2007-3590 OrdinanceORDINANCE NO. 2007-3590
AN ORDINANCE OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF
THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, DELETING THE
LANGUAGE IN SECTIONS 82-366 THROUGH 82-388 (THE
CITY'S SIDEWALK CAFE ORDINANCE) IN ITS ENTIRETY, AND
REPLACING IT WITH NEW LANGUAGE IN SAID SECTIONS 82-
366 THROUGH 82-385, ADOPTING AND INCORPORATING THE
CITY'S NEW SIDEWALK CAFE ORDINANCE; PROVIDING FOR
REPEALER, CODIFICATION, SEVERABILITY, AND AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY
COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA:
SECTION 1.
That Chapter 82, Article IV, Division 5, Sections 82-366 through 82-388, of
the Code of the City of Miami Beach, Florida, is hereby deleted in its entirety, and
replaced with Chapter 82, Article IV, Division 5, Sections 82-366 through 82-385
as follows:
Thy ~.,; n ,•,s~d-s
~er~s aed-
k-~a-srs
w "ee
d
i
~ i
~
+
a
1
,
~
-
~
L
"
`
`
+ -mss e
-
r -
~
r
s
efl-~
4
~bE
~}Gin
Tec
}R~}E~-rc
~-S6i"FbPa-tF.3-t~}~°i i=n
-r~riT~?C~cr "'vF}~*cG + ~", here-t~l° 'c-v°vr°rcccc
s
5 I o n rl
~
~
-
-
- ~e~ i n ~ ~ ih i r h
't ~t°~Fi e~~~t~a° n
a
~
m
° n~n
f
f
c
~ttt
~
V~~
. tFtl~
cp
-r
cr
rr
v
r
+r~±nonnr+°+inn +h° r+ni ~n+~i nr +hn ni
e
nr rnrn sir°r+ fnr i ~o° °c ° +rononnr+n +~i Homo +hn f°° nr h-~c nn nnonm°n+ rJ°~in+ni+ fn
+inn fnnili+~i nr o+r°°+
~Ja-~}~t~Q~--~~e`~S `C~#E°t-.o.~c"n`Jinn ~_frnm° c~iaonfi ir° Innr.+.~.d ..
rnn+°ino n Ginn nc rl °fin°~ in c°n+inn 'I 'I /1_1
m°ono
eve
C +h irvh+_nf_~~i°~i ~~ihinh io Innr++°r! hn+~~mnn
F
~r
t#e-s ~~ Ltt
~~~e-e~~h~e-la~e~ crr
~rrrv rv o ay~rrrtvrrrv~vvctcccrvccnccrT
e--eta
st~ee~
~~t~a~' i'
a
t
i -
-
-
f~ e~-
+r~e~
+~e
s ~#
~e~r ~nniJ in +hio o°r+inn h~ i+ ohnll
fnr
~,-~`
~
~
J
~6-~# ~
~t
C1tY
~Fe~--~e~A~ee~l-~~e T
~t
~-
,
Ct
rrrccTrr~-crnv~cvrrvrr-vu~.m crc.-r
F
~}Re
fA
21~
a
R~t~}(~vel~t i n ° ef
~h
"
T ~ ~
°v
s~FS
ni n°
S sa
~- -
~
~
j
-
-
-
~,~-
~
,
nnlJ ~+ 'I2fnn+ eiiiJ° ono + fn ~i
-area-s
-:
er~ee
r
#
+
l
~
o °uw~ ,~
,~
. T vz
.-~~~
~-.~
~e
~
s~
,a~
h n Irrexri--v~°. a-~e--~9 r v ie~ll~f-}~~t~}I~TU nrmiT~9 , ~SK~r^ ° narra'-r"ri~t~~v
n rnonnm+inn r~i~iioinn
es~ab#s#r~er~s~el~
e6~~ "
~-T
'~
''
mo
+
~~F6
"
a
'T'
a„nef
&S to
t
p
6 e~}S
e
~~~ ~
~,
C
,
~
-,
,
--
-~,e
} ~
~ I
, ,
,
n n+ i +
+i n
~
Tn
~ " I"
rtttttt
-C~t
t~Qt~'C~K~t,D
~9~f~# ;;; h°
-nv-I
'
e~# ,~
~rvrr
~~e6
~,'~~~~.5 tat~i't'J ~ ,,„
{
~
~t 'III,, iII~ imin~,4
r
{~
~
°
~e
e
°
nvt~
'
~c
rc
~~
~tt
af~
#e-te
' e~-##e~T
°
-
~#° I
-
i- ;
^ e
ta-Ftt
~c
a~
-If
e
~^
c'
~ {r
;
{
e°+ o i.. i n ° h ° c +~~ r~~
~e~(f
e
-
~r
i
~
d
t
~
cR
v at
i
Cd
d-lte°c.Z+--rn ° •• ncGrrr~#Ctt~ei-tte~-d1~Q-1~ hrrfvi°v~~° ~ ~ i°ca~c°~TT~n CtJ-bt
}~~, ~~,', I I o -Win`-reWt`~11"c-~~e~e~S ~(~-F~{3r~ ° of tl-FL,~ r6peFt~ ~ ° ° t hri ~- wiair"r
e~tFil.. r. i rl r. ., I L I r. .+ f'. ~" f....+
e
~~~~
//'I ~nr} f
Vr-vu
T-°
uii~
-- caol
iv
h
m
~j~
~ o
ivc
i/ai~
~~
t
~f°c
S i .7tStttt:
~~~ T~
cc~
I
tttt~v
r
~~~
,x
-61}c
~}^~ i
r
rr
rr
Jr
{~~+nllo °nc ~
v
c
/irnnm°nf
TC
~
7\ Th~~~~ °nn° of iti
^
.
eir}nuvnlL nnf°c °nnnllr~rv °~ .~rlrli+innol n °r•°c+rinn
r
~} r..ff=rQTtTViv-c
/Z
~in
~ n~ °~c°-aT°
f
n
c~
~v
° ~+ n
l~°\~/-±IL r~±f°e ~~~/ Ic i
mn°~~~~~o°
~
°
a
f'°
`~
~
fln\e/ of nn
//1 \ Thore is ~
_
.
t
.
r}no+rion
n n°°~ fn
+roffin ~ ~ ~`^J
r rnnl Ilo+inno onr! of~n/J~
nJc fnr +hn nvio+ .
.7
7
e
nnnn onr!
n
n
~~' o\•/
I~af~?
+n f~nilif~f ° ~niJ ~~r° ~J~~
o
~
on\/irnnm
// F~
h
°
~ °n} in +h°
I i c hmn n ~
~
c° ~r°~c~
~ °
"
~aT~~~i~
/J
'-
rav~vr
T
i
t
.~ .
~~ iv n rn+~+ o
~
~~
-
Q
vT ~
l
n i} n rn m n~~ an
r
Z
~
~T
n~+h ca
e
/nrrl nln o~
~ -
fe+v ~nr}
nQ
f: 1 /'2 ~
.a
.
.v
~
\w/°If~r° of +hn rnoi~Jnn+o
'I~~
nrr}
Nln
a_~\\ of +hn ni+\/
~7_'2n~'~_S~~ 9
c
T~gT
~ / /
~
. `r
~d~°~ S27_4RQ. Gomw~l ~n~ c4~\r~r~o fee+v±• rlicr~~+~i4ir\n .+f r~r~\ner4v
f
I~ ni+v r n\/°o nll
~ roll~n+ ~ +hic~ /-~ivioinn env I°c nh~ir c nr n}h~
v~~.~~ aurr~ ~Tir.~ , ~
1
,~, ,.,,J ,.} on° nh nhi +v±
~
-
~ Th° ~Jir +
~ ^,.~h
oll nrnmlllr~ln}~
.~n~ ~ \/i~~
a'J
r~
QNd~t
ug~. vrr
vvj ~rr
t ~
~
Gt 1
e
}hic /-!i\/icinn
rr1 Aln ~7_Zn071 ~ ~ / 2D_ 2C.\1 0_~ n_~7\
n
e -S n
h~
9~ h a+
S
F~--~~
~6~~ h o n rnn°rl
~+ ~+ 1 1 r° c o n+ fn r+h i n n h n n}° r
~
~
r AY~tt~
tc
~Ctt7 ~
e
/nrrJ Al n D7_2$nR
--s-~T~Q\
~o nln
R-°
~(~;~ o7_~no~
s~
~~ o_~~
-~-9-9~~ ~
o
~ ~
. -_
.
lif° cif°+\/ \/inl.~ of ~ l
- Jivioinn p v±ofo+v vinl~ nc ~r° n~(~ ~~
~
-~
1Tfli~TriL~YfOTLfCfCyYYa7~rGTT7T
I
}hnc° nnnr}is \\w/~
~
~ TfVTJit7T~ .~JCiTGC~PTOfCtCTVTT~7
AT~
V~TT~J
c°r
~~ n h~T~
ivla~ r}
unn
~
i
1r
Inl+ll l!"~In/'Y
~
Tp+\/ !lr \A/~,T
~
~ cr
~r
c3
~" ~ "~ ~ ~/'~/'~p ~+~+ p ~(~~s
\/In l']11pL]_L~~ ~`f ~]~i
~TIT~eQ'
~
1
Q
Y~GGTTII
C~ ~
~l T~Q~J a~
C f~l
1 J
CTTVf
)
/h\ If o nnrl° nmm~li~nr° nffiror ~c~ r!°fin°rl in cor+inn 4n_`2 fin.-Ic ~ \/inl~+inn of
c~
~
a J~ ~ •~ l l i
-
-
~rtv
r
m
~
"
~~
tt3l~
ltf-ttil.
W~t tC1
dtl ~ AttfbtC~
Fi-
tti
ttb
urr
r
r
rr
~
~
v
vi
~~
~ r--
- ~ fn r
P
'C}
--
-
G~
,
- \ ~/ h i n h +
h ~
tt~7
tFFl.~
i
GttYi
tFfl
"F'FC
\/inlr+tnr mr+\/ hn li~hlo K7t
YtFtl
tl
inc In~ tYi
.
Ft~t~1
F11
t
t1Fi
YF/
~nr nip th
no onrl ^1lo rlo,t c
~~e
l
~~Z\~~~~n mr+
f
n~ \/ ho nnn r
nnlnr~ h\/ ronlloctinn ~n ~r~m iniotr~ti\/n
~
_
nn \~/i+hin ~n~~
~
+ri
h «~.n ~
~~y+inn of \/inloR~n
,~_on ~T~~
r
-r
C
i
•'1
Tn'T 'r~lll ly A~y~
, II
nn
n
~~L1 r
o
h
~ \/In l
1~7Y1 '~OJ~C
I~
TC
~ 7tlnn 7n1~
~
\•/r]1\/or of thn rin ht ton ho~
/nrrl nln o2~nQ ~ 1 /Z~ r
'
~
rinn `C
_'2~\ ~ n_ T
~
IT~
I
GGG\\\000TTT111777111 'J
f U7T
S2_~7• nrrl nle a7_~n~'~ R ~ /
-
- '
'
~~_~g\ O_
IV~T\V'J -'~J~ ~JC~TL~TT
7a T
~~ T
Tho fnlln\e/inn nivil finoo oholl hn imnncor• fnr \/inl~tnrc of Chic ~1-finlo•
~~-d~~~vitQtinrvrrwTttiin orrcrnvrni°~\~~~a'rrp rincrrvc~r `~~v-vv
/nr~ nln ~')~~nS2 ~ ~ /~a_.~ n\ ~ n_Q_o~• nrr~ nl o~ gno~ ~ ~ /~o_~o\ a_
~-9-~~
~'~+. Q7_477~ ~i ~~~4 .,f fine; riryh~cv~pcwl~ f'~--rwTi'n'r°~.-iv
/o\ D \/inl~tnr \~/hn hoo hnnn oon/orJ \~/ith o nntino of \/inl~tinn oh~ll nlnnt oithor
/1 \ D.~\/ thn ni\/il Finn in
~~nnt~
~
rT r I~~,e~
~m
-
~
'
ar
~
~
t1
F
.
~
r
r
T~~ vet nn n/~minintcratt7~1*~ r° ~~I~ ~cV T
t
T Iloct ~n ~rlminic•t
~ }i\~. ~ orp in iv h ro ~jr nl
~~ on~l
~l
t
m~ct~~nll hn infn
- rmor) of c
-
- llnh foilllro h ~o
r
\/ ronnrt fr 1
em ~
~LLwc
rrravc ulr
v~.~rnv rrrTCa vr
. sa cpvrr-rr m -
niJ~
nmm~li.~nno
~v ~~ ~ +~n
th
y ar~h
~~{I.mo -_r ~r
irin
~nuiT
o
_
tttl
nnneti~o o \~/~i\/or o f tho \/inl~ ~
r
~
~-lo rirv ht ~
- ~
.~`Jminic•`~'~~' /~oP ~
~
ho~rin A
wrrscr c-a~vurc
nl\/or of rinht
~
iot ~-
r~rr~
roti\/n h
-
' ~rarrRrn~
~oll hn t
- -c
rn -rr\.zn-rr-r~~-c
nt~~ on
-
urccr-vt- r
r+/-Imiooinn of thn \/inl~t
inn o ~
nrl no ra
srv
.err
nnltioc mn\/ hn urr
v .~c
~onnooor! n r ~
nn c
arT
nr/-linnl\/
//-1\ 4n\/ nort\/ onnrio\/orl b /
y tho
~onic
inn of o cnoni
ol moctor m
ov
onnool that
/nr~+ n
i `~.~nS2 f:
l
~~ ~ /`2~_i l ~ \ 1 n~~~~r
-~ ~~~-z~~7 f: ' ~
v~~
.
~u--r
r
i
r/-~ nln oz~zna~l ~ ~ / ~Tq. n\ o_~ cr.
n_o~\ z r
v
~~++ Q7_'27'2 Q ~~i i ..f ~~nr~~ii•1 fin~• ~~nr~i~'~~p~J~v 6A~54i4~~4e ~ liens
d~~. ~sv~ r ~ urr~ r znuc~w--rrcrr
q~gc~inn ~ ni~ii
/h
+orl r•nn~i ~~~p~j l fino m~~i hn ronnrrJor! in fho
~
.
^r+'I n+-^p
e~~
o n~~~.
