C6A-Report- September 9 2015 Land Use And Development Committee MeetingMIAMIBEACH
City of Miomi Beoch, I200 Convention Center Drive, Miomi Beoch, Florido 33,l39, www.miomibeochfl.gov
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM
TO.Mayor Philip Levine and Members Cf the City C
FROM: Jimmy L. Morales, City Manager
DATE: October 14,2015
SUBJECT: LAND USE AND DEVELOPMENT C MMITTEE MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 9,2015
A Land Use and Development Committee meeting was held on September 9,2015. Land
Use Committee Members in attendance were Commissioners Joy Malakoff, Jonah Wolfson
and Ed Tobin. Commissioners Micky Steinberg, Michael Grieco, and Deede Weithorn were
also in attendance. Members from the Administration, including, Thomas Mooney, Eve
Boutsis, Eric Carpenter, Jose Gonzalez, Jay Fink, and Michael Belush, as well as members
of public, were also in attendance. Please see the attached sign-in sheet.
The meeting was called to order at 3:03 PM.
1. DISCUSSION ON PROPOSED AMENDMENTS TO THE LAND DEVELOPMENT
REGULATIONS TO REMOVE THE EXISTING 'SUNSET' PROVISTON FOR PARKING
DlsTRlcT NO. 5 (SUNSET HARBOR) AND TO CLARIFY THE CONDTTTONAL USE
REQU!REMENTS IN THE CD.2 DISTRICT.
(RETURNTNG FROM THE SEPTEMBER 3,2014 LUDC MEETTNG
SPONSORED BY CITY GOMMISSION
JULY 23,2014 CITY COMMISSION METING !TEM, C4L)
AFTER.ACTION
Thomas Mooney provided an overview and history on the item.
MOTION: No further action by acclamation
2. DISCUSSION REGARDING SEAWALL CONDITTONS, ENCROACHMENTS
INTO PUBLIC PROPERTY FOR PRIVATE USE.
(RETURNTNG FROM THE JULY 29,2015 LUDC MEETING
SPONSORED BY CITY COMMISSION
FEBRUARY 11.2015 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4J)
VERBAL REPORT
AFTER.ACTION:
Jay Fink provided an overview and update regarding seawall encroachments into public
wateruvays and indicated the policy now is to allow rebuilding seaward once up to the width
of a seawall (18 inches), otherwise demolition of existing seawall and construction of a new
seawallwithin the property is required.
Agenda ttem C6 Aoate_w189
Report of the Land Use & Development Committee Meeting of September 9, 2015
Page 2 of 5
MOTION: No further action by acclamation
3. DISCUSSION REGARDING TRAFFIC STUDIES.
(RETURNTNG FROM THE JULy 29,2015 LUDC MEETTNG
SPONSORED BY COMMISSIONER MICKY STEINBERG
JUNE 10. 2015 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4H)
AFTER.ACT!ON:
Thomas Mooney introduced the item.
Jose Gonzalez indicated that thresholds are being developed as part of a citywide
Transportation Management plan.
MOTION: Continued to October 7,2015 by acclamation
4. PROPOSED REVISIONS TO CHAPTER 126 OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT
REGULATIONS OF THE CITY CODE, PERTAINING TO LANDSGAPING AND
MINIMUM STANDARDS FOR THE LANDSCAPING OF PRIVATE PROPERTIES AND
ADDING A REQUIREMENT FOR A TREE SURVEY PRIOR TO THE ISSUANCE OF A
DEMOLITION PERMIT.
(RETURNTNG FROM THE JULY 29,2015 LUDC MEETTNG
SPONSORED BY COMMISSIONER JOY MALAKOFF
JUNE 10. 2015 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4I)
VERBAL REPORT
MOTION: Continued to November 18, 2015by Acclamation
5. DISGUSSION: LEGAL OPINION CONCERNING WHETHER A VACANCY ON THE
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD RENDERS THE BOARD IMPROPERLY
CONSTITUTED AND WITHOUT POWER TO ACT, AND TO DISCUSS AN
AMENDMENT TO SEC.2-22(21) TO REQUTRE THE MAYOR AND Ctry COMMTSSTON
TO FILL BOARD VACANCIES WITHIN 90 DAYS.
