanchez presented additional alternatives to the committee.
MOTION: Motion to send all option for umbrellas to the Ocean Drive Task Force and to
continue the item to the June 17 , 2015 meeting by Acclamation.
Meeting adjourned at 5:30 p.m.
tffinRMlRAM
T:\AGENDAUOI5Uune\Report of the May 27 , 2015 LUDC Meeting.docx
74
a
]
J
-t
j
c9-l
nE
\
5
5)--4'
\
.s)9]f\6- r\-IR ,io((^
E(cb LC.O rlt
olElO /ao:> <\8"c
-g \n6\-
3-Hd\-l
9.8cocz5g-+
=j
{_
oo
IIJtoo<(
J
=IllJ '
\
1
)
I)
e
I
)
=
{St'
a)
{
)
P
a)t
->.-\
J\{-\' \/.
J\.\
i'f--
(
i
'Y
:
'!
,(
a)
t.
r
U
'aJ
*
:<
;
s
\
Q)
a\l
s
.\)Y
s
q
a's
a)
Nsxxf
s\i-t
i\
t\i
.\\
G)
I
J
l
r,?,J
I
ra
G)
0
-?)Y
.gq
)
\I,q
\)
'.-
<J)(q
\S
F.\\sa
\--\
,$
?
-]
l*I/s
\)
a)
s
hD
U\
,s
t!
---<,.r.
i
U\
\
't\
.\j\
O),f\\
fi
\
Nli.\\, ,u-
\\
.J
'"---
(.\-,,(
s
@
If)
d>rx
t\f
)irJ
J
,\)J
'J)-*)-
@
s
v'lt
J
='j
I.cl-
.s
.U
$
,.)
\j\!<r
Q)
,--y.F
\)
s,S
5>
'j
\TIq
c)
<{
.s
:
':l
\,)
Q)
.\
\:
. .j
\..\
o
)4
NJ\.
t)
N
('\
T.
t
sFr_s\
'jN
I
Q)-$
T\.\
t
S
\-
Ja\
o
C<
A
J-
il
Xooq
N
oo-c(/)
oN
oo
E
Eoo
EEooof
=
o2
lrJo
ur -{
--3
H=fieo=
HH
Pd
Io
=
\
\,U
=\
tr
IIJo
=fz
Fo
Fzoo
t/5
1
(J
J
,a
b
crot
l^
*
l.nll
->
,C
ltt
\
'n
I'J
.f
q)
c/v
r,')r\
cn;)
c..n
J
t/l
v1
J()
s)
\)(t-
^:(+
\J
a0(s
-OY
N
rF
GS
r,1
.?
f'-)
tt-
.-!
r\\
(--
\\)-'^
"nDl'
t\
!X,J
,.4
,.]
\
a
\
;
J
\"zr
<)rt
u4
C0
rYl
-\>
I
N
i-t-(\
t.\:'
'\^\)
c-\
$
\
\
I
U\
\\
:
{.n
s.
,M(
;a
I
-Y
Jl.-
h
co
U
NJ
)r
)
N
t
N
{-r
$\
(-
rJ\
3
$J
l"s
I'4
I
"{
<)r-
r\
5.
N
CNu-
\_,
(l
cn
a.I$
trs-
trr
lr.,
Cfi
'\)Ct\,
\)<l
\q-
3\o
\r
')
tLl
=z
c<
,'v
v.
6<
-:
;
I
2
3
,4-
[;
J
L,
>(
c.i
.F
L
(a
L
?,
)
.(
a
-9',>r\<
>C
s
\)
F)
\
s\Z
d
q-t
d
)-
,.!
\Y
(o
\c:
.J
^-n
J
-\.
t'
F-
.)
A
c)-
dc"
-l
b
)a
ci
SJJ
\J
Sr
\-\rq
s(-f
o,
\q
_9
(_
0'\-)
(
-fl.+)
*
o
(-
;:)\_\l(\.Sr
=c_-\(-
lA
;
'!
\
\{
\
+\s
\-
c.i
\c
\
\
Ax
I
I^\:\*
c")
c
:{v
.3
E
rd
'
\-t"
sf
'ss,,\
,;\(
>.5
d
bc
IA
?
\(-)
@
\e'f
\--
R
E
\\\
\\r"
l'.,\
sl\L'
\-
P
I\
.-u'E'
t(r_\---*-
P
(
T
)
tx
It?
oN
oz
trtutu
=[uU
Fa
=E- L.a
-,-rg.E p
F5() 6fr1S I
FN B E6 EE Eil> 5 EHr
OOz
UJ
U)l
oz
75
t2\"t.r F .o,
o
cD
UJ
E,oo
J
=I
lrJ
!,J
:
rJ
Et
Q)
O
t-((-\
:-l-
a
k
)
a)
I
-?