~_ nfnrnnrd in fho
hn
o
~
~
p~5
.+ nn++rf i++i-Inm~~~i f~~
r'~'
n _~~
y
hnri ,e^'
- _~
~,
}
~fo
-' ~
-r
~-a
rri
}~~ ~
h+++ oh~ll
~
T
3 t
l
nnf hn rJn tti
t
+
omorJ fn ho o rn++rf
-~TT~~S +
~~
E
ii +~nmonf ovrnnf fnr onfnrrnmonf ni +rnnoo e 4ffor fiein mnnfhc frnm fh
filinn of r+nv o+inh li ~eihinh rom~inc i+nno
~ irl f rife
'
~ m
~6~~
~--8~
--
~rnTVrrrr. rrramv
vrrn .
nfhnn~iico ovnn++fn nn fho lion vrcy
+
s rrr
J
/ n r.J . 1~ I n , a ~~~g n S2 +~.TT` ~,~--rv°~.ri ,-n rv,~~~6~-~~~~~~~-4~, -~-
nll ln~~if+il fnr nn~ i norce n fn nnnrof~~~ ~w~~
b+p~ n
~~ ~i
~ n ~ ~~
~p ~
~pr! h,,~ ~~ i-1 i~ii~n~ ~ ~, ~~~nl~i ho Inn~forl +~ihnrn
n" ~
n`irmif`f"n"iJ"'hJv r
fho nif~i+c ~nnin n nrrJin ~nno ~n~ omonrlmo nfc fhorofn /r honfar
n
/ h
~ norr+fn fhof
~
~~+n
te
~+
i
° cirlouroll~ n~fn n
h
n I I h o. in f h
c +mo++on
~
~~--~ f fn fhi
8~~ c rJivicinn
-an°
~'~.4
}~F°
-~~~r-~}e~
~ ,
--
r
ti
a i
~ ~ ,c
c '
+
/ nrr• nln
S2a _~~F ~
4 ~
~ n_'I _Qa
nr~
n ln
a~_~Qnu ~ ~ /~zo_
~9- .
~-~; nrrl n ~=
ln a~_~na~+~ _~
,+
~~n '
~ a_~ ~
,
n_a~~ ,
+
/'I~~~n n~mo or•r•rnc~o ~nr! folonhnn
~~~j +
~
o n~mn ~niJ nrliJroc
h
~~°
~
T
vTf o n++mhor of fho onnlin~nf
aaT~
n
~
.
~`-/ "
cr
r
c
~
r ar
r
frnnf of ~~ihinh nrnnn ~d rv+h
o~oT
rri~-o ~~~ n
~~
~6
ai° ~"
-
-
a
~
r
T
'
c
v
~
rr
°~ rl rn ~eiinn ~"
rrti o aT
~ rCa{ ai'°I
i s ~~
~'~ 'e
Y°~~~
o
~
pn i
i
nf
n a
vio
+ ~
i
n
n ~v
-ln~~
ci
i r
iolL ~tY~
o
r
°
o
° tttC
nrl
~r~
i~r #Y~t
F~
nr~+ r~ri~tn i~
+
~
~
T
~
r ~ ~~
vn
nr r ,~,~ '
~
° ^
~,
~ ~
., ~
~
~
~~ ,
a'~} ~
,
~
,
„,,~
-- ^{
~
~~
--
~ ~--
naTi
P
s z
P
rvF~
+°n -
nl•+n Pr
p
+°ro .
sCd--
i~mh ~b~t
rnlln itif
o t~~t
Inro+inn of G
YfdtY~
rlnnn~io G1
t
vc Inro+i v
.
J~
nn of +r°°
n•, rl m ~~~S ~ t~ s~ia°~ Ul
" ~v T av
~
°
' ~
r7 ~
°~ Ct
~ io I
n v c
i ~ r+i
h
c vT
r
nn CNtrFiC
~t#~ ~ ~ tt~Fi
~
~
,~,p e ~t
.
c
.
~gCgf~~ ~
~~ii+hin +
/7\ Dhn+nn ~
h°
rr+n tYF
nnr•n
ho r c
o+rion
•Irrn~iin w'aT
or°°
nc n
r m ._
~
s7
oni ~for
+~ ~r°
rc~ hrnrh c
J
y
i it°c fi ill ~ h'~"Y
y r+°crrihin
n
P-T-~^°zv g
~q
+
h rail
q° °o ... ~ .
r
unv .. ~ .......
~~ y ., ...
~ ..
~ •,.... ~ .........
°°~j .,,....
~~ ~,.,,.'f.II ........
'-
~e .......,.~, •+.~•.,~
e~ e
-- ~I ......, .........
h
air
~
r . y
ir
r°
~ imhr~ ca
o
" r
nr n+
h°r nh
i +c
LS T
r
~n~#
n +h
- ~
~
Qtt
n cir1Y°~~i° d
tA#i
IL rofn ~r
r
t
~ s
ar~TVr a-ra vr-vc rrcr-vv r
j ~~ crr
v
r+nnlirr++inn f° ° oc c°+ fnr+h i n on n° nr•iv D
m~ ~ ~~
•~ py~p rl h" n i ~hlin \A /yT~~
rl~ n
g ~~n+
n lnnninn r Jnn°r+mnn +
~
firr rl°n~•+r~"~mYr~
n'+~•"
n`"ffi"rl _
° of ric
L m
nn r
nr+mm~n ~
+• r ~
nrJ° rmm
~lionr°
r!°n°rfm°n ~
+•
finnnr° rlnnnr•
rrJ
I
In ~Z_ f
fm°
~(1
n+• o
s
f.'
52
nrl h~ ~i
'I /'2~_`
liJinn
2'~\~
c
v
°niir°c
(
-~~ f
iJ°n
lr~
°r+m°n+
'-
~
'
y~i
~
~-~~ e
_
•
~ ~ L~ ftt.
~i +
,~'~+~ Q7_4524. C~~~ u~r~°°~ r~er»14ioc fnr 1~4o nwmon4c f°r rnnoui~l feo~
nvne n4i~n
~T
h~~
~e n r•+h i n ~ n n °
~ T
--p
-
°
r~
u aT~~vre
- uoTn o i rl °~ a io I I~ ° r° n
c
-
t
inrl~~rlinn + Y
h° ° hnfi~i
~~- ~t~
t
~
c
~
nnn ~~~~I
n?
- t
d~
onrl rh~-~+
~
- ~
C
n~~~°~h
~
~
ri+~i monon
/ h
°
r
i~
~n
' ~
vccvr
°r nr hir l+noi
--vr-rti
~ r c
ccrr
nnn°
n
°
v `+
'~ ~
arrcr
vrr
S~
~s`~ T
~
c
~
_ ••, n n ~ ~ •, I
rv ra+
°
` o ~
--
r
~
v ~ ~
r
. ~
~. p
c~
.
i n r l ~
~ n r•l i n n +h °~
S~'
-Tn I
~.
t~r
~ ' ~~h ° n
~n'
~-r
,
/r~~~~n
~
mT ~
~~~oll hn T
GT
noir! nn nr hnf ~
,
CrJ
nr°
r~~°
-r c~
c
h
~vQV°
-~i
~
~
~
t c
.. ~r
r
T
c
ttil.
F
sa~ ~
~~~- +
-r~
~ ~
-
~~fS~
~ ~
CtitYAt~
m n~ i h° n° ~
t
i'J i n in o ° tta~
r
ttil.~
,'1
m
uTm Q i CG~
„~
,~F,
,
+
~~~~ + ,~, ,~ ~., n~ ltil.~
~e
-
s~e~
~
~~~~`~~ cr
nnr! iJ~ i° nn rrt
~tt
D aril 'I Aln nnrm lt~YK
i+ eholl h° ioo~ i ~3#
i~
~
°rl fnr on~i nnrFinn of
~nr ~An~i 'I of on~i ~i°or mo~i nh~~ p~e,F~ r°moininn nnr+inn of
fic~r~ G~~f nnn_ho lf of +h° n°rmi+ f°° r°ni sir°iJ h~i +hio
~
r•Ii~ii inn G vr°n+ ~+c nrn~i ir•nr• in onr+inn S2`)_QS2/1 nn rnf~ inr•1 of +h° f°°c chnll
hn nron+°r•I
/r+\
~~~e
~
a
+c fnr nnr
e~
mi+ r °~.~~I f
er~
-
-ee
i°
r~
s--s ss
°+ +h° ro+° of +°n
-
-
~a ~
--p
y
°n+_n°
n
~~ ~-~pc~
r ~nn~im fnr cPru,
,
,,,rT
+h° ~ ~
~
~~~1-+~n
°..
r~ ~
~,T~~~~,
~~c~°~~ f°° i~n
.+
`:"' ` ~P
~7
7 ~~
r o
~
~~
°~ nn~~ '
~d
°r
~°rmino+inn droll h°
-
~
~n J~ ~
c°-°P
n~~~n
~~°~~iolL rnf° cr
~~ii ~ ~+~
r crrrTrnuc7vrr~~urr
pc
onrl +h° rlir~+~~
mi+
~ p ~
nll
~ .
. rinh=
~ nom ,,,,{{yy or nA
`
~
~ f +' n
5~}e
6 on~i +~hlo o nh~ iro
~ ,
Y ~ ,
e ~vv~ dtl cr~
i 8 tt f ~ ~
~ ~ n r a i lf
f~n Aln ~o~fio~e~ ~o onnff ol nor mi+
i
"~ ~# on u ~
fill v
h ~
o rpp
'"`
`` yo
LLlL
~~~
``"" ~
~~} .
~nrcr n h~ ~nurtg f
~~ ('n no f i~ r Dri nn Ini +ov
/ (`DI \ h nfi n77
~io
o +
ha 1~ 4oc+ ( SDI ~n r! + ho rlo+ o of +ho rDl ~ ~c or! fnr +ho I~c+ foo
f
n ~+if ~ +m on + io f i~fn nn rna n+ /~i0%\ nr n ro~+nr
f
'
'
`
'
/ (lrr! • hI
` n• ~
,_~ ni2 !
f
` : ~ /4~
` _4n\
f ~ n_ Q_a~•
f rr!
~.• T AI ~~
~I~fB~
` )
' ODD R 1
f f C._
)
I _
ZT ~~-.•
T~
~rr! f~l
Tq~TI n D
TJ'7 7
.2
'b n~
VaT 7 f:
L'~ ~ /
2_
T
' 21 \ D
VT~ _1 n_~7
~aJ'7 • .
f . ri-1• f~l
f ~
e-T g_
~~4G:
T ~ f
'
' !~ ~ ~ n_~~ _
f ~g~(l
f `~ ri-1
T~
I~Ir~-~ -v c~
~ 7
f ~
f I~z-v
r im r
f rl• I~Irv: zv v~-~~ ~7
f f: ~
~_
~G
f :_n ~~T~~ f
f r'vzv vc~
~42~~ ~, ~ _~ n n a\
~
~
~ ^
Ta
~
~
~
~
~~e
cn
c
~°
h n
vur~
v
zv
v~
-- p@ 1.~
. T - f f ~
c c -vr
c f f
n
o
nn ~ 7_'2S2 'Z frn m ~~~ ~
n • nnnol+i no fnr I~+n n o~imn n4~
o
,
~
~ ~ r ~ ~~
f ~~ ~ f
n n
f f f
nvnon+i nn ff
/n
~~''~nf~f~±ll~ n~±foc or~ ~~c~ _~ oil+° f"i
nlL
fr~ ~~
r~ of +ho
- linon onr!
\ ~
~~ ~
u o
r
sT
~c. ~rv~cr rJCa
hf filrlinn f~ihn~~ .i~lirll~ n
c ~c
~
n }
~Q~}~ ~~i ^
~
T
-
~ ~a~c a
nf
n i+ m ov
~
~~
-
s a
+nnr•I h~
-- o
J
c
u
i o movim
-
-- t
+n+~I o
~
f C.n fn
-- CG-
~
n+ n
fl--
nn
e -o
r
~~
~i
ra-
nT
c~
+h r~
~
-
~ cccrTa
~
n v
r
m
T rrra~cn
rT
~ci
5 h f f o
~
'
n~ zvrarv
~
av
~ rvv
rc
~ crv
n rn~ vrr
-
i i c i n n c n
f
t1
il: ~ti*
Y
Qtfatd
cf fhcon+inn /h\ of +hio~T~To~'n
/h\ An nnnlin~n+ fnr n oirl ~
i
rt
tt
~nf"+inn .
va
~r
~+ m
~{~
' ~
7
~~i ho n
~ rt
tt
mi++oiJ tl,
+n nv+
onrl h ~
r
~i n
~rc~~--c~r>varrc-rv>-a~ru r~n
r a~v~-p rTrrccccr -cv cnc crTC~v y-cr
~ onnlin
~~~r oi~rc
h' o n+fo rno ~ nr~ ~~av w~
u r
n
f +4r1°
r
f
r~ormi+ +n ov+on'+o +n .~
of fhlin r
inh+ nf_fef~~i
in frnn+ o
f nn n J
~
r+innnn+ ri
a-vr
nf~in -c
r.
orfe
nrnnor+~i +hn nnrmi+too mf fo+ nh +~in ufri++nn nnrmiooin n fnr ~ f oo of o f frh n ron
f
~L~~iJ~Q~+ n~nn
fr
nm
nr+
~~
C.~h
p~~~
~~~
II h~
~n~
n
rr
~~ ~ _ ~
T
P
~S
~ e ~a~`
~
~ ~ •~ n~~ in~? h~
.--
tkitl~'
t-tttC
Qtid~tT'h
~~~~~n~a~ ttt-C
~it'
f-~onoinn t--tFt
L
'
of of in~n r~~
j~
~holl
nn+ n
nn~~ ~y.
~e
e~` `'"
r
'
-
n
~~ ff'"nf~
-
ia--o ~
~~ ~}~ foo nr ~n~i n cn
r
~
° °
°v
~VttttFtt
~
r~
-a
r
r
/ n~T~ r~~
o l
i-rtv
-
-
Sv c~
u
~
v
- l
2F~Gi~ ~
o o o nr
d
n h
n i rc~ f ~ in ~~ I rl h r
c
±
o n la cc
o~
i
ur
t
CC
F.
~~fi+hin fi~io fon+ n
~ vas ° Gd
~
~o ,
~T~
,a,{~v~
f ~
~,.