(RETURNTNG FROM THE JULY 29,2015 LUDC MEETTNG
SPONSORED BY VICE.MAYOR JONAH WOLFSON
JUNE 10. 2015 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4M)
VERBAL REPORT
AFTER.ACTION:
Eve Boutsis provided an overview and background on the item
MOTION: Continued to October 7,2015 by acclamation
6. DISCUSSION REGARDING AMENDING THE CIry CHARTER AND CIry CODE TO
PROVIDE THAT, INSTEAD OF THE BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT, THE CHTEF
SPECIAL MASTER SHALL HEAR AND DECIDE APPEALS FROM, AND REVIEW,
ANY ORDER, REQUIREMENTS, DECISION OR DETERMINATION MADE BY AN
ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICIAL CHARGED WITH THE ENFORCEMENT OF THE
ZONING ORDINANCE OF THE GITY OF M!AM! BEACH.
(RETURNTNG FROM THE JULY 29,2015 LUDC MEETTNG
SPoNSORED By VICE MAYOR JONAH WOLFSON)
JUNE 10. 2015 CITY GOMMISSION MEETING, ITEM RgL)
190
Report of the Land Use & Development Commiltee Meeting of September 9, 2015
Page 3 of 5
VERBAL REPORT
AFTER.ACT!ON:
Eve Boutsis provided an overview and background on the item.
MOTION: Continued to October 7,2015 by acclamation.
7. DISCUSSION ON A PROPOSED ORDINANCE AMENDMENT TO MODIFY THE
MINIMUM FRONT AND SIDE SETBACK, AND MINIMUM PERVIOUS AREA
REQUIREMENTS FOR SINGLE FAMILY HOMES, AS WELL AS SIMPLIFYING THE
REGULATIONS PERTAINING TO THE CALCULATION OF UNIT SIZE AND LOT
COVERAGE.
(RETURNTNG FROM THE JULY 29,2015 LUDC MEETTNG
SPONSORED BY COMMISSIONER JOY MALAKOFF
JULY 8. 2015 CIry COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4C}
AFTER.ACTION:
Thomas Mooney introduced the item.
Commissioner Weithorn expressed the need to maintain pervious landscaped area.
Members of the public addressed the Committee.
Commissioner Malakoff recommended the Ordinance be bifurcated.
Commissioner Wolfson indicated that the proposed changes are not an undue restriction on
property rights and supports contextually compatible homes.
Commissioner Tobin indicated support for increased setbacks only at this time.
Commissioner Steinberg indicated that compatibility is a key concern.
Commissioner Weithorn recommended that the Ordinance be bifurcated.
Commissioner Grieco agreed with bifurcation and discussed types of ownership.
Commissioner Malakoff recommended study of larger lots vs. smaller lots, including
waterfront vs. non-waterfront lots be studied for further analysis, and possibility of a larger
unit size to be reviewed by DRB
Commissioner Tobin indicated that all homeowners should be notified of proposed changes.
MOTION: JWJM (2-1)
Recommend that the City Commission refer the proposed Ordinance as drafted to the
Planning Board.
8. DISCUSSION PERTAINING TO MAIN USE PARKING STRUCTURE HEIGHT LIMITS
ON TERMINAL ISLAND.
(RETURNTNG FROM THE JULY 29,2015 LUDC MEETTNG
SPONSORED BY CITY COMMISSION
JULY 8. 2015 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4D)
VERBAL REPORT
MOTION: Continued to the November 18,2015 meeting by acclamation.
9. DISCUSSION REGARDING ADDITIONAL HEIGHT IN THE ALTON ROAD PARKING
DISTRICT FOR PROJECTS THAT PROVIDE STRUCTURED PARKING.
(RETURNTNG FROM THE JULY 29,2015 LUDC MEETTNG
SPONSORED BY COMMISSIONER JOY MALAKOFF
JULY 8. 2015 GIry GOMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4F)
VERBAL REPORT
191
Report of the Land Use & Development Committee Meeting of September g, 2015
Page 4 of 5
AFTER.AGTION:
Mickey Marrero and Alex Heckler provided a summary of the proposal pertaining to
increased height of 10 feet and modifications to setbacks in CD-2 Districts.
MOTION: JWJM (2-1)
Recommend that the City Commission refer an Ordinance based upon the submitted proffer
to the Planning Board.
10. PROPOSED ALTON ROAD ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE ESTABLISHMENT OVERLAY.
(REQUESTED BY THE LUDC COMMITTEE
JULY 29. 2015 LUDC MEETTNG)
AFTER.AGTION:
Commissioner Malakoff recommended moving forward with a draft Ordinance. Hours in
Sunset Harbor neighborhood and South of Fifth neighborhood should be reviewed as a
guide.
Commissioner Tobin indicated that 100 foot buffer is too small.
MOTION: Administration directed to prepare a draft Ordinance and bring back to LUDC on
October 7,2015 meeting by acclamation.
