C6A-Report- July 29 2015 Land Use And Development Committee MeetingMIAMI BEACH
City of Miomi Beoch, I700 Convention Center Drive, Miomi Beoch, Florido 33,l39, www.miomibeochfl.gov
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor Phllip Levine and Members 0f the City
FROM: Jimmy L. Morales, City Manager
DATE: September 2,2015
SUBJECT: LAND USE AND DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE MEETING OF JULY 29,2015
A Land Use and Development Committee meeting was held on July 29,2015. Land Use
Committee Members in attendance were Commissioners Joy Malakoff and Ed Tobin.
Commissioners Micky Steinberg and Michael Grieco were also in attendance. Members
from the Administration, including, Jimmy Morales, Thomas Mooney, RaulAguila, Margarita
Wells, Eve Boutsis, Eric Carpenter, Saul Frances, Michael Belush, and Rogelio Madan, as
well as members of public, were also in attendance. Please see the attached sign-in sheet.
The meeting was called to order at 11:02 AM.
1. DISGUSSION ON POSSIBLE AMENDMENTS TO CHAPTER 6 AND GHAPTER 142
OF THE CITY CODE.
(coNTtNUED FROM THE JUNE 17,2015 LUDC MEETTNG
SPONSORED BY GOMMISSIONER JONAH WOLFSON
SEPTEMBER 10. 20{4 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4O)
VERBAL REPORT
MOTION: The item was removed from the agenda by Acclamation.
2. DISCUSSION ON THE COLLINS CANAL PROJECT.
(RETURNTNG FROM THE MAY 27,2015 LUDC MEETTNG
SPONSORED BY CITY COMMISSION
SEPTEMBER 10. 2014 CITY COMMTSSTON MEETING, ITEM RgG)
VERBAL REPORT
AFTER.ACT!ON:
Eric Carpenter provided a brief presentation on the interim project.
MOTION: Continued to the November 18,2015 meeting by Acclamation.
3. a) ANNUAL EVALUATION OF PARKING IMPACT FEE STRUCTURE.
(RETURNING FROM THE MAy 27,2015 LUDC MEETTNG
SPONSORED BY CITY COMMISSION
Agenda ltem C GA
Date /-J-/-F251
Repoft of the Land Use & Development Committee Meeting of July 29, 2015
Page 2 of 2
SEPTEMBER 17. 2014 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM R7E)
VERBAL REPORT
MOTION: Continued to the September 9,2015 meeting by Acclamation.
b) DtscusstoN REGARDTNG THE PHTLOSOPHY BEHTND PARKTNG IMPACT FEES
(RETURNING FROM THE MAY 27,2015 LUDC MEETING
SPONSORED BY COMMISSIONER JONAH WOLFSON
NOVEMBER 19. 20{4 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4J)
VERBAL REPORT
MOTION: The item was removed from the agenda by Acclamation.
4. DISCUSSION REGARDING SEAWALL CONDITIONS, ENCROACHMENTS
INTO PUBLIC PROPERTY FOR PRIVATE USE.
(RETURNTNG FROM THE MAY 27,2015 LUDC MEETING
SPONSORED BY CITY GOMMISSION
FEBRUARY 1{.2015 CITY GOMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4J)
VERBAL REPORT
AFTER.ACTION:
Eric Carpenter introduced the item.
Commissioner Tobin expressed concerns over the funding of seawall improvements.
Raul Aguila discussed the possibility of funding sea wall improvements using storm water
management funds.
MOTION: Continued to the September 9,2015 meeting by Acclamation.
5. DISCUSSION REGARDING THE PROVISION OF RENEWABLE ENERGY SOURCES
IN NEW CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS.
(CoNTINUED FROM THE JUNE 17,2015 LUDC MEETING
SPONSORED BY COMMISSIONER MICKY STEINBERG
MAY 6. 2015 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4H)
AFTER-ACTION:
Margarita Wells introduced the item and the need for LEED Standards.
Rogelio Madan described the details of the Ordinance amendment and statistics regarding
the average size of homes within the City.
Commissioner Steinberg described the process that has been undertaken to develop the
Ordinance.
Committee members discussed the scale of buildings to which the LEED regulations would
apply.
MOTION: 2-0 (ET/JM)
Recommend that the City Commission refer the Ordinance to the Planning Board with a
modification that the LEED requirement applies to construction 7,000 SF and over, and that
focus groups be held with construction professionals.