,,
~c-R +
s
air pl[C~ri `
°
~a r~ o
uT-v
nr ~n~i +~fnn of ni fhlin c+r
/~ \ A l n +o h l o o
viv
h
c~'1~
f
--
'~ f tG
oo+ fi frn
r'
h
r°
~~a-J ~
t
f
-Tr
i+ffro oni-!/nr
r
r n
+
T~~l~ ~GtGt
f}iv,+f free
-ti~
o
#n tt
~-
l~h
"7"
i++ ~
.
orl f e i i r
+h i n
f-
r
r
,
-
~
p~~nfef'±IL n~±fno oh-~II h
' rn
r
c
n Inno+ ~
~
o
~f inh o
'
'
- tdi
~.
.
m~r
'
- ~
+h~
' ~~~ n~n
f nn
+
=
crrrv
`"'~~ ~ri
~rvvcrr
avr
r
~r
rrr
cr
ru o rn
o
t
+h fnr +
n
~r ho r~~rn ?~~+
hy minima ~ m rl ~+h nnr Linn
fs
Jtt-Ff~t~Y-~
m~1~~' ~r~ffo
}~~~ o ~
~
ni+ III cimi
l~r nhc~,
~~~
h
oll
n f
n
n~~,'
i+o
m f .~f i
~ n
°r~p~
fn
~°~~}
i~m~o
~
a+h
~f
f~---~} +r~ ,., IfI ~..,
'S-~~}
--
~~e ,,~ ~
-
~ ~ f
e--
`Tr
"'y"''"
rv
cu
-p 7 Aii
l7 ~ l
d~ tt
hlnn ~ +n hln n ~ ~+ ni+ +h~++ +h° nn+ho mn ~i mp~ ~i~~p.q~~ ~~~s ~e~ T
.
+°~ n i+ nh iro ~~i hinh ~~ini ~ Irl hn~in ~rn? cffoa+ of fnrminn n nh~i civur -vT
iii ~ ~ ?
I
h
r rt -
~
ni ~ r~+ninn +h ° fr~ Sn of +h° +o hl°o nnr+ n hoirc by + h
~
~
r _
6
~
Dn
v ' ~ c°
v
v cii-!
T 6 "T
~~s~
- r'~~v8~ --~
e` ~
~ °
rcva
rlir°n --a
~~
+nr m
~+~ ~
-
f~
i n°rmi+ + r
h° ~ ~c° o
f nlnn+ nn n
~
c
.
n+oin°ro /nlo
n+°r~l +h° c
c
n~ ~m .
h°r ~+ r
c
nr~
~ai'rc~.
° w~ ~~
~
~ ~..,~ ~...,...... .
F~
V ..,., ...,.., ..
~
~}Q . ~....,.... ...
-
iu"
~ ....,.......~... fir.,.
~
~
F
F
e
6i
A ...'-•-i+ -.._
~~--~F .._... __. ~ .._
.
sr~~
DI n° $--
m°n 2-
+ 1
-~E~F4e
of nl~+n+°°r --
~
~n
r
° -
r
~+
m
~~+
T~ ig
^
{
~
'
I
'
~
~
~°
v
~. ~#~I
ar~~ I h~ ~ ~
~ n ~
~ T
T
t Rttc
Qt
~
y J
i+n n 1 /'~
~'~? ~ •1+ C
n ` h n I~
T ^ ~']
T
G T000G~T 'A '
`'
i
~ r'r-Qo _
` ~
T7
v
11 G~~ TTJTI7T ~G7T7~ d
t
~ Q11~
rirni ~ m + nn ° A~r+vi m~ im cis° f nlnn+
n °r~ oholl nn+ °vr°°rl +h° fnlln~ ei'
.
.,~~.. ... r,~.... ~. .......~ ..,... ~ . ... ............ .. ... ..,..., .....~
inn
Dn h° o hinh
c r
l
a
r
o. `)il inn
hne rli°m
°+°r h
7/~ in
chno hi
h
-rcv m ~r~T
r
'
~ ~ ~
Dln~c
r•h I I h° n rnn°rl ~~~ ~~~ 5+~~~
~~q~ ~s~~~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~
Y
~
in ~~ii~+h ch~+ ll nn + ° vnn°r! fni ~r fn°+ in h°inh+
~ t ~
of +~ e
~~
~rmi+
C~~nh nor
~ij~ihl° mr++
°rinlo nrn~i
irl°r1 ~
eii+h
+h°
~,~°ncr r~uT°.~ tti l7~c7T°+~i nnr+ nnn~i °ni°nr°
~ ..v..v... of +h° n~ ihlir_
..~ .~ . ~............
r
s ~
I° c c +h ~+ n c i ~° I (
~~ '1 h+ 1 C16#~ ~gvi~
(~ ~}~-~--~ ~~f.~.. ~~} 5}~.eV1~ ~ C i n n c o r°
G T
~
n i
~
In
n +°r+ nn f
+h° n~ ~hl '
in rinh+ n
f_~~in~i °vnnn
+ +h o+ +h° °
c+°hl
ichm
a
v
Trv
n m rQr
° ni
+/n
r i+ Innn r
i n°rmi+ ~
+°rl nn i ~ ~ r
mhr°Il~c I °+
+°rinn °nrl
/nr Inn
nc
mo~i
nn+ °
rrv vr°°
~...... rl
.... civ inch°
.,... ......... c in h°in
.. ... .. .~. h+
...
e
°~
~-e~
-a
+L.e~..L.i~
Fges-e~
e~--~e~
e-6~ •• h~~ ~ ~
° n°rcnn
r°n~ i f
oc+in r
n °
~
~b ~ ~#
i
~
S S
1 6W fl-9f
Con}omh nr `.2(1
~ ~ ~ ~ Ffl~F~~}
~~ I~~~ ~ e ° ~d~
i
S~aTi r'
l ~--6~F-~BF
Fea
arr -F
- S -9f~ -
~ e ~ r
~
u
`irlo~~i~+ll
~mc~-rln _ n
_ fo
___ _ fiv}~
_ roc rnlnn~+}off r'I
CG C,T'C, i ~rinn om
TgT'ITCGT'G7Tf orno
CTG{G I nnioc
TGTGN
f
f
linen o nr nor }ifin }o of ~ ~ o i lim i}off }n }n L o_n~ ~ } con iino
~ s
ohr
ic~
c
no
~
~ s
~
~
~I~
o0
r-ttt°
of o•,nh
crii-~ ~
~ ~~ ~ ~
Q
vC~if-c°. ~ Ii i. __}o r1 } to c} nnne ~~i ooL nr me re fr om ion }I~i ~o noorlo rl
/~ ~\ Aln ~+rl~i~pin
n o~ ~c nr hi is•i nnoc ~rlo
n+'if ro S+a~~ ~.~ ll hn normi++or) in
~
+hn n~ ~hlin rinh + of ~enw
~ n nn+ ~
r
r
7c
' ~
mi~~nr'I
' ~ y c~ ~h
~~ co ~
r+inn [h
l
,nf +
-
~ h~~
1TT
nhr+ir
[a
nll +
hlo c ~ ~ mhrnlln ~
o Yom`
nlon ~p
°^`"' ~~
+c nlnn n
rr cc
+orc n rr
av
r ~rni n+ vc
ho ~
vcrv
r i+omc T
r
r
r
o
nr n~r+c of
,~
~
_
~ ~ ~ ~n• l
a
v s
#^I~ e
~
o nh ~ioinoll .i o++~nho i-1
Tt~s
~t~c .
~~r~ ~v
n
'
n
n r
v-,
,, ~{~~~,~ +
'
X
e'
'- ,
, }
Y'
}
',.
s
6 8~4~ ~
trt~FA~e
}h ~/~~~r ~f~~~v/+y~.• ~.~~.•
^ r
n~~ ur
i
r
inlL TCYt
uii+ lii
F
c
G
t
hin nr n tY~
~~j ~- +h
-
'
" tt#
tttF
o normi+
" ~
4or ~
l nron
'
~CTi{.iTIT/CCG"I
~
n
nrmi
[~ei
+~P
~
~ G~P QT TP~TG TfiT7~TTT
~e~ GTfr
r
I
I
~/ T L-~7GTT7
TT[
ohlno ~ rG C
nrl WCT
TC77
rhoirc
nn nri~i~
+o
`~~
~
~
~
n r c ~ l~~~OF~
zE ~ SEI
'N~~~ 6--~~FS SfA ~~ ~l n l l h o i ~ e a r! fn r
va t - Y `" , t
"`"
nr i ~ i~+nno of
•+ lin
g nnr lino
n
o fn
r nn~i no
+nhlic
hmon+•
nnr '
ohnll
+hn n~ i+r~n
nr
~
vim El
S2~
cd
S ~
~
~"
°
1~v~
m
^
^
t s
l~
-F
FFEE~
S
~
6f
lg-
-
v~
row+~+~ ~rnn+c %+nr ~ rli -
ninn rnn ~
m u
c n r nc nrn ~r
rrp
w
~ ~nrlc ~
fnr nlnim in n ovo ~
mn+inn fro m
r~ ., .......~ ~ ......... ......
n~ inh rnn~ tiro mo .. .....
no .... y .....
~ inr~nr + . ~ ...
hn . ~ ...
nrn ..... ~ ~ ..
~iicinno ..~ ...,...
of nrni
- .... .........
ni+~i nrrl ....
inn ~ .:, ..:.
nr+o n .. r...., .. ...
r c+o+o I n~ ... .
ei
~~_.._~---------
----
------ -
--- -rn-g
r- vTOn~rr~ 7rorrv
~ orr v o ~ v
- ~ rn c ry ro~c~ oi ~ rcrrc,zcro v .
~pq~+i
~c e
~~
nr
fire
nr firo e
~gp~
~~_~~
~p r
i ~ip~o
n+ ohnll
hn
r
r
lln
~~ n ~~i~ IL r ~ihn+hor nr nn + c~ ~nh ~ ro ~ is n rniororl by ~
~
~~
n~
~ rm
i
T
vvv
~ r
n
vc
~
}
e
~
'~f
'
'
~
n~ ~ i ~ ~
~ ~'~'~ 'rr
r ~ ~
u
~ C
t
. ~C
I 1ttF tt tt tc~i
e
~ ~ ~. ~ nr n
° n~i n~~r flnmm~ hlo
~
/~i1 I Innn +h n i e~~ ~n~n ~ nf o h~ irrin ~
nno ~~ ~
inrn• ~ e
~~
p~ +{~ o
pf~~ ~ ~~ s
n hoirc n nr n+hnr one ~imm ~n+
~~~F
~
~n~
~ ~i`°~ ~I h
T
~'~~""~1
c -F~
~ ~ ~~
-
64i --
'
h
uT
r' 6i~ F~n ~ --S~
n '
ii
--
--~-
c
rnnc+i+~ ~+o nn nmornon v.-cm
nv r
:
i
c•i+i in+in .r
.
n n r
o ro fo ronno rr
iJ in +h a
r
r
r
r
ic rl i~iic in n G r
r~ cr
find D ~+r~rli+innr+l mo no of nnfn rno mo n+ +ho n i+v mn ~i rmm~~ m onv oir •n~~iolL n nfn
' ~pCtLLLgIyy
~ ro
~ c• n n n ~ i h i I i+~ i of ~~
~-6 +
~-rt
e
o T
° ~T~ ~
~- rtvi
~
GYtY--~
~t
roonnncihlo fnr nn~i rln ~-G .
m n ~il.
noc nr I nc•c • of nnr ~inm t
.
on+ ~eih o
v
Qt
inh is lo r
~eif ~ ill~i r•n btl~
nficno+or+
~\ ~lnl~lnl
i
+~~ ~fo o ne iinm ,,~
,,-~L
-~ ~•fin~ i c~
'~ _en +h rn~i or^I
y
-
~L / _ J
r+innrnm ~niJ n
n~ C~G
~ ~iic ~
o n T~TT
rnh ~{
~
~
}
_ ' ' ' _ 1_
ihi~~
~nl~ J
~,~~~
~ 1 1 `1 1
~~n
normi+ nr
on
,
~
6
T
~~ ~ ~ n~~~~ ~
~ O
~~p~p/++h ,
n +h
n
r
v r
rv°
°
~
c '
~n
-rrt
-
tititCtt
h
o+ +ho
nr
"
v~+
nh~irc•T~i
'~ ~
} ~,,
T
n
--+
h- T
te
r
c
cr
c~
c~, .
c., I
,.
,
I
Jnrn- v~~~~
'
r°
e-`"
-6~°
-
'
r
ir
p
rovi
Aln ofnrr+no ~ ~c+
~
~ loc
~-~ tliir
i
cT
r
~no
oil~ r
cr.
~
CVY~Mr
c
c
c
ioneinr ~.~~IU nofo
-
-
~e ~~
~e
-
-
-
nnr ~inmon+ oh~+ll h i
.
~
o r+lln~~ior• in +hn '
c. ~
normi+ n rvv
ar
tFt
v~
a
rrr
varc
ron in nnv nnr•finn of +hn n~ ihlin
~f ~~i~+~i nr ni i
ri
n
h +~irlo ~`~ ~~6Anf ~ of +ho h~ ~iliJinn in ~eihirh +
h~
~
r
7 r
uii+hin +ho nifi~ ov nnn+ +h-~+ +ohloc nnr! nlno orJ_~ in ~ imhrolloc mov rom~in nn
vnrrnrrrrr .. ~~ ~ ......
ho n~ ~hlin rinh+_nf .....~..< <. ~.... ...........,
_uro~i n~ In
-ate ..... ~... .......
+
h
ar
~ .... ... r. .................. .......~ ............ ,...
~ nl.~rnr~ in ~n nrrlorhi mnnnor
w~ ~
r
~ •
+h r++ rln nn~non f nr hro~+Lf~+c~r c
- ~~ro ~ n•nn m hr±ll _+ +ho
e
-
~
Z
-
-
c,-raxc-crv-r,v pcr,--r v,-vrG~rcra-v ,
v r~crn,
rv :v~
t~
rr-
~u.,
,
c
nn .•.f h. ~c•innoo
- - - - - r
e n./°
~~ - o or}o
S
6
- m° n~ ~ ° nn
6+
'vrv
~
hn
G~~ ~+ni} o+n r° r
~~
- v c~
}}
~ in
--
-~~
' ~
u~r~.ro~ ~
„
TC~~~
J
°~~r
'
- rrr~ r
m
°1 rc~
-r°
~ } p c
~
~r~} i is
t
vv
.. / r~n
~
m
n i
F
v
~ i
n
tt
I
} ° lttl.