11. DISGUSSION REGARDING ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES AS A CONDITIONAL ISSUE
IN COMMERCIAL DISTRIGTS.
(SPoNSORED BY MAYOR PHtLtP LEVTNE
JULY 31. 2015 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4A)
AFTER.AGTION:
Thomas Mooney introduced the item.
Javier Fernandez representing 1667 Alton Road provided comment.
Commissioner Malakoff was not supportive.
Commissioner Tobin opposed the concept.
Commissioner Wolfson indicated that it may be a bad idea.
Dr. Morris sunshine provided public comment opposing the proposal
MOTION: ET/JM (3-0)
No further action to be taken and no recommendation to move forward.
12. DISCUSSION REGARDING THE VACATION OF A PORTION OF THE ALLEY
BETWEEN ALTON ROAD AND WEST AVENUE, JUST SOUTH OF 17TH STREET -
AS PART OF A PROPOSED MIXED USE PROJECT THAT WILL INCLUDE
RESIDENTIAL, RETAIL AND STRUCTURED PARKING, INCLUDING PUBLIC
PARKING.
(SPoNSORED BY COMMTSSTONER JOy MALAKOFF
SEPTEMBER 2. 2015 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4I)
VERBAL REPORT
MOTION: Continued to the October 7,2015 meeting by acclamation.
13. PROPOSED AMENDMENT TO SECTION 146.306 - DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS
IN THE CD.2 COMMERCIAL MEDIUM INTENSIry DISTRICT.
(SPoNSORED BY COMMTSSTONER MICHAEL GRTECO
192
Repoft of the Land Use & Development Committee Meeting of September 9, 2015
Page 5 of 5
SEPTEMBER 2. 2015 C!ry COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM C4J)
VERBAL REPORT
MOTION: Continued to the October 7,2015 meeting by acclamation.
14. WASHINGTON AVENUE ZONING INCENTIVES
AN ORDINANCE OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
MIAMI BEAGH, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE LAND DEVELOPMENT
REGULATIONS (LDR's) OF THE CITY CODE, BY AMENDING CHAPTER 142,
"zoNlNG DtsTRlcTS AND REGULATIONS," ARTICLE !1, ,,DISTRICT
REGULATIONS," DIVISION 5, "CD.2 COMMERCIAL, MEDIUM INTENSITY
DISTRICT," TO ESTABLISH SEGTION 13.309, "WASHINGTON AVENUE
DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS AND AREA REQUIREMENTS," TO MODIFY
THE DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS FOR PROPERTIES FRONTING
WASHINGTON AVENUE BETWEEN 6TH STREET AND LINGOLN ROAD; BY
AMENDING CHAPTER 130, "OFF-STREET PARK!NG," ARTICLE II,
"DISTRICTS; REQUIREMENTS," TO ESTABLISH PARKING DISTRICT 7 TO
MODIFY THE PARKING REQUIREMENTS FOR THE PROPERTTES
FRONTING WASHINGTON AVENUE BETWEEN 6TH STREET AND LINGOLN;
PROVIDING FOR CODIFICATION; REPEALER; SEVERABILIW; AND AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
(spoNSoRED By COMMTSSTONER JOy MALAKOFF
SEPTEMBER 2. 2015 CITY COMMISSION MEETING, ITEM RsE)
VERBAL REPORT
MOTION: Continued to the October 7,2015 meeting by acclamation.
fhe meeting adiourned at 5:30 p.m./\- '4
JLM/SMT/TRM/MAB
T:\AGENDA\201S\OctobeAPLANNlNG\Report of the September 9, 2015 LUDC Meeting.docx
193
5I G)
!o
)
+
i=
(l)
9o
\I-'l-IP.-
TTI, vtsIf
(,
)t
\z\(r. \
Tt
C-
d
(
J\
J
C\.
(/)
P->c-
7.c,r
T
a
-rof
T)
Cr'c
sI{\.\'l.
C.
-\tir
n
d( (li
OJ5.t
-\.\)
i
)
\
\J\
(t,'
J
$'.{V\*
G)(])
dYH
.).t
!<*
(
-(--xvlS
rr-.
(,
I\)
rr
I.-t
(-
t
V1
3
=^-?-,
Si
Ya+S
\J
N\
Y
(,)I
L-/\
2u-
e
t_/(\\
^,
I
N)
to
^{.t- \
'i\-n
.)
oLt
(.f)
2'?-\
90
+
)
C{
&
N:
D
t)
t
L
;
a,
(n
{
t
NP
-
a:
i
n
F
N)I
C(t\
(--
!l/
(
I
f
N)
!^)
It"'
4.,
J
d--l
L.