\-rl
t\
\
\
@-\
cJL\--\t-
,}tr.r
U
rl-
',4\
\
. \.)
\!
I
a)
\!
\
xJ
{t(t\$
a)s.
{
?
AD
Ee
E
(
(-f,.
rI
G)
*c\
-C)
Y
\j
q"
'r-
CN
t
\c)
^\:r-
U
J
=t-v:
,5
Htsvq
.J
->,A
<{
{
t
-J
&
I-
@
\-
\
\
.:s
Ja
@
L
<
-j
C
L
c
(
\
@l
(\
s
\
:i$
I
r\\I
.$
a)
F\E{
iT\
S\+(J
r'\,
.\
*)
ii
)i,.^.J
J
r-.!
=!,
a)
s-l
-.5.<>
=rr
e
+
'-q
'{\-\
Q)
\\-
"JL
[:I
:1
(
'1-
d
e)
a
1
\C
F\i\
rl
1r\)e
a)IJ.J\
(
1
a)
<-+(
\J
;-
'<.E
\9
u:
C;
':a
i-l
.\J
@
L
\-),
.a
\r
+.
:\
\:N
C,/
a)
E
(\
..\\
;
s
I
s
@
-\\\lr
;
r
o-c
J
IIJ -
-, I
oFv(
=ar.rJ oI<Ie>*
UE
UH
gd
Eo
=
'v^,,u
1)-
<)>)\J
J
IJ$
P,
=--1
v
=-f
)
^6_x
=->
\
i-
$.\v
\
'\0
Ctr\J
a
\\.^'
t"\\\
\
\
>r -ta-d ^o?I C\-l
\
J*,/1v-r
Xoo
.ri
tr
UJ
m
=fz
Fo
Fzoo
-.1
)
J,--J
7- -.
N
#<-
<)\!\
V.J
N\^
it\
>
N
J-.i1
J\r
I
\4
a\/'
$-
,!.
J.
- (\.\J
Cr\J
(
t\\)4
o-('\*i
s
V\.Js\
I
f-s
l
!:
5
I
C\.)
.
!
\lq
-*.
\)
:)L-
s\s.
\
\'J.('\
\
\J
F-
{
.'s
uN
N'
C_rq
q.r
\J
l-*
,.)
rJ\
(-.
Jt
{\
I
u
F
I
Ni\r\
$
e
.(l$-\s
I\
S
\
I
\-)\rr
\r
\\
N
rl
\n
\I
;"\-
An
,0
o
t6
t(r
rf
-l\
,,^
D(
r.J.).
D4fJ
\ll
c{
I
\'{
l-*
\'
\
\
\
N"
(-\n
\-
"\I
1|,
\s-
.{
\.' a.
\/-
I
(-.\
')6r
f,-
i\f\
S$
\
O+.,
:ra(
tA
q)
ft1
I
ooc
U)
oN
oa
.E
EoO
E
o
oof
c
IIJ
=z
c
-
j
Cl
-\}
\
c'\\\
:NN
f,
"1
.e-
CAN
ilt
\t-
\
5.
\
.l
$N
A
2
u
tr
J(l)t
TvE
dN
$
.)
co
s/a
(o
N
A
\
tto,
Rq
N
F-N
FF
x
&
?rF
V
a/
@c!
(
\('I
t6
'-i'J
o
(f)
\\
:
\.._r\
t.
\tL
\
.I:xts:
\
-(a
sq_
,-d
-I
c.i(9
;
\.1>
s
j
C\
s:
\q
c-1
c"j
CO
i
\
\
\
'\
1^\-\l\\
sf
CO
\i
4
{
{-il
w
a/
r-11
.z-
ri
t\
N
Nx
3
-<
x
'x\\\
\
\
.\
F-(e
\:
-
Cv
\J
d(a
,v
:$
.-
'i,zl
,tl
oi(o;N (o(o
.9)o
0
oz
tru
tU
Lu
tUFFg
- r.l4,-r,1 EoU-E g
F-b() OZc.t g oLll ^o o
=N B E6 EE EJ> t or.u- o E
Hn
OOz
tUaf
oz
J
76
tF\t)
r'{(
F+
oZ
,tr/
/1?Nvr(s4s-.u s\.\ )$,Y -NCY
1\))'J*'a+
\--
)_
\Vf
r({a\ rl\r -v
=$\{\bel+l.\r\l
G
{
s
tr
sftl\t
,/l
(
2
JJd{Ir -a)11 \ 5YS?\ \* 't \J
€dd
N]
C-
\
-!
-e
YC
_8"tt
,J\\,N
\J
-I-N
N-.1>-o6NriN\U
'd Sr-r { \)
YGP
.NJ\JY$tG.i
\adys*\JJN]\ss
)\
\
\
\,\)
RJ)
e.\ \
\\,^t-\\\*),v\\t^
t\\:'\c'.\
a\
,\\
I
77