~
r
C
~
~
° n-
~ h~~
c
' FT
a
s
~~~ c t
r
~
JB r'
i~
- -v°
T
v
'
v 7a~
~
I '
~
° ~ ~ r
n
i~
a
v ~
c
rt
7
a
FI~'Fc}n
vr° v E~c
h E' J
n m ~
n. / m J
r
u
~ i n ~ n~ c
~
t
Ctlttil.
t
ggb
q° r
T n
m
a
~~ vt
.C
}, ,' aur
r
r
i
~
u~ rn I I
-° T
~
t
~ ° n / i
G~t~
°
-~
rt
v~~
r~~
°
n° rm i} o
r° o
,
c
~
'~
cr
~"~ ~Y ltFl ~.~-
~vm t~
r
i
~~
crrr ttt
~
i~~r~-~
'
° n /
iv ~~~~
e ~~}'
~
~~
~S
'
~ S ~vio n
° n n rf o n /~•~
tt
ll~
~
~oinn nnnnoonr~
h v
~~ c
oll nn} h° ~
.
7
t
UtF
n~~~
~
~v ~
ea ~wT
- ~
~
n fi./° fn°} of
p
}hn .~/°I ~
nnl
i~
r
a ~
8 i
~~ tt
l
~~' "-' }F~~~`^6"
~
~ ~~ ti
t1
n
5 r in frnn} of
~
-wr
r
r
r
c+nr°frnn+o nn I inn
/.•.n\ Thn nlon
erx~e~i ~
nln C
~~ ?n°~
a of n
s+~
-- ~
ttil:
i ~
~ ~e~--s
e~ e~s~
ol ~
i-Q~
~~ chic }
s
+n
~r-~„~Q - -
~, ~
~
~ ar ~ ~
y oh
/hh
1 T oll h° nn li. /° °n+°r}°inm° n+ nr c n°oL°rc nl°n°~J in +h° n°rm i+ or°°
r
~
~ ~nl°oo nn rmi++°~ o0 0 on°ni of °./°n + (~nn /+i+inno o~ ~nh oo hn~ ~ro on/-1 /- 7ovo of
pp~~~n nnr+ n~ Arli n I~olo .~/ill h° r ~p~J h.~~
~i~~~ on+
``•'''YYUrt~ttil.o°
/nn~
h
°
~~
m}}}}°./ ./ orv
f
~
rIi ~rinr. t vno
r•
- ~
"`"I' "'!
r°
~'
'B
B~}
~
n~ ~irq ~
~~
n
'+
j
r
i
.c-~
r rlinr. tt
ni ~+rdnnr t
c
~~p_ nl°°r tt
tYFC
Ln°° ~
tt
~
i
can°n~Q~F}~. 7 7 i~ r
i
c
~~
h+ '2n
h ~
innh°o in ~
"~
~~~9 in
vrt
°~~r
°n+h onrl Z/1 innhno i
`+
n mo ~
vim~ im
i
-r
r
~ohl
n h
[~}
yµ,-~-~,-.,)
+
+
n
~h ~rr
~
f
~ I~~I+nr
--o c
r
no+i./ c
7
/ °n~ ii./°I°n+ ~±nnnooi
-
'
'
hln o
°n~
~
rt
" -
~-
~
-
J"" '-1- ~
~
-' TGT TCfCTP ~ GTI
C1lYGffGTIT
Q
QQ .~..TJT 17iri ~ cCf
rni ~nrl +o hl° of ZL: innhno rl~
~ ~ rG
T ni ~r i
~ rl
h
@S -~R boo
--
- n ../i+h
-
inrli./irl~ ~r+l
o~ ~nnnr}o T
.
~
° n T r
r
v
o oh.~ll nn+ °nnrnonh va
~
in +h ~vv
rcrr
° nl°or
n r n roo C~~ . i
~ /o I
f
°
rt
~
" ii~-~~ ~~-
c°
~~°cr
~~
-
~
°- ~~~ ~-z v
t
~~°n~ vu
}
rtu c
i
r
~
c
,,, h„
-~e
~ + nn~ ~
d
At
d
c
~
c
~Zl'+
-
ur
~}°
v~S ~oll
- n
v
lr
F
imm°rlio} -
t~
c
°Iv l~t
G
tlti
~+ ^~~^ r
tilY
rr
cc
~ ~rr v
~
p
oirl°.e/oIL nofno•
/'I \ In np~~ ~ /~/~r.~ i ~n+inn oll rlinin .ter°oo cc p ~/+/+~~+oihl° In
'
VT ~7TJLTF QL7~ ~ ~ZfT
cQa~~a ~Clvv~iJ~T{7T~'-TlT
Tpry~ ~~r'p _1
/
1 1
n r(1. /1/l D
/1 TfI~L}h/1.
_C7n ~jpn/InnC 7n1~ !ln/~nr 7rn nrn\/111n~T
~?
on ~
ihl p
n ono nGl°-Trf'U' a~gGlhTll, ~`
L1 +~^ p~°roI n~~ii~hlin one orn~
Vi
Q
r°~+rin+
/~n °i•1
n
~ +n ~ ~o°
°c h./ n°nnl°
~~~ ~~ 7
T
../i+h rJtitio~n: hilyi+i°o
goll h° ~ minims ~m of 44 innh°c
--
-
- -
-
-
rr ~
dv
n-
-
~ v
~n~ c~
~c L/ If rr
on nnn°oo un
Trnrrm~arrr
vr
rnvrTU
v~. a
a
ihl° rn~ i+° boo Inoo +hon G:n innhno nlnor
i
rtly
I
..drl+h + ho n nooo inn ~+ Ino o+ Rn innh°o h./ an innh°o oholl h° Inoo+°rJ
n+ r°r+c
/41 (~ hi +
~ nn
o ~+hln in
innh ~rli +nnrole nn
nn ~ imhr°I + +n °vn°°,~ inn f°°+
loo mn~ in+°rJ .~/i+h +hnir Inorlinn °rln°o o}
r
~~°' °J
~,Y ~,~,'~ a s
,`•'
77 in
nh°o ohn. r
/o o./ nrn+r~ ~r•I° on./
~s
~ ~~
~7C~
n~~n YY
+ ~'~--r-m
fro°o+ vrn~~
onrlinn nh a~prvrrcra~arr~
~
J
ion+o mn~~n}°/-1 nn nno}o nr n./Inno mo./
nvnrho nn 17 inn h°o m.wi m~ im frnm 77 innh°o +n Stn innh°o ohn./°
nrn ~n rl nr fin ioh ~~~p~.~~~~ f~~~
nlpnr .w /irl+ h of nn nnnnooihl n rn~ ~+° nr m~nn~°~~i n/°rinn onnn°
i~e~-~s 6
^
--^~R e~+~° ~~ F81F 2E~TR
EAR
1~F'~s#+E~f~ ~l~'+~ ^ ~
S+~e p
y
Wc?~k
s of e- eF~}I~ ~} r
-F~ ~
&Ifl~~ --
}
-
2~-Afl-~~e
eF~+~ ' c n Te-
~Fe
r
i ^ ;
Q
oh.~ll ~
ho o.,~ilo ~
~
hlo fnr in ono^+i nn by ^i+v ~
norcnr.nol •++ III +im oo ~
~~
+ho r on+
esfa~ Tho ,-hio
-
- ov
~ c II
# I ho c ~ rn.,io~e, ~ i
~7es#~ n
~e cuho
~
er~ie nc
~~
527_`2 ~,r
r
A`)/^\ ~nr! rT,~
a,~
S27_'252~1/ ~
~
n\ .~,h a„
i^h ~~
in^I~„- ~~
loc ,-locinn nnr•) hio ,~
+nrin ,~
„
nraonn,~+in ~
n
~~~
~~F~_
~_~gp,~ e
~~
~r
2ionl o.
, mn., hn rp~jp~~
or•I i
n n nno~ n
n
Tea fer-~k~a~-#+ ~e~ee+ .~ ,ir~1n
h ., fn s ~r fn ~~p~
nr,r•1 fi.,o fn n+ hin h
nr ~+ ^~+o n
~
sf~ +r~+fa~-sa- as+~--~ ~
les~ a--~a ~
e~ ,
~+s
~"Yi~S "° a
or` +~~,
~~
p ~ ~
~ -- ~tti
~
im omon+ of +ho
~ nlw
- oho ll mi
-- nimi~n ^
ss~e no n, f
s nr
~ r ptuy ~~u n
mr rnnTr~~
v r-rre ~~ry--r vr
/
riJ ~A
-~ ~ ~~T~ 41
i v-
~ ra
~
~ I~~~ !:
~ 1 /'2 ~ 2 ~ 1 ~
..
~ n~
~lF~ .
-~t
P~e
~9AA Gttd
-~~~~ ~~-~ T-
~~ E~
llT ~1 ter
.
t~
~
~nn~-~~s2~
~
P
le ~
~
~ ~
~ ~-n
; -
: ~
-
i
- ~ ~
/o\ Tho n e~- a
rees ~~
pp n
i~rl ~~a. ~
r+nr~ hnlr! h~±rmloo~
C„~tt t g _ ~
e
F
#~I
c~ '
n
-
~--
s
`
~F~-SeS$
f~6+in
r
-v:
h
~s
~
"
•
~ic
~^
d+r +
v
~~1 e
~
~
~H+
^
+
h t
°
.
~
pe~i~~ a
oo~c r
r
~^+i ~
c
.,i+., nn +h Trv
r
o rlomio r
r
7T
nrl nrn T'T
~
-
~r:
c
micoc• v r-
1 pe
C
r
v~
i-r r~
i+o nu,n
rte
/ 1
~
nvn
`v
m
nno
m
e~
o +hn fnll
~
I p~
s+
~
rne,inn ro
° rn~
n~ iirom
~ h i I i+.,
nn+o•
i
i ~ ro n ^
i n
G s
L~m n~~
~
,~
~ ~ ~ r
r
~~ rr
R ,
"
'^
~ ~ ~
e
r! e
o •
Tho ni+.
- , m + h
-
~$ o .~m
~
- nlJ ~n
-
~- ~r1~i
- ~
~~ ~
v
6~+s ~~
a ri~~vrc
e~ae-e ~n
r
rv
e~e~som ~
rn
rT
n~' crrr
CV+
~
'~
~~~ c~rar
uea
~ ,
~ o nnr^
,,
/71
-- ~
roflo
C r
~ ~
^+in
oirlo n ^mm~li~
.~, ~ o
~
s n^n ~~,i+h
f .shin
e5 z
+hio rn
nn
~S r
r1~7
n~ ~irnmon
,
~2~69~6 -
+
h
~+G
e ~7
~n
~eF
no nhnli
^
~ r
,~ ,Q ~
~
~ ~.,,,a ~ -Q ~g ..~,
s ~
m
uj r
- ~u~a J ~e s*~
~e s I ron ^o ~ e,i+h +h i o
\
4 r
rr
ron~ i
ron~ i
rcga
All n ~C
irom
_`~
ir~
-rr
nli
+ Y~
on+
\ \A/n
h., th,~ o+
v~ rr~.~
mi ~c+
es- ~Att~
r ~~' E
o+n
rcr«
h ~ ~o
e-+s~ -t
-~
J h., n
-
-
e -
FtG
~~~
ioc
+
~ 'ttti
~pm
`"'~~ ~' ~~
~~ ~+hnr
nln"~
YY~~`"'77
i~nrJ
5+~ li~hili+~
-ncrvn
~
-
n
u-~ ~~~
ui~ °
"
a-r ~~
ac ~ R 1 G~
o
• \ / I n r h ~
c
n~n
n r r
R~~ r~~
,
~ o.
R
~~ n (`
~
/F\ itt
l
to+oo
Tho + orl
^i+. .c~
rr
i+inn
, m~ ~c+
r~~
~ ~
~
~ ,c' .~,ri++
on nn ~
+i v ~
rinr +n
.,
~'~ fl~ _ ~J-YY'TTL GGTI-fT~ 'LTO~G ~TR7T-C~ GfT I~
1
e~ m ~ i c+ n rn~ i i rJ n
~~~
n ~,~h'~~,~ nn ~
rt
~
l~TFti~
~if~~~r~f inoi ~r~±n
ini ~~hn rnn~
n° ~±~
°n~
~
` ~irmm~n+o
~
~o
n +h
~
~
r
+h i
~~ r
~
d
I~
n--n
~
iA
~° ~nviT
T
~
e
r
n
i-.~
nn°rr++inno Coif ern +n nmm~l~i ~
~
c
~~ii+h +hncn rnn~ sir°mon+c drol r~
l roe is
~....~~...~~.... ~ ...~....... ... .......~..~~
ci ~ nnnoinn nr r°inno+inn of +
~ ~ /~°_~ti\
~ n_
~~
~ns2
riJ I ...... ...v..v .....~...~~....~....... ........
hn nnrmi+
s2_°~
(1T'
--P~6~-~~~
- . ........:..: ...
53-~4-~9-
~
,
~
~ ;
a
.
~~. Q7_'2QQ. ~~e~'{~~~c~rvrr~~~~ip'6~e~
/~~ P.FI~}i+r-'r~~ 6F1vFtttYtti~-i~AtrtMtFP.'.S~t
oirlnui~+IL nnfn nnrmi+ mn~i h° r°vnLnrl. nr oyf~~,on°nrl„°~~rl ~.if i+ is fni ~nr~ +ho+•
/'1~1n~nT~~j~oni hi loin°c•c•~T~Li-~gEftYttt-YF~'J~°°n c~ ~cn°nrl°r~
Y e
/7\ hn n nn+
~
P
~ ho~m ino~ iron ° uih
6
- in nnrr°n+ onrl
'
-
rc~-l-rtc~l
YMt~t
. .
~
°ffnn+i~i° in +hn minims ~m m rurr
vm
r.
m~~ ~n+c rlnonrihnr+ in o TV ~~vn
co~r
urrv
nn+inn Q7_4S2C.