N)N
/_
I
-.t
fl)r'
N)i
-\
F,{-
I
\\\ I
z
=m
,3t
i\
t'\-.I
v
-$,
G'g
wt
-r-
-S)\^.r
I
-L!>J
v(
Y
>-\
t,
"\
I
U,o,
(:
V\)
df
&o
\..,i
e
kj
\,J
Cvl
-U
r\
o
I
"1
I
\
*l{
I\r
s'j
\
C\
{
rJ
t:
I
J,o<
\,
<-'
Ns'-.
(
CJir)
lS.
I
oq
=S
!a\o-
\r.)o-
--s,
U\
Co-{
\-x)(}
J-(
I
rf\
ur'
>r
I
-k-&
>
s
I+
-nJli+
\
o
txj
1-
\l
v
,/1\J.
4
,J
_F)
JJ\!
*>.1
\
\\,(,
\-'
.A
r;l
O
\J-
,<)
-$f-
I.$orJ
-x,
*r\5.t
)
q
o
f.
?.\
|-
3\
-?
v$
5
}{,ci\
(\^
a\
\4.a
ooz{
o{
zc
=trmv
\(\
\\
(
\\
\\\\\
=
aE
Fd
Hn
TR
=E
>-Oml1I -a4>zl
o
I
m
o
v-\,(t
C.s
on++
T.\i\-
sFt\-
-l- '
[=I-I ,x\VI,J\r-3r
C-
(o
-l,o
c-
N
-S
st:
C\.
ia
J
\r\,
o
r(''
-ti
I
-
\
a>
(o
]!+a
U)
[.
L
llr\
t(\
\lir
t
o
{"\
&;
i
\'$\.
a,q
i1.
N.
(o
\N
it_
n)
Nt\\
t\
\;
v*
rc.on\q
r\)-vt
.td1sf!o
Ej
(.
--J/'F{
rn
-<i-
o
Lr)s
,fi
O
T[\
F'?fl'15
E
F
pL
F
r
o
:(\st
Nl:\n\)
o
.-+-
-+-N
a-t
.f)
(o
J
t_
t
)
h\'lr
U0)\
r\,
il{o
\-)ej
jr."
c
s
z
(o
t'
5
,
tu{
2
P
(
t
,:
\\'
1\\
L
(o
e)
p\
F
t)
H4n
a
o
\
21-
N
l\
:\,
;--
\.
\
a
C\f,
o
\'
(\
\
-:-{
I
T
.O-
'S- L
o
o
-s
,q)
.>-s
f\(
at
a:?\
o
-tr
^J\
o
t
;.r
--
a?
1'
-r->'
rc-
o'\
;i
i>
E
\..i
o
€,>\
C/l
c\J
-
:
mI
=r
oo7maa
r
zo
Co
m
zoo€H
F qSF
= =0oL =.J -rg s*;o 6'Y rno = aZ9 QL-{6 d qP
O = =\JFl J \)l-Sv
u' -{-{m
m
mm-{zo
+oi aa\--r\
ao
@ooCllo
-.1m
@
l-
0,
CLcluo
0)
o.
o(D
!qo!,3o
f
C)o
3
3
oo
o
Ora
@f
afo(b
NJ
i^
oox
194
=
-tm
Coo
A'fo.
c)o
3
3
oo
No
Ja5oo
N)
Ur
ir.o()
X
I
51c
:
o
s
N)P
iS\'lsls'
s.
s\.
1
\
(o
J*
9o
--.\. \
.-\
=--6
.
7
i\\
2
>l
(I''*
r-[
J
C\
3o
Z(^\
o)s,
S\\
\
$\
N.l'
Nr
s
S\ 9\-s\i
iJ
Nt\)
N
s,,
*l
;
Y'
i)
l,/
b.r
-.i
N
>t
/c
,t,|n-l
')\
:'
('
7v
$a
A..rN
^
{
F
F?l'
5-1
sc
J.J
;
i>
X
7
='..)
V
90
I--.>i>
/..'
o1
'\o+:rt-
(^
-r)
\
\
b-
tr\$d
\
A
)
/,J
s-t
=>lf
e
N-(-',-
c,
sr'
7i
{
_):<-
tI-,t,
-{- .\
5
\\
\.Jt
\{
i
\
a
s,
t\
Y,
)
t
)
Nt
\0-
)
l\)>
--l--,
'.J
{-+
)t
c'
J'+o
J
:-
At")
'7
c\
.<
/o
c
z
=m
-T-'
VVo
*{
q
w
t
Nt^
['
N
t
J\
\
<\
-\J
Uin
-J!