252
Repoft of the Land Use & Development Committee Meeting of July 29, 201 5
Page 3 of 3
6. SIDEWALK CAFE OCEAN DRIVE UMBRELLAS
AN ORDINANCE OF THE MAYOR AND CIry COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI
BEACH, FLORIDA, AMENDING CHAPTER 82, ENTITLED "PUBLIC PROPERTY,"
ARTTCLE lV, ENTITLED "USES lN PUBLIC RIGHTS-OF-WAY," DIVISION 5,
ENTITLED "SIDEWALK CAFES," SUBDIVISION 2, ENTITLED "PERMlr," BY
CREATING SECTION 82.389, ENTITLED "ADDITIONAL MINIMUM STANDARDS,
CRITERIA, AND CONDITIONS FOR OPERATION OF SIDEWALK CAFES ON OGEAN
DRIVE BETWEEN sTH STREET AND 15TH STREET" TO PROVIDE MINIMUM
STANDARDS FOR UMBRELLAS AND AWNINGS, REQU!RE REGULAR
MAINTENANCE OF UMBRELLAS, AND PROVIDE PROHIBITIONS; AND
PROVIDING FOR REPEALER, SEVERABILITY, CODIFICATION, AND AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
(GoNTINUED FROM THE JUNE 17,2015 LUDC MEETING
SPONSORED BY CITY COMMISSION
MAY 20. 2015 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM RsB)
MOTION: Continued to the October 7,2015 meeting by Acclamation.
7. DISCUSSION REGARDING GRADE ELEVATIONS FOR NEW CONSTRUCTION.
(RETURNTNG FROM THE JUNE 17,2015 LUDC MEETING
SPONSORED BY CITY COMMISSION
JUNE 10. 2015 GITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4E)
MOTION: Continued to the October 7,2015 meeting by Acclamation.
8, DISCUSSION REGARDING TRAFFIC STUDIES.
(RETURNTNG FROM THE JUNE 17,2015 LUDC MEETING
SPONSORED BY COMMISSIONER MIGKY STEINBERG
JUNE 10. 2015 CITY GOMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4H)
AFTER.ACTION:
Thomas Mooney introduced the item.
MOTION: 2-0 (ET/JM)
Continue the item to the September 9,2015 meeting and recommend that the City
Commission refer the item to the Planning Board.
9. PROPOSED REVISIONS TO CHAPTER 126 OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT
REGULATIONS OF THE CITY CODE, PERTAINING TO LANDSCAPING AND
MINIMUM STANDARDS FOR THE LANDSCAPING OF PRIVATE PROPERTIES AND
ADDING A REQUIREMENT FOR A TREE SURVEY PRIOR TO THE ISSUANCE OF A
DEMOLITION PERMIT.
(RETURNTNG FROM THE JUNE 17,2015 LUDC MEETING
SPONSORED BY GOMMISSIONER JOY MALAKOFF
JUNE {0. 2015 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM G4I)
AFTER.ACTION:
Thomas Mooney introduced the item.
253
Report of the Land Use & Development Committee Meeting of July 29, 2015
Page 4 of 4
Commissioner Malakoff requested that GTAG's amendments be incorporated into the
Ordinance.
MOTION: 2-0 (ET/JM)
Continue the item to the September 9,2015 meeting.
10. AMENDMENT TO CHAPTER f 30 OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS
TO MODIFY MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS FOR OFF STREET LOADING SPAGES.
(RETURNTNG FROM THE JUNE 17,2015 LUDC MEETING
SPONSORED BY COMMISSIONER DEEDE WEITHORN
JUNE 10.20{5, ITEM C4J)
AFTER.AGTION:
Thomas Mooney introduced the item.
MOTION: 2-0 (ET/JM)
Recommend that the City Commission refer the proposed Ordinance to the Planning Board.
11. DISCUSSION: LEGAL OPINION CONCERNING WHETHER A VACANCY ON THE
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD RENDERS THE BOARD IMPROPERLY
CONSTITUTED AND WITHOUT POWER TO ACT, AND TO DISCUSS AN
AMENDMENT TO SEC.2-22(21) TO REQUTRE THE MAYOR AND CITY GOMMTSSTON
TO FILL BOARD VAGANCIES WITHIN 90 DAYS.