/Q1 Thn nnrmi++°° °vr`°°r!c +h n onnrn~mrl cn~ ior° fnn +on° by nlorinn onv
e ~
n foilnr•
/nl Th°
- •~
+ ~iinlos+
-
-
of +hio r•ivieinn nr
-
'
~
~T'~7"T - 1_ I,TITiGTGTTfQ~'
TQTTGTI
i+nnrli+inno of +hic n°rmi+ ~~ ~YYG~~T
V~iLf
ii+hin 77 hn~ pro of rnr ~r
ITTT
JZff7TJ~T~T r~7T
nin+ of +hn r•irnr•+nr~o
nn+inn of c~ inh ~iinln+inno rJ nli~mrnr~ in ~eiri+inn +n + hn n°rmi++°°
/h\ If +h° nnrmi+ +nn foilo + n r° mnv° on~i +ohl °c nhoirc °nrl n+hor n hion+e r°lo+°rl
t°
+n +hn cir!°~~
i°IL nofn
~~ii+hi
n 77
hn~ pro of ~
rnnnin+ of
+hn iJirnn+n
r~c final nn+inn
~u
n ~~
~~
n~o~
n
n c~
~
~S
-
~ ~
~m~ r~
+
c~~°
mvvc
ttil7
c rr p ~ lttC~Y t
ttQit
YY av r
r
c
`
-
°
m-
r
T
C~E'°
~
F~F~i°
~-1~
'
irB pp,~
~F ~ t
e
~
c
m
r c a "' 7 , `" "~
crvY
e
~ v
~ ~ rro
inv
± -
-i
n
in
n
~ G~'6+
i8~n°
~}~tib~
'~
m nm l~
d A'bt~~++,
,,}}
h o l
i~
° }
-viT a ~,, ,.
aii °
a-c
° ~
+
8~~~}
- r
c„r
~r
~r,~ +
~
-
'
~ r
r.
+
'
~
o
if n n
~~~ ur
tttl
ti
n
~~
~~ tYS7 T.
c~
_ C
t CFFt
FitrF
t
tY ti
i
~
nrinr ~r•mini ~
,
o+ro+i~i° h °orin r~ hn fnrn o cn nniol mac+ or onnnin+° r• oc nrnvir+°r•
~y~ }}h~~~ r`i.rl i
~ + i ~nl°cs Tn n +nr finrlo
'
- +h n+ nn mm
- ~rnnnn~i n nnrl i+inn Hula+o
'
-
TITLTTI
~~CG CRI"1T~JJ G~ 'CO1T
7~~7 c7TLfCZTr
GTTf GTl3. GTIV~ TTQfCf~TT
r./~TJ
R7
°n
~+
a
~
ri
oll nn s
+ hn rnn~ ii o
r ~h
~soc,~o
n
pry ~r~nv ~
C~ii
o~ ~onnnoi T
nn n
r~~~r~~°~~~
in`"'n~~ ~n}~/~n
}h[~ n°rmi++ T
p° ohnll i ~
~
mmnrJio+nl~i hn
~i1Tf~CiTIV~ ~JF7G rrJi 01TV TTriY V~CfGf~TT CI""IL FTGTITTfiT 6
~~~~~~ ~rinn i n °r nnrrl onnn ~~ii+ ~{}~nr~n °~J~ on + fnr+h in +hic
b~:
rr~
I
rv
°
n S2
~
~v
V 7
--
\
v°~ ~
~ ~ ~ " ~" ~
~~ O
~7
-~~--~
f. ~
~ 7 _ ~
°~
.
n-a--r
~ ~~G~7
vv . -r
T 7
r
,
.r ~
(~ ~
~
Q7 '2527
Time ~
~`
. ~
~ ~~ rr~.l .. f ~~nnr.i~) f
ees rl~~ o• •~i~i~isr .~.
- f 1~4n
--
•
~
• ~ ~ ~ ~a ~.~~~
o ,
ram
. h
~}~ l~n n mr.rrvnr~~.i ~f fon}inn nrn nor}~ i of + ho }n~ ~ricm in ~Ji ~c}ni
G
tFY1F+ew~
of }he ni},~ c ~.~oll c ni }i~onc • of ~Ai~mi R nonh ~c o uih nlo n~~~mon} of ~ mnoirl
~ v~ ~v~~o~~~~ o c
~n
~'I }
frn
~
'~ ~ ~~UOr~i ~1~1~~or n
v ~ rho ovniro}inn of ~n~i
~
o
~
~
rlrJi}inn~+l }imn norinrl nn } }n o vnoor} D(1 rln ~
vc• oc of ~}h p
nri~ orl h~ i }ho rifii m~n ~norl
cnvaTrv ~ ......... .... ...... ~.,, ...., ......,.. .....~.. ... ..~ .. ... ...~ ....,.. ....~... ~r
~~ ,,h,.,~,.,,,I
~C-A'k3QtCtY
Timms
'2QQ
ve
~rr~l ~
~e
f ~~nn~irl
fos
c rl~~
e• ~~i~i~ier ~
f 1~4n
-
•
des. @L YFAi t f
I
T°~~
°
e~i
~ §~ifln wii~e{~eF{
n ~
T6
'
° i
^
6} rB h
° }
-
°~
`
n
f
}- n
ar~
T
rc
-
cw v 9- p r
~r
~~
r
c r
r
r~ ~r
p r
T
om
c
r
~
v
rz v
l
n ~
T
e
~~
d f ~"^ '~ n
r~ p r
•~ I L n ~l f l i f G~
m
~ - '
"G
e ~f~T~
GTfO ~-~T~ O
~
1
FTf
~7QT
'Q
~n~
r}•+~i frn
erT
m
vv .?n~t
++^^ GT
,,,,„
~~,
~e
°r
- l
Tf
~7
~nn~ /n
'1 ri
RG
r
~ ~n I
7
T
nn +h P
o ovniro}inn of ~n~i
-~t
rrrv
-
t~fY
~+r}r1i}innr+l }imn norinr} nn Yl7~t~
} }n o titki
C .
vnoor^) ~(1 r}o ~
vc ~c of i} '
hnri~ orl by }ho t+i}~i mM n~+nnr~
~~ii}h ~+}n n~+~imnn} fn oc~ ~n rl i-Inlinn~ ~on n~i non~l}i oc in ~nn nocr}inn }hnrn ~~ii}h }n
vr~~Tr ~~' N 7
~~
~+
r M
s 7 M
Subdivision I. Generally
Sec. 82-366. Definitions.
The followina words, terms and phrases, when used in this division, shall
have the meanings ascribed to them in this section, except where the context
clearly indicates a different meaning:
City Manager - means the city manager or the city manager's designee.
Menu board - means a board allowing for the posting of a restaurant's
complete menu and fabricated in such a manner so as not to constitute a
form of general advertising or establishment identification. The location size,
design materials and color of the menu board shall be approved by the City
Manager and will be no larger than six (6) square feet; may not be internally
illuminated and the top of the menu board shall not exceed five feet, six
inches (5'6") from grade.
Permittee -means the recipient of a sidewalk cafe_ permit under the terms
and provisions of this division.
Restaurant - for purpose of this division only, means a food service
establishment that is maintained and operated as a place where food and/or
beverages are prepared and/or served and sold for consumption within the
premises or a business establishment which has, as an ancillary or
secondary use, a part thereof where food and/or beverages are prepared
and/or served and sold for consumption within the premises. No sidewalk
cafe permit shall be issued to a restaurant whose occupational license or
certificate of use is limited to take-out service and does not have inside
seatin .
Right-of--way -means land in which the state, the state department of
transportation, the county or the city owns the fee or has an easement
devoted to or required for use as a transportation facility or street.
Sandwich board sign - means a freestanding, A-frame structure located on a
sidewalk or street which may be affixed in position or is collapsible and which
contains a sign (as defined in Section 114-1 ).
Sidewalk - means that portion of the right-of-way which is located between
the curb line or the lateral line of a street and the adjacent property line and
which is intended for use by pedestrians; provided that on Lincoln Road Mall,
a sidewalk shall mean aright-of-way as defined in this section, but shall only
refer to that area between the property line and the centerline of the right-of-
way, exclusive of landscaped areas and a twelve (12) foot-wide clear path for
emergency and maintenance vehicular access.
Sidewalk cafe - means a use located on a right of way which is associated
with a restaurant, and is primarily characterized by tables and chairs, may
be shaded by awnings, canopies or umbrellas, and may include such other
sidewalk cafe furniture (as hereinafter defined) as permitted and/or approved
pursuant to this division.
Sidewalk Cafe Furniture -means those non-permanent fixtures, furnishings
and equipment associated with the operation of a sidewalk cafe and approved
pursuant to this division including, without limitation, tables, chairs, umbrellas,
planters heaters, fans, rolling service stations, service carts, bussing stations,
and menus and/or specials board.
Sidewalk cafe site map -means acity-approved map detailing the location of
the pedestrian pathway as it relates to a sidewalk cafe.
Sign -shall have the same meaning as provided for in Section 114-1.
Specials board - means a board allowing for the posting of a restaurant's daily
specials and fabricated in such a manner as to not constitute a form of
advertising or establishment identification. The specials board shall be no
larger than four (4) square feet; may not be internally illuminated; and the top
of the sign shall not exceed five feet six inches (5'6"~ from grade. The
location, size, design, materials and color of a specials board shall be
approved by the City Manager.
Street -means that portion of a right-of-way improved, designed or ordinarily
used for vehicular traffic or parking.
Usable sidewalk area -means the frontage of the property times the width of
the sidewalk, less five (5) feet.
Sec. 82-367. Declaration of necessity and intent.
It is hereby found and declared that:
~a) There exists the need for outdoor eating establishments (sidewalk cafes)
in certain areas of the city to provide a unique environment for relaxation
and food consumption.
(b) The existence of sidewalk cafes encourages additional pedestrian traffic
to these areas.
(c) The presence of sidewalk cafes may thus impede the free and safe flow
of pedestrian traffic.
(d) There is a need for regulations and standards for the existence and
operation of sidewalk cafes to facilitate and ensure a safe environment in
these areas.
(e) The establishment of permit conditions and safety standards for sidewalk
cafes is necessary to protect and promote the general health, safety and
welfare of the residents of the city.
(Ord. No. 92-2808, § 1(39-28), 10-8-92; Ord. No. 97-3092, ~ 1(39-28), 9-10-
97
Sec. 82-368. Removal and storage fees; disposition of property.
If pursuant to this division, the city removes, any sidewalk cafe furniture, the
~ermittee shall be responsible for the reasonable expenses incurred by the
city for the removal and storage of all such sidewalk cafe furniture. The City
Manager shall promulgate and review, as needed, regulations regarding the
storage and disposition of sidewalk cafe furniture under this division. The city
and its officers and employees shall not be responsible for sidewalk cafe
furniture removed and/or relocated pursuant to this division.
(Ord. No. 97-3092, ~ 1(39-36), 9-10-97)
Sec 82-369 Appeals from the decision of the City Manager.
Appeals from decisions of the CitLr Manager made pursuant to this division
shall be to the special master in accordance with the procedures set forth in
chapter 30 article III Appeals from the decisions of the special master shall
be to a court of competent jurisdiction by petition for writ of certiorari.
(Ord No 92-2808 $ 1(39-38) 10-8-92' Ord. No. 97-3092, ~ 1(39-37), 9-10-
97
Sec. 82-370. Notice of violation.
~a) Code compliance officers shall issue twenty four (24) hour warning
notices for all non-life safety violations of this division.
(b) No warning notices shall be required prior to the issuance of life safety
violations and/or sidewalk cafe site plan violations, and shall be
corrected immediately Life safety violations are defined as those
conditions which in the reasonable determination and judgment of the
City Manager involve serious danger and/or risk to the public health,
safety or welfare (including without limitation blocking or obstructions
to pedestrian pathways and violations of the state accessibility code for
building construction) Site plan violations are defined to include those
instances where the permittee and/or sidewalk cafe operator is
o~eratinq outside of the permitted sidewalk cafe area (as approved
pursuant to Section 82-382(a)(6)) and shall include: a table or tables
set up outside the approved boundaries of the sidewalk cafe site plan;
and/or umbrellas heaters fans busing stations and other sidewalk
cafe furniture found to be outside the approved site plan; but shall not
be deemed to include instances where a chair or chairs are moved
outside the boundaries of an approved site plan by a sidewalk cafe
atron s .
(c) If a code compliance officer finds a violation of this division, such code
compliance officer shall issue a notice of violation to the violator, as
,provided in chapter 30 article III, as follows:
1. For non-life safety violations of this division (where a 24-hour
notice has been previously issued within the preceding sixty (60)
days for the same violation) - a violation will be issued.
2. For life safety violations of this division and for site plan violations
- no 24-hour warning notice is required and a violation may be
issued at an ty ime.
Sec 82-371 Civil fines and penalties/Denial of Future Permits to Repeat
Violators.
~a) The following civil fines and penalties shall be imposed for violations of
this division:
(1) First Violation .............................................$100.00
(2) Second violation within the preceding twelve (12)
months .$250.00
(3) Third violation within the preceding twelve (12) months
- 500.00
(4) Fourth within the preceding twelve (12) months $750.00
(5) Fifth violation within the preceding twelve (12) months - a fine of
$1 000 and suspension of the sidewalk cafe permit for one
weekend (Saturday and Sunday)
(6) Sixth violation within the preceding twelve (12) months - a fine
of $1 000 and revocation of the sidewalk cafe permit for the
remaining portion of the permit year
(7) Failure to apply for permit -termination of sidewalk cafe
operations
(8) Failure to renew permit - suspension of sidewalk cafe
operations
(b) A permittee who has been issued more than six (6) violations pursuant
to this division within a permit year shall be prohibited from applying for
and obtaining a sidewalk cafe permit for a period of two (2) permit
years following the permit year in which the applicant/permittee
incurred the aforestated violations.
Sec 82-372 Rights; payment of fine; right to appeal; failure to pay civil
fine or to appeal.
a) A violator who has been served with a notice of violation shall elect
either to:
(1) Pay the civil fine in the manner indicated on the notice; or
~2) Request an administrative hearing before a special master, to
appeal the decision of the code compliance officer which
resulted in the issuance of the notice of violation.
fib) The procedures for appeal shall be as set forth in chapter 30, article III.
~c) If the named violator after notice fails to pay the civil fine or timely fails
to request an administrative hearing before a special master, the
special master shall be informed of such failure by report from the code
compliance officer Failure of the named violator to appeal the decision
of the code compliance officer within the prescribed time period shall
constitute a waiver of the violator's right to administrative hearing. A
waiver of the right to administrative hearing shall be treated as an
admission of the violation, and penalties may be assessed accordingly.
