HomeMy WebLinkAboutPB 20100928
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
PLANNING BOARD
After Action
September 28, 2010
(Revised 11/9/10)
Discussion of Administrative Issues
2011 Planning Board Meeting Schedule
The scheduled was handed out to the Board. Some members said they had conflicts. The
members will email Acting Director Richard Lorber their comments for him to work out.
Regular Planning Board Meeting
Administration
After Action report August 24, 2010
Motion: Beloff/Stolar. Vote 5- 0. (Kuperman & Frohlich absent). Approve with amendments.
Items for Deferral
File No. 1977. 1747-1759 Bay Road. The applicant, 1747 Bay Road Properties, LLC, is requesting
Conditional Use approval to allow the use of a robotic parking system within a commercial main use
parking garage with restaurant or retail uses on the ground floor, as part of the adaptive re-use of
the existing structure, and to operate the parking garage after midnight.
Deferred to the October 26 meeting due to the applicant’s failure to meet the requirements
of Section 118-193 of the City Code regarding the submittal deadline of 30 days before the
meeting.
Public Hearings
Previously Continued Items
File No. 1965. Alton Road New Parking District. An Ordinance amending Chapter 130 Off-
Street Parking, Article II “Districts; Requirements,” Section 130-31 “Parking Districts
Established,” creating a new Parking District no. 5, and Section 130-33 “Off-Street Parking
Requirements for Parking Districts nos. 2, 3 and 4,” by adding new parking regulations for
Parking District no. 5, for properties with a lot line on Alton Road from 5th street to Dade
Boulevard, including a reduction in off-street parking requirements for certain land uses and
bicycle parking requirements.
Motion: Beloff/Veitia. Vote: 5-0. (Fryd & Kuperman absent). Recommend approval to the
City Commission as amended.
File No. 1966. 1651 Cleveland Road. The applicant, Didier Milon, is requesting Conditional
Use approval to install an L-shaped wood boat dock, boatlift and mooring piles, adding to an
existing dock, with a total linear projection of approximately 72 feet from the seawall.
Motion: Beloff/Veitia. Vote: 5-0. (Kuperman & Frohlich absent). Approve as
recommended by staff.
Progress Reports
File No. 1897. 304-312 Ocean Drive. Progress Report as required by the Board to set a public
hearing for modification/revocation.
Motion: Beloff/Veitia. Vote: 7- 0. Come back for a progress report on October 26, for the
Board to possibly set a revocation/modification hearing.
File No. 1647. 1775 Collins Avenue. The Raleigh. Progress Report to discuss written warnings
and complaints, cure letter issued by the Planning Director and possible revocation/modification
proceedings.
Motion: Beloff/Frohlich. Vote: 7- 0. Approve. No further progress reports unless a violation
occurs.
File No. 1840. 2301 Collins Avenue (a/k/a 2377 Collins Avenue) - Gansevoort rooftop
venue. Progress Report deferred from the August 24, 2010 meeting, at the request of Planning
Department staff, in order to further develop proposal to construct awning over garbage area on
24th Street.
Motion: Beloff/Kuperman. Vote: 7- 0. Come back for a progress report on October 26. A
modification/revocation hearing was set for November 16.
Public Hearings
New Applications
File No. 1973. Code Amendment - Citywide. The applicant, Leroy Griffith, is requesting an
amendment to Chapter 6 “Alcoholic Beverages”, Sections 6-4- and 6-41 “Total Nudity and Sexual
Conduct Prohibited” and “Provisions Pertaining to Establishments Permitting Partial or Total Nudity”,
of the City Code to allow establishments licensed as alcoholic beverage establishments to offer
partial and total nude adult entertainment.
Motion: Stolar/Kuperman. Vote: 5- 2. Recommend denial to the City Commission.
Motion: Stolar/Beloff. Vote: 7- 0. Recommend a citywide Adult Entertainment Study to the
City Commission.