(RETURNING FROM THE JUNE 17,2015 LUDC MEETING
SPONSORED BY VICE-MAYOR JONAH WOLFSON
JUNE 10. 2015 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4M)
VERBAL REPORT
MOTION: Continued to the September 9,2015 meeting by Acclamation.
12. DTSCUSSION REGARDING AMENDING THE CITY GHARTER AND CITY CODE TO
PROVIDE THAT, INSTEAD OF THE BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT, THE GHIEF
SPECIAL MASTER SHALL HEAR AND DECIDE APPEALS FROM, AND REVIEW,
ANY ORDER, REQUIREMENTS, DECISION OR DETERMINATION MADE BY AN
ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICIAL GHARGED WITH THE ENFORCEMENT OF THE
ZONING ORDINANCE OF THE GITY OF MIAMI BEACH.
(spoNSoRED BY VICE MAYOR JONAH WOLFSON)
JUNE 10. 2015 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM RgL)
VERBAL REPORT
MOTION: Continued to the September 9,2015 meeting by Acclamation.
13. DISCUSSION REGARDING RFP FOR ELECTRIC VEHICLE CHARGING STATIONS
FOR CITY PARKING FAGILITIES.
(SPoNSORED BY C!ry COMMISSION
JULY 8. 2015 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM G2B)
254
Report of the Land Use & Development Commiltee Meeting of July 29, 2015
Page 5 of 5
AFTER.AGTION:
Margarita Wells introduced the item.
Rogelio Madan described the details of the Ordinance.
Members of the public addressed the Committee.
Saul Frances made suggestions regarding the applicability of the Ordinance.
MOTION: 2-0 (ET/JM)
Recommend that the City Commission refer the Ordinance to the Planning Board with an
amendment establishing a minimum applicability requirement, and the amendments
recommended by Commissioner Steinberg.
14. DISCUSSION ON A PROPOSED ORDINANCE AMENDMENT TO MODIFY THE
MINIMUM FRONT AND SIDE SETBACK, AND MINIMUM PERVIOUS AREA
REQUIREMENTS FOR SINGLE FAMILY HOMES, AS WELL AS SIMPLIFYING THE
REGULATIONS PERTAINING TO THE CALCULATION OF UNIT SIZE AND LOT
COVERAGE.
(spoNSoRED BY COMMTSSTONER JOY MALAKOFF
JULY 8. 2015 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4G)
AFTER.AGTION:
Thomas Mooney introduced the item and described the details of the proposed Ordinance.
Commissioner Grieco had concerns over the size of homes and speculative development.
Members of the public addressed the committee.
Commissioner Tobin suggested that focus groups be held to study the proposed Ordinance.
Commissioner Tobin expressed concern with smaller lots.
MOTION: 2-0 (ET/JM)
Continue the item to the September 9,2015 meeting. The Administration was instructed to
identify homes constructed in accordance with recently adopted regulations.
15. DISGUSSION PERTAINING TO MAIN USE PARKING STRUCTURE HEIGHT LIMITS
ON TERMINAL ISLAND.
(SPoNSORED BY ClrY COMMISSION
JULY 8. 2015 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM G4D)
VERBAL REPORT
AFTER.ACTION:
The City Manager provided an overview of the item.
Michael Larkin addressed the committee on behalf of Fisher Island.
MOTION: 2-0 (ET/JM)
Continue the item to the September 9,2015 meeting.
16. DISCUSSION REGARDING ADDITIONAL HEIGHT !N THE ALTON ROAD PARKING
DISTRICT FOR PROJECTS THAT PROVIDE STRUGTURED PARKING.
(SPoNSORED BY COMMISSIONER JOY MALAKOFF
JULY 8. 2015 CIry COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4F)
VERBAL REPORT
255
Report of the Land Use & Development Committee Meeting of July 29, 201 5
Page 6 of 6
AFTER-AGTION: Continued to the September 9,2015 meeting by Acclamation.
17. DISCUSSION REGARDING WITHDRAWING THE PROPOSED ORDINANCE
ASSIGNED FILE NO(SI.: 2233, 2234, AND 2235 (ALL RELATED TO ALGOHOL
BEVERAGE REGULATTONS) FROM THE PLANNTNG BOARD',S JURISDIGTION.
(spoNSoRED BY COMMISSIONER JONAH WOLFSON
JULy 8. 2015 CtrY COMMTSSTON MEETING, ITEM RgS)
AFTER.ACTION:
Thomas Mooney introduced the item.