(d) Any party aggrieved by the decision of a special master may appeal
that decision to a court of competent jurisdiction as provided in Section
162.11, Florida Statutes, as same may be amended from time to time.
(Ord. No. 92-2808. & 1(39-41), 10-8-92; Ord. No. 93-2897, $ 2, 12-15-93;
Ord. No. 97-3092, ~ 1(39-40), 9-10-97
Sec. 82-373. Recovery of unpaid fines; unpaid fines to constitute a lien;
foreclosure.
(a) The city may institute proceedings in a court of competent jurisdiction
to compel payment of civil fines.
fib) A certified copy of an order imposing a civil fine may be recorded in the
public records and thereafter shall constitute a lien upon any other real
or personal property owned by the violator, and it may be enforced in
the same manner as a court judgment by the sheriffs of this state,
including levy against the personal property, but shall not be deemed
to be a court judgment except for enforcement purposes. After two (2)
months from the filing of any such lien which remains unpaid, the city
may foreclose or otherwise execute on the lien.
(Ord. No. 92-2808, ~ 1(39-42), 10-8-92; Ord. No. 97-3092, § 1(39-41), 9-10-
97
Secs. 82-374--82-380. Reserved.
Subdivision II. Permit
Sec. 82-381. Required Action of City Manager upon failure to obtain.
(a) The approval and issuance of a sidewalk cafe is conditional at all
times.
b) It shall be unlawful for any person to operate a sidewalk cafe without
first obtaining a permit as required by this division. Sidewalk cafes shall
only be located where permitted by the city's zoning ordinance and
land development regulations, as same may be amended from time to
time.
cl The Citv Manager shall have the right to immediately remove, after 24-
hours' written and/or verbal notice to the germittee, any sidewalk cafe
furniture used in connection with a sidewalk cafe which is operating
without a valid permit. The city and its officers and employees shall not
be responsible for sidewalk cafe furniture, removed and/or relocated
pursuant to this division.
Sec. 82-382. Application.
~a) Each permit shall be effective for one year, from October 1 until
September 30 of the following year.
fib) Application for a permit to operate a sidewalk cafe shall include, but
not be limited to, the following information:
~1) The name, address and telephone number of the
applicant/permittee.
(2) The name and address of the business establishment seeking a
permit to operate the sidewalk cafe, and the name and address
of the restaurant.
(3) A copy of a valid city occupational license to operate the
restaurant in front of which the proposed sidewalk cafe will be
operating. The total count of chairs to be utilized for the
restaurant must include the number of chairs used in
conjunction with the sidewalk cafe and the number of chairs
inside the restaurant as authorized by the license.
(4) A copy of a valid certificate of use for the restaurant in front of
which the proposed sidewalk cafe will be operating.
,'5) A copy of a current certificate of insurance in the amounts and
categories required by Section 82-385.
(6) A site plan signed and sealed by a duly licensed architect or
engineer which accurately depicts the layout and dimensions of
the existing sidewalk area and adjacent private property;
proposed location, size and number of tables, chairs,
umbrellas, and any other sidewalk cafe furniture; and location(s)
of doorways, steps, trees, parking meters, bus shelters,
sidewalk benches, trash receptacles and any other sidewalk
obstruction(s), either existing or proposed, within the
proposed sidewalk cafe area. A sidewalk cafe permit shall be
specifically limited to the subject area shown on the approved
site plan.
(7) A copy of the sidewalk cafe site plan, as approved pursuant to
Section 82-382(a)(6) ,shall be maintained on the permittee's
premises and shall be available for inspection by city personnel
at all times.
~8) Photographs drawings or manufacturers' brochures fully
describing the appearance and dimensions of all proposed
tables chairs umbrellas, and any other sidewalk cafe furniture
related to the operation of the sidewalk cafe.
(9) Tables chairs, umbrellas, and any and all other sidewalk cafe
furniture shall be approved by the City Manager prior to the
issuance of a sidewalk cafe permit.
~0) The annual application shall be accompanied by a non-
refundable base application fee as set forth in appendix A.
(11) Applications shall be reviewed for compliance with applicable
city state and federal laws, and must be reviewed and
approved by the city's public works department' fire department;
office of risk management' finance department; and building
services department.
X12) Prior to issuance of a sidewalk cafe permit, the city's chief
financial officer shall certify that there are no outstanding fines,
monies fees taxes or other charges owed to the city by the
applicant/permittee and/or the restaurant and/or business
establishment. A sidewalk cafe permit will not be issued until all
outstanding debts to the city are paid in full.
(13) No sidewalk cafe permit shall be issued to a restaurant whose
occupational license or certificate of use is limited to take-out
service and does not have inside seating.
(14) A sidewalk cafe permit may not be transferred and/or otherwise
assigned. A new owner and/or operator of a restaurant and/or
business establishment with a sidewalk cafe permit will be
required to apply for and obtain a new permit.
X15) The permit covers only the public right of way. Tables and
chairs on private property will be governed by other applicable
regulations. No outdoor seating authorized pursuant to this
division shall be used for calculating seating requirements
pertaining to location of, applications for, or issuance of, a liquor
license• nor shall the outdoor seating be used as the basis for
computing required seating for restaurants, or as grounds for
claiming exemption from such requirements under the
provisions of any city ordinance or state law.
Sec. 82-383. Fee; renewal fee; penalties for late payments for renewal
fee; exception.
~a) The annual permit fee for operation of a sidewalk cafe shall be as set
forth in appendix A and shall be based on a per square foot
calculation of permitted sidewalk area (including the area between the
tables and chairs).
fib) The city manager in his reasonable discretion and judgment may
suspend or prorate the annual permit fee in cases of public
construction or public emergency situations.
~c) The permit fee shall be paid on or before October 1, and shall cover
the time period from October 1 through September 30 of the following
calendar year (permit year).If the permit fee exceeds $2,000.00, the
fee may be paid in two semi-annual installments, with the first
installment due on October 1, and the second due on April 1. No
permit shall be issued for any portion of a year, but any person/entity
operatinq a sidewalk cafe for a period beginning after the
commencement date of the full permit year (October 1) may obtain a
permit for the remaining portion of that permit year upon payment of a
pro-rated portion of the permit fee calculated from the first day of the
month of issuance of the permit to the end of the permit year. Except
as provided in Section 82-384(s), no refund of the permit fee shall be
rag nted.
(d) Late payments for permit fees shall accrue at the rate of ten (10%~
percent per annum for the first thirty (30) days. If the permit fee is not
paid within sixty (60~days after it is due, the permit shall terminate
automatically. Any continued operation of a sidewalk cafe after
termination of a permit shall be construed as operatinq a sidewalk cafe
without a permit, and the City Manager shall have the right to remove,
upon 24-hour's written and/or verbal notice to the permittee, any
tables, chairs, umbrellas and any other sidewalk cafe furniture used in
connection with the sidewalk cafe.
el As provided in Resolution No. 2003-25299, a review of the annual permit
fee will be required whenever the change in the Consumer Price Index
(CPI), between the latest CPI and the date of the CPI used for the last fee
adjustment, is five percent (5%) or greater.
Ord. No. 92-2808, ~ 1(39-30), 10-8-92; Ord. No. 95-2999, ~ 1, 6-21-95; Ord.
No. 97-3092, § 1(39-31 ), 9-10-97; Ord. No. 98-3146, § 1, 10-21-98; Ord. No.
2000-3237, ~ 2, 4-12-00; Ord. No. 2003-3397, § 1, 2-26-03; Ord. No. 2003-
3423, § 1, 7-30-03)
Editor's note: Ord. No. 2003-3397, ~ 1, adopted February 26, 2003,
changed the title of § 82-383 from "Fee; renewal fee; penalties for late
gavments for renewal fee" to "Fee; renewal fee; penalties for late payments
for renewal fee; exception."
Sec. 82-384. Standards, criteria and conditions.
(a) Sidewalk cafes are restricted to the sidewalk frontage of the restaurant
to which the permit is issued or, if the restaurant is an ancillary and/or
secondary use to another type of business establishment, the sidewalk
cafe shall be restricted to the sidewalk frontage of the building (or
portion thereof) of the "primary business" establishment (within which
the restaurant is located). The area of the permit may also extend by a
maximum total of fifty (50) feet on one side and/or the other of the
restaurant and/or the building (or portion thereof) of the business
establishment (within which the restaurant is located), subject to the
provisions of paragraph (b) of this section.
(b) An applicant for a sidewalk cafe permit may be permitted, upon prior
written request by the permittee to the City Manager to extend by a
maximum total of fifty (50) feet in the right-of-wav on one side and/or
the other side of the restaurant to which the permit is issued (and/or
the building or portion thereof of the business establishment where
the restaurant is located). In the case of sidewalk cafes on Lincoln
Road an expansion of a sidewalk cafe across the centerline of Lincoln
Road Mall will be allowed upon a determination by the City Manager
that:
the applicant/permittee would otherwise be significantl
deprived of the use_ of the right of wav for which the
sidewalk cafe permit is sought;
(ii) there are special circumstances and conditions that exist,
which were not self-created by the applicant/permittee,
and are peculiar to that portion of the right of way, and
are not generally applicable to other rights of wav in the
immediate area;
(iii) the granting of the expansion is the minimum that will
allow the applicant/permittee's reasonable use of the
area for its sidewalk cafe operations; and
(iv) the granting of the expansion will not significantly impair
the ability of pedestrians on that particular portion of
Lincoln Road Mall to walk comfortably from one side of
the Mall to the other.
(1) In order for the sidewalk cafe permit area to extend into the
portion of the right of wav or across the centerline of Lincoln
Road Mall pursuant to this subsection, the permittee must make
written application to the City Manager setting forth the
reason(s) for the proposed expansion and providing a site plan
showing the proposed expansion.
(2) All requests shall be reviewed by the Cit i~Manager on a case by
case basis. In reviewing such requests, the City Manager, in
making his determination to approve or deny, shall consider the
following:
Pedestrian access;
(ii) Visibility of the front of the adjacent owner(s')
business es);
(iii) Obstructions;
(iv) Accessibility to the adjacent owner(s') business(es) by
patrons;
(v) The City Manager, shall solicit input from businesses and
property owners on the same block;
(vi) The City Manaqer may also consider any history of
violations and/or warnings pursuant to Section 82-371;
and
(vii) In the case of a request to extend the permit area across
the centerline of Lincoln Road Mall, the City Manaqer
shall also consider the criteria as set forth in the first
paragraph of subsection (b).
(c) In the event of approval by the City Manaqer to expand a sidewalk
cafe the additional square footage will be computed into the new
permit fee.
(d) The permittee shall take any and all actions to assure that its use of
the public right of way in no way interferes with patrons of other
sidewalk cafes, or limits their free, unobstructed passage thereto.
(e) No tables chairs, umbrellas, or other sidewalk cafe furniture shall be
permitted within ten (10) feet of a bus stop bench. A distance of five (5)
feet shall be maintained from taxi stands, fire hydrants, alleys, bike
racks or any type of street furniture and/or public fixtures.
No tables, chairs, umbrellas or other sidewalk cafe furniture shall be
permitted within five (5) feet of a pedestrian crosswalk or corner curb
cut.
Sidewalk cafes shall be located in such a manner that a distance of not
less than five (5) feet is maintained at all times as a clear and
unobstructed five (5) foot pedestrian path around public amenities and
areas including, without limitation, fountains, landscaped areas, and
other similar public areas and/or amenities. For the purposes of .the
minimum clear path, parking meters, traffic signs, trees and all similar
obstacles shall constitute and be considered obstructions. A five (5)
foot pedestrian path shall also be required and established where the
City Manager in his reasonable judgment and discretion, determines
that the operation of a sidewalk cafe inhibits pedestrian access to an
adjacent business establishment or adversely affects the visibility of an
adjacent storefront.
h1 The pedestrian path for Lincoln Road shall be a twelve (12) foot, clear
path for emergency and maintenance vehicles, The exact location of
the path on each block shall be determined by the City Manaqer, in his
reasonable judgment and discretion and shall be incorporated into the
sidewalk cafe site map of Lincoln Road.
(i) No object shall be permitted around the perimeter of an area occupied
by tables and chairs which would have the effect of forming a physical
or visual barrier discouraging the free use of the tables and chairs by
the general public or (in the case of Lincoln Road) which would have
the effect of obstructing the pedestrian path or the public access
between the north and south sides of Lincoln Road.
~j) The City Manager may cause the immediate removal or relocation of
all or parts of a sidewalk cafe in emergency situations or for public
safety considerations.
(k) The City Manager may require the temporary removal of sidewalk
cafes when street sidewalk or utility repairs or other public
construction necessitates such action If such temporary removal
exceeds fifteen (15) days the City Manager shall pro-rate the
remaining permit fee for each additional day the sidewalk cafe is
removed and apply a credit toward the following year's permit fee, or,
upon written request by the permittee refund the remaining fee to the
permittee.
(I) The city and its officers and employees shall not be responsible for
sidewalk cafe furniture removed and/or relocated pursuant to this
division.
(m) The area covered by a sidewalk cafe permit and the sidewalk and
street immediately adjacent to it shall be maintained in a clean, neat
and orderly appearance at all times by the permittee. The area of the
sidewalk curb and gutter immediately adjacent to the sidewalk cafe
shall be cleared of all debris during hours of operation and again at
the close of each business day or as may otherwise be determined by
the City Manager The permittee shall be responsible for pressure
cleaning the floor surface on which the sidewalk cafe is located at the
close of business each day The city shall pressure wash the right-of-
way from time to time in accordance with such schedule as shall be
established in the reasonable judgment and discretion of the City
Manager In establishing said schedule the City Manager shall use
reasonable efforts to assure that the City's pressure cleanina of the
public right of way occurs at such times as will cause the least
disruption to sidewalk cafe operations.
(n) Tables chairs umbrellas and any other sidewalk cafe furniture shall
be maintained in a clean attractive and orderly appearance, and shall
be in good repair at all times.
~o) All sidewalk cafe furniture shall be of high quality desian materials,
and workmanship to ensure the safety and convenience of the public.
(p) Only the sidewalk cafe furniture specifically shown on the approved
sidewalk cafe site plan shall be allowed in the permit area.
All tables, chairs, umbrellas and any other sidewalk cafe furniture shall
be readily removable and shall not be physically attached, chained, or
in any other manner affixed to any structure tree, post, sign or other
fixture curb and/or public right of way within or near the permitted
area.