JJ
./l
A
vf!o
{
C>g
N
/i
?)
,.i{r
u)
UN\t\
.A
\\
\
rC
\
SN
\N-\
0,Nrq'
N
V'\
(
wC}
t ;'r
\J{!-,
(
Nqr
(,-\
--\ _'
C^)
L-,'a\
o\
"4t
cfr
U},,\
-a
j
A(-
+\)
rJ
G-
-\-c
Nr\+
\$
r\.
\
\
$v'.t
).t Z\l
,t5
P
(Y,
n-L
vr^\
L..,r\,
.,1't
qr-
=ScA
I*\
(,r.,
r t.
N
'$
\
it
{\
\t.
Y'
u
s
\
.\t
V^J
C
J-
\
V
{
)r\
\\\
L.1
0V',
c"
.J
\
'
\:
J
o4q
$l
NJC
-s
LJ
J.
c
J
--.I,
{q--
!-dA
ooz{
o-{
zc
=tr
mv
C \Y
(
s'\
S\
i\
-Y.\
r$
c
C\
s-
N
n\,s--I
N
=
@I
FdEztlm
Ailz#Or>+im
o
mzo
s
Al
l-
tt\
(o
B-\
N
t
N
\
o
:tl
I
+=
-x
(o
>,+
=)-+
5"
H'
S
t\
3
S-
-)o
o
L
c/
f*s.<)Gfr
T-
\
N
-^
@
\
q:.-
I
f
1
\
\
\t
Nh
@
S
.&'
N
\\
\s
N
\l.\i(
@
S,,*
\
NY
N
N
h
s+-
-L-5;
a
(o
D.(_)
)o
-r)D
^-
f,
J:,
ZS
(o
q-7
(-,
9'*
i?;-)f
t
o
LJ
5
[J,
I
I
d-
(o
\::
t-
\JI{\
R
({\
$
o
rn
^B-:t,-3Ir
o
C)
I
n
-s
o o @
\\
N
C
1l\o
o
\
\
.lI,\
I
b
f5>
@(y
-1
\1
;t *-
h\
I
I
)
?:,
I
(o
-S,
s,c:
_+
e
J\,t
\
J
o
mI
=
l-
o
tr,nma
@
n<
t-
zU
C
@m
z
OO€H
F qgFa =eIq, a ):= c.H <o oxmo = aZI QLi6 d qPg 3 Gy>v
ut -l-{rn
rn
rnm-{zo
$$\(
l.
$=46
C)
/-\-E0!_*
-C)B(rI
atn
r \!orf. oG S:6'v'i ,€r3
r \NO
-) nAJXod, Y3., ocF
r/-; irJ RK+3') wouv E
-, *d(rFoFqr1<-
hi<
s
F
$.
/
\
'<,
6
t,
\I
195
(,
i=
3
*\
{.
-.
1
!
-ai
6)
l-
,J^,
o
\^il
Fr
1
Er,'-z-
..,\ f\i'l\fV
-+- r\2r
i)
\ -r\ /\\; 6. nts
-Al3 d;(t//i\.i iu,3,\q T r-c: 6) r,.: ^D 5? (/i -+.r5, I2-{
;\
ia,?
{>)l
C\,
\
6
F,1
t
n +t-'i? [r' l-Tw Y r, u,'d '+",]3*t'y1 ':;;r'-'r 1', :,i;-ry ':, # i. 7 *', {: i I ii *r;3y 5 t{r {}ir$'ERisE d\
U I Xg'v\J F S;,'l i *l P i 'J ot* )i {iI*ri r rf 4 tB!u;5:.Ai
H{}$.P
t:-
\$a
r.
C-,iJ
-ri'
;
-t
_c
f; > Rf i i -\rr7\r)
.,-i fo t6,x ; pi: i"s .\' rli 'i*' F Sc,,-D i
F (-' #.; lt r):,5'.r(t 7 ,fi- \ +i; !{:C ;g,D> U--t'; f tP: :jinfl3,?: ! l ^ i I;, FS <"i i L F- -'+- ;
E' S-F+ !\ t:r *i'!-: .\ {'51, I
"
t tdf '|- :'J i t. ;' 'ji -->- i t - j ,; -'-* j
t-)w='s F -i?
-<\f1 fr-<
^\z\
(,n.
sn
(r
-l)j;(
?{:q
t-\ti cr,
atoi>..Y {
;${iF
i-
s\
:
\i-\)
, ^-{C,f,
f,1
rt'cIrit'-?I+,c
r
196