Members of the public addressed the committee.
MOTION: 2-0 (ET/JM)
Prepare an overlay study for alcoholic beverage establishments along Alton Road, within the
West Avenue Area and bring the study back to the Land Use and Development Committee
on September 9, 2015.
MOTION: 2-0 (JM/ET)
Recommend that the City Commission refer the draft Ordinance amendments for Chapter
114, 142, and Option A for Chapter 6, with the recommended amendments to the Planning
Board.
nfih
JLM/TRM/RAM
M:\$CMB\CCUPDATES\Land Use and Development Committee\2o15\July 29, 201s\Report of the July 29, 2015 LUDC Meeting.docx
256
'\ i ( 'i.?*1, rU
oo
IIJtoo
J
=I
IIJ
.\
\)
.l+<*+
G)
N
F{J>t
l
)
--:..{\
'1
!_.
,s)
c)
(
ll
\
Cr
(:
Q,
€
)a
G)
{
I
\r(<)S
t
L]
\l
\
s
t\-\
@
L
:J.
YV
(
,.-}
I
E
<-
e)
a
af{
:!.=*
)
"f.
:>,:
..P
._J
e)
N\)
-AJ
\5J r-.),'-;
=
l.=
._s
<_
tra>S
.\
-\{)*
j
\
a)
(
)-
*-\-
S(J
-"1t
t
J
,5S-+
a)
,{s
)-J-s
,.d
\
o\'(
\
N
@
')
NJ\
tSt
\
!
i
{
\
\t:
@
I)t
\
\.'J
a:
\-((
-
,.1,
c)
+g
l-
E{
Jy1..
J.F
-l
G)
n
,-i-=
io
L
o;
-\s
INu_
-Y
)
rfi
i
),)
),
{t
@)0
J))I
D
[<
s,
s.lr
t
<)
c')
5
,>-
G)
€F
)A-L
19
at-oP
,t2
q
i.1..-;1:
.(
\)
Q)
a/{.
N4.c
\5
v
X
,iJ)2A.l
1*
F
a)
,)
J)x
i 1,,
c-J,2
)o
C\
-cI
d
,
G)
\)>
\,
.{u
n/-
{'
o
tu
\
0
N
@
"!
N
S.
sL
oz
UJ(,
u-{+<F(Jq=
fi9o=
HH
Pd
!
U'
=
n
tr
UJ
m
=fz
Fo
Fzoo
$
I-t
.D<
i
O
\)
R
1J-
t\
a,
Cd
r+.,
"C
r^i
J
(';
l*i
(-
1J
atr\
p
f-l
-Dr\
c\
l-\o
l')
\n
\l\o
1
-0
\n
,J
FOtr
'J.
,lr\-
-l
I
\7'
$
"t\\s-\-.S
N\q)
+
\
lF
f-.'[)
cS
I
,*ry
-\9'--t"
1--
rn
(()
ll+'\
v
\
I
!l
V\\
')
tN
\
tr
f--
\^
\-
c..'\)
rrl
its
.lp
\s:
\(-t
\'(\
(--
rt-
\
h\
r.f.u
J
N
i
,o
un1
"/)L
,{
,:)
T
)
ur
C
,,2
oo
\r.
OJtn
I
(,*A
aJ
I
.t9
Aof
nr
ol
,..\l
II
,/)
14r)
0a,
D
:5
r l\l
,1-tl
"-
Cr'\
\S
iEf
r\
?aIAA
sts-o
?.
r'
\
\
N
a
N
$..\
0
M otr(u
oof
EcoJ
U)t!F
o(L
foo
@
=o@
IJJ
=z
>/-
"Jdn-t\
['
..5dri
;
t
s.
.t
\L
{,l
-s
I"t\
c.i
J.\
)
}
I\
'ts
.{3N
co
.J\-q
-_93T
{.;3
cd
(o
\
"S\
s
.S
(
Y')
J
F-
\Yn[
T
r
"\5
=5
s-
!/-\
o,ci
L\
\-\
'\J
\-r
t_
\,
J
)\
-
!-z(t
s=t
a
c.i
!...*\\o
:
S
c"j
),2
\9
A-+I
)a
o
J-a,
E
+r
cp.E
Ft
(o
')J\:'\\\-,\.