~ The stacking or piling up of chairs shall be prohibited on the right of
way Tables chairs and closed-up umbrellas may remain on the right
of way as long as they are placed in an orderly manner. Tables and
chairs may remain set up for business on sidewalk cafes on Lincoln
Road Mall that are set up and open for business before 11:00 AM.
Any sidewalk cafes not set up and open for business before 11:00 AM
shall remove all chairs and all other sidewalk cafe furniture, at the
close of each business day and store them inside the premises. The
permittee may maintain such sidewalk cafe furniture as rolling service
stations service carts and bussing stations in the permit area only
during hours of operation subject to review and approval by the City
Manager Provided however that planters that cannot be readily
removed may remain within the permit area subject to the provisions of
subsection (z) hereof. On Lincoln Road Mall, rolling service stations,
service carts and bussing stations shall not be permitted to be placed
within five (5) feet of the walls columns, or posts of the Lapidus
structures City planters or in front of other storefronts and/or business
establishments The City Manager may require a permittee to store its
tables chairs and/or umbrellas off of the right of way if, in his
reasonable judgment and discretion the City Manager determines that
the sidewalk cafe permit area and immediately adjacent public right of
way are not being adequately maintained in accordance with this
division.
(s) No storage of dishes silverware or other similar sidewalk cafe
equipment shall be allowed in the permit area, or in any other portion
of the public right-of-way (or outside the structural confines of the
building in which the restaurant is located) during non-business hours.
(t) Sidewalk cafes shall comply with all applicable accessibility codes
including without limitation the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)
and state codes addressing accessibility for building construction, as
same may be amended from time to time.
(u) There shall be no live entertainment or speakers placed in the permit
area unless expressly permitted as a special event. Conditions such as
hours and days of operation and audio levels will be regulated by the
city's special events office and these may vary during the year.
~v) One menu board plus one specials board shall be permitted, per
sidewalk cafe for every fifty (50) feet of frontage. The location, design,
materials and color of the menu board and/or specials board shall be
approved by the City Manager and the menu board and/or specials
board location shall be shown on the sidewalk cafe site plan. Menu
boards will be no larger than six (6) square feet may not be internally
illuminated and the top of the menu boards shall not exceed five feet,
six inches (5'6") from grade The menu board and/or specials board
shall not be a sandwich board or A-frame sign.
(w) No food preparation food displays food storage, or refrigeration
apparatus or equipment or fire or fire apparatus or equipment, shall be
allowed on the right of way.
(x) No advertising signs or business identification signs shall be permitted
- in the public right-of-way except as permitted in subsection (y) of this
section.
~y) Umbrellas and other similar sidewalk cafe furniture shall be fire-
retardant pressure-treated or manufactured of fire-resistant material.
All umbrellas (including type number and location of) shall be
reviewed and approved by the City Manager No portion of an umbrella
shall be less than six feet eight inches (6'8") above the right of way.
Siclns are prohibited on umbrellas as well as on chairs, tables and
other sidewalk cafe furniture except that the restaurant name and/or
its logo may be permitted on umbrellas Lettering and/or logos may not
exceed six (6") inches in height Two or more umbrellas may not be
clipped zipped or otherwise fastened together in order to form atent-
like structure Clear plastics or other materials may not be fastened,
rolled or otherwise be attached to umbrella edges in order to create an
enclosure.
~z) The City Manager may permit the use of plant containers (planters)
manufactured of terra-cotta or polymer materials as decoration with,
the number and size to be reviewed by the City Manager at time of
application Placement of planters within sidewalk cafe areas shall be
five feet (5'-0") apart or greater It shall be the permittee's
responsibility to immediately remove said planters upon written and/or
verbal notice from the City Manager in case of emergency or other
special circumstances Maximum size of planters shall not exceed the
following:
(1) Rectangular planters: 30 inches long by 15 inches wide by 20
inches high.
~2) Round planters: 24 inches diameter by 24 inches high.
(3) Planters 20 inches or higher shall be on rollers or on rolling
bases.
~4) Plants shall be properly maintained. Distressed plants shall be
promptly replaced Plant fertilizers which contain material that
can stain the sidewalks shall not be allowed. Water drainage
from any plants onto the sidewalk shall not be allowed. Potted
plants shall have saucers or other suitable systems to retain
seepage The combination of planters and plant height should
not exceed the table height of 34 inches.
~aa) Permittees may make written request to the City Manager to use City
electricity for powering floor fans during the summer months. Summer
mnnthc ara ~iPfinPri as the period beginning on Mav 1St. and ending on
operable upon payment of a flat fee of as determined and presented in
the reasonable business judgment and discretion of the City Manager,
for each of the calendar days during the summer months. City
electrical outlets will be restricted to powering floor fans only. Using
the electrical outlets for powering lights menu board lighting and any
other electrical device is strictly prohibited. Permittees violating this
restriction will have the electrical boxes deactivated and forfeit any
monies paid for electrical use. Fans must be UL approved for outdoor
use. Extension cords are not allowed.
(bb) No permit shall be granted on Lincoln Road in an area designated as
restricted for special and cultural events provided however, that the
City Manager may approve temporary use of such area(s), on a case
by case basis and only for a defined limited time. Area(s) restricted
for special and cultural events shall be designated in the sidewalk cafe
site map.
~cc) Upon written and/or verbal notification by the City Manager of a
hurricane or other major weather event or the issuance of a hurricane
warning by Miami-Dade County whichever occurs first, the permittee
shall within four (4) hours of same remove and place indoors all
tables chairs and any other sidewalk cafe furniture located on the right
of way The notification by the City Manager of a hurricane or other
major weather event or the issuance of a hurricane warning, shall
constitute a public emergency situation as referenced in this division.
The City Manager may remove any sidewalk cafe furniture found on
the right of way that has otherwise not been removed by the permittee
pursuant to this subsection Any and all costs incurred by the city for
removal or storage of sidewalk cafe furniture shall be the responsibility
of the permittee The city shall not be responsible for any damages to,
or loss of sidewalk cafe furniture which is removed and stored
pursuant to this subsection Sidewalk cafes will not re-open for
business following a hurricane or other mayor weather event until
notified by the City Manager Violation of this subsection shall result in
the issuance of an immediate $1000 00 fine and/or suspension, for up
to thirty (30) days of the sidewalk cafe permit.
Sec 82-385 Liability and insurance.
(a) The permittee agrees to indemnify defend save and hold harmless
the city its officers and employees from any and all claims, liability,
lawsuits damages and causes of action which may arise out of the
permit or the permittee's activity on the public right of way.
(b) The permittee agrees to meet and maintain for the entire permit period,
at its own expense the following requirements:
(1) Commercial general liability insurance in the amount of
$1 000 000 00 per occurrence for bodily injury and property
damage The city must be named as an additional insured on
this policy and an endorsement must be issued as part of the
policy reflecting compliance with this requirement.
(2) For sidewalk cafes which serve alcoholic beverages, liquor
- liability insurance in the amount of $1000,000.00 per
occurrence for bodily iniury and property damage. The city must
be named as an additional insured on this policy, and an
endorsement must be issued as part of the policy reflecting
compliance with this requirement.
(3) Workers' compensation and employers' liability as required by
the state.
~4) All policies must be issued by companies authorized to_ do
business in the state and rated B+~VI or better per Best's Key
Rating Guide latest edition.
~5) The city must receive 30 days' written notice prior to any
cancellation non-renewal or material change in the coverage
provided.
(6) The permittee must provide and have approved by the city an
on final a certificate of insurance as evidence that the
requirements set forth in this Section have been met prior to
commencing operations Failure to comply with these
requirements shall cause a suspension or revocation of the
ep rmit.
SECTION 2. REPEALER
All ordinances or parts of ordinances in conflict herewith be and the same
are hereby repealed.
SECTION 3. SEVERABILITY
If any section, sentence, clause or phrase of this ordinance is held to be
invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, then said
holding shall in no way affect the validity of the remaining portions of this
ordinance.
SECTION 4. CODIFICATION.
It is the intention of the Mayor and City Commission of the City of Miami
Beach, and it is hereby ordained that the provisions of this ordinance shall
become and be made a part of the Code of the City of Miami Beach, Florida.
The sections of this ordinance may be renumbered or relettered to accomplish
such intention, and the word "ordinance" may be changed to "section", "article,"
or other appropriate word.
SECTION 5. EFFECTIVE DATE
This Ordinance shall take effect the 22nd day of December , 2007.
PASSED and ADOPTED this 12th day of December , 2007.
ATTEST:
~ AY
CITY CLERK
F:\attoWGUR\RESOS-ORD\Sidewalk Cafe Ordinance (New Final -Second Reading 1-7-08).doc
APPROVED AS TO
FORM ~ LANGUAGE
t~ FOVt EXECUTION
~ I~Inf~
Date
COMMISSION ITEM SUMMARY
Condensed Title:
An Ordinance of the Mayor and City Commission of the City of Miami Beach, Florida deleting the language
in Section 82-366 through 82-388 {The City's Sidewalk Cafe Ordinance) in its entirety, and replacing it with
new language in said Sections 82-366 through 82-388, adopting and incorporating the City's new Sidewalk
Cafe Ordinance; rovidin for re eater, codification, severability. and an effective r~atp
Ke Intended Outcome Su orted:
Make Ci More Business Friendt .Increase Resident Satisfaction with Level of Code Enforcement.
Supporting Data (Surveys, Environmental Scan, etc.): 63% of businesses were either very satisfied or
satisfied with the fairness and consistency of enforcement of zoning or ordinances by the City of Miami
Beach overnment for businesses.
Iccuo•
Shall the Ma or and Ci Commission approve the Ordinance?
Item 5ummarv/Recommendatinn•
Second Reading -Public Hearing. The ordinance regulating the administration and operation of
sidewalk cafes was discussed at the first reading held at the City Commission meeting on October 17,
2007. The City Commission approved the entire first reading version of the Ordinance with the following
changes:
Section 82-370
- Clarified the definition of site plan violations to include those instances where the permiee is
operating outside of the permitted sidewalk cafes area, and shall include: table or tables,
umbrellas, heaters, fans, bussing stations, and other sidewalk cafes furniture placed outside of
the approved site plan.
Section 82-384
- Deleted proposed policy of maintaining a 50% minimum open space on each block of Lincoln
Road Mall.
- Allowed tables and chairs to remain set up for business on sidewalk cafes on Lincoln Road Mall
rather than being stored inside the business.
- Allowed food displays on the public right-of-way under the following conditions:
- Food must be real,
- Food must be displayed in a covered display case, and
- Food display may only be located on the portion of the right-of-way which is immediately
next to the entrance of the restaurant.
The discussion leading up to the Commission Public Hearing and Ordinance second reading has been
characterized by significant participation by Lincoln Road businesses. Unfortunately, the participation has
not been consistently representative. At the first reading, the public attending the Commission meeting
might have been more heavily representative of one perspective and not necessarily the view of the
majority of businesses. The Ordinance as presented is representative of the attendees' interests. The
Commission may find that a different perspective is voiced in the public hearing that differs from the first
reading's comments. From the Administrations past meeting experience the display of food, the storage of
furniture on the right-of-way and the 50% open space requirement may be raised by attendees.
The Administration will assist with any modifications requested. If significant change is designed by the
Commission it may be appropriate to refer the item for an additional committee review before final
Qw r.d ~~ _J_ae
•r •~vvv......p1.4aHVI~.
Financial Information:
Source of Amount Account
Funds: ~
2
OBPI Total
Financial Im act Summa
r`ifi. rlerW a. llii:.... ~ _~_ae___ ~
De artment Director Assistant Ci Mana er Ci ana er
FHB RCM JMG
TaAGENDA120071dec12071Re°ularlSidewalk cafes nm ~„a,,,y. ci iuu a,,..
..... ~ vn~a.c ~.c 1.71Ctt1Vt: ~ racKin
Robert Halfhill Property Management Director ext 2984 --1
SI n-Offs.
- - -- - --..._..~ _ ............... g U
I A~ f I<,,,i ~~~, ~ At3ENbA !~7~M RSF
BATE l2"/2 -U7
m MIAMIBEACH
City of Miami Beath, 1700 Convention Center Drive, Miami Beach, Florida 33139, www.mi°mibe°chfl.gov
COMMISSION MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor Matti H. Bower and Members of the City Commission
FROM: Jorge M. Gonzalez, City Manager
SECOND READING
DATE: December 12, 2007 PUBLIC HEARING
SUBJECT: AN ORDINANCE OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, DELETING THE LANGUAGE IN SECTIONS 8266
THROUGH 82-388 (THE CITY'S SIDEWALK CAFE ORDINANCE) IN ITS
ENTIRETY, AND REPLACING IT WITH NEW LANGUAGE IN SAID SECTIONS
82-366 THROUGH 82-388, ADOPTING AND INCORPORATING THE CITY'S
NEW SIDEWALK CAFE ORDINANCE; PROVIDING FOR REPEALER,
CODIFICATION, SEVERABILITY, AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
ADMINISTRATION RECOMMENDATION
Approve the Ordinance,
FUNDING
Non Applicable
BACKGROUND
The revised ordinance regulating the administration and operation of sidewalk cafes was discussed
at first reading Public Hearing held at the City Commission meeting on October 17, 2007. The City
Commission approved the entire proposed first reading version of the Ordinance with the following
changes:
Section 82-370 Clarified the definition of site plan violations, to include those instances where
the permiee is operating outside of the permitted sidewalk cafe area, and shall
include: table or tables, umbrellas, heaters, fans, bussing stations, and other
sidewalk cafe furniture placed outside of the approved site plan.
Section 82-384 Deleted proposed policy of maintaining a 50% minimum open space on each
block of Lincoln Road Mall rather than being stored inside the business.
Allowed tables and chairs to remain set up for business on sidewalk cafes on
Lincoln Road Mall.
Allowed food displays on the public right-of-way under the
following conditions:
- Food must be real,
- Food must be displayed in a covered display case, and
- Food display mayonly be located on the portion of the right-of-waywhich
is immediately next to the entrance of the restaurant.
Commission Memorandum
Sidewalk Cafe Ordinance
December 12, 2007
Page 2 of 4
Other provisions of the Ordinance include:
Section 82-366 Definitions of terms were expanded and improved for clarity and understanding;
such as:
- Restaurant to include business establishments which have as an
ancillary or secondary use the preparation and/ or service of food and/ or
beverages or consumption. No sidewalk cafe permit shall be issued to
establishments that provide take out service and do not have inside
seating.