File No. 1975. 450 W. 41 Street. The applicant, Jewish Learning Center/Ohr Menachem Mendel,
Inc. is requesting Conditional Use approval to operate a day care center for approximately 26 Pre-K
children ages 18 months to 3 years.
Motion: Frohlich/Veitia. Vote: 7- 0. Approve as recommended by staff.
File No. 1734. 1801 Collins Avenue. Shelborne Hotel. Shelborne Associates, Costello
Investments, Inc., Shelborne Ocean Beach Hotel corp. and Beach Group III, LLC, collectively
the Applicant, is requesting a modification to a Conditional Use Permit for an existing
Neighborhood Impact Establishment (NIE) in order to renovate and improve accessory uses
including, Nightclub space with dancing and entertainment; Brasserie restaurant with
entertainment: Lounge Bar with entertainment; a Café and Outdoor Café restaurant without
dancing and entertainment; Lobby Bar and Restaurant without dancing and entertainment; and
a Pool Bar and Outdoor Cafe without dancing and entertainment.
Motion: Belloff/Frolich. Vote: 6-1. Stolar opposed. Approve all the venues except the
nightclub (f.k.a. Shine) with amendments. The applicant may come back without a new
application to operate the ballroom space as a nightclub. Planning Director is to report
back on status of karaoke bar (not in CUP)in the basement.
File No. 1974. An Ordinance of the Mayor and City Commission of the City of Miami Beach, Florida,
amending the Land Development Regulations of the Code of the City of Miami Beach, by amending
Chapter 138, entitled "Signs", by amending Article V, entitled “Sign Regulations by District”, by
amending Section 138-173 to modify the requirements for the Lincoln Road Signage District;
providing for inclusion in the City Code; providing for repealer, severability and an effective date.
Motion: Veitia/Kuperman. Vote 5- 0. Fryd and Frohlich absent. Continue (without being
heard) until the October 26 meeting.
File No. 1976. To be heard after 5:00 PM. An Ordinance of the Mayor and City Commission of the
City Of Miami Beach, Florida, amending the City Code, by amending Chapter 114 of the City Code,
“Zoning Districts And Regulations,” Section 114-1, “Definitions,” defining “Religious Institution”;
amending Chapter 142, “Zoning Districts and Regulations,” Article III, “Overlay Districts,” creating
Division 8, “40th Street Overlay,” and by adding Sections 142-858 “Location and Purpose,” 142-859
“Compliance with Regulations,” requiring Conditional Use approval for Religious Institutions In the
40th Street Overlay District, and 142-860 “Off-Street Parking Regulations;” and amending Article II,
“District Regulations,” Division 2 “RS-1, RS-2, RS-3, RS-4 Single-Family Residential Districts,”
Section 142-103 “Conditional Uses,” to add Religious Institutions as a Conditional Use for properties
in the 40th Street Overlay District; and amending Article IV, “Supplementary District Regulations,”
Division 4 “Supplementary Yard Regulations,” Section 142-1131(D) “Generally,” to exempt
properties in the 40th Street Overlay District from additional 50 feet minimum side yard requirement
for public and semi-public buildings; and amending Chapter 118 of the City Code, “Administration
and Review Procedures,” Article IV, “Conditional Use Procedures,” Section 118-192, “Review
Guidelines,” to add review criteria for Religious Institutions; providing for Codification; Repealer;
Severability; and an Effective Date.
Motion: Kuperman/Frolich. Vote: 7- 0. Recommend approval to City commission.
Motion: Frohlich/Beloff. Vote: 7- 0. Recommend to the Commission to include the Kollel.
Meetings Reminder / New Business
*** Next Month's Regular Meeting: TUESDAY, October 26, 2010 at 1:30 p.m. for discussion of
Planning issues and 3:00 for the regular agenda, unless otherwise changed in consultation with the
Chairperson depending on the length of the agenda. Please mark your calendars and inform staff if
you have a schedule conflict.
F:\PLAN\$PLB\2010\9-28-2010\9.28.10 Afteraction rev 11.9.10doc.doc