-.-)(/
T
'1
c-i
J
\J
t-
-)(.
t),-\
-l
'-\i\.f
)
d
<
a)
\Je-
-{
A
t'v
o,
)
\
$
\i
oc{
xo
,a;
(\
oo-cU)
:E
E
.sro
ro
oN
oc)
=E
Eoo
c
0)
Eo.
-9o
oo
oz
tr
tU
Lu
=tU
r.u
Fa
=$n,1 coU-E IFEO 661s I
=R B E
H 2^.F E\r.-=LJ5 t or.IJ -o tHr
OOz
IU
U)f
oz
257
J
-{
o
U'
IIJtroo
J
=I
IJJ
Jr
g.J
\
$-(\
s
{
@)
a-\(J
s.
s
,')
'!
!
+g
or
a)
N\l
(J
J5
G)G)G)G)@ G)a)
s-\tL
i:5ir
@
d
qI-
c,
s
v.E
'-l
.i
a)
9
_j
C
'-)
--\t\l's
s
($I
C).\-
a)
+
]
;-\J
)
r
U)J
\
a)(
i.lN\J.\i
Is
\
\
$
$
a)
$
-l
e
C
s-
tss:
i\
\a
c--a
c)
-s
\.)
\st
\('
1\
G)
r\
q$
1
G)
t\,\ :
J,_]t'rvl(.
:
13
N
L-q
a)
t
U+l//>
€
<5
F
\rl\A;
--)Irr 'rl
XS
lrS
G)
I i.,\)\)
"J
I
r-t
.\:
d\'\
.. d\.\
o-\
Sv
c\--':-
)a-hl
:S,
Y\\-
X()
,r;
N
0,
o)
o
;
.9)o(,
oNoo
E
Eoo
o)
Eo.
-9o
oo
Ec(E
o)ol
EcoJoutF
=
[J
I
c
u4
=o=2.Jui
JOI<Iq
z=,
^IJ E
#n
:uJ
I
2
B
\\\
tr
uJ
m
=fz
Fo
Fzoo
N
N
\
"r!'\
/"\
{L(:.l
x(
"t
r.\-
,t )
C)c"6
^a\()
\
\\,\
,a\
\4in
\t\^
(/'t)
\|
\fr
C
:"rir
Irt
I
L
*
jr
'f
{')
-a
t\^
O
Lr'
fi
{
c
tA
..i-
\JJ
,i
r\
\
V'trr
-j)
-\<-)
(---
lrr',.C
N
-J(
sl J
\p
I
\rl()
.l
\L
f-(-
I,l\-zt
-S\rrt
C
$\r
.\J
;
0(
T
Vocn
a\
\\\
I
NN
\
N
€N
NrA
OoStr-\-
Ltl
M,a
(!
t
\
t
S
!
'0(tr
<l
rT
I
r
-l
(
(-
)
GS
M
N,sN
An
u
(J
m
fr
\\td
\a
\
N
h\
(-)
\>\\.t
'r\t3
\s
CC
I!
=z
N
,-\
\
*N-\;
a\
L
(
(-i
1Lz
I
C
e
NAl
o
\\\
S
:
c
"t
\
c.jN
t\\5=t
a.-\
\-
C..\
stN
--r-.J
c--q
U
q
dN
\
N-J
:
f+u
\9
(o
N
t
Ua:?
v
-\.
\}--f-J
IrN
?
)
J
AJ
xiN
:-,4\
e
-^)\-)
t"/
C
oiN
T\._a
a--l:f
-
:
o
cf)
3
0.,*
Y
1ql
l.,<
-(a
eh-n
{
=
-q)>)/
-i
+
r-CS<
c.i(r)
-sa'(
q
al
-=*(-
-)1
(f)(9
$
\
G
\.
SI
\\
s
st
(f,
S
_3a.
-s?
Crq
.D
(-
-g
r()
(f,
-J\
\
-I
C\
a.
q
F
(o
(f)
r
5
3C/,'/
F-
(f)
.\
Y,
{s
as
=+.+\s.-a.
d(o
\i
\u
In
UJ,\
J
oi(o
\{i
rL
f'.4\\
\
\--S
:osl
oz
tr
IU
I.U
]U
lU
Fg.
=-o1,-+J/1 coSuoE IFEO 6fr1s I
=R
B EH 2"'F E\rr-=LJ5 t ollJ -o E
HaoOz
tU
U)f
oz
258