- Sidewalk cafe furniture provides a more inclusive listing, without
limitation, of the type of furniture that is considered part of the sidewalk
cafe operation.
Section 82-370 Life Safety and Site Plan violations were exempted from the 24-hour Warning
Notice. In the current ordinance, it was customary for Code Officers to issue 24-
hour Warning Notices before issuing a violation, this created conditions for
repeat violators that would get multiple 24-hour Notices over a period of time and
never get a violation. Under the revised section, there will be no 24-hour notices
for Life Safety Violations and/ or Site Plan Violations (i.e. operating outside of the
permitted sidewalk cafe area). Life Safety and Site Plan Violations must be
corrected immediately.
Section 82-371 Expanded the fines and penalties by increasing the range of fines and providing
for the suspension and revocation of repeat violators. Under the current
Ordinance the City did not have the ability to suspend or revoke a sidewalk cafie
permit for repeat violators. The civil fines were limited to three (3) citations within
a one (1) year period with a maximum fine of $500.00. The revised Ordinance
significantly expands the civil fines and penalties including a fine of $1,000.00 for
the fifth violation within the preceding 12 months and suspension of the sidewalk
cafe permit for one (1) weekend. It also adds a fine of $1,000.00 for the sixth
violation in the preceding 12 months and a revocation of a sidewalk cafe permit
for the remaining portion of the permit year.
Section 82-383 Fee; renewal fee; penalties for late payments for renewal fee. Allows the pro-
rating of fees for applications made after May of each permit year.
Section 82-384 Standards, Criteria and Conditions
Para (a) Defines the permit location for Sidewalk Cafes. This section outlines the
criteria and sets the procedures to be used to determine the existence of an
extreme hardship for an expansion of a sidewalk cafe across the center line
of Lincoln Road Mall.
Para (b) Defines the process for applying for expansion laterally and across the
centerline of Lincoln Road Mall. This is a major change to the current
ordinance which allows expansion laterally beyond the restaurant storefront
simply by obtaining an affidavit from the property owner where the sidewalk
cafe desires to expand. Under the revised Ordinance the approval for
expansion is left up to the City Manager or his designee based on
established criteria such as pedestrian access, visibility of the front of the
Commission Memorandum
Sidewalk Cafe Ordinance
December 12, 2007
Page 3 of 4
adjacent businesses, obstructions, current open space available,
accessibility to the adjacent businesses by patrons; the City Manager or his
designee if necessary may seek input from businesses or property owners
on the block where the permit is being requested.
Para (i) Pedestrian Pathways- defines the pedestrian pathways at 12 feet.
Para (j) Changes the center to center distance of the planters to create more open
space.
Para (n) Defines the allowable use of gas powered space heaters and specifies the
storage requirements. Heaters are allowed to remain on the sidewalk cafe
areas. However, fire regulations require the removal and safe storage of the
propane tank.
Para (p) Defines the size, location and design Menu Boards.
Para (z) Defines specifications and parameters for cleaning.
Para (bb) Defines requirements of the City and actions by the sidewalk cafe owners
during emergency situations.
Para (II) Establishes the ability of Sidewalk Cafes to use of city electricity for fans
during the summer season.
ORDINANCE DEVELOPMENT HISTORY
Since September 2005 a committee of citizens, sidewalk cafe operators, building owners and City
staff met eleven (11) times in a workshop environment to revise the current ordinance regulating the
operations and activities of Sidewalk Cafes.
The committee members reviewed and discussed each section of the current Sidewalk Cafe
Ordinance. Leng#hy productive discussions resulted in improved language, new sections and
deletion of obsolete language. The revisions over the drafting period were so extensive that it was
decided that a new ordinance incorporating all of the revised language would be more efficient and
understandable.
The draft ordinance was first presented to the Neighborhoods/Community Affairs Committee on
September 27, 2006. The Committee discussed the issues with approximatelytwenty-five sidewalk
cafe operators and building owners present.
The Neighborhoods/Community Affairs Committee directed that the draft ordinance be presented to
the Planning Board. The intention was for the Planning Board to serve as citizen input.
The Planning Board did not offer input as to the key Ordinance provisions, but did discuss several
collateral issues including enforcement and whether the Public Works Department should be the
department administering the sidewalk cafe program.
The proposed sidewalk cafe ordinance was brought back to the Neighborhood/Community Affairs
Committee on November 29, 2006. Following lengthy discussions with sidewalk cafe owners and
operators present, the Committee moved unanimously on the following three items:
1. Establish a 50% minimum open space requirement for Lincoln Road Mall with one year
reconsideration and grandfathering provision.
2. To not allow expansion across the centerline of Lincoln Road absent an extreme hardship.
Commission Memorandum
Sidewalk Cafe Ordinance
December 12, 2007
Page 4 of 4
3. To allow all restaurants that begin serving lunch by 11:00 am to stack chairs on the Lincoln
Road Mall at night as long as the tables are set up by 10:00 am.
The ordinance revision was held back until the FY2007/2008 budget development process was
completed. Due to the length of time since the last Committee discussion, the ordinance was
brought back to the Neighborhooc~ommunity Affairs Committee on September 19, 2007 to be sure
that the ordinance still reflected the Committee's opinions. The Committee discussed, at length, the
three items listed above and other items previously agreed upon. The direction from the Committee
was:
1. Maintain 50% open space on Lincoln Road Mall. In areas not meeting the fifty (50%)
percent requirement, if an existing sidewalk cafe closes and the location is taken over by
another business which desires to open a sidewalk cafe, the new business would be allowed
to operate a sidewalk cafe on the right of way only in front of the business within the properly
boundaries. Any previous lateral expansions would not be permitted. The ordinance does
not create a vested right to continue a sidewalk cafe after a change of owner/operator. New
owner/operators need to apply for a sidewalk cafe permit and meet the ordinance
requirements and there has to have been a sidewalk cafe permit in good standing in the
previous permit year. In areas not meeting the 50 %standard, existing establishments would
have the ability to continue their operations under the new ordinance with any approved and
existing lateral expansions.
2. To pro-rate, on a monthly basis, the Sidewalk Cafe fee for business opening after May.
3. Allow restaurants that open and serve food before 11:00 am to keep the sidewalk cafe
chairs and tables setup overnight on the rights-of-way.
Subsequent to the meeting, since the more expansive storage of chairs may create operational
constraints for City cleaning and maintenance crews, the Administration recommended an additional
provision be added to the ordinance that if the permttee fails to complywith the cleaning requirement
of Section 82-384(z), the City reserves the right to revoke the privilege of storing chairs on the public
right-of--way. This is intended as a trade off for what is expected to greater difficulty for the City in
cleaning these areas. The language is included in the current draft ordinance.
CONCLUSION
The discussion leading up to the Commission Public Hearing and Ordinance second reading has
been characterized by significant participation by Lincoln Road businesses. Unfortunately, the
participation has not been consistently representative. Onoccasion one interest or another would be
more heavily representative of one the Ordinance modified in some instances on the basis of those
concerns. At the first reading, the public attending the Commission meeting might have been more
heavily represented a perspective and not necessarily the view of the majority of businesses. The
Ordinance as presented is representative of the attendees' interests. The Commission may find that
a different perspective is voiced in the public hearing that may differ from the first reading's
comments. From the Administrations past meeting experience the display of food, the storage of
furniture on the right-of-way and the 50% open space requirement may be raised by attendees.
The Administration will assist with any modifications requested. If significant change is designed by
the Commission it may be appropriate to refer the item for an additional committee review before
final adoption.
JMG\RCM\FHBIRTH
T:(AGENDA\2007\dec1207\Regular\Sidewalk Cafe Ordinance MEMO .doc
• 20
N ;
° `~ CITY OF MIAMI BEACH
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
~,
NOTICE IS HEREBY given that a second reading and public hearings will be held by the Maya and C'rly Commission of the Citi of
•Miami Beach, Forida, in the Commission Chambers, 3rd floor, City Hail, 1700 Convenrtion Center Drive, Miami Beach. Florida. on
z YVeMtaaday, December 12, 2007, to consider the following:
j:
t0~0 a.m.
~: An Ordinance Amending Chapter 2 Of The Code Of The City 01 Miami Beach, Florida, Entited "Administration." By Amending
~~ Article 91 Thereof, Entitled "Agencies, Boards And Committees," By Amending Division 6 Thereof, Entitled "Cultural Arts Council,"
8y Amending Section 2-58; And Creating New Sections 2-58(A) And 2-58(B); Said Amendments Related To Assigning The Powers
AOd Duties Ot The Community Benefit Fund 7o The Miami Beach Guttural Arts Council.
:.~ Inquiries maybe directed to the Tourism and Guttural Development at (305) 673-7577.
i 1fY.2D a.m.
An Ordinance Amending Chapter 2 of the Coda of the City Of Miami Beach, Florida, Entitled "Administration," By Amending Article
Ill Thereof, Frditled °Agencles, Boards And Committees," By Amending Division 5 Thereof, Entitled "Converdion Center Advisory
~ Board." 8y Amending Sections 2-46(B) And 2-46(GX1) And 2-46(CH9) And 2-46(F)• Said pmendmerds Related To Removing The
'~ Jedde Gleason Theater Or Performing Arts. (Now The "The Filmore Miami Beach At fie Jackie Gleason Theater") kom The Powers
~ And Dotes Of The Board And, Further, Aemovinp The Powers And Duties OI The Community Benefit Fund From The Powers And
Duties Of The Convention Center Advisory Board
N
i htquries may be directed to the Tourism and Guttural Development at (305) 673-7577.
10:30 a.m.
z An Ordinance Amending Chapter 82 Of The Miami Beach City Code, 6ttitled "public Properly," BY Amending Article I, Enittied "In
~ General,"By Amending Section 82-4 - 82-5, Entitled "Reserved,' BY Amending Section 82-4 To Prohibit Foods Containing Artificial
~ Trans Fat Irt Vending Machines On City Property And In Concession Facilities Subject To Concession Or Managemerd Agreemerds
~ Widr The City.
L
d:
E ~ Inquiries maybe directed to the Legal Department at (305) 673-7470.
~° ' 10:31 a.m.
~ ~ An Ordiner>ce Amending The Code Of The
'MBMred Parking" BY Amending Sections 106 55"Mp~in Rates. Fees, And~PonaltiestaCreating A New Subsection (N) fiereiri
~ } Erditled "Hybrid/ILEy (Inherentry Low Emissions Vehicles) Vehicles Incentives.
InWhres may be directed to the Parking Department at (305) 673-7275.
1Q36 a.m.
M Ordinarce Amending Sections 18-901-18-910, Entitled Street Performers And Art Vendors; AuCraizing Street Performers And
Mist Vendors To Use Portable Tables On Ocean Drive Folbwing Receipt Of A Permit Sufrject To Certain Condfions And Permft
Fees; Prohlbi0ng Spray Painting And Airbrushing; Providing Definitions, Setting Forth Terms, Conditions And Regulations For
i F'enrdts Issued To Street Vendors Performers And Artist Vendors; providing Fa Enforcement, Suspension Or Revocation.
) klquhies may be directed to file
i Neighbortaod Services Department at (305) 673-7077.
j 1Qr10a.m.
~ M INdinence Deleting The Language In Sections 82-366 Through 82-388 (The City's Sidewalk Cafe Ordinance) In tts Entirety, And
Cat It VYrth New Language In Said Set~ions 82-366 Throu~l 82-385, Adopting And I
Cafe Ordhrance. r~capaating The City's New Sidewalk I
Urquiries may be dkected to the Public Works Department at (305) 673-7080.
11~Oa.m.
~Otdkmnce Amending The Land Development Regulations Ot The Code Of The City Or Miami Beech, By Amending Chapter 142,
ing Distrtcts And Regulations," Article II, •District Regulatons,• By Amending Division 3, "Residential Multifamily Districts,'
By Amercing Subdivision V, "RM-3 Residential Muttifamiry High Irder-sity," To ModilyThe Maximum Building Height Requirements
~ Orxmniront Properties Located In Historic Districts.
! Inqures maybe directed to the Planning Department at (305) 673-7550.
i 11~0a.rn.
~ An Ordinance Amendin The land Deve ment
j 9 bP Regulatkms Of Tire Code Of The City Of Miami Beach, By Amending Chapter 142,
"Zoning Districts And Regulatkxrs," ArtirJe il, "Dlsbtct Regulations," BY Amending Ditddon 3, "Residential Multifamily Districts,'
jAmending Subdhvision Y, •RM-3 Residential Mul6tamiy High intenstly," To Modiry The Maximum BuBdmg Height Requirements
Properttes Lor~ted In The Architectural District,
kprtirles may be directed to the Planning Department at (305) 673-7550.
I~iTERESTEp PARTIES are invited b appear at this meetktg, a be represented by an agent, a to express their views in writing
addressed to the City Commission, c% the Ctty Clerk, 1700 Convention Center Drive, isl Floor, City Hall, Miami Beach, Florida
I 33139. Copies of ttu'9e ordinances are available for public duri normal business tours In the
1700 Convention Center Drive, 1st Floor, Cdy Hall, and'Miami Beach, Flaida33139. This meets ~ Clerk's Office,
such circumstances additional legal notice would not be provided. n9 ~Y be continued and under
i
Robert E. Farther, Oily Clerk
i City of Miami Beach
Pursuant to Section 286.0105, Fla. Slat, the City hereby advises the public that: if a person decides to appeal any decision made
i by the City Commission with respect to any matter considered at its meeting or itg hearing, such person must ensure that a
~ verba8m record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be
i based. Ttds notice does not constihrte consent by the City for the introduction a admission of otherwise inadmissible or irrelevant
I evidence, nor does it authorize clta8enges a appeals rat otherwise allowed by law.
To reglreit title rfreterfel in acceeeible format, aiprt hderpreter:, bllormetion on access fa wtlh dbabH8lee, and/
a any alxommodatbn to review any document a participate (n amr cKy-sponwred proceeding, ass contact (305) 804.2489
(~ice), (30673-721t1(TTY) five days in advance to Initiate your request. TTY users may also cell 11 Florida Rele Servi
~~ Ad A463 ( Y ce).
m MIAMIBE
, _